[@doddleoddle]

THE SHAKING HANDS I FORGOT BAHAHAHAH

[@noahdavis5888]

HAHAHAHA

[@anoukfromthenetherlands3059]

love it

[@jennifer-rose5504]

WOOPSIES

[@danielbottcher3343]

doddleoddle I am pissing my self

[@mioloco]

doddleoddle bdbdjdjsks

[@nanettelo4912]

dodie is sitting IN THE MIDDLE of the couch.

[@puntastic1926]

Ironically iconic

[@matthewcorbett9055]

Eheheh

[@georgiastratton3278]

Ah yeahhhh

[@harveycollyer5427]

😯 it's as if it was planned

[@Renyen76]

heheheh

[@meaghan2115]

"Talk about your taste in women" James shakes his head

[@Max-ux2rl]

Meaghan 13 1:36 I luv it

[@chloechockley3499]

James when they sang “Talk about you taste in women”😂

[@phia8205]

lmao i just realized that and i'm still cackling

[@simplykatexo2504]

everyone knows why though

[@msbrownie8248]

Which time stamp?

[@grace1679]

Ms Brownie 1:34

[@jasparkerr]

The guy in blues reaction. You can seem him smile knowingly

[@charlottedorey4364]

The whole group is insanely talented but in this song particularly the guy doing the beatboxing really shines. WOW

[@noahdavis5888]

❤️

[@lilali9797]

agreed! like not a single beat out of place. and the final chorus' (after the bridge) was a nice touch!

[@sam_rags]

Noah Davis 🖤

[@maryannc7223]

I’m rewatching this in spring 2021 and I agree- This is a great rendition, but the beatboxing really makes it!

[@katandjessie540]

james' little NOPE hand thing every time the "taste in women" line came up. ICONIC - jessie

[@friendsaccount3500]

Omg yesss I was dieing

[@meganm5988]

yesssss i was hoping someone else noticed

[@faithcushman9339]

Kat and Jessie lmao I just rewatched the video because I missed it lmao

[@molly6449]

theyre all so attractive

[@reeganseabury5504]

michael mell me

[@brooke2558]

i'm sensing bmc trash, hello

[@danielwatson7257]

literally every single one, especially noah

[@robinegggs]

Agreed

[@ok-mw2wi]

right

[@deannasutton1606]

Everyone: "Talk about your taste in women-"
James Charles: *oh hell naw sister*

[@liliacruz8444]

Lol

[@therainbowsponge4403]

Everyones talking about the beatboxer and im just really impressed with the bass!

[@socialheart6249]

the caffeinated giraffe sameeee

[@jameswest9321]

reno is so talented and also SUCH A PRETTY MAN

[@makethebestoutoflife9948]

SAME, THAT BASS
Why isn't anyone talking about it? I mean, the beatboxer was fine but
That bass though

[@d.no33]

the caffeinated giraffe same!!

[@matthews1029]

Idk why

[@anonymous2092]

The blonde guy seems like the sweetest, his little hand gestures

[@emilydanielle4968]

Hannah Banana yes i love him

[@blane8791]

Hannah Banana that's Anthony Graguila, he's amazing! 😍

[@jays.harmony]

ikr he's adorable

[@stonersloane]

he's sooooooo adorable 😍

[@kitnkat8154]

Hannah Banana Anthony

[@kathyagarza4550]

Its obv not a complete James Charles look without him in a crop top hahaha I thought it was a formal wear t shirt until he raised his hands up Lol

[@cherfancherfan6682]

Kathya Garza yeah me too😂

[@rebeccaknight6163]

SAME!!!!!
Hahaha

[@caitlynhanselman1319]

Kathya Garza I thought the same exact thing girl

[@bixxerz]

I thought the EXACT same thing XD

[@jamarriannacharlene5531]

Asd_Maker cause hes shistar james.... Look it up

[@christina2077]

dodie missed the memo of doing music stuff with your hands idk

[@johnthechamp4208]

Christina T Its because she’s in the middle xD

[@v3rlabupopcorn897]

Lol
She be bobbin her head

[@niamhdoyle928]

I AM COMPLETE

[@lucytalbot1845]

Does this comment remind anyone else of a certain hole some tortilla chip?

