France, Islam and Secularism | Start Here
Vložit
- čas přidán 31. 01. 2021
- French President Emmanuel Macron says he wants to get tough on “Islamist separatism”.
So why does his proposed new law have some people feeling like he is targeting Muslims?
And why is he being accused of trying to score political points?
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
#Al_Jazeera_English
#Start_Here
#Al_Jazeera_Digital_Shows
Toleration of the intolerant leads to the destruction of the tolerant
They need stop bieng too nice
Good
the bible also has intolerant and oppressive passages in it. just like the quran and pretty much every religious book. grow up. they were written thousands of years ago.
Karl Popper meant to fight the intolerant in the battle of ideas, not with force. He warned how easily could someone become intolerant in the name of tolerance, specially with subjective ideologies at hand. It's easy to see the problem under the new woke culture.
@@kenlandon6130 first u grow up ? Why r u hiding behind the Fake name? Have u read all the scriptures in the world? Have you read them in right Perspective?
Ppl with common sense know Al Jazeera supports whom 😏
You dumb every country has its own broadcasting channel and they will never speak against them. It's not only Al Jazeera but as I can sence the ignorant in you...I'm not shocked to see your reply.
@@anonymous_246 "every country has its own broadcasting channel and they will never speak against them." Yes you are right, but that speaks a lot about Freedom of Press. It's not dumb of him to say this, because it reminds the listeners to be aware and just consume the news objectively and not the news channel.
so you support radical French people satirizing other people's religion? how about respecting other people or just darn shutting up? do they die when they don't make fun of other people?
When a person comes in France, you have to abide by French laws. Nothing radical in that. If anything is radical, it is beheading a teacher just for a cartoon.
Yep
There's a similar problem in India.. 'They' want other communities to be secular to them, but they won't do that to others under 'right to practice religion'.. beheading is justified, constitution is challenged, barbarism is displayed, rights are shrilly demanded, other religions are incessantly vilified, anti national activities are encouraged and victim card is played again and again
Average hateful p*nj**t coping in AlJazeera's comment section with made up lies
Sadly true. India gets a lot of bad reputation thanks to them
Ya that's true, I do feel the same way that it's not just France and not just europe but India and many countries facing these issues
Ameya tikekar isiliye bulldozer chalna chahiye
@@hank561
Your moslims from your people
But moslims in france not Europeans race they are not real frensh france must be careful
Because moslims in her country not easy people almost
they are arabs from middle east and north africa
why don’t you do one of these about the anti-secularism of Saudi Arabia?
Maybe because they were paid by the rich arab countries not to say so.
Because Saudi Arabia is a theocracy and has never claimed to be a champion of secular values which include the freedom of religion which France claims to follow. Its rich coming from a people who vehemently claim to represent the "civilised people" to enact such draconian measures to crackdown on a peoples freedom. You can't have your cake and eat it too
@@maazahmedpoke well if you find that claim to be false or hollow a muslim country might be up your alley....you can have all the sharia law, beheadings etc....that france doesn't want that inside its borders I don't blame them freedom of religion also comes with following the law within the country when your religion goes outside of those bounds or inteferes with those who do not share islamic values then your impeding on others rights freedom of religion is but one there are others that must be respected you only focusing on religion shows your true agenda.
@@CAM8689 so a women wanting to wear what she wants or not wanting to eat pork or alcohol goes beyond what is allowed by law in your country?
@@maazahmedpoke no reply from @cam . I think he found his brain now and is rethinking. 😂😂😂
France is doing good.
Separate religion from politics and state..
Shut up
@@alireact1827 wet dreams 🤣
@No One is no one what are they doing for hindus ??? Soft persecution ?
Do you know that the Islam is the second fast growing religion in France after Christianity they can't separate religion from politics especially Islam Islam Zindabad Long live Islam.
@Hrushikesha Sahoo chup kr oy india me bhi Islam fastest-growing hai
Secularism isn't about protecting the freedom of religion, it's about protecting the state from religion. It's sad that France is left alone to do this in an age where religion has been shown to have a malevolent influence on government again and again.
Yeah, I think all Western countries should move in that same direction. I personally see ALL religions as cancer to the world because it stops progress, that doesn't mean I would infringe on other people's rights to follow their religious beliefs. If any of these religious groups were to gain momentum, non-believers would be forced to abide by their religious standards. To me doesn't matter Islam, Judaism or Christianity I don't want it near my politics or school system.
@@Skies133 most western countries are secular, what are you talking about?
@@FakeR19920828 donot worry he was on Alchol
@@FakeR19920828 They are not strictly secular like France..Eg.. Religious symbols in public are banned in France..
one thing the commies got right, im so blessed to be born atheist in the USSR, the first generation in the history of mankind to be born free of religious brainwashing, amazing.
I support total secularism and don't care what anyone says: Your religion is your private business and if you live in France, you must respect their laws. Schools should be secular. If you want religion to be every part of your life, move to a country like Saudi Arabia where they treat women like cattle.
