Which economy did Gaza or the West Bank biult up? Taking billions of USD as financial aid is not building up an economy. Does their government structure has attracked international investors? Did they built up industries for export? So, what we are taking about here - no question mark required.
@@adlenechellali2419 Those walls are borders, work permits are like visa or green card to enter another country. I see nothing weird about not being able to cross to another country like going to the toilet. Unless to you it is unacceptable when it's about Israel ;)
The single greatest economic partner the West Bank had was Israel. Now Israel has revoked the work permits for thousands of Palestinian commuters for security reasons. (Remember: That’s how Hamas gathered intelligence ahead of 10/7.) For the record, Israel’s economy has taken a hit as well without Palestinian commuters participating. But it is trying to make up the gaps by hiring more workers from South Asia.
its pretty sad for west bankers . But I can understand israel's concern of letting palestinians from west bank in. What if they help in another terrorist attack?
I am sorry but Palestinians allowed Hamas to make choices for them. This is the result. Palestinians should have listened to themselves instead of the Imam. Hamas and Imams and not missing any meals.
I am sorry, but palestinians in west bank dont even protect their own kids when they are dragged away by idf to prison camps. they really are not in a position to allow or disallow anything.
@@knottastu It is unreal for Isreal to steal peoples land, steal houses, murder children, keep innocent people in prisons without any charge or conviction- and not to expect some kind of retaliation from Palestinians. Those people had suffered enough. I hope they will achieve what they wish for and get their stolen land back to them.
Well, if you start a war by kidnapping innocent people, there are going to be consequences. It was a horrid CHOICE. And I haven't heard one time where Palestinians have said they were wrong.
So-called Israel kidnapped many Palestinian teenagers, children, women and keep them in prisons without any charge or conviction- they can just seem to be a bit suspicious to them. It didn't start in October, it started long ago. Israelis cannot murder children, steal houses, steal peoples land and not expect some kind of retaliations from Palestinians
@@davidgaskin5417 against Israel, yes, the Palestinian Authority does not fight Israel, but collaborates with. it, and still, Palestinian land in the West Bank is being confiscated by Israel.
The Palestinians must give up on their campaign of terror and violence. No sympathy. Develop a real society based on peace, life and love, not the opposite.
@@Noname-lx3ne and Israelis have been celebrating the displacement and killings of Palestinians for decades. What's your point. You believe people should be killed for your perception of their collective opinions? A colonized, displaced people should love their oppressors?
When Palestinians committed their war crimes of October 7, there is evidence that they had knowledge passed on to the terrorists by Palestinians who had worked in Israel.
neither the PA or Hamas allow elections because they know they would lose. instead of turning their guns towards the israelis they should challenge their weak and inept leadership.
Remember a few weeks ago when the world was reporting that the paletinians were running out of food and then someone did their research and thy found out it was just a lie?
@elishmuel1976 13500 children were killed and children are suffering from malnutrition, famine. Infrastructure is destroyed and ongoing violence, land grabbing on the west bank.
@@jaaksavat7916 >> That was before Jordan invaded Israel and lost. Too bad, so sad. Why can’t Palestinians EVER move forward? A victim mentality? Their infantilization by the “international community?” The martyr culture? 🤷🏻♂️
Our economy is struggling with uncertainties, housing issues, bad weather conditions,foreclosures, global fluctuations, and the pandemic aftermath, causing instability. Rising inflation, sluggish growth, and trade disruptions need urgent attention from all sectors to restore stability and stimulate growth.
Ez egy magyar csaj lehet szerintem ez a Fanny Facsar, nem mondanám, hogy magyar akcentusa van, de pl az ö betűt lehet hallani, és más betűket is, z-t, r-t, nem kritizálom, nagyon szép inkább
I live in Jerusalem and I’ve seen this firsthand on my visits to the West Bank! It’s terrible, people are so desperate! Our taxi driver told us he’s gone weeks between customers. Almost every store is closed and every time we bought something the store owners would thank us profusely! These are real people, and they don’t deserve to suffer like this 😔
God, this comment section is such a sad display... The fact that some of you people can't even differentiate between the West Bank and Gaza says a lot about your understanding of the conflict. The West Bank isn't ruled by Hamas, but by the Palestinian Authority, which disavowed violence decades ago, and guess what? They're land is still being gobbled up by Israel, and their people, including civilians and children, are still targeted by deadly violence from the Israeli army, police and illegal settlers on a daily basis.
