Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.

The Great Hunt REVIEW - The Wheel of Time #2

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 5. 08. 2024
  • Spoiler-Free and Spoiler discussion and review of book two of Robert Jordan's fantasy series.
    twitter: / mancarrying
    patreon: / mancarryingthing
    reddit: / mancarryingthing
    discord invite: / discord
    0:00 Review (no spoilers)
    3:14 Spoiler Discussion
    #thegreathunt #wheeloftime

Komentáře • 358

  • @DanielGreeneReviews
    @DanielGreeneReviews Před 3 lety +718

    I’m just here so I don’t get fined.

    • @lord_ishamael
      @lord_ishamael Před 3 lety +17

      It’s so interesting to see the fan base grow now, I’ve met very few people in my day to day who knew about this series before bringing it up to them, it’d be cool to see it explode and become gigantic like LotR and Song of Ice and Fire have due to the video adaptation. On the other hand, I always felt like I was part of something special, and I’m kinda afraid for that to go away and become mainstream.

    • @ChaseMcCain81
      @ChaseMcCain81 Před 3 lety +3

      Oh, I understand that joke/reference/whatever it’s called.

    • @wabisabi7755
      @wabisabi7755 Před 3 lety +15

      But... you are fiiine.

    • @ManCarryingThing
      @ManCarryingThing  Před 3 lety +69

      Good call. The IRS skims my comments all the time.

    • @citizensguard3433
      @citizensguard3433 Před 3 lety +9

      My advice? You know he's going to have to get through like 10 more books and will have a review for each one (asuming the slog doesn't make him give up). start writing your comments for each video now. You'll have had months to pen the most witty and hilarious quips the comment section has ever seen and will be celebrated as both a gentleman and a scholar, for all time. Actually... don't do that. I'm doing it now. It was my idea. No one steal it! 😁

  • @lostschedule51
    @lostschedule51 Před 3 lety +183

    * flicker flicker flicker *
    And Nynaeve's test are my favourite parts in this book

    • @magisterofsteam7880
      @magisterofsteam7880 Před 3 lety +5

      My favorite is the "blink" scene in the one village.

    • @sumukhavenkatesha6171
      @sumukhavenkatesha6171 Před 2 lety +1

      @@magisterofsteam7880 bro mine two there great

    • @totesmagotes213
      @totesmagotes213 Před 2 lety +1

      That scene is one of my favorites in the entire series and what solidified for me that I was going to finish the series.

  • @weirdhillstodieon3322
    @weirdhillstodieon3322 Před 3 lety +122

    The portal stone scene is one of my favorite chapters of any book. The amount of character development thrown into this one sequence, of seeing all these possible outcomes for Rand and the other characters, really solidifies the paths that they must walk as the books go on. In my mind, it's what finally convinces Rand that he must accept he is The Dragon Reborn, and that he has to take control over this path as he moves forward. Can't wait to see how they pull this off in the show.

    • @ManCarryingThing
      @ManCarryingThing  Před 3 lety +17

      I am excited to read that section again after finishing the series

    • @varsityathlete9927
      @varsityathlete9927 Před 2 lety +2

      that is definitely one of the top parts I really want to see on screen. thought that when first reading it years ago.

    • @winxclubflora8446
      @winxclubflora8446 Před rokem

      @@varsityathlete9927i was soooo confused at that scene. Like i was vaguely aware what was happening but at the same time didn’t understand what it meant to the characters or their storie

  • @piotrbrys8008
    @piotrbrys8008 Před 3 lety +236

    Jordan's use of clothing is a great thing to pick up on, because it only intensifies as the books progress and it becomes a vessel for the political conflicts - especially in terms of allegiances. The Great Hunt is definitely a low point for Mat and we don't really get to see "His" true character until book 3, but oh boy is there stuff to look forward to. The series will keep increasing the world size and the cast size but it all comes down to the personalities and the changes in our main three Ta'veren. Good luck with the next books!