@Mohamed Boualem French women have freedom and ownership of their bodies. No serious person would compare the freedom and rights of French women to that of any Muslim country. Try again.
Agreeeeeee 100%
@@h.b.7104 if you do not like france go to a muslim country then and complain about democracy and freedom there not in the free western world if you hate this place so much
So anybody who doesn’t confirm to your laws are effectively treating women like cattle.. what a myopic, idiotic mindset
Let’s be realistic the banning of the veil is stupid
I am a Muslim but i must admit that we need to be more tolerant. This is what happens when you use violence to defend a religion you only make people insult your religion even more.
Thank you from an,an atheist
@@ForestKingdomswell said
The problem is Muslim became intolerant because that's what Islam teaches
I am a Muslim and I never use violence to get any thing.
Same goes for my family.
Advising tolerance is very good.
But judging millions of people based on the 0.1% people you know if not smart at all.
Islam give knowledge of everything except education and tolerance .
Ask those people which is more valuable to them
Country or religion? I'm sure 95% will say religion..
So it's really necessary for France to control radicalisation of religion..
But don't do such things.
U r correct this community always believe in own religion instead of country. That's a reason Iraq, Syria ,Yemen and many more
Suffers bcoz of these community
@@pradeepmishra2988 not by the community there..there are weak power keeping people like in india ..what is the biggest problem in india ?modi government and its policies .and rss .
@@pradeepmishra2988 and you try to correct your community and rss group. it will return india to indians.
@@muhammedarshad695 I am not surprised to see a muslim who failed to see the problems in their religion and community.
When a Turkish president turned a Christian church Hagia Sofia to a mosque to score political points its ok, but when a French president proposed a bill to counter Islamist extremism to score political points, its a big issue. Why ???
Exactly
Omg, really? 😮
Actually an eye for eye made the world blind
@@flawyerlawyertv7454yes, Hagia Sophia was an Orthodox church
@@commonman9782 Very sad they did changed it. :/
Lets talk about Qatars secularism, oppsy it doesn't exist.😂
🤣🤣🤣
Qatar has never claimed to be secular
Exactly why qatar>france
@MUN Chak do you lack reading comprehension?
@M S don't bother, there's no reasoning with these people
When in Rome, do as the Romans say.
so in america when slavery was thing we were supposed to just go along with it orrrr
so your a racist
@@mdstate829 Americans were the ones that made it about race
@@mdstate829 true latest in Qatar.
@Moon Deccans No it is not. slavery is allowed.
@Moon Deccans It is bro. :) Kafala system is pretty much slavery. :)
Also google slavery and islam.
Religion and state must stay separated. Religious freedom is good as long as it doesn't become radicalized.
But Islam calls for Shar'ia. It's a legal & political system. See Iran for details.
I'd call Macro's version of Democracy radical. Anything radical is bad, not only religion.
So peoppe living by religion is raducal? Religion is a way of lifeand seculars live by a way of life
@@jaggar28 you want Shar'ia law?
@@jaggar28 Macron does not listen to the people from what I can see xD
A teacher beheaded I mean, I thought it was all about religious tolerance and not straight up revenge
Lets not be judgmental, cause if we do judge, lets take a look at WW1 and WW1, Cold War!
There's no proof that the Muslim guy did it or the motivation was Islam in the first place, as he was shot and killed without trial or investigation s
@@beamseff2239 the murderer himself literally said it was for religious reasons . he’s from Chechnya, a muslim region
@@anonymousbee All of the world's uncertainties and problems stem form European Colonialism.
@@zainshamsi2841 religious extremism nowadays is just as big or maybe a bigger issue especially when it comes to islam
Forced marriage is not the same as polygamy. Saying that you have "laws against polygamy" does not address forced marriage.
They mock other countries for not allowing gay marriage and they ban polygamy.
@@salahaldin447 what kind of monster supports polygamy?
@@ankurjain7514 maybe half of the world.
And do you support homosexuality ?
@@salahaldin447 atleast we don't live in same world and obviously I support marriage equality for all.
@@ankurjain7514 just do a Google search and see how many counties allow poligamy before you speak. Your own country allows polygamy are you kidding me ?
And for you to support marriage equality and not support polygamy is quite hypocritical. Polygamy is also a type of conventual marriage that's the should only concern the people engaging in it.
Who are you to say they can't ?
Why do you think polygamy shouldn't be allowed ?
I’m Muslim, and I support this law. Radical Islam is an issue. Just ask the dozens killed this week in my home country, Afghanistan.
You guys are the real gem bro! Love from India! You guys are real muslim! Respect ❤️
@@navalgupta2289 long live Afg-Indo friendship.
💖🙌🏽
Thanks
Protecting your country is more important than offending people 😐
Is this a joke? Really? if you keep offending people who are you protecting anyway?
@@av9553the right to say it.
