what Noam is saying is summed up in a few words by Samuel Huntington: “The West won the world not by the superiority of its ideas or values or religion (to which few members of other civilizations were converted) but rather by its superiority in applying organized violence. Westerners often forget this fact; non-Westerners never do.” - Samuel Huntington, The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order, page 51
Why easterns don’t hate Arabs who changed the identity and names completely even their ethnicity name and made them backwards ? I’m Saudi btw if the westerns and their civilisations bad they no one think of running and living among them.
Revolutionary Rabbit Dude why waste the 30 minutes? You don’t think this other guy has Google? It’s called purposeful/intentional ignorance. It’s a regurgitated trope-sound byte. “Muslims waged bloody war for thousands of years, and we brought the world civility.” “Jews have been kicked out of every country they’ve ever been in. I’m sure there’s no good reason for that LOL.” People, especially on CZcams, are going to regurgitate this absolute nonsense. But I will commend you for what I perceive to be accuracy, willingness to cite sources to support your claims, and taking the time. I just doubt it will have been well spent.
I'm from Somalia I don't hate American,British,French,German citizens what I don't like is their governments which interfere in our country everytime we try to rebuild we are blocked from moving forward ❤
@@yurinator6380 You can say lol as much as you like but let me teach only one example kid. In 2002 to 2003 the westren governments were fuding somali warlords to fight terrorism. Do you know what those warlords were doing in somalia before the funding ? Massacring entire clans and then westren govs were like we will fund them and we don’t care what they are doing to their people as long as they are doing our job. So learn before you talk kid.
What he is saying is true..but we have a problem tolerating other people's religions and opinions. We have a problem with tolerance and accepting difference.
@@markkuuss The middle East did not have an issue with tolerance. Once Western powers came to the middle East they created false divisions between the people of the middle East.
@@haltdieklappe7972 who said I support biden? And don't get me started on Hilary. I think the one I liked the most was bernie sanders. Edit: yup, out of all the candidates, I (a muslim) prefer the one who was raised a jew.
As a Tunisian, I do not hate Western people I worked in tourism as a tour guide and had friendships with the French, Germans, and people from Eastern Europe and Scandinavian countries. But I strongly hate Western governments, or most of them, especially the governments of France, Britain, America, and Germany, and their entire political system. Since my childhood, I remember the first shock in my life seeing Israeli planes and tanks storming and destroying the Jenin camp in the Second Palestinian Intifada of 2000. And all of this with absolute American support Then I saw the American invasion of Iraq in 2004, and despite my hatred for Saddam Hussein, I hoped that the Iraqi people would change him and not change him by destroying the country, killing hundreds of thousands of Iraqis, and giving Iraq to Iran. Then, in 2008,2012 2014 2018 2021 2022 and 2023 I saw the Israeli aggression against Gaza, and I saw the most horrific massacres, with absolute and unlimited American support, against a people with primitive weapons. As for France, I will not forget its intervention in my country, Tunisia, especially after the 2011 revolution. It tried with all its might to weaken Tunisia and thwart the democratic path by carrying out assassinations and trying to create strife in my country. To this day, France controls Tunisia and prevents any attempt to establish a true democratic state. I swear that since I began to rise above the world, I hear daily in the news about Israel’s crimes against the Palestinians Every day I hear about the killing of Palestinian children and women at the hands of the Zionist army to the point that it has become normal news and I am not affected by it. On the other hand, I do not see any American pressure on Israel to stop building settlements. On the contrary, it supports it even though it knows that it is an illegitimate state. But when I read history, I knew that the only way for the Palestinians is resistance and more resistance And there is no liberation without pain The West only wants its interests. It is enough that the two most prominent candidates for the presidency of America, Trump and Biden, and despite their differences on all issues, the two strongly support Israel. Both of them still think with the mentality of white man supremacy Despite everything Biden claims that he supports human rights But it turns out that all the principles Biden claims are lies, with the screams and corpses of Gaza’s children
Well, basically colonialism still exist and they don't label them as such, what US and France have been doing are no difference than a century or two ago.
Btw both Biden and Trump are total aholes, they are too old and incompetent anyway. Not just them, but half Black Obama also supported evil Israel. Politicians are worse than Kings.
It is so refreshing to hear the real truth about U.S. involvement in world affairs. I get so disgusted with hearing this sickening propaganda about countries hating this country for reasons that make no sense whatsoever. Chomsky is a breath of fresh air.
Exactly. Hating us for our freedom? IV traveled abroad and saw many places with much more freedom than the US. But to a huge population that think they have it the best, it must seam like a threat if countries are jealous, who could just change their own laws if they really wanted them.
Sadly, the "real truth" about Israeli involvement in world affairs is not so pleasant either! Same with the "real truth" about British involvement! Russia and China (despite both being openly authoritarian nations) are also both famous for telling a very one-sided story to the "rest of the world" to cover up their attacks on human rights! Both the Russian and Chinese governments (sadly the Americans, British, and Israelis all are guilty of this too, and I suspect the Indians are as well) have conveniently used "radical Islam" as a boogeyman to distract from their abuses of human rights, which historically have included war crimes! Interestingly, despite America's abuse of power in the Middle East, CANADA surprisingly has taken a very different approach to foreign policy... but what's funny is that both the American and Canadian governments declined to support the joint British/French/Israeli occupation of EGYPT during the SUEZ CRISIS back in 1956! Starting with America joining the Vietnam War though (not too long after the Suez Crisis) Canada has generally supported peacekeeping efforts around the world, while America sadly has taken a very different approach...
Let's put blame where it belongs: the US fossil fuel industry. Even today, the fossil fuel industry has the most influence over politics than anyone else. The primary constituent of the Republican party is the fossil fuel industry. The US political system is pretty much run by the fossil fuel industry and their chosen representatives, like Joe Manchin. Joe Manchin himself is a wealthy coal plant owner, and regularly meets with Exxon. The reason the US is so corrupt is because companies have taken over the political system.
The real truth? The Arab and Ottoman empires did the same to other parts of the world and it happens to you now and you cry? Let us stop the hypocrisy!
“After operation desert storm ended, i have always wondered why we left the dictator in charge even while his military was defeated. Now I know, the top brass knew we would need another profitable war in a decade or so....” -unnamed US veteran.
No try this instead...it is because there would be a vaccum of power and Muslim factions of Shia and Sunni powers as well as terrorists, as well as Iran, which fought Iraq (1980-1988) who would love that. We saw this happen irregardless after Operation Iraqi Freedom. Oh, I'm also a Veteran, who served in the wars and it was my job to understand this as a military intelligence officer. These are complex issues. The fact that some people profit off war and other groups exploit war (terrorism) are two different issues which are also complicated.
Scott Moresh See that’s what I thought too at the start. Yet we had no problem installing a pro US government every time we fight. Like we did in Afghan later on. We let the dictator keep his power to avoid a power vacuum? Then did we not have a plan for an alternative when we went in? Or was Saddam still on CIA payroll that we could use him? Regardless of which, what we cannot deny is that a second invasion was necessary and killing the dictator that we had every opportunity to remove earlier was sold to us as the goal.
ahmed hussein The issue is that whether or not a dictator steps out of line is both predictable and secondary. If geopolitical interests stands in favour of a war, no one is not expendable. Regardless if we supported a dictator or not, whether there were atrocities, whether there were humanitarian crisis, if a war is desirable it will be so. The difference is merely how easily it could be sold to the public.
He is called an extremist and a traitor but there is nothing to argue about here. He's just a remover of sugar coatings. His radicalism is basically that he supports transparent and honest democracy. I suppose that makes him a dangerous man.
As a "middle eastern..." That can mean alot of things... Which country, and which religion? The middle east is diverse. There are Sunni Muslims, Shia Muslims, other Muslim sects, Christians (and their denominations), Jews (and their denominations). There is no group of people known as "the middle east." Middle Easterners feel differently according to their individual group interests.
There are over 50 minorities in the middle east, you are quite spot ok, it is very diverse To be specific, I think the audience who have strong relationship with the west either as an ally or enemy are the ones who are rich with oil and other important resources, which draws the west to them
USA isn’t responsible for holding back the Middle East. That’s such silly bs. Thanks to USA the Middle East is richer than ever, with more vaccines and iPhones and CZcams and cars. The main victims of Islamic Fascism are your fellow middle easterners. Osama’s hatred of the west is as insane as his hatred of Shiite or Jews.
Yes people are ignorant. MOst leftist doesnt recognize that Assad Iran and Russia has destroyed Syria in tandem with Daesh. They blame Usa as if the destruction of Syria by these actors was selfdefense agianst Usa . Thats sick.
As an American in todays world, I just wish we would withdraw from the world, come home and take care of our own people. We have millions laying in the street homeless. And , the American worker is exhausted and we don’t have decent healthcare. All the American worker has to look forward to is bankruptcy.
