India Will Never Be Like China - Here's Why
Vložit
- čas přidán 4. 09. 2024
- If India's manufacturing sector grew at 8% compounded for the next 30 years and China's stayed the same, India's still would not be as big. That alone reflects the scale of the challenge India faces.
India's economic rise leads to honest questions about how it fell behind China in the first place. It's strange relationship with the Soviet Union, colonial legacy, manufacturing challenges and past policies have all played a role.
India's demographic dividend is more time sensitive than most people think. Yes, it has advantages but the window and manner to capitalise upon them is
not permanent or straight forward.
#india #economy #indiaeconomy #china
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Enjoyed the video?
Subscribe here: / @altsimplified
Subscribe to my newsletter!
ripplereport.b...
Follow AltSimplified on Social media:
Facebook: / altsimplified
Twitter: / altsimplified
Interested to hear other views on the historical comparison between India and China, as well as the productivity graph I mentioned. If you enjoyed the video you can subscribe here 👉 czcams.com/channels/LiRGHCMGB14Pw0yEqLM2fQ.html
Hindu democracy is India’s problem stem.
According to the latest information India will become the world's biggest contributor to GDP growth by 2029. I don't think your pro China video's will change the trajectory of India rising and China in decline.
@@sancatheone6258well, it’s only 5 years from the year you mentioned. Can it be done? Be realistic.
Understanding Caste in India (Jati & Varna) - How We Destroy Ourselves
@@applebee9060中国很落后很贫穷，印度是一个超级大国发达国家能打败印度的，只有宇宙强国韩国。
Chinese culture does not allow one talks harder but works harder.
Ironic, the comments from you and your people tell otherwise, surely there wouldn't be so many comments if they had a job and we're working you'd think?
也不全对，中国一样也有说大话的人，不过这样的人在中国会被别人看不起，如果他提前说出了他的计划和目标，但是又实现不了，这个人会成为笑柄。印度一样有很多务实的人，只是受宗教和教育的影响太大了，很多人没有办法施展自己的才华，这是非常可惜的，印度政府应该拿出来一个15-20年的计划，稳步的提高国力，先从公民的教育开始，比如学会遵守规则、尊重妇女、不做小聪明的事情，让印度人习惯性用长远目光看待问题。希望我们的邻居有一天能成为真正的超级大国。
@@mr.MazhenL 人家印度有计划啊，莫迪去年宣布2047年印度成为发达国家。莫迪现在72岁左右吧，23年后莫迪才95岁左右。印度国家做事也是有计划的，不要总说人家没计划。
@@mr.MazhenL we respect women. In my religion most of God are women. Ok
@@Marcus.22823yet doctors gets raped in hospital and criminals walk away freely no wonder they migrate to western countries.
A few years ago , every title was India is the next China . Or even replace China .
Now, every title is, India is not the next China ......
That's because it's become readily apparent that FDI into India doesn't get results like FDI into China. All of that wishful thinking evaporated in the face of the reality of an undereducated Indian workforce with terrible logistics further mired in red tape.
@ZweiZwolf yes, China has developed efficient soulless bully bots out of its people.
@@ZweiZwolf And a lazy labor force that approaches work with a laissez faire attitude.
Now is 2047 india superpower....
@@yangyang7230Super powders saar 😁
China and India are not in the same category for comparison.
China is collapsing...Economically...Financially...and Now..even Politically...! Please tell us the TRUTH...the real inside situation about China
@@ChuckUstaad Bro, you need to break out of your echo chamber and open your eyes to the real world
@@ChuckUstaad I want you to come back to reality, India is failing
印度很难了，9月份开始美联储将会降息，大量的钱会重新流向制造业，美国正面临前所未有的金融困局。看看这几个月的汇率变化你就知道哪些国家在被美元收割了。很不幸，印度是其中之一，中国得益于自身强大的制造业汇率反而上涨了。缺乏制造业的印度又将错过第二次崛起的机会，接下来就是进口商品全面涨价，波及到印度人民生活的各个方面。印度与中国的差距会越来越大。我虽然是中国人，但我是站在客观立场说的。你可以留意最近一段时间印度市场价格的变化。@@ChuckUstaad
Not even one Olympic gold obtained yet to talk a lot nonsense 2024.
Apart from the population size, these two countries have absolutely nothing in common.
India and China both have ancient cultures; similar independence date for India and founding date for China in the late 1940s; and similar GDP metrics through the 1960s. That is, India and China started at roughly the same place in 1950, and have since grown to the same population, but very different economies!
They actually have a lot in common (all nations do), including sharing a mountain range, among a lot of common history, most people have minimal or no real knowledge of.
@Sovereign_Citizen_LEO none of those makes these two countries share values and culture TODAY which are the ultimate deciding factors to shape a society. A few simple examples -- 1) chinese people's view on the Opium Wars vs. Indian people's views on the British rule and the continued adoration of everything western. 2) China is an egalitarian society vs India's caste system no matter how some indians deny it.
@@FallenLeavesBackToRoots - In other words, India will largely be irrelevant for a while (a decade to two decades).
@@FallenLeavesBackToRootschina is not egalitarian society. It has internal cast systems like "Guanxi" and "Hikou" System which are more terrible than the indian cast system
India always dream to be like China, but Indian don't know China nor learn about. One thing Indian do well is talk but Success isn't by mouth but by deeds, hard work, sacrifices. India need several hundred years to get near China.
You are definetly uneducated in economics. India can surpass China within a few decades, but to do that they must solve their internal issues. They are not doing a great job of that right now. If they never do, India will still grow rapidly, and quality of life will improve, whether you like it or not, but it will not match China. Still a great improvement for India and its people though.
Olympic 2024 is an example
Accept it, china wants to be America and in India we don’t put bulldozer on our students. And everyone know about Chinese real estates (tofu cement)
India obviously became develop country but terrorist nations never become
@@pranabsarkar6395 India is not terrorist, Pakistan is. India actively invests in anti terrorism in its region and uses its navy to protect shipping from pirates. What are you on?
education, infrastructure, anti corruption and government policy are the key
which will never materialise
Also more actions and less talking, boasting and bragging.