A channel run by religious nation, with out Human Rights, democracy, women equality etc, talks about fence
What rights people don't have in Qatar
@Moon Deccans true
@Moon Deccans with only people who are against the law
Guys why do you get upset, she actually says that QATAR doesn't have the right to speak of FENCES, that's it... Why all this drama... Personally, I am not sure why she proclaims this, but she might be living somewhere where there is human rights, a democracy and women equality... I mean, women equality; I think there are countries with inequality between man and women but never heard of a country with problems of inequality between women and ... women. Her country must one of a kind.
@@fa8911 isnt this the same nation that forced foreign women to get vaginal exams just because they found a baby in a dumpster at the airport?
I see no problem with what France is doing. Keep your religion to yourself, in your house. I will have no problem with religion if it is kept private but that doesn't seem to be what religious people want.
All these analysis will not matter when Islam violently engulfs the whole of Europe, lol. Smell the coffee and nip it in the bud now. State and religion should always remain separate.
If muslim can do that, they will. The covering of their head by muslim women is obligatory when they met strangers which is in the public space. even if they met a mailman at their front door, it is still obligatory for them to cover their head. muslim woman dont sleep and shower using hijab, you know.
@@olu1718 the idea of separatism is good. but just like what is says on the video, the law they make by French leaders doesnt match with the actual meaning of separatism.
yes, unfortunately those extrimist using the name of islam, but in reality they are not. and this policy just generalized that all muslim are like that. when in fact, they are not.
Religious always gotta shove it down everyone's throat
@@sbf155 and where exactly is written that it's obligatory. I can't see any reference in Quran or religious text.
Please show us what's the procedure for citizenship in Maldives, Malysia, Saudi ,UAE
You can't get citizenship in Saudi or UAE, you are not a local.
@@sidahmed3855 Then you cannot stay in europe. you are not local..
@@alangervasis no I'm being fr you can't get citizenship in Saudi or UAE you cans Tay there but not citizenship I was born there and I still don't have citizenship
@Daniel Lim no, they dont give citizenship to anyone even muslim. You can get permanent residence tho.
Why your ore so stupid..do your homework
Alternative title: why France is the most based country in Europe
Lol 😳
As a none-Christian , none-Muslim person. I don’t see any issue in the points in that bill ( learnt from this video ).
Why can’t Muslim people accept those terms and be happy about the opportunity to silently follow their religion. Those points are not against you following your religion.
Protecting individual lives is the most important task to overwhelm separatism and extremism
I'm a secular and liberal Indian and I support france. I wish we can have that type of free speech here in India.
This proves secularism and liberalism is terrorist version of anti-religion movements that oppress religious people who don’t believe in their ideology
@@middleeaststats271 atleast better than Your middleeast piecekeepers, osama bin laden etc.
Is not freedom if is “banning” -.-‘
@No One is no one i totally agree, these bjp and rss goons will totally ruin noble image of India and Hinduism. They are also threat on India's secularism and democracy.
I'm also a hindu but there are some Hindus who don't support secularism.
@No One is no one NAME ONE TERRORISM DONE BY RSS OR BJP?
Kindly if you could do a short story on UAE’s citizenship policy ...
Thanks
Sort your own country instead of running away from it
@@rathernot6660 it is smartass
Ninety percent of UAE population foreigners.
You want to give Citizenship to foreigners they become extinct!
@@mohamedasaid7910 You do love to have them as slaves, don't you?
@@broadcastmadnesss No you have to be practical.I am not a UAE citizen I would love to be one.
However UAE is under-populated if they give Citizenship to many foreigners the indeginous could lose there country.
May be they give 10 percent of there population to those who have lived and accepted there way of life.
Civilized societies must not tolerate crazy people who believe in spirits.
People only became civilised due to the teachings of people who belief in spirit.
@nori the seaweed yes maybe not everyone. But honestly people did not become civilised cause they already knew what was bad and what was wrong.
@@armaghanahmad3096 I totally agree with that Ahmad. But I also think that now we have reached the point where we can teach right and wrong with more modern methods.
I love all religions, and people should be free to enjoy them without politics. It is when they turn us against each other for silly reasons that they become a bad thing.
@@gg1275 what are the modern methods care to explain.
@@armaghanahmad3096 don't stone women to death when they commit adultery, don't stone people to death just for being gay, rather, give them rights that will protect them from outdated superstitious beliefs. You know, like most modern democratic countries do...
You come to another country, they accept you, they offer you a chance for a normal life - and you give them back by trying to make that country the same stale country you escaped from!
That’s gotta be the most ignorant comment I have heard in a while
The truth hurts sometimes! And the conflict of cultures is a real problem, whether you want to admit it to yourself or not.
When you add religion to that, which in some countries is to closely woven into the culture, you have big problems.
