@@linkinwithlia2511 who would it be then? it was probably just a mistake the owner put. the brother and the father is the only people who knows the names of the twins. also Grandparents, foster parents, legal guardians, older brothers or sisters, widowed stepparents, and aunts and uncles are not considered parents unless they have legally adopted you. (I just copy pasted the last sentence from google btw)
It was probably the brother. He grew jealous of the twins because his father never paid any attention to him so he wanted to get revenge. The girls were identical twins, but the brother could still tell them apart which would be hard for a person outside of the family to do (hence the name whispering) He blindfolded the girls so they couldn't see and recognize him He told the girls that he contacted their PARENTS just to make the girls think that the kidnapper is someone else and to make them less suspicious of him Also for the people saying it was the mother, the riddle clearly said "an unknown MAN" But i still have 1 question, if it indeed was the brother, then couldn't the girls recognize his voice? Maybe that's the reason he whispered instead of talking, cause in that case it would be harder to do so (also it said that the whispering was high pitched)
It said unknown man but how did they know it was a man if they were blindfolded ?? He or she could’ve been wearing a mask with a beanie or hiding the hair so that they would think it’s a man and so a lady would be the least suspicious
Kidnapping is not a prank, and the father spoiled them. It didn't say they did anything wrong, and if he was trying to "teach them", he probably would have gotten in a lot of trouble for falsely kidnapping them after he returned them.
Umm the person who gave the details of what happened like how did they know blind folds were on them yea mabye people found them there but how do you know that he put them on there face and kidnapped them because that person is a sick person and wanted money and by sick I mean like what he did was horrible so yea but to me it’s kinda obvious plus also how do you know it was a man
The brother kidnapped them because he was jealous, and he was the only other person who could tell them apart, but he used ‘parents’ to confuse the girls.
But, they also asked "why did they do it?" and earlier said "everyone was jealous of them" and "they heard a high-pitched voice say in their ear" including their mother so what if their also had a part to play in this
I think it was probably the brother. He was jealous of how much attention the girls were getting. And he would’ve been one of the few who could tell them apart properly. Edit: for those who are interested due to my pfp, I main Aether ;)
"everyone was jealous of these girls because their father loved them so much and gave them everything they wanted and all his attention" Me: it's the brother cause 1. Everyone was jealous of them that includes the brother 2. He knew their names 3. He knew who is who 4. He had their dad's number 5. It's obvious
@Dolores Madrigal👂🏽 i was also gonna say the mother,but then it says the kidnapper was a man.... but the video also states the kidnapper was a unknown and never caught moreover mandy and melissa heard a high pitched voice... so how did they know the kidnapper was a man
The kidnapper was the brother because he was jealous how he was getting all the attention and he was one of the few people who knew their names and could tell them apart
It's a high pitched voice. It is probably the mother. It clicks to me every time. It's the mother bc she knows the name of the girls and also the voice is high pitched. The mother, as in the second parent said "I called ur *parents* " because she knows that both the parents are alive, as in she is the mother. Think logically. Who else would know the girls' names, the father's phone number, and that both the parents are alive.
I was scrolling through the comments and everyone is saying it’s the brother but why did he say parents if it was just the dad? I think it’s the mother or a step mother that the dad left for whatever reason and she thought that he remarried or something like that so she wanted to have money for whatever she wanted it for (I’m not great at explaining stuff 😂)and she kidnapped them knowing that the dad loved them very much or she got jealous of the girls which is why the dad left her and she got mad This is my comment and why I think it the mother just so you know lol
You are kinda right. She knew the Parents are alive and its not adding up to much if it was the brother because she never said "brother" or "big family of 5".
It was their brother as him being a family member knew their names even though they were identical twins. He was jealous of them as they both got all attention of their dad
POV: you have to watch the video again to understand the story because you were too focused on watching her draw. Edit: AINT NO WAY YOU GOOFY AHH GOOFY GOOBERS THIS IS THE MOST LIKES I HAVE EVER HAD! TYSM!