@@hengongchua6250 that is UNindian you are asking .
Anti corruption, is that the reason we see people begging their parents to get a medical treatment they can't afford, and the parents declining their help because they don't want to let their children pay huge amounts of money and choose to die instead? Is it normal that people don't get help from hospitals if they don't pay upfront? How great is this China?
India's literacy stands at 27%, corruption is off the meters scale, cronyism , nepotism , religious and gender inequality , weak leadership and the list goes on and on. As for as I am concerned India is doomed.
India is an example that "democracy" doesn't guarantee social justice, productivity, or stability.
Tell me you are a muslim without telling me you are a muslim
Researching the productivity challenges really emphasised the scale of the opportunities ahead for India 👍
Exactly, could not agree more with.
Indian politicians are much more interested in religious struggle than economic construction.
Its not really a democracy.
Indian society reward hot air talking. Chinese society reward hard working. After 40 years, the results are obvious.
😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😂😂😂😂😂😂👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Why compare a Mansion with a junkyard?
Yes why compare A tiger with a cockroach
Ma'am your goat need some weed 😂😂😂😂
not junkyard, you mean sewage dump?
@@lizzardlivesmatters🥶
More like a junkyard to a mansion that was still under construction and looked just as dirty as a junkyard of construction goods
I visited India in March 2024 to see for myself the real India. I was in China just before the pandemic, to be honest India still has a long way to go to catch up to China perhaps in 50 years I am being optimistic 😅
You should come back to China today and see the difference when you were in China since 2019. It will shock you if you know what I mean.
50 years to catch to 2024 china maybe 100 years and even so China will be more futuristic that will ever be.
Where in India did you go? Did you go to Indian cities or just went to slums and low income areas to please your fear of India's growth.
@@aarthirajaraman7453 There are slums and cow dungs everywhere in E-ndia.
@@aarthirajaraman7453 Just go to Mumbai, India's richest and most developed city. Their local government reported there are 2400 slums in Mumbai. Just google "2400 slums in Mumbai" and you'll find articles on it.
Don't compare it with China because it will never be the same
India doesn't want or aspire to be like china. Why make everything plain vanilla bot? India loves its spirituality, humanness, freedom, individuality, democracy, diversity etc... it is ok to be less rich than being bully bots.
@@striker44 I'm sure you love your polluted streets and your grapists as well.
Thank god we don’t want to be a communist ccp entity
Bro you guys call your country religious when you guys can’t even keep it clean from your own behind
Under someone like Deng Xiaoping it maybe.
India lacks in, education, infrastructure, manufacturing sector, ect. Everything that is the backbone of development is lacking in india. And the sad part is people still dream about India becoming the global super power.
lol keep crying india is already global power
So u r saying we can't even brings changes , and development
The thing is that why these fools want to be superpower and where does this idea came to their mind ?😂😂😂
I have lived my entire life in India and never felt positive about the society even once.
I have seen the sheer arrogance, stubbornness and lack of civil manner everywhere and knew that this nation is doomed to fail eventually and that time has finnally come.
Huge population, no jobs, no developement.
And its too late for that.
And still crossed the economies of Europe .. can anyone explain ?
@@krishnachaitanya3105
Yes.
Individual European countries are smaller in size with smaller populations and smaller resources.
They are actually extremely rich given their size.
India despite being so huge barely crosses their economy.
Not to mention they are also extremely rich in per capita income while India is still a sh*thole.
only China can be China. China, the Nation, is what emerges from the society in China. India doesn't have China's society. Simply having population and money isn't what makes an economy. We're used to thinking of economics as if it's a technical subject like electrical engineering or physics. It's not. The economy is what emerges from society. So, how society organises itself and its values, etc are what determine the economics. India will be the next India.
This guy gets it 🙌
True that
China is a han Chinese nation state while India is a forced union of dozens of nations and civilisations
JAI HIND
@stevenlai1199 China is a han Chinese nation state while India is a union of many nations and civilisations
Indians had no idea that China's civil war and resistance against Japanese aggression had lasted for 30 years around 1940. At that time, China's long-term chaos severely damaged China's economy. Around 1940, there was no major war in India at all. India was in a period of peace, and in 1840, China's GDP accounted for over 40% of the world's GDP. Indians always enjoyed comparing the GDP of the two countries in 1940, but in fact, there was no comparability. In 1949, the Chinese Nationalist Party and the Communist Party invested more than 14 million troops in the civil war, which swept across China from north to south. In the end, the Communist Party won the victory and drove the Nationalist Party to Taiwan. China's independence was achieved through large-scale wars and countless small-scale wars, while India's independence was achieved through sit ins. The implementation is completely incomparable, Although India illegally invaded China's Tibet/Xizang and occupied a large part of China's territory, including Kashmir, Ladakh, and southern Tibet, since 1903, China has always been very restrained. In the 1962 invasion and counterattack against India, China only sent a small number of troops. If there was a large-scale land war, all Indian troops would have no hope of victory. In the history of the world, large-scale wars involving more than 1 million people basically took place in China. Most Indian people have not realized China's friendliness to India until now. If China were replaced by Russia, India would have been destroyed long ago
Comparing the Sino-Japanese war to what the British did to India is a joke. It's like comparing a broken ankle to an amputation of the your legs and arms.
India didn't illegally invade Tibet, China did and the world did nothing and in the 60s when China invaded INDIAN KASHMIR AND LADAKH, the world yet again did nothing, thinking you own Kashmir and Ladakh is a joke, please go educate yourself.
In 1962, it was a Chinese invasion of India, ask anyone not brain washed by propaganda unlike you and they'll say China were the agressors. I agree India stood no chance but get the facts right.
Most Indians know China isn't friendly, you play China on as if it's some great power which can destroy the west in a year yet your to scared to invade Taiwan, if China were to be replaced by Russia, south Asia would be a lot more amicable.
