Mavic 3 Active Track vs Skydio 2 Torture Test

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 9. 03. 2022
  • The Mavic 3 has the best active track and obstacle avoidance on a DJI drone so far but how does it compare to the tracking and obstacle avoidance on the Skydio 2? This video compares the Active track on the Mavic 3 and the Tracking of the Skydio 2 and I also compare the mavic 3 obstacle avoidance to the Skydio 2 obstacle avoidance. The results might surprise you.
    Mavic 3 geni.us/BRxL (affiliate link)
    Skydio 2+ geni.us/sY9kk (not affiliate link)
    Learn how to use and fly your drone to create professional results by taking my course here: www.solocreatoracademy.com/store
    Find my favorite camera and drone tech here:
    www.amazon.com/shop/jakesloan (affiliate link)
    I use Artlist for all my music: geni.us/kqV9l (affiliate link)
    Join my patreon to see behind the scenes content and more!
    www.patreon.com/jakesloan
    Connect on:
    Facebook: / jakesloanpage
    Instagram: / jakesloan
    Twitter: / jakesloaninak
    Jake Sloan
    PO BOX 212445
    Anchorage, AK 99521
    DISCLAIMER:
    Jake Sloan is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.
    This video and description contains affiliate links, which means that if you click on one of the product links, I’ll receive a small commission.
  • Věda a technologie

Komentáře • 296

  • @NICKs_HIGHTECH
    @NICKs_HIGHTECH Před 2 lety +23

    Very nice comparison Jake. I think obstacle avoidance during active track algorithm has bugs in Mavic 3. It has the hardware to be equal to skydio. Maybe in future firmware updates will be fixed.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety +7

      I agree! I think one or two firmware updates will take care of many of these issues. I also think trying to active track while filming in dlog might tax the drone a bit. It’s handling a LOT more data while also trying to active track.

    • @izoyt
      @izoyt Před 2 lety

      nope, just try to obtain 1,5 or 2 meters from objects, which doesn't help in congested forest like this.

    • @Anticheat2011
      @Anticheat2011 Před 2 lety +2

      i just bought mavic 3 and tested it in heavy trees ... no issues

    • @NICKs_HIGHTECH
      @NICKs_HIGHTECH Před 2 lety +1

      @@Anticheat2011 the problem is in higher speeds. In walking or jogging there is no problem at all

    • @Anticheat2011
      @Anticheat2011 Před 2 lety

      @@NICKs_HIGHTECH with active track on yes . but in manual flying obstacle avoidance is prefect . pretty sure it is fixable with firmware update

  • @AnthonyAntTony
    @AnthonyAntTony Před 2 lety +2

    Appreciate your get to the point, speak quickly delivery and videos. Thanks Jake.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      Thank you and you’re welcome

  • @TruckHouseLife
    @TruckHouseLife Před rokem

    Well done man, thanks for the input. Been flying Mavic Minis on my channel for years, just picked up a Skydio 2+ for the channel, maybe cya up here in AK sometime!

  • @JimOutLoud
    @JimOutLoud Před 2 lety +1

    Boom.... another great video Jake. Been anxious to see this one since you teased it Wednesday night! For me, I've still got training wheels on (aka I fly the Mini 2) but loving the journey.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety +1

      Enjoy the journey. It’s a huge part of the fun lol. Thanks a lot it was a fun and slightly stressful video to make lol

  • @brucegruenbaum
    @brucegruenbaum Před 2 lety +6

    Really useful video, Jake. I’ve been trying to figure out where I go next with drone purchases and how a drone tracks a solo creator is absolutely critical to my purchase. I was on the fence between Mavic 3 and Air 2S, but I think this video makes it clear that a combination of Air 2S and Skydio 2 is what I need, especially as most of my video is on CZcams

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      Nice! I’m glad to hear this helped!

    • @brucegruenbaum
      @brucegruenbaum Před 2 lety

      @@JakeSloan Which Skydio kit do you have? I’m leaning towards the Sports kit because most of what I’ll be doing with it is autonomous flight with it tracking. But I just discovered it can fly keyframed paths and I’m guessing the key frames are easier to set with the controller. Thoughts?

  • @dougcooper4917
    @dougcooper4917 Před 2 lety +1

    Excellent Test Video Jake. Very Interesting. Thank You.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      Thanks Doug, glad you like it

  • @-paulmp
    @-paulmp Před 2 lety +2

    Great comparison Jake... I'm so jealous at the scenery though, it looks so beautiful there!

