Some people complaining about his voice...it's called getting old, performing live and being caught up in the moment. Imagine being 80 and still being able to perform like this and the crowd knowing lyrics from songs you performed in your 20s.
I don't think his voice is bad at all; all voices change as the career goes on, never mind by the age of 80, and yet he is still able to do the job. He still sounds pretty good, he clearly has enthusiasm and isn't just going through the motions.
his voice was much worse 20 yrs ago. I think he really prepared for this moment. His voice was purposely dominated by the band in the mix but probably didn't need it. What a champ.
I like the fact that he's humble enough to try and sing the most as possible. Any other artist would point the mic to the crowd and expect the audience to sing, but not Paul. Have also in mind he just got off a tour in the US! He hasn't taken a break.
@Paul McCartney If that is true, is there any particular reason that you joined on December 29th? You realize that you can possibly put on your ACTAUL official channel that you have a community-type account? I'm very very sure that ain't you tho mr. "McCartney"
In this song,I would tend to agree. I think the chance to 'sing' with his mate,John reinvigorates his voice. He reaches high notes that he cannot reach at other times. We all age but Paul is a musical genius and no one can ever take that away from him.
Absolutely! Just so cool to see him turn around and listen to John. Gave me goosebumps when I saw it live last summer and still gives me goosebumps and a tears of joy
When John started his part and Paul stood there, saw and heard him it brought some youthful energy into him again, you can tell by how he starts hitting his notes! I can only imagine how much Paul misses John.
This guy came into my life in 1964, when I was 13/14. He's been there all along. We're all old now. When he goes, I won't be far behind. Thanks for the music.
What you said at the end is exactly what I said when I was able to meet my musical idol Thom Yorke. I simply thanked him for the music, and said it changed my life. He said "me too, man. me too." What a moment.
@@funlittlefish There are no other Beatles. That's like missing your friend and someone says, If you liked your partner, let me introduce you to Leslie. Well, maybe it's not totally off. But...
That’s really something when John appears on that screen, playing in sync with his partner in the greatest songwriting duo in popular music history, across a span of 53 years. Amazing.
I had the opportunity to talk with Paul's live sound engineer Pab before the show in Baltimore in June; that segment is so extremely rudimentary - only Abe had a click track in his in-ears for that whole song and Wix had some control over the tempo; I'm assuming with a tap pad or something to adjust the BPM. The rest of the song's performance was guided through the stage monitors. That's the only cue that Paul had. What a testament to how tight he and John were (and how tight he, Rusty, Abe, Wix and Brian are) that after all these years, all he needs to sync up for a live performance of I've Got A Feeling is John's isloated vocals from 1969.
When John appeared on the screen, Paul's voice got stronger. Like it hyped him up. So many mixed emotions watching this. Bittersweet. Slightly more sweet than bitter but pretty much evenhanded.
@@claudevieaul1465 yes. I object to the stupidity of saying he sounds thirty! He is a musical genius, with one of the most recognizable voices ever. Even at 80. And this format with the recorded Lennon is super creative.
Just be aware that an actual real live Beatle still actually performs these magnificent songs really well for nearly 80 years of age on this earthly plain...oh yeah. Thank you Paul.🙂
I went to his Melbourne show when he performed this and John came on his voice sounded so fucking good like it was already great but it sounded incredible for this song
It's cliche to say this but honestly, this moved me to tears and I'm not one to cry easily. Seeing Paul play with his best mate again, it probably takes him back all those years. RIP John and thank you Paul for living so graciously and carrying his spirit with you
I saw the show in the U.S. & when this came on even the guy next to me was crying…so don’t feel bad. Everyone had the same reaction. It was so great & sad @ the same time.
48 years old, been to hundreds of gigs. Watched this on my sofa and cried. The Beatles split before I was old enough to get into music but they mean so much.
Paul turns around and faces the screen because as much as I’m sure he knows the fans will get a kick out of John being on the screen, it’s all for him. This gives him another chance to sing with his first partner and best friend.
McCartney is playing live with the recording of Lennon made 53 years earlier, still in the same key, still nailing that tricky guitar rhythm, still hitting all the vocal notes and tones perfectly. Just amazing.
Před rokem+18
The fact that Paul still sings his repertoire in the same key, even with his current voice, is amazing. Guitar rythm is not tricky at all.
@ Well, the original rhythm played by Lennon is kind of tricky, but you can learn it. However, Paul, plays a sloppier version of it. I personally don't agree with singing stuff in the original key being a great idea in this age. In this performance, he still managed to sound good, but that's not true for all of his songs. Songs in lower keys (like Lady Madonna) generally sound better when he sings them these days. Im not even sure if hitting all these high notes is health for his voice. If you compare his vocal performances from 7 years ago with the ones from Billy Joel now, you'll realise that Billies voice sounds stronger and generally better. This is because he transposes almost all of his songs down - since decades. I think, transposing songs down when your voice ages is a really good technique of dealing with a changing voice over the years.
Před rokem+3
@@aheendwhz1 I know! I meant it's amazing that he's still trying to do the songs in original keys. He pulled it off for decades with great results, but he's stubborn about key changes. I don't think he's ever going to do it. He tried it with that 'Here there and Everywhere' 2016 piano version but it seems like he didn't like it at all.
He's not singing perfectly. There's a frailty in his voice which, given his immense legacy, is quite touching. I love his old man's voice for what it is, it isn't fair to compare. There's absolutely no one to touch Paul’s singing from 1964 to about 1976. Certainly not present day Paul, by any stretch of imagination.
Před rokem+4
@@RayMusicman9 Paul's 2002 tour was a great period vocally as well. Even into the 2010s he still sounded younger than his real age!
He's doing great for an 80 year old but you could hear him struggling to sing that song. But that's ok he's a Beatle and part of our growing up. I loved this just the same.
@@jimmoore826 Exactly, his voice has changed a lot, but man, he's 80 yo, over 60 years of career and still plays and writes really well. He's a living legend.
Who has imagined before that 80 years old Paul McCartney sings Rock’n’Roll with 28 years old John Lennon in front of a huge crowd !! Young like granddaughters & grandsons are singing along I’ve got a feeling!! This definitely is MAGICAL MYSTERY TOUR concert!! Long live Paul please ! Thank you !!
