Come home Cardinal Pell - The Project
Vložit
- čas přidán 18. 02. 2016
- Tim Minchin made this song and video to criticize Cardinal George Pell, and the way that the Catholic Church has treated children in its care. When it was aired on the Channel 10 show "The Project" on Feb 16 2016, there was an amazing response from Steve Price.
Talk about respect for authority figures !! "This man is the most senior Australian Catholic ! He is a Cardinal..." This serves as a strong reminder of the power the churches had once, indeed the power of life and death. I include here the full conversation and the links below to the originals. Here they are used for commentary and satire.
The studio version on Tim's channel
• Come Home (Cardinal Pe...
www.gofundme.com/sendballarat...
I tried to include the original Project clip, but YT seems to truncate the link. I will put it in the comments.
And even more www.smh.com.au/national/victoria/george-pell-how-the-mighty-have-fallen-20190226-p5109w.html?ref=rss&
"use your talent to abuse somebody" yikes, what about people who use their power to abuse children.
Exactly
Not enough evidences only testimony .
@@kamwamtam Testimony IS evidence.
“Did he need to use the word scum?”
*yes*
We now know it was Minchin that was the scum !!! 7 --- 0
The notion that this person cannot be carried up the stairs of a private jet, recline for 16 hours while being waited upon by handsome stewards, and be carried back down the stairs in Australia is an audacious, incredible assertion of entitlement. He should be jailed until he can be extradited in handcuffs in a cargo plane..
To hear someone take more offense about a song then the abuses, is a clear sign of either being brain washed or an offender himself.
The song is great, in fact it could have been much ruder, however Minchin showed great restraint and respect for the victims.
We have the same problem here with priests being accountable, the whole lot of them should be in prison
racoonsister Minchin has another song where the lyrics are “Fuck the motherfucker” and it’s like over 100 curse words in 3 minutes where he’s swearing and being offensive while also talking about priests raping children and calling out people who do get offended by his songs and ignore the fact that there’s worse things to be offended by
MAX. Films ahh yes the pope song
Cardinal Pell released after being imprisoned for a crime he did not commit. Overwhelming evidence of his innocence then we had an overwhelming result 7 - 0 recognising he is not guilty. Such a wonderful, courageous, good man to return to Australia to face the hostile media and the mob.
Cardinal Pell died cos he was an elderly man who had complications following an operation ... He admitted with the benefit of hindsight that he made mistakes 30 + years ago when nobody thought Child abuse was prevalent .. Of course after being wrongly convicted he has reached his aim and is in heaven ... Mr Minchin has still not shown any dignity and not apologised!!
Love the song Tim. I am a victim within the Jehovah's Witness. I so relate to this song. Don't go much on the idiot that commented afterwards… Obviously he has never been sexually abused. Love ya work.
What a fabulous song. Well done Tim Minchin. If this Priest came home to answer the charges against him; no one would need to call him a coward would they? This Priest has exhibited cowardice.
As we sing in a football match when winning by a large margin ""You have all gone quiet over there "" He came home Cardinal Pell faced the mob and trial by media ABC ..... Cardinal Pell faced the travesty of a guilty verdict when all independent commentators at the trial predicted an acquittal.. 7 - 0
That's what you get for covering up child abuse
Matt Arthursson an awesome song written about you? Damn now I wish I had
Zebra M He did. It’s called a ten foot cock and a few hundred virgins.
Zebra M Tim Minchin does have a song about Muslims actually. I guess it was too hard to do a quick google before your clumsy attempt to suggest he’s a hypocrite. Also it’s pure fantasy to suggest Waleed is mates with all Muslims. I don’t think all Christians are mates with George Pell and Gerald Ridsdale.
Wow, as the sister of Stephen Woods and two other abused brothers I applaud The Project for supporting victims of abuse in Ballarat. I love the Tim Minchin song for lots of reasons, mainly for its musical genius, but also for its insight into how strongly people feel about the truth that is emerging about the church's cover-up of abuse by its clergy. Good on you Project!!! And Steve Price, go look at your own videos and the venom that comes from your mouth from time to time!