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety +1

      It definitely is an awesome place to be able to go and film! I think I’m as jealous of you as you are of me…

  • @4WheelingSA
    @4WheelingSA Před 2 lety +1

    Very interesting video Jake! Thanks for this!

  • @romi4386
    @romi4386 Před rokem

    amé tu video! Muy buen material. I loved your video. It ´s so good !

  • @robcameron7632
    @robcameron7632 Před 2 lety +1

    Great clip as always, thanks again champ.

  • @RangerRickTV
    @RangerRickTV Před 2 lety +1

    You have the best reviewer channel on CZcams !

  • @SloMo2723
    @SloMo2723 Před rokem

    Hey Jake, Thanks for your review. I'm taking a biking and hiking trip to Germany,Austria and Switzerland next year. This was most helpful. I'll be going with the Skidio!

  • @stevencasteelassistantgene5263

    Nice video quality of your talking to camera shots. I liked your music choices too.

  • @Joe_Fotoleo
    @Joe_Fotoleo Před 2 lety +8

    Great comparison...that skydio is really amazing. I just prefer to be in control, but its great for the right user.

  • @BuddBieber
    @BuddBieber Před 2 lety +1

    As always, great review!!! Thanks!!!

  • @glennalan
    @glennalan Před 2 lety +1

    Great video! Just subscribed. Thank you

  • @Haniflylivewithme
    @Haniflylivewithme Před 2 lety +1

    Thanks Jake for the INFO!

  • @brianharrisonlightscape360

    Great video Jake, Still can't wait to wait to get my M3

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      I hope you get it soon! Great drone with a few small issues that I think will be worked out in future firmware

  • @jonathanwhalen1041
    @jonathanwhalen1041 Před 10 měsíci

    Thank you for creating this video.

  • @kiwiadventurer
    @kiwiadventurer Před rokem

    Got my eye on the Skydio 2+ for my motorcycle adventure channel and you reinforce my choice. Thanks for a great comparison

  • @PaulRanky
    @PaulRanky Před 2 lety +1

    Very useful video; Thanks!

  • @michaelpoczynek
    @michaelpoczynek Před 2 lety +4

    My drones go up 100' and stay there and above. Hard lesson learned after a stack of dead drones. Great video Jake. Well done as always. Summer is around the corner. 😀

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety +1

      LOL yep!! thank you very much and yes I cannot wait for summer

    • @LVirus702
      @LVirus702 Před rokem +1

      Pardon my ignorance, just curious as to what the altitude has to do with killing the drones?

    • @michaelpoczynek
      @michaelpoczynek Před rokem +1

      @@LVirus702 Good question. I may not have been clear. I launch, get to 100'+ and never go below that until I land. That way I never crash into buildings, trees, etc. Have a great day!

  • @hhyperdd
    @hhyperdd Před 2 lety

    Thank you for such informative video.

  • @Lordvader330
    @Lordvader330 Před 2 lety +1

    Now that’s a great use of the DJI refresh program!

  • @bretth3718
    @bretth3718 Před 2 lety +1

    Great review, thanks from Hawaii!

  • @Ecoroof1986
    @Ecoroof1986 Před 2 lety +2

    Great video Jake. The Skydio would be amazing for the trail running that we do. I wonder if it will come to the UK?

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      I don't know but I do know that people from the UK have managed to figure out a way to get one there lol

  • @robertbondar6640
    @robertbondar6640 Před 2 lety +9

    Awesome video Jake, I’m tempted to buy both because they are used for such different reasons.
    Drones at the end of the day are tools for the creator and not every tool is set for every job. Sucks to see such an expensive drone not compete with a drone that’s half the cost, I’m surprised DJI hasn’t tried to buy Skydio or their technology. (At least that we are aware of.)

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      Agreed. Different drones for different uses.

  • @ArminHirmer
    @ArminHirmer Před 2 lety

    very interesting and expected. I guess I need both :D

  • @YFZriderdude15
    @YFZriderdude15 Před rokem

    I watched your entire video, and right as I was switching tabs, I heard you mention "Alaska time" at the end of the video. That immediately caught my attention! I live in Anchorage and want to use a drone to capture downhill mountain biking footage in tight singletrack. Now, I've been watching videos on CZcams of people using the DJI Air 2S for "mountain biking" but all the videos seem to be of big open plains with few trees. I haven't see even one video of a rider going fast through trees, like I'll be doing. I have to wonder if even the Skydio 2+ will keep up, or if that investment would be a waste of money. Jumps, fast corners, 40+ mph downhill riding in the forest. There isn't one video about it on here.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před rokem

      The Skydio 2+ would definitely be the better drone for that, not without its flaws but definitely the best on the market for that kind of stuff currently

  • @DangerousDaveKincaid
    @DangerousDaveKincaid Před 2 lety

    Great Video Jake, I love my Skydio 2 and I think the video that comes out of the camera is really good. I don't have the Mavic 3, to much $$ but have the Air 2s and video is also really good although I was flying yesterday with my variable ND filters and did not like the color change in the sky. sides were darker than the middle. What are you thought on variable filters?