Yep I grew up with the Beatles and saw them when they made their debut on Ed Sullivan when I was only 5 years old watching that with my whole family and my older siblings . We grow up with the Beatles and always had their music in our house they were just a part of our lives . Makes me glad to see that he and Ringo have made it to live to be 80
The "Ive Got a Feeling Take 1" on the Rooftop is my favorite, and one of the greatest live performances of all time. Paul's vocals are unbelievable. John, George, & Ringo are all killing it per usual, and Billy Preston adds so much with his keys. To hear Paul still crushing this song, at 80 nonetheless, is so amazing to me. 53 YEARS LATER
The rooftop version is really amazing, and at 80, well, it's also inspiring, you can just keep going until you drop, doing what you love, important message for everyone.
@@tf2368 He's moved to respond by a legendary musician playing a legendary music festival. You're moved to respond by a simple CZcams comment. Who is more easily moved? I'm aware of the irony in me doing this, but I like to encourage people to engage their brains. Whether I succeed is really down to whether you can.
Am I the only one that got goosebumps when John came up on screen and and tears came to my eyes.. It's a reminder of just how damn good they were together
@@bls8959 "Ya he sounded rough" no, not for an 80 year old, that's far from rough. He's definitely struggling, mainly during the bridge (AWAWAWWA lol), and of course he doesn't sound like he used to, but that's still better singing than most people will achieve in their lifetime. I'm sorry, it sounds _good._
shout out to the sound tech that tempo mapped the rooftop concert so they were all able to play in sync w the video, this is some elite level production
Even you could do that, Zach. Just tap the beat to the original on a midi keyboard, or even record the sound of you tapping or clapping the beat along with the original, and then play it back in their in-ears. Rather shout out to the ones cleaning the toilets after Glastonbury. A lot more deserved, and a lot more complicated;-)
I was in the crowd on this day . Me and my family had come to Glastonbury for the weekend and the Friday before and it was my first music festival of my entire life. We went to see Sir Paul do his concert. I am a huge Beatles fan and was extremely excited and my excitement payed off. After the main concert, we stayed for about a minute before Paul marched around the stage with a Ukrainian flag. He then told us Peter Jackson had isolated John’s vocals from the rooftop concert and they were going to perform with John live again. Me and my whole family were in tears when we heard his voice. It actually sounded like he was really there. This concert was truly something special, and I hope Macca will continue to do live concerts for years to come.
That they were able to sync up Lennon's vocal track to this performance tells you how rock solid Ringo's drumming was. I mean no lag no rushing, just right on the beat.
I think the clip is from Get Back the new film from Peter Jackson. They used AI and other tech to isolate all the different components of the tracks from mono recordings from the time. So I think it's likely that John's singing has been isolated from the drumming.
I can’t help but get emotional watching this. I’m the same age now that Paul was when he sang on that rooftop, and I’m a musician because of the Beatles. I even got to play on a rooftop unsanctioned by the authorities (wonder where the boys and I got that idea ?) and I also have some friends that I used to play and sing with that are no longer here with us. I can’t even imagine what Sir Paul was feeling when John popped up on that screen. Thank you Paul, for being my inspiration to become a bass player, a songwriter, and thank you Peter Jackson for giving the world the opportunity to hear these two sing together across time and space. Just stunning.
Can you imagine John actually recovered from the shots back in the day? He makes a full recovery, plays for many more years. Beatles got together one more time before George actually passing away. And now, 20 years later, as casual as he always was, John randomly pops up on stage and sings this tune with his old pal like it hasn't passed a day. Can you imagine?
@@karlkk5191 lol yeah I know. It’s just, John’s death feels so… unfair, you know? But George (as sad as it sounds) kinda had it coming, he smoked like a godamn chimney and everyone told him to chill on the cigarettes. But sure, I often wonder what would George think of current events or the state of the world and politics right now
Paul's work ethic at 80 is quite an inspiration. A 3 hour set like that is not just 3 hours on the stage--there were a lot of hours of rehearsals with the band to get some quite complex music (including this one) up to performance standard.
Paul still rockin' at 80 years old. I saw him in May of this year at the Oakland Arena. I had never seen him play live, so I had to go this time around. Paul moves around the stage like he's still in his 20s he is amazing. I know people that are younger than him get around with walkers and canes, and very shakey afoot, but Paul steady as a rock throughout the whole 3 hours he was on stage rockin' away...he's amazing, and you got to know that he will continue to rock, as long as he can, because it is so much a part of him...he needs to perform, its in his DNA...and I'm appreciative of that!😁👍🎶
There is a hilarious clip of him on a talk show (maybe the Frost Show?) Sometime in the later 60s where he says "well, it would be pretty sad if I'm prancing around on the stage at FORTY"
I've seen Paul 4 x and Ringo 1 x. I am so very happy. Beatlemania never end. Never. After Bach and Beethoven comes The Beatles as comet on the earth. Happiness for mankind. ❤️ ♥️ ❤️ ♥️ ❤️ ♥️
I love how he turns to face John. It was also very lovely how he said how much he loved him, how you could never say it back in the day and then Paul reminded us to appreciate our loved ones why we still have them. Brilliant stuff.
In 45 years I've never had chills from a concert. I never thought I would see John Lennon and Paul perform... modern technology may often be the bane of our existence but it also is miraculous. Amazing. Tears.
John ❤ I am not one of those cry-babies but I think I would have started crying when John appeared on that screen. I miss his voice. Musically and socially.
So sad I missed that show - I had an Hawaiian vacation planned for over a year and considered changing the date (at great expense) just to see this at Fenway.....I am jealous
I guess music keeps him preserved. It's nice to see such power at that age.I ponder that as long as one keeps up with good music, poetry and art in general, these can work like a life's elixir for most of people.
tell me who has sing since late 50's to 2022 , someone 80 yo and still be relevant known for being a legend alive, No one. just the one and only Paul McCartney. literaly the only one ,the man who redfines music since he was a teenager. musical genious. he's funny, lovely and humble enough. like are you kidding me, If others with less talent think they're Gods, and Paul see himself as the same guy from liverpool from early 60's. that's how humble this guy is. A man I will always admire
So very well done Paul and the guys, great work with the John Lennon video, really made this performance. RIP John, we are STILL listening and loving the music.