[@olivesinacan8269]

phan trash #1:u phan trash #2: Me

[@chliothemuse]

SAMEEEEEEEEEE!!!

[@benandrani]

Same omg so good

[@thatsourdan2214]

Li Jing The Phandom is fucking everywhere

[@whenever4296]

Oh my god nobody in the comments knows who Anthony is (the blond one on the right) but he's so fucking talented and went to Acapella Academy and he's an actual angel plz appreciate him

[@eldonmati]

Self Explanatory boys doing those typical and excessive runs and riffs are so 2014, no news lmao

[@whenever4296]

Steven Matthews I can agree that he does overuse riffs sometimes but if you look at his channel, some of his covers are really nice. Idk, he just has a unique voice to me 😂

[@joycehkim]

most of them went to acapella academy tho

[@whenever4296]

Jesus all I'm trying to say is that I appreciate him 😂

[@joycehkim]

Self Explanatory ok ok 😂

[@alldaymashup]

0:03 James Charles doing the mouth pop that all beauty gurus do! haha

[@Angie-re5bh]

alldaymashup Shane Dawson is so a beauty guru

[@jaeyrl]

alldaymashup so true

[@bennycook1]

And also all of the drag queens who invented it.

[@carys1]

Bennycook1 especially Miss Edwards

[@Ben-zn9ow]

Bennycook1 👏🏼👏🏼

[@fish1705]

James’ no sign at 1:36 😂😹

[@noahdavis5888]

Omg I’m so proud of this!! I love you guys so much!

[@unknown_twinz4797]

LOVEE thiss

[@j.ashley9152]

Noah Davis the girls are amazing don’t get me wrong.... but the FELLAS! Ugh! Y’all murder it every time!! 🙌🏽🙌🏽🙌🏽❤️

[@lehbr7330]

You're very talented! (i hope that's good but btw you understand what I would say^^)

[@oliviaw4945]

Dodie's over here looking like an actual angel

[@whereskatie]

she is one already soo

[@LC-jj5xk]

James’s facial expressions and dancing are a big mood

[@LIZ-jq3lb]

1:27 well that was awkward

[@gabby8823]

LIZ I know 😭😭

[@LIZ-jq3lb]

Gabby 😭😭

[@pinokino7488]

Why?*_*

[@kateble5676]

Alina Bede look at this blond guy and girl. Shaking hands not going well 😂

[@Jay-qw1sh]

HAHAHAHAH

[@mariamkharpoutli675]

*they r so good* how the hell do they do that beat with their mouthesssssssss *WHAT*

[@sophiaa3315]

Loving your profile pic!

[@mariamkharpoutli675]

Same goes to u !!!!and u have great taste in music ❤️❤️

[@sophiaa3315]

I have no social life thanks! Troye is just amazing I love him so much!

[@mariamkharpoutli675]

I can’t wait for the new album!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@sophiaa3315]

I have no social life omg same, it's going to be amazing!!

[@bailebeck2925]

tbh just staring at their hands the whole time

[@alexrusso7051]

Baile Beck just wanna stare at Reno all day (the guy in the far right sorry if I misspelled his name lol)

[@avezumin]

Alex Russo Ikr he's so cute

[@vennathompson536]

Baile Beck same🤣

[@kpagel2001]

Alex Russo ok literally

[@GQ-zn2jh]

Wow now I only stare at their hand what have you done

[@ella-suzanne9216]

ANTHONY BEING REJECTED BY GABA I'M QUAKING 😂😂

[@kimberlyaung6428]

The blonde one is absolutely amazing

[@abbeybryner4683]

Kimberly Aung Anthony

[@fabulousarmadillo8877]

Ikr he should be way more popular than he is with how talented he is!