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety +1

      Thank you very much and I agree the image out of the skydio is excellent. I usually don't put the variable ND filters all the way to the darkest due to this reason

  • @lettheroadtakeyou
    @lettheroadtakeyou Před rokem

    Jake, great video! Thank you. What camera bag do you recommend that fits the Skydio?

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před rokem +1

      I’ve used the thinktank Mindshift 26l pretty well in the front pocket

  • @reptilianresearchredux5887

    Great video Jake👍the skydio is really cool but the mavic is more who I am😎

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety +2

      Agreed! Different drones for different uses!

  • @richardtremblay7646
    @richardtremblay7646 Před 2 lety +1

    Very good video as usual. I have 2+ and I have already 3 Incidents. 2 hitting very small branches fall in deep snow and one on landings the drone when propeller hit the side of the rooftop. Also Skydio should provide some advise when drone fall in deep snow or other situations. like Clean, stop using it, blow air etc what’s the best for the drone.
    Skydio to not offering speed settings in Manual Mode (no controller) I understand moving the slide controls slowly works but there is situations you would like minimum ,maximum speed set’s. Also there is no way to visualize the setting in any skills without having the drone in flight mode. This will be useful for learning all the settings. 👍

  • @KAPture3D
    @KAPture3D Před rokem

    THIS IS A GREAT REVIEW FOR A HIGHLY DEBATED TOPIC IN THE UAS INDUSTRY - WELL DONE SIR. I personally took the slightly less video quality reduction (obviously not the CINE version, I could buy SkyDio Enterprise at that price) for the superior AI in SkyDio 2+ - especially considering they are going to be constantly updating, and the AI is going to literally be learning to be better the more customers they have, unlike DJI. Thanks for your input!!

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před rokem +1

      Thank you

    • @KAPture3D
      @KAPture3D Před rokem

      @@JakeSloan the advantage SkyDio has over DJI in obstacle avoidance can't be touched. It has it's own NVIDIA GPU 256-core Denver & 64-bit CPU 4-core for the Autonomy ALONE. As a former Shield AI test pilot, I can see this exponential efficiency with certainty. Example: Google Lens hit the market OCTOBER 2017, and 9/10 times failed to ID. WE taught it's AI how to recognize objects because every time it couldn't ID, it would ask you to tell it what it was. Here we are now and it works 98/100. The same thing is going to happen with SkyDio both in the military world and in consumer/cinematography....

  • @bluesteeltraining
    @bluesteeltraining Před 2 lety +1

    Great review!! That part where it landed by itself without any input from you was really bizarre! Were you able to figure out what caused that? Or is it a firmware or design glitch? I have had my Mavic three for a little over a month and I really do not trust the active track or obstacle avoidance features yet. I put it through its paces at a local cemetery having it go between large markers and trees, and although it did well for the most part there were times when it would try to avoid a tree or a marker and nearly crash into something else. This comparison review definitely clinched my belief that I should not yet trust the Mavic 3 obstacle avoidance and tracking features. Hopefully a future firmware update will correct this. 🤞. As you said, it depends on what you use the drones for.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      Agreed and I never did figure out what happened in that one spot lol.

  • @DanielNaias
    @DanielNaias Před 2 lety

    isso é briga de gigantes. Parabéns 👏👏👏

  • @DPVLOGS8786
    @DPVLOGS8786 Před 2 lety +1

    Awesome video mate, i am user of Air2s and feeling that mavic 3 is still not good as Air2s as this is crashing blindly.. Skydio is the trust and best buddy when you are busy in performing your act and not to look again and again at the drone.

  • @davidwalker2402
    @davidwalker2402 Před 2 lety +1

    Good Job was using the filter a problem for M3 . I’m not sure but is there something in the manual saying not to use filter or anything on the camera in AT. Could be wrong Jake, thanks for doing a great test it was Skydio’s day out.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      you're welcome and no the filter wasn't causing any issues for the mavic. DJI sells their own filters for it as well. Now filters on the obstacle avoidance cameras would be a different story

  • @michaelblaisdell
    @michaelblaisdell Před 2 lety +3

    Thank you so much for doing this video! I want to track myself on a motorcycle, so the Skydio seems like a great option. But, I also want the cinematic, color grading control of the M3 - plus the 4K 120. I just got my Part 107 and it’s time to buy. Decisions, decisions….. Great video - thanks again!