The average American believes that he or she lives in the greatest country ever. Many are poorly educated to a decree that would simply astound most ordinary individuals with access to a reasonable education & or the internet & who are also curious about the world around them & its history. In the USA media organisations such as TV news & newspapers etc owned by corporations & the super rich have controlled a considerable percentage of the voting adult population, their minds & opinions etc since even before the First World War using a government supported Propaganda apparatus that was the envy of the old soviet empire. The arts, literature & music were all used for propaganda purposes. Joseph Gobbels & the Nazi party we’re avid students of the propaganda machines of Great Britain & the USA. A lot of people, especially in the USA, fail to understand that the only reason their country is top dog is because of its geopolitical & strategic position in this world & of course, it’s a big, big country with a big, big population. A big, big population of taxpayers & consumers. America has the biggest prison population per capita of anywhere in the world, literally millions & millions of Americans are homeless, living in squalor, tents, cars, the insides of sewers or Freeway flyovers or in the gutter & millions & millions of Americans can’t even get basic health care. If they have Cancer, MS, arthritis, they are doomed, I could go on & on, but I’ll end here. Despite all the wars all over the world that the Americans have fought in, despite the hundreds of thousands of 18, 19, 20 & 21 year olds & the rest who have been sent to die for America in foreign wars & despite the millions of Iraqis, Syrians, Afghans, Vietnamese, Indonesians, south & Central American’s, Koreans & Chinese & all the rest slaughtered by Americans in the name of Freedom & hotdogs… Americans really & truly excel in slaughtering Americans, they’ve killed more of each other by far than any foreign enemy or terrorist or whatever they want to call them. Yes, Bouslama Karin, I find it hilarious & tragic that many an ordinary US citizen would think anybody but the most desperate would envy them a place in such an unfair, racist, bigoted, violent & bitterly divided, police state.
@@flemhawker9134 Hi Thanks for the enlightening answer. The US is of course enviable for many things let's be honest but what I meant is that the Western way of life is often portrayed as the model for the whole world to follow. Here in Tunisia we have more or less adopted the western way of life since the 1950's but it has also clashed with traditional values of the population and now with the rise of political Islam we have the back clash against this rapid westernisation. I did my MA thesis on Globalisation of Culture so I can say I studied that quite a lot. Many Europeans and Americans when you talk to them think that people from other countries should be grateful to change their culture which is outdated and adopt the western way of life which is In.
@@thelovertunisia Everyone loves the western world, nobody that immigrated here wants to leave. Countries with religion ruling are hellholes (atleast for people with another religion). You wouldn't want to move to countries with dictators. Western world is too much freedom, that's why everyone loves it. But western world still exploits poor people. We live in luxury while others are being exploited. Eventually there is no perfect place, but the western world is still most loved
@@slupschuiters1774 Well you should take this idea with a pinch of salt. I am half German half Tunisia so I know both worlds well and I assure you it is not as simple as you think. What you see as positive is not universal.
Frankly speaking I don’t see anything objectionable to the idea that non westerners should be grateful for at least the core principles of the western civilisation (freedom of thought, speech, religion, ownership, movement, etc, republicanism ; the idea that the people ought to be involved in matters of the state, capitalism, which is just derived from the aforementioned freedom but is nonetheless very important, equality before the law, empiricism, etc). The lack of all those, admittedly in varying degrees, is a constant throughout traditional societies, including pre 1800s western civilisation and what still lingers of that era in the current western civilisation, and is demonstrably harmful, so yeah I’d say non westerners should happily embrace those values if only for their own sake. Now of course having McDonalds is not anything to be proud of but honestly I don’t know any westerner that’d claim that it is either ^^’
This is amazing example of a human being , a scientist who is commited to telling the truth , so refreshing and relieving hearing that even therapeutic . Thank you sir
Dear author of the video, I added Spanish subtitles to the video so it can be easily enjoyed in Latin America, Spain, etc., even by the people that does not speak English. I think you need to aprove the translation, somehow. I have tried to communicate with you privately but I do not know how. Thank you very much for your attention, and for the upload, Best regards, S.H
@@intranext1359 not necessarily, when your country is getting needed resources from another country and that country goes into conflict, it would be hard to get those resources. For instance, America relies on palm oil and other natural resources from other countries that cannot grow here due to our climate being different. If South America were to have a social conflict and could not give us our palm oil, we’d intervene in order to get our palm oil. In the age of globalization where we get a lot of resources from other countries that either have the resource and we don’t/we cannot grow it due to our resources, it’s hard not not intervene when we have a clear motivation to.
@@qqfuwu1 yeah but to intervene to restore order not cause more chaos (iraq for example) 2. America did not need Iraqi oil since they already had Saudi Arabia trading with them
@@WhyTheHorsefacebut you havent really have you. If you look at the western controlled media that is actually pushed and influences, take cnn or fox news, you will never see this man let alone here his name
He spreads lies. His analysis of the situation is on a simple and childlike level. The problem is much deeper than he says. The problem is not that the United States influences the countries' policies. The problem is that countries are so corrupt and dysfunctional, and that's why the United States can influence. The influence of the United States is not the problem, it is the symptom.
@@niklasmolen4753 part of what u said is true , but world war 1 and 2 wasnt started by any islamic or middle eastern countries , and many mid/islamic countries were destroyed cause of that , the french/british/german... Colonization of africa is still active till now , u cant advance when you are imposed and forced to follow laws that r made to secure colonizers interest so you are doomed , no islamic country is allowed to implement sharia (law) , if they do as u probably think , they ll be called terrorists oppressors..all kind of bad wrong names as most westerners think and usa ll bomb them(like iraq) , and sharia if u study history is what lead non arabic and arabic countries to develop for like 1200 years , and jews or christian were never oppressed under islamic sharia , look for so called (golden age) were christian and jews and muslims under islamic law (sharia) were contributing in science , poetry , astronomy...etc , in peace and harmony , and of course u can have wars every nation deffend itself and what it think is right , till the end of time , thats how humans are , but people need to study and get to know the truth , who's wrong from right , and...the meaning of life is somewhere there awaiting cause no matter what u do , conflict is always present between humans from ur family to the gouvermant.
@@joundi007 Africa has always been underdeveloped and corrupt. Sometimes individual nations have reached international standards, but then always because of a strong and good leader. After his death, the empire shrank until it was just an ordinary part of corrupt Africa. There are many misconceptions about colonial times in Africa. More money went into Africa than out. Security and stability were higher during the colonial era. On the whole, the people were better off during the colonial era than after. Today's problems have very little to do with colonial times. Islam began to stagnate in the 13th century with Al Ghazali and has never recovered since. Almost all prominent Islamic scientists came from recently conquered areas. Areas that were Muslim for a long time have hardly produced any science of their own. Islam was tolerant until quite recently. It was as Saudi Arabia's money grew that Islamic intolerance grew. They spread their Salafism which causes Islam to come into conflict with everyone else, even with the more liberal Muslims. Since there is no successful / well-functioning Muslim country, there must be some serious problem with Islam. Exactly what it is I have not understood.
In fact they are the ones being manipulated (I mean the masses) they send off their children to fight in wars that only profit the leading minority , wars that are funded with their tax dollars. While most of them have no access to free education nor free healthcare. All that to defend themselves from made up enemies fabricated by their agencies.
Except that it's utter bullshit. The hate every civilization that supplanted theirs as the intellectual leaders of the world. Well, what should they expect when they stopped even trying four or five centuries ago? When you see an Iranian news service in Iran taking video of Iranian women in Burkas raising both fists and shouting "Death To America", you should really get half a clue.
I've said this for the last 30 years! America is getting really scary to live in because there's so much evil we can not avoid. I'd rather hide in my house, away from the ways of the American ways. ( If that makes any sense)
The British were cruel, but the Hindus radical ideology and bad attitude had STILL made it important for Muslims to form a Muslim state. So not only British meddling, the Hindus extremism also contributed to the division of the subcontinent. Our Muslim forefathers were left with no choice. Jinnah was not a divisive individual, he knew what the Muslims needed.
I never worry about foreign threats, the domestic ones consume all of my fears and anxiety. "Foreigners" don't make my life impossible to live. The US banking system and corporations do. Like Perry Farrell said, "they are either trying to steal your money, or steal your fun". The reality is, it's both!
Hi Edriss, I've been trying to fight for you, as a software developer, not robbing you from every penny and right.... Guess where it has brought me... Right by your side... Still... And I'm a westerner... I hate my culture and it's past. I mean... Nobody is perfect, but, the filth... The stench... it's drenched and I don't know where to look some times... I'm disgusted by my people, my brother... Hope are you doing well... ❤
Why easterns don’t hate Arabs who changed the identity and names completely even their ethnicity name and made them backwards ? I’m Saudi btw if the westerns and their civilisations bad then no one think of running and living among them.
Im glad he also mentioned the Dutch, its a small country landmass wise; but they have their fingers in a lot of pies despite their "goody two shoes" image of eve. Not mention, a lot of important families (with ruthless reputations) are Dutch or have a Dutch heritage.
And this is wonderful about the US, which he constantly rants against. Imagine him teaching in Iran, Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, even in the Palestinian territories and constantly criticizing his government, calling it criminal. He'd be long dead.