😂
Commi😅
😁😁😁😁😁🙏🙏🙏🙏👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
@@7Ms18VKDhoti
It does not matter whether a country has a political system that follows or not the US/Western values of "democracy" What really matters is whether the political system serves or not the well being and interests of the people in that country.
Democracy matters a lot, because multi-party democracy divides the country.
Morality is the foundation of a nation-state.
Average Chinese national now eats more protein than an American: UN food agency
The milestone was reached in 2021, according to United Nations data despite US predictions that it would destroy the planet
18 Jul, 2024
China has surpassed the US in the amount of daily dietary protein available to its population - an important indicator of a modern quality of life, and one that some commentators and politicians in the West thought would be impossible to achieve.
According to the latest data from the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), China overtook the US in 2021, reaching a daily supply of 124.61 grams (4.39oz) of protein per capita
SCMP
@@ZweiZwolf besides democratic system, the main problem is India is a federation where states has a lot of power. So regionalism and factionalism dampers India's progress
@@samuelmorales2344
China raised >800M of its people out of poverty - a historical milestone, never accomplished.
More than a thousand years ago, Chinese monks went to India to study Buddhism. He recorded in detail the dozens of federal states in ancient India and the squalid conditions in India at that time. During the same period, China already had urban cleaners. I think India has been more like a group of uncivilized tribes since ancient times. They pay more attention to the spiritual level and do not care about the living conditions of ordinary people.
Jokers like you who have no past and future are commenting on indian civilization 😂😂😂
What you think is irrelevant stick to eating bats
And I suppose humans would float on wings before Newton discovered gravity. Ancient India was fantasized by the European powers as country with knowl streching across centuries, wealth to last an Eon and a society so advanced they were untouchable by land.
Ok if we are uncivilized we eat meat 1kg 😂😂😂 and not be vegetarian. In India one city where meat ban in Gujarat. China is civilized why people eat bat, snake, frog. They are civilised. Ok we are uncivilized don't come India. We uncivilized never capture other land. Ok kid go back read history. Your ancestors are civilised that's why he looted other land and kill them try to convert into Christianity.we never try to convert other people like Christian, muslim do for conversion Don't teach about civilisation ok. One Chinese writer says India is uncivilized.. No country on earth is uncivilized from native American to sentinel island people. Chinese are civilized that's why he comes to India.kid you need to grow your mind. If you says we are uncivilized tribe ok.😂😂😂😂
Chinese , British are most civilized people on earth 😂😂😂😂
india talk, China work, who will win?!!
India talk only? No India will steel you home
True
Yall talk so much about us talking. 😂
They all move out from China to India ? Show me the evidence 😂😂😂
Yea not all but very few most went to asean specifically Vietnam.
@@swapneelbehera260Companies moving to Vietnam are mostly Chinese. They assemble stuff their or redirect it to avoid import tariffs of usa
@@Dr.Kraig_Renyou are right , most companies move to vietnam are still china companies , inclding some korea and japan companies , but most of them are still china companies
Only the manure recycling ♻️ part moved into INDIA.
Why move to india to make india another threat like china.... china is already a hesdache moving all to india means the headache just move to anther part if the brain.
India is super power & super human in Indian media 😂😂😂😂😂😂
indian is already better than china, korea and japan.
Indian please don’t talk but do and show the world 😂😂
indian is already better than china, korea and japan.
Nah, only talking & chest thumping while dwindling in gutter & broke wallet life.
Most of the CEOs of US IT companies are from India. They studied in Indian Institute of Technology (IIT). I am very sure the Chinese will know nothing of it. 40% of America's generic medicines (Paracetamol type) are from India. I am very sure the Chinese will know nothing of it. It is not our problem that people in China just sit in an island having no knowledge of what takes place in the world. We are doing things.
@@aniruddhrajendran7570 This is precisely the problem of India, where elites go abroad to work and dedicate themselves to white Europeans and Americans. This does not provide any assistance to India itself~
@@aniruddhrajendran7570 So what? Even if an Indian becomes a CEO, he is still essentially a wage earner, and the industrial chain is still in the hands of other countries. What do you want to prove with the many examples of Indians becoming CEOs? Nothing can be proved, and the success of a few elites cannot represent the level of the entire country. These Indians play for other countries and will not come back to India. It can be seen from here that the Indian elite is proud of integrating into Western countries and is proud of being fluent in English. The Chinese elite has completely different thinking. Return to China and make China more powerful. Let foreigners learn Chinese instead of letting Chinese People learn English. The national pride and ambition of the elite determine the future of both countries.Indians' pride in English reveals that the legacy of colonialism still exists.
China made plans and excute the plans. India made plan , execution none😂
Bro You need cheap Chinese cloth 🤣🤣🤣
@@Marcus.22823Dhoti
You can watch this video in 2124 and the title is still applicable
Doubt, given what happened 5 years ago, China would just seize to exist due to being the origin of all diseases and unsanitary conditions
Wipe the tears off once you done😂
THAT'S TRUE... iNDIA WILL NEVER BE LIKE CHINA.
India never want to be china. Why be bully bots?
It is True, but it will be much better than China, example is Covid how the manage it... similarly they have the capability to do better when time is come...China id giving problem to world and India is giving solution on that problem
India is different 👌👌👌
@@Marcus.22823what he said was not a compliment 😂
@@yuugenr7549what he replied wasn't wrong either 🤣
Spot on. India will never be like China because India is not like China. Markedly different cultures. Markedly different politics. Markedly different peoples. The Chinese are very focused, united, hardworking, and clever. They have a strong, capable and intelligent government that gets things done.
Not to mention humility and a sense of responsibility to the fate of the people. When leader Deng Xiao Peng saw other countries enjoying progress and prosperity and not helping their arch enemy Japan is doing better than them, supposed to be a defeated country. Japan people have Fridge and microwave at home while China people have bicycle. The Leader Deng Xiao Peng was anguish that CCP have let down China people and that US when he said doesn't matter white cat or black cat as long as catch mice...That means the CCP have to change mindset. They did an honourable thing by turning around and adopt foreign country economic model especially Singapore. They succeeded. Will N Korea do this feat? Highly doubt so..