@@oscargrove2107 You are obviously hard of hearing
@@oscargrove2107 Not at all. This is what is observed everywhere in Europe. Ask those women who escaped Algeria if they want the religion controlling all their lives...again
We the indian citizens are facing the similar situation in INDIA. Islamic extremists with the support and help of leftist parties , madarasas , castist and anti -social political groups have launched a heinous phisical attack on Hindu society. We support Macron in his efforts to weed out Islamic terrorism from France.
Yes!
Good, Erdogan and Qatar's Thamims should raise their voice for uighurs next
😬😬😬 inki himaat nai h
@@jakharkartik1152 nahi hai inki himmat
Yes sahi hai .
Erdogan did
@@zakazikoziko1419 by sending them back to xinjiang into china's arms. Yea he helped them by feeding them to the chinese.
All christian majority countries are secular, muslim majority are not,this explains a lot
Yup
@Gayshriram Ramaurlaxmangaypartners I don't support that and India is a secular country.
@Gayshriram Ramaurlaxmangaypartners I was talking about the Constitution
@Gayshriram Ramaurlaxmangaypartners I was talking about the Constitution
@Gayshriram Ramaurlaxmangaypartners And India is not just UP and Bihar. India is bigger than that, have you heard about south India and kerala
CAN U EXPLAIN WHY THERE IS BLASPHEMY LAW IN ISLAM? OR WHY THERE IS A NEED FOR SUCH A LAW?
Insecure religion!!
Great idea
The reason is to protect the truth from ridicule and mockery and to make sure that people take the religion seriously and not as a joke like modern Christianity.
@@dk2.026 'Truth' doesn't need any protection but puny ego and false claims always need protection, and this is what they are trying to protect.
@@dk2.026 😂😂😂why words of god need protection...? Or is it because of insecurity.. objecting the teaching that is inhuman?
It is keeping ppl from questioning..that no other religion do. It keep ppl mouth and mind shut and make them believe everything. Though they may have issues with it but they cant openly talk about it. If they do so they are not muslim acc to their religion.. what an stupidity.
No religious teaching is supreme. All the present day religion born in the ancient and medieval period. People should take only those part that satisfy their common reasoning. Religion must be open and not closed one like Islam.
You can fight everything except “ Islam”
Only dictatorship can handle Islam.
@@SubhamRai5 you are mistaken man
Hard to handle nut balls!
exactly, 100% true with current generation.
Islam brainwashed innit like in village of the damned innit?
I love Qatar's version of Secularism. We should follow this type of Secularism 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Stfu you are mad because they live better than you country
Secularism is bad. We need to Unite the Catholic Church to the state.
so you support radical French people satirizing other people's religion? how about respecting other people or just darn shutting up? do they die when they don't make fun of other people?
@@makara2711 ???
In Qatar every religion is treated equally come and look
You should interview people who lost their families in the name of religion, let them speak their mind!
Yes it is saddening and terrible that there are those who misinterpreted or utilize religion or philosophy as a way to justify their sadistic or unrighteous actions..
Like Hitler, or the invading of iraq and other middle east countries or asian countries in the name of “freedom”, anti communism and etc.
The Qur’an stated about being secular and to live with one another.
“If God had so willed, He would have made all of you one community, but he has not done so, in order that he may test you according to what he has given you; so compete in goodness. To God shall you all return, and He will tell you the truth about what you have been disputing."
(Qur'an: 5:48.)
“human beings are created in different tribes and nations so that they may know and understand each other.”
(Qur’an 49:13)
We are all told to find ways to not just to live and respect one another but to also help one another.
The Qur’an allows you to make your own choice as you believe with respect to other people.
Although I don’t support the way the West / French of rule of thumb about free speech, the Qur’an teaches us on how we should respect other people’s point of view, be it they demonstrate it with hate or love.
Thus, it is important to have a public law on how to respect one another, especially with regards to freedom of speech, so that the state / a community remains in peace, respectful, and help one another.
Surely the French government would condemn anyone using any racist slurs in publications or antisemitic publications, which should be put in laws equally to prevent islamophobia and such others.
However, preventing people from practicing or showing their religious belief (i.e. placing strict dress code) is not a way to show or cultivate tolerance in society.
It is showing and upholding what is right and just, and bringing respect and help to one another is what can nurture the tolerance in us all, for the most part.
About freaking time a western government takes a hard stance against religious extremism inside their countries. Either adapt to the new culture or stay in your countries. I was not sure if I was going to see it during my lifetime, with all these brain numbing 'wokeness' going on
oh stay in your countries? well I would stay in my country if France and every other western country didn't aid in the destruction of Palestine! first destroy our countries and then order us to stay there in the ruble
Agreed
It seems that laicite is saying that the French Republic comes first, that there are certain secular values that are essential towards the harmony of the state and what it is to be French. Religion becomes secondary, as laicite was used to diminish the roles of Christianity and Judaism in French public life. If someone does not agree with those values, then perhaps France is not the place for them to live.
So now Arabs are talking about secularism and democratic values.😂
So question can also be what is the percentage to the support of the state should tell you how you should dress and limit your freedom of speech?