[@DylanLive745-music-and-arts-14]

His name is Anthony gargula

[@chipebi]

James Charles face when he's talking by "his taste in women" @0:46 is all sorts of extra 😂😂😂

[@katrinadouglass6236]

Nancy Ebi oh my godd

[@hiimgrace7747]

Omg i love it SO MUCHH

[@yasmin-lq8pp]

Ohhh myyllaannttaaaa

[@LaraZoe]

I thought there were drums playing but sike it was THAT GUY'S MOUTH oMg

[@Lunadeuranomrp]

Lara Zoe it was so edited... it didn’t even sound real

[@hollybramhall1351]

Miranda Paz Ik it sounds so fake, but I have heard people make similar sounds - I’ll bet it was real

[@LarryS378]

yeah its sooo heavily edited lol. they all obviously prerecorded their stuff beforehand (if you blow on a mic that closely you can make similar noises)
shame they did that tho cause it's still good just but makes it look fake

[@mackenziemcclara5495]

Lara Zoe it sounds like beatboxing not drums

[@user-sg2bt3sh9d]

he lowkey hot

[@tiagol-t951]

The only video on this channel.

[@ShreeyaMerchia]

i edited this comment two years later so now if you see it you’ll never know why it has 3k likes :DD

[@tierra8715]

And he’s hot too

[@cadybtterfly521]

Shreeya Merchia
and attractive

[@fizafiza1982]

Sooo true his really gooood his toooo talented

[@aordrie]

He looks like a guy in my show choir 😂😂😂

[@soggychippett8232]

Shreeya Merchia hes a vocal percutionist not a "beatboxer"

[@Irakli96]

1:32 😍

[@nadzeyas]

Irakli G Ираклиии 😍

[@dainasaurs]

I got goosebumps

[@georgethomas746]

Irakli G agreed

[@attiegrey]

Irakli G Ahhhh

[@tvx276]

"talk about your taste in women" *James shakes his head*

[@katherinee.3759]

Dodie looks like she is genuinely having an amazing time and it is making me so happy.

[@doddleoddle]

I was LIVING

[@emmaerlenbusch]

Anyone here wondering if this group is still a thing

[@Emma-kj9ii]

emma erlenbusch yup

[@claire207]

emma erlenbusch don’t think so, because Nina (the one between Dodie and James) is in a new acapella group. It’s a girl group called Citizen Queen, created by the founders of Pentatonix

[@beeperspeepers]

I'm also wondering why this is the only video on the channel

[@omniipotence]

I really felt it when the blond guy at 1:27 got denied his handshake

[@thebatmanwhoposts9600]

Lol, nice catch.

[@Coco-ge3cq]

IM DEAD Anthony’s eye roll when James shakes his hand 😂😫😂😫😂😫😂

[@sydney6598]

1. Loving the aesthetic
2. Y’all have a really good sense of rhythm and musicality 10/10

[@jessseddon1339]

ikswozaw ekim ir a 6/10 😊

[@zaheera5164]

Louby Lou I applaud you 👏👏👏👏

[@arthurstable223]

WHOS THE GUY SECOND TO THE RIGHT CUS HOLY JESUS I LOVE HIS VOICE

[@gretavo8076]

Redstone Rocket His name is Anthony I think. He was in a sing off on Jame's Charle's channel

[@esmegrantt]

Yee Haw they’re like best friends

[@micheal2458]

00:47 cracked me up hahahah!! I had to rewatch it a few times!

[@inactiveaccount4398]

this was so freaking GOOD

[@rafy3647]

Mackenzie Frecloud wow you again.

[@addifranc]

Mackenzie Frecloud dude I see you like everywhere

[@miaomalley9327]

why do i see you everywhere lol???

