@@ni-kitten it's harder for unknown groups, people probably have no idea what are the names of 12dal members, so I think she would lose all popularity of 12dal if she started using her name
@@user-vd5kq5gr6d I mean true, but to be fair, considering how some groups of this gen don't even have anyone at high W-A or average, I think it's understandable to give some praise to the entirety of NMIXX.
@@user-vd5kq5gr6d you're entitled to your opinion and I respect it. Ye singing isn't entirely about technique (one can have amazing technique but can still sound boring to others. Dynamics (and artistry as a whole) especially can affect performance quality. But ig they'd be able to develop individuality throughout their career (hopefully).
i love how this is based on their actual SKILL and not biased, and how it includes vocalists from groups that aren’t super popular as well as popular groups!
@@NRam-ke6cs tone and skill are two very different things bfr. you can be born with an amazing tone but not have the skills to utilize it. take Sana from twice as an example, amazing voice but she makes easy parts sound hard when singing live. lily is objectively a better vocalist than Ning², a larger range and better control with it, amazing belting and by far has the best head voice control even beating Wendy in that area if i'm not wrong (Wendy is still overall better)
@@NRam-ke6cs Good thing about vocal rankings is that it can be based on objective criteria like stability, agility, accuracy, range, power, etc. Not on some delusional BS a random fan comes up every time he intimately believes he knows something no one else does. Yes, Heawon is better than NingNing, even though I love Aespa, she's a better belter, her mix is a universe apart, her stability is legendary and has more power whispering than NingNing entire career. And Lily is achieving something you will never achieve even if you could restart your life a thousand times. Now be a dear and deal with those facts far away from your keyboard before you manage to convince everyone here that your IQ sits in low single digit.
@@pignonMZ6 Defending flop lily and flop Haewon from the flop group Nmixx shows how much you know about music. It also shows that you know nothing about music and vocals. You belong to the clown community. Take an immediate appointment with your doc. You seem disturbed and troubled.
@@pignonMZ6 Defending flop lily that sounds annoying and flop Haewon from a flop group Nmixx shows how much you know about music and vocals. Chill clown. Seek help.
Because your idol is not always the best lol 😆. Because she's from SM Ent. you thought she's the best 😜. She's not Wendy lol, because right now the mini Wendy is Lily, Nayul is in the max of her improvement unlike Lily everyday she's improving. And most of the people who listens to voice of Ning Ning always irritated their because of her overlapping notes.
@@nikkolaurente01 “BeCaUsE sHe’S fRoM sM. eNt YoU tHoUgHt ShE’s ThE bEsT” 🤪😜😆😂 What was the whole point of that reply? To get the Ningning stans riled up even though everybody here already agreed upon the list? If you wanted the attention, here, I am happily giving it to you😊
@@naylafebrisa4612 Nope. Aespa is only one that mainly lipsyncs. SM does have some of the best vocalists, like Wendy and Chen are the best male and female vocalists if the 3rd gen, And even Sub vocalists from SM have good technique.
@@naylafebrisa4612 Seriously? Lol no, Almost all SM vocalists sing live most of the time except for Aespa. Examples: Taeyeon, Baekhyun, D.O, Taeil, Doyoung etc.
The people commenting “where’s x idol” clearly know nothing about vocals and vocal technique. Just cause you like their vocals doesn’t make them a good vocalist. Sorry your faves didn’t make top 10.
I am so happy Haram from Billlie and Goeun from Purple Kiss were included! People often forget about them! They deserve so much more appreciation and recognition.
sorry but it seems the range of Vocal Monday has increased, the evidence is in the song he covers, the title is twenty one twenty five by jaurim he is High Note with support tone on D5, Monday is already on tone
The haewon and Lily duo is amazing and Nmixx sub vocalists can be lead vocalists in some other 4th gen groups. The fact that this group is from JYP is quite surprising.
Among these top notch vocalists, Haramie is the only one who can capture the attention of both my eyes and ears perfectly. There's something about her that makes me ... relax and at ease.