Yes, correct. Although it is odd that the USA - the greatest exponent of Realpolitik in history - still has this weird obsession about being liked, and being seen as in the "right". No previous empire has ever been so concerned about its reputation: power is its own justification. And "Snook On the fly" is also correct: most people in the world are charming, helpful and considerate. They want to live their lives, bring up their kids, don't hate people on sight and operate very much on the idea "live and let live". Politics has much to answer for: and we should be seriously questioning why governments seem to be run by the worst of us, not the best.
"...it is odd that the USA - the greatest exponent of Realpolitik in history - still has this weird obsession about being liked, and being seen as in the "right". No previous empire has ever been so concerned about its reputation: power is its own justification." Never thought of that. Thanks man!
That is such an asinine take, previous empires didn’t have stuff like the UN or NATO to cater to and no true rival or significant opponent to care about in the way the US has to. The only exception being nations or people with a hegemon, which is exactly what the US have, ie not a political but a diplomatic and cultural empire. It’s not exactly a new concept that if you have to choose between love and fear, you have to choose fear, but if you don’t have to then you ought to have both, so it’s no surprising that the US chooses to have both, even aside from the very obvious fact that… The US also has to appeal to its own people more than any previous empire, so it helps being seen as right even from an internal standpoint. And all of that is not even discussing the even more basic idea that nobody likes to think of himself as the bad guy, so of course everybody wants to be seen as the good guy as much as possible.
@@nathanjora7627 you need to read up on some history you don't think the Greeks empires we equal to the persons or the Roman's in its early days to the Greeks or the Carthage Ian's. The argue that these dead Empires that had fallen did not have worthy Rivals is laughable how the f*** do you think these Empires fell the Greeks used to invade the Romans that's why the Romans developed the military that made them such successful conquerors in the first place and then the Romans fell to the Goths ... your stupid please reproduce if you already have it beyond your child and please stop voting
Lets just say that convinving people from and out of your empire that you are the moral highground is a great way to get support from people that otherwise doesnt really care about material possesion or social and relationship, some people are more about the ideology, wich is what the USA sells to the rest of the world
Thank you Professor Chomsky for always speaking the truth even when it isn't popular to do so against your own government. On behalf of Muslims worldwide, we thank you for always speaking the truth.
Its not true that Usa destroyed Syria. Its not true that the worst war in Afghanistans was the one Usa brought. The Russian was ten times worse. Its not True that Usa attacked Russia this winter. But it is to Chomsky because he is not a political scientist. He is a politician,
You know what is really hard to understand and it's scary , is that hundreds of people don't believe this to be true. How can so many dislikes be given , do these people live under a rock!?
We do not hate you, we just need to be free, live happily, see our kids grow up; not to grow up oppressed by people you bring in power, you kill people in our countries again and again, some people are tired of asking 'why?' and started to say 'enough!'
@@Vinny00754 would you support western countries give eastern countries wheat for free? that's a dumb question, my friend, I have something you need you pay for it or exchange, take it by force as it's being done like now, and ... you see the result.
@@ibrahimN17 Is it a dumb question if your response is exactly what I am looking for? You answered the “why?” with your response to my question. That is, we do what is best for us. Sometimes that is pay, sometimes it is exchange, and sometimes it is take by force. Which one is chosen by out leaders is the one which benefits us the most, all things considered. The reason some people are saying “enough” is because they are finally realizing this and understanding they need to create a power symmetry or continue to lose at the hands of those stronger than them. Good luck to them and may the best men win.
@@Vinny00754 then enough with the hypocrisy and lying, they aren't the free world, they aren't the guardians of morals, they are lying thieves, with no bottom line, the worst nation the world has ever seen. so, no wonder then we abhor them, those people should stop asking "Why do they hate us!".
I'm sick of being outraged and disheartned by the facts and doing nothing about it, I'm going to write a letter to the Minister of Foreign Affairs and make my voice known.
@June Osborne I can relate to you in that. I am 55 as well! ( Congratulations)🥂 Stumbled upon The Majority Report 4 years ago. The late (RIP) Micheal Brooks- discussing foreign policy . Eloquent, smart, multiple perspectives, fact checked with thing I'd ever heard on CZcams. Been a member ever since. Sam Seder, Emma V..they're funny as well. COVID-19? They were ahead of everything- and proven correct in numerous issues. If you like Professor Chomsky who is the man. Well researched facts- not interpreting, twisting ,omitting.. ☑️Check out The Majority Report. With 30 years of NY Times, New Yorker magazine(8 year subscriber), Newsweek, daily MSNBC.. Thought I was informed. I was, but within how they framed coverage or reported issues. Manufactured Consent. Part of the machine. Obama's horrificness never ever covered. Many other omissions. Even in Obituaries. I've found lies in Washington Post videos after researching them. Billionaire Bezos owns that paper. So there you go. If everyone knew ( or cared like you do) the how much BS they're being fed, which feeds there opinions and their vote, this country would be hell of a lot more like what The Constitution intended.
@@Medium341 That's because thru the 90s, I was too busy with the nervous breakdown part of my life. You don't know me and people like you say things like that to make yourself feel superior to others online which is pathetic.
And when it is said to them: "Make not mischief on the earth," they say: "We are only peacemakers." Verily! They are the ones who make mischief, but they perceive not. (Quran 2:11-12)
He missed an important factor. What one group thinks is an obvious right, the other thinks is a crime, and vice versa. They have basic values that are so different from each other that they can never live side by side.
@Artistic Projects In the West, we think that homosexuals should be allowed to marry each other and live in peace. In the Arab world, they think you should kill homosexuals. In the West, we think that all children should listen to female teachers. People from the Middle East do not think it is necessary to listen or respect female teachers (of course not all, but so many that it is a serious problem). In the West, we think that politicians and religious leaders should be joked about. In Muslim countries, it is normal to punish someone for such jokes, even the death penalty.
Samuel Clowntington claims that it's the other way around: that Religious extremism starts rising first in places like Saudi Arabia and Tunisia and the west is the reactionary. In reality the us supported theocracies all around the middle east against Secular nationalism because Secular nationalism leads to independence and you can't let that happen if you want to rule the world.
To overthrow Iran's PM Mohammed Mossadegh in 1953, the CIA funded specific Islamic clergy along with the Shah's goons, especially a certain young individual named Ruhollah Khomeini
Noam Chomsky is a gift of sanity in this world., I'm not saying he's perfect. But his knowledge and accuracy in presenting subjects that need presenting....and which we just won't get on the national news ...is astonishing.
Watching this as gaza is being bombed is very surreal. It feels like a dystopian omen at times, we have this information available to us at a mass scale but it doesn’t prevent the few in power from carrying out their planned actions.
My parents revolted against shah of Iran, it is common knowledge that shah of Iran was heavily tied to the US. However, when shah was trying to be independent, and build nukes and started to increase the price of oil. Thats when the revolution happened. After all khomeini was for a period in paris then moved to turkey. And when shah fled, khomeini immediately entered and the revolution happened. However, there was Iraq vs Iran war that adds complexity. My parents who are very political and lived and observed through the period told me US installed khomeini. Why would there be tons of sanctions on IR and yet they were installed by the US? Have they gain their independence? Everything american is not accessible in Iran. So what is the benefit for the US to have one of the most anti-american government in the region? It is very known that in earlier years of Islamic Republic they had dealings with the republican party of the US. However, what doesnt make sense to me is US has tons of satellite channels to advertise its agenda against IR. And believe it or not these had affected the protests in recent years. So Iran does sell oil to the world. But our government hasnt used this industry to progress our nation. It has become a super market. Most of the budget is spent on military because we are one of the most threatened country in the world, constantly in the fear of being bombed. But make no doubt, vast majority of middle easterners hate the US government. The sheer amount of interference, no matter for what reason has caused us to hate the US. And there is support of Israel of course.
It was not the republicans, it was the liberal carter administration that coordinated Khomenis return and cooperated with him. Not to mention, Kennedy, another liberal, also wanted to depose the shah by organizing the 1963 protests, but he changed his mind afterwards. Otherwise nice comment. By the way, for anyone wondering about the factuality of these claims just good jimmy carter and khomeni and you will find plenty evidence. The documents have already been released a while back and BBC even covered this in 2016.
+TheJimmax Keep them well fed, watered and entertained and your slaves won't care about the murder of other people. How could the same system that offers me a Big Mac and plenty of TV with a big smile, be the same system that's killing thousands abroad?
Whatever agrees with you is clear, whatever does not is wrong-headed if not downright reprehensible. I'm saying nothing whatsoever against him, only noting that our moral and intellectual evaluations tend to colored by subjective considerations.
@@zarathustravideo That in itself I do not find strange at all. I'm subjectively familiar with the phenomenon. If one believed that it were invariably a bad thing, and tried to root it out through ruthless self-examination, the exercise would soon prove tiresome and futile.
They tried, but the majority of the media is controlled by corporations that also influence the government and its policies. Not to mention Western media dominates the world, 80% of it. Its unlikely news and information like this gets spread to the world. Mainstream media dictates how people process and prefer information. People see anti muslim, anti china video title they are likely to click it, the same cannot be said for "why they hate the west".
