But is the Roscoe 8 Worth $500 More?
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 06. 2024
- If you are thinking about the New Trek Roscoe, chances are you are debating between the Roscoe 7 and Roscoe 8 as they are the clear value winners in Trek's Roscoe lineup... But is the Roscoe 8 Worth $500 More?
Link to Trek Roscoe: bit.ly/3SFTU7C
Let me know what you think in the comments below & Don't forget to subscribe!!!
- Visit my Website: www.jamesthebikeguy.com
---
- Check it out at my favorite shop: bit.ly/3pVF6lS
---
- JBG Merch and Support the Channel: teespring.com/stores/jamesthe...
The Gear I use:
-----
Accurate Escali Scale: amzn.to/2qhO6Fm
-----
Sony ZV-1 Camera: amzn.to/38QHfK3
-----
Rode Wireless Go Microphone: amzn.to/35NyazG
-----
Camera Tripod: amzn.to/2qfKdk4
-----
GoPro Hero 9 Black: amzn.to/3nUGkwm
-----
Google Pixel 4: amzn.to/2UM9kf6
-----
Lav Mic for Gopro/Phone: amzn.to/3bwiF0d
-----
Cell Phone Gimbal (Bikes Shots): amzn.to/37gU10h
00:00 Trek Roscoe 7 vs 8 Comparison
00:43 New Hardtails From Trek
01:43 New Frame & Geometry
03:09 Suspension Fork Comparison
04:28 Drivetrain Comparison
06:41 Weight Comparison
08:00 Wheelset Comparison
10:18 Actual Weights
10:42 Shootout Winner
Is the EXTRA $500 Worth It? | Roscoe 7 vs Roscoe 8 Comparison Showdown
DISCLAIMER: This video description contains affiliate links, which means that if you click on one of the product links, I’ll receive a small commission. I work within the cycling industry, and the views are not representative of the views of my employer. Jamesthebikeguy videos are produced outside of employment obligations and are made of my own volition unless otherwise stated. - Sport
If you bought the ROSCOE 7 don't feel bad, on paper of course all those specs are worth it, but in real life you won't feel the difference unless you are paying attention to all those details. Enjoy the ride!
I recently bought the 7 after trying both back to back. Personally I couldn’t tell a great difference in the drivetrain and suspension. The biggest difference was the hub engagement. After spending a day with both though the 8 wasn’t true instant engagement and truly not worth the price increase to me. I can gladly ride the 7 and upgrade as needed.
I notice a lot of comments from people who don't understand the word "budget" Of course the more expensive bike is bound to have better parts and potentially more value, but some people don't have $3000 to spend on a 9, They can however afford the 7 and maybe in another year can afford a better fork, or afford better brakes and still get a year of riding in while earning their way to a better bike. For a lot of people, they may not even know what to look for in the differences between parts. Some people are just buying bikes so they can ride. We have gotten to a point where their is so much snobbery when it comes to what you ride... Anyone who bought a 7 and is loving it should ignore anyone who said "You should have bought this or that" or "You're gonna have to pay so much more in the end and should have just bought this instead" ... Ignore them. They only focus on spec and forget about budget and the fact that you are still riding regardless of what you bought. I was just getting into mountain biking back in 2019 and bought a budget Kona XC bike.. QR wheels, cheap hubs, cheap bb and cranks.. cheap everything really... hell, it has a rockshox 30 silver fork... I still ride it today and I still have so much fun on it.. I've upgraded parts as I went and don't feel bad about not buying a more expensive bike at the time because of the fun I have had with it and the experience of making it my own... The grips, brakes, drivetrain, rear hub, and seat post have all been upgraded and I still love riding it today. Just enjoy what you can afford and get your bike to where you want it to be when you can.. :)
Thank you! I bought the 7 and a lot of comments about better parts and put more money in but I’m just happy with this one, no need to upgrade
What a great review, thorough, quick and easy to understand for new mountain bikers. Thanks ! Just picked up a 8
I am keeping and still riding my 2005 Fuel 90 at just 27.6 lbs. The light weight makes it feel like a rocket on any trails!