We are everything that you described the chinese
@samarthbagwe1736 India is not united. Too many different cultures. Some cultures cant excel or exceed Chinese cultures but many cannot, thereby dragging the countrys net success
@@samarthbagwe1736 You have a cast system.
@@samarthbagwe1736 nope curry, you are nothing alike, you are 3rd world material and will always be third world in every aspect.
As of January 2024, over 855 thousand companies were defunct or struck off in India. On the other hand, about 33 thousand companies were amalgamated or merged during same time period. The total number of closed companies in the country stood at about 924 thousand as of 2024.27 Mar 2024. The list of obstacles they face in India is equally long: “regulatory flip-flops, high tariff barriers, red tape, corruption, perplexing land policies, infrastructure issues and others tied to the ease of doing business,”.
Thanks for the additional stats and facts, commenting for others to see this.
I found the land registry to be particularly interesting. Often disputes can last decades, a particular headache for mega projects.
@@AltSimplified Why does India like to compare with China, but China doesn't care about India? China doesn't see India as a threat or something to aspire for, then the reason is simple. Talk to any one. For a vast majority of them, India is a low income country, with poverty and misery everywhere. That's literally how the ordinary people views India. Business people that travel to India but never eat outside the hotel or only do selectively because they feel it is too ‘unclean’. Just take an aerial view of Shanghai and compare it to Bombay and it doesn't take a genius to figure out why that is. Remember, China is a middle income country (think Turkey or Mexico), while India is a low income country (think Pakistan or Bangladesh).
Is that 'China statistics' borrowed by Cherubim? 855 thousand companies? Please do not 'sloppyganda' here?
@@cherubimcherubim9515India really should compare itself with a rising Africa these days
I remember in the early 1990s
There was talk wages were getting too high in China and India was the next China
@@DW-op7ly That's' why China is pumping everything into high-tech industry , they don't want to stuck in a middle income trap
Democracy is holding India back. A huge portion of the population is too poor and uneducated to make sensible voting decisions.
How much poor in India kid go back some study then lecturing about India. If I have no degree i am uneducated . Kid your are living in 1950 era . India different than china. Respect every country.
@@Marcus.22823 People like you, who cannot even form a coherent sentence, shouldn't have the right to vote.
@@Marcus.22823lol okay marcus what’s ur real name? you are even afraid to show your real name - streetpooper 2000. lemme guess ur one of those street vendors selling cow dung for dinner
@@Marcus.22823indian 😂
@@harlow2264chinese 😂
China rode the waves of globalisation. The ultra focus to ensure that they got the most out of it and not became a collateral damage from that. Unless India got some secret sauce, the world today is different and protectionism is the buzz word. It would be hard for India or anyone else to replicate China success
Why everybody go to China instead of India
Be patient.lndia will be the next China, all lndia need now is
forever years to achieve it's goal.
Hope keeps the dream alive
你是说印度可以变成30年前的中国吗？
You need to reform your government.
@@jiewang7443 我看过印度的基础设施、种姓制度、营商环境、治理效率、就业环境，政府的不作为占主要原因，虽然他们的文化导致很难改革，你看过什么才能说出无知啊？
🤣🤣🤣
Everything comes down to government leadership and policies. For example, China's biggest EV manufacturer BYD has just opened up a maga plant in Thailand to produce the latest tech. EVs where the wages is about 3X of India. But BYD decided to open the factories in Thailand, Brazil and Hungary but not India. The Indian government has this extremely short sighted mentality policies that make foreign companies stay away. Those who have entered India in the past such as Ford, GM, Harley Davidson, Nissan, Xiaomi etc. have either left or is thinking of leaving. Foxconn, Tesla reached the door step but decided to back out. Modi has been in power for all these years and still hasn't changed much. Looks India has missed the boat Again and will stay that way. India needs to less emotional, arrogant and more rational and think long term.
Actually BYD didn't get approval from India for their factory. Do your research, bro.
@sancatheone6258 LOL... That's exactly my point. India needs to be less emotional, arrogant and more rational. It is not the only place companies can set up manufacturing plants. It has missed the industrialization boat.
@@sancatheone6258atleast India have the ambani to show off to the western friends about their wedding😅😅😅😅
@@baikeiast5255 You go girl, if that is what makes you happy. I don't care about their wedding.
@@laowantongchau Well, I busted your story, didn't I? The decision to refuse BYD was taken after rational decision making. Maybe you're emotional, that's up to you.
What You really mean to say is.... India can never be as smart or as powerful as China...!!!!!
Looting and capturing others land ok 🤣🤣🤣🤣
You did not mention the most critical problems: Corruption, Gender Inequality and the Caste system.
Caste system is overrated. No-one knows what caste other people are from. And it's only evident in rural areas of poorest states.
You know nothing about India. You mentioning problems are in 2000. This is 2024 society grows up
@@Dr.Kraig_Rencaste system runs the politics and almost all boomers are casteist by nature. Daily caste violence and ₹@pe are common in indian culture
India can never be like china😂
Yes and India doesn't want to be it wants to be India
No one in their right minds want to be like china bots.
least India have space program better than Britisher 😂😂
@@Marcus.22823we don’t need space programme, i’m surprised you can even afford a phone to type on with 2000$ gdp per capita 😂😂. meanwhile indian government needs to give food rations to 1 BILLION people 😂
@@xerogue pork eating kid don't know about India Giving lecture about .see your country homeless people 🤣🤣🤣 and islamization of Britain. Giving lecture of phone and gdp . This is the result of cheap wine 🤣🤣🤣.your economy is dieing your country need to loot other country . Your history tells what is your country do in past. Your ancestors are biggest looter in history of human. Don't lie 🤥🤥🤥.
Of course , India will never able to catch up with China
"Life is a contradiction". How can india be a democracy (equality for all) when there is a caste system.