I have the goosebumps, I love how Paul turns around to watch John , it’s almost like time stood still and John is really there singing and playing his guitar with Paul ❤️❤️❤️🎶🎶🎶❤️❤️❤️
This has always been a really fine song... and to see John Lennon singing with the wind passing through his hair... young, cheeky and talented as he was, made me sad and gave me pleasure at the same time...
I saw Paul 30 years ago in New Orleans, (I'm from England) my Father in Law got tickets for us. To be honest I wasn't that excited, I was young and arrogant. Well.. More than one tear ran down my cheeks that night, it was emotional, he blew me away as he did last night at Glastonbury. I love this guy!
my favorite musician ever...I was born in the 70s so I wasn't alive for the beatles...I heard Wings on the radio growing up in New york all the time and i loved all their songs...my father tried to tell me how awesome the beatles were, but like you I was too arrogant lolll..solo paul , wings, solo George, solo John I liked... because It was current lollll..beatles were for my dad ....in the early 90s when I was in high school I was finally mature enough to go back and go through the beatles catalog...my mind was blown....I saw paul with my high school friends in 1993....then I took my own kids in 2009....he has been a constant music wise for me since I heard silly love songs on the radio as a toddler...glad you finally saw the light the way I did lollllll
I can’t believe some people are criticising Paul McCartney, if you don’t like him don’t watch or listen to him, your loss. He is a genius, he did a 3 hour show at 80 years old, of course his voice isn’t the same as when he was 25, but that doesn’t matter, the songs are the same, make the most of him while we can, people will still be listening to his music in hundreds of years time, we are so lucky to have him in our lifetime
This was an iconic show! Macca is still rocking as good as he was 20 years ago. It would be cool to get one more gig with Macca, Ringo, Dhani Harrison and ‘virtual’ John, before they retire.
I'd rather see him do one with this Sokil-bloke, who some of us got to know as mjsokes: czcams.com/video/pTEk7MdBAM8/video.html . Somehow incarnates all the proper feel and timing in his playing.
That was seriously special to see John and Paul singing together, even with a 53 year gap. For a brief moment, time transcended and they were there again on that rooftop. :)
Paul and John singing together in the 21st century. Isn't it magical? Isn't it also sad to think what it could be like to have all four Beatles alive today?
This sends chills down my spine. I honestly don't care Paul doesn’t hit some of the notes perfectly. I used to play and sing, too, and I've lost it at around 30, he's 80 and still kills it, I'm astonished at what he is able to do. Hopefully he will keep playing for many years to come. Thank you Paul.
I don't have words to describe this, just fellings. Paul is a living legend. God bless you, Sir! I went in 3 Paul's concerts and, for sure, it was the 3 best days of my life
God. this is so fucking beautiful. I love how much Paul still loves John. I love them both so much. God bless The Beatles, God bless Paul McCartney, God bless John Lennon
Watching the Peter Jackson films, I was struck by just how much John and Paul seemed to genuinely enjoy playing together on the rooftop. It's so sad to think that within a few months their friendship would completely fall apart. But this does go a long way to making up for it.
Me and my boyfriend were crying our eyes out. This is so bittersweet and cute. Even after all these years they have chemistry and I feel Paul perks up when he’s duetting with John
One of my favourite Beatles tracks.. seeing John pop up and sing is enough to give you the shivers.. John Lennon was and is a loss to humanity, but wonderful so see Paul still rocking at 80. If John were here he would have been 82..!! Wonder if he would still have the same energy..?
It breaks my heart. I know how it feels to lose such a close friend. It's a rare thing to have such a close friend and then to lose that is so heartbreakinly sad.
He just keeps proving over and over and over and over and over again that he's the king of music. When he passes, the world will become less beautiful .
God this song is so incredible. A 1968 John Lennon poem (essentially) combined with Paul McCartney's sheer bloody force of nature. Their final act of combined genius.
Paul is such rockstar, man... That was great! Still rocking at 80! 👏 I saw him in Hollywood, Florida some weeks ago. I'm glad I recorded the whole experience. 🙌
Es impresionante que a pesar de que tenga 80 años este hombre siga cantando y rockeando como si aun fuera joven. Larga vida a Paul McCartney, el mejor de todos los tiempos.
Deja de eso se mantiene en buena salud y eso es de apreciar y más cuando llegan a esa edad ya en los 80s ya nadie sabe, lo que si me impresiona es que artistas que en su juventud probaron de todo y aún tienen una larga vida un ejemplo mick Jagger ...
@@VICOWWE pero el hecho de estar ahí con ese estado físico ya es meritorio, tú ves por ejemplo a Charly García con 10 años menos, y hay terrible diferencia
@@joakokoos ah eso siiiiii no lo demérito!!! 80 años y tener la energía de subirse a cantar un setlist de 3 horas y tocar el piano , la guitarra e interactuar así con la audiencia es de respetarse.
![Eminem - Houdini [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/22tVWwmTie8/mqdefault.jpg)
Some people complaining about his voice...it's called getting old, performing live and being caught up in the moment. Imagine being 80 and still being able to perform like this and the crowd knowing lyrics from songs you performed in your 20s.
Exactly. And if Paul's lost his voice it's because he gave it to us.
I don't think his voice is bad at all; all voices change as the career goes on, never mind by the age of 80, and yet he is still able to do the job. He still sounds pretty good, he clearly has enthusiasm and isn't just going through the motions.
his voice was much worse 20 yrs ago. I think he really prepared for this moment. His voice was purposely dominated by the band in the mix but probably didn't need it. What a champ.
I like the fact that he's humble enough to try and sing the most as possible. Any other artist would point the mic to the crowd and expect the audience to sing, but not Paul. Have also in mind he just got off a tour in the US! He hasn't taken a break.
