I LOVE THIS SONG SO MUCH! A year ago I was working on TL5Y backstage and we did have a female Jamie and it was honestly so much more heartbreaking for me standing side stage every time she sang it. This version too. It rips through me.
Agh I love The Last Five Years, this is so good. The choice to make Jamie try to communicate with Cathy as earnestly as he (or is it she in this case?) can is incredible, I love it so much
You seem to have a knack for posting whenever I’m about to do homework. Please continue to do so it helps marvellously with procrastinating. Edit: holy wow the talent I- Edit 2: well I don’t know what else I was expecting you are always amazing
OMG you did not just re-sing my favorite cover of yours!!! Ngl I listened to that video almost every day for two months EDIT: Guys she's saying Cathy's name in this one!!!!!
I'm just getting to this now because youtube died, and oh my god it was totally worth the wait!!! Mariah!! This was so good! I love your voice so much. And my god, your acting??? It's improved so much, I really believe you. Edit: typo
AHHH MY HEART! I ABSOLUTELY CRIED! You are a GOSH darn QUEEN you know? Gee I LOVE the emotion you can portray with you voice! That's so crazy! The more I watch the more I fall in love with this channel! Yo keep being awesome my dude!
@@MariahCasillas me watching this and not seeing among us: are you sure about that there is one impostor among us channel among us mariah was the impostor this comment is a mess imma stop typing now
There are people And they are publishing my book And there's a party that they're throwing And while you've made it very clear that you're not going I will be going And that's done But what's it really about? Is it really about a party, Cathy? Can we please for a minute stop blaming And say what you feel? Is it just that you're disappointed To be touring again for the summer? Did you think this would all be much easier Then it's turned out to be? Well, then talk to me, Cathy Talk to me If I didn't believe in you We'd never have gotten this far If I didn't believe in you And all of the ten thousand women you are If I didn't think you could do Anything you ever wanted to If I wasn't certain that you'd come through somehow The fact of the matter is, Cathy I wouldn't be standing here now If I didn't believe in you We wouldn't be having this fight If I didn't believe in you I'd walk out the door and say "Cathy, you're right" But I never could let that go Knowing the things about you I know Things, when I met you four years ago, I knew It never took much convincing To make me believe in you Don't we get to be happy, Cathy? At some point down the line Don't we get to relax? Without some new tourist To push me yet further from you? If I'm cheering on your side, Cathy Why can't you support mine? Why do I have to feel I've committed some felony Doing what I always swore I would do? I don't want you to hurt I don't want you to sink But you know what I think? I think you'll be fine! Just hang on and you'll see But don't make me wait till you do To be happy with you Will you listen to me? No one can give you courage No one can thicken your skin I will not fail so you can be comfortable, Cathy I will not lose because you can't win If I didn't believe in your Then here's where the travelogue ends If I didn't believe in you I couldn't have stood before all of our friends And said, "This is the life I choose This is the thing I can't bear to lose Trip us or trap us, but we refuse to fall" That's what I thought we agreed on, Cathy If I hadn't believed in you I wouldn't have loved you at all
i subscribed after i saw your cover of dead girl walking on tumblr and got addicted and replayed your cover of i didnt believe in you atleast 10 times a day for a month three years ago so it feels so nostalgic to see this again!! the talent ma'am!!!!!!!
Like, he’s not just trying to put the blame on her for not communicating and leading the attention away from her legitimate sadness and anger, he’s actually trying to communicate, and I love that (also, female Jamie is something I didn’t know I needed)
What do you use to put the music in the background so it’s not just sounding shitty coming thru the regular mic? Or does it come thru the regular mic bc it sounds so good
It's from the Last Five Years. I definitely recommend you check it out; Jason Robert Brown's music is gorgeous! There's 3 different recordings of this musical, but my favorite is the one with Norbert Leo Butz and Sherie Renée Scott.
Only after listening to the covers of the song do I realize that there's actually a few differences in the movie and the musical: Musical: Is it just that you're disappointed to be touring again this summer? Movie: Is it just that you're disappointed to be going again to Ohio? Musical: Without some new tourist Movie: Without some new tsuris (trouble) Musical: Now, why don't you put your dress on and we'll go, okay? Cathy? Can we just do that please? Please! Movie: Does not exist(or at least not in the song)
This is one of my top musical theater songs! There's this incredible analysis of the song that I love by Mateo czcams.com/video/F_P-KtJDw6Q/video.html and I love your version and also Jonathan Bailey's version. Gah I love this song so happy you posted it!
ok i've only listened to i can do better than that and a minute thirty of this so I don't know the plot but this feels like I'm on facetime call with my wife and shes confronting me about all the shit I've done and I didn't expect her to. omg the emotions
omg, my lesbian heart realising how good it would be if Jamie was a woman - like, she’d still do a lot of shitty things, but everything would just be so much better (the og straight version is still good of course, I just very severely dislike Jamie)
mariah the last five years
🤝
being re-obsessed with the show every now and then
Why is that me tho😂
JAIME 👏 SHOULD 👏BE 👏A 👏WOMAN. 👏 a WLW The last five years is iconic
YES
I actually played Jamie with one of my friends and we changed the pronouns to make it wlw, it was amazing!!