You are not updated with the latest news on Apple. Apple just signed up with its latest business partner not with India but the auto maker in China BYD. Also it is important to know what is China doing right now and compare to what is India doing right now because the global industrial and business environment is different now to when China rose to the top as a manufacturing nation. For a nation like India being the service centre and without the manufacturing pillar is not ideal to increase its industrialization in a country like India, India has a large untrained youth employment population and this group needs to start off with industry that is labor intensive industries that are making their way away from China but into countries like Vietnam and India's neighbor Bangladesh. If we look at population dividend of these two nations then we see why China is so much ahead of India, with almost comparable population China has 40% more people in its work force than India, in term of skilled and trained workers China has 192 million compare to 27 million in India. The other reason is how these two countries invest in education and science and technological research. China invest 3.3% of its GDP in education and while India invest 2.9% of its GDP in education, considering China has an economy that is almost 5 times of India so China actually spend almost 5 times what China spent on educating its youth. In term of science and technological R@D China invests more than 9 times that of India, this is why you are seeing China has a growing tech sector that is able to lift the country into higher value added industries like EVs, with forward thinking China is also a major player in getting the critical resources around the world. China has factoring the needs of infrastructures decades before India with it it is ready to grow for decades. Compare to China India is also rather poor in natural resources, China is widely considered as resource rich nation while it does not have all the natural resources but globally it is considered the 6th resource rich nation behind the likes of Russia, US, Saudi, Canada and Iran.
你说的是油气资源。我们的国土面积就决定了我们的其他资源也是很充沛的。
耕地、海洋、铁矿、淡水资源都不如印度，好在我们的邻居不太聪明，没有诞生出高等级文明，至今还沉迷于封建迷信😂@@user-us3wc9qv9l
India is at least 35 to 40 yrs behind where china is today so after 35 yrs where china will be 😢
So right now there is no comparison
India is super power only in godi media and social media 😂
i bet the gap is even further apart by looking at China's AI, ev, spacestation, 5.5g robotics,hsrail, power genaration,solar, semiconductor & most important the talented ,well educated and discipline people is the biggest asset.
Better than Pakistan who needs step dad America to bail him out with imf loans cause he doesn’t understand economics
Modi grew us to the point where foreigns even suggest we will overtake China. China isn't 35-40 years ahead, at most it's 25 years ahead but should be 10-15 years ahead
Lol even poor quality of life than India 😂
If they are so much developed
So why not even 1 million medical tourism coming in china whereas
6 million in india every year 😂
@aarthirajaraman7453 25 years ahead, at most? Your country doesn't even have enough toilets. 😂
Look at India Olympic medal performance , Ha Ha !
Largest population and largest demoncrazy no gold. 🤣😆😂🤣🤣🤣😆😆😂😂😂😂😂
@@twilight6460i think he is doing comment while sleeping 😪😪
yeah it's not like we are forcing a 14 year boy to play at olympic so that with the price of it he can pay for her mother's treatment ...what a great governance ...😂
@@ayushikumari6175 14 year boy also get high level confidence, unlike your ind students doing nothing before age 18
@@GAMEONHWG building confidence and forcing it is different so don't coat words and on second part did you take surveys here 😂 and btw what milestone you have achieved to say that
India missed the cheap low cost labor ride because A.I. automation would reduce human labor involvement. So it's near impossible to catch up to China in the next 50 years.
it’s impossible for india to develop ever. the country won’t exist in 50 years. you will see a free east punjab, kashmir joining pakistan, south india independence.
Umm so by that logic. Chinese will will be jobless too. 😂
到了九月份，印度还会因为制造业薄弱再错过一次机会，看看国际汇率吧，哪些国家又被美元收割了？目前只有中国面对美元汇率上涨。这意味着，到了九月份美元降息，印度企业将大面积被美国人收购，国有资产被贱卖，失业和通货膨胀将会加剧，物价在2024年下半年将上涨10%，阿达尼公司被收购就是这个原因，他们只想在印度经济崩盘前卖个好价钱。而美元降息会导致大量资金流向制造业，最主要就是中国，这是经济学常识，如果没有大范围的战争，这是无法避免的。如果印度人看到了我的评论，我建议你们把存款想办法兑换一部分人民币，到时候你会感谢我的。❤❤
Hi bro
@@noisyboy178 The difference is China already have a big domestic industry and a circular economy.
China and India started at the same place after WWII. China is far ahead of India today. That alone tells you why India will never catch-up with China. The reasons why is why India was left behind.
Because there is no tension of election
And freebies policy doesn't work in china
All the money government has to develop the infrastructure but in India everyone is running for government job
@@rahulramola934 The problem of human mind! Indians are lazy and like to brag! Chinese people like to do more and talk less.
If China is a failure, what is India today?
A spiritual, diverse, free and interesting culture.
@@striker44 More like superstitious, divided , chaotic and complicated culture...
@@striker44
India is often perceived by Western tourists as an exotic, chaotic, and underdeveloped country. Furthermore, it is viewed as a poor nation with limited industrial capacity, posing no significant threat to Western hegemony.
@@hyuxion
I mean, are they wrong ?
I think not.
West is definitely scared of China.
@@striker44bro stop lying India is unsanitary is every way possible
The lack of strategy to implement a strong policies which is must needed to make a potential change is one of the biggest issues.
India needs 50 years to reach some of China's current status, but not all.
India is another example that democracy doesn't provide economic development, safety and happiness for its citizens.
Agree absolutely. Democracy is not for poor developing countries. Democracy is the worst form of government for poor developing countries. Many countries were not democratic when they were developing their economies.
So you believe the rigged indexes?
India is a different country! Every country is unique. Every country has its own geography, climate, history and economic patterns. That creates different languages, culture, customs, etc. Why don't you stop using language like "xxx can be the next China.". No country will become China. Why don't you say: "xxx can grow their economy very fast."
Comparison bring views😅
@@samratshashank4919 The point is to stop using nonsensical language. To compare, say compare.
The funny part is that most Indian want to compare with China so......
@@adrianmah1504which Indian wants to compare with China ?