The only person that would know the difference between the twins is someone who has been with them almost their whole life, and if they live in a large mansion there would already be security so it could be someone on the inside and the only other person living with them other than their dad is their older brother
It was either the kids who were jealous, or the brother because they were loved more and got more attention. The kids did it so they wouldn’t have to worry about being around rich people, and if the brother did it, then he probably would have been loved more than ever because the parent were scared that he would be kidnapped too. Thank you if you like! 😊💗
The older brother was jealous cuz his dad wouldn’t pay attention and his dad buys everything for the girls and not him so he wanted money from his dad so he kidnapped the girls to get what he wanted
It was the brother. His father was focusing ALL his attention on the twins making the brother feel neglected or something, so he decided to kidnap the twins.
The older brother was so jealous of the two because the father had spoiled them. He was only said once in the story meaning he wasn't very important, or so you would think. He knew the names because he was the brother, he never got any attention because on the two so he wanted money from his father to get his attention and so he could finally be in control..
i mean it has to be the brother. 1. He was jealous of his sisters 2. He new their names 3. He knew the difference between them 4. He knew their father would do anything to get his daughters back.
anyone gonna notice they said they lived with the dad and brother, yet they said parents? edit: wait i think i got it ok so basically i have this the mom kidnapped them and said she contacted their parents but only their dad to get 1 million after some kinda divorce edit 2: nvm anyways i started a debate in my replies edit 3:BRO THE LIKES
I don't think it's the brother. He said "I will contact *your parents*" when there isn't a mother. The brother would know that already. And who said the kidnapper knew wich girls were they, if they're blindfold ? The brother would know that by how they act, so I don't think it's the brother, probably the mother who left the dad, wanted to kill one of the girls because the brother were her favorite when he was young (the mom left the dad AFTER the brother was born, she never met the twins, or maybe she only saw them when they were born.) so since she was stalking probably, she wanted to kill one of the twins by saying that, so the brother wouldn't be jalous, and say she'll call the parents, the dad, because she knew they were the favorites, wanting to help the brother, she didn't acctualy kidnapped the brother but only the twins. It's just a theory !
But remember that it says they were kidnapped by an unknown MAN not woman. It would’ve been a man who kidnapped the twins. I don’t actually know the answer but based on the comments, it seems the majority of people think it’s the older brother. Think about it, he’s a man and he was part of the girls’ family. It said that the father gave them all of his attention so it wouldn’t be suspicious if the older brother took them out somewhere. It also states that EVERYONE was jealous of them, that could include the brother. The kidnapper, if it was the brother, wouldn’t reveal what he already knew about the twins therefore saying parents as a plural word. But there’s a problem with this theory, she said, “It was the kidnapperS,” it’s plural meaning there could be more than one kidnapper. I see why you thought what you thought but it doesn’t make as much sense even though both stories have holes in them. (This is just part of my theory as well!)
The brother. It’s mentioned that the father loves and adore the sisters, but it doesn’t seem like it’s ever mentioned that the brother was ever given much attention
It is the brother because the father always gave the twins all his attention and everything they wanted and the brother was very jealous that the father wasn't paying attention to him. Also when she was reading the only time she mentioned the brother is when she told us about the family but listen to how she says the father gives the twins everything they want but not the brother so It was the brother because he wanted to get revenge on his parents or something like that
The brother. He was jealous of the sisters because of all the attention they received from the father. He would have been able to easy get into the house with no signs of a break in or struggle and he would be close enough to know both Mandy and Melissa's names. He also would have been able to easily tell the twin girls apart.
This is very similar to a real life mystery about a brother running away from a rich home, saying he was kidnapped, and cut off his own ear just to get money from his parents. It was the brother, of course.
Definitely someone close to them since they can identify which one is Mandy and Melissa, and if everyone envy the two since they are loved by their parent, guess there only one family member left
Maybe the brother kidnapped Them because when he said if you escape blah blah blah your sister gets killed So I think the brother is testing them to see who would sacrifice there own sister to live because he said he was going to kill the sister not themselves
I thought there would be a plot twist, and was going to be something like "one of the twins died, so if one of the twins died and the kidnapper told the other twin, then who did the kidnapper kidnap?"
I think it’s the brother. They were identical twins so the kidnapper would have to know them well. He was jealous of how much their father loved his sisters so he kidnapped them
It was their brother. Because he was jealous of his sisters. Because if it wasn't the brother, how did he know Mandy and Melissa's names? If he could just be a stranger.
