The Faint Young Sun Paradox
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 05. 2024
- Get a free audiobook and a 30-day trial of Audible (and support this channel) at www.audible.com/upandatom or text "upandatom" to 500 500 on your phone.
Hi! I'm Jade. If you'd like to consider supporting Up and Atom, head over to my Patreon page :)
/ upandatom
Visit the Up and Atom store
store.nebula.app/collections/...
Subscribe to Up and Atom for physics, math and computer science videos!
/ upandatom
Follow me @upndatom
Up and Atom on Twitter: upndatom?lang=en
Up and Atom on Instagram: / upndatom
For a one time donation, head over to my PayPal :) www.paypal.me/upandatomshows
A big thank you to my AMAZING PATRONS!
Brian Wilkins,
Cy 'kkm' K'Nelson
, Michael Seydel,
Purple Penguin
, Thorsten Auth
, Gary Leo Welz,
Berj Bannayan
, Chris Flynn
, Dr. Varun Pant,
Adam Thornton, Andrew Pann
, Anne Tan
, David Johnston
, Jeffrey Smith
, Jessica Rose
, Lynn Shackelford
, Rick DeWitt
, Yana Chernobilsky
, Thomas Krause
, 12tone
, Aaron Dorn
, Aaron Moffatt,
Alex Hackman
, Artem G.,
Brian Kent
, Broos Nemanic,
Chris Amaris
, Corey Sampson, Dag-Erling Smørgrav
, Damien Holloway,
Drew Hart,
eris esoteric,
George Fletcher,
Jana Christine Saout,
Joe Court
, Joel Becane
, John Lakeman,
John Shioli
, KhAnubis
, Matt G,
Michael Dean,
Michael Hunter,
Mikely Whiplash,
Paul Barclay,
Robert Hillier,
Susan Jones
, Thomas V Lohmeier, Todd Loreman
, Tony T Flores,
Zhong Cheng Wang,
Craig Thorpe
, Russell Barlow, JT, Phat Hoang, Spuddy, Josh Bauer, RJ Hikes, Larry Kuzniak, Sascha Bohemia, tesseract, Will Miller, J-J, Dagmawi Elehu, Philip Swan, Hansjuerg Widmer, Carlos Gonzalez, Jonathan Ansell, Arsalan Noorafkan, Thomas Kägi, Courtney Rosenthal, James Palermo, Dominic Riverso, Jeroen Melchiors, Gary Leo Welz, Andrej Zon, Richard, Chris Teubert, Dylan Kolstad, Fran, Joe, Chester Stadler, John Sokolowski, Robert J Frey, The Doom Merchant, Martin Zenuik, Wolfgang Ripken, Jeremy Bowkett, Vincent Karpinski, Nicolas Frias, Christopher Phipps, Louis M, kadhonn, Moose Thompson, Hal Roseman, Austin Rose, Andrew, Tamara McDermott, Charles from USA, John Klinkner, S, Rob Napier, Sam Ross, Peter Walsh, Garrett Chomka, Jeff Schwarz, Bobby Butler, Rebecca Lashua, Pat Gunn, Luc Ritchie, Elze Kool, RobF, Aditya Anantharaman, Frédéric Junod, Vincent Seguin, Bernard Wei, Help I'm trapped in a driver's license factory Roberts, Shawn, Israel Shirk, Ken Takahashi, Jesse Clark, Steven Wheeler, Philip Freeman, Jareth Arnold, Simon Barker, Dennis Haupt, Lou, amcnea, Renato Pereira, Simon Dargaville, Magesh.
Creator
Jade Tan-Holmes
Script
Steffani Grondin
Editing and Motion Graphics
Hamish Gilbert
Mental Image Productions
www.mentalimage.com.au
Junior Arruda
/ iamaduo
Music
www.epidemicsound.com/
open.spotify.com/artist/1D30m... - Věda a technologie
I appreciate the commitment to the water gag.
Ikr, she didn't even put ice in the glass to make it easier. True education warrior.
Hahahahaha, I notice how she's trying to show something simple but a in a hard way
haha, yes it was like "here I have a point I want to prove" *looks at the camera with scientific intent*
hyponatremia intensifies
I love the look of panic in her eyes when she was half way through and realized she was only half way through.
