Perpetual motion machine Idea 永久機関
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 02. 2020
- This is the new Perpetual motion machine Idea. This piece of kinetic art is first showcased by Gianni Nadalin. Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @veproject1
This overbalanced wheel has a good chance to become workable. I call it Spider wheel. 永久機関
#veproject1 - Věda a technologie
Dude I remember seeing one of these videos when I was little and being totally convinced it was real. Then I brought it up to my grandpa, who has a masters in nuclear physics. Good times.
What's his reaction???
Fabian dinatra hopefully it wasn’t nuclear
Did he fuse?
He re-fuse it
@@fabiandinatra6957 (unintentional pun)
Theoretically this would work if there wasn't something called friction
Friction, deplaced center of mass, newton laws, thermodynamic laws, god, the fate
@@eliocepe5270 hahahahahah
Unfortunately
America: _let's add more oil into it_
yes. but at least it looks cool so ill give em that
I don’t believe in perpetual motion, but I watch it because it looks beautiful.
Sorry bud but you don't really need to justify yourself you can just watch it
Ok, but could you care in explsin why?
And aerial friction makes it worse
Great
Me either
The force gained by the dropping leg is lost again when it is reset by the ramp, so there must be some kind of motor. Looks cool, tho.
I think so....
It's all fake
Where he put it(time)
These are all just concepts, made as tests for engineering students as to why they wouldn't work.
Of course it's fake. This is just a concept. With our current understanding of the universe and current level of technology, it is impossible to make a mechanical perpetual motion machine. Also, almost every concept that exists, even if it could some how move perpetually, you couldn't do anything beneficial with it. For it to move perpetually, you must not interfere with it in any way once it starts moving. If you would try to extract work from it, the machine would simply stop moving. All of the work that you extracted from it you would have to put back in for it to move perpetually again, which gives a net 0 gain of energy which doesn't help us :/.
Maybe one day... but not today.
As they all say, the hardest part of building a perpetual motion machine is figuring out where to hide the batteries
I feel like I'm perpetually losing my shit every time I see this comment
@@HD_10180 why
Before acting smart why not read this " My models of PMMs are of motorized versions that were built to illustrate how they were supposed to work in the minds of Inventors."
@@ruthsoriano6886 or... before talking about people trying to act smart, how about you understand the difference between a serious comment and a joke, you don't even understand that this is a reference.
Oh wow you can read you must be so smart, no shit sherlock everyone knew that this was just a visualization
The ability to read does not make you intelligent
I just wished it could be true 😥😔😟🙁
Veproject models are meant as a test for mechanical engineering students, they have to describe exactly why it couldn’t work, and then work out where the hidden motor and batteries are.
Yeah! These models are unique learning tool!!
Why this will not work? The theory looks okay i.e. torque on one side more than the other.
The track (the plexiglass supporting the descending weighs) will hold some of the weight and therefore this force will not be used to spin the wheel. The big wheel will end-up in equilibrium and will no longer spin.
Many of those shown about these mechanisms do not work. I tried the one with the water bottles and it doesn't work.
But this seems to me the only one that would have reason, because that plexiglass directs the weight of those wheels left to the axle and right to the outside. so on the left is easier than on the right. That plexiglass does not totally take on weight. It directs it towards the wheel axis while on the right it is further away from the axis towards the outside. what are you saying
No debe de funcionar porque cuando las pequeñas ruedas tocan la pista necesitan energia para subir por esta misma. Por lo tanto la fuerza que llevan las que van bajando son anuladas por las que se mueven por la pista. Debe haber un motor y polea oculto dentro de la estructura imitacion madera y seguramente se energizara por medio de las tuercas sobresalientes de la base. No he tenido oportunidad de estudiar ingenieria ni tampoco he hecho muchos estudios de fisica, pero tengo mucho sentido comun.
When the teacher sais to ignore friction and air resistance:
Reality : you can't design a perpetual machine
Fiction: Jaja magic crystal go brrr
If you pause the video well the wheels spinning you can see one weight is picking up three Weight which is impossible
Minecraft: Two water buckets go * splash *
Until you go to another universe when there's no law of physics or a law that allows you to make unlimited energy
@@1MadJack1 Unfortunelly, we are not in that universe
Fools, everyone know that the only infinite source of energy is Redstone
Finally
I really like kinetic sculptures like this, we know it’s impossible, but they’re cool to watch.