@@maninadar7562all the time I see indians trying to compare with china, but I guess now they are sad they realise they will never be what bjp promised 😂
When ever I hear china it reminds me of progress, stability
Chinese also control muslim population 🤣🤣🤣 . Why are you not crying 🤣
For all things India, just listen to Jayant Bandhari
I followed Jayant Bandhari too. I find him an amazing enlightened woke indian. But his words will have NO TAKERS in india. india will just keep on RUSTING AND ROTTING.
He is the right person. Whatever he says the opposite will be true.
At least he is a true hater. Does not change his opinion based on who wins the election.
Bro is a loser
Saar india superpower 2047. Jayant Bhandari is anti national
500 millions people in India doesn't have access to toilets taking about overtaking China.😅
Aww, ur little Chinese ego got hurt, here have a band aid 🩹. Cope more
For 2022, three years after all the Covid-19 disruptions, the US GDP has grown to $25.46 trillion, China’s GDP to $18.1 trillion, and India’s GDP to $3.39 trillion.
The US and China have added GDP of $4.08 trillion and $3.76 trillion respectively in these three years. At the same time, India could add only $0.55 trillion. Both the US and China have added more than India’s 2022-23 GDP ($3.39 trillion) during this period.
Given this, are we ratcheting up our GDP growth to catch up with the US and China, or is India’s GDP gap with the US and China widening uncomfortably.
Treasury Sec. ADMITS Devastating Thing For U.S.
czcams.com/video/8r93La5dnu8/video.html
DUDE if you have huge sums to start with , you will get equally large outcomes ..so your narrative and context is flawed to start with...
Secondly look at growth figures from the same covid era , it throws china and US off the bandwagon before the starting point...and that's being said....
Just because china started early, with dictatorship, cleared anything and everything for money..he'll with the people or environment or everything else , is not exactly a achievement ...
Interesting
@cherubimcherubim9515 Crafty... reported to delete my comment... for starters, your narrative is out of context... If you have a bigger GDP to start with, your outcome numbers will look bigger which is the BS narrative you float ...for real comparison, let's look at GDP growth numbers in China and US during COVID.. India outdid both US and China combined... so state facts, not narratives... while you are at it also compare the pathetic state chinese economy is and also how every one is abandoning China...that will be the real comparison.
India and Indians accept China grew much ahead of india for 2-3 decades.. but now it's indias time...
Facts may not satisfy your ego , which doesn't mean what indians say is incorrect
@@sandeepsandhu4286 india needs 4 decades of uninterrupted growth like China did to overtake China. Can india achieve it without the Chinese market? It will take decades to come close to China even if China stop growing. If india growing at 8 % and China growth is at 6% mean India’s only have 2% advantages which will take india kingdom come to even come close to China. By that time China will have overtaken usa as world largest economy. How on earth is india going to feed your ever growing population with just 4 trillions dollars? India still have regular power interruption, water interruption, lack of toilets this is just basic needs.
You can just go visit India and know why.
India is the graveyard for foreign investors
@@twilight6460Sure man
Deleting comments over here. Where is the lie when I say they need to fix their sanitation first?
Lol by this logic Americans need to stop their school shooting and shoplifting habits before doing anything. Get a life you are so negative.
@@philosopherfrombedFixing the sanitation is a must no? I don't see how this is negative.
@@OK-jn4wn coming from a westerner lol, you go figure out your gender first, dmbazz
Indians wash while you wipe. Do a little experiment with chocolate and you will know which one is cleaner. However if you are talking about street food, it will automatically as Indians make more and more money coz right now their focus is on getting the next meal on table. They were robbed of their riches by your forefathers.
500 millions people still defecating on open air it’s a real problem India has.
I challenge anyone to name a country that has the following characteristics and still became advanced economies:
1. Backward socio cultural attributes
2. Failed democracy
3. A population more than what the country's resource base can handle
4. Poor work ethic
5. Crappy bureaucracy
6. Increasing brain drain
7. Increasing communal disharmony
8. Lack of unity
9. Rapid environmental degradation
10. Poor law and order
11. Lack of any major economic, political and social reforms
12. Slave mentality
13. Hero worshipping
14. Lack of any unique economic edge
15. Unfair labour laws
16. Lack of efficiency in anything
India has all these characteristics, yet bhakts love to belive that India will become a developed country in 2047. What else do you call this other than madness?
If anything china is becoming like India
So, what are you doing about it?
You got me, bro.
💯
Yes, Saudi Arabia, Quatar and UAE. But actually, this bhakt will tell you you won't have to wait until 2047, India will overtake China within a decade. It's a combination of India rising and China imploding, you can thank me later if you make money from it.
India is also known as religious intolerance now a day's and own religious inequality. India has it's homemade obstacles for her future. 😮
One andhnamazi spotted. Karma hit back on Britain islamization of Britain start, us vice president right 🤜🤜. France have muslim problem.in muslim rally in Germany muslim want saria in Germany. Quraan is book to transform whole planet into stone age 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Finally a peaceful, known for their tolerance far and wide, speaketh!
So no Muslims to protest and cause problems is an obstacle?
If the simple things like cleaning your surroundings they can't do , how do you expect them to do more?
Why does India like to compare with China, but China doesn't care about India? China doesn't see India as a threat or something to aspire for, then the reason is simple. Talk to any one. For a vast majority of them, India is a low income country, with poverty and misery everywhere. Watching india's street children is heart breaking. That's literally how the ordinary people views India. Business people that travel to India but never eat outside the hotel or only do selectively because they feel it is too ‘unclean’. Just take an aerial view of Shanghai and compare it to Bombay and it doesn't take a genius to figure out why that is. Remember, China is a middle income country (think Turkey or Mexico), while India is a low income country (think Pakistan or Bangladesh).