It’s the older brother because he can tell the difference between the two twins. He probably kidnapped them because he was jealous that their dad gave them all of his attention
I think it's the older brother. He is jealous that his father is giving all the attention to the twins so he decided to kidnap them and take his revenge
It all makes sense if it was the brother, he probably was jealous because his dad paid more attention to his sisters, and how mould have he know their names or know which twin is which?!
It was the brother he knew their names even though they were identical twins and she said the father loved them more then anything or something like that
It seems you are not such a loser, after all. The real shame here is that the girls could have loved their brother, and been friendly with him for the rest of their lives. It was their father who was making the brother jealous, not the sisters. But, he put an end to that possiblity, didn't he?
Exactly, he was jealous that he never gets attention, and he's supposed to be around to protect them, but he didn't, meaning he managed to kidnap them "since he's older he is way stronger, well age doesn't really matter that much but still"
Mostly the older brother, because the Dad loves the twins but the narrator never mentioned about the brother to, so there is a sign he got jealous, And after kidnapping them, he used helium to high pitched his voice so that the twins don't recognized his voice.
I think it’s the older brother, because he was jealous of the twins and wanting a large amount of money from their father because he didn’t get anything he wanted
I think it was the mother because she said parents. It was also a high voice which would increase the likelihood of it being the mother. I also think it was a joint effort because maybe the parents are divorced and if the sisters were killed then they couldn't receive his will if he died so the brother would get it
It was the brother. He was probably jealous of how his sisters were treated versus how he was treated. Also, if it wasnt him then how would he know the names of who was who, because remember- theyre identical twins and even if they would tell me their name id probably get it wrong.
It was the brother, he was probably jealous of the two sisters because everyone was jealous of them and the twins father only payed attention to them, this is also why the brother knew the twins names, Melissa and Mandy. As in the video they were kidnapped my a unknown man, they said it was unknown because the brother wasn’t a big part of the money. If one of the twins got killed then anyone outside the family wouldn’t tell anything apart but since the brother lived with the twins he could tell them apart
It says in the story that the father gave the girls everything they wanted but there was so mention of the older brother so he must be jealous of them and decided to take revenge
It was the brother because he was jealous of the twin sisters because his dad gave them whatever the sisters wanted. I knew bc it said they had an older brother and I knew the father wouldn't because the father loved the twins
it was probably the brother. he might've gotten jealous that his father spoiled his sister's and not him. although theres a possibility that it wasn't him, theres still a chance.
Its the brother since he was jealous of them being the favourite ones. The fact that he new their names (Mandy and Melissa), but because they are twins he also new who was who.
It was the brother. He was jealous of his sisters.
And that is also how he knew their names and knew which one was which. (As Melissa and Mandy)
But it said that he would contact the parents and there is only the brother and the dad
New it
Kinda weird how easy and obvious this is🤔
Yep
@@linkinwithlia2511 who would it be then? it was probably just a mistake the owner put. the brother and the father is the only people who knows the names of the twins. also Grandparents, foster parents, legal guardians, older brothers or sisters, widowed stepparents, and aunts and uncles are not considered parents unless they have legally adopted you. (I just copy pasted the last sentence from google btw)
It was probably the brother. He grew jealous of the twins because his father never paid any attention to him so he wanted to get revenge.
The girls were identical twins, but the brother could still tell them apart which would be hard for a person outside of the family to do (hence the name whispering)
He blindfolded the girls so they couldn't see and recognize him
He told the girls that he contacted their PARENTS just to make the girls think that the kidnapper is someone else and to make them less suspicious of him
Also for the people saying it was the mother, the riddle clearly said "an unknown MAN"
But i still have 1 question, if it indeed was the brother, then couldn't the girls recognize his voice? Maybe that's the reason he whispered instead of talking, cause in that case it would be harder to do so (also it said that the whispering was high pitched)
It said unknown man but how did they know it was a man if they were blindfolded ?? He or she could’ve been wearing a mask with a beanie or hiding the hair so that they would think it’s a man and so a lady would be the least suspicious
@@ivanahermoza4828 even high-pitched male voice is identifiable
@@Hal-fx9xx Sometimes but not all the time.