@@elishmuel1976 Well over 500 Palestinians have been killed in the illegally occupied West Bank since Oct 7th, the majority of them unarmed civilians. This compared to 12 Israelis... Not to mention the thousands of Palestinians from the West Bank who were detained and held without charge or due process, and held under atrocious conditions, often enduring torture and starvation, or the thousands who are being forced from their homes. The Oxford definition of terrorism is as follows: "the unlawful use of violence and intimidation, especially against civilians, in the pursuit of political aims.", which is what Israel has been doing non-stop since it's creation in 1948, on a scale that Hamas could only dream of...
People are not claiming that Hamas control west bank. They are highlighting that since Oct 7th, many in west bank have turned to violence and support what Hamas did - and there is a suggestion that if they could, the people in west bank would want Hamas over the Palestinian authorities. If this is true - the people there really need to learn some harsh lessons .
Let see if their rich arabs will help with some cash money instead of criticism of bla bla & happy some wishing an end to the creasy revenge & the genocide of civilians children & eomen Help to survive not to starve in front of the work dilence
I was many years in forced labour against my will and without payment in forced poverty in the military of the fascist state of Israel that has been torturing me my entire life.
Which economy did Gaza or the West Bank biult up? Taking billions of USD as financial aid is not building up an economy. Does their government structure has attracked international investors? Did they built up industries for export? So, what we are taking about here - no question mark required.
with walls everywhere and controlling everythings you are asking them to be switzerland....
@@adlenechellali2419 Those walls are borders, work permits are like visa or green card to enter another country. I see nothing weird about not being able to cross to another country like going to the toilet. Unless to you it is unacceptable when it's about Israel ;)
@@sebastien-wx9gb visa in their own land .......give them the right to have state and they will not need your humiliating work....
@@adlenechellali2419 Israel is not their own land if they don't have the Israeli nationality. And they already have a state called Jordan.
@@sebastien-wx9gb the lies you need to tell yourself....
PA, Hamus, Hizbolla, UN, and Egypt are getting loads of money for them. Why cant they get it?
The single greatest economic partner the West Bank had was Israel. Now Israel has revoked the work permits for thousands of Palestinian commuters for security reasons. (Remember: That’s how Hamas gathered intelligence ahead of 10/7.)
For the record, Israel’s economy has taken a hit as well without Palestinian commuters participating. But it is trying to make up the gaps by hiring more workers from South Asia.
22 Arab countries awash in cash can dribble a little sustenance to their fellow Arabs.
That cash is only for the ruling families, not the plebs
@@haroldlipschitz9301 Name the ruling families if what you say is true.
@@Historiehomme Google is your friend
Hmmmm maybe start a peace movement instead of a war movement
you know what about palestinian cause ....
Hmmm maybe stop electing a right wing war monger and stop stealing Palestinian lands and homes.
Palestinians have been starting peace movements for 75 years and only went backwards
I am sure they are feeling very peaceful now that they can no longer buy food.
Those who wont feed their own army will feed a foreign one.
is that an advice to Israhelis?
EU bars visas for Russians, frontline EU countries close boarders, and no one questions the logic or necessity.
so palestine is russia in your logic. unless you consider that the war is not in russia but it is in palestine.
Nepal workers and Thailand are way less problematic. and they dont hate israel. so its perfekt.
its pretty sad for west bankers . But I can understand israel's concern of letting palestinians from west bank in. What if they help in another terrorist attack?
I am sorry but Palestinians allowed Hamas to make choices for them. This is the result. Palestinians should have listened to themselves instead of the Imam. Hamas and Imams and not missing any meals.
Hamas isn't from the West Bank
@@notorio526 true but they are all Palestinians so as a people they should have pushed their cousins in Gaza for peace
The West Bank isn't ruled by Hamas, but by the Palestinian Authority, which disavowed violence decades ago
I am sorry, but palestinians in west bank dont even protect their own kids when they are dragged away by idf to prison camps. they really are not in a position to allow or disallow anything.
@@knottastu It is unreal for Isreal to steal peoples land, steal houses, murder children, keep innocent people in prisons without any charge or conviction- and not to expect some kind of retaliation from Palestinians. Those people had suffered enough. I hope they will achieve what they wish for and get their stolen land back to them.
So why hasn’t Hamas given up yet?