Lower middle income country not low income!! And he is using old data 2011 data in his video!! He is not telling the investment made in infrastructure by government, weapon manufacturing, development in critical tech!! And multiple start up in India and business port openings. And India is lower middle income but it's soon gonna become an upper middle income more likely by 2030s
@@abhishekbhaskar6268Bangladesh per capita is even higher then india. GDP per Capita in India reaching 2239.25 USD in 2023. GDP per Capita in Bangladesh had a GDP per capita of USD 2,528 in 2023. China's GDP per Capita in 2023? China Gross Domestic Product (GDP) per Capita reached 12,621.721 USD in 2023.
It's the mind set, Indian should stop calling other 'Sir' and 'Madam' ,
@@LeeVS-mo2fs this is duel to the colonial and cast system mind set.
Yet the pla lost to a bunch of stick indians
India aims for overnight riches.
India will never match let alone bypass China. Indians being individualistic have a tendency to not be totally committed but expect that they get a fair share of their efforts, especially when they realise their effort is benefiting their employer. They are not backwards in agitation in their demands, especially when feel their contribution is greater than what they first expected to be.
Loyalty is a not preponderance occurrence in their behaviour.
Some people say that India will catch up with China in the next 15 years, which is very difficult. This requires India to build a large port ranked among the top ten in the world every two years, and to construct 3000 kilometers of high-speed railways and 10000 kilometers of expreways every year for the next 15 years. At the same time, building 20 square meters of housing per capita for 100 million people every year.
Wheres the money come from?
@@niceguy76 China's investment in these infrastructure projects costs less than $10 trillion, while the money taken from India by the UK is $45 trillion
@@adenauerheesen2137lol that is a fake figure, plus that figure is for british india, which includes now pakistan and bangladesh, so that figure doesn’t even make sense. today even bangladesh has higher gdp/capita than india😂
@@adenauerheesen2137also china didn’t get rich from natural recourses they put in hard work,just like many other countries like south korea, they were also colonised. but you poor indians always blame other people for your problems. just face reality
@@xerogue why you spreading lies in every other reply bangladesh currunt gdp per capita is low than india bangladesh had higher gdp per capita only when covid spread after that india economy was recovered and have higher gdp per capita....
700 000 000 people don't have toilet at home and crap outside in India they say
The problem with manufacturing is its intense labor and capital business that affect the environment. India is very polluted. Can India handle more pollution?
Will India never be like China ! ?
Elon musk : Yes !
Tim Cook : Yes !
Lol. Always looking for validation from the white man 😂 Typical Indians
Just a story from my Uni years. During the finals all the Indians in front of me were openly cheating even after being warned by the examiners. An Indian seated behind me who I didn't know kicked my chair asking for a free handout until I shushed him. Apparently exams for them were not a test of the depth of their knowledge but merely a test of their ability to game the system. Its a structural problem so I can't imagine a fix for their home country. As a side note, that they weren't kicked out of the exam hall just shows how Unis have become degree mills.
Funny that you mention degree mills. I have a future video coming up on just that...
Ok we are cheater not greater than your ancestors 😂😂😂. Your whole British ancestors looted Africa, Asia, and native American. Your ancestors looting golds, mineral. Kid see in your country your economy down your country need indian investment. Many rich indian living in uk. Jd Vance says uk first Islamic nation which have nuclear bomb. How many Indian kill by britisher. I can write many book what crime your ancestors do in Asia, Africa. Once Britisher once try to destroy white . Kid don't teach about India. Your dirty missionary doing illegal conversion in India. Kid stay in your limit ok 👌👌👌
its the color of the skin that causes this behaviour
China never compares China with india. Why does india keep comparing themselves with China. You should aim high. Compare yourselves with USA.
You're right. Why would a healthy human being compare himself with a leper?
indian is already the best of the best, better than uk, us, and china.
EB我猜
😂
China isn't a standard for India to follow.India must set its own standards.
China isn’t a standard India can achieve.
Remember India will always win in social media 😂 thier father ambani offers them cheap data now they are complaining 😂😂😂
people like ambani are real enemy of india, bip party is looting indian from within, just like british did😂 but indians are brainwashed
Dream on catching up with China🇨🇳
India the ultra power in this universe. The no1. in everything and anything including but not limited to the loudest mouth. 😅😅😅
You need burnol. India is different
Indian media and people talk too much do nothing . Chinese media and people talk less do more .
chinese are still ruled by a communist dictator while even africans are advancing politically with democratic societies.. look at south africa, kenya etc., where elections to choose leaders are becoming regular.. chinese are decades behind africa politically even tho African & Chinese iq is similar.. & when chinese eventually transition away from communist dictatorships, there could be chaos & china might break apart like the former soviet union.
Chinese cannot talk freely and made to become bots of the emperor. Bots are needed to build pyramids for the Pharoah.
what a nonsense, you do not know anything about China at all. Actually Chinese can say anything in their social media, remember now everybody could be a media reporter.
😂中国不能自由说话！中国文化不喜欢夸夸其谈的人，并不是我们不能自由表达。几千年来，历史上的中国，已经发生过目前世界上所有国家发生过的事情。所以我们无需多言，坐而谈不如起而行。
@@striker44 You admit you as a bot of your living God Modi? good, you earn your ration of this day. Try not get starved before tomorrow.
India should be compared to Pakistan only
Even Sri Lanka & Bangladesh are ahead of India despite being in crisis
AFRICA IS THE FUTURES. AFRICA CAN DO BETTER THEN INDIA. ♥️♥️♥️🕊️🤝🕊️♥️♥️♥️
😂😂😂
Ok your africa going Mars in 2030🤣🤣
By the standard of international verbosity, India is indeed the largest super-power.
In this respect and to your opinion how many gold medals does it deserve in an international competition ?
All the baljeets are crying on this video.
Baljeets support Khalistan. You meant Sharma and Guptas
Hey, Mo ghand'i.
they are living in fairyland khikhikhikhi
@@SatpalVerma000sharma gupta agrawal tiwaris
You mention 63rd in ease of doing business ranking. But you don't mention it went to 142 (medium) in 2015 to 63rd (easy) within 5 years ranking above Indonesia and Vietnam which you mentioned as competitors in the video.
you dreaming?