The Qur’an stated about being secular and to live with one another.
“If God had so willed, He would have made all of you one community, but he has not done so, in order that he may test you according to what he has given you; so compete in goodness. To God shall you all return, and He will tell you the truth about what you have been disputing."
(Qur'an: 5:48.)
“human beings are created in different tribes and nations so that they may know and understand each other.”
(Qur’an 49:13)
We are all told to find ways to not just to live and respect one another but to also help one another.
The Qur’an allows you to make your own choice as you believe with respect to other people.
Although I don’t support the way the West / French of rule of thumb about free speech, the Qur’an teaches us on how we should respect other people’s point of view, be it they demonstrate it with hate or love.
Thus, it is important to have a public law on how to respect one another, especially with regards to freedom of speech, so that the state / a community remains in peace, respectful, and help one another.
Surely the French government would condemn anyone using any racist slurs in publications or antisemitic publications, or holocaust denial which should be put in laws equally to prevent islamophobia and such others.
However, preventing people from practicing or showing their religious belief (i.e. placing strict dress code) is not a way to show or cultivate tolerance in society.
It is showing and upholding what is right and just, and bringing respect and help to one another is what can nurture the tolerance in us all, for the most part.
As a Filipino, France maybe strict about secularism but they really do secularism properly.
I want to be as calm and composed as this womn next time when i am on the stage.
She is legend
She's good, but don't forget this is a studio-recorded programme, without an audience.
@@Toyota415 true
@@Toyota415 do you really think it's easy to do that too?
@@Galland780 yes. Not that difficult once you get into the profession. After she was trained for this and she charges huge money for this.
Haha
anyone who thinks it's ok to murder someone over a cartoon needs to check themselves. That's just crazy.
There is 56 Islamic countries why don't they go a live There, we in India are fade of them.
How can terrorism in Islam be stopped?
If someone truly followed Islam, they wouldn't have been terrorist in the first place. Evil people justify their actions with religions.
Listen, France is as in much its right to ban religion as other countries who have islam as it’s government.
Your ancestors where forced to ban Islam is that democratic?
@@positive4694 they were actually forced to convert to Islam or die and then got sick of it and kicked them out of Portugal.
@@CarolinaSanctos88 your ancestos choose to become muslim. If your moorish ancestors forced Islam the whole iberian peninsula would convert. Looking at you its clearly your parents were moorish converts to catholicism
@@positive4694 loooooooooooool ok thanks for inventing my family’s story. And no, we don’t lie or omit and sugar-coat things in our history lessons, that religion was spread by the sword and those who refused had to pay jyziah. Trust me, my ancestors prefer to Christ to old Mo any day, even though I dont prefer either because to me religion is fairytales.
@@CarolinaSanctos88 christianity was enforced in america by the spaniards with genocides.
I am not inventing your family history I am stating a fact. Its clearly that you need a new mirror because its obvious you'r a latinized Moor
"All those communities have been able to coexist because of secularism. The state is neutral but the people are not neutral"
Macron spoke truth. The problem has been identified & needs solution. No religion can be allowed to kill other faith people.
true!!!
Al Jazeera propaganda mechanism in full effect ,its interesting that this presenter will sell her soul for a paycheck just to defend a religion that would make her a "Concubine" !!!
Why is it always the Hindus cheering Macro targeting a certain group of people
@@MeoWooff_01, Hindus support the truth, as they know truth and ideology of the religion & their intention in the long run for other religions. One religion preaches that it is the only religion & no one else. It is not truth. Any religion based on hating others & violence against others is not acceptable. Read history how Syria(Christian) , Iran(Parsi) & Iraq were converted to Islamic nations,not secular.
@@dharamvirsinghdahiya9362 irrelevanttt bindoooo trying to be relevantttt 🤣🤣
While I think it was rude of some people to criticize someone else's belief system, murder is not the way to respond to "you hurt my feelings". Religious people are secretly rejoicing in these tragedies.
Just stop, next time u wanna comment somthing know what your talking about
@@serialz4908 I know exactly what i'm talking about. Majority of the people in my country are rejoicing over Rushdie's tragedy. They are happy that he got stabbed.
@@serialz4908 he seems very educated in what he's saying, maybe you should educate yourself before criticizing others
Wow...That's so nice. I better migrate to France now.
... Is this sarcasm ...?
@@rueosman5808 not for atheist
@@rueosman5808 it literally heaven for any seeker who doesn't follow any dogmatic religion.
@Muhammed Fariz Are you Christian?
i am hindu but i will also migrate in France..... or file a PIL to abolish blasphemy in my country.....
Talk about secularism in all Muslim countries
Wtf live in France live by French laws...simple.
I have never heard "A good Buddhist and a Bad Buddhist", and when can we expect democracy in Qatar?