To answer your question, look at Assange, truth tellers get thrown in Jail. America is not a Democracy, it is controlled by Corporations, who control the Govt, who control the people, who control the voters. Anyone can see how corrupt politicians are in America, Australia, Britain etc, yet they keep voting for the same people. Look at this video, 4 years up and only 262K+ views, yet watch an American sprouting hatred against Muslims and it has 5 million views in a month. I forget who said it, but he stated, "I can convince 1 man with logic, but I can convince 1000 with their own prejudices". And that is so True, look at Trumps base, they are getting screwed but still believe they are winning.
Bruh… « moderate Muslim » is what every western imperialist wants you to be, which means not a Muslim… You are responsible for what happens in Palestine, what happened in Irak and what will continue to happen Except if you’re able to give me an explanation of what « moderate Muslim » is for you, if it’s reasonable I’ll retire my comment
I am thankful for freedom of speech, to being able to understand how people feel through this forum of understanding on youtube... I am thankful for Noam Chomsky's insights. Without this, I would be confused and scared , because propaganda is not a substitute for human understanding, it is an excuse for retaining privileges by people who are dogmatic.
😂😂😂😂 sad to see westerners be embedded by these so called « values », the very fact that it’s something so meaningful for you shows that the West always had, and still has a big problem with « freedom of speech » otherwise it wouldn’t be so important for you.
Oh, it has now. We are in 2023, and China (PRC) is incontestably the biggest bully on the block. Russia is freely expressing the glories of its culture in Ukraine, with the help of robed Iranian clerics and their fleet of drones. The isolationist Trump is running again for prez. You must be over the moon with delight. The accession of Finland to membership in NATO is the one sour note in your happy tune.
*shakes head* Everything was set in motion long before any of that and even before that. We are still dealing with the fallout from things that happen thousand year ago.
Joe Schmoe Yeah,but more current events,I don't agree with him on everything,but like to listen to him-he usually only does interviews that don't have interviewer's,lol
@@someoneelse.2252I don't know hombre. I don't think an avarage iq person would take his "views" seriously. It's mostly populist horse wank with shit flavour that fuck tons of uneducated fucking idiots buy into. And honestly; education is easy to come by these days. Proper morals and a decent character is what most people lack the most.
what Noam is saying is summed up in a few words by Samuel Huntington:
“The West won the world not by the superiority of its ideas or values or religion (to which few members of other civilizations were converted) but rather by its superiority in applying organized violence. Westerners often forget this fact; non-Westerners never do.”
- Samuel Huntington, The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order, page 51
Do you recall if Huntington was affirming that notion?
Huntington was also a hack
Huntington was also a proponent for the failed Neo-conservative movement/PINAC proposals and Clash of Civilizations was doomsaying nonsense.
well said ...have read his book..every person should read it
Why easterns don’t hate Arabs who changed the identity and names completely even their ethnicity name and made them backwards ? I’m Saudi btw if the westerns and their civilisations bad they no one think of running and living among them.
*"The people think the us supports evil and corrupt regimes and It's hard to counter this perception, because it's true"* - ROFL. So epic.
Revolutionary Rabbit Dude why waste the 30 minutes? You don’t think this other guy has Google? It’s called purposeful/intentional ignorance.
It’s a regurgitated trope-sound byte.
“Muslims waged bloody war for thousands of years, and we brought the world civility.”
“Jews have been kicked out of every country they’ve ever been in. I’m sure there’s no good reason for that LOL.”
People, especially on CZcams, are going to regurgitate this absolute nonsense.
But I will commend you for what I perceive to be accuracy, willingness to cite sources to support your claims, and taking the time.
I just doubt it will have been well spent.
@@definitiveentertainment1658 disagree. Extremely informative for third parties
@@revolutionaryrabbit7715 not a lot, and I say this while thinking on a global scale, are smart as you
@nationwidebw If Islam talked about Jesus 500 years before his birth, you should 💯 convert.
Same goes for each American that supports those regimes at the gas station. I'd bet Chomsky himself supported Sadam Hussein at the gas station.
I'm from Somalia I don't hate American,British,French,German citizens what I don't like is their governments which interfere in our country everytime we try to rebuild we are blocked from moving forward ❤
Lol
Get some Jews.
@@shaunstakiw2722init
There's corruption and then there's west corruption
we also hate our governments too.
lol says Somalia
@@yurinator6380
You can say lol as much as you like but let me teach only one example kid.
In 2002 to 2003 the westren governments were fuding somali warlords to fight terrorism.
Do you know what those warlords were doing in somalia before the funding ? Massacring entire clans and then westren govs were like we will fund them and we don’t care what they are doing to their people as long as they are doing our job.
So learn before you talk kid.
As a middle eastern person, this guy understands us.
Same/بتفق معك
What he is saying is true..but we have a problem tolerating other people's religions and opinions. We have a problem with tolerance and accepting difference.
@@markkuuss The middle East did not have an issue with tolerance. Once Western powers came to the middle East they created false divisions between the people of the middle East.
Yet you’d still support Biden over trump despite Biden bombing the Middle East
@@haltdieklappe7972 who said I support biden? And don't get me started on Hilary.
I think the one I liked the most was bernie sanders.
Edit: yup, out of all the candidates, I (a muslim) prefer the one who was raised a jew.
As a Tunisian, I do not hate Western people
I worked in tourism as a tour guide and had friendships with the French, Germans, and people from Eastern Europe and Scandinavian countries.
But I strongly hate Western governments, or most of them, especially the governments of France, Britain, America, and Germany, and their entire political system.
Since my childhood, I remember the first shock in my life seeing Israeli planes and tanks storming and destroying the Jenin camp in the Second Palestinian Intifada of 2000.
And all of this with absolute American support
Then I saw the American invasion of Iraq in 2004, and despite my hatred for Saddam Hussein, I hoped that the Iraqi people would change him and not change him by destroying the country, killing hundreds of thousands of Iraqis, and giving Iraq to Iran.
Then, in 2008,2012 2014 2018 2021 2022 and 2023 I saw the Israeli aggression against Gaza, and I saw the most horrific massacres, with absolute and unlimited American support, against a people with primitive weapons.
As for France, I will not forget its intervention in my country, Tunisia, especially after the 2011 revolution. It tried with all its might to weaken Tunisia and thwart the democratic path by carrying out assassinations and trying to create strife in my country.
To this day, France controls Tunisia and prevents any attempt to establish a true democratic state.
I swear that since I began to rise above the world, I hear daily in the news about Israel’s crimes against the Palestinians
Every day I hear about the killing of Palestinian children and women at the hands of the Zionist army to the point that it has become normal news and I am not affected by it.
On the other hand, I do not see any American pressure on Israel to stop building settlements. On the contrary, it supports it even though it knows that it is an illegitimate state.
But when I read history, I knew that the only way for the Palestinians is resistance and more resistance
And there is no liberation without pain
The West only wants its interests. It is enough that the two most prominent candidates for the presidency of America, Trump and Biden, and despite their differences on all issues, the two strongly support Israel.
Both of them still think with the mentality of white man supremacy
Despite everything Biden claims that he supports human rights
But it turns out that all the principles Biden claims are lies, with the screams and corpses of Gaza’s children
❤❤❤❤
Sorry, but you just showed how biased you are against non-muslim people.
@@juliankorb2848 what?? Why?
Well, basically colonialism still exist and they don't label them as such, what US and France have been doing are no difference than a century or two ago.
Btw both Biden and Trump are total aholes, they are too old and incompetent anyway. Not just them, but half Black Obama also supported evil Israel. Politicians are worse than Kings.
It is so refreshing to hear the real truth about U.S. involvement in world affairs. I get so disgusted with hearing this sickening propaganda about countries hating this country for reasons that make no sense whatsoever. Chomsky is a breath of fresh air.
Exactly. Hating us for our freedom? IV traveled abroad and saw many places with much more freedom than the US. But to a huge population that think they have it the best, it must seam like a threat if countries are jealous, who could just change their own laws if they really wanted them.
Sadly, the "real truth" about Israeli involvement in world affairs is not so pleasant either! Same with the "real truth" about British involvement! Russia and China (despite both being openly authoritarian nations) are also both famous for telling a very one-sided story to the "rest of the world" to cover up their attacks on human rights! Both the Russian and Chinese governments (sadly the Americans, British, and Israelis all are guilty of this too, and I suspect the Indians are as well) have conveniently used "radical Islam" as a boogeyman to distract from their abuses of human rights, which historically have included war crimes! Interestingly, despite America's abuse of power in the Middle East, CANADA surprisingly has taken a very different approach to foreign policy... but what's funny is that both the American and Canadian governments declined to support the joint British/French/Israeli occupation of EGYPT during the SUEZ CRISIS back in 1956! Starting with America joining the Vietnam War though (not too long after the Suez Crisis) Canada has generally supported peacekeeping efforts around the world, while America sadly has taken a very different approach...