    • @ManCarryingThing
      @ManCarryingThing  Před 3 lety +41

      Thanks! I'll keep an eye on that. Very eager to see Mat in book 3

    • @Brian_L_A
      @Brian_L_A Před 3 lety +8

      @@ManCarryingThing Mat is usually everyone's favorite character.

    • @SMClonk
      @SMClonk Před 3 lety +3

      @@Brian_L_A i still dont get it. and i am now in book 8

    • @piotrbrys8008
      @piotrbrys8008 Před 3 lety

      @@SMClonk for me he shines towards the ending, but he has an irony and somewhat of a mocking character so it might not work for some people

    • @user-rl2md3km3g
      @user-rl2md3km3g Před 3 lety +2

      @@SMClonk Mat's character is not for everyone. I found his mistrust of the One Power particularly annoying. But his parts of the story are interesting, unlike Perrin who basically becomes a broken recorder in the latter half of the series.

  • @pooyashirazi1991
    @pooyashirazi1991 Před 3 lety +83

    Oddly enough, my favorite part of the book is Hurin. That moment when Hawkwing calls out to him to join the Heroes of the Horn is just something else!

    • @someweeb4110
      @someweeb4110 Před rokem +3

      Dude yes that was sick. Still sad I havent seen him again on book 9 :( no spoils plz

    • @winxclubflora8446
      @winxclubflora8446 Před 6 měsíci

      @@someweeb4110I actually just read the great hunt and i was suspecting hurin to be a darkfriend all along😂 he was just too good!

  • @Aero3691
    @Aero3691 Před 3 lety +75

    The Accepted trial and the portal stone were easily my favorite scenes in the book. I love seeing the potential futures for these characters and how seeing that changes them in the here and now.

  • @benshelsby5628
    @benshelsby5628 Před 3 lety +28

    I really liked Bornhald in this book, which is kinda strange considering he only had like 2 chapters to himself. I just liked how he was sort of beginning to question the leadership of the children of the light and I feel like he had such great potential for a sort of redemption arc.

  • @matthewletexier
    @matthewletexier Před 3 lety +58

    Oh man that scene where mat says he won't betray Rand breaks my heart

  • @marinhobrandao
    @marinhobrandao Před 2 lety +17

    I also got strained about Selene since the first plot and was all along expecting to see when she would reveal herself a bad villain, and I got quite annoyed why Rand was so naive about her all the time, and then suddenly she vanished with no continuation.

  • @jaiadlakha212
    @jaiadlakha212 Před 3 lety +45

    Local man carrying things mispronounces Cairhien,throws Fandom into chaos

  • @JoshNeller
    @JoshNeller Před 3 lety +21

    "UNEXPECTED" was the word I would use in my review for TGH, it's such a serious book, and when the characters just have a small break, the trio bantering at the side as if their back at Emond's Field, I genuinely had a brief, and refreshing smile. It's non-stop just here and there flicker, flicker, flicker, flicker, flicker, flicker.

  • @fredischilling
    @fredischilling Před 3 lety +34

    Nynaeve develops some of the best dynamics with the other characters, and they only get more nuanced and interesting with every book.
    Edit: typo.

  • @dontdoitsayan2921
    @dontdoitsayan2921 Před 3 lety +30

    I’m also just two books in and Nynaeve is my fav as well!!

  • @UdyKumra
    @UdyKumra Před 3 lety +168

    I cannot wait for you to get to Mat’s POVs in book 3 and immediately flip in your opinion on him lol. My favorite thing about Mat (which you see a bit in book 2) is that he will constantly say he doesn’t want anything to do with his dangerous friends and the shit they get up to and he’ll be a dick about it and the next thing you know he’s crossed a continent to help them because in the end he’s the most loyal one of them all.