I CAN'T BELIEVE YOU PUT SWAN FROM CRAXY!!!!! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ I LOVE HER SO MUCH BUT SHE ISN'T POPULAR.... THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR PUTTING HER IN THIS VIDEOOOOOOO❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ STAN CRAXYYYYY
Try their cover of ABC! Their vocals are insane. And while there's no record in high quality, they have an amazing live cover performance of Move your body by Beyoncé that's working checking out.
she is a good classically, but being that her job involves a lot of pop singing, she’s actually way far behind in vocal especially her mix. but her head voice is really good
@@gratefulyes6282 Singer? My favorite is Tori Kelly, Jojo Levesque. Korean Singer : Sohyang(F) and Jong DongHa (M) FavKorean KopVocalist : Sandeul (M) Uji (F)
It's not about hitting high notes it's about hitting highnotes perfectly. It's not about singing live It's abt singing live perfectly. Singing with technique is important. And as for me all the SM artists are well trained when it comes to vocals. That's why SM artists are recognised for having Good vocals. So it's normal for the kpop stans for saying that SM artists have the best vocals but it's not just SM artists there are other artists who sing really well too. Coz we have to appreciate the ones who are actually really good. Mostly SM artists enter the top lists of having best vocals I mean why not? Tbh only a handful of groups have good vocals.
@@Netaliatwiceonce lol keep calling Liliy noisy vocalist Boi don't really know about vocal and vocal belts and lacking vocal knowledges and let me hear you sing and I will compre you belts with Lilly
As much as I love Lily and her vocals, she’s not better than Nayul. Nayul is the only 4th gen idol that is a proficient vocalist and the only 4th gen idol to produce resonance. Maybe in the future Lily will be better than Nayul, but for right now Nayul is better than Lily.
@@hayazrik8112 it's called a keyboard fault and I didn't notice it And please fix your English grammar because we shouldn't say "she isn't not better" ok? And for winter being better than goeun I'm talking objectively and technically who are you to tell me that I'm wrong? Have you ever known about vocal technique?
Girl get a life its fine to make mistakes Also having a nasal is not good no one with a nasal voice like winter should be top10 her high notes some times hurt ur ears and thats not what a good vocalist wants to do
@@shujinko2944 Voice range and support are not the main thing. And any range can be expanded over time. I'm telling you this as a girl who has been practicing vocals for more than 15 years.
Pretty sure it's objective. Based on support range and technique.
Also source: sooztubæ
Yerim from 12dal is number 4(just reading from sooztubæ)
@@frenzy7666 she's not part of 12dal anymore tho
@@katykim if I'm not mistaken, 12dal were a duo, so both of them are not a part of 12dal anymore
@@ni-kitten interesting
@@ni-kitten it's harder for unknown groups, people probably have no idea what are the names of 12dal members, so I think she would lose all popularity of 12dal if she started using her name
NMIXX is just crazy.
They're also good at dance!
yeah
What a joke ? FLOP NMIXX
@@NRam-ke6csthey can sing,rap and dance so cry about it
Having 2 decent vocalists in 1 group...
With 7 members with All Supports...
Please JYPE...😭😭
GIVE THE GOODS MUSICS AT OUR QUEENS PLEASE !!!!
They only know how to support but their riff,vibrato,dynamics and other material from a vocalist besides technique is lack except Lily and Haewon
@@user-vd5kq5gr6d I mean true, but to be fair, considering how some groups of this gen don't even have anyone at high W-A or average, I think it's understandable to give some praise to the entirety of NMIXX.
@@nyx_1864 Yeah they are better than i expected even though they sound flat and plain
@@user-vd5kq5gr6d you're entitled to your opinion and I respect it. Ye singing isn't entirely about technique (one can have amazing technique but can still sound boring to others. Dynamics (and artistry as a whole) especially can affect performance quality. But ig they'd be able to develop individuality throughout their career (hopefully).
I really love lily and haewon even tho I don't stan nmixx tbh
But who ever the girl in #8 she gives ne goosebumps 😭😭
“whoever that girl is” her name was right there dumbass - Jungwoo
Ikr, idk bvndit but jungwoo sang so beautifully
jungwoo, bvndit main vocal! bvndit are in the same company as chungha and are close with her, their latest comeback was venom, please check it out!!!!