😂😂
Lande jithe pn aahe tikre problem asnar
@ঘোসিটা ফ্লেমিম্গা So why do citizens of a Non democratic nation, always want to be refugees/citizens of democracy and wish to risk there life's for it?? they can just walk there way to other Monarchy but they don't..
@Mohammed Faisal Yes, gobar is part of my culture... Yours is to go to a foreign land loot and plunder ..good for nothing
@ঘোসিটা ফ্লেমিম্গা Right.. so why do the citizens of these country wish to move to the country/s who tag them terrorist??
I always love the irony of Arabs talking about religious tolerance 🤣
I know right makes me laugh
i can't understand what make your mouth open?
A thing called liberty
I mean they stood for that in Palestine and now look at what's happening to them.
@@haykay1626 they stand every where for Peace. Please understand the issue of palastine. It's very different. Their own land stole the jews before 60 years and they have been attacking unanimously and when Palestine tries to prevent the Israel government scaring their people in the name of one or two. Hamaz attacked Israel. But reached israel as well for one or just numbers. Because they prevent almost all the rockets by their technology. But in turn, to palastine. There nothing to prevent, they all hurts and being killed. Ok? Are you a adamant? A thinking human. It should you keep in your mind. Not be an adamant. Be free your mind from prior knowledges by society. Ok?
This will be good, i'm sure the Qatari government (Al Jazeera) will be very impartial with this one
I thought they had money fron Saudi Arabia.
@@giovannimannelli2158 quatari government
Well, what do you think? Was it impartial?
@Dabbing Titan The right stance is a skeptical one when you're talking about state approved, state funded media. I obviously watched it after i commented this. If you dont recognize Qatar's ownership and use of AJ as state propaganda idk what to tell you buddy. You dont have to respect me idc lol
@@giovannimannelli2158 Saudi Arabia banned them in their country-
Myanmar military coup or Gamestop rally
@Oliver Royal yea about the charizard analogy, it was awesome
Why can't you do both
the government was silenced with threats of coup and death of NLD members if they spoke up. They wanted to brand Aung San Suu Kyi and her party as traitors to the other ethnic groups if they openly supported Rohingya against the country's main ethnic groups so that they can finally have the excuse to jail and kill the democratic party. U Ko Ni, a devout muslim, was her right hand man in parliament but he was assasinated by the military shortly after bringing up the conversation for Rohingya crisis. Even in the election last year, there were so many admin errors, eg. Our names were intentionally missing, one woman's name was duplicated etc etc. My name and many others were not registered despite the fact that we registered way beforehand. The military rigged us, got caught, lost the election and now they are afraid that they would be stripped of their power in the next 5 years and be arrested for genocide.
@@kennethjimenez9561 i don't think they'll talk about the gamestop stuff. It's too complicated to be here. You should listen to all in podcast, they explain it well. Smart people.
Al Jazeera a Qatar newz channel talking about secularism 😂😂
If you live in France 🇫🇷 then integrate or leave! Remember that the French people were there before you!!!
Yes
We stand with French govt!
People don't have problem with terrorism but problem with cartoon...
Total muslim world oppose cartoon but not terrorism...
💯
It doesn't just mean secularism, it has more to do with the English word "laity". It's the rejection of organized religion's control of public life.
Secularism is ideal but blasphemy is radical and not good at all
thank you for this video !!
Japan is the most secular country, France are years behind compared to Japan.
Japanese don't have a large Muslim community
@@user-rh5nd9zk9w
Whether, Muslim, Christian or what have you, religion is a TABOO subject there. If you want to rent a hall for a religious service, you are 9/10 likely to be turn down, just because you’ve mentioned a religious purpose.
Japan is a very non religious society, even when it comes to their local religions.
France never had Kamikaze pilots
@@jbk19xx57 and also japan has one of the tightest migration laws
@sneksnekitsasnek
Maybe so, but it doesn’t seem to be observed as a religion, but more like a seasonal event. It has been stated, that 70% visit shrines but only 3% claim to be Shintô and another 36% claim to subscribe to a religion.
Please do a story on Southern Africa and its near dictatorship politics.
Yeah man doesn't matter what race, age or gender all those politicians are corrupt tbh the same can be said for allot the leaders of the entire continent hopefully this is the last generation of that style of rule
Who are they. The dictators
What's happening in south Africa...
@@k-way232 Equatorial Guinea was supposed to be a prime example but yet the people are bieng oppressed by a younger and even more corrupted 'leader'. Our generation is helpless, with global powers steering the entire agenda of our economies in the name of climate change and so on... today and forever will always be about the 'old vs new'. Politicians and world leaders are like today's toilets - inefficient whichever way u make it smart.
@@rathernot6660 Not the presidents at all even, the elite whites that inherited the apartheid regime. This includes large private corporations which operate accross the southern region with complete immunity. They have monopolized the entire region while maintaining different political climates, hence the borders. This ensures limited movement of goods and services and opens up good opportunities for companies like shoprite and standard bank. They keep on operating in countries like Zimbabwe while we are generally scared of exploiting those markets. The dictatorship does not lie with an individual or the elected officials but the large corporations which fuel the seperatism.