    • @petecoleman3443
      @petecoleman3443 Před 3 lety +5

      I'm on book 5 and I still dont really like Mat

    • @ManCarryingThing
      @ManCarryingThing  Před 3 lety +37

      I'm super excited for some Mat POV's. I feel like having a lack of them has contributed to my feelings about him

    • @UdyKumra
      @UdyKumra Před 3 lety +5

      @@petecoleman3443 I’m on book 5 too and after book 3 I love him. He’s still my favorite character despite having a reduced role in books 4-5. Book 3 he literally traveled all over the continent to help Egwene and Nynaeve because he’d do anything for his friends 🥺

    • @ladelteravada
      @ladelteravada Před 3 lety +10

      @@UdyKumra Dude(tte?). No spoilers.

    • @notjazz.
      @notjazz. Před 3 lety +6

      @@petecoleman3443 if you don’t love Matt after book 5 you’re a demon

  • @Wirrn
    @Wirrn Před 3 lety +29

    Mat's "See ya" moment worked really well for me, because it's so utterly shitty, but also so utterly believably human in the context of the setting.
    Rand's a male channeler. There isn't any way of standing by that and helping him through it, everyone in the room knows he IS going to go insane.
    But then like you say, after the flicker scene Mat is distraught and repeatedly promising he wouldn't ever betray Rand - clearly he DID betray him in one of those other worlds, and whatever happened shook him to his core to learn he was capable of that.
    Good writing.

    • @winxclubflora8446
      @winxclubflora8446 Před 6 měsíci +1

      Ohhh i never considered that part in the flicker scene!! You really gave me a new perspective! Nice analysis

    • @Wirrn
      @Wirrn Před 6 měsíci +1

      @@winxclubflora8446 thank you, that brightened my day! 😀
      But yeah the flicker is a turning point in the way Mat acts - towards the others. Though granted the Aes Sedai heal the stupid out of him shortly after 🤣

    • @winxclubflora8446
      @winxclubflora8446 Před 6 měsíci +1

      @@Wirrn actually mat has been my favourite character(along with rand ofc) since the first chapter of the first book! I know his reaction to finding out about rand being dragon was awful but mat still remained my most favourite character throughout the two books i read! So i cant wait to see how he becomes even better in book 3 cuz like he is already my favourite and you guys say he becomes even better?! Cant wait to start book 3!! (I am currently on chapter 1 and damn pedron nial opening chapter was something else i mean the questioner is a darkfriend!! Whitecloaks were supposed to be good!!)

    • @Wirrn
      @Wirrn Před 6 měsíci

      ​@@winxclubflora8446 Whoops, glad I didn't say more!
      Most people find Mat one of the best from Book 3 onwards, but also most people seem to not like early Mat, so hopefully you'll find he improves rather than changing the bits you like :D Honestly its mostly that you actually get inside his head in POVs and see he's not as dim as he sometimes appeared :D
      And who told you Whitecloaks are good? Was it a whitecloak? :P

  • @randalthor6771
    @randalthor6771 Před 3 lety +35

    The character development of rand is insane throughout the series

    • @bemusedalligator
      @bemusedalligator Před 3 lety +6

      and the way his behavior, which externally looks obviously like man channeling style madness, makes perfect sense from inside his head.
      The shift from normal teen to insane ruler of half the planet was SO well done, unlike some other series I might mention...

    • @magicker8052
      @magicker8052 Před 3 lety

      I am blasting through the books ahead of the shows.. I find rand a bit rushed at times. Especially after Tier. The jump to hanging went very fast

    • @anypercentdeathless
      @anypercentdeathless Před rokem

      @@bemusedalligator You mean normal teen to Jesus.

  • @perfectly_desi
    @perfectly_desi Před 3 lety +20

    About the fireworks part: DON'T FORGET IT. Rand being ta'avern nothing he does is unnecessary. We will hear more about the aftermath of it in book 3. I'm pretty sure you would love where that arc is headed.

