BEST TEMPO SHOES - Saucony Speed 3 v Puma Deviate 2 vs Nike Zoomfly 5- REVIEW & Comparison
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 07. 2024
- Today we are talking about all things plated training shoes! What is the most comfortable? What is the best value? And most importantly what is the fastest!! Follow along today to see the comparison. As always all these shoes were purchased 100% with my own money.
Part Time Athlete Tee - benparkes.com/collections/cas...
ALL NEW RUNNING HATS, SWEATERS, TEES IN STOCK WITH FAST WORLDWIDE SHIPPING!
benparkes.com/collections/mer...
Code CZcams for 10% off your order. Thank you for your support!
TRAINING PLANS TO GET YOU THAT PB YOU DESERVE!
benparkes.com/collections/plans
Full Review of the Saucony Endorphin Speed 3 - • Is THIS the best plate...
Full Review of the Puma Deviate 2 - • My most surprising sho...
Full Review of the Nike ZoomFly 5 - • Nike ZoomFly 5 REVIEW ...
Follow along on Social Media!
Instagram - / benparkes
Facebook - / benparkesruns
Twitter - / benparkes
Strava - / strava
Ways to help
Join the CZcams Channel / @benparkes
Time stamps
0:00 Intro
1:20 Facts and figures
2:49 Value
5:54 Comfort
8:29 Performance
10:42 Summary - Sport
Which one would you pick for your next training session or race??!
I love the video as I was thinking about getting the puma shoe definitely helpful
Endorphin for the extra session endorphins : - )
And in Australia Puma is more expensive than the Saucony : - 0
I tried on the Saucony's at a running shop and loved them immediately but going into the winter season with all the wet & leaves and light firetrails I run on it feels like the right decision to go with the Puma's
Loved your video. On top, perhaps it would be great to see some feedback wrt the endurance of these shoes. Obviously, Puma will have better durability since it has more grip but wanted to see your feedback on this as well.
The Puma colorway just looks wow to me.
Really enjoying the amount of videos your brining out and the quality of videos just now.
As someone just beginning to reintroduce a rotation to my shoe line in prep for marathons and races, I'm really enjoying the Saucony Speed. I'm not experienced enough yet to fork out for a Carbon Plated shoe, but I think this will work as a trainer/racer combo. Some people have told me plated shoes are also good trainers because they encourage better form. I do most of my daily runs in a Pegasus, which has always been a reliable shoe for me. If conditions are super wet on race day, I can always just do the run in it, I'll lose some time, but I've never had comfort issues with it, and as of now, most of my PBs were set in Pegs.
Just getting into being a little more goal oriented in my running workouts, I find the sheer selection can be pretty dizzying, but Nike Pegs have been good to me, and the Saucony line, in general seems to have a lot of solid shoes for different purposes. At the moment I'm not going to bother with the really expensive Carbon shoes like the Vapour Fly.
My plan through winter spring is to use Pegs as Daily Runners, and once it gets closer to spring, Saucony's minimalist Kinvera as a training tempo runner, and the Speed as my race shoe, occasional trainer. Are the Speeds completely useless even on dirt/gravel? Some of my country routes involve occasional forays onto such surfaces, not for too often or too long, but it gets you away from the traffic.
Have you ever run in the Saucony Kinveras?
Hey Ben！
Fernando from Taiwan here🙋♂️
just wanted to say thanks for the videos, they are full of that positive energy 😉
Love the endorphin speed2 - fav shoe in my present rotation. Considering the speed3
Sold on the Pumas. Austrian winter is coming lol
Always amazed of how good your reviews are Ben.
THANKS ALOT!!
excellent video, ben! great delivery. that saucony looks tempting to me!
Picked the Noosa Tri 14 as my speed day shoe for this year but recently took advantage of the season sales to also buy the Takumi Sen 8 and Deviate 2 precisely due to concerns over grip. I do a number of small, local, olympic triathlons every year and more often than not the running portion goes through some gravel path/fire road/sand and so I will be using whichever of those two turns out to be grippier.
Ah such a perfect timing for me! I need to find another alternative for my Nike Air Zoom Tempo NEXT%. I can't seem to enjoy other shoes that do not have carbon plates so these could be great options. Thank you so much!