@@tamarlevy5949 :(( bvndit have since disbanded
@@lunacxx1330 i know ;-; it's actually tragic how mnh wastes every talent they have....
i love how this is based on their actual SKILL and not biased, and how it includes vocalists from groups that aren’t super popular as well as popular groups!
It is biased. Lily has an annoying piercing voice lol. Haewon above ningning hahahaha. What a joke. And Liz ?
@@NRam-ke6cs tone and skill are two very different things bfr.
you can be born with an amazing tone but not have the skills to utilize it. take Sana from twice as an example, amazing voice but she makes easy parts sound hard when singing live.
lily is objectively a better vocalist than Ning², a larger range and better control with it, amazing belting and by far has the best head voice control even beating Wendy in that area if i'm not wrong (Wendy is still overall better)
@@NRam-ke6cs Good thing about vocal rankings is that it can be based on objective criteria like stability, agility, accuracy, range, power, etc.
Not on some delusional BS a random fan comes up every time he intimately believes he knows something no one else does.
Yes, Heawon is better than NingNing, even though I love Aespa, she's a better belter, her mix is a universe apart, her stability is legendary and has more power whispering than NingNing entire career.
And Lily is achieving something you will never achieve even if you could restart your life a thousand times.
Now be a dear and deal with those facts far away from your keyboard before you manage to convince everyone here that your IQ sits in low single digit.
@@pignonMZ6 Defending flop lily and flop Haewon from the flop group Nmixx shows how much you know about music. It also shows that you know nothing about music and vocals. You belong to the clown community. Take an immediate appointment with your doc. You seem disturbed and troubled.
@@pignonMZ6 Defending flop lily that sounds annoying and flop Haewon from a flop group Nmixx shows how much you know about music and vocals. Chill clown. Seek help.
I can't be the only ningning stan who agrees with the ranking here
I agree too with Ning Ning as my bias
me tooo
Because your idol is not always the best lol 😆. Because she's from SM Ent. you thought she's the best 😜. She's not Wendy lol, because right now the mini Wendy is Lily, Nayul is in the max of her improvement unlike Lily everyday she's improving. And most of the people who listens to voice of Ning Ning always irritated their because of her overlapping notes.
@@nikkolaurente01 “BeCaUsE sHe’S fRoM sM. eNt YoU tHoUgHt ShE’s ThE bEsT” 🤪😜😆😂
What was the whole point of that reply? To get the Ningning stans riled up even though everybody here already agreed upon the list? If you wanted the attention, here, I am happily giving it to you😊
@@nikkolaurente01 you are so cringe I feel like crying for you even tho I don't stan aespa
Lily is sooo cute and I'm in love with her voice
She's a flop tho. Sadly no one knows her
The best ranking I've ever seen, people tends to be biased towards the most popular ones and forget some other vocalists that are actually better.
Perfect ranking
Unbiased video
Everyone put SM artist on top1 without knowing valid reason and vocal techniques
True
And the fact that their artist using backtrack too much and evem lipsync 100%
@@naylafebrisa4612 Nope. Aespa is only one that mainly lipsyncs. SM does have some of the best vocalists, like Wendy and Chen are the best male and female vocalists if the 3rd gen, And even Sub vocalists from SM have good technique.
@@VT-ng7tc only those both are singing and the rest using backtrack nor AR
@@naylafebrisa4612 Seriously? Lol no, Almost all SM vocalists sing live most of the time except for Aespa. Examples: Taeyeon, Baekhyun, D.O, Taeil, Doyoung etc.
gotta flex that haewon and lily sounding the rawest but sound so good.
im in love with lily cover omgg
SAMEEEE that smooth register switch im in love
My Haewon №2 , Lily №1
Nmixx crazy group , for me best!!!!!!
😂🤡🤣🤡🤣
Nayul is definitely better. But she's now inactive so I don't know if she counts..