    • @winxclubflora8446
      @winxclubflora8446 Před 6 měsíci

      I just finished the great hunt,and oh my gosh i thought the fireworks was just a random action scene! It means more?!!

    • @perfectly_desi
      @perfectly_desi Před 6 měsíci

      @@winxclubflora8446 Random scenes are always important if it involves a ta'avern. The fireworks scene leads to one of our main cast developing one of my most favorite attribute in their character. Stay on the lookout.

  • @gman7774
    @gman7774 Před 3 lety +15

    Pretty much every character in the series other than Moraine will frustrate you to no end. But the fact that they can frustrate you and make you so angry just shows how much you care about all of them.

  • @wilsontabb8222
    @wilsontabb8222 Před 3 lety +16

    Whenever I go back through for a reread, I’m always a little surprised with how little I like Mat for the first two books because he gets so much better.

  • @johntencate4781
    @johntencate4781 Před 3 lety +40

    on book 6 rn, and the 'flicker flicker flicker' scene is still the best part yet.

    • @convective7103
      @convective7103 Před 3 lety +10

      That’s just because you haven’t gotten to the end of book 6 yet ;)

    • @johntencate4781
      @johntencate4781 Před 3 lety +11

      @@convective7103 *increases audiobook speed to 2.0*

    • @alexhall3516
      @alexhall3516 Před 3 lety

      @@johntencate4781 You have no idea. I never actually re-listened to a chapter until the end of Book 6. Make you sure you listen to the end in one straight hit.

    • @ChristmasLore
      @ChristmasLore Před 2 lety

      I first read it in a haze, as I was falling asleep on both the physical book and the audiobook.
      It felt like I was dreaming, like I dreamt it all, and I had to go back the next day.
      After re-reading, maybe the haze was the very best way to experience it.

    • @MrSmokinDragon
      @MrSmokinDragon Před 2 lety +2

      The Rhuidean chapter in book 4 (the Crystal Columns) is my absolute favourite chapter of the series. Seeing the past through the eyes of your ancestors is such a cool concept

  • @JS-ct5jn
    @JS-ct5jn Před 3 lety +3

    I am remembering all of the difficulties I had trying to pronounce cities and names with my first read. I have listened to the audio books so many times that I just forgot how different I pronounced these in my head verses the narrator. I now listen to the whole series once a year. I am still surprised at some of the very early foreshadowing that takes place as well. Love this series!

  • @kaspermygenfordt2323
    @kaspermygenfordt2323 Před 2 lety +6

    When mat says he won't betray rand, after the portal stone. I always interpreted that as him just seeing himself betray him over and over again and now the "real" mat was realizing that he doesn't want to be that person. Trying to reassure himself that he will do different.

  • @thelemmiebee
    @thelemmiebee Před 3 lety +7

    It’s really cool watching you go through your wheel of time journey. I feel like whoever finishes the wheel of time series has their fantasy palate forever changed up a bit and it’s awesome

  • @BrandonsWritingRoom
    @BrandonsWritingRoom Před 3 lety +30

    I was impressed by the way Jordan uses this book to establish how certain actions and their consequences will continue to ripple throughout the whole series. The dagger, Rand growing as a channeler, the arrival of the Seanchan, the wound he suffers in the fight at the end. All of these things continue to affect the rest of the story. I'd love to know how much Jordan had planned from the outset, because the lengths of some plot and character arcs across the series are just astounding.

    • @ManCarryingThing
      @ManCarryingThing  Před 3 lety +9

      I get the sense that this series is insanely well-plotted

    • @kg4wwn
      @kg4wwn Před 3 lety

      @@ManCarryingThing Yes, and then again, very much no. Jordan plotted the beginning and end with all kinds of cleverness. Did a lot less work figuring out how to get there.

  • @conormeehan.
    @conormeehan. Před 3 lety +24

    Congrats on being noticed by Brando Sando :D

    • @piotrbrys8008
      @piotrbrys8008 Před 3 lety +4

      wait how did he get noticed?