@@ivanahermoza4828 It’s not like this is real. She’s made up the story and the characters and she has decided that the kidnapper will be a man.
@@FroppyFroggy it is identifiable most of the time than not
I thought that both girls tried to escape so they were both killed- 💀
Same
SAME 😭
Lol same🤣
It was the brother, he was jealous so he decided to prank them so they wouldn’t like being rich and spoiled as much as they used to.
prank???
Kidnapping is not a prank, and the father spoiled them. It didn't say they did anything wrong, and if he was trying to "teach them", he probably would have gotten in a lot of trouble for falsely kidnapping them after he returned them.
Most normal prank in ohio
Umm the person who gave the details of what happened like how did they know blind folds were on them yea mabye people found them there but how do you know that he put them on there face and kidnapped them because that person is a sick person and wanted money and by sick I mean like what he did was horrible so yea but to me it’s kinda obvious plus also how do you know it was a man
"its just a prank bro"
The brother kidnapped them because he was jealous, and he was the only other person who could tell them apart, but he used ‘parents’ to confuse the girls.
You should be the fbi
But, they also asked "why did they do it?" and earlier said "everyone was jealous of them" and "they heard a high-pitched voice say in their ear" including their mother so what if their also had a part to play in this
I think it was probably the brother. He was jealous of how much attention the girls were getting. And he would’ve been one of the few who could tell them apart properly.
Edit: for those who are interested due to my pfp, I main Aether ;)
Omg aether its me lunime uwu im a dog now
@@ILoveRadishz O-o
@@ILoveRadishz ?
@@user-wp6sl7bz3m uwu
Agreed
"everyone was jealous of these girls because their father loved them so much and gave them everything they wanted and all his attention"
Me: it's the brother cause
1. Everyone was jealous of them that includes the brother
2. He knew their names
3. He knew who is who
4. He had their dad's number
5. It's obvious
"Can you solve this mystery?"
"No"
IT WAS THE MUFFIN MAN 😞💗
YES IT WAS HE IS A MEANIE 😭
@@lashawnas1st YEAH😾💗
THE MUFFIN MAN?!?
@@mejustme7757 THE MUFFIN MAN
@@mejustme7757 UES IT WAS YHE MUFFIN MAN
Wha-
But she said:"Parents",but they only lived with their dad and brother?
@Dolores Madrigal👂🏽 they said that he whispered in Mandy hear first AND THEN Melissa heard it
@Dolores Madrigal👂🏽 i was also gonna say the mother,but then it says the kidnapper was a man.... but the video also states the kidnapper was a unknown and never caught moreover mandy and melissa heard a high pitched voice... so how did they know the kidnapper was a man
Fr
The kidnapper was the brother because he was jealous how he was getting all the attention and he was one of the few people who knew their names and could tell them apart
She never said parents
It's a high pitched voice. It is probably the mother. It clicks to me every time. It's the mother bc she knows the name of the girls and also the voice is high pitched. The mother, as in the second parent said "I called ur *parents* " because she knows that both the parents are alive, as in she is the mother. Think logically. Who else would know the girls' names, the father's phone number, and that both the parents are alive.
I was scrolling through the comments and everyone is saying it’s the brother but why did he say parents if it was just the dad?
I think it’s the mother or a step mother that the dad left for whatever reason and she thought that he remarried or something like that so she wanted to have money for whatever she wanted it for (I’m not great at explaining stuff 😂)and she kidnapped them knowing that the dad loved them very much or she got jealous of the girls which is why the dad left her and she got mad
This is my comment and why I think it the mother just so you know lol
You are kinda right. She knew the Parents are alive and its not adding up to much if it was the brother because she never said "brother" or "big family of 5".
But like she said a man, so it also couldn't be the mom either.
It was their brother as him being a family member knew their names even though they were identical twins. He was jealous of them as they both got all attention of their dad
POV: you have to watch the video again to understand the story because you were too focused on watching her draw.
Edit: AINT NO WAY YOU GOOFY AHH GOOFY GOOBERS THIS IS THE MOST LIKES I HAVE EVER HAD! TYSM!