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety +1

      Awesome and thanks for the kind words!

    • @KnightmareOX
      @KnightmareOX Před 2 lety +1

      If skydio comes out with a drone that’s foldable, has 1 inch sensor and 10 bit color I’ll drop dji in a heartbeat

    • @michaelblaisdell
      @michaelblaisdell Před 2 lety +1

      @@KnightmareOX agree! If the camera on the Skydio 2+ was 10 bit / capable of color grading, I would have bought it. As it stands, I pulled the trigger on the M3 yesterday. Gulp….expensive!

    • @brucegruenbaum
      @brucegruenbaum Před 2 lety +1

      That right there is the reason the Skydio is going to be a buy for me. Tracking myself on a motorcycle just does not work with the DJI drones. I’ve messed with it a number of times. @Jake Sloan’s video makes clear which is better. The only thing I’d use it for is tracking and I think it’ll fit in my H-D’s Tourpak.

    • @michaelblaisdell
      @michaelblaisdell Před 2 lety

      @@brucegruenbaum it seems like a great option for sure!

  • @The_Snowbike_Channel
    @The_Snowbike_Channel Před 10 měsíci

    Hey fellow Alaskan here. I agree with your assessment between the two drones. I’ve gone back and forth between DJI products and for the last three years have exclusively used the Skydio for active tracking. It’s the only thing that I have found that will keep up with me snowbiking in the winter. It’s light years ahead of DJI. It’s unfortunate the Skydio consumer drones will no longer be available. Also wish we had slightly better camera and battery but beggars can’t be choosers. Cheers!

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 10 měsíci

      agreed, I was extremely disappointed when skydio announced their exit from consumer drones

  • @PaulRanky
    @PaulRanky Před 2 lety +1

    Hi Jake, could you pls. advise me on the first steps of learning to fly a DJI Mavic 2 pro? From the very beginning... thanks, Paul

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      Definitely start here: czcams.com/video/7s5TYFPP6Uw/video.html

  • @Stpilot
    @Stpilot Před 2 lety +1

    That tracking is amazing on the Skydio!

  • @aaronpk
    @aaronpk Před 2 lety +1

    oh no, "Anthem of a Quirky Hipster" in the intro triggered my PTSD from dealing with the bogus Content ID claim on a few of my livestreams that used it! Hopefully we got that sorted out so it doesn't trigger it on yours now!

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      Hahahaha I’ve had a handful of those claims against various music I’ve used. Never against that one though.

    • @aaronpk
      @aaronpk Před 2 lety

      @@JakeSloan It was a whole thing. Some comedy label used the song as the outro to some comedy sets and then published the songs to Apple Music and CZcams Music, which then made CZcams think I was using their copyrighted song. They rejected my first dispute but thankfully I was able to get the Artlist lawyers on them and they got it sorted out! I did a couple livestreams about it if you're curious about the details, it made me so mad!

  • @donaldmartin7109
    @donaldmartin7109 Před 2 lety +1

    Thank you for sharing and displaying these drones. I enjoy my mavic line of drones but guess won't buy the $2500.00 dji 3. way over price and not impressed with high dollar price tag. excellent demo and thank you.

  • @w.e.s.
    @w.e.s. Před 4 měsíci

    Jake idk if u ever read my previous comments but u look just like a best friend i lost years back. U dont just resemble him u look like identical twins. Even his brother. Btw ur clothes cost more then my vehicle. I envy a person like u but it makes me feel worse about my life. I dont understand how so few win and so many loose. I have a spark and a mini 2 which is modded and flies for 1 hour. I have saved up a year to just afford a air 3 finally after giving up on the mavic 3 pro. I just couldnt do it. I love my life and am happy but jake man u have got it dude. Be proud of yourself.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 4 měsíci

      Sorry you lost your friend! The air 3 is a great drone probably better for most people than the mavic 3.

  • @Akulion1
    @Akulion1 Před rokem +1

    I love DJI products but I'm totally in love with the Skydio 2 tracking ❤

  • @TheThaiLife
    @TheThaiLife Před 2 lety +5

    Great video and one of them curious about. But oh my gosh, watching the DJI crash into the ground was freaking scary. How the heck does it not see the literally black ground against the white sky? I call active track of DJI active crash. I don’t trust it at all.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety +1

      Yep I agree and I almost never even have it on so I don't rely on it at all

  • @pjf4e2
    @pjf4e2 Před rokem

    Thanks!