Let's put blame where it belongs: the US fossil fuel industry. Even today, the fossil fuel industry has the most influence over politics than anyone else. The primary constituent of the Republican party is the fossil fuel industry. The US political system is pretty much run by the fossil fuel industry and their chosen representatives, like Joe Manchin. Joe Manchin himself is a wealthy coal plant owner, and regularly meets with Exxon. The reason the US is so corrupt is because companies have taken over the political system.
They hate us because we're not Muslim. It's as simple as that.
The real truth? The Arab and Ottoman empires did the same to other parts of the world and it happens to you now and you cry?
Let us stop the hypocrisy!
“After operation desert storm ended, i have always wondered why we left the dictator in charge even while his military was defeated. Now I know, the top brass knew we would need another profitable war in a decade or so....”
-unnamed US veteran.
No try this instead...it is because there would be a vaccum of power and Muslim factions of Shia and Sunni powers as well as terrorists, as well as Iran, which fought Iraq (1980-1988) who would love that. We saw this happen irregardless after Operation Iraqi Freedom. Oh, I'm also a Veteran, who served in the wars and it was my job to understand this as a military intelligence officer. These are complex issues. The fact that some people profit off war and other groups exploit war (terrorism) are two different issues which are also complicated.
Scott Moresh
See that’s what I thought too at the start. Yet we had no problem installing a pro US government every time we fight. Like we did in Afghan later on. We let the dictator keep his power to avoid a power vacuum? Then did we not have a plan for an alternative when we went in? Or was Saddam still on CIA payroll that we could use him?
Regardless of which, what we cannot deny is that a second invasion was necessary and killing the dictator that we had every opportunity to remove earlier was sold to us as the goal.
The problem is that if you remove a crazy dictator he/she is almost always replaced by a new crazy dictator.
We used Saddam to control Iran but when he or Gaddafi got out of line they were expendable.
ahmed hussein
The issue is that whether or not a dictator steps out of line is both predictable and secondary. If geopolitical interests stands in favour of a war, no one is not expendable. Regardless if we supported a dictator or not, whether there were atrocities, whether there were humanitarian crisis, if a war is desirable it will be so. The difference is merely how easily it could be sold to the public.
He is called an extremist and a traitor but there is nothing to argue about here. He's just a remover of sugar coatings. His radicalism is basically that he supports transparent and honest democracy. I suppose that makes him a dangerous man.
Something i have to think about = radicalism
And he supports that those who blindly obeys the goverment should be taken away from society! An enigma!
@@babyyoda3118 Source? What exactly did he say, and where and when did he say that?
@@jamesanthony5681 Search on his views on those didn’t follow big pharma and the goverments recommendations on vaccins!
@@babyyoda3118 ohhhh those who follow big pharma and etc... if that's true, he's right.
"When you crush people, they don't like it" Seems obvious but some people would rather defend the crushing and blame the crushed
"BuT wE aRe gIvinG you cIViliZatiOn" - said some brainwashed western citizen.
Because of western propaganda
As a middle eastern, everything he is saying is true and how we feel. Thank you Mr chomsky 🌹❤
As a "middle eastern..."
That can mean alot of things...
Which country, and which religion?
The middle east is diverse.
There are Sunni Muslims, Shia Muslims, other Muslim sects, Christians (and their denominations), Jews (and their denominations).
There is no group of people known as "the middle east."
Middle Easterners feel differently according to their individual group interests.
There are over 50 minorities in the middle east, you are quite spot ok, it is very diverse
To be specific, I think the audience who have strong relationship with the west either as an ally or enemy are the ones who are rich with oil and other important resources, which draws the west to them
USA isn’t responsible for holding back the Middle East. That’s such silly bs. Thanks to USA the Middle East is richer than ever, with more vaccines and iPhones and CZcams and cars.
The main victims of Islamic Fascism are your fellow middle easterners. Osama’s hatred of the west is as insane as his hatred of Shiite or Jews.
Yes people are ignorant. MOst leftist doesnt recognize that Assad Iran and Russia has destroyed Syria in tandem with Daesh. They blame Usa as if the destruction of Syria by these actors was selfdefense agianst Usa . Thats sick.
Who are you that's so wise in the ways of science? Did you somehow survey thousands of people in different groups
As an American in todays world, I just wish we would withdraw from the world, come home and take care of our own people. We have millions laying in the street homeless. And , the American worker is exhausted and we don’t have decent healthcare. All the American worker has to look forward to is bankruptcy.
Some may call that “karma” in a way
@@MadaraUchiha-gi1se it is called capitalism...
People who live by the sword die by the sword.
America is the richest country in the world. How that country spends it's riches defines that country.
@@RadiantStar8997 The "People" of this country ( 60%+) do not "live by the sword."
The Government / Secret Service apparatus runs the show.
His words are without deliberation or questioning. His words are brutally truthful.
Brutally lies. There corrected your idiocy.
@@buckyoung4578 dang what insightful analysis you have... if you're 12 years old
everyone should watch this...... from about 2004... nothing changes
+ED d But still comes as a surprise to most!
+ED d 2002
3200 B.C.
Well if nothing can change then why watch it? It will just make you sad.
You crush people under your boot they don’t like it. Never changes..
"They hate us because we have McDonalds" ahahaha love this
You should have said "I'm loving it!"
The irony is they have McDonalds too and they still can't be happy, those ingrates
@@concars1234 McDonalds is CRAP food, over priced sugary CRAP. And it is another sign of the West trying to dictate to them.
@@BatMan-oe2gh I was being sarcastic
They need to have a Jihad big mac :)
What I find hilarious is that many common US citizend really think that we envy them about their wonderful fast food and so on.
The average American believes that he or she lives in the greatest country ever. Many are poorly educated to a decree that would simply astound most ordinary individuals with access to a reasonable education & or the internet & who are also curious about the world around them & its history.
In the USA media organisations such as TV news & newspapers etc owned by corporations & the super rich have controlled a considerable percentage of the voting adult population, their minds & opinions etc since even before the First World War using a government supported Propaganda apparatus that was the envy of the old soviet empire. The arts, literature & music were all used for propaganda purposes. Joseph Gobbels & the Nazi party we’re avid students of the propaganda machines of Great Britain & the USA.
A lot of people, especially in the USA, fail to understand that the only reason their country is top dog is because of its geopolitical & strategic position in this world & of course, it’s a big, big country with a big, big population. A big, big population of taxpayers & consumers.
America has the biggest prison population per capita of anywhere in the world, literally millions & millions of Americans are homeless, living in squalor, tents, cars, the insides of sewers or Freeway flyovers or in the gutter & millions & millions of Americans can’t even get basic health care. If they have Cancer, MS, arthritis, they are doomed,
I could go on & on, but I’ll end here. Despite all the wars all over the world that the Americans have fought in, despite the hundreds of thousands of 18, 19, 20 & 21 year olds & the rest who have been sent to die for America in foreign wars & despite the millions of Iraqis, Syrians, Afghans, Vietnamese, Indonesians, south & Central American’s, Koreans & Chinese & all the rest slaughtered by Americans in the name of Freedom & hotdogs… Americans really & truly excel in slaughtering Americans, they’ve killed more of each other by far than any foreign enemy or terrorist or whatever they want to call them.
Yes, Bouslama Karin, I find it hilarious & tragic that many an ordinary US citizen would think anybody but the most desperate would envy them a place in such an unfair, racist, bigoted, violent & bitterly divided, police state.
@@flemhawker9134 Hi Thanks for the enlightening answer. The US is of course enviable for many things let's be honest but what I meant is that the Western way of life is often portrayed as the model for the whole world to follow. Here in Tunisia we have more or less adopted the western way of life since the 1950's but it has also clashed with traditional values of the population and now with the rise of political Islam we have the back clash against this rapid westernisation. I did my MA thesis on Globalisation of Culture so I can say I studied that quite a lot. Many Europeans and Americans when you talk to them think that people from other countries should be grateful to change their culture which is outdated and adopt the western way of life which is In.
@@thelovertunisia Everyone loves the western world, nobody that immigrated here wants to leave. Countries with religion ruling are hellholes (atleast for people with another religion). You wouldn't want to move to countries with dictators. Western world is too much freedom, that's why everyone loves it. But western world still exploits poor people. We live in luxury while others are being exploited. Eventually there is no perfect place, but the western world is still most loved
@@slupschuiters1774 Well you should take this idea with a pinch of salt. I am half German half Tunisia so I know both worlds well and I assure you it is not as simple as you think. What you see as positive is not universal.
Frankly speaking I don’t see anything objectionable to the idea that non westerners should be grateful for at least the core principles of the western civilisation (freedom of thought, speech, religion, ownership, movement, etc, republicanism ; the idea that the people ought to be involved in matters of the state, capitalism, which is just derived from the aforementioned freedom but is nonetheless very important, equality before the law, empiricism, etc).
The lack of all those, admittedly in varying degrees, is a constant throughout traditional societies, including pre 1800s western civilisation and what still lingers of that era in the current western civilisation, and is demonstrably harmful, so yeah I’d say non westerners should happily embrace those values if only for their own sake.