STAN PURPLE KISS
YASS PURKI FOR LIFE
lily so talented❤ i love her
😂🤡🤣🤡
@@NRam-ke6cs???
@@user-gh9sv3jt3znayul is better than lily
Honestly,Monday is literally the best
The people commenting “where’s x idol” clearly know nothing about vocals and vocal technique. Just cause you like their vocals doesn’t make them a good vocalist. Sorry your faves didn’t make top 10.
Goeun is so talented
There is also Nayul's former duomate, Yerim who's around/above Yechan and solist Minseo who's in the higher part of A-AA.
I am so happy Haram from Billlie and Goeun from Purple Kiss were included! People often forget about them! They deserve so much more appreciation and recognition.
so happy to see monday here!! her vocals are incredible
Ningning forever ❤️
Ning ning voice has its own fandom
So does Lily??
I'm actually so surprised to see that several videos like this mention Yechan she's so good but a lot of people don't even know her 🥲
Swan from purple kiss deserves more attention as well
sorry but it seems the range of Vocal Monday has increased, the evidence is in the song he covers, the title is twenty one twenty five by jaurim he is High Note with support tone on D5, Monday is already on tone
Ningning
"if lily is not in the the list...oh, she is 😁
The haewon and Lily duo is amazing and Nmixx sub vocalists can be lead vocalists in some other 4th gen groups. The fact that this group is from JYP is quite surprising.
it's so weird how most talented idols always go to small agencies
bcs its not just about vocal talent
I think that Jungwoo is very underrated
I'm happy non popular gp make it , in happy for purple kiss
Among these top notch vocalists, Haramie is the only one who can capture the attention of both my eyes and ears perfectly. There's something about her that makes me ... relax and at ease.
Haewon's vocals tho😭
finally someone mentioning Haram 🙌 Also GOEUNNN 🔥❤
Yuri ( ex-IZ*ONE )
omg i forgot about her!!! i literally love her voice sm in pd48 & izone
Just hearing these people sing it makes my heart melt it is so good and relaxing
Goeun ❤
So good to see yechan being appreciated she's such a good vocalist
straight up facts! girl spit it out
#5 gives me goosebumps damn
Ningning is my fave here✨😍
For me she is the best here 🦋
@@Netaliatwiceonce OMG agreed😇😙
Goeun omg ❤
Swan - purple kiss 😢
Goeun is here on the 10th place and Swan is weaker than her, Chaein is the same level or even better than Swan actually
I CAN'T BELIEVE YOU PUT SWAN FROM CRAXY!!!!! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ I LOVE HER SO MUCH BUT SHE ISN'T POPULAR.... THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR PUTTING HER IN THIS VIDEOOOOOOO❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ STAN CRAXYYYYY
CRAXY in the hall ❤🎉
thanku for adding haram
Haewon and Lily seems like they were destined to meet and become two of the best vocalists in 4th generation in one group.
I think Winter ❄️ is really good too
On top 20
Nayul, Lily, Ningning these are the top three of 4th gen vocal queens..
Nayul>Lily>Haewon>Ningning 💀
Nayul B+
Lily B
Haewon B-
Ningning C+
Im annoyed. Haewon? Where is she?!?!
@@M.in_ 3rd place?? Behind Lily and Nayul.
Haram and Ningning my SM girls
Yechan is to talented yet so underrated....
STAN BILLLIE 🙌🙌
I feel like Swan from purple kiss should be here too
Monday❤
yechan and swan are so underrated for their voices
Support them
❤craxy❤
🎉Pink fantasy🎉
Heavy on Monday!!
nmixx sullyoon, haewon, lily, kyujin
Mostly lilywon tho
not kyujin but go off
@@august-ub5zk uyes since shes the third best vocalists in nmixx if not kyujin then not sullyoon
@@august-ub5zk …kyujin 3rd best vocalist in Nmixx
@@august-ub5zk probably didn’t hear her sing FINE BY TAEYEON
Finally a TRUE RANKING !