Well then the machine should spin faster and faster
Yeah
But it doesn't, it spins at a fixed speed, like it had a kind of electrical and spinning device or something.
Ignacio Gomez Duran , it’s a concept. There is an motor
I once shared your imagination until it was destroyed by the law of thermodynamics.
The problem is that the wheels at the right lose energy as they collide with the track at the bottom.
Make the track to a flummy with stable kickback energy and put it in superliquids.
It would seem that if the acrylic arc can tuck in the weight at the bottom that another arc could extend it at the 1:00 position. Good design.
Very cool design.
That's a nice foot pedal controlled motor you've got there
す、すげぇ！！！
Nice silent motors you have there
Wtf, this video is actually the coolest I've seen. It almost seems like it would work forever
Except for the fact that it's impossible and there is most likely a hidden motor.
This is nice to look at i know that it dosent work irl but there is always a chance that we will discover something like this kn the future
Cool, *what batteries does it use*
Could you show us the motor as well, please?
First and second law of thermodynamics be like: Ha, NO.
Nice Hazbin Hotel reference
lets inore for a moment the concept was inteded for perpetual motion becase in this case i just think it should be on loop becase of super satisfying to watch
The main problem is the loss of energy due to the rotation of the round weights. After climbing the treadmill (track construction with plexiglass support) they begin to rotate and lose energy for friction throughout the entire cycle.
現実での永久機関は｢与えられたエネルギーをできる限り持続させる｣ 物だからそこからエネルギーは取り出せないんだよね…
Good idea
His next upload was going to be a flux capacitor
Remember that weights, which lies on acrilic rail, have no affect on the wheel, until the knee is not totally closed.
永久機関はどう頑張っても作れないのだなぁ悔しい！
Doy like por el trabajo realizado y la imaginación. Nada más.
So, does it work forever ? Or HOW LONG ?
こういうものを実際に作ったということは評価できる。普通の人はこれを実際に作ろうとまでは思わない。
じゃあ俺、普通の人じゃなかったのか…
@@hina0o1 そうだよ(適当)
Well this one looks even more nonsensical than other.
Alexander Skladovski it’s purposefully fancy to make it harder to work out intuitively
Yes
Because the arms are smashing into the ground below, which OBVIOUSLY causes friction.
Where did you put the machine?
I love these videos!
Physics students: *you've just yee'd your last haw buddy*
You might gain some energy by dropping one leg, but it is the same required to lift it again. And you have friction...
Satisfying
Need something like this that works in a vacuum and is frictionless.
maybe there is more weight on left but in this model diffrence of masses are so low that they are negate by main bearing and weels so it will spin for moment and start to slow down if pushed
Beautiful ferrytale
I find it funny when people try to "debunk" videos like this.
It's obviously not trying to fool anybody, but a fool will still fall for it and try to call it out, not realizing that they've just made themselves look stupid by believing it enough to try and disprove it in the first place.
Funny thing is while watching this video the first recommendation I have below it is a Ted ED video about HOW PERPETUAL MOTION DOESN'T WORK 🤣
I need to look at any perspective of that kinetic machine, just in case there is no rotors connect to any electric source with hidden wires or something like that.
Oh nice
Great ❤️💖💗🌹💋💕♥️
O melhor!
Can you please explain the exact method, sizes
Nice machine! Now lets wait until it stops
It is motorized cause if you look closely you can see it "hitch" as the motor struggles when the wheels hit the ramp
*EDIT*
Perpetual motion doesn't exist, it has been disproven multiple times
veproject1: shows perpetual motion machine
the laws of physiks: coughs
Ideas!
Além disto temos um eixo fixo e seis eixos móveis. O torque terá que dar conta da rotação em torno do eixo do braço móvel. Ao lado esquerdo, na subida, não há rotação nos eixos do braço (eixos móveis), porém no lado direito, descida, há rotação em torno do eixo do braço, o que necessita de torque. O torque da direita é maior, mas ele é usado para rotação no eixo do braço.
Eu quero ver depois de inspecionar esse mecanismo ai se ele vai funcionar.