[@xxjaysephxxx]

This is so beautiful! I love how when Dodie sang "talk about your taste in women", James made a 'nope, not for me' face.

[@stonersloane]

CAN WE JUST TALK ABOUT HOW CUTE ANTHONY IS?!?!?

[@hamiltonlover6715]

Who......

[@eel000]

Hamilton Lover the one in blue

[@lou6039]

Hamilton Lover it‘s the blonde one

[@jestjade2520]

the girl in bluE IS LIFE

[@pigeonbraine]

This video just turned my black heart a dark shade of gray🖤✨

[@gabujita4088]

trash sameee

[@emmabago5740]

trash hahaha

[@ren4798]

wow v edgy

[@ellarhodes5476]

trash me

[@BABY-dc3xb]

Edgy

[@SydneyFillinger]

Omg all the tongue pops have really paid off James😂😂😂 in all seriousness I love this sooo much

[@MySGarden]

I feel like these people are too cool for me LOL

[@nyhh.dupree]

in confusion. @ 2:54 nobody mouthed "in the middle" AM I THE ONLY ONE THAT NOTICED THAT?

[@udreams_9532]

Whaaaaaaaaat

[@itziaramos5964]

it's pre-recorded, as almost all covers

[@arandomperson1885]

It’s prerecorded as you can tell by the fact that the ‘Hey!’ at the end sounds kind of tinny compared to the rest of the song since the Hey was done at the time of recording this video :)

[@matthews1029]

Just your casual lip sincing foul lmao

[@reanncooper6734]

am i the only one that noticed the underwear

[@clanskrub665]

_Wheres the rest of James' shirt_

[@saramaccormack5475]

Clan Skrub I was waiting for this comment

[@cuddlingteddybears]

Ikr

[@firstofallloo.second9323]

Clan Skrub omg, I didn’t even notice

[@karma4975]

He's wearing a crop top

[@impishizzy2590]

ikr

[@moonchildmochi2128]

Acapella version of In The Middle, the content nobody knew they needed

[@elswrld9632]

i’m dead
all my babies
together
YES

[@rubywojcik]

“There’s more coming” this is there only video on the channel... um

[@ElinorMahoney]

Yikes, I think it's cuz of James

[@katiemarie5725]

The beaaaat boxing in this is insane. They all look like they’re having so much fun. I love this.

[@tina-by3uh]

dodie is IN THE MIDDLE

[@ken-hx7de]

Anthony is so good!

[@lyanf.acevedo7857]

How does that kid make so many AMAZING sounds with his mouth(human beat box) I am in Aww... You guys are ALL great and your soprano is on point. I just found you guys and subscribed!💞

[@maddietownsend225]

James when you all sang "taste in women" at 1:36 😂😂😂 love you guys 💗

[@jade7235]

Maddie117123 😂😂😂 ikr!

[@erinbreske]

That made me laugh so hard 😂

[@anqel4686]

Maddie117123 i didnt even notice that 😂😂

[@KarmasEnergy]

MN

[@davidesimonetti8989]

1:28 brutally left hanging

[@megan-zl9iu]

Davide Simonetti I knooooswww 😩😂

[@rosewilting]

OOF

[@user-sg2bt3sh9d]

OH SHIT THATS SAD

[@harper7624]

Wait what

[@f.g.748]

I'm confused. How?

[@valcorton6756]

1:26 when you get rejected, didn’t even get a hand shake!! She looked so confused. 😂

[@cupcakebigelow1579]

You should upload more, you guys stopped uploading around two years ago and I’ve been waiting ever since, you are all so talented

[@emilyvictoria7857]

they broke up babe

[@lovebabyjones2121]

That baritone is lookin’ like he wants to know my deepest desires and I’m ready to tell him. 😍

[@annaliseflint8905]

hes gay...