Jade's energy so adorable!
"And now for the most important question: Who cares? " I choked
I cannot be the only one that found that whole section on Albedo very endearing and adorable. I appreciate that Jade can give us good info without being too serious about it, makes it very easy to pay attention.
It is because you had libido all over your head.
@@individuotipo I don't get it... Like "in deep water", or "in hot water"? Maybe.
I’m pretty sure i’ve heard the word “albedo” more times in this video than I have over the previous 38 years
And every single time, she was thinking of something else.
You clearly don't move in the right planetary circles. 😊
The English pronunciation of albedo is misleading.
I had a creepy Teletubbies flashback with the young sun :o)
As always, good information presented by a charming host.
Thanx!
Something tells me if you kept the albedo giggles in, the outtakes reel for this video must be priceless.
Hey, I'm not a native English speaker. What's up with that "albedo" joke, I didn't understand it? I work with 3D graphics and use that word all the time.
@@FM_GOBi It just sounds like "libido", which you can look up :)
At 8:40, I thought you were going to say : "I've been listening to "The Planets"... by the composer Gustav Holst". ;-)
I love how communicative your enthusiasm is. Thank you.
I love that whole suite by Gustav Holst. I can remember playing around with a cardboard astronaut helmet, exploring new worlds in the living room while listening to it.
I just discovered you and Joe Scott via Nebula this month, and I feel like I hit an absolute goldmine of grounded and informative science videos. Really great stuff that I couldn't recommend more to my teacher friends to show their students and get them interested in these complex topics.
What I find funny in science is that whenever someone who focuses on the broad strokes shows new hypotheses to be the most likely, those who focus on the minutia (which is necessary) sometimes have to change direction and regroup. I love it even more when the minutia people change the broad strokes people's direction. I just love the way science works, really.
Just wanted to say that you're such a great channel.
5:42 i can't say that thought has ever crossed my mind. Now I can't unhear it. Thanks a lot :D
It means you’ve done a good job at keeping your mind clean. Well done.
I can't imagine hearing albedo and not thinking libido. And from her giggles every time she said it, I'm pretty sure she can't either.
such an underrated channel tbh
So in the whole video you finished your breakfast 🙂
I finished my lunch watching this :p
Finished my supper watching the video xd
6:30 i love the tiny "yeah" when you say we've solved the paradox!
and frankly it distresses me that your videos don't get more attention. you're a fabulous presenter and constantly both educational and entertaining. i can't be your ambassador, and i haven't the money to be a patreon, but i promise to watch more of your videos than i have from now on. and multiple times if i ever see them all.
Lmao yeah its not solved. Carl Sagan proposed this theory so people can see the this system is false just cause a bunch of people agree on conditions that are pure speculation in a time before anyone existed doesn't fix a paradon it's just a run around excuse they is no definitive evidence of a globe let alone giant ball body's and gas body's in space everything they see in the sky today is the exact same as it was over 10000 years ago and ancient history proves that the pyramids are lines up perfectly with their star system and they knew they were never moving
The toast B-roll is great XD
The enjoy and joy you bring to learning is absolutely unmatched.
Having straight, bright white teeth and not wearing make-up helps, too.
@@rubiks6 "she is great, isn't she? you think a princess and a guy like me could..." "NO!"
Well done, Jade! I think you get better and better at this over time. Just added you to my Patreon subscriptions.
I love that this is such an original topic that I've never heard of (nor thought about until now) in any other scicomm channel! 👍
And quite an interesting one like always.
Amazing video as always! Thank you Jade! Thanks for your commitment and your work! Its nice you share with us all of this!!😁
The question never entered my mind too. Until now.😂 But now I need answers.
I love the paintings behind you and of course the video, very interesting and clear! ;) thanks Jade!
you're more than just making videos, you're having fun while at it! this is why I like your videos, that and the fact that I enjoy uncovering the secrets of the universe
Welcome back! It's nice to see another video. Thanks for the great content - always interesting!
Keep calm and carry on. Nice presentation; I always look forward to them.
Very cool to see the faint young sun paradox being covered. Keep up the good work!
Drinking the whole glass of water in one go, amazing work Jade.