Sinwar : “no blood, no news”
Qatar funds them
west bank and gaza are diferent places. there's no hamas in west bank. it's the same if I arrest the staff from a bank after a bank robbery
Well, if you start a war by kidnapping innocent people, there are going to be consequences. It was a horrid CHOICE. And I haven't heard one time where Palestinians have said they were wrong.
The West Bank isn't ruled by Hamas, but by the Palestinian Authority, which disavowed violence decades ago.
So-called Israel kidnapped many Palestinian teenagers, children, women and keep them in prisons without any charge or conviction- they can just seem to be a bit suspicious to them. It didn't start in October, it started long ago. Israelis cannot murder children, steal houses, steal peoples land and not expect some kind of retaliations from Palestinians
@@sundiataqDisavowed violence!? Are you sure?
@@davidgaskin5417 against Israel, yes, the Palestinian Authority does not fight Israel, but collaborates with. it, and still, Palestinian land in the West Bank is being confiscated by Israel.
Your comment shows how ignorant you are on the issue at hand…
The Palestinians must give up on their campaign of terror and violence.
No sympathy.
Develop a real society based on peace, life and love, not the opposite.
except not in the Middle east because its ours!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! who has the policy of terror and violence here ?
yes, I am sure they will have very much peace and life with no food and their kids in idf prison camps.
yes, I am sure they will have very much peace and life with no food and their kids in idf prison camps.
I don't think they need sympathy. They just need the lands back.
its their right to decide who work in israel and who isnt. especially with such a high risk of more violence
logic
Now, they understand the consequence of their own actions.
The West Bank isn't ruled by Hamas, but by the Palestinian Authority, which disavowed violence decades ago
Yeah, Ukrainee also tested the same consequnce
@@sundiataq yes, that is exactly the consequence. Collaboration and submission backfires in the long run.
@@sundiataqlmaooo, people in the West Bank were celebrating and if they had the choice to vote, they will vote for Hamas
@@Noname-lx3ne and Israelis have been celebrating the displacement and killings of Palestinians for decades. What's your point. You believe people should be killed for your perception of their collective opinions? A colonized, displaced people should love their oppressors?
So not only should Israel feed its enemies, but employ them too? Can we think of any other country that would be expected to do the same during a war?
West bank is an occupied territory by Israel, they are mandated by international law to feed them, yes.
When Palestinians committed their war crimes of October 7, there is evidence that they had knowledge passed on to the terrorists by Palestinians who had worked in Israel.
Yup. No one from gaza will EVER get a permit into Israel for work.
yeah I know its so weird people living in an apartheid state and trying to sabotage the establishment that oppresses them
@@luismoura3687 please look up the definition of apartheid. It doesn’t mean what you think it means.
good for them... now learn from your mistakes and elect the right leadership!
neither the PA or Hamas allow elections because they know they would lose. instead of turning their guns towards the israelis they should challenge their weak and inept leadership.
Your comment sounds like it's from a 5 year old child. There are no elections in the West Bank Bantustan.
Why don’t you elect tight leadership in Israel also?!?
@@asha8443 They only elect criminals
okay noted, whatever israel is doing its not good.
So many falsehoods in this reporting. Get the facts straight.
Remember a few weeks ago when the world was reporting that the paletinians were running out of food and then someone did their research and thy found out it was just a lie?
I’ve seen Hamas taking rice bags that Japan gave as cover/reinforcement instead of food.
@elishmuel1976 13500 children were killed and children are suffering from malnutrition, famine. Infrastructure is destroyed and ongoing violence, land grabbing on the west bank.
Such as....?
@@elishmuel1976 someone?
Wait, “Palestine” has an economy?! Also, it’s Judea and Samaria, not the West Bank. Jordan lost; wars have consequences.
the lies you need to tell yourself when you hold an american arms......
@@adlenechellali2419 it's not like you even attemptred tpo debunk his so called "lies"
The west bank is for Palestinian people, agreed upon by the UN, just like the forming of Israeli statehood in 1948 was given by the USA and the UN
@@jaaksavat7916 >> That was before Jordan invaded Israel and lost. Too bad, so sad. Why can’t Palestinians EVER move forward? A victim mentality? Their infantilization by the “international community?” The martyr culture? 🤷🏻♂️
@@adlenechellali2419 >> They did well enough in 1967 with an embargo!