His voice is husky. He's 80 years of age! Come on! He still has rhythm and sexuality. A genius who has wow factor. He is amazing. Go Paul. 💓
I don't understand why people complain about his voice. He sings wonderfully for being 80
@Paul McCartney wow you have gotten yourself 2 subscribers paul great job
@Paul McCartney If that is true, is there any particular reason that you joined on December 29th?
You realize that you can possibly put on your ACTAUL official channel that you have a community-type account?
I'm very very sure that ain't you tho mr. "McCartney"
In this song,I would tend to agree. I think the chance to 'sing' with his mate,John reinvigorates his voice. He reaches high notes that he cannot reach at other times. We all age but Paul is a musical genius and no one can ever take that away from him.
Literally nobody is complaining about his voice. What are you talking about
@@FliptopObserver123 Yeah people are. Maybe not in this comment section but I've seen people write about that
An 80 year old Paul McCartney singing with a 29 year old John Lennon. Damn I'm glad I lived to see this.
Keith...therein lies the magic!
I'm 73 and I'm with You on that one Bro.. God has given Me the gift to see a lot of beautiful things in My life time,, And this was one of them
@@butchschulz9879 wut...
Oh get a grip! 🙄
Ok fun police
Imagine how Paul must feel hearing John singing with him live again. I bet he got chills.
@@paulmicartney1455 The great great Micartney! How blessed we are oh lord.
@@stealthbastard8837 Yeah the Paul McCartney who joined 4 days ago and has got one subscriber
@@johnp515 Imagine it's really him just getting bored so he created a profile days ago lol
@@johnp515 @StealthBastard was just being sarcastic(you can't really tag people in comments).
@@paulmicartney1455 haha
Please BBC, upload the whole show. This is beyond commercial use, it is history and belongs to Humankind.
Amen!
It is available…if you know where to look.
@@transfo47 where
I can’t watch it from 🇺🇸
@@transfo47 but not in America
Got chills when John Lennon came on screen and the audience roared.
You might like a band called The Doublejumps if you like listening to Beatles/Paul McCartney
John lennon should've appeared as an hologram.
john lennon did WHAT to the screen
I love how Paul turns around to watch Lennon.... even after all these years he's still captivated by Lennon, that's special
Absolutely! Just so cool to see him turn around and listen to John. Gave me goosebumps when I saw it live last summer and still gives me goosebumps and a tears of joy
It's just part of the routine. He did it on every performance of the tour😆
I think we’re all captivated by John! Oh, this put a huge smile on my face. I sure miss John…and George!
Paul needs to watch John as they did back in the day to pull off the duet.
They should jump back farther and do “If I Fell” or “I’ll Get You” if they really wanna get the seats wet.
When John started his part and Paul stood there, saw and heard him it brought some youthful energy into him again, you can tell by how he starts hitting his notes! I can only imagine how much Paul misses John.
They literally rehearsed this hundreds of times before the show
@@ardenaudreyarji
I'm sure they did but it's a different kind of energy when you're playing in front of the audience.
@@knightscroftsquire-muldoon He also did this on his American tour
It's just marketing dude. For folks like, well you
@@VanceLeeMusic paul misses John
Can you imagine the amount of memories flooding through McCartney's mind?
Underrated comment. So deep.
I probably try not to cry in front of the public from so much emotion and nostalgia combined.
I can't. I don't think anyone can but Paul.
This guy came into my life in 1964, when I was 13/14. He's been there all along. We're all old now. When he goes, I won't be far behind. Thanks for the music.
What you said at the end is exactly what I said when I was able to meet my musical idol Thom Yorke. I simply thanked him for the music, and said it changed my life. He said "me too, man. me too." What a moment.
What a great comment, sir. Honestly
Sent chills. Short comment. But huge.
Thank your love ❤️ and support I sincerely hope you never stop listening to my music🎶
God Bless U Sir
If you a beatlemaniac, you can't help having tears in your eyes while watching this. 💙
You might like a band called The Doublejumps if you like listening to Beatles/Paul McCartney
Not only for Beatles fans,but for everyone loves great rock music.
@@funlittlefish There are no other Beatles. That's like missing your friend and someone says, If you liked your partner, let me introduce you to Leslie. Well, maybe it's not totally off. But...
Absolutely, tears of JOY❤
@@davidhill2971
People have no idea what it means to be 80 and belt out the vocals to a song! Paul is one of the greatest voices in music of all time
That’s really something when John appears on that screen, playing in sync with his partner in the greatest songwriting duo in popular music history, across a span of 53 years. Amazing.
I had the opportunity to talk with Paul's live sound engineer Pab before the show in Baltimore in June; that segment is so extremely rudimentary - only Abe had a click track in his in-ears for that whole song and Wix had some control over the tempo; I'm assuming with a tap pad or something to adjust the BPM. The rest of the song's performance was guided through the stage monitors. That's the only cue that Paul had. What a testament to how tight he and John were (and how tight he, Rusty, Abe, Wix and Brian are) that after all these years, all he needs to sync up for a live performance of I've Got A Feeling is John's isloated vocals from 1969.
Paul: turn him down a bit!
Made me cry.
@@cockeyedoptimista me too!! How beautiful to see John at Glastonbury with Paul ❤
@@cockeyedoptimista oh yeah- I watched them on the Ed Sullivan show, and been a fan since- didn't expect to be as emotional as I did, but so be it
Take a moment to appreciate that Paul McCartney is 80 years and still hitting the high notes like he's 30.
When John appeared on the screen, Paul's voice got stronger. Like it hyped him up. So many mixed emotions watching this. Bittersweet. Slightly more sweet than bitter but pretty much evenhanded.
No, he is not even close. Pretty good for 80, but he is a shell of his younger self. Still entertaining though.
No, his voice isn't what it once was - it can't be at his age, but he still sounds amazing, sings in tune, and he's just instantly recognisable.
@@claudevieaul1465 yes. I object to the stupidity of saying he sounds thirty!
He is a musical genius, with one of the most recognizable voices ever.
Even at 80. And this format with the recorded Lennon is super creative.
No, he does not sound 30
Just be aware that an actual real live Beatle still actually performs these magnificent songs really well for nearly 80 years of age on this earthly plain...oh yeah. Thank you Paul.🙂
Thank your love ❤️ and support I sincerely hope you never stop listening to my music🎶
Ringo too!