[@NotMe-ic2xy]

He's also a beauty guru

[@hannah.vargas]

and the first ever Coverboy

[@annaliseflint8905]

yeah he's the best

[@kyreelong8105]

Annalise Flint Lucky me😂😍

[@melroseonyechi7221]

Finally you did something with Dodie!!!!!

[@melroseonyechi7221]

She's awesome!!!

[@cael_aj]

Y'all need to get together and upload again, this is so fire!

[@nawwarraalawqati3726]

I have listened to this countless times 👌👌👌😍😍

[@LaurenJewel]

i adore dodie so much omg💕💞💕

[@hillmandy]

Lauren Jewel don’t we all?

[@ItsJustEllieX]

And dodie said that her songs are sad songs and has no BOPS. OH IM SORRY DODIE, BUT HAVE YOU HEARD YOUR SONG IN THE MIDDLE. 😂

[@sarahkeiper7589]

ItsJustEllie X so all her songs are sad OR about threesomes lmao

[@ItsJustEllieX]

Sarah Keiper lol, on twitter she posted a video of her dancing to secret for the mad and evan replied with him dabbing to she i was legit crying of laughter😂😂

[@Qwuarter]

literally what I was thinking when she tweeted that :D

[@PhoenixVert]

Dodie looks so cute and happy the whole way through ♥

[@IzzyDizzy212]

I haven't stopped listening to this oml

[@Icelittledoll]

The person at the left who was doing the beatbox was so talented like damn that's some pretty good mouth you have here. Also the one on the right with the denim jean make my heart skips a beat whenever he was looking at the camera ( so basically all trough the video ) gUeSs i HaVe a CrUsH NoW

[@hannaharevalo199]

Every time “taste in women” is said and James is like BITCH NO IM GAY AF I die I love it you kill me QUEEN

[@nessaw.5191]

OMFG I didn’t even notice until you said it. I had to watch the whole video again just staring at James 😂😂🏳️‍🌈

[@annameintrup3072]

Like at 1:35

[@bandamani]

Anna_Mya 2703 and 00:45

[@antoniodellaventura9783]

It killed me, I didn't even noticed it

[@Kittygirl2326]

You guys are amazing ! 😆

[@karenc7238]

No words! Fabulous! So much talent!!!

[@carlaravelo2887]

I️ Love dodie she is amazing. She is insanely talented I’m obsessed with her😍😍😍

[@doddleoddle]

[@carlaravelo2887]

doddleoddle omg u replied this is amazing 😘😘😘

[@emily-lb1op]

THIS IS SO GOOD OMG

[@isabelleanderson5995]

We need more!! I love this group so much!

[@irbesmilgaine3217]

I could listen to this on repeat for 24/7 and not get bored of it. You ALL are so amazingly talented!! 💕💕💕

[@petranak3206]

The beatboxers WHAT! HOW DO YOU PRODUCE SUCH SOUNDS

[@findingmemo2105]

YASS y'all killed this! I love Dodie's voice and Anthony with those riffs and James' outfit I was like 😱🔥🔥

[@chelsea-om1sd]

Lou Pend the accuracy 👍🏽😂

[@CaloobianMongoose]

I didn't think I could *love* this song any more than I already did.
But I was *SO* wrong. This is _ridiculously_ awesome.

[@Kbbn]

I NEEEEEEEEED MORE OF THIS!!!
You guys are insane!!!! I looove this!!!!

[@melomana91]

aww, this is really good, but shame it wasn't a live recording :(

[@danandbands5854]

it was probably the only way to balance the volume of the vocals vs the beatboxing, just giving us the best sound:)

[@pinkishtoast3561]

Danandbands They aren't balanced that well, though. The harmonies are really hard to hear.

[@melomana91]

Danandbands They made a video together on Dodies channel that was a live recording and it sounded amazing! so they were absolutely capable of doing it.

