Presumed Innocent Ep 7 Recap | AppleTV+
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 09. 2024
- #PresumedInnocent #PresumedInnocentEpisode7 #appletvplus #jakegyllenhaal
Here to discuss the New Apple TV+ show which stars Jake Gyllenhaal as Rusty Sabich as he's accused of the murder of his colleague Carolyn Polhemus played by Renate Reinsve.
The fact that none of us is really sure who the killer is, says that they did the writing Right!
The fact that 7 episodes in, nobody in the audience knows anything about who Carolyn Polhemus is and why all these other people 'may' have wanted to kill her, says they took a perfectly written book and botched the storytelling of it.
@@daveclark8337 that part is also true 😆 Renate has more seggs scenes than court scenes
I know that’s right!!!
My humble thoughts:
Who would she trust enough to let into her apartment?
Who had access to files about that previous case, knowing the details of the murder and how she was tied up?
Who has a creepy infatuation with Rusty?
Who would put an office-related Post-it note on the murder weapon?
Answer: The legal secretary!! She did it. And she feels terrible that Rusty is going down, so she put in Tommy's house.
Love it. Thanks for the comment.
She probably snapped and killed Caroline after Rusty's visit when Caroline called to her crying, and told her that she was pregnant.
Yea I can see that being a def possibility
Yep! Great catch!
I’m really enjoying your recaps, but people need to understand this. The Judge is doing things that only happen on fantasy courtrooms not real ones. The burden of proof is on the prosecution, it stays with the government. It never shifts to the defendant. Del Guardia, thinking as a prosecutor he can ask for a mistrial is insanity. If the State asks for a mistrial Rusty walks free, why, because jeopardy has attached and you can’t twice be put in jeopardy for the same offense it’s a provision in the US Constitution and every state constitution . Rusty could not in any shape, fashion or form open a door, where any judge or any prosecutor could compel him to take the stand, it’s sheer fantasy. At no point in time could Maya walk off of a case the way she did even if Rusty wanted to “represent himself” as is his right but Maya would’ve been sitting in that seat right there the whole time. It would never happen, the fact that his, primary attorney Raymond, had some kind of heart attack or electrical disruption, and had to get a pacemaker a pacemaker MEANS that your heart isn’t working. You don’t come out stronger because your heart is already weak. I’m not even a doctor, but my mom had three pacemakers so I know a little something about them. The adjournment request would’ve been for a week not a day. I love the drama. I love the suspense. I love now we know who actually did it but, guess what the burden never ever shifts to Rusty at all. He should have listened to Maya and took the mistrial. The craziest part about this case is that while Rusty was at the scene before Carolyn died there’s not a drop of his DNA anywhere, on a piece of rope anywhere in her house except under her fingernails that by itself is reasonable doubt the show is crazy. I am enjoying it as an attorney, but the reason why I hate watching lawyer shows is that it gets out there in the ether that a criminal defendant has a burden of proof in a criminal case, you don’t and people see this craziness on TV and they don’t know it’s just fantasy. I am enjoying it and I’m enjoying the recaps as I said, but I just had to step in for this one.
Who do you think did it?
I can respect that. I know nothing about being an attorney. I recap what I see, the story that’s being told. Not what the reality is. The shows we see is full of bent reality. I love what you said because yeah I can imagine it be super hard to watch something like this and take it seriously. So thank you so much for your comment. Much appreciated. And keep sharing your pov. It’s helpful to know what’s up.
Technically Raymond did leave the hospital stronger, as he had bradycardia which caused the cardiac arrest. Receiving the pacemaker treats the bradycardia, therefore he was technically better than he was before. Obviously, having a pacemaker isn’t optimal health, but he is much better off than if he didn’t get it implanted at all. And he should have been in a arm spling lol
Ha!
@@GardeniaBlossoms_ point well taken.
Only thing I know is neither Rusty or Tommy killed Carolynn 🤷🏾♂️🤷🏾♂️🤷🏾♂️
Its the kids and the mom helped them clean up
I still don’t think his wife did it. I’m still going with Tommi.
Good good. We will soooooonnnnn find out!!!
The kids
Awesome review
Thank you much!!!!
My question. Someone who was not in the courtroom planted the murder weapon and broke into the apt
Who are you thinking?
Maybe the Rusty’s wife and Tommy set the whole thing up? Maybe Rusty’s wife is pretending like she doesn’t know what’s going on when in reality her and Tommy was up to it this whole time? Idk just throwing out ideas
Yeah no I’ve thought of this and so many other options.