When John joined in, Paul started to sing better, his voice came alive again. 😻
I thought this too!!
I went to his Melbourne show when he performed this and John came on his voice sounded so fucking good like it was already great but it sounded incredible for this song
They always lifted each other up
After all those years John and Paul singing together still give people goosebumps. 😭😭😭
True
Still the best duet ever!❤
both dead, only John is beloved.
@@communitycollegegenius9684 🚫
@@Jacqueline_Cobb this should be a single for us beatle fans to download
It's cliche to say this but honestly, this moved me to tears and I'm not one to cry easily. Seeing Paul play with his best mate again, it probably takes him back all those years. RIP John and thank you Paul for living so graciously and carrying his spirit with you
What a nice message... Touching
I saw the show in the U.S. & when this came on even the guy next to me was crying…so don’t feel bad. Everyone had the same reaction. It was so great & sad @ the same time.
48 years old, been to hundreds of gigs. Watched this on my sofa and cried. The Beatles split before I was old enough to get into music but they mean so much.
@@croesrob If you're 48 they split before you was born.
You weren't the only one...amazing performance!
Paul can still kick ass even at 80
Paul turns around and faces the screen because as much as I’m sure he knows the fans will get a kick out of John being on the screen, it’s all for him. This gives him another chance to sing with his first partner and best friend.
The emotions watching Paul McCartney duet with John Lennon in my lifetime are indescribable
Absolutely, mate 👍👍👍
McCartney is playing live with the recording of Lennon made 53 years earlier, still in the same key, still nailing that tricky guitar rhythm, still hitting all the vocal notes and tones perfectly. Just amazing.
The fact that Paul still sings his repertoire in the same key, even with his current voice, is amazing. Guitar rythm is not tricky at all.
@ Well, the original rhythm played by Lennon is kind of tricky, but you can learn it. However, Paul, plays a sloppier version of it.
I personally don't agree with singing stuff in the original key being a great idea in this age. In this performance, he still managed to sound good, but that's not true for all of his songs. Songs in lower keys (like Lady Madonna) generally sound better when he sings them these days. Im not even sure if hitting all these high notes is health for his voice.
If you compare his vocal performances from 7 years ago with the ones from Billy Joel now, you'll realise that Billies voice sounds stronger and generally better. This is because he transposes almost all of his songs down - since decades. I think, transposing songs down when your voice ages is a really good technique of dealing with a changing voice over the years.
@@aheendwhz1 I know! I meant it's amazing that he's still trying to do the songs in original keys. He pulled it off for decades with great results, but he's stubborn about key changes. I don't think he's ever going to do it. He tried it with that 'Here there and Everywhere' 2016 piano version but it seems like he didn't like it at all.
He's not singing perfectly. There's a frailty in his voice which, given his immense legacy, is quite touching. I love his old man's voice for what it is, it isn't fair to compare. There's absolutely no one to touch Paul’s singing from 1964 to about 1976. Certainly not present day Paul, by any stretch of imagination.
@@RayMusicman9 Paul's 2002 tour was a great period vocally as well. Even into the 2010s he still sounded younger than his real age!
Watching Paul turning back to see John singing made me cry so hard💔
This damn band is still bringing tears to my eyes after all this time.
Me too. That was so excellent for Paul to have done that bit of magic…
It wasn’t that bad!
This "duet" of Paul with John was one of the biggest hits of recent tours. Paul McCartney is still doing great.
He's doing great for an 80 year old but you could hear him struggling to sing that song. But that's ok he's a Beatle and part of our growing up. I loved this just the same.
The magic of technology. John is alive again. 👍👍👍
@@jimmoore826 Exactly, his voice has changed a lot, but man, he's 80 yo, over 60 years of career and still plays and writes really well. He's a living legend.
@@stevenandrean2661 It must be amazing to see this show live
@@alexandrevilarinhof Indeed.. Sir Paul Is Living Legend. God Save the Queen. 👍👍👍👍
Who has imagined before that 80 years old Paul McCartney sings Rock’n’Roll with 28 years old John Lennon in front of a huge crowd !! Young like granddaughters & grandsons are singing along I’ve got a feeling!! This definitely is MAGICAL MYSTERY TOUR concert!! Long live Paul please ! Thank you !!
:) this give me a lot of joy and hapiness.
Yep I grew up with the Beatles and saw them when they made their debut on Ed Sullivan when I was only 5 years old watching that with my whole family and my older siblings .
We grow up with the Beatles and always had their music in our house they were just a part of our lives .
Makes me glad to see that he and Ringo have made it to live to be 80
What the shit are you babbling on about?
You've never been to a Motörhead concert, I imagine...
The "Ive Got a Feeling Take 1" on the Rooftop is my favorite, and one of the greatest live performances of all time. Paul's vocals are unbelievable. John, George, & Ringo are all killing it per usual, and Billy Preston adds so much with his keys.
To hear Paul still crushing this song, at 80 nonetheless, is so amazing to me. 53 YEARS LATER
The rooftop version is really amazing, and at 80, well, it's also inspiring, you can just keep going until you drop, doing what you love, important message for everyone.
My favorite Beatles song...
That bridge he sings was hard when he was in his 20's - most people couln't even hit that in their prime. Well done Paul. And hey John.
agrees...he sound here very much like the rough and ragged vocal that he did on the 1969 original recording!....really pretty amazing
80 years old...and still ROCKS.
Paul McCartney: Living & Inmortal Legend.
2:19 John stills lives
If John’s face appearing on the screen didn’t move me, Paul turning around to look up at him sure did. What a performance. We love you
The same feeling here
You are easily moved
@@tf2368 He's moved to respond by a legendary musician playing a legendary music festival. You're moved to respond by a simple CZcams comment. Who is more easily moved? I'm aware of the irony in me doing this, but I like to encourage people to engage their brains. Whether I succeed is really down to whether you can.
@@M2Mil7er I'm not moved at all
Brian May also performed with a VR Freddie Mercury not so long ago. It clearly moved him as well as the audience.