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před rokem

      you're welcome and Thank you very much!

  • @rubenvor
    @rubenvor Před 2 lety +2

    Thanks for the review. Considering cost, I still would get DJI. The other one seem much outdated and a bit more like a toy.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      DJI is putting out fantastic products

  • @UtahOutlander
    @UtahOutlander Před 2 lety

    Great comparison! They're both amazing aircraft, but, as you mentioned, really made for two different purposes or audiences. I have wanted a nice drone for a few years and DJI has been at the top of my list. I wanted a drone for capturing my adventures out on the ATV, so controlling a drone while riding at the same time was the challenge that held me back. I scoffed at Skydio when they came out, probably because I think the name is silly, but that's beside the point. I new DJI was the king of consumer drones and had all the experience...blah...blah...blah. Skydio was the new kid on the block, and I never buy brand new tech (or anything "1st iteration" for that matter), so I waited. Then the 2+ came out. Done deal! Take my money!! It arrived on March 1st, and I've only been able to take it out for two short fights, but I am SUPER IMPRESSED! Tracking is incredible! It's exactly the type of drone for me. I'm glad I waited! Not to buy the "Best" drone...but to buy the "Best for me" drone.
    BTW...I've never flown a drone before the Skydio. You can check out my 3rd flight ever (Horseshoe Knoll) on my page if you so desire. Let me know what you think! czcams.com/video/KIq3DJCZtR4/video.html

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety +1

      nice video! love the scenery so different from Alaska lol. I dare say you did get the perfect drone for you which is exactly why I make these comparison videos to try and help people decide which one is the best for their uses. Cheers!

  • @BlackOps-Ent
    @BlackOps-Ent Před 2 lety

    Say, do you carry some sort of s&m equipment on your backpack?? Nice!! #freak
    haha, jk. Very well done. I hope you made another video after giving the Mavic 3 the 1.00.0700 firmware release.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      Lol. I haven’t directly compared but it is better for sure

  • @azdronedude
    @azdronedude Před 2 lety +1

    What you don't go through for us Thanks for what you do

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      Thank you! It was fun and worth it. I don’t know if would have said the same if the mavic 3 had been badly damaged lol

  • @guidetheride2103
    @guidetheride2103 Před rokem

    Mavic Tree👍. I still love it. for all the reasons you mention and some, haven’t upgraded to the pro yet though 😂.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před rokem +1

      agreed any of the mavic 3 series are fantastic

    • @enchanched-music
      @enchanched-music Před 6 měsíci

      Mavic tree 😂😂😂😂😂

  • @SkydioUkraine
    @SkydioUkraine Před 2 lety +1

    bravo!!!!

  • @DE-signYourLife
    @DE-signYourLife Před rokem

    Thx for the Video. Is Mavic 3 fixed now?

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před rokem +1

      yes it is and it's fantastic

  • @KnightmareOX
    @KnightmareOX Před 2 lety +1

    I hope the skydio 3 or whatever their next consumer drone is has a 1 inch sensor, 10 bit color, and log. If they did that I’d totally switch to them from DJI.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety +1

      You and me both!! I'd drop DJI in a heart beat if Skydio had those options

  • @DroningaboutIreland
    @DroningaboutIreland Před 2 lety +1

    Is that you Jake or T-1000 running there 🏃😂 just kidding, great comparison and the Skydio blows the Mavic 3 away with AT and OA I wouldn't trust my Mavic 3 at all in any tight situation, hopefully they improve it.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety +1

      Hahahahaha I haven’t run that much in a LONG time!!

  • @thebrownthomascrown917
    @thebrownthomascrown917 Před 2 lety +1

    Great demo...but what are those pants your wearing??

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety +1

      Those are the best outdoor pants I’ve ever found and they are made by Kuiu.

    • @thebrownthomascrown917
      @thebrownthomascrown917 Před 2 lety

      @@JakeSloan Thanks I'm gonna check for those. I'm a country boy and wear whatever but I'm gonna step it up a bit.

  • @andyb7123
    @andyb7123 Před 2 lety

    When are Skydio going to sell this drone outside the US and Canada, I have been waiting to get this drone since forever here in Australia.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      I hope soon but I have no idea.

  • @CarolinaAirshots
    @CarolinaAirshots Před 2 lety +1

    Run Jake Run , lol , had to say it. Mavic 3 can see miles away but can't see a tree in it's face , very interesting

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      Oh man I was so out of breath lol.