Now of course having McDonalds is not anything to be proud of but honestly I don’t know any westerner that’d claim that it is either ^^’
This is amazing example of a human being , a scientist who is commited to telling the truth , so refreshing and relieving hearing that even therapeutic . Thank you sir
His first sentences about intellectuals = he's talking about guys like Harris, Dershowitz or Weinstein hahaha...
A lot of hypocrisy on this site.
Dear author of the video,
I added Spanish subtitles to the video so it can be easily enjoyed in Latin America, Spain, etc., even by the people that does not speak English. I think you need to aprove the translation, somehow. I have tried to communicate with you privately but I do not know how.
Thank you very much for your attention, and for the upload,
Best regards,
S.H
Done.
thank you Santiago for doing that translation
How the fuck did you do that?
Thank you
Thanks
"Avoid foreign entanglements." G. Washington.
Fred Loeper Word
In case of present globalisation it is impossible.
@@mikloscsuvar6097 It is Really easy
@@intranext1359 not necessarily, when your country is getting needed resources from another country and that country goes into conflict, it would be hard to get those resources. For instance, America relies on palm oil and other natural resources from other countries that cannot grow here due to our climate being different. If South America were to have a social conflict and could not give us our palm oil, we’d intervene in order to get our palm oil. In the age of globalization where we get a lot of resources from other countries that either have the resource and we don’t/we cannot grow it due to our resources, it’s hard not not intervene when we have a clear motivation to.
@@qqfuwu1 yeah but to intervene to restore order not cause more chaos (iraq for example)
2. America did not need Iraqi oil since they already had Saudi Arabia trading with them
I have never had a man crush on anyone until I stumbled upon Noam's mind.
Oh, you should look up pics of him from the 60s and it won’t just be his mind anymore. I’m 90% heterosexual but young Chomsky is a major exception
Look up Christian Prince.
czcams.com/play/PLq4HFAwfHlA3HCGojX0Of45XKoLN-tTCs.html watch non zio media
And you like the fact that he's a stumbler as well?
Norm loves fools having crushes on his lies. Another useful idiot from Leftist indoctrination.
It will be a real shame when this man passes on. Such an intelligent and true voice, but was blocked by western controlled media.
True
How did you see this? I’ve seen dozens of his speeches on “western controlled media”.
Can’t wait!
@@WhyTheHorsefacebut you havent really have you. If you look at the western controlled media that is actually pushed and influences, take cnn or fox news, you will never see this man let alone here his name
8 years later and it feels like fresh
this interviews from 2002
This is something that needs to be spread now more than ever.
can you please give me the link or the title for the full video
Maybe we should indoctrinate the right wingers with facts
He spreads lies. His analysis of the situation is on a simple and childlike level. The problem is much deeper than he says. The problem is not that the United States influences the countries' policies. The problem is that countries are so corrupt and dysfunctional, and that's why the United States can influence. The influence of the United States is not the problem, it is the symptom.
@@niklasmolen4753 part of what u said is true , but world war 1 and 2 wasnt started by any islamic or middle eastern countries , and many mid/islamic countries were destroyed cause of that , the french/british/german... Colonization of africa is still active till now , u cant advance when you are imposed and forced to follow laws that r made to secure colonizers interest so you are doomed , no islamic country is allowed to implement sharia (law) , if they do as u probably think , they ll be called terrorists oppressors..all kind of bad wrong names as most westerners think and usa ll bomb them(like iraq) , and sharia if u study history is what lead non arabic and arabic countries to develop for like 1200 years , and jews or christian were never oppressed under islamic sharia , look for so called (golden age) were christian and jews and muslims under islamic law (sharia) were contributing in science , poetry , astronomy...etc , in peace and harmony , and of course u can have wars every nation deffend itself and what it think is right , till the end of time , thats how humans are , but people need to study and get to know the truth , who's wrong from right , and...the meaning of life is somewhere there awaiting cause no matter what u do , conflict is always present between humans from ur family to the gouvermant.
@@joundi007 Africa has always been underdeveloped and corrupt. Sometimes individual nations have reached international standards, but then always because of a strong and good leader. After his death, the empire shrank until it was just an ordinary part of corrupt Africa. There are many misconceptions about colonial times in Africa. More money went into Africa than out. Security and stability were higher during the colonial era. On the whole, the people were better off during the colonial era than after. Today's problems have very little to do with colonial times.
Islam began to stagnate in the 13th century with Al Ghazali and has never recovered since. Almost all prominent Islamic scientists came from recently conquered areas. Areas that were Muslim for a long time have hardly produced any science of their own. Islam was tolerant until quite recently. It was as Saudi Arabia's money grew that Islamic intolerance grew. They spread their Salafism which causes Islam to come into conflict with everyone else, even with the more liberal Muslims.
Since there is no successful / well-functioning Muslim country, there must be some serious problem with Islam. Exactly what it is I have not understood.
This is so refreshing to hear somebody saying what's odvious
Would help, NO actually wouldn't, if you could spell.
We don't hate you, we just want to be free we don't want to be manipulated by you!!
Let's hope the future is diffrent.
In fact they are the ones being manipulated (I mean the masses) they send off their children to fight in wars that only profit the leading minority , wars that are funded with their tax dollars. While most of them have no access to free education nor free healthcare. All that to defend themselves from made up enemies fabricated by their agencies.
@@HMalem that's a rhetoric from a backward country drowning in religious extremism
Except that it's utter bullshit. The hate every civilization that supplanted theirs as the intellectual leaders of the world. Well, what should they expect when they stopped even trying four or five centuries ago? When you see an Iranian news service in Iran taking video of Iranian women in Burkas raising both fists and shouting "Death To America", you should really get half a clue.
Yea, you want to be free from American oversight so you can murder Christians and Jews and ethnic minorities.
Man who clearly see and understand what is going on .
Much respect .
I've said this for the last 30 years! America is getting really scary to live in because there's so much evil we can not avoid. I'd rather hide in my house, away from the ways of the American ways. ( If that makes any sense)
Indian subcontinent will never forget what british did
Not only Africa and Middle est DIVISION !
The British were cruel, but the Hindus radical ideology and bad attitude had STILL made it important for Muslims to form a Muslim state. So not only British meddling, the Hindus extremism also contributed to the division of the subcontinent. Our Muslim forefathers were left with no choice. Jinnah was not a divisive individual, he knew what the Muslims needed.
@@speedking7224 true. Britain was a catalyst not a cause in that regard
@@dansheffield4021 Yes. Hindus as a whole community have never been well wishers of the Muslims, that's why the two nation theory was correct.
Modernised a third wordl country and supplied a extensive train system ..you should move to the U.K....thats right you already did !
30 years ago I didn’t care for Noam Chomsky.
After I grew up and got more life experience and see a bigger picture. I’ve realized he is SPOT ON.
His true colors came out during COVID plannedemic
I never worry about foreign threats, the domestic ones consume all of my fears and anxiety. "Foreigners" don't make my life impossible to live. The US banking system and corporations do. Like Perry Farrell said, "they are either trying to steal your money, or steal your fun". The reality is, it's both!
As someone originally from Afghanistan, this guy understands us.
You are not from real Afghanistan.
Real Afghanistan is rural Afghanistan where all the atrocities have happened.
Hi Edriss, I've been trying to fight for you, as a software developer, not robbing you from every penny and right.... Guess where it has brought me... Right by your side... Still... And I'm a westerner... I hate my culture and it's past. I mean... Nobody is perfect, but, the filth... The stench... it's drenched and I don't know where to look some times... I'm disgusted by my people, my brother... Hope are you doing well... ❤
yes indeed.
So you prefered the russians.
Why easterns don’t hate Arabs who changed the identity and names completely even their ethnicity name and made them backwards ? I’m Saudi btw if the westerns and their civilisations bad then no one think of running and living among them.
It's at once so simple yet so hard for people in the West to understand.
plenty do understand it, but the lie machine is louder.
Im glad he also mentioned the Dutch, its a small country landmass wise; but they have their fingers in a lot of pies despite their "goody two shoes" image of eve. Not mention, a lot of important families (with ruthless reputations) are Dutch or have a Dutch heritage.
Dutch empire had more people in it than the French empire did.
The Dutch are basically the people who formed modern capitalism, followed shortly after by the English
@@gumdeo not sure, but maybe they got close enough for a little country
Perhaps one of the few good things about America is that has people like Dr.Chomsky teach and speak freely...
This is very crucial point in evaluating the "adversaries", who always do exactly the opposite, as soon as in power !
not anymore AIPAC hijacked Americans govt
Not if he had videos as evidences like Assange had
And this is wonderful about the US, which he constantly rants against. Imagine him teaching in Iran, Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, even in the Palestinian territories and constantly criticizing his government, calling it criminal. He'd be long dead.
@@afanasymarinov2236 Same. Assange.
World needs guys like him in power the world is fucked up
The world will always be fucked up.
I wouldn't want to wish that tragedy on him though.