As usual the video is brilliant.
I was wondering for the last few days when you were going to release the next video.
Thanks 😊
Thanks for another lovely video, it's fun watching your delivering as it's obvious that you love this subject very much. keep up the amazing work ^_^
Wonderful video. Excellent narration and performance and video editing.
Also... I find the "Jezero Crater" name funny, because in Slavic languages the word "jezero" literally translates to English word for lake. I'm pretty sure that's no coincidence.
Just watched this with my 6 year old son...he doesn't quite get it yet, but is fascinated with your videos......its great to take him on the journey. Thank you
Can't remember if she's had these in her background before or not, but love the equations on the wall behind her. I remember discussing e^(i*pi) +1 = 0 in a fractals & chaos course in high school math class and was blown away.
They've been in a lot of previous videos. I like the design of her set (room? wherever she's filming), it's nice and clean without distractions.
And yea, I had e^(i*pi) +1 = 0 explained at university and it blew my mind. Math is cool!
Love your videos: ) The wait is always worth it
Water? I was thinking "coffee, it has to be coffee"
Hi Jade i love your videos im sure you inspire loads of young people to take up maths and science, your a treasure
The Faint Young Sun Paradox would be a good name for a band
... right up there with Alexander's Dark Band.
A fascinating video as always Jade! And can I just say that I always get a little bit of enjoyment out of seeing an Australian street whenever one shows up in a CZcams video. Feels like home! :P
I really like the way you say words like hello, why, yes and no.
you always bring a smile to my face and knowlege to my brain :) hope you and yours stay safe and healthy in these times
Up and atom ❤️ Been here in this channel from the very beginning and it never failed to amuse me🙂. Hope your channel will be more successful coz you deserve it! Love lots...
i remember you!
I must, painfully and reluctantly, admit that the "Perserverance" pun was absolutely top notch. Kudos to you, you evil Word Mistress.
Well done with the water, shame you can only like a video once.
Awesome watch for a Wednesday night. Your videos are getting better all the time.
Your videos are so informative, understandable and the way you present things is adorable and witty! Love it, I very rarely subscribe but there you go : ) I'd love to support the show too, please don't stop!
The gags were on point in this one. Excellent work.
That Undying Eye contact untill it feels like your dying from trying to drink the whole thing is awesome. Your commitment and sense of humor makes these videos easier for me to digest. Iv been learning alot!
@Up and Atom
Loved your treatment and especially the water gag!
Wondering whether you came across anything on higher (than now) intrinsic heating based upon more plentiful radioactive nucleotides in the early Earth. I did a quick google and didn’t find a comprehensive answer, though there is a LOT of young Earth creationist BS to prune away so I might well have missed it. I wonder as well what the Earth Moon collision would do to stratify the nucleotides with, I presume, the Earth getting the heavier metals and the Moon the lighter silicates and 40K & 26Al
Thank you Jade for the reminder to keep hydrated
Very clever channel ligature. Here is the best paradox I've ever encountered...the common human. Good luck solving that one.
I love your videos! This is such a great channel!!!! I wish you could make videos more often!!!
My six year old daughter and I love your channel and learning about new things.
1:09 to when she said liquid water could definitely be apart of a Up and Atom out of context video
I can only hope to one day have the level of commitment you applied to the water gag
Thank you for this informative and wonderful content 😇😇
Great video Jade! Tysm! 🙏🏻 you are amazing!
So glad I subscribed! Very interesting topic!
As you spun around at the beginning the Joe Scott jingle played in my head
Very nice videos, dry topics explained very well,,, I think you can do a video on young's double slit experiment and it's results
Ok that was a pretty cool video. I just have one question. Volcanoes also release gasses that reflect sunlight into space. Why in this case we can be confident that the greenhouse gases had the greater effect on the plant? I'm asking because according to my understanding, the reflecting gasses usually have the greater influence on the short term. Meaning they can start a cooling which can then be increased by the oceans freezing into ice which has higher albedo than liquid water.
The sulphur aerosols are short-lived (years to decades) while, in lieu of weathering and photosynthesis, the carbon dioxide stays there basically forever. So you end up with an equilibrium of albedo-increasing aerosols in the atmosphere, while the carbon dioxide continues building up over millions years, so eventually the impact of the latter dominates.