THANKS SAYING FACT !!😭😩🔥
FINALLY SOMEONE APPRECIATING NAYUL
Even if i listen to these little parts omggg😭😭😭😭👑👑👑👑
Yassss queens 👑
Can someone talk about Ningning’s technique? Sorry not sorry, she’s one of the 4th gen idols who has best technique.😅
Finally recognized craxy and pinkfantasy
Support them
🎉 CRAXY 🎉
❤pink fantasy❤
AHHHH U PUT JUNGWOO HEREEEEE I LOVE UUUUU
Haram my love ❤
I am sorry but who the hell is Haewon and why her voice is so damn good. I need to stan NMIXX asap.
Try their cover of ABC! Their vocals are insane. And while there's no record in high quality, they have an amazing live cover performance of Move your body by Beyoncé that's working checking out.
1-Lily
2-Nayul
Based in 10 years experience in singing and studying music
Maybe if lily mix is more fuller
reason?
10 years experience eating hamburger?
You clearly don't know Nayul.
Thank you so much for acknowledging Swan's existence and the beautiful vocals that come with it! 💙🌟
Swan CRAXY ❤
@@littleharuka96 I'm so sad that their agency fired ChaeY 😭
@@kiodoiii8794 wish the best for chaey and Craxy
@@littleharuka96 Absolutely 🥂
What's the song jungwoo from bvndit is singing- can anyone tell me?? It sounds angelic😭✨
Yunjin lesserafim I am pretty sure she is an opera singer
She is
She isnt a opera singer,she just learnt classical music and theatre ,never went into it as a profession.
On top 20
If it's only about HV, i bet she is on 3rd 🤗 Her F5/F#5s even sounds fuller than Taeyeon's
she is a good classically, but being that her job involves a lot of pop singing, she’s actually way far behind in vocal especially her mix. but her head voice is really good
Haram of Billie is like Joy RV😮
I think Swan from Purple Kiss deserves to be in top 3
No, she isn't even the best in Purple Kiss.
no lmao
Not the Halsey of kpop taking the spot
@@bubuthefooll JAILLLL😂 why she sing in cursive too though
Swan and Bora!!!! Why are missing that's all I kept asking myself
ning ning is top
I think haewon vocals are so good
Why does everyone forget about chaewon of class:y
Ningning hits different ❤️
With her light mix ?? 🤣🤣 Girl Cmonn
@@xxfogartinixx no one asked about your shits, get a life this is my opinion
@@xxfogartinixx
Who's favorite singer?
@@gratefulyes6282 Singer? My favorite is Tori Kelly, Jojo Levesque. Korean Singer : Sohyang(F) and Jong DongHa (M) FavKorean KopVocalist : Sandeul (M) Uji (F)
The only accurate ranking imo
Actually Now Ningning is B- tier
@@CrownPrinceEdvin nah she recently become B-
@@CrownPrinceEdvin keep crying bc she is
That’s your opinion,fact is ningning is C+
@@linralyn lol not my opinion I'm spitting facts 👽 seems like yours one the opinion Lmao
🤡🤡🤡
i'm surprised how swan and chaein of purple kiss + jiwon and hayoung of fromis-9 aren't here
Jiwon is pretty close but slightly weaker than goeun. Others don't have average technique. Also swan is stylistic
*Minji* & *Dita* (secret number)🥰🥰🥰
Weekly Monday is better than Ningning tho
No, Ningning is better, objectively
@@KpopFan-pz7vy Very true
For me my fav main vocalidt in4gen:
1 ningning
2 lily
3 liz
4 monday/ chahyeon
5 miyeon
6 minnie
7 yunjin
8 sieun
9 lia
Umm ningning for what
@@naylafebrisa4612 that my opinion , my favorite main vocalist in 4generation is ningning so, what you want .