I had a 7 on order but someone at the LBS bought an 8 and then returned it after one ride. Got it for 2k out the door. I feel good about it! I do really like that hub.
Just picked up an R8. The rear hub with 108 engagement was my selling point.
Great video by the way!!
Yeah 108t is so so nice
Tried the 8 yesterday…it’s definitely nice, but I think prices are out of hand. Manufacturers have to realize that lockdown is over and people aren’t scrambling to buy bikes anymore. Trek and Specialized are pricing out seasoned riders, (read: repeat customers), and losing them to smaller brands like Ragley and Canyon, who make similar specced bikes at a better price point.
The problem is us consumers with our or what we think is our need to have everything in the best of everything if we stop buying all this high-end stuff, maybe the prices will go down if we stop going on vacations and driving around all the time and keep the car is parked maybe gas prices were down OK shut the whole country down . $6000 for a frame and fork I mean really.
This comment actually did age well!
I have the 22 R8, I wanted the 7 but I would have had to wait till November to get it. The main reason I wanted the 7 was because I love the paint scheme but so far after 5 weeks of riding and nearly 150 miles on my days off I am loving my R8. After watching your video I am glad I have the R8 and I would have upgraded to the R9 if my local shop had that one on order but they didn't.
I had put a deposit down on a Roscoe 7, but my dealer had a Roscoe 8 in Mulsanne Blue become available a couple weeks before the 7 was supposed to show up. I couldn't be happier with it; I love the upgraded components, and it's in my favorite color. Swapped out the pedals and grips and it's good to go!
What pedals and grips did you go for?
@@kihealthandwellness Race Face Gripplers and Bontrager Line Elite pedals.
This vid is great! I have the 7 and love it! I think the official tire max size is 2.6? Do you know if it will take a 3.0 or 2.8?
I own a 2018 Stache, and LOVE it....but I would absolutely have bought one of these if they had been available then. The new Rosco is a legit HT now!
I just got the Roscoe 8 home this week and I can tell you there is nothing better under it.
I love the new roscoe, I have the 2020 Roscoe seven at this point I have completely rebuilt the whole thing. Just got done doing a full service on the fork. Last thing I need to do now is get some new tires they’re currently Maxis 27.5‘s (semi fat) 2.80mm could you recommend a set of rubbers?
Great video. I'm getting ready to buy a Roscoe not sure which yet. Would love to see a Roscoe 9 vs 8
It’s the color of the 9 holding me back. 🤮
About to get the Roscoe 8. Hell of a bike imo
Great video!
And great bikes!
As for the tyres, are they tubeless or tubeless ready, so with inner tubes?
Thanks!
I'll take the 8 with the 7s paint and drivetrain!
I went R9. Love the color way and the Fox Rhythm 36 up front. If o had to choose between the 7 or 8 though, I’d go 8, though I love the color way of the 7. I wish Trek would let people choose the frame color and components package like other direct to consumer brands. I feel like that would be the true value. Every person has their own personal preferences.
R9 spec with the R7 Blue and Orange frame please.
Same, been waiting nearly a year now haha
The 9 is obviously the best bike but I just can't with that colour, either the snot green or the metallic red. The lower models have way better colours imo.
You're the man, debating these same two options now.
I got the 7 and love it but I feel like the 8 would have been best
@@pebbleinyoshoe532 I just ordered the 7. It hasn't arrived yet but we'll see. Did you notice anything in particular on the 7 you didn't like?
I would definitely go Roscoe 8 and I've been looking at the 8 for awhile now.
I hope they’ll do a new 2023 8 bc the new 7 race face drivetrain is really nice tbh
I'd buy the 8 if i could get the 7 colourway. Often higher end bikes seem to get pants colour schemes.... Let us choose if the frames are the same
!
Bro. Go check out the Roscoe 9 and see if you still believe that.
Roscoe 8 vs 9 comparison would be cool
I have an 8 after 10+ years with no Mtn bike. Wow what a difference. Would have gotten a 9 but none available in several states that I checked??