Am I the only one that got goosebumps when John came up on screen and and tears came to my eyes.. It's a reminder of just how damn good they were together
No you certainly are not!
...and a few tears.
He's still hitting C5s with good tone... at 80. That's beyond impressive, it's insane.
lol he didn't hit any of those c5s. come on...
@@atomeyes99 What do you mean? Are we hearing the same thing?
It didn't sound good
@@atomeyes99 Ya he sounded rough...I mean understand but let's not sit and act like he sounds great like he used to
@@bls8959 "Ya he sounded rough" no, not for an 80 year old, that's far from rough. He's definitely struggling, mainly during the bridge (AWAWAWWA lol), and of course he doesn't sound like he used to, but that's still better singing than most people will achieve in their lifetime. I'm sorry, it sounds _good._
shout out to the sound tech that tempo mapped the rooftop concert so they were all able to play in sync w the video, this is some elite level production
aka Time Bandits
Even you could do that, Zach. Just tap the beat to the original on a midi keyboard, or even record the sound of you tapping or clapping the beat along with the original, and then play it back in their in-ears. Rather shout out to the ones cleaning the toilets after Glastonbury. A lot more deserved, and a lot more complicated;-)
@@hepphepps8356 hahahahha
Right, matching tempo. lol you are a fool
I was in the crowd on this day . Me and my family had come to Glastonbury for the weekend and the Friday before and it was my first music festival of my entire life. We went to see Sir Paul do his concert. I am a huge Beatles fan and was extremely excited and my excitement payed off. After the main concert, we stayed for about a minute before Paul marched around the stage with a Ukrainian flag. He then told us Peter Jackson had isolated John’s vocals from the rooftop concert and they were going to perform with John live again. Me and my whole family were in tears when we heard his voice. It actually sounded like he was really there. This concert was truly something special, and I hope Macca will continue to do live concerts for years to come.
Good choice for your first festival! :)
They should have gotten some isolated vocals from Paul (back when he was alive) and mixed them in too.
@@communitycollegegenius9684 WHAT?
Too soon?
@@communitycollegegenius9684 😂😂😂
John & Paul singing again together in 2022... their special bond stronger than ever..love you guys..
@Paul McCartney God bless you !
@Paul McCartney Thank you so much...I will..
@@ChiaraMichela23 I hope you’ve realised that the guy you’re talking to isn’t actually Paul McCartney
Sir Paul McCartney is still going strong at 80! He is perhaps the greatest Artist of all time!!!!!
lol hardly
No 'perhaps' about it. He *is* the greatest musical artist of all time!
Despues john lennon seguro
only short of Lennon himself
Perhaps????. 100%
That they were able to sync up Lennon's vocal track to this performance tells you how rock solid Ringo's drumming was. I mean no lag no rushing, just right on the beat.
I think the clip is from Get Back the new film from Peter Jackson. They used AI and other tech to isolate all the different components of the tracks from mono recordings from the time. So I think it's likely that John's singing has been isolated from the drumming.
"just right on the beat" the bare minimum for a drummer lol.
@@xChrisDarko Or as Ringo put it: "of course I can keep time, but the art is in the fills"
@@thescrewfly Ringo is not the guy to listen to when it comes to playing percussion.
Respectfully, it says less about Ringo, and more about how precise Paul's band had to be.
Absolutely brilliant from Macca. 80 years old and still proving his legendary status.
I couldn't stand up that long.
Felt my eyes well up when John came in. I’m grateful I was alive to experience The Beatles ❤
I can’t help but get emotional watching this. I’m the same age now that Paul was when he sang on that rooftop, and I’m a musician because of the Beatles. I even got to play on a rooftop unsanctioned by the authorities (wonder where the boys and I got that idea ?) and I also have some friends that I used to play and sing with that are no longer here with us.
I can’t even imagine what Sir Paul was feeling when John popped up on that screen.
Thank you Paul, for being my inspiration to become a bass player, a songwriter, and thank you Peter Jackson for giving the world the opportunity to hear these two sing together across time and space.
Just stunning.
if you like paul mccartney you might like my brothers music. his band is called The Doublejumps. they're popular in new zealand
Paul turning back to watch his best friend sings once again still gets me every time.
Can you imagine John actually recovered from the shots back in the day? He makes a full recovery, plays for many more years. Beatles got together one more time before George actually passing away. And now, 20 years later, as casual as he always was, John randomly pops up on stage and sings this tune with his old pal like it hasn't passed a day. Can you imagine?
That's a nice picture. Nothing like the power of imagination - John would agree, I guess.😉🤩
@@ceciliagincho6806 Interesting that you use the word: "Imagine."
You could let George live too... if it is fantasy it costs nothing... :)
@@charissesavarin5257 ;)
@@karlkk5191 lol yeah I know. It’s just, John’s death feels so… unfair, you know? But George (as sad as it sounds) kinda had it coming, he smoked like a godamn chimney and everyone told him to chill on the cigarettes. But sure, I often wonder what would George think of current events or the state of the world and politics right now
They way he looks up to John. . you can tell he misses him still.
I've watched this over twenty times. When I hear the roar of the crowd as John comes on I just tear up. I have no defense.
Paul's work ethic at 80 is quite an inspiration. A 3 hour set like that is not just 3 hours on the stage--there were a lot of hours of rehearsals with the band to get some quite complex music (including this one) up to performance standard.
Paul still rockin' at 80 years old. I saw him in May of this year at the Oakland Arena. I had never seen him play live, so I had to go this time around. Paul moves around the stage like he's still in his 20s he is amazing. I know people that are younger than him get around with walkers and canes, and very shakey afoot, but Paul steady as a rock throughout the whole 3 hours he was on stage rockin' away...he's amazing, and you got to know that he will continue to rock, as long as he can, because it is so much a part of him...he needs to perform, its in his DNA...and I'm appreciative of that!😁👍🎶
Can only hope that I’ll be able to catch a show of his… it’s a dream.
Last time he was in town…. Tickets were $2000 just for nosebleeds. Was no way.
I was his concert and totally agree with you!