*The elite whites I have mentioned are obviously the richest men in Southern Africa and not the general public*
It is something like this...you take pity on a beggar and allow them place in your home. Then this beggar starts saying that I want a part of your home.
Ohk saudi arabia banned anything other than islam.
If someone is even starting yoga classes they are detained but if france banned their burkha and nakaab they are feeling opressed .wtf hypocracy
As an agnostic Muslim, I say well done France! 😉😘
“Agnostic Muslim” lmao that’s not a thing
@@popoffpeppar I am an agnostic Christian.
@@johnpijano4786 Then I am a virgin Gigolo
Im a law abiding criminal
Islam needs reform
Well we can’t because Europe has been booming us for last century
Throw them out , before they start to ask for a separaate country , like they did in India , when they created Pakistan .
This playlist is one of my favorite playlists of all time
India supports France forever
Love from India
No man cares what a man worshiping a cow supports and what he doesn't.
let christians, jews and hindu make a protest in qatar, saudi arabia, pakistan and we'll see what happens there.
For some news another teacher has been threatened by a parent by reminding him about samuel patty's event and what could happen to him , because he noted that parent's child 0/20 and convocated the parent to ask what was wrong or if something happened for her to abandon school , but the parent claimed it was racism and harassment to note her 0 even tho she did nothing on the exam
Killing should be banned in all religions.
I don't know why people say this french bill is bad
Because Al Jazeera is the propaganda network of Qatar - an oppressive salafist Gulf Monarchy. They want to construct a narrative against the bill (while also being one of the biggest public and private funders of extremism and terrorism within France and the West).
Nguyên Đào have you seen the video lol?
@@aaminahasan6270 the bill only restrict the appearance of religion in public and minimize the funding for religious organization in general (abroad) other than that it only shut down mosque that is suspicious
If you didn't do anything they won't pick on you is that not simple
Further more i thought the bill will wipe islam in france out of existence but it only limiting the chance of it become malicious not like they are cracking down by bringing believer to a concentration camp or banish them
@@aintnoslice3422 i guess what you are saying is true since euqal benefits on both party have never been done (generally speaking) (even in old time)
If you have influence you might as well as make it look good on you are make your narrative become the norm for everyone
@@ricefarmer1688 that is the problem with the bill. To wear a hijab is an obligation, not juts a symbol like a nun veil. To remove the hijab itself is a sin. Hope you understand
The french government and the French people have every right to make whatever law they want
@Student Work lol the reason their world values are widespread is because of post colonialism and I dont think u wanna be reminded of the atrocities the west committed in Africa,America,Australia etc
If every country passes its laws without care for international law and peacefull co-existense then will have to go for third-world war to rectify the situation .
No country is an Island
Mohamed A Said correct but that’s not what France is doing ? France is a majority Christian/catholic country so they have the right to make people follow Christian/catholic laws the exact same way many Middle Eastern country’s force people to follow Islamic law but nobody has a problem with that🤷♂️
Student Work and I don’t think you want to be reminded about atrocities Muslim country’s/empires committed either
@Student Work Yh I do look at 8th century to 14th century Islam during this time there was full sharia law in the caliphate and Baghdad was the capital of education and technological advancement in the world.most modern hospital equipment and techniques,astronomy encyclopaedias,physics,chemistry, medicine agronomy and geology etc came from Islam even the Jews had their golden age under Islam in Spain during this time. Additionally the first welfare system for pensions,poverty,unemployment insurance which didn’t go near the west until the 19th century,a minimum wage,and no interest which u can see clearly is destroying economies because of constant loans that are hard to repay due to interest.most of the things you see in the world today are because of Islamic culture
Intolerance must end. If a cartoon can hurt your faith then you have a problem with your faith
Muslim immigrants in France must respect "laicite" and secularism and the separation of state and religion. If they don't respect that why should they be allowed to live in France or be French citizens?
Why is depicting bad and offensive photographies of Muhammad is considered freedom of speech while anti-homosexuality or supporting Nazism isn't?
Most peaceful community in the world😂😂
We need more secular more governments in the world, the true form of secularism, not how the French government has corrupted it for their own use.
muslim have also to be secular
ok, can you explain??
All Secular Governments are Corrupted like macron ..The whole Secularism idea is just a Bullshit and corruption
@@unapologetic7291 do you think they dont ?
There is a lot of secular muslim states like turkey but the west still hate turkey .. becuse you have a problem with Islam only .. The secularism wants to end Islam just like how they ended Christianity then you become a pure slave and ez to be controlled by the Corrupted leaders
Secularism and Islam is a paradox lol
American needs this bill as well, all the west countries needs to apply to this bill
We need a bill like this for hinduvta
Thank You! France for defending Secularism.