    • @conormeehan.
      @conormeehan. Před 3 lety +9

      @@piotrbrys8008 Brandon retweeted his Stephen King crashes Sanderson video on Twitter!

    • @ManCarryingThing
      @ManCarryingThing  Před 3 lety +9

      Thank you my friend. It has been an honour of a lifetime. Retiring soon.

  • @codyreitsma5918
    @codyreitsma5918 Před 3 lety +5

    The Great Hunt is still my personal favorite WoT book, and I am currently on book 14. To me it just has a great balance of almost everything I want from a fantasy story: great characters, adventure, humor, magic, heist elements, world building, exotic people groups, politics, mystery, and it leaves you eager for more.
    My favorite aspects of the book are seeing Rand growing into his leadership role, as well as the entire climax. I love that the climax not only has a great magical/legendary feel with the sounding of the Horn, but we also get a good old fashioned sword fight between Rand and Turak before that. Something about that sword fight gives me a good sense of payoff going back to the moment Rand first decided to take his father’s sword in book 1.

  • @nottherey4333
    @nottherey4333 Před 3 lety +8

    Nynaeve is also one of my favourite characters so I'm glad you like her. My favourite part is portal stone, everything that happened to girls, Seanchen...

  • @wotfanedit
    @wotfanedit Před rokem +14

    The algorithm blessed me with this review 1 year later. Books 2 absolutely SLAPS so hard. Jordan really brings his own voice to the story after the Fellowship homage that was Book 1. I will never forget the scene with a certain character defending an alleyway. So masterfully written and amazing to think about in hindsight.

  • @maddu8437
    @maddu8437 Před 2 lety +7

    Just finished the Great Hunt yesterday. I felt so glad to find someone who shares my dislike with everything regarding Selene. I LOVED Rand’s development mind you. Him “growing into the Lord’s clothing” was incredible to read. And I get she was a big part of that, but I still hated her. I also immediately suspected her to be Lanfear, which made me even more pissed off at Rand for not suspecting her at all lol.
    Still a great read tho, jumping into the third book soon.

  • @korgaupisc129
    @korgaupisc129 Před 3 lety +16

    Yup, great book. I honestly can't distinguish anymore what exactly happened in which book, but I definitely have a positive feeling about it

    • @ManCarryingThing
      @ManCarryingThing  Před 3 lety +5

      Already I'm starting to mix up certain scenes between books 1 and 2. I think that's a good thing, as they flow together so well

  • @SlowBurnReader
    @SlowBurnReader Před 3 lety +4

    Nynaeve going into the archways was so GOOD! That was my favorite scene as well. So metaphorical and magical at the same time

  • @boxbo7926
    @boxbo7926 Před 3 lety +14

    The clothing as representations of the character’s arcs and feelings only increases throughout the series. It’s a fun thing to pay attention to.

    • @bemusedalligator
      @bemusedalligator Před 3 lety +1

      I don't need any bloody lace! well... a little bit. You gotta have a touch of lace, or it's just not proper clothing.

  • @Sam-jx8tv
    @Sam-jx8tv Před 3 lety +4

    Great Hunt is my favorite of the first 3 books and a top 6 book for me. I just love Rands growth so much. He goes from running from his destiny to facing it so organically. Jordan and Sanderson's character work is so good in this series.

  • @violetfactorial6806
    @violetfactorial6806 Před 3 lety +4

    I'm glad to hear you enjoyed Nynaeve. She's one of my favorite characters in any story and I love the way she uses her anger. It's clearly harmful to her, but at the same time it helps her get through things that she might not be able to otherwise. I think you'll enjoy where she goes in the later books. She's one of the strongest characters in the story.

  • @finncripp1473
    @finncripp1473 Před 3 lety +10

    Right now i am through two hundred pages of Dragon Reborn. And it is so good. Perrin is my favorite character by now. I love Egwene and Nyneave too, but Perrin is just... Perrin.