  • @SunriseWaterMedia
    @SunriseWaterMedia Před 2 lety +1

    Those trees come out of nowhere! Lucky, your Mavic is ok!

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety +1

      Yeah they are sneaky like that! Lol

  • @briandougherty481
    @briandougherty481 Před 2 lety

    When the mavic tracked you from the rear, did you tap your controller

  • @gustavozaratini
    @gustavozaratini Před 2 lety +1

    Jake, I would add another positive for skydio that helps me a lot, Skydio there is not No Fly Zone :)

  • @Strgchris
    @Strgchris Před rokem

    I would like to see this comparison with the firmware updates since this post. Just curious if the mav 3 has improved

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před rokem +2

      I am working on that video now!

    • @Strgchris
      @Strgchris Před rokem

      @Jake Sloan looking forward to it! Love the content. I am studying for my part 107 and starting my own now cause of it. Thank you!

    • @drAndreLinoge
      @drAndreLinoge Před rokem

      I too am interested :)

  • @vantagepointphotography

    Wondering if after a few firmware updates on the Mavic 3 the test can be done again. This was very interesting. We know when the Mavic 3 first went out there, it was far from been ready to hit the road. But eventually and after a number of firmware updates, it is now a tank. But the active track... which was disappointing at first. It is significantly better? Has anyone tested this again recently?

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před rokem

      they have massively improved the Mavic 3 with the updates however Skydio still wins hands down for tracking and obstacle avoidance

  • @garymorris6819
    @garymorris6819 Před 2 lety

    I want that cinematic quality from the Mavic 3.

  • @KoryFPV
    @KoryFPV Před 2 lety +1

    If DJI could acquire Skydio's software, it would be a game changer. Nothing on the market would come close to DJI at that point. They already have the tech to handle it.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety +1

      That would be incredible

    • @BlownMacTruck
      @BlownMacTruck Před rokem

      I mean maybe. But everything DJI’s done in the past says they’ll make an attempt to emulate it themselves, not do great (and have it take forever), and not make it backwards compatible with any existing models, and will make you buy a new model to get it.
      Also keep in mind the Skydio uses some pretty hefty processing power to achieve their results. DJI would have to really take a jump in their DSPs and CPUs, which would cut into their profits.
      I like DJI but they often get good at something, then end up stagnating as they let their greed get ahead of them. They usually come back in a good way though. Usually (third party devs relying on their woefully ancient SDK which gets updated on a terrible schedule has been consistently bad).

  • @MrEddieNunez
    @MrEddieNunez Před 2 lety +1

    Great comparison video. I would be so scared to do this with my mavic 3, lol

  • @donaldmayfield9159
    @donaldmayfield9159 Před 2 lety

    Every drone has its pros and cons so if I had to pick one, definitely Mavic 3!!!

  • @AntonioIndelicato
    @AntonioIndelicato Před 2 lety +1

    Mavic 3 still my fave ;)

  • @PhilSledge
    @PhilSledge Před 2 lety +1

    Jake's face at 8:58 tell you all about the problems with the Mavic 3 you need to know for a $3k drone

  • @gameAnM
    @gameAnM Před rokem

    I think it's better that the drone is controlled manually than that it flies by itself, because if you control it yourself you can take pictures as you want, but if it flies automatically, that's not quite possible

  • @josephbruce5080
    @josephbruce5080 Před 2 lety +3

    Thanks for the comparison. At the end of the day, I think I’m still choosing the Mavic 3 for overall performance. Sucks that Skydio can’t beat DJI when it comes to camera performance.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      I agree!!

    • @baalzamon3593
      @baalzamon3593 Před 2 lety

      I think if Skydio had the overall quality of DJI AND the edge in tracking, it'd be even more expensive

  • @vienneliao2748
    @vienneliao2748 Před rokem

    Skydio so amazing

  • @johnny_123b
    @johnny_123b Před 2 lety

    Almost ran into the ground? It definitely did 😂

  • @othoapproto9603
    @othoapproto9603 Před rokem

    And that's the 2 and I understand the 2+ is way better. But Why didn't they make the arms fold down like the DJI?

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před rokem

      The 2+ only has better range. Nothing else has changed. I imagine it was much more difficult to get the vision sensors to calibrate when arms are fading in and out

  • @not4younot4you70
    @not4younot4you70 Před rokem

    can you choose what to track? like i stand at one area with the control and i want to track my friend as he ran away to area B

  • @ensaricokur1784
    @ensaricokur1784 Před rokem

    What brand ND filters do you have on DJI?

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před rokem

      I use Freewell filters on everything

  • @filmowewyprawy
    @filmowewyprawy Před rokem

    Trees are quite naked in this forest, no branches or no bushes surrounding them. Did You test Skydio in a thicker forrest?