FAX 😎
Fr XD
DanTDM: and that's a fact
Fr
True
The only person that would know the difference between the twins is someone who has been with them almost their whole life, and if they live in a large mansion there would already be security so it could be someone on the inside and the only other person living with them other than their dad is their older brother
Everyone: Telling theories
Me : Omg her drawings so cool😍😍
It was either the kids who were jealous, or the brother because they were loved more and got more attention. The kids did it so they wouldn’t have to worry about being around rich people, and if the brother did it, then he probably would have been loved more than ever because the parent were scared that he would be kidnapped too.
Thank you if you like! 😊💗
Everyone:talking about the answer.
Me:trying to find out if the drawing is of the twins from the shining
Same
Sameee
Omg same 🤣
That’s what it looks like tho
the second I heard 'everyone was jealous of them because they got all their father's love', I knew it was the brother.
no brainer-
Dude when she said "the father loves the both twins. " and remembered there was a brother, immediately knew
It could be the brother cause they got all the attention so maybe he was jealous?
me: checking the comments for answers🙈
The older brother was jealous cuz his dad wouldn’t pay attention and his dad buys everything for the girls and not him so he wanted money from his dad so he kidnapped the girls to get what he wanted
Same lol
So true
So true
Same lol
It was the brother. His father was focusing ALL his attention on the twins making the brother feel neglected or something, so he decided to kidnap the twins.
It was the brothers because he was jealous, that is how he knew which one was which (Melissa and Mandy)
The older brother was so jealous of the two because the father had spoiled them. He was only said once in the story meaning he wasn't very important, or so you would think. He knew the names because he was the brother, he never got any attention because on the two so he wanted money from his father to get his attention and so he could finally be in control..
It was the brother. He was extremely jealous of the attention the girls got from their father, which explains how he can tell them apart
Pov:Everyone knows it's the brother cause he was jelous
i mean it has to be the brother.
1. He was jealous of his sisters
2. He new their names
3. He knew the difference between them
4. He knew their father would do anything to get his daughters back.
anyone gonna notice they said they lived with the dad and brother, yet they said parents?
edit: wait i think i got it
ok so basically i have this
the mom kidnapped them and said she contacted their parents but only their dad to get 1 million after some kinda divorce
edit 2: nvm anyways i started a debate in my replies
edit 3:BRO THE LIKES
The mom died,and they put the grave near the house
@@Go2sleepnow3 ?
She said kidnapped by an unknown man and he said . Everyone was jealous so it includes their brother but high pitched voice confuses me
@@roshinipriyadarshini6956 oh ur right
@@roshinipriyadarshini6956 moreover how did the kidnapper manage to know who is melissa and who is mandy
I don't think it's the brother. He said "I will contact *your parents*" when there isn't a mother. The brother would know that already. And who said the kidnapper knew wich girls were they, if they're blindfold ? The brother would know that by how they act, so I don't think it's the brother, probably the mother who left the dad, wanted to kill one of the girls because the brother were her favorite when he was young (the mom left the dad AFTER the brother was born, she never met the twins, or maybe she only saw them when they were born.) so since she was stalking probably, she wanted to kill one of the twins by saying that, so the brother wouldn't be jalous, and say she'll call the parents, the dad, because she knew they were the favorites, wanting to help the brother, she didn't acctualy kidnapped the brother but only the twins.
It's just a theory !
But remember that it says they were kidnapped by an unknown MAN not woman. It would’ve been a man who kidnapped the twins. I don’t actually know the answer but based on the comments, it seems the majority of people think it’s the older brother. Think about it, he’s a man and he was part of the girls’ family. It said that the father gave them all of his attention so it wouldn’t be suspicious if the older brother took them out somewhere. It also states that EVERYONE was jealous of them, that could include the brother. The kidnapper, if it was the brother, wouldn’t reveal what he already knew about the twins therefore saying parents as a plural word. But there’s a problem with this theory, she said, “It was the kidnapperS,” it’s plural meaning there could be more than one kidnapper. I see why you thought what you thought but it doesn’t make as much sense even though both stories have holes in them. (This is just part of my theory as well!)
A GAME THEORY
It was the brother. It said the MAN that kidnapped them.