I have two pairs of the Speed 2s I'm working through right now, but I'd love to get both the Puma and the Speed 3 down the line! The plan is to wait for some sales, lol. But I am eyeing the Puma as a possible road-to-trail shoe.
Gote the Speed3 just recently, what a great shoe! Love it!
Asics Evoride 2 is my favourite session shoe currently, simple, effective and snappy.
Great video! Still haven’t committed to the top tier shoes so this is my area.
Have the zoom fly3 and saucony speed2s, ran my marathon in the speeds just amazing very lightweight and still giving a bit od that pop ! Nikes are good but the weight kills them a bit for racing we agree on that one.
I guess the nike folks just want you to go for the alphaflys 🤷🏽♂️
Regarding wear on the Saucony's, I'm 190 lbs, supinate a little, and have 270 miles on my Speeds. The tread on the rear outside is essentially all worn smooth.
Speed 3 is a must have in the rotation. Did have some heel rubbing but cleared up after about 30km.
Great video! It's interesting to see the shoes! Question not related to the video: thoughts on chip time Vs watch time?
Yes i run in the zoom fly 4 fantastic for long distance runs..this is just how i feel..however vaporfly next per 2 is best..
I totally agree with you. Personally the Nike Zoomfly 5 is not even in the conversation. I would sub the New Balance Rebel 3 instead. But the the Puma and the Saucony are so close. I think the Puma Deviate Nitro 3 is more fun, but if I were to pick just one shoe, I would pick the Speed 3.
thank you, great review
Thanks Ben. Saucony for summer, Puma for Britain!
Love the t shirt Ben! I would say you are a full time athlete! ;)
sometimes I almost forget that Puma has been in this segment for a very short time, really incredible.
On my 1st Saucony Endorphin Speed I did more than 1200 km, my 2nd is 1000 km on it's way and is still not completely finished. I use both 1st version around the house now (not for running). I'm on my 2nd batch of the Endorphin Speed (the 2nd version) now and they are resp. 180 and 460 km on the way. I don't have the Speed 3 yet.
I have the Saucony and the Nike and totally agree with this.
Deviate Nitro underrated shoe Loved version 1 now loving v2
Please make comparison video for asics novablast 3 and puma deviate nitro 2. 😁
Great review! Not the first time a nike shoe lost a comparison. I have a nike air zoom and somehow the shoe and I will not fall in love.
I have Speed 1 and DN 2. Speed 1 has speedroll tech which makes it slightly easier through the gait cycle.
Speed3 all the way!! Great daily driver!! But race day it is all about the new endorphin pro!
Any major difference in arch support in these 3? I thought the Pumas were super but a bit too flat under the arch to my liking. Doubting to try the Saucony
I do pretty much all my running in the Speed 2s and I love them for their light weight and springiness, but now that they’re discontinued I don’t know what to buy 😢 I’ve done 250km in the Speed 3s but don’t like them as they give me arch pain (maybe due to softness) and they’re not springy. I’ve also got 300km in Puma Nitro Velocity 2 too and really dislike them, which puts me off the Pumas in the video.
Does anyone have any recommendations for shoes that might compare to the Speed 2s in terms of ride/springiness, high stack and preferably plated? 😅 Probably a bit specific :(
I agree. I like the Speed 3 better than the Puma. The Puma made my arches ache a bit.
I am looking for a "racing shoe" for my first marathon. Hoping to do it in just under 4 hours. The rout is 50% gravel and 50% road. I did buy the FuelCell SuperComp Trainer, but it is to mushy and feels unstable because of the high stack. What shoe you recommend?
Hi, I've a spot in ibiza marathon I can't use happy to foc transfer to a youtubers. Any use for you or Sarah? 👍
Is the previous Puma shoe you are mentioning as comparison a Deviate Nitro Elite rather than the regular Deviate Nitro version 1?
I love the Saucony Speed 3 for everyday training. I use the ASICS Metasky Plus for races, but think the Saucony isn’t far behind in terms of speed.