My absolute favorite science CZcams channel. I love your videos
My excitement to know about this is LEAKing out of my body
This is an amazing video! One of the best ones ever!!!!!!!
thanx for a book suggestion, anything spacey, timey, quantum-y, lol, is usually right up my ally
Jade, you are awesome! Love your talks!
Great stuff, Jade! I'd never given the issue much thought.🙏
I really like your video. This gives me a sense of hope.
absolutely lovely presentation!
Life......finds a way
Nice video Jade.I love it!
It gets even nuttier when you think about how life completely threaded the evolutionary needle on this one. Volcanoes provided enough heat and cover for cyanobacteria to evolve 3.8 billion years ago--and kept that cover going while they built the ozone layer. Without all that help from volcanoes--life might still be stuck deep in the oceans to stay safe from solar radiation. So many monumental and incredibly tiny events had to work out so perfectly for our tree of life to get going.
2:34 I love your humor!
I love your work, Jade.
Your videos are great Jade!
"Life might take a little Perseverance" - best joke I've heard all week
Thanks jade you made maths and science very fun.
Perfect editing with the arm moviments
Perimeter institute has an amazing lecture about requirement for life and habitable zone and other factors. It portrays quite impressively why life might be rarer than we think and\or maybe life as _we_ understand may not be as prevalent.
That glass of water bit is pure gold.
Beautifully crafted animations 👍
I just want to say, THANK YOU! Excellent video ;)
Archaeon Eon, cool band name.
One of the most attractive math, space, and physics channels. Keep up your good work! 👍 👩🎓
Hi Jade, kudos for yet another great video. I love your work and sense of humor.
Recently I finished a book (any details would spoil the ending...) which claimed that the very hot argument of the religious approach to creation, namely that it introduced order into chaos, has been overturned, by science proving that life has been a factor which increased chaos, in full accordance with the thermodynamic law. I would love to hear you comment on that in your very special way.
Great watch! Keep it up!
Hard to express how adorable you are. You bring smile. And I learned cool things. Thank you
Thank you for the video.
I love it! 1.5k thumbs up and only 16 thumbs down. You do a great job Jade!
I was wondering: does life really need that much liquid water? What I mean is that if this greenhouse effect were somehow absent, the thermal suboceanic vents would still carve out liquid water cavities below the ice-shelf of a snowball earth and life could persevere there indefinitely (and by the way you would also account for some rocks shaped by erosion by liquid water). Or would a snowball earth lose heat so rapidly (because of low albedo) that if such an episode were sustained for too long its core would actually cool down and those thermal vents would fall silent??
I love the graphics. Your amazing
Came for the sun, found out about volcanoes!!!! That's why I subscribe. Another great video, Jade!
You had too much fun making this video. Bless.
Hi Jade, It is interesting that planetary scientists have stuck to trying to solve the faint Sun paradox to planetary conditions. A colleague of mine and I showed that a 4% to 7% increase in the Sun's initial mass would entirely have solved the faint Sun paradox -- not only for Earth but also for Mars having liquid water in the early portion of the Solar System. It also solved gaseous components in lunar highland soils, very old meteorites, and a few other things. We went looking for young solar-type stars losing mass at a rate that would be compatible with this idea, and demonstrated that this could be detected. I'm surprised that our work of 25 years ago is still under debate because one has to solve the faint Sun paradox for all the planets, not jsut for Earth. By the way, love your shows!
I've never ever, not even for a second in my entire life had "libido" come to mind when hearing/reading "albedo". I mean, c'mon.. however, this incident reminded me of the excellent Vangelis album that I could really use right now as background for writing.
Your videos are so fascinating I'm currently watching one on my TV, and one on my phone! 🤣 P.S. cute baby sun! 😉
U r great in explaining paradox s
Another Paradox. Love you videos 👍.
Great graphics in this video!
Geology is also physicsy!
Loved the tectonic animation.
Thank you. Your video has helped raise my albedo!
i'd love to see the followup on the Gaia principle
Lol I have the same red shirt. Like the material too looks exactly the same. I am joining my first day of work tomorrow and I am wearing it!