こういうの信じたくなっちゃうよなぁ
いづれ止まりますもんね
そうなんですよねーこういうの99.9999%嘘なんですよねー何回騙されたことか。こいうのは後ろとか台の下に仕掛けがあるのがほとんどなんですよね。台も変に分厚いし台の下に仕掛けを隠してそうですね。
これって裏にモーターかなんかあんの？
それとも永久機関ではないけどずっと動くやつ？
神はねこ好き 一応永久機関は実在しませんからね〜(確か)
cyan tara 別に騙してるわけではありませんよ
量子力学上永久機関ではないが永久機関と呼ばれている装置の紹介です。
この装置はモータがなくてもしばらくは運動を続けますが次第に遅くなり止まります。
動画の尺の関係で止まるところまで無いだけのことです。
永久機関と呼ばれてしまっている装置の共通点は、エネルギーが消費(変換)される時に発生する必要消費エネルギー量を極限まで減らして少しづつエネルギーを消費していくということです。
この必要消費エネルギー量が小さくなるよう工夫された運動装置を一般的に永久機関と呼んでいます(永久ではないけど)
If anybody thinking that those weights hanging far out on the right will cause the wheel to rotate, no, those weights are being balanced by the weights that are forced to climb up the ramp. So basically this is just like a simple wheel mounted on a shaft, but with more friction!
Yo how did you hide the batteries and the strings
In 1:03 we see, 3 legs pushing clockwise via long arms and 5 legs pushing counterclockwise via short arms. So it will balance and not move at all
Ahahahah I fuсking died when I saw the car at the start of the video
I would like to see the same test done from all angles by rotating the device and its base and keep the hand away from it to see if it is real or fake, otherwise it looks good!
"The most neat part of making perpetual motion machines is to where to hide the batteries".
GOOD
Can we generate electricity from it...?
Muy lindo el juguete , .¿cuanto le dura la batería?.
Незнаю
1:31 did the wheel slow down before being touch?
use 0.25speed
Looks good... But the weight in the lower left and weight in upper right would cancel each other leading to rest position... So practically it won't rotate by itself
Нас не обманешь. Где-то спрятан моторчик.
И в мыслях не было)))
@@veproject1 Значит, моторчик где-то спрятан без мыслей. Но спрятан. Но моторчик.
@@veproject1 тогда где миллионы от продаж вечного двигателя?)
If this is possible then what we got?
Good idea fo Free energy
Interesting. 👌🏼
Thank you
@@veproject1 You're welcome. 😊
Smart and may be is true can moving forever
The fact that it is producing sound just disproves that it is perpetual
How does PMM sound?
It broke the second law of thermodynamics
Dimana ada yg jual?
I wonder how long the battery will last?
Excuse me, does this work 100%?
More of a ‘conservation of energy machine’!
Drakilicious well it conserves the original energy in the way a flywheel does, but however low the friction flywheels eventually ‘run down’!
por que nao mostram a parte de tras???
The support/stand looks thick enough to contain a motor.
All of these have suspicously large bottems is there a battery or motor under them?
These models are also used in various exhibitions, so large bases make them more stable
I like to see perpetual machines in youtube
Почему Вы не сообщаете в конце видео, что это розыгрыш?
Increíble 🤤
Exacto, no lo creas es imposible
Motor nerede !!!
wow, very inteligent!! 👍👏
That's not his idea, and it doesn't work in reality
@@TheMessi324 ok, thanks!!
Effective
Wow
How th dose that first one even work
This is so cool. Interesting I find most comments negative while I find it imaginative and innovating. I mean we've been moving around the sun for million years of course it's possible
From where this sound energy is getting transferred. Because energy can neither be created nor be destroyed. Friction is also a part here. It can never be perpetual.🙂😏
It comes from Earth's gravity.
gravity is a force not energy. And if it would have been due to earth's gravity as per formula e=mgh and -mgh during upward movement on oneside and downward movement on other side. This could only be perpetual only if there is no loss. Here a lot of loss of energy by sound and friction. So it can never be perpetual. I hope you are getting me.
Conservação de energia kkkkk, achei um tanto grossa a madeira :p
Strange thought but couldn’t you use a perpetual motion machine to make it easier to make hand cranked energy or something?
Why is the axis rotating?
good eye.
You cannot break the laws of thermodynamics
Esto es realmente impresionante
Gracias
When we can see the person plugging the machine in, it sorts of blows the illusion. Never lifted it up because there's a plug in the table. And it's obvious when the device is lined up and the plug goes in.
Can we build a bigger model to get enough energy to power the light in our house?
Since perpetual motion machines don't work I would say no.
Улыбнул
Due to distribution of mass it rocks back and forth and stops after some time
Just by looking at it we can tell so much of energy is lost in form of friction and sound so it will lose energy and comes to rest
Power companies: Wait. This is illegal.