I love both shoes. But definitely perform better in MS sky
I absolutely love my Saucony Speeds! My current rotation is Triump 20s for recovery/slow runs. Speed 3s for more uptempo, faster long runs. Endorphin Pro 3s for race day. I also switch in my Kinvara 14s for when I want to run shorter sprints with a nice ground feel. Have you tried the Endorphin 4 series yet? Thoughts on Kinvara Pros? They seem like a quirky and fun shoe.
I bought Zoom Fly 5 few weeks ago and I am positively surprised. These are the first Nike shoes that I really like and feel comfortable using them. The weight isn't that bad. It is the same weight as Asics Nimbus 24 of the same size. Glideride 4 are few grams lighter, but still I run faster in Zoom Fly 5. If you don't run the race below 4:00 per km, you won't feel that they're too heavy.
this is so true i am in middle school doing xc with my Zoom fly 5's with 5 min per km for 10k and it has been great. The grip is not terrible and i do not notice the weight at all. If i were running on roads i would choose the streakflys
Man this is the review I needed. I’ve just bought a pair for Christmas and I was worried about all the negative reviews as I wanted these as a tempo/race shoe but I’m only trying to go around 20 min for the 5k so it’s good to know
Ok. I will try out the puma then.
Please @BenParkes how is the new balance fuelcell propel v4 compare to the Puma deviate 2 and Saucony speed. Thx in advance
you guys should totally check out Buffalo shoes, must the same but better looking
Have my 2nd pair of the Deviate 1 and now trying the New Balance SC Trainers. I really like the Deviate and plan to purchase the 2. The Deviate have great traction, fit and last long…375 miles first pair and 185 so far on 2nd. Even ran the Atlanta half in the first pair when they had 250 miles because the course is very hilly and it was raining…great traction. I like th SC trainer but will no way get the same mileage out of them. Saucony are way to narrow for me in the forefoot and I have average d width feet.
I feel that the Deviate Nitro 2 might fit those with slightly narrow or average width feet better than the Speed 3, if anyone is after the fit like a glove feeling but decided that stuff like the Takumi Sen 8 is overkill/minimalistic. The Puma grip is also phenomenal on wet tiles. I just got the DN2 at a pretty good price though and generally from what i see it'd run noticeably cheaper than the Speed 3 in most countries/websites, just usd 99 on 365rider and UPS Express costed only like usd 10 to my country (actually i shared shipping with another shoe so that's only usd 5 in reality). PS. Colourway and overall design is the best out there of any shoe, IMO.....so that's another +ve point. Sometimes i use it as a sneaker during shopping lol.
I have the endorphin pro's, and I regularly get 300~ miles on them.
Thx. Well done Mate!!!
My endorphin pro2 would be perfect if only it would be more grippe on wet. But love to run with them on dry
Have the Speed 3 best shoe (for me) just set a big 5k PB in them
i wonder why saucony is not changing the outsole in endorphin series when that is the complain of most. great on dry conditions but terrible when wet
I have the Speed 3’s and at first I was a little disappointed because I like my Novablast 3’s much more. There was something about the Speed 3’s that felt different. However, I am starting to come around. I think that part of me felt that the Speed 3’s are too light. I might be changing my mind about which shoe I like more. Now that I am getting used to them.
I'm very happy with my Puma Velocity Nitro 2 but I wonder if I should have payed a bit more to get the Deviate Nitro 2 instead ... I got the Adidas Adizero Boston 11 and would love to see comparisons bettewn it and these other shoes you have showed in this video !
RunnerIn has crazy discounts on runnings shoes.I picked up a pair of Deviate Nitro 2 for $128 after taxes and shipping
What about sizing on Puma as compared to boston 11?
@@wasifali1326 For Adidas I use all of their running shoes in the same 8.5 US size, and that includes the Boston 11 or the Ultraboost 22.
While for Puma ,the size 8.5 was not available and so I got the size 9 US and it worked well for me,just a tinny bit long but comfortably snug all around like I love a running shoe to fit my feet.