+Anne Murray I wonder if you have rejected the theistic claims made by the Catholic church now as a result of these horrific events ?
I just find it incredible that Price dared to use the word "abuse" when talking about the song. It shows his complete lack of perspective. And yes, the song is completely brilliant.
I wonder if you have seen this ? www.smh.com.au/national/catholic-education-system-under-a-cloud-after-child-sex-abuse-commission-findings-20170210-gua1pv.html
What do you think now Steve Price?
Tim Minchin just said what the rest of Australia was thinking.
And all of them were wrong and none, in their arrogance will pause to reflect
@@adamwaugh3373 Georgie's in a box
Did you hear that?? He said: "To write a song like that and use your talent to just abuse someone from a distance, I think's pathetic"
Well, first of all I pretty sure that there are plenty of people who are more that willing to deal out a litlle abuse to mr Pell up close and personal and secondly... you think that a song is pathetic while the abuse that Pell oversaw (which was NOT from a distance) is just excused by him being a senior cardinal.
I think I just trew up in my mouth!
+suziecreamchease Such an ironic malapropism.
+suziecreamchease, great name from history. Long live Zappa
AsFew+, um she was being ironic, sorry you missed the irony in her post. Oh thank you for posting this, the song is brilliant
Ardent Fan It’s actually disgusting they had him on the panel. Bring him on in a day or a week to whinge or whatever but the discussion after that song shouldn’t be about Pell’s widdle fee-fees.
and police investigators have now gone to Rome to question Pell, hopefully justice will be found
6:50
Steve Price: "George Pell says he never knew what was going on in Ballarat."
Me: "And I say that I'm a magical fairy that shoots pixie dust from my butthole... doesn't mean I'm telling the truth, does it?"
Tim, don't panic. He's coming home in a box now.
Couldn't have happened to a nicer arsehole. If there is a place like hell, I hope he rots there.
DERRRR He is already home with God in heaven
Tim Minchin is a genius who is endeavouring to help the victims, which is more than the Catholic church has ever done. Go Tim.
Steve price only wants freedom of speech for himself and Bolt.😜
Absolute brilliance 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
BEST SONG EVER, GO TIM!
Bloody hell Peter Hellier is a funny bastard
The other three can barely hide their incredulous contempt of Price.
Steve Price...you really seem incredibly unintelligent
and have chosen sides.
i fricken love this song, tim has done amazingly well with this song. i also do not care what pricey said especially when pete burned him with if the lyrics were changed to one pro abbott pricey would be happy. overall thank you for uploading this clip. tim minchin has a way of quickly making a strong point that is similar to that of a retorical question, instead of taking an hour to debate the issue he has taken 4 minutes and gone a greater effect. and thank you again AsFewFalseThingsAsPossible for uploading this clip.
Well, the guy at 5:49... That didn't age well, did it? Hahah
Ouch...
Briliant
What a beautiful song. Well done Tim.
Even more info coming out www.smh.com.au/national/catholic-education-system-under-a-cloud-after-child-sex-abuse-commission-findings-20170210-gua1pv.html
The song is flames tho lmaooo
You can order the book here: www.mup.com.au/items/204955
I'll admit. I'm a little disappointed that there are no karaoke versions of his songs. Now what will I sing at parties? What a shame. :(
The original Project show where the song was launched.
tenplay.com.au/channel-ten/the-project/2016/2/16
From Bessel van de Kolk, whom I respect with all my heart and mind....People have two choices in respect to the abuses of
anyone, and especially by those in power or authority.
Unless it has happened to you, you have no idea of the
damage to the spirit. So take your pick. Whose side are YOU going to take? Trauma therapist and survivor.