The Roscoe 8 is on sale for $1700 now, they have too many after the manufacturing caught up. I'm sure the 7 is cheaper too, but to get the 8 for the $500 off, is a great buy. I'm going to pick mine up Friday. Thanks for the great video.
It's$2300 at the Trek store by me?
Where did you find them for $1700?
@@jimmyvien3094 he's lying
Local shop has the 7 on sale for $1649 through the end of March '23. Think the 8 is $1999
He’s not lying they are down to 1700 I’m from canada and they are $2500 CAD rn no tax
I recently bought a 7. Ended up coming up with a new takeoff fox performance 34 locally for $400 which I think is a better fork than the Rockshox 35 anyway. Replaced the front rotor with a 203 mill. Put Renthal fat bars on but that was mostly to get more rise. So I’m in it for roughly $500 extra at this point but I got a better fork and spent some money to tailor it to me. Now I don’t have the four piston brakes or quick engagement hub but those items aren’t important to me or at least not yet. Maybe in time. Still happy I chose the 7 overall.
If you are going to spend all that extra $ and still thinking of spending more you should’ve gone for the 8 at least and probs the 9. It’s a false economy to do it the way you have done. Yours is a classic case of buying the lower spec, but not being happy and really wanting the higher spec all along and then trying to play catch up with what you’ve bought and trying to make amends. Far better to bite the bullet and buy the higher spec from the get go.
@@paddyotoole2058 I don’t really see it that way because I wouldn’t have been happy with many of the components on the 8. I really think I would’ve changed the same items. Now potentially the 9 but that’s a lot more money than I paid to make my 7 what I wanted. Depends on whether you want to brag about your kit or make the choices you personally want
I think Trek missed the mark on the R8 with the drive train, fork and brakes. The Deore (6100) brakes are a better brake. A lower level Pike or Revelation would have been a better way to go. Both are upgradable, unlike the 35. On the drive train they should have stayed with the Deore.
if the Drivetrain on the 8 was the Deore it would be my pic. the effort to upgrade to a 10-51 or 10 - 50 (new freehub body need) is too much cost and effort. Trek messed the spec up imho. Shame really.
Trek Fest has discounted both bikes to $1659 for the Roscoe 7 and $1999 for the Roscoe 8.
With the $400 savings on the Roscoe 8, it is easy to do some up upgrades to the shifters and eventually the fork.
I took advantage of the sale, which they have since extended, and picked up the Roscoe 8. Fabulous bike.
Mine was 1875 minus 250 sell price. That was 2 weeks ago. I love it.
Is this the best bike for the budget? I can afford the roscoe 7 and was planning on getting it but I’m wondering if there are any other good options for that price point.
So if I got the Roscoe 8, and upgraded SRAM XG-1275 GX EAGLE 12-SPEED CASSETTE 10-50T would I still be able to use hub and would it be worth it ?
I have a Roscoe 7 pre-ordered since the end of last year. First, I absolutely love the color scheme but I also simply don't have the budget for the Roscoe 8 atm. Since I'm also a beginner I don't think the 32mm stanchions will be a problem to start with. Brakes would probably have to be swapped on both bikes which I'll probably do rather sooner than later so the only thing I really miss is the high engagement hub. However, the Shimano FH-MT510 freehub at least comes with Shimano Quick Engagement, so 32 or 38 points of engagement so at least it's not completely terrible.
Brake rotors on both these bikes are the new Chinese discs. They're stamped instead of lasercut. Complete garbage, some are tacos out of the box. All of the cross drilled holes are bent. You can see it in this video, 1 side is concave and the other convex
i upgraded from a 21 to a 22 and the 7's hub while not quick engaging, is way better than last year model way more clicks
@@joshfullbright7678 I just got mine the day before yesterday and it's definitely the fastest engaging hub of all the wheelsets I own which are one normal Shimano Hub, one DT Swiss 3 Prawl and one mystery trek hub.
@@janeblogs324 Not sure how it is on mine but at least they came 100% straight out of the box and braking is quite good. However, I didn't get the Bontrager Wheels but the ethirteen substitutes instead.
@@CaptainShiny5000 I also got the e13’s on my R7. Hopefully they are decently comparable to the Bontragers.