Puma DN2 is having a Big Sale in our country converting it only cost 92$ if converted to USD. But I just bought a new pair of shoes. Shoes are over the place. Is this an addiction? 😅
Puma as it's the best allrounder with better grip, stability, looks and price compared to the Speed 3, doesn't sacrifice anything meaningful to me (not looking for max perf in a training shoe)
I've tried the Speed 3, owned the Speed 2 and today I ran on ICE with the Pumas..
what best daily trainer shoes for u (not plated)? many thanks!
Endorphin speed 3 fan here. I just wish they had more grip as well.
Ive got the Deviate Nitro 2 and the Endorphin Speeds but not the Nike. It was interesting to compare the Puma's with the Endorphins since people have been saying they are very similar. Just coming back from injury so havn't used the Endorphins for a while. Went for a short run in the Puma's yesterday and really enjoyed them very comfortable if slightly on the heavy side. The Endorphins definitely feel much lighter on foot and have a more of a shoe that's suitable for racing. The Endorphins are still my favourite shoe of all time so much so that i bought 3 pairs of version one. I shall be using the Puma's for shorter runs.
Hi Keith, did you get the same size in the Puma as the speeds? Cheers
@@user-mc5ru2to8p yes i got a UK 7.5 in both shoes although strangely the Puma's are EU41 and are more on the snug side but still comfortable. I have a slightly wider foot than normal.
@@keithisaacs6092 thanks for that, I am a UK 9 in the speed 2 so I reckon the 9 will be fine in the Puma.
Puma 2 feel great and springy and that's just walking, probably the most comfortable trainer I've had more so than the boost.
Deviate or velocity? I’m training for Ironman
My mind is getting completely blown with the speed shoes.. my current endorphin speed 2’s are coming to the end of their lifespan.
Looking for a shoe that is specifically for hill sprints, intervals and speed work track/treadmill
Any suggestions please to Ben and the knowledgeable runners that follow him
For hill sprints and speed work, I would imagine you want a lightweight / fast show - you really can't go wrong with the Endorphin Speed 3 - you can grab them for about £120 online if you shop around. Saucony aren't releasing the Speed 4 until Spring 2024. Being an owner of the Speed 2s, you should really enjoy the step up in the Speed 3s.
Fastest ? Nike Tempo Next ! I have the Speed 2 and Zoom Fly 3. ZF3 was my favorite shoe before other plated shoes were released. I think they are great for slower runs, they are quite comfy and have a good amount of cushioning. But I usually like to run faster so I now prefer Tempo Next and Speed 2. Speed 2 feels more natural but also offer less cushioning so #1 is Tempo Next for me .. at least for now. Also Tempo Next is relatively similar to Alphafly so it seems logical to train in a similar shoe as the one I will be racing with. The main negatives about Tempo Next is that they are not so great a slower pace imho and with all the cushioning and technologies, I'm not sure they are the best to help maintain a good overall fitness.
Interesting. So far in my research the Deviate Nitro has edged out the Speed 3. The feedback seems to be that the Speed 3 is pretty meh compared to the Speed 1, and the Deviate Nitro is filling in the gap that the Speed 1 left. So a bit surprising to see Ben going with the Speed 3 here, but it goes to show that different shoes work for different feet.
Watched last night, but just seen the thumbnail again. Is the ordering of the shoes like the medal rostrum of gold, silver & bronze subconscious or purposeful? 🤣
We made the cover photo last week.. a long time before the review!
@@BenParkes ah subconscious then spooky 🤣
You’re holding up the Deviate Nitro ELITE 1 not the previous Deviate Nitro model.
I was about to say the same thing. Deviate Nitro Elite is a completely different animal, and light as a feather.
Yes, I've messed up there. Picked up the wrong shoe for the video and Puma being still a bit new to me I didn't realise. Apologies.
Eagle eyes out there. Still a great video though!
Spot on
Faltan las reinas .
ADIDAS BOSTON 12
I’ve got some Nike Pegasus 37 which I quite like but I only run for 5 or 6 k at a time.
If ONLY Saucony would fix the outsole rubber grip, which is atrocious on wet pavement, the Endorphin Speed would be perfect and I wouldn't buy anything else. Hard to believe they haven't fixed this huge problem with now three versions of the Speed.