Our economy is struggling with uncertainties, housing issues, bad weather conditions,foreclosures, global fluctuations, and the pandemic aftermath, causing instability. Rising inflation, sluggish growth, and trade disruptions need urgent attention from all sectors to restore stability and stimulate growth.
Attacking Israel and then complaining about jobs.
It's surreal.
Ninguém conquista a confiança e o amor com ataques terroristas.
Parece-me bastante simples.
A vocês não?
odd how supporting a terror group could have gone any other way
The should have read Genesis 12:3.
Nobody has time to read fairy tales
Ez egy magyar csaj lehet szerintem ez a Fanny Facsar, nem mondanám, hogy magyar akcentusa van, de pl az ö betűt lehet hallani, és más betűket is, z-t, r-t, nem kritizálom, nagyon szép inkább
What trust is left before, is long gone.
I am against any Occupier regardless of their race or nationality!
Palestinians attacked Israel in 1967 and won't make peace. They've literally never stopped being at war.
Palestinians shpuld leave and seek jobs in Europe
Committing atrocities and then playing victim … it’s getting old, Palestinians
Sound like another group of people in Palestine who are not Palestinians.
You reap what you sow Palestine 🇵🇸
How come “apartheid” “ open prison “ have economy?
You don't know anything obviously and yet you speak. The open prison is Gaza not the west bank, two different things under different leadership
The palestinians have been on the "verge" of a lot of things since Oct7..non of which materialized.
they apeak arabik native they have 50 countries to sek for job.......i would go to dubai
All the aid money was gone into making tunnels.
Well, looks like collaboration and peace does not indeed pay off in the long run. Who could have seen that coming? 🙄
Maybe Jordan should employ them
Imagine that business/labour economic expedience became a force for reconciliation between Israel and Palestine.
I live in Jerusalem and I’ve seen this firsthand on my visits to the West Bank! It’s terrible, people are so desperate! Our taxi driver told us he’s gone weeks between customers. Almost every store is closed and every time we bought something the store owners would thank us profusely! These are real people, and they don’t deserve to suffer like this 😔
Actions have consequences
There is hamas in the West Bank thy are not the government but there are cells
proof?
Lots of Israeli bots here in the comments section.
Nope, just pro Israelis not bots
So Israel is not allowed to decide on its policy regarding foreign workers?
🇺🇳🇺🇳🇺🇳🇺🇳🇺🇳🇺🇳🇺🇳
God, this comment section is such a sad display... The fact that some of you people can't even differentiate between the West Bank and Gaza says a lot about your understanding of the conflict. The West Bank isn't ruled by Hamas, but by the Palestinian Authority, which disavowed violence decades ago, and guess what? They're land is still being gobbled up by Israel, and their people, including civilians and children, are still targeted by deadly violence from the Israeli army, police and illegal settlers on a daily basis.
Wow! That's so awesome to hear there are no terrorists in the west bank! I was wrong this whole time! LOL
They are genocidal crazy toward the Palestinians.
@@elishmuel1976 Well over 500 Palestinians have been killed in the illegally occupied West Bank since Oct 7th, the majority of them unarmed civilians. This compared to 12 Israelis... Not to mention the thousands of Palestinians from the West Bank who were detained and held without charge or due process, and held under atrocious conditions, often enduring torture and starvation, or the thousands who are being forced from their homes. The Oxford definition of terrorism is as follows: "the unlawful use of violence and intimidation, especially against civilians, in the pursuit of political aims.", which is what Israel has been doing non-stop since it's creation in 1948, on a scale that Hamas could only dream of...
@@elishmuel1976 certainly there are! they are called Israehelli settlers stealing Pals land, are you one of them?
People are not claiming that Hamas control west bank. They are highlighting that since Oct 7th, many in west bank have turned to violence and support what Hamas did - and there is a suggestion that if they could, the people in west bank would want Hamas over the Palestinian authorities. If this is true - the people there really need to learn some harsh lessons .
Let see if their rich arabs will help with some cash money instead of criticism of bla bla & happy some wishing an end to the creasy revenge & the genocide of civilians children & eomen
Help to survive not to starve in front of the work dilence
Israel do no need Palestinians
It's punishment from God.
There is nothing allah can do to stop God.
I was many years in forced labour against my will and without payment in forced poverty in the military of the fascist state of Israel that has been torturing me my entire life.