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před rokem +1

      there are tons of small sticks and twigs there

    • @filmowewyprawy
      @filmowewyprawy Před rokem

      @@JakeSloan ok didn't see that in the video, thanks.

  • @verdinec
    @verdinec Před 3 dny

    Hi,have you ever tested any autel drones? evo II Pro v3?

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 dny

      I have not, I have asked many times but never been able to get a loaner drone and they aren't readily available here. From what I hear many people are quite happy with them

    • @verdinec
      @verdinec Před 2 dny

      @@JakeSloan oh ok would have been good for them to let you test one..From my experience customer support is very bad and they don't try to improve or fix software issues. I recently bought one and have some issues out the box...hoping they reach back out to me and can get it resolved or else ill have a brick..

  • @CaminoAir
    @CaminoAir Před 2 lety

    Both of these drones are outside of my realistic price range at present (for uses that I could honestly justify the expense). However, I always appreciate your videos Jake and I can dream, can't I! I read somewhere that the Skydio 2 has 256 processing cores, which is the main reason for its remarkably intelligent behavior. Can anyone confirm if this is true? My understanding is also that the Skydio 2 is essentially a dedicated tracking platform and is far less flexible than something like the Mavic 3, which is designed to cover a wider scope of use (or which at least is designed to surpass the Skydio in everything except tracking). Again, can someone confirm if this is a fair evaluation?

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      you are correct on both accounts! Cheers mate

  • @FahadKhan_3007
    @FahadKhan_3007 Před 2 lety +1

    I am going to declate this as a tie.
    As a two years experienced UAV enthusiast, I declare that it was a tie between Skydio 2/2+ and Mavic 3/Cine for sure.
    There is no doubt that Skydio drones have the best Artificial Intelligence, Tracking and Obstacle Avoidance system whereas DJI drones are superb with breathtaking camera quality, Long Battery Life, Long Range and a wide variety of drones to choose.
    Both are really good product makers but I have to say that Skydio is a bit too harsh with DJI as shown in their official videos of telling the only the negatives or cons of a DJI drone and only positives or pros of a Skydio drone.
    Anyway, DJI is still the most famoua Drone brand out there, even though they are costly, they are worth it.
    My Mini 2 which costs around 1,100 US dollars is really durable and works very nicely!(yeah, it is a bit more expensive because nano drones are more pricey in India.)
    Also waiting to see a futuristic Skydio 3 and DJI Phantom 5 with DJI Inspire 3 as well as DJI Spark 2 and DJI Mini 3 Pro!

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      Cheers!

    • @FahadKhan_3007
      @FahadKhan_3007 Před 2 lety +1

      @@JakeSloan Yeah

    • @ironman98
      @ironman98 Před rokem

      @@FahadKhan_3007 Skydio 3 definitely in the future. DJI Phantom 5 no further production updates most likely a dead project. DJI Inspire 3 definitely a possibility but have heard no rumors. DJI Spark 2 most likely will not happen as they like their "mini" platform way too much. DJI Mini 3 Pro will most likely happen in the near future possibly within 2023. As an experienced drone pilot of about 8 years as well as a fully certified FAA part 107 commercial drone pilot, I agree with your overall conclusion of the two models. "but I have to say that Skydio is a bit too harsh with DJI as shown in their official videos of telling the only the negatives or cons of a DJI drone and only positives or pros of a Skydio drone" this is just marketing. I've been around long enough to know that pretty much everybody does that. That's how corporations sell products. And lastly, unless you are doing very big jobs and have a pretty good business flow, which unfortunately not everybody has, DJI products can be quite expensive. Especially for the more recent products from DJI. It's pretty cost prohibitive. Especially if you want something on the level of the Mavic 3 cine. I think the market that Skydio is going for is a good move on their part. Their business plan is solid. And they are also catering to the more professional market with their X2 platform. That's their more professional platform for around $13k USD.