Did a local production of it last year where one couple was 2 women. It was 😍
Yes please
But with a better ending pls 😭😭
Love the Willie jingles in the background, it really enhanced the performance ✨
This cover was so powerful it temporarily broke CZcams 😂
Me: Found the original video two days ago
*CZcams reawakens from its outage and sees this*
Me: Oh, goody gumdrops! This makes it worth it!
The lyrical transition from present tense to past tense 🙃😥
that always causes a little pain in my heart
why did i take this so personally. acting skills are through the roof
1: This was excellent
2: Lesbian TL5Y
I was just rewatching the first one this week! I already know this one will be even better!
okay i know i’m late but this woman is so powerful and her voice is so gorgeous that she single handedly broke the internet
i know right everytime i hear her i mcswoon hard
@@farateq *definitely* (also hi again)
Lorn Lope i’m two days late but hi lol i see you everywhere
I LOVE THIS SONG SO MUCH!
A year ago I was working on TL5Y backstage and we did have a female Jamie and it was honestly so much more heartbreaking for me standing side stage every time she sang it.
This version too. It rips through me.
Agh I love The Last Five Years, this is so good. The choice to make Jamie try to communicate with Cathy as earnestly as he (or is it she in this case?) can is incredible, I love it so much
I WAS JUST LISTENING TO THE LAST FIVE YEARS. YAAAASSS! PERFECT WAY TO START MY DAY
You seem to have a knack for posting whenever I’m about to do homework. Please continue to do so it helps marvellously with procrastinating.
Edit: holy wow the talent I-
Edit 2: well I don’t know what else I was expecting you are always amazing
this was posted right after I got this song out of my head. am I the chosen one?
✨yes✨
yer a chosen one emily
MARIAH..I-THE TALENR
This is phenomenal! Great job, Mariah - you are so talented!
TALENT
OMG you did not just re-sing my favorite cover of yours!!! Ngl I listened to that video almost every day for two months
EDIT: Guys she's saying Cathy's name in this one!!!!!
mariah's hair is looking fly today, it's like it became an airplane
ok fine i'll just shut up and leave that "pun" didn't even make sense
not mariah making me cry again because of how her good her singing and acting is
rip she uploaded this right when youtube died
What??
@@madeleine.exists9207 it died a couple hours ago, videos wouldn't load
@@farateq oh. I think i was playing among us when that happened😂
@@madeleine.exists9207 lol
Your covers are literally my favorite to listen to, I’m obsessed with them
This was amazing!! I just rewatched the movie version like a day ago at 4 in the morning
I don’t know who you are but could tell as you spoke your singing voice was gonna be great, and you did not disappoint
Petition of TLFY to be revived just so Mariah can play Jamie
such. a. good. musical. and a beautiful voice!!
my heart SWELLS for this cover mariahh!!!
Can you Re-sing Ment to be yours from Heathers please!!!!!!
i think the one we have now is amazing but if it was better and i watched it i would be a bigger tomato than amity blight
I'm just getting to this now because youtube died, and oh my god it was totally worth the wait!!!
Mariah!! This was so good! I love your voice so much. And my god, your acting??? It's improved so much, I really believe you.
Edit: typo
I saw the clip of this on Instagram and came to CZcams to watch the full cover and turns out CZcams isn’t working so I can’t watch your video 😔
CZcams isn’t working for me either
the talent!!!
I love this show, can't wait to play Cathy when theatres open again. Your voice is beautiful x
Mariah, I won't ask what because it's none of my business, but it seems like you're going through something, and i really hope you'll be okay. Ilysm❤
ah nah i’m fine but i’ve BEEN through it past tense
@@MariahCasillas okay good to know❤
Pleaaaaase do a new cover of Waving Through A Window. The short clip you posted a few years ago was amazing, and we need a full version!
What a wonderful re sing ! I love both versions so much
So many chills...
this is SO GOOD MARIAH
AHHH MY HEART! I ABSOLUTELY CRIED! You are a GOSH darn QUEEN you know?
Gee I LOVE the emotion you can portray with you voice! That's so crazy! The more I watch the more I fall in love with this channel!
Yo keep being awesome my dude!
literal chills
I'm sorry, I thought this was an among us channel.
YOU RIGHT
@@MariahCasillas me watching this and not seeing among us: are you sure about that
there is one impostor among us channel among us
mariah was the impostor
this comment is a mess
imma stop typing now
There are people
And they are publishing my book
And there's a party that they're throwing
And while you've made it very clear that you're not going
I will be going
And that's done
But what's it really about?
Is it really about a party, Cathy?
Can we please for a minute stop blaming
And say what you feel?
Is it just that you're disappointed
To be touring again for the summer?
Did you think this would all be much easier
Then it's turned out to be?