  • @coffeeandhoots3712
    @coffeeandhoots3712 Před 3 lety +8

    Excellent review. I can't wait to see your opinion of Mat's character for each book now, because you really reflected my initial feelings for him as well.

  • @moneshque
    @moneshque Před 2 lety +2

    I read this book more than 10 years ago but I'll never forget that "flicker flicker flicker"...

  • @ghostpartea892
    @ghostpartea892 Před 3 lety +38

    You didn’t even mention the twist with ingtar at the end. That was such a good twist when I first read it. Sad but so good!

    • @ManCarryingThing
      @ManCarryingThing  Před 3 lety +12

      YES! Poor ingtar

    • @joanacasaca6922
      @joanacasaca6922 Před 3 lety +18

      SPOILER WARNING
      I have only read Until the dragon reborn, so I have no idea if what I'm saying is trash (probably lmao), but I love how that twist establishes the multi faceted aspect of the dark friends. We see ingtar as this noble man, and the reality is that he is. But that honourable quality to him is the reason that made him turn to the darkfriends and that kind of nuance is just beautiful to me. I expect more people like him in the next books but I dunno

    • @Brian_L_A
      @Brian_L_A Před 3 lety +13

      @@joanacasaca6922 Yeah, it ends up Bella the mare is a dark friend too.
      Kidding, of course!

    • @piotrbrys8008
      @piotrbrys8008 Před 3 lety +10

      @@joanacasaca6922 bro to avoid spoilers and confirm your theory :absolutely! Some of the reaaaally important characters from books1-2 are darkfriends and will remain as positive characters for a while, but i won't spoil who it is. Also there are characters"in the light" who are 10x worse than some derkfriends

    • @Wirrn
      @Wirrn Před 3 lety +4

      @@joanacasaca6922 I always appreciate how in a series that's ostensibly the forces of good against an eldritch personification of evil, probably at LEAST half the conflict is with other humans not on the Dark One's side, it's explicit from the start that the forces of light have utterly corrupt arseholes (hello Whitecloak Questioners) and there are dark friends who were either not evil or even actively noble when they joined (though granted, not MANY of them)

  • @ThatPash
    @ThatPash Před 3 lety +27

    Congrats on finishing the second meal, I see you enjoyed it quite much. Advice: don't google any characters, it's danger zone - even the search bar cannot be trusted!

    • @ManCarryingThing
      @ManCarryingThing  Před 3 lety +13

      I have learned my lesson the hard way -- completely agree!

    • @loraz5343
      @loraz5343 Před 3 lety +1

      Yeah..... big, big time. The WOT wiki is merciless. I'm dumb.

    • @simplyaarya7821
      @simplyaarya7821 Před 3 lety

      Tasty advice for tasty books, just like halva;)

  • @alexanderlane
    @alexanderlane Před 2 lety

    Man, I really love your analyses so much. You really manage to make some amazing points and bring out things I was only half aware of, and in only ten minutes. I'm quite a bit ahead of you (just finished book 9) and I can't wait for the rest of your reviews, particularly of some of the middle books where things get so complex. Maybe more than ten minutes for those haha

  • @lucafarrelly648
    @lucafarrelly648 Před 3 lety +9

    I think The Great Hunt and The Eye of the World are definitely of similar quality, but the next two books steadily get better from there

  • @TheMusicalLawyer
    @TheMusicalLawyer Před 3 lety +3

    I love when you said “I was watching it.” For all the WoT’s faults, Jordan is such a good writer that he can bring you into his world. My favorite series! Glad you’re enjoying it. :)

  • @seangriffey8669
    @seangriffey8669 Před 3 lety +23

    Selene is definitely my least favorite part as well, so much so that this is actually my second least favorite wheel of time book. The last 25% of the book is what really save it for me.

    • @Merecir
      @Merecir Před 3 lety +5

      Selene does not really make sense until you realize who she is and what her underlying motivations are.