@@jihadhachemi281 ok. I don’t want that list
@@naylafebrisa4612 good
@@naylafebrisa4612 bcs his a opinion OMG
Thanks for including Swan from craxy in my opinion she should be first but the ranking is very good
CRAXY in the hall ❤
yechan🥺
Bro haram not me thinking abt the arabic word haram lmao..😭
ME TOO!!! “my bias is haram” sounds weird
@@stanme well if you come from a conservative household and have a bias in a bg......👀💀💀💀✋
Same
In hindi it also sounds really weird 😭 "haram"
young eun -kepler
bora-cherry bullet
chaehyun-kepler
yoon and sieun-stayc
My Favs are Stacy and Purple kiss those 2 groups are the best in Vocal capabilities 😍😍
Nvee is nice vocalist 🎉
Tho im so happy to see goeun here✨
yunjin left the chat
As she should
Stop overhyping her when she can't compete with these idols
@@closed3000 umm do you hear yourself rn?? she deserves the overhype even if she doesn't get it, she is one of the best vocalists out there atm
@@Lydia05K but definitely not in top 10 best 4thgen female vocalists LMAO😭.
Not even in top 20
It's not about hitting high notes it's about hitting highnotes perfectly. It's not about singing live It's abt singing live perfectly. Singing with technique is important. And as for me all the SM artists are well trained when it comes to vocals. That's why SM artists are recognised for having Good vocals. So it's normal for the kpop stans for saying that SM artists have the best vocals but it's not just SM artists there are other artists who sing really well too. Coz we have to appreciate the ones who are actually really good. Mostly SM artists enter the top lists of having best vocals I mean why not? Tbh only a handful of groups have good vocals.
Okay?
okay but what does it have to do with this video💀 ?
Purple kiss is sooo underrated and i love themmm
I really think that Ningning's and Haewon are on the same level
Ningning is C+ while Haewon is B-
@@JasPugliese if only I knew what that means.....
@@alexwhite7680Haewon is FAR better.
Lily is a thousand times better vocalist than Nayul, for me Lily is number 1, her vocal skills are on another level and she far surpasses Nayul
Nayul>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>noisy lily
@@Netaliatwiceonce lol keep calling Liliy noisy vocalist Boi don't really know about vocal and vocal belts and lacking vocal knowledges and let me hear you sing and I will compre you belts with Lilly
@@Netaliatwiceonce??
As much as I love Lily and her vocals, she’s not better than Nayul. Nayul is the only 4th gen idol that is a proficient vocalist and the only 4th gen idol to produce resonance. Maybe in the future Lily will be better than Nayul, but for right now Nayul is better than Lily.
eloborate your reason
Winter deserves to be here
She's interchangeable with haram
She has a nasle voice no way she is better then any of these
If she didn't have a nasle voice she would have been here bc she is really good
@@hayazrik8112 learn how to write in English and then you can argue with me
Winter is technically a high average vocalist she is better than goeun
Yea yea tell me to learn English while u wrote "here" as "hier" 🤣
Also no she isnt not better then her like there is no way
@@hayazrik8112 it's called a keyboard fault and I didn't notice it
And please fix your English grammar because we shouldn't say "she isn't not better" ok?
And for winter being better than goeun I'm talking objectively and technically who are you to tell me that I'm wrong?
Have you ever known about vocal technique?
Girl get a life its fine to make mistakes
Also having a nasal is not good no one with a nasal voice like winter should be top10 her high notes some times hurt ur ears and thats not what a good vocalist wants to do
purple kiss swan!!
Time to token stan nayul to spite nmixx fans
Liz deserve to be on the list 😭
Liz is definetely a good vocalist but compared to these ones she falls behind
not compared to everyone else
Ningning >>>>>
No
@@Cat-jp5jr Yes
LMFAO💀
NAYUL>LILY>HAEWON>>>>>||BIG WALL||>>>Ningning
@@mulfand_00 hahahaha ningning >>>>>> kpop
kinda sad that winter wasn’t mentioned
For me Mia/Sihyeon, Lily and Winter 😌
„For me“ well this isn’t about opinions though
@@shujinko2944 I'm just sure that they are capable of more powerful vocals, we just haven't seen it yet
@@sunrisedagger they have plenty of materials to judge them.
@@shujinko2944 Voice range and support are not the main thing. And any range can be expanded over time. I'm telling you this as a girl who has been practicing vocals for more than 15 years.
@@sunrisedagger No one cares about "voice range". It is about technique and all of those you mentioned have weak technique in comparison.