Yes, correct. Although it is odd that the USA - the greatest exponent of Realpolitik in history - still has this weird obsession about being liked, and being seen as in the "right". No previous empire has ever been so concerned about its reputation: power is its own justification. And "Snook On the fly" is also correct: most people in the world are charming, helpful and considerate. They want to live their lives, bring up their kids, don't hate people on sight and operate very much on the idea "live and let live". Politics has much to answer for: and we should be seriously questioning why governments seem to be run by the worst of us, not the best.
"...it is odd that the USA - the greatest exponent of Realpolitik in history - still has this weird obsession about being liked, and being seen as in the "right". No previous empire has ever been so concerned about its reputation: power is its own justification." Never thought of that. Thanks man!
That is such an asinine take, previous empires didn’t have stuff like the UN or NATO to cater to and no true rival or significant opponent to care about in the way the US has to.
The only exception being nations or people with a hegemon, which is exactly what the US have, ie not a political but a diplomatic and cultural empire.
It’s not exactly a new concept that if you have to choose between love and fear, you have to choose fear, but if you don’t have to then you ought to have both, so it’s no surprising that the US chooses to have both, even aside from the very obvious fact that… The US also has to appeal to its own people more than any previous empire, so it helps being seen as right even from an internal standpoint.
And all of that is not even discussing the even more basic idea that nobody likes to think of himself as the bad guy, so of course everybody wants to be seen as the good guy as much as possible.
@@nathanjora7627 you need to read up on some history you don't think the Greeks empires we equal to the persons or the Roman's in its early days to the Greeks or the Carthage Ian's.
The argue that these dead Empires that had fallen did not have worthy Rivals is laughable how the f*** do you think these Empires fell the Greeks used to invade the Romans that's why the Romans developed the military that made them such successful conquerors in the first place and then the Romans fell to the Goths ... your stupid please reproduce if you already have it beyond your child and please stop voting
Because power structures of any kind attract the power hungry. And the power hungry tend to be the worst of what humanity has to offer.
Lets just say that convinving people from and out of your empire that you are the moral highground is a great way to get support from people that otherwise doesnt really care about material possesion or social and relationship, some people are more about the ideology, wich is what the USA sells to the rest of the world
Thank you Professor Chomsky for always speaking the truth even when it isn't popular to do so against your own government.
On behalf of Muslims worldwide, we thank you for always speaking the truth.
yes indeed.
@@petergreen5337 "on behalf of Muslims worldwide" lol. who elected you as the spokesman for all Muslims?
Its not true that Usa destroyed Syria. Its not true that the worst war in Afghanistans was the one Usa brought. The Russian was ten times worse. Its not True that Usa attacked Russia this winter. But it is to Chomsky because he is not a political scientist. He is a politician,
Now if you only let your women speak their truth ‘freely’ maybe the world would support your ideology!
@@pinchebruha405 You mean like the NaziRepuplicans in Usa that just denied ten year old girl that had been raped an abortion?
noam chomsky : 219k views in 4 years
kim Kardashian : 30 million views in 24 hours 🤔
America loves its junk food and junk TV
Maybe because Kim Kardashian is less ridiculous?
YOUR POINT is ? Ok people r very STUPID self absorbed. How did we get HERE.
@@roberthertz6634 Amazing how liberals claim to be tolerant, yet decry anyone who thinks differently as either evil or stupid.
There’s only so much crap people can take, beyond that, anything is better.
You know what is really hard to understand and it's scary , is that hundreds of people don't believe this to be true. How can so many dislikes be given , do these people live under a rock!?
Millions actually
probably american bots gaming the algorithms so this video isnt suggested by youtube.
@@dharker7595nah it’s in my recommended lol and I’m barely watching political stuff
Chomsky has nailed this, and it is as true today as when he made these comments.
Truth is a slap in the face, wake up.
And the Truth shall set you Free
He is absolutely brilliant and right on the spot
you are of gold character sir. Much respect to you.
You are a Badass Noam. Thank you for the post.
God bless him for his achievements and his name will be famous in history of mankind
I’ll bet you wouldn’t say that if he said something you didn’t agree with.
We do not hate you, we just need to be free, live happily, see our kids grow up; not to grow up oppressed by people you bring in power, you kill people in our countries again and again, some people are tired of asking 'why?' and started to say 'enough!'
Would you support Eastern countries giving Western ones oil for free?
@@Vinny00754 would you support western countries give eastern countries wheat for free? that's a dumb question, my friend, I have something you need you pay for it or exchange, take it by force as it's being done like now, and ... you see the result.
@@ibrahimN17 Is it a dumb question if your response is exactly what I am looking for? You answered the “why?” with your response to my question. That is, we do what is best for us. Sometimes that is pay, sometimes it is exchange, and sometimes it is take by force. Which one is chosen by out leaders is the one which benefits us the most, all things considered. The reason some people are saying “enough” is because they are finally realizing this and understanding they need to create a power symmetry or continue to lose at the hands of those stronger than them. Good luck to them and may the best men win.
@@Vinny00754 then enough with the hypocrisy and lying, they aren't the free world, they aren't the guardians of morals, they are lying thieves, with no bottom line, the worst nation the world has ever seen. so, no wonder then we abhor them, those people should stop asking "Why do they hate us!".
He nailed it. Couldn't be said better...
I'm sick of being outraged and disheartned by the facts and doing nothing about it, I'm going to write a letter to the Minister of Foreign Affairs and make my voice known.
It would be better to write to the Ministry of Truth
+liamskimac LOL I see what you did there
Dont bother. They already know from reading this. War is peace. Freedom is slavery.
😂😂😂😂 do you REALLY think that they ever will care about what you re saying
@@quiche78😂😂😂😂
The things our government does, I had no idea until the last 5 years and I'm 55. Better late than never to find out.
@June Osborne
I can relate to you in that. I am 55 as well! ( Congratulations)🥂
Stumbled upon The Majority Report 4 years ago. The late (RIP) Micheal Brooks- discussing foreign policy . Eloquent, smart, multiple perspectives, fact checked with thing I'd ever heard on CZcams.
Been a member ever since. Sam Seder, Emma V..they're funny as well. COVID-19?
They were ahead of everything- and proven correct in numerous issues.
If you like Professor Chomsky who is the man. Well researched facts- not interpreting, twisting ,omitting..
☑️Check out The Majority Report.
With 30 years of NY Times, New Yorker magazine(8 year subscriber), Newsweek, daily MSNBC..
Thought I was informed.
I was, but within how they framed coverage or reported issues.
Manufactured Consent. Part of the machine.
Obama's horrificness never ever covered.
Many other omissions.
Even in Obituaries.
I've found lies in Washington Post videos after researching them.
Billionaire Bezos owns that paper. So there you go.
If everyone knew ( or cared like you do) the how much BS they're being fed, which feeds there opinions and their vote, this country would be hell of a lot more like what The Constitution intended.
Took you decades to realise what was in front of your face…
@@Medium341 That's because thru the 90s, I was too busy with the nervous breakdown part of my life. You don't know me and people like you say things like that to make yourself feel superior to others online which is pathetic.
And when it is said to them: "Make not mischief on the earth," they say: "We are only peacemakers."
Verily! They are the ones who make mischief, but they perceive not. (Quran 2:11-12)
indeed.
Truly. Quran indeed predicted all of this.
What a brilliant man, thanks for sharing this.
He missed an important factor. What one group thinks is an obvious right, the other thinks is a crime, and vice versa. They have basic values that are so different from each other that they can never live side by side.
@Artistic Projects In the West, we think that homosexuals should be allowed to marry each other and live in peace. In the Arab world, they think you should kill homosexuals. In the West, we think that all children should listen to female teachers. People from the Middle East do not think it is necessary to listen or respect female teachers (of course not all, but so many that it is a serious problem).
In the West, we think that politicians and religious leaders should be joked about. In Muslim countries, it is normal to punish someone for such jokes, even the death penalty.
@Artistic Projects Tell it to the teachers who heard it straight in the face from the parents.
@Artistic Projects They have even written about it in the newspapers.
I just feel fortunate that I'm one of the "1%" that appreciate and understand everything Mr. Chomsky's brilliant mind conveys. I love him.
+Qhorin Halfhand
ewww you're rude.
Samuel Clowntington claims that it's the other way around: that Religious extremism starts rising first in places like Saudi Arabia and Tunisia and the west is the reactionary. In reality the us supported theocracies all around the middle east against Secular nationalism because Secular nationalism leads to independence and you can't let that happen if you want to rule the world.
To overthrow Iran's PM Mohammed Mossadegh in 1953, the CIA funded specific Islamic clergy along with the Shah's goons, especially a certain young individual named Ruhollah Khomeini
Great excerpt. Full interview?
Happening In Sudan Right Now #SaveSudan
The good thing about this man he will tell us the history of the 50 years ago that’s why his ideas is make sense
Noam Chomsky is a gift of sanity in this world., I'm not saying he's perfect. But his knowledge and accuracy in presenting subjects that need presenting....and which we just won't get on the national news ...is astonishing.
Thank you for your intellect and truth.
Watching this as gaza is being bombed is very surreal. It feels like a dystopian omen at times, we have this information available to us at a mass scale but it doesn’t prevent the few in power from carrying out their planned actions.