There is a hilarious clip of him on a talk show (maybe the Frost Show?) Sometime in the later 60s where he says "well, it would be pretty sad if I'm prancing around on the stage at FORTY"
makes you wonder who he sold his soul to
I've seen Paul 4 x and Ringo 1 x. I am so very happy. Beatlemania never end. Never.
After Bach and Beethoven comes The Beatles as comet on the earth. Happiness for mankind.
❤️ ♥️ ❤️ ♥️ ❤️ ♥️
Gave me goosebumps to hear John and Paul singing one of their songs together again❣️
Thanks Debby
3:33 John and Paul having fun together for the first time in decades. My heart is full.
I love how he turns to face John. It was also very lovely how he said how much he loved him, how you could never say it back in the day and then Paul reminded us to appreciate our loved ones why we still have them. Brilliant stuff.
it's a lame gimmick you are too easily impressed.
@@nonrepublicrat
And you’re a troll…
@@OnceTheyNamedMeiWasnt yeah, they loved each other soo much that they even stopped talking to each other
@@OnceTheyNamedMeiWasnt oh, I thought you were locked into some esoteric psychosis
@@hom0s4cer You do know they reunited before John was assassinated, right …. 🙄
In 45 years I've never had chills from a concert. I never thought I would see John Lennon and Paul perform... modern technology may often be the bane of our existence but it also is miraculous. Amazing. Tears.
Nice comment Karen.
pink Floyd 2007? reunited... that's chills
@@adamkrol69 2007? Think you got that wrong
@@user-ux1vj9vx7s sorry 2005 for live aid
@@ChrisBmufc lmao her name is actually Karen
If you hear, Paul’s singing gets better when he duets with John 🙏🏽
John ❤ I am not one of those cry-babies but I think I would have started crying when John appeared on that screen. I miss his voice. Musically and socially.
Saw him in Boston a couple of weeks ago. He did this number, along with 35 others. 36 songs and almost 3 hours on the stage - all him. Awesome....
So sad I missed that show - I had an Hawaiian vacation planned for over a year and considered changing the date (at great expense) just to see this at Fenway.....I am jealous
Crazy how this guy can perform like this aged 80!
It’s because he’s a f#&%ing Beatle
I guess music keeps him preserved. It's nice to see such power at that age.I ponder that as long as one keeps up with good music, poetry and art in general, these can work like a life's elixir for most of people.
@@totallybored5526 Facts
I teared up a little. You're dearly missed, John.
Hearing and seeing John come in at exactly the right moment was fantastic! Wish John was still here-
Hello 👋
Are you also one of my music fans out there?
This is so beautiful… when they’re singing together again, it brings a tear to my eye. 🥲❤️
I teared up at this scene.
Despite the lows they had.
Paul and John were musical soul mates and they needed each other.
John treated Paul like dirt from 1970 to 1972 i dont understand how Paul wanted to meet
John after that
@@eivindgj3761 probably they were just tired of arguing with each other and that their hatred wasn’t gonna solve anything
@@eivindgj3761 it's because they are brothers, sometimes you fight with ur brother and its normal.
@@ffahrulchaniago we shall forget the old negative stories. They have both done so much good together, that far outweighs the negatives.
Let them be!
Paul and John always brothers. In music sometimes different opinion is normal.
We are very fortunate to still have Paul among us, giving concerts and playing like when he was a Beatle.
tell me who has sing since late 50's to 2022 , someone 80 yo and still be relevant known for being a legend alive, No one. just the one and only Paul McCartney. literaly the only one ,the man who redfines music since he was a teenager. musical genious. he's funny, lovely and humble enough. like are you kidding me, If others with less talent think they're Gods, and Paul see himself as the same guy from liverpool from early 60's. that's how humble this guy is. A man I will always admire
George Clinton lol
Roger Daltrey
Frankie Valli and Dion
Ringo and Dylan, Stones soon. But yeah. McCartney is definitely on top.
So very well done Paul and the guys, great work with the John Lennon video, really made this performance. RIP John, we are STILL listening and loving the music.
Imagine the site of lennon, McCartney, Ringo, doing Glastonbury, isle if Wight 90s say, Mark Chapman should rot in jail
RIP George too
I have the goosebumps, I love how Paul turns around to watch John , it’s almost like time stood still and John is really there singing and playing his guitar with Paul ❤️❤️❤️🎶🎶🎶❤️❤️❤️
Honestly I don’t know how anyone there kept it together. I cry every time. And I’m only able to watch it on CZcams.
@@natalyamartirosyan same here
This has always been a really fine song... and to see John Lennon singing with the wind passing through his hair... young, cheeky and talented as he was, made me sad and gave me pleasure at the same time...
The greatest songwriting team in music history not even close
Great to see these two legends singing together again!
I saw Paul 30 years ago in New Orleans, (I'm from England) my Father in Law got tickets for us. To be honest I wasn't that excited, I was young and arrogant. Well.. More than one tear ran down my cheeks that night, it was emotional, he blew me away as he did last night at Glastonbury. I love this guy!
You cried at a McCartney concert 30 years ago when you were unexcited, young and arrogant? What made you cry?
my favorite musician ever...I was born in the 70s so I wasn't alive for the beatles...I heard Wings on the radio growing up in New york all the time and i loved all their songs...my father tried to tell me how awesome the beatles were, but like you I was too arrogant lolll..solo paul , wings, solo George, solo John I liked... because It was current lollll..beatles were for my dad ....in the early 90s when I was in high school I was finally mature enough to go back and go through the beatles catalog...my mind was blown....I saw paul with my high school friends in 1993....then I took my own kids in 2009....he has been a constant music wise for me since I heard silly love songs on the radio as a toddler...glad you finally saw the light the way I did lollllll
Thank you Paul McCartney, that you played live with John Lennon after 53 years. It's so great!! Thanks!
Thank you fan
I can’t believe some people are criticising Paul McCartney, if you don’t like him don’t watch or listen to him, your loss. He is a genius, he did a 3 hour show at 80 years old, of course his voice isn’t the same as when he was 25, but that doesn’t matter, the songs are the same, make the most of him while we can, people will still be listening to his music in hundreds of years time, we are so lucky to have him in our lifetime
True, but the instrumentals are shit
The Beatles were gifts of the Devine. We really needed them!