We're getting a few for our NICA team, the 8 seems a better choice; better wheels, weight, and forks.
November 23 the 7 is currently discounted to 1629 while the 8 has a 400 discount and is priced 1999$ which makes the gap 370$. The 9 is 2499$. I wish all the models were available in the black like the 7. No word on when prices may rise back to whatever normal will be.
Good video, trek 7 or 8 are both great bikes? I think the 8 is worth the difference and now in 2024 you can get the 8 for 1600 great bike fir thst for sure
This was very interesting. Not sure but I think you verbally got the price wrong on the 8. You said 29 and the writing on the video said 99. I would be incredibly happy to have either of these lovely bikes. Thanks for sharing this with us.
Thanks for the catch. Sleep deprived and not proof reading my work.
No worries. Thanks for the video
Only took 5+ years for this bike not to suck, its actually a nice bike now. Drivetrain as people have pointed out is an absolute joke on the Roscoe 8. I'd rather have SLX over GX with a NX Cassette.
Thanks for the review. I’m about to buy the 2023 R8 for $1999 tomorrow
How you like so far ? I’m on the fence of getting one this month
@@caaande I ended up not making the purchase yet. I am stuck between the commencal meta ht , the San Quentin 3 and the Roscoe 8. Can’t make up my mind
Right on. Now I’m looking at the roscoe 9
@@caaande The R9 is badass!
Hi
In Europe is 700 € different so I take the R7 with gx axs and four piston break. I hope the wheels wiil good for me
How much is the Roscoe 7 selling for in Europe? I saw that prices for those Roscoe bikes are much cheaper than here
Bought the roscoe 7 in xl. Immediately upgraded the fork to a marzocchi bomber and replaced with some new pedals and have since turned it into a heavy trail/Enduro hardball. It costed me just a little north of what the 8 would cost with better suspension. I would go this route instead of spending the money on the 9 or 8. The only difference you might really notice is the brakes....they're fine but they are not as reactive and stiff.
Would agree, except for the difference in the hub that the 8-9 come with.
@@AnAbortiveRomance totally.
I was thinking of buying the roscoe 7 as well as upgrading the fork witch one did you go with the z1or z2?
@@JooKushin Z2 with 150 mm of travel. I use it as an aggressive trail bike. It handles big hits very well. If you want to send it off bigger drops or features go with the Z1.
Trek increased the prices last week of the Roscoes appx. $70.00 per bike. I looked at the 7, 8, and 9. For me the 32 mm stanchions on the 7 fork are too thin and the Shimano 200 brakes are marginal at best. The 8 is better with the 108 POE on the rear hub and has a beefier 35 mm front shock but IMHO still lacks on braking with the Shimano 4000 series brakes. The 9 has way better 6000 series 4 piston brakes and a Fox Rhythm 36 shock. Thats more like it. The people that buy a 7 with intentions of upgrading will have to spend almost 1100 just to get a fox 36mm shock, plus another 3 ro 4 hundred to get shimano 6000 series brakes and 203 front and 180 rear rotors. For me it was a no brainer. I bought the 9. Nothing needs upgraded on that bike. Buy once, cry once , and you are done.
I agree with that, and if it makes you feel any better I was about to buy a fuse a few weeks back and specialized increased the price by $700 (2300 to 3000) because they know what the customers want. So with that in mind a $70 hike is marginal at best.
Vitus just upped the sentier VR from 1400 to 1700 but that's still a way better deal than any trek.
I bought the 9 as well, but some people don't want to or can't spend that much so buying a 7 is a good move, you still get the thru axles, 1x gears and a same frame.
@@MM-qv5lf I'm gonna get a 7, and upgrade as the parts simply wear out. Only thing I'm going to immediately upgrade are the brakes....
@@worgle123 Roscoe 8 looks like a nice option too. 4 piston brakes, nicer fork, maybe you wouldn't have to upgrade much in that case.