My parents revolted against shah of Iran, it is common knowledge that shah of Iran was heavily tied to the US. However, when shah was trying to be independent, and build nukes and started to increase the price of oil. Thats when the revolution happened. After all khomeini was for a period in paris then moved to turkey. And when shah fled, khomeini immediately entered and the revolution happened. However, there was Iraq vs Iran war that adds complexity. My parents who are very political and lived and observed through the period told me US installed khomeini. Why would there be tons of sanctions on IR and yet they were installed by the US? Have they gain their independence? Everything american is not accessible in Iran. So what is the benefit for the US to have one of the most anti-american government in the region?
It is very known that in earlier years of Islamic Republic they had dealings with the republican party of the US.
However, what doesnt make sense to me is US has tons of satellite channels to advertise its agenda against IR. And believe it or not these had affected the protests in recent years.
So Iran does sell oil to the world. But our government hasnt used this industry to progress our nation. It has become a super market. Most of the budget is spent on military because we are one of the most threatened country in the world, constantly in the fear of being bombed. But make no doubt, vast majority of middle easterners hate the US government. The sheer amount of interference, no matter for what reason has caused us to hate the US. And there is support of Israel of course.
مشکل ما ایرانی ها این هست که با ذهنیت کهن وارد یک سیستم مدرن شدیم که سگ هم صاحبشو نمیشناسه
We gon get that oil
the US installed Al Khomeini??? LMFAO ARE YOU FUCKING SERIOUS?? WAKE UP BRO
@@gageadams8662 Finish your beer, big guy.
It was not the republicans, it was the liberal carter administration that coordinated Khomenis return and cooperated with him. Not to mention, Kennedy, another liberal, also wanted to depose the shah by organizing the 1963 protests, but he changed his mind afterwards. Otherwise nice comment. By the way, for anyone wondering about the factuality of these claims just good jimmy carter and khomeni and you will find plenty evidence. The documents have already been released a while back and BBC even covered this in 2016.
And the right call criticism of Israeil anti-semitic: the British press are really leaning on this with the election currently. Dangerous times.
alfamonk The left has a visceral hatred of Israel. Just admit it
B olton Stolen land ! 😂😂😂
@B olton based
MetalDetroit
You mad bro?
He is a huge gift to Humanity.
@Johnathan S White supremacist spotted
"they hate us cause we're free" ha!
+TheJimmax Brilliant response!
+TheJimmax I think the inverted commas indicate sarcasm...
+ED d So we'll take away your freedom and then somehow win.
+TheJimmax Keep them well fed, watered and entertained and your slaves won't care about the murder of other people.
How could the same system that offers me a Big Mac and plenty of TV with a big smile, be the same system that's killing thousands abroad?
you think that you are free ? re seriously speaking ? are u sure ? how u determine freedom by the way ?
IT IS GRATIFYING TO READ THAT THE PEOPLE UNDERSTAND.MAY GOD HELP US.
Thank you so much!
Such a clear thinking, thank you for your analysis
we call it justice from Allah. If we dont get it in this world then we will in the Next. InshAllah.
Whatever agrees with you is clear, whatever does not is wrong-headed if not downright reprehensible.
I'm saying nothing whatsoever against him, only noting that our moral and intellectual evaluations tend to colored by subjective considerations.
@marcus onesimus I have confirmation bias like everyone else. Why would this be strange to you?
@@zarathustravideo
That in itself I do not find strange at all. I'm subjectively familiar with the phenomenon.
If one believed that it were invariably a bad thing, and tried to root it out through ruthless self-examination, the exercise would soon prove tiresome and futile.
Noam Chomsky is the only person I would trust to be the president of the United States.
Why? He'd willingly let America collapse and die.
Childish rubbish.
Bernie Sanders
Ironic because he's an anarchist.
He wouldnt wont to be a president in the first place.
This guy is not afraid to speak the truth! There are many more truth tellers out there but they are not coming forward. Why?
everyone is ready to be in heaven, but they’re not ready to die for it.
We all need to! Learn, be or become informed, and then SPEAK!!!!
They tried, but the majority of the media is controlled by corporations that also influence the government and its policies. Not to mention Western media dominates the world, 80% of it. Its unlikely news and information like this gets spread to the world. Mainstream media dictates how people process and prefer information. People see anti muslim, anti china video title they are likely to click it, the same cannot be said for "why they hate the west".
To answer your question, look at Assange, truth tellers get thrown in Jail. America is not a Democracy, it is controlled by Corporations, who control the Govt, who control the people, who control the voters. Anyone can see how corrupt politicians are in America, Australia, Britain etc, yet they keep voting for the same people. Look at this video, 4 years up and only 262K+ views, yet watch an American sprouting hatred against Muslims and it has 5 million views in a month. I forget who said it, but he stated, "I can convince 1 man with logic, but I can convince 1000 with their own prejudices". And that is so True, look at Trumps base, they are getting screwed but still believe they are winning.
@@seetowin I wish people would, but that will never happen.
What year was this interview shot?
A higher man.
Long live Chomsky!
He WON'T however HE will be sorely MISSED. Enjoy him TODAY.
As a " moderate" Muslim, I believe Professor Chomsky correctly analyzed the Muslims' view point.
@@mosaabtwice3999 how is that necessary?
@@mosaabtwice3999a muslim who doesn’t like Islam basically
Bruh… « moderate Muslim » is what every western imperialist wants you to be, which means not a Muslim…
You are responsible for what happens in Palestine, what happened in Irak and what will continue to happen
Except if you’re able to give me an explanation of what « moderate Muslim » is for you, if it’s reasonable I’ll retire my comment
I’ve seen Chomsky reference that WSJ opinion poll a couple times... anybody have a link to what he’s talking about?
His voice is very soothing like a symphony
Noam Chomsky - Why They Hate the West
2018. 2.4.
I am thankful for freedom of speech, to being able to understand how people feel through this forum of understanding on youtube... I am thankful for Noam Chomsky's insights. Without this, I would be confused and scared , because propaganda is not a substitute for human understanding, it is an excuse for retaining privileges by people who are dogmatic.
😂😂😂😂 sad to see westerners be embedded by these so called « values », the very fact that it’s something so meaningful for you shows that the West always had, and still has a big problem with « freedom of speech » otherwise it wouldn’t be so important for you.
was the microphone placed in the other room?
middle east people are so lovable and respectful, no way they would hate someone without a reason.
*coughs in Issis*
@@confusedcapitalist2242 didn't you understand anything from the video?
missing1person nope ;)
2019 and nothing's changed.... 😭😭
Yep. Fuck Trump as Chomsky says.
Oh, it has now. We are in 2023, and China (PRC) is incontestably the biggest bully on the block. Russia is freely expressing the glories of its culture in Ukraine,
with the help of robed Iranian clerics and their fleet of drones.
The isolationist Trump is running again for prez.
You must be over the moon with delight.
The accession of Finland to membership in NATO is the one sour note in your
happy tune.
2023 and STILL nothing has changed
i thought it was oil too, back in '02.
Thank you sir.
You crush people under your boot, people dont like it
where is the link about Eisenhower era NSA report?
What is its name?
history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1958-60v12/d5
I like ike
when he said "so on" my heart skipped a beat
Spartan 450 ml * sniff *
Hate ✖️
Haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaate✔️
Chomsky great to read. Torturous to listen to
its a christmas miracle.
This time i lasted about 37 seconds before waking at my desk...so I’m getting better at listening.
*sighs*
It's one thing to win the war, it is another to win the peace
Happy Birthday Gang
“jealous of our freedom i can’t believe u bought that excuse “- Immortal technique
DOESN'T GET ANY MORE CLEARER THEN THAT !!
*shakes head* Everything was set in motion long before any of that and even before that. We are still dealing with the fallout from things that happen thousand year ago.
Who keeps opening the doors, ffs. I'm watching this high and keep getting scared by that sound.
What is the date of his speech? Not that it matters,just like to listen in chronological order.
Joe Schmoe
Yeah,but more current events,I don't agree with him on everything,but like to listen to him-he usually only does interviews that don't have interviewer's,lol
playback speed: chomsky 1.5x shapiro .75x
I looked it up that shapiro. People really watch that fucking clown?
@@franticmower7300 yes millions ):
@@franticmower7300 : He may be a clown but he is a well educated clown and many of his views resonate with a helluva lot of ordinary 'Joe's''.
@@someoneelse.2252I don't know hombre. I don't think an avarage iq person would take his "views" seriously. It's mostly populist horse wank with shit flavour that fuck tons of uneducated fucking idiots buy into. And honestly; education is easy to come by these days. Proper morals and a decent character is what most people lack the most.
The purpose of tension is paradoxially love. - Wald Wassermann, Physicist
A Great Man
Of course Noam knows what’s been going on!
Wherever the Golden arches appear,decay begins. . 🍟🍔
A Gift from THE Yankees
-- *U.S.A*--
To THE World!
❤️ Noam Chomsky!!!🌹
Wish I could find that wall street journal article
And six years later, same... same... same...
Six? Ha. This was filmed in 2002~2003.