[@elswrld9632]

honestly it probably was when they recorded this, and then covered the video with the recording, if that made sense

[@MichelleNadin]

Absolutely amazing cover! I love Dodie😍💗❤️

[@marishagnossis1451]

YALL. YOU ARE AMAZING COME BAAAACK

[@dawsonnhill]

anthony is literally amazing and when dodie smiled when he came in on that falsetto entrance aw

[@JosephMcCrossan]

This is insane, all of you Guys are so talented

[@patiencewomack334]

y’all are so cute WHAT

[@ruby1605]

They have perfect voices, and are singing a perfect song. What else do we need?? NOTHING

[@alexbuxton4679]

I love this so much! You guys are really talented! Best wishes to everyone in this video! ❤❤❤

[@hansinikumar1648]

1:27 a rejected handshake

[@barrybbenson9968]

Hansini Kumar My Life Summary

[@snatchedbatch4311]

I literally read this at the exact moment that came on

[@morganbritt2539]

FLASHBACK IS MY FAVORITE AND DODIE IS MY FAVORITE

[@LeoDtrch]

Arthurs moves are always so precious, it's
fascinating me in every Video.

[@balletgirltwo685]

Wow is this really the only video they ever uploaded? I thought they would actually try to go through with something

[@star3674]

I-Is that a cropped shirt?

[@itmesneha]

EXACTLY!

[@jalynnewilliams1637]

Amazingsofiaisnotonfire ! Why

[@karenrodrigues101]

Amazingsofiaisnotonfire ! Love your profile pic and user name ♥

[@hollygr4ce]

Amazingsofiaisnotonfire ! i love it mMmmMmmmMm

[@virginiawallace7077]

He is slaying it tho😍

[@emmalewis6991]

James' makeup is on fleek!

[@cathydane5669]

You are all amazeing,can't wait to download

[@natbertman2081]

you are all such naturals, can't wait to see what else you come up with!!

[@joannabartlett2035]

Love this group song..everything.. and love newer member. What happened to zoe...the other member that was in other covers like new rules...

[@yeseniaportillo6661]

Joanna Bartlett I was thinking the exact same thing I never seen the girl to the left :0

[@savanablandamer1386]

They announced that she decided to go to college! 😊

[@elle1071]

Zoe went to college, I think she's called Nina Ann but I might not be right

[@moistanklesock]

Ayyyeee same last name

[@janhvirochwani5127]

Now Nina's gone too.. For the better I think. She's in this new group called Citizen Queen and they're amazing!

[@puritymua1763]

YESSS I LOVE YOU GUYS AND DODIE

[@mayaluz8326]

Kaily Grazar 99 like 😆

[@hi-ft8er]

I've just realised that i've been listening to this for the past 3 hours. (i put it on loop).

[@savanana8514]

They're too good for this world.

[@sky.mangini1172]

Does anyone else notice that James always gives himself a solo and Anthony gets like 1 second like Anthony deserves a solo

[@helenfaith1508]

Justmynamebecauseimbasic Jerry you know they all decided who sings right

[@lottiej742]

Watch their new video. Satisfied?

[@wowwhatafreak5417]

does this dumb ass really think they do it one go without any planning?

[@NellieCollier]

Bitch stop being so salty we need positivity here

[@twedsta0559]

Because baritones and altos get solos in accepela and Tenors and sopranos do the melody ❤️❤️

[@l0verofmusic]

Haha loved how dodie accidentally mouthed when there was no music

[@patsymcfee7867]

l0verofmusic when lol

[@davidmc8478]

Sotto voce, she sang not mouthed

[@ilovecampcar22]

David Mc nah, the music was prerecorded and then they filmed this lip sync. you can tell because there’s no reverb, like there is at the end when they’re doing the outro

[@user-sg2bt3sh9d]

^^yeap

[@signenielsen711]

I’M LITERALLY IN LOVE WITH ALL YOUR AMAZING A CAPELLA SONGS😍

[@kimberlyoosthuizen8416]

Okay but in 2019 we need some more content from Flashback