It look like little handheld bikes when he pointed down at the camera for a moment
Just get on, ride,, and have fun. A brake upgrade is going to be at least $500 as well for the 7. Obviously the 8 is a better bike but it could use some upgrades too. Either way your going to put money into both bikes to make them truly capable.
super curious what your decision would be with the current Trek sale going and $350 between them. The R7 is $1649 and the R8 is $1999 right now. Seems like an even stronger endorsement for the Roscoe 8 at this point.
The Roscoe 8 would be my take at $2,000
@@JamesthebikeguyThe Roscoe 8 is now selling for 1.6k. The 7 is selling for 1.4k. I wanted to go for the Roscoe 6 since I'm not sure how much riding I'll do. But all the sizes sold out at regular price. It never went on sale. So which one should I get now?
Did you end up buying any of the Roscoe bikes?
@@Jose-sy1je I DID! I bought a Roscoe 8. LOVE it
@@TheQuikMix I was between the Roscoe 8 and 7. Ended up going for the 8 as well 😐 Soon it'll be ready at store for pickup lol. Let's see how that works out
Just bought a Roscoe 8 for $2000 on sale
The Recon forks have steel stantions - so even though they are only 32mm and not 35mm they still have plenty of strength (in the same way steel frames can be thinner than aluminium frames) and I have not noticed much difference to the Yari fork I had on my previous bike which had 35mm stantions. There may be a very small amount of extra flex but it is very hard to tell - so not a major difference. The main benefit of upgrading a fork which I hope to do in the future is to save weight and have a better air spring and damper. I will be looking at a basic Pike which will save nearly 400g in weight and should have a plusher suspension action. The 35 is still a basic fork and is a similar weight to the Recon so has a very marginal advantage. Not worth upgrading to in my opinion.
Another area of concern with the 8 and something I have experienced with a previous bike is the NX cassette. It is very expensive to replace and this is a part that will need replacing. The deorre cassette gives better shifting, is slightly lighter and cheaper. I am glad my 7 has deorre and I have simply added an XT shifter to have a fantastic drivetrain. This gives much better shifting than the NX shifter with multi shifts possible both up and down.
Otherwise a good review but as others have said if you can only afford the cheaper bike the real world differences are small and you can pick the upgrades you want when you can afford them.
Both bikes are nice but unfortunately with the economy I’d go 7 - I have noticed a few other reviews where the cranks have varied so I’m guessing Trek is having problems sourcing Deore cranks which are the spec’s on the websites. I think to me crossing over the 2000.00 price point I’d just try to go to a full suspension MTB.
The trouble with that is, you end up with a poor spec full sus. You'd need to go beyond 3000 to match specs.
@@Mapantz1 yes I agree on the specs but to me and I’m not a diehard MTB rider I’d get a cushy ride for the few hundred dollars more. I’m old lol 😂. Actually the Roscoe 7 is the bike I have been thinking about getting, fits the budget and I dig hard tails for bike camping and some fire road rides with friends.
@@jmounce50 I like the paint job on the 8, but I'm not willing to go up to that price. lol
i got a praxis crank, wich i believe is a minor upgrade, its lighter and still forged aluminum, with center lock sproket.
The 8 is worth the extra money. I tried both and the 8 won me over. I bought the 8 and it's awesome.
IMO Roscoe 8 wins all categories and is well worth the price difference. I’m getting a 23’ Roscoe 8 for 2k.
Great price on Rocoe 8 right now
Except for the Roscoe 6 they all went on sale. The 7 on sale is a lot better than the 6 at regular price though. What I don't understand is why certain colors of the 7 say they are 1,650 regular price and others say 1,900 regular price. Do to know why that is?
I have been looking at the r7 vs r9 and lets be honest, the best thing about r7 is the colour, and this is why I am looking at it, however it is no brainer that the r9
Is the best.
Where can I buy the frame only of Roscoe 8?
Your Trek dealer
OK, I’ve never heard of this before so help me out. To change from one cassette to another, both the same number of cogs, I need to change the freehub body? Is that true or an error. I’ve been swapping cassettes for decades and never heard of this. If I switch to a better level cassette that has a larger big ring will it still work with the freehub body that fits the 10? All that said, I’m not sure there would be a ton of times I would need a 10 over an 11.
The New 12 speed cassette use (1) of three different freehub.