"When the traumatic events are of human design, those who bear witness are caught in the conflict between the victim and the perpetrator. It is morally impossible to remain neutral in this conflict. The bystander is forced to take sides. It is very tempting to take the side of the perpetrator. All the perpetrator asks is that the bystander do nothing. He appeals to the universal desire to see, hear and speak no evil. The victim, on the contrary, asks the bystander to share the burden or pain. The victim demands action, engagement, and remembering.
The more powerful the perpetrator, the greater is his prerogative to name and define reality and the more completely his arguments prevail. In the absence of strong political movements for human rights, the active process of bearing witness inevitably gives way to the active process of forgetting. Repression, dissociation and denial are phenomena of a social as well as individual consciousness."
+Annapurna McQueen "People have two choices ..." how do you know they don't have three or more ? Not all people have the morals you espouse. When you say "The more powerful..." it's important to recognise that the power differential changes over time. What we are seeing here is an attempt to get the Catholic church to redress the power imbalance they have enjoyed for hundreds of years.
That's a powerful paragraph. Standing by and doing nothing is so much easier, but it's imperative to take action.
You're awesome Minchin and band.
March 5 2018 Hearing begins bit.ly/2H05NPS
He worked hard to protect….. the churches assets. That makes the word “scum” valid even if there was no other reason, but come on, “scum” was fitting on several levels.
Breaking news www.9news.com.au/national/2016/07/27/19/22/two-men-claim-cardinal-pell-abused-them
Steve Price, there is 'shock jock' & 's*it jock'. Your criticism of Tim Minchin, while supporting George Pell was one of the most vile television items I have ever seen. The comments below illustrate how disconnected you are & the producers of The Project need to consider your value & impact on ratings - when you're on, I turn off.
an amazing response eh?
Meanwhile in New Zealand www.stuff.co.nz/national/70377103/Catholic-priests-who-abused-New-Zealand-children-will-not-be-investigated
"No reason"
www.theguardian.com/australia-news/video/2016/mar/01/cardinal-pells-response-to-question-about-paedophile-priest-draws-audible-gasp-video
Minchin +10,000 good Karma points
The guy must be a contrarian for being contrarian's sake
Pell update bit.ly/2ghqeNu
LOL Steve...............So Steve as a survivor I find it offensive that you defend Cardinal Pell and I think the language was tame to the suffering we have all gone through our whole lives and we have been called all sorts of names that I found offensive by people in the Catholic church like Liar, prostitute, I must have encouraged it, advanced girl and on and on - I WAS A CHILD, it is obscene to make to say these things, let alone to a child and blame the child. I hope you have not been a victim Steve (though I doubt as you defend Pell) or any child you know. I think it has since been shown that Pell allegedly did know???
Hear from the survivors themselves tenplay.com.au/channel-ten/the-project/extra/season-7/no-more-silence
December 2018 Shit got real. wapo.st/2zW3Piu
And so it goes www.theguardian.com/world/2017/jan/15/catholic-church-not-done-enough-to-tackle-abuse-claims-new-book
He's actually nice in this song
Have you seen his one about the pope
Hahaha yas and the song for Phil doust
This song was abusing someone who'd already answered to the same issues at a previous Royal Commission in Victoria. Many legal tribunals accept video testimony.
George Pell was investigated by Victoria Police without the initiation of a complaint, and as it stands now he'll be sentenced for sexual crimes from the 1990s this February.
Guilty :p
Ooh rather good thoughts on sacredness by Minchin czcams.com/video/AnIpuoxVol0/video.html
www.abc.net.au/news/2016-02-27/parents-of-abused-girls-in-rome-for-pell-testimony/7204718
www.abc.net.au/news/2016-02-26/abuse-victims-travel-to-rome-for-george-pell-appearance/7201482
www.youngwitness.com.au/story/4473700/notorious-paedophile-former-priest-sentenced/
Church made mistakes.