Well, then talk to me, Cathy
Talk to me
If I didn't believe in you
We'd never have gotten this far
If I didn't believe in you
And all of the ten thousand women you are
If I didn't think you could do
Anything you ever wanted to
If I wasn't certain that you'd come through somehow
The fact of the matter is, Cathy
I wouldn't be standing here now
If I didn't believe in you
We wouldn't be having this fight
If I didn't believe in you
I'd walk out the door and say
"Cathy, you're right"
But I never could let that go
Knowing the things about you I know
Things, when I met you four years ago, I knew
It never took much convincing
To make me believe in you
Don't we get to be happy, Cathy?
At some point down the line
Don't we get to relax?
Without some new tourist
To push me yet further from you?
If I'm cheering on your side, Cathy
Why can't you support mine?
Why do I have to feel
I've committed some felony
Doing what I always swore I would do?
I don't want you to hurt
I don't want you to sink
But you know what I think?
I think you'll be fine!
Just hang on and you'll see
But don't make me wait till you do
To be happy with you
Will you listen to me?
No one can give you courage
No one can thicken your skin
I will not fail so you can be comfortable, Cathy
I will not lose because you can't win
If I didn't believe in your
Then here's where the travelogue ends
If I didn't believe in you
I couldn't have stood before all of our friends
And said, "This is the life I choose
This is the thing I can't bear to lose
Trip us or trap us, but we refuse to fall"
That's what I thought we agreed on, Cathy
If I hadn't believed in you
I wouldn't have loved you at all
queen doing queen things
oh okay OKAY okay when do we get to do TL5Y together and switch roles every show
This is EXACTLY what I needed today. Thank you 😌
I love this song!!!
i subscribed after i saw your cover of dead girl walking on tumblr and got addicted and replayed your cover of i didnt believe in you atleast 10 times a day for a month three years ago so it feels so nostalgic to see this again!! the talent ma'am!!!!!!!
... may i simp?
BRO I JUST GOT INTO THIS MUSICAL AND LISTENED TO UR OLD COVER UR STALKING ME U HAVE TO BE
WOW what a voice. killed it queen
ps: where did you get the track from?
If you look up “If I Didn’t Believe In You female” the track is on CZcams
I love how earnest you made Jamie
Like, he’s not just trying to put the blame on her for not communicating and leading the attention away from her legitimate sadness and anger, he’s actually trying to communicate, and I love that (also, female Jamie is something I didn’t know I needed)
This is beautiful! Oh girl you're talented!
ICON
What do you use to put the music in the background so it’s not just sounding shitty coming thru the regular mic? Or does it come thru the regular mic bc it sounds so good
i download the instrumental i used and overlay it!!
The improvement is incredible! Also your version literally broke my heart ♥️ (in a good way)
mY EMOTIONS-
i’ve just gotta say your videos are higher quality than my life
song begins at 0:54
Omg, I would Kill to see you play Jamie 🙈
haha yes
this is incredible Mariah❤🥰
I really need a cover with you and Matthew
You make such a likeable jamie and it scares me 😂
Periodt
Can someone tell me what musical this is I feel out of place listening to her gorgeous voice and not knowing the musical XD
The last 5 years
It's from the Last Five Years. I definitely recommend you check it out; Jason Robert Brown's music is gorgeous! There's 3 different recordings of this musical, but my favorite is the one with Norbert Leo Butz and Sherie Renée Scott.
@@madeleine.exists9207 Thank you! I've listened to the soundtrack of TL5Y and new I recognized this song, but couldn't put my finger on it! Thank you!
@@mumsiewhachacallit6497 you're welcome!
A concept: Mariah singing Pretty Funny from Dogfight
I LOVE THIS CHANNEL
ouchie it hurts
The last time you covered this was January 18, 2017!
Hi yes it’s super late ignore that lmao but any tips on lifting your soft pallete while singing? I’m really struggling with this right now :)
Remarkable.
Fun fact: Cathy Hyatt has the same amount of syllables as Mariah..see where im going with this?
I didn't need to cry today, but whatever I guess.
is there a way i can get a video tatted
Damn you killed it
Only after listening to the covers of the song do I realize that there's actually a few differences in the movie and the musical:
Musical: Is it just that you're disappointed to be touring again this summer?
Movie: Is it just that you're disappointed to be going again to Ohio?
Musical: Without some new tourist
Movie: Without some new tsuris (trouble)
Musical: Now, why don't you put your dress on and we'll go, okay? Cathy? Can we just do that please? Please!
Movie: Does not exist(or at least not in the song)
The Alice voice really came through in this one
It feels so much more earnest and less gaslight-y coming from a female Jamie....and I can’t figure out why
you last sang this on January 18th, 2017.
This is one of my top musical theater songs! There's this incredible analysis of the song that I love by Mateo czcams.com/video/F_P-KtJDw6Q/video.html
and I love your version and also Jonathan Bailey's version. Gah I love this song so happy you posted it!
What key is this in?
ok i've only listened to i can do better than that and a minute thirty of this so I don't know the plot but this feels like I'm on facetime call with my wife and shes confronting me about all the shit I've done and I didn't expect her to. omg the emotions
omg, my lesbian heart realising how good it would be if Jamie was a woman - like, she’d still do a lot of shitty things, but everything would just be so much better (the og straight version is still good of course, I just very severely dislike Jamie)