  • @BlairAir
    @BlairAir Před 2 lety

    Hey Jake. Is this on V01.00.0500 FW? I noticed the M3 was tracking really close, like it was on V01.00.0400. Also when in bright light and I have high contrast with surroundings, I get much better directional tracking. Like it hauls butt to get to the new position as I switch on the fly. Still it's not 100% trustworthy.
    In all fairness you were wearing black.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety +1

      I was wearing black but even when I’ve been wearing red in this same area on other trips I’ve had the same issues. Yes it’s on the .0500 firmware and while the active track is MUCH better than older DJI drones it’s still definitely not on the Skydio level. I do think it will continue to improve with firmware updates over time though. Hopefully we will get the GPS fix soon as well. Cheers

    • @BlairAir
      @BlairAir Před 2 lety

      @@JakeSloan I've heard tell of a beta out there for GPS sat. Aquisition. Hopefully soon. A small thing but it really irritates! Thanks for the comparison 👍

    • @BlairAir
      @BlairAir Před 2 lety

      @@JakeSloan They also seemed to have fixed the ghosting on bottom wide angle sensors that caused many un-commanded altitude increases - in my case up to my set max altitude. Still get it a bit in APAS Bypass Mode during low sun angles at sunset/sunrises - those are glass lenses - but hugely improved.

  • @Jjones24680
    @Jjones24680 Před 2 lety +1

    What is the song at 5:05 !!!!!!??????

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      That’s cyber-runner by 2050. Cheers!

  • @sungyle
    @sungyle Před 2 lety

    The DJI Mavic 3, when tracking, will rise and/or move sideways to keep you in it’s view finder. And it does that automatically without warning.
    Does anyone know how high it will rise and move sideways? Is there anyway to guesstimate/anticipate that and avoid challenge?
    For example, you may be walking on the beach as in your video; what if there are trees on the other side and what will happen if you walk too close to the trees?
    Also, what if you set the obstacle avoidance to ‘brake’? Does ‘brake’ work during tracking? Will the M3 stop instead of trying to ‘Bypass’?

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      braking works too well at the moment. I found it just stops way to often thinking there is an obstacle in the way. as far as height goes it try to maintain a constant distance from the subject so if its 12 feet away from the front when it tries to go high it will try (not very well) and stay 12 feet away

  • @BasicFilmmaker
    @BasicFilmmaker Před 2 lety +2

    38 BELOW zero! Brrrrrrrr. :)

  • @stanislavcoros
    @stanislavcoros Před rokem

    WHAT IS THAT LENS ON DJI MAVIC ? ROUND ?

  • @friendcircle49
    @friendcircle49 Před 2 lety

    May Allah bless you and go Ahead brother

  • @iPig
    @iPig Před 2 lety

    I would be scared if I saw a man walking with that much purpose through the woods.

  • @gabzilla2809
    @gabzilla2809 Před 2 lety

    Where is this location so beautiful

  • @d_ward4871
    @d_ward4871 Před rokem

    Damn😮 I didn’t realize the skydio2 was 2500 bucks !!

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před rokem

      depends on the package you get

  • @Nyke226
    @Nyke226 Před rokem

    Did the Active Track got better by now? Its almost 1 year now

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před rokem +1

      it is better still not as good as Skydio but better

    • @Nyke226
      @Nyke226 Před rokem

      @@JakeSloan thanks for replying! :))

  • @ericsparkman3645
    @ericsparkman3645 Před 2 lety +1

    For manual flight the Mavic 3 wins all day, but when your talking tracking the Skydio 2 will win every time

  • @d_ward4871
    @d_ward4871 Před rokem

    Can the skydio 2 track the Mavic 3 through the trees?

  • @RevMikeBlack
    @RevMikeBlack Před rokem

    Unless I missed it, you didn't mention that the Hasselblad cameras make the DJI the best flying camera system available other than super-expensive cinematic cameras. The Skydio 2 can't begin to compete on image quality.

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před rokem

      this was a active track and obstacle avoidance test, there is currently nothing on the market that can compete with DJI for image quality and price... They are just so dang good

  • @screamingiraffe
    @screamingiraffe Před 2 lety

    Price vs performance the DJI Mavic 3 wins hands down, Skydio 2+ is double of what it should cost for what it offers

  • @khoatran-sv7je
    @khoatran-sv7je Před rokem

    The Mavic 3 is bound to get a massive firmware update soon from the time it was released 2 months ago, otherwise it's all set now and tracks like a dream

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před rokem

      since this video was made the updates have made it significantly better!

    • @khoatran-sv7je
      @khoatran-sv7je Před rokem

      @Jake Sloan Yep I agree!

  • @richrye5832
    @richrye5832 Před 2 lety +1

    Hopefully Sky2 upgrades battery life. Get it to 30 plus minutes and it’s perfect

    • @JakeSloan
      @JakeSloan  Před 2 lety

      Their latest battery is pretty dang close!

  • @nino1filionewheeler257
    @nino1filionewheeler257 Před 2 lety +1

    Skydio 2 for me

  • @briandougherty481
    @briandougherty481 Před 2 lety

    Oh No
    My Air2s does great in the Forrest