No
Just because the mom wasn't mentioned doesn't mean she doesn't exist
The brother. It’s mentioned that the father loves and adore the sisters, but it doesn’t seem like it’s ever mentioned that the brother was ever given much attention
I feel like it’d be their mom, they’d recognize their brother’s voice
Ooh i get it
The older brother bc he did not get any attention and he was jealoussss
But it said that he would contact the parents and there is only the brother and the dad
@@linkinwithlia2511 r u trying to say the brother is a parent? . _.
@@Departing_Sanity no I am saying their aren’t any PARENTS just a dad
@@linkinwithlia2511 oh ok
@@linkinwithlia2511 So Theres Just NO PARENTS Just A Dad?
His brother he knew their names also
probably the brother that was jealous as the kidnapper already knew their names so it must've been someone they knew
It is the brother because the father always gave the twins all his attention and everything they wanted and the brother was very jealous that the father wasn't paying attention to him. Also when she was reading the only time she mentioned the brother is when she told us about the family but listen to how she says the father gives the twins everything they want but not the brother so It was the brother because he wanted to get revenge on his parents or something like that
Ayo the brother could literally just talk to the parents about this and not make this dramatic by kidnapping his own sisters-
POV: Your finding hints at the comments.
Me; The brother
Yeah I didn't even have to look at the comments to know it was their brother💀🤣
same
It was the brother as Mandy and Melissa got all their parents attention
Who else went to the comments?
Also this is a creepy mystery, my name is also Mandy and I am a twin as well 😅
MY SISTER IS NAMED MELLISSA
also it's spelt like dat
POV: your looking in the comments to find the answer
The brother - he was jeaaalousss 😏
The brother. He knows them. He knows the dad's number. He knows their name. He knows which one is which. It's him!
The OLDER BROTHER HE DIDNT GET ALL THE ATTENTION AND COULD GET IN THIER ROOMS EASILY
Aaaaannnd he knew both of their names and could tell who is who
Easy it's the older brother 🤔
I'm gonna go out on a limb here and say he kidnapped them for money
The brother. He was jealous of the sisters because of all the attention they received from the father. He would have been able to easy get into the house with no signs of a break in or struggle and he would be close enough to know both Mandy and Melissa's names. He also would have been able to easily tell the twin girls apart.
the brother, how'd he know the names, and he's probably jelous cause they get all the attention.
Her: can you solve this mystery
My stupid self: no
“Checks comments”
True
High pitched? Sounds like a kid . He knows their name ? Sounds like they know him. They have a brother? Hell yah sibling slaughter
This is very similar to a real life mystery about a brother running away from a rich home, saying he was kidnapped, and cut off his own ear just to get money from his parents. It was the brother, of course.
Definitely someone close to them since they can identify which one is Mandy and Melissa, and if everyone envy the two since they are loved by their parent, guess there only one family member left
“With her FATHER” - 1 parent
“I’ve contacted your PARENTS” - 2 parents
It was the mother 🤌🏻
The mother died and the grave was next to the home apparently??
But she said he and I’m not saying your wrong though
Why would the mother say parents if she was the one demanding-.-
This comment is just a joke answer plz don’t take it srsly 👁👄👁
It was the brother. He was the other person who could tell the differences between them.
Maybe the brother kidnapped Them because when he said if you escape blah blah blah your sister gets killed
So I think the brother is testing them to see who would sacrifice there own sister to live because he said he was going to kill the sister not themselves
I thought there would be a plot twist, and was going to be something like "one of the twins died, so if one of the twins died and the kidnapper told the other twin, then who did the kidnapper kidnap?"
It was the older brother bc he was probably jealous of the twins and how much affection they got from their dad
Yeah it was the brother, the fact he knew which twin was which gave it away too lol
It was the bro cus the dad only gave attention and everything or whatever to the sisters and not him lmao
But then, wouldn't the brother hate the dad?
Maybe the Sisters loved their brother very much. 🙂
it was the brother he was jealous of them and he was the only one who knew how to tell them apart
The older brother for sure!
See, he was envying his sisters and wanted attention, so he kidnapped them.
I think it’s the brother. They were identical twins so the kidnapper would have to know them well. He was jealous of how much their father loved his sisters so he kidnapped them
It was their brother. Because he was jealous of his sisters.
Because if it wasn't the brother, how did he know Mandy and Melissa's names? If he could just be a stranger.