I would like to hear more about the question, whether carbon taken up by plants would slow down climate change and the effects of planting trees. Thank you for the excellent series "start here".
lets be open minded here and honest. Islamic terrorism is not inspired by ISIS or Al quetta,or Boko Haram or Al Shabah but is instructed by verses in the quran. There many verses where the quran is referencing these kind of attacks.
Lol Al Jazeera talking about secularism 😂😂😂😂
First fix Qatar with apostasy and blasphemy law 🤣🤣
qatari are paid 3 times better than french and have free education free hospitalization and great architecture and rich culture people are happy and great scense of and meaning of family even if its 10times a small country
@@saadel348 if it's has better way of living how many scientists from qatar, how many scholars,how many sportsperson hahah...
U can have lot of money but can't but quality mate
About time! I hope the entire European continent follows macron’s lead
In any place in this world...when some people do bad thing in the name of their religion.
The religion would be in danger itself.
I am for the law, go Macron! Viva la France and la Laicité. Same rules for everyone or no tolerance at all
This is a great start.
And France is NOT an Islamic Republic, they can do what they want, if people don't like it, they can leave.
Stop with the backlash already.
Im a hindu it means i am a kafir... Please dont kill me 😥😥 i will convert into islam....but plss dont kill me and my son .
That I like ❤ most about you is a program presenter who is completely self confident
Shut up dude. Any news presenter would be self confident 🙄
S I m p
Definition of Secularism itself is being changed over the years that is why some people hate Secularism. Secularism now has different meanings in different countries.
Secularism, actually means every person will have right to practice his/her Religion while the State remains Neutral towards all Religions.
Whereas some States think Secularism means removing Religion itself which is wrong that is why some people don't like Secularism.
Of course...
@@sommmeguy it's kinda annoying. Especially when all she does (while useful and quite helpful) is present a quick summary of topics. It ain't groundbreaking
I think that it's a complex situation pertaining a wide variety of factors of why one group is retaliating against the other. I see several keywords as crucial to this matter such as, "integrate", "control", "freedom". One group expects another group to integrate to their national and cultural identity. One group claims to give freedom through constitution, yet another group expresses freedom in which the former don't agree, thus wanting to establish "control" over the latter. It's a vicious circle.
@Weedling 2 no other country forces assimilation like France but they have immigrants just fine
Country is above all religion, things that happened in France in recent times justify this kind of bill
Next Episode Suggestion: Carbon Emission Disclosure of Big Businesses to Solve Climate Change
I'd like to see a video on the India China relationship and boarder dispute
wat to know india accept british lines but china don'[t recognize it there boarder issue
Me too
and I would like to see a video of me tying the knot with the lovely hostess of this show😏🤭
We do not always get what we want, do we?
@@axel665 no India accept Tibet lines.India shared its borders with Tibet not china.
Why my child Pakistaniii
Islam ia not a religion, it is a political movement.
Enjoying watching Starts Here.
After all these deaths, some still got the nerve to say there is no problem with our religion's interpretation.
Are you a muslim yourself? Because it's very rare to see a muslim acknowledging the fact that there is a problem within their religion. So if you are, chapeau.
@@bornwithoutconsentobviously I am indeed. It's time we face our own demons, too many people think it's just about pumpkins and fairies.
France owns islam in france.. quran talks bout slavery in jihad!!
Gov must edit the Quran to help its citizens follow religion that comply with laws of france, law before quran
" Quran talks about slavery in jihad " , this line just shows your level of knowledge. Pls STFU
@@hamzaghazi 😂😂 just enough bruh
@@hamzaghazi he is wrong sahih muslim says about slavery in jihad not quran
Jews and Christians must pay the jizyah and feel themselves subdued. So said Muhammad the warlord and paedophile.
@@dotdashdotdash much better compared to the convert or die in christian empires, oh and btw those who didnt pay the jizya tax were not given the protection, however were allowed to live in those nations
I want learn from Al Jazeera how to take the attention away from the real problem.
A person who just drew a cartoon of Mohammed. And he was killed for his art. Is that right to kill someone because of his joke or drawing.
@Mohamed Boualem because he wanted to make that painting. He was cartoonist. His job is to do political and religious satire. His work is to criticises everything in the society question every religious beliefs and idea . Criticise the ideas of religion. Making fun is also a one form of criticism of religious ideas. Which stop us from doing certain actions. So through his art he criticises that actions.
One action is not drawing mohmmad. He asked a question through his painting why I can't. And he drew him.
So he challenged the idea of what we can't do. That's it.
When they haven’t realised 7 out of the 23 man World Cup winning squad was Muslim
And?
My parents are muslim but that doesnt mean I have to be one too.
So I dont get the point. Norms are norms, regardless of what religious people have done for you or me
@@selcukdilek4656 I agree with u but what does it have to do with my comment
@@beastfrombradford6685 thats the thing: it has nothing to do with your comment, just as your note to their national team is not relevant