No need to spend that much money on the Puma Deviate Nitro 2. Just volunteer at 2022 Weltklasse Zürich Wanda Diamond League Meet and get it for free in your official volunteer uniform.
i absolutely love that shoe in terms of its versatility, comfort feel and stability. Maybe one of the best shoes i have ever had in my Rotation.
Nike shoes are not durable at all. Just picked up the speed 3, feels comfortable but ive got so many shoes already only thing i dont like are the stretchy laces though.
Agree… I got a PUNCTURE in the air pocket of my alphaflys!!
Thnx for pointing that out. I also really dislike stretchy laces, too, as well as stretchy shoes in general. Would be nice if such aspects were mentioned in reviews.
I think it just depends on the model. I wouldn't particularly trust anything with an air bubble so that rules out the Alphafly and Pegasus models. My pair of vaporflys though has so far held up extremely well over the first 100 miles, almost no noticeable wear on the outsole, and I've seen people even put 500-600 miles and they still hold up pretty well
I kinda like the laces, but I hate it when it gets caught up with your fingernails
i have the zoom fly 3 that has lasted about 600km and recently got the pegasus 39 last week and no signs of wear after about 50km (i know it’s not much) and also my streakflys have been surprisingly durable although i don’t know how far i’ve ran in the because it’s only on the occasional workouts and races but they have had at least 75km + i think
I like Puma.....
PUMA was the surprise shoe my feet enjoyed best, saucing was close Nike was a joke, the shoe made a popping noise each time I walked on a hard surface? I don’t know what it was put it was so bad I through them out, later to find out others were complaining about the same thing worst shoe I ever purchased
What the ES3 has a plate? Never feel it😂
it's there mostly to give some stability. I'm not sure it does much tbh... :D but I can't really tell 100% because I rarely push it beyond 3:30/km.
The speed2s were great. But I have no aspirations to buy the speed3s, not at the current price. Nike, those are bricks. The pumas seem to be the potential winner as much love that they have received. Can't find them here in the U.S. to save my life.
I ordered another pair of Speed 2 on discount over the summer for when the current pair die (currently 400 miles), I’m sure I’m going to get much extra from the Speed 3.
@@vincewarne228 I literally just hit 400 miles in my speed2s this week. They are still in great shape but definitely not anywhere near as good as the were in the first 200 miles. Outsole is in excellent condition. I'm not a lazy runner so I'm pretty easy on outsoles. The midsole has become very soft. I can compare them to the midsole of my pro2 which have about 130 miles on them and there is a big difference. All in all still my favorite shoe and will keep them around for shorter faster stuff but anything over 8 miles leads to some foot and calf discomfort which I'm not experiencing in some of my newer tempo based shoes.
Puma is def $200 American and the Saucony is $160
I think you confused the deviate nitro elite 1 with the deviate nitro 2. One is a racer, the other is the speed trainer.
Yes, I've messed up there. Picked up the wrong shoe for the video and Puma being still a bit new to me I didn't realise. Apologies.
REPLY
The Zoom Fly 5 is a heavy brick with a Carbon plate. One of the worst shoes of 2022. The Deviate Nitro 2 looks good, going to grab me a pair soon.
Is this now becoming a comedy channel? "3 market leading plated training shoes, the Nike Zoom Fly 5..." is a good one, or did you mean to say 2 market leading plated trainer and one from Nike? ;-) Previous Speeds were too unstable for me, but the Nike Tempo works well for me, Speed 3 seems more stable but then the Pro 3 felt even better, but also much more expensive than the Speed which is not cheap to start with. I eventually got a Pro 2 with a good discount and use that as a speed trainer next to the Nike Tempo and (non-plated) True Motion Solo (which by the way could be a great shoe to review for you).
pee-u-ma? 🤣
99% of CZcamsr dont talk about the current slavery agenda 2030
Your point is ?
??? Shoes, my friend.
@@apoa334 I'm talking about your end of life before 2030 - dont you see people already dying everywhere? Shame on people not talking about the current slavery agenda - see my home page
Nobody needs plated shoes unless you are a professional runner who needs a new PB…
pumas nitro line is so underrated !!!
Just started watching 2 seconds in and i know that you will choose saucony