The older brother as how would the kidnapper know their names?💅
The brother, I knew right when it said they were kidnapped because it said EVERYONE was jealous of them
It was the brother he was jealous that the sister's were adored so he kidnapped them and that's how he knew their names
The brother had kidnapped them because he became jealous, since Melissa and Mandy got all of their fathers attention
It’s the older brother because he can tell the difference between the two twins. He probably kidnapped them because he was jealous that their dad gave them all of his attention
I think it's the older brother. He is jealous that his father is giving all the attention to the twins so he decided to kidnap them and take his revenge
It all makes sense if it was the brother, he probably was jealous because his dad paid more attention to his sisters, and how mould have he know their names or know which twin is which?!
your drawing is so good heidi wong
It was the brother he grew jealous of the twins cuz the father gave them attention a lot of attention more than him
just as i hears the part where the father spoiled them, i knew it was the brother.
It was the brother he knew their names even though they were identical twins and she said the father loved them more then anything or something like that
It seems you are not such a loser, after all.
The real shame here is that the girls could have loved their brother, and been friendly with him for the rest of their lives.
It was their father who was making the brother jealous, not the sisters.
But, he put an end to that possiblity, didn't he?
It was the brother because the brother grew jealous and kidnapped the twins and he can tell them apart so he knows their names
Exactly, he was jealous that he never gets attention, and he's supposed to be around to protect them, but he didn't, meaning he managed to kidnap them "since he's older he is way stronger, well age doesn't really matter that much but still"
Am i the only one that Right after i heard “they were a rich family” said .”thats reason enough”
Mostly the older brother, because the Dad loves the twins but the narrator never mentioned about the brother to, so there is a sign he got jealous, And after kidnapping them, he used helium to high pitched his voice so that the twins don't recognized his voice.
The brother was jealous and everyone was so jealous too so the girls were kidnapped by the brother for money or love.
I think it’s the older brother, because he was jealous of the twins and wanting a large amount of money from their father because he didn’t get anything he wanted
I think it was the mother because she said parents. It was also a high voice which would increase the likelihood of it being the mother. I also think it was a joint effort because maybe the parents are divorced and if the sisters were killed then they couldn't receive his will if he died so the brother would get it
I feel like the brother kidnapped both of them idk?
The brother. He didn't get enough attention and he knew the twins names.
I think it’s one of the workers in their house because it was an unknown voice and if it was the older brother they would have known the voice.
The brother did it. He was jealous. He was one of not many that could tell them apart.
It was the brother. He was probably jealous of how his sisters were treated versus how he was treated. Also, if it wasnt him then how would he know the names of who was who, because remember- theyre identical twins and even if they would tell me their name id probably get it wrong.
It was the brother, he was probably jealous of the two sisters because everyone was jealous of them and the twins father only payed attention to them, this is also why the brother knew the twins names, Melissa and Mandy. As in the video they were kidnapped my a unknown man, they said it was unknown because the brother wasn’t a big part of the money. If one of the twins got killed then anyone outside the family wouldn’t tell anything apart but since the brother lived with the twins he could tell them apart
It was the brother because she never said anything about the brother getting love that's also how he knew who was who
The Kidnapper kidnapped the twins and demanded ransom from his parents easy😂
It says in the story that the father gave the girls everything they wanted but there was so mention of the older brother so he must be jealous of them and decided to take revenge
The kidnapper knows they’re name so it could be their brother
It was the brother because he was jealous of the twin sisters because his dad gave them whatever the sisters wanted.
I knew bc it said they had an older brother and I knew the father wouldn't because the father loved the twins
The brother: he was probably mad, sad, or jealous of the 2 because the sisters got all they wanted and he was never mentioned
it was probably the brother. he might've gotten jealous that his father spoiled his sister's and not him. although theres a possibility that it wasn't him, theres still a chance.
the brother might have hired someone to kiddnapthem and got loads of money, or its just the brother
The brother did it, he knew their names and was probably jealous of them.
Its the brother since he was jealous of them being the favourite ones. The fact that he new their names (Mandy and Melissa), but because they are twins he also new who was who.
Imagine if the brother got the sisters wrong 😂
It was probably the police and my theory is that the sisters father's were robbers which is why they were rich
The brother was jealous of how much attention the twins were getting that's how he new them from mandy and Melissa