This was an iconic show! Macca is still rocking as good as he was 20 years ago.
It would be cool to get one more gig with Macca, Ringo, Dhani Harrison and ‘virtual’ John, before they retire.
You know John has musician sons too, right? Would be weird to have George's son to stand in for him but not John's.
how 'bout a lennon son instead of a virtual john ?
Nope. Only the real thing. Even if it’s only virtual. No one can take Johnny’s place.
I'd rather see him do one with this Sokil-bloke, who some of us got to know as mjsokes: czcams.com/video/pTEk7MdBAM8/video.html . Somehow incarnates all the proper feel and timing in his playing.
@@gretchennelson7056 or georges
That was seriously special to see John and Paul singing together, even with a 53 year gap. For a brief moment, time transcended and they were there again on that rooftop. :)
I’m not crying…
I cant imagine a world without Paul. One of the "GOAT's " of music, amazing performance😍
i know i should expect john to show up but whenever he does i get goosebumps each and every single damn time 😭
When the crowd cheered John popping up on the screen, I got goosebumps. If only he were alive....
Paul and John singing together in the 21st century. Isn't it magical? Isn't it also sad to think what it could be like to have all four Beatles alive today?
This sends chills down my spine.
I honestly don't care Paul doesn’t hit some of the notes perfectly. I used to play and sing, too, and I've lost it at around 30, he's 80 and still kills it, I'm astonished at what he is able to do. Hopefully he will keep playing for many years to come. Thank you Paul.
This will always bring tears to my eyes. What a gift to hear these two geniuses singing together again in whatever way possible 😞❤️
@@marilotta yes it is ,it's true ,yes it is 😭lg from Ellen 🌹✌peace and love,,from me to you,,
Thank your love ❤️ and support I sincerely hope you never stop listening to my music🎶
I don't have words to describe this, just fellings. Paul is a living legend. God bless you, Sir! I went in 3 Paul's concerts and, for sure, it was the 3 best days of my life
The moment when both start to sing is epic 👍
As a Beatles fanatic, that was so awesome! Paul sounded better than I expected. So cool seeing Paul singing with John!❤❤❤❤
I'm not crying I'm cutting onions honestly ...I gotta feeling 💖
John hasn’t aged a bit and his voice still sounds amazing!
He’s grown considerably
Love Paul, seen him in Dublin about 15 years ago. Unfortunately his voice is so shot it’s heard even when he’s speaking
@@Vincentlpp08 Yeah, he even sings about this on "Starting Over": "We have grown, we have grown"
@@Vincentlpp08 hahah
He made a deal with the devil, he did.
John´s voice is so pure and beautiful. McCartney is a hero.
I got goose bumps when John came on the screen.That was GREAT.
God. this is so fucking beautiful. I love how much Paul still loves John. I love them both so much. God bless The Beatles, God bless Paul McCartney, God bless John Lennon
Watching the Peter Jackson films, I was struck by just how much John and Paul seemed to genuinely enjoy playing together on the rooftop. It's so sad to think that within a few months their friendship would completely fall apart. But this does go a long way to making up for it.
Lennon's vocal is something really terrific!
Omg this is truly amazing.
Hearing Sir Paul and John singing together after all these years
Me and my boyfriend were crying our eyes out. This is so bittersweet and cute. Even after all these years they have chemistry and I feel Paul perks up when he’s duetting with John
The duet is, indeed, a beautiful moment. Hard not to be moved by it.🥲😍
Yeah I think Paul’s vocals improve after John appears
Haha. Exactly what I thought. Lennon brings back his competitive spirit.
It's my pleasure having you as my fans ❣️❤️
@@ceciliagincho6806 It's my pleasure having you as my fans ❣️❤️
One of my favourite Beatles tracks.. seeing John pop up and sing is enough to give you the shivers.. John Lennon was and is a loss to humanity, but wonderful so see Paul still rocking at 80. If John were here he would have been 82..!! Wonder if he would still have the same energy..?
Probably he would - music and poetry were in his blood too.
John and paul still sound perfect together 60 years later!
I noticed their harmony just rekindled the second john came up on screen
It breaks my heart. I know how it feels to lose such a close friend. It's a rare thing to have such a close friend and then to lose that is so heartbreakinly sad.
Goosebumps the moment Lennon started his part!
Very emotional to see them playing together like this, very beautiful.
He just keeps proving over and over and over and over and over again that he's the king of music. When he passes, the world will become less beautiful .
Agreed. The entire world will stop to shed a tear I dare say. Such a gift to all of mankind.
God this song is so incredible. A 1968 John Lennon poem (essentially) combined with Paul McCartney's sheer bloody force of nature. Their final act of combined genius.
Paul is such rockstar, man... That was great! Still rocking at 80! 👏 I saw him in Hollywood, Florida some weeks ago. I'm glad I recorded the whole experience. 🙌
Beautiful and uplifting, but terribly sad at the same time.❤️❤️💔💔
Well said, its hard to watch without a lump in your throat.
Thank your love❤️and support I sincerely hope you never stop listening to my music🎶
Must've been so emotional to be there and see John out of the blue there!
Es impresionante que a pesar de que tenga 80 años este hombre siga cantando y rockeando como si aun fuera joven. Larga vida a Paul McCartney, el mejor de todos los tiempos.
Deja de eso se mantiene en buena salud y eso es de apreciar y más cuando llegan a esa edad ya en los 80s ya nadie sabe, lo que si me impresiona es que artistas que en su juventud probaron de todo y aún tienen una larga vida un ejemplo mick Jagger ...
Honestamente no se que escuchas 🤷🏻♂️, el tiempo pasa factura ya no tiene la misma voz.
@@VICOWWE pero el hecho de estar ahí con ese estado físico ya es meritorio, tú ves por ejemplo a Charly García con 10 años menos, y hay terrible diferencia
@@joakokoos ah eso siiiiii no lo demérito!!! 80 años y tener la energía de subirse a cantar un setlist de 3 horas y tocar el piano , la guitarra e interactuar así con la audiencia es de respetarse.
@@VICOWWE siii, ojalá siga otros añitos
80 years old ... incredible