www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2016/feb/29/george-pell-church-made-enormous-mistakes-in-dealing-with-paedophile-priests
www.stuff.co.nz/world/australia/92545805/australian-cardinal-george-pell-accused-of-sexually-abused-choirboys-in-explosive-new-book
www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2016/feb/29/george-pell-church-made-enormous-mistakes-in-dealing-with-paedophile-priests
I see the mob who were so proud of Aussie justice following the trial have not had the decency to come back and admit they had got it so wrong and persecuted an innocent man ... No doubt some one will say not guilty finding is not innocent but when you are innocent what other verdict is there ?? 7 -- 0
The Catholic Church deserves every criticism it gets, no one can deny that. Now lets for an exercise apply the same attention to Islam. Let someone produce a mocking song about one of their Islamic leaders in the face of the murderous and cowardly attacks in the name of that so called region. Well that aint going to happen now is it? Least of all receive air play on a show such as this. The never ending hypocrisy and stupidity of the media is astounding.
Of course this has been done. czcams.com/video/uQBgrUObbHw/video.html
Thanks for the link. Will never be played on a program such as this but. Latest news is that Islamic prisoners in Goulburn Supermax are bashing those who will not convert to Islam. www.dailytelegraph.com.au/news/muslim-prisoners-threaten-others-convert-or-be-bashed/news-story/cb7eb48ecf60fc78d34b444b0b146c34
Nice pivot.
Your jihad envy is gross (and also completely irrelevant).
Suffering. www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4547010/Child-sex-abuse-campaigner-dies-stroke.html#comments
The Catholic Church in America spent 1 Billion dollars in lawyers fees protection racket for Priests.🎃
Looking forward to minchin apology song, come on minchin it's the right thing to do.
He came home He faced the worst trial by media ever seen ... He faced the trial by Jury who were so scared / influenced what was going on outside the court building and capitulated to give a guilty verdict .. He put up with the first appeal which hinged on a Judge saying he did not want to overturn a Jury decision though he felt less than happy about the verdict . Cardinal Pell then got justice 7 - 0 ..... Kept his dignity and got justice against all the odds
This song will be a historic song of shame, hate and injustice because it was delivered an abusive language and accusation towards the cardinal before trials.
This song only upset the faithful Roman Catholic followers. The shame and the condemnation of God on the Roman Catholic Church has been pronounced by Jesus Christ in the book of Revelation. This is the reason that RC followers never study the Bible prophecies.
Mike Dan Keep taking the tablets mate.
What happens when the pope dies?
.
,
,
another one popes up
😂
/|. |\
_|. |_
Christ didn't judge the world...
How can you possibly know that ? And what are you trying to say ? We should not have a judicial system to protect children ???!
If people didn't believe in "Christ", "God", "Jesus", the "Bible", religion, the whole illusion, in the first place, we might not have this situation at all.
All our prayers for this great guy against evil and falshood against this holy person
HE IS GUILTY PELL, DISSCUSTING.
Can somebody please tell me why this song doesn't come under the category of hate speech???
Because Minchin is condemning paedophilia.
I do not believe the verdict is correct. Cardinal Pell is a holy man of God. He is like Jesus being condemned and crucified like him.
Also St Paul was imprisoned and John The Baptist too.
Your reasoning goes: He is a priest therefore he cannot do harm to children therefore the verdict is incorrect ?
Do you realise how that goes against the evidence we have of priests doing bad things to children ?
So what if Jesus was harmed, he also called for hatred towards children. (If you accept the alleged text ascribed to him in the Bible).
educate urself. the church has been infiltrated. there r masonic pedo priests in it. he upholds pre v2 tradition. he is a proper priest. the real priests r being framed by imposters. u know nothing. v2 is liberal ..he is not. he is conservative. its liberals that uphold homsexuality.
Daisy Train
Daisy you are agreeing with me. He is a good priest.
AsFewFalseThingsAsPossible
Because there are priests leading double lives and should be brought to justice does not automatically incriminate Cardinal Pell. The evidence was not at all convincing.
yes he was.. these people who do these vile things to him will account to God. vile ugly song..look at his hateful eyes