@@mengkhiangtan1144 you checked the index?
Never say never, India will change, they will eventually make it easy for doing business.
I often hear this stupid comparison between India and China. The only similarity between the two countries is the huge population size. Apart from this, the countries are very different in terms of culture and history.
India CANNOT be like China. We can definitely take a note or two from China, but what worked for China wont necessarily work for India. India needs to find its own solutions.
India shouldnt stop compare themselves to china.
@@walhdamaskus2408 India doesn't want to compare with China, she feels she's far better than China. 😂😂😂😂
@@brianliew5901 But it is not.
@@brianliew5901 , india is far better than china is only exist in bollywood movie.
Plus, business and service sector is no longer possible to get outsourcings when AI will replace human services. India has to find new frontiers of growth.
We will be number one in world wide Jay hind jay hind jay hind jay hind jay hind jay hind jay bharat Jay hind jay bharat Jay hind jay 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Jail Hindu
Thanks for the video. The information is very interesting. 👏👏👏
I very much doubt that India will surpass China, not with Modi anyway. But if they have a better knowledge of economic development, then it won't be hard for them to pass America! I believe that Indonesia will surpass America more quickly. Don't underestimate the second largest Muslim country in the world with huge resources.
What to expect. Modi was a tea seller who had no education.
Do be aware that any political n economic system whether it's democracy, autocratic, free market capitalism or socialism is only as good as those who are running the show. If democracy is so superior, why has India fallen so far behind China in almost every sphere of development. So it's not the political system but the leaders that are most important
The primary problem, the caste system of Hindu. Revolution !
India's primary emphasis is on religion. That does nothing for the economy. Wealth is frowned upon by the bureaucracy. The quality of construction is bad. The judicial system is slow and questionable. The pandering to those left behind drains resources. The accent on living in an organised high trust society like Singapore, Hong Kong or Mainland China is not there. The flaws in the framework are such that growth will always be patchy
Thanks for the detailed comment! I found the historical journeys of both India and China to be fascinating (the similarities and the differences).
Religion keeps India united. In the absence of religion, India would disintegrate into nation states like nation states in Europe based on their respective languages culture ethnicity history and associated interests
@@SatpalVerma000Incorrect! The illusion of secular democracy kept India united. Since that illusion has disappeared, the unity is going down fast.
@@nyazee Lol 🤣 secular fabric my foot look at Bengal very secular fabric compare to communalist gujrat
I challenge anyone to name a country that has the following characteristics:
1. Backward socio cultural attributes
2. Failed democracy
3. A population more than what the country's resource base can handle
4. Poor work ethic
5. Crappy bureaucracy
6. Increasing brain drain
7. Increasing communal disharmony
8. Lack of unity
9. Rapid environmental degradation
10. Poor law and order
11. Lack of any major economic, political and social reforms
12. Slave mentality
13. Hero worshipping
14. Lack of any unique economic edge
15. Unfair labour laws
16. Lack of efficiency in anything
pakistan & most islamic countries have all these characteristics, yet fanatics love to belive that they will become a developed country. What else do you call this other than madness?
" India never will be china " We indians know about it 😅
A very nice analysis.....
You're most welcome. The historical comparison was my favourite section to make.
Realy as a indian china is very advance country
Agree.
The only question that I have is, why would India even try to be China? It can well be its own thing and chart out its own unique path of economic growth. Later on, other countries might be compared to India in that regard.
中国和印度本质的不同，用宗教来对比更为合适。那就是印度教和佛教。人们往往忽视了这方面。务实，求真，严谨是佛教的本质。然而印度教不是。佛陀说印度教，婆罗门教，耆那教等等是外道邪教。这够不够权威？看看中国人的佛教活动的环境与面貌，印度似乎把所以宗教都玩的越来越邪😅忘记说印度几千年已经没有佛教了，即使有一点点也早被印度教侮染侮辱了。佛陀几千年前就把印度无视了
@@HK.i😂 ur speaking utter bullishit
lmao dream on dude
India will progress but being democratic system it'll b much different than China
Incorrect.
India will never progess.
It will be worse than Africa in next 20 years.
India = $455 bn.
China = $4.9 trillion
Better say:
India = 0.455
trillion
China = 4.9 trillion.
Makes more sense..
They dont have the same drive.
What really holding india back, not the political system but it's religion and caste system (despite being banned after 1947)
Excellent Presentation.
Glad you liked it!
Why my innocuous comments get deleted? My points was too sharp for moderators?
India should be compared with Indonesia, Pakistan, Nigeria or Egypt.
🌹🇮🇳🐉🇨🇳
India is a fragmented and
backward confrontational
Democrazy.with a lot ,of
poor and starving people.
India,is an extreme divided
society. It has too many languages, and religious beliefs. The rich is very rich and the poor is very poor.
... Harris Ng YM 💜
07:10 What? Mauritius is not an "indian archipelago".
It is located on the east coast of Africa and belongs to the african continent.
It has a mixed ethnic and cultural population where indians are a major part but not the only.
Like foxconn returns to china after not getting proper factory settlement in india. They have established their factory in Henan, china. But india still lags in getting proper empty spaces for settlement in many states except Gujarat, Maharashtra and Tamil Nadu.
India's rigid caste system will ensure it won't go as far as China has.
What do you know about caste system??
so true, the reservation system because of caste system isn't letting india grow 😊😊
Viwe from china, caste system doesnt matter, earth revoltion is matter , people share equality to the earth means society equality. However, from foundation of india since 1947, they remain the same system without society revoluton.
@@luoroger-qm9sw no one cares about caste unless they have to marry. And intercaste marriages are common now.
@@ridhamatri9447 if a talent low level caste can marriage with a high rich acste , that would change his lifetime. This talent would be great in the future and benefit for the whole inida people. So, marragie is a important thing to your society.
India will never be like China . Proud Indian.
Stop migrating out of India then
What are you proud of?
@@rpatel3935 nothing to be proud of
@@johnsullivan8673no toilet make him proud