The 12speed drivetrains that have the smallest tooth of 11 will use a standard "Shimano HG" freehub.
12speed Shimano Deore and up with a 10tooth cog use something called "Shimano Microspline"
12speed SRAM cassette that have a 10tooth cog use the "SRAM XD Driver"
So you can swap cassette just like the old days if they use the same type of freehub. In this case the limiting factor is Trek used a NX cassette that mounts on a HG freehub and not compatible with better quality higher range cassettes.
@@Jamesthebikeguy Thanks very much,, reminds of that ill fated Shimano 10 speed freehub body back in the day.
Ill take shimano 1x12 over pg1210 any day. As ive heard 12010 its cheapest 12x you can get. Tbh i prefer 1x10 anyway :D
I genuinely think the 8 is bad value. I'd have to go for either the 7 or the 9.
I just ordered a rosco 8
I got the Roscoe 8
Is 73 degree really considered steep for a seat tube angle?
My Kona lava dome has steeper, and it is half the price of this TREK...
How about the 8 vs 9?
If you're already spending that kind of money just get the 9. It's much better.
Roscoe 7 for me
Is it just me but I would pay 500 extra for the better paint job 😂 your already spending a lot so might as well get what you want.
Also my specialized Fuse is better then both 😏
Give me Deore over NX every day of the week.
roscoe 7
Trek Roscoe or Nukeproof Scout?
Surprised you called it a draw on the brakes. I have a Dual Sport 3 with the same brakes as the R7. I’d never buy a MTB with those brakes. I think they are terrible.
While I agree they are not the best, the Roscoe 8's brakes are hardly any better. Either bike is due for a brake upgrade down the line
@@Jamesthebikeguy that's disappointing to hear as I am searching for my first MTB in this price range. I figured a four piston caliper and much larger rotors would be a huge step up in stopping power. Thanks for your reply, I guess I'll skip on the Roscoe.
I got the roscoe 7 but it didn’t feel as good as the 9 so I got the 9
That is kinda how it works 😂
It is not brand new for 2023. You keep quoting 2023
It’s new for 2022
I think if you have enough money get the 8 ...i would if i had the money
Before this video I would’ve gone R8 but disappointing to hear the hub doesn’t allow a 10t cassette.
but you can swap the freehub, which Bontrager offers on their site.
@@mellissanash7517 Where abouts on the site?
NICE...........
sold my 7's recon for 200$
roscoe 8
My choice is none of them. Thanks for review.
8
Your wife chooses the freaking bike, i am just on for the ride
I Personally dont like Trek
their bikes are Overrated.
but in this review.
interms of frame color, ill pick the 8. but interms of spec?
ill Choose 7.
why? if had this bike.
either ill replace its fork to a Higher-end Rockshox/Fox
then Drivetrain and brakes ill go for Shimano XT.
and Hub DT-Swiss or Hope
Sounds like the Roscoe 9 has the upgrades out of the box.
Exactly $500? I make that $570
Roscoe 7 is now $1899 lol
Yep, shoot. I messed that up. Started the video prior to price changes and didn't get everything correct. Whoops
@@Chris-de2qc 2200
If you read the specs on the Shimano 200 brakes they are in paper much less powerful
Yet in practice both are not especially great and worth upgrading in the future
You must be the last one living in a pandemic!
Lol, not sure what that means
@@Jamesthebikeguy probably meaning no one can get any bikes still but you somehow have one.
These were new for 22 not 23. The model to get is the 9. Both the 7 and 8 have the junk Motion Control damper. And both dampers CANNOT be upgraded. Total waste, ime. The 9 has a very good Fox 36 with a Grip damper.
Watch the review of the 9 on Hardtail Party.
$2000 for cup n cone hubs and no dropper? Is there even a frame hole for a dropper cable?
Both bikes have droppers, and are internally routed
❤️❤️❤️❤️🔥🔥🔥🔥
My 2007 cannondale f7 weighs less 😂
Cool story.
Well it's outdated.
My 1975 vintage road bike is also much lighter. And that means....?
that means the Roscoe will shred your bike into pieces anyway hahaha