    • @LagMasterSam
      @LagMasterSam Před 3 lety +13

      @@Merecir Also, Rand trusting her so easily makes more sense in retrospect. I can't really explain why without spoiling anything though.

    • @sofielundsskolan
      @sofielundsskolan Před 3 lety

      @@LagMasterSam this person speaks sense

  • @juanjosegutierrezmerchan2669

    Dear, this book improves the saga by all and believe me when I tell you that you do not expect the big surprises that come in the rest of the books. I'm finishing the last one and I'm a big fan

  • @DRAMATICA1100
    @DRAMATICA1100 Před 3 lety

    I've just subscribed to your channel! I'm eager to see your take on the coming books :) I've been reading (and listening because I love the audio books) WoT since 1991, when I picked up Eye of the World in a grocery store when I was on a lunch break from my part-time job. Welcome to this world. It's pretty great.

  • @afk2514
    @afk2514 Před 3 lety +2

    It keeps getting better and better. Love hearing your thoughts!
    The Wheel turns. . .

  • @Izrezar
    @Izrezar Před 3 lety +19

    wow Nynaeve's your favourite character already? Oh boy she only gets better and better
    also if you haven't made the connection yet, all I'll say is that your Selene take has some merit to it

    • @ManCarryingThing
      @ManCarryingThing  Před 3 lety +1

      ooh interesting

    • @SMClonk
      @SMClonk Před 3 lety +2

      I think she gets much worse in the next books. maybe she will get better later on. there are signs in book 8, that she might, but i am not sure yet

    • @quattroCrazy
      @quattroCrazy Před 3 lety +2

      @@SMClonk I agree, she still kind of sucks half way through the series. It feels like the characters who started out as actual children all matured faster than a woman who held absolute power in their early lives. I can feel empathy for her, but she’s still annoying AF.

    • @Izrezar
      @Izrezar Před 3 lety

      @@SMClonk from Bk 11 onwards she's just perfection in character form

    • @Izrezar
      @Izrezar Před 3 lety +1

      @@quattroCrazy I found her brashness and self-righteousness endearing 😂

  • @girfreyrhallgrimsson4935

    I want to thank you for bringing the Wheel of time to my attention, I began listening to the audiobooks last week and have just finished The Great Hunt. Absolutely fantastic series thus far, and I can't wait to follow your progress in the books to come.

  • @user-zn7ek6uj3h
    @user-zn7ek6uj3h Před 2 lety

    I love your short sitcom type clips, like Ba'alzamon, every 5 seconds. They are extremely hilarious! Keep them coming 🤣

  • @dominuscircensis3645
    @dominuscircensis3645 Před 3 lety +3

    Ingtar sacrificing himself in a moment of regret and the Whitecloakes charging the Seanchan are my favorite moments of The Great Hunt!

  • @nimishrai257
    @nimishrai257 Před 3 lety +8

    What the hell bruv, nooooooo!!! Now I have to catch upto TWO Wheel Of Time Books.

    • @ManCarryingThing
      @ManCarryingThing  Před 3 lety +1

      the pressure is ON

    • @nimishrai257
      @nimishrai257 Před 3 lety

      @@ManCarryingThing I am a violent reader when my animal instincts take over

    • @nimishrai257
      @nimishrai257 Před 2 lety

      @@ManCarryingThing 4 months pass by. And I caught up.

  • @jabbott6748
    @jabbott6748 Před 3 lety +4

    Good review. Wwwaaaaayyyyyy too short though! I would watch 5 more spoiler videos at least 30 min each where you got into a lot more detail. All I can really say is it wasn't enough. More, more, more!

  • @this.is.a.username
    @this.is.a.username Před 3 lety +5

    I'm glad you've been team Nynaeve from day 1, because she has the greatest character progression and the greatest scene in the entire series. And she has so many good scenes that I hope you go "Oh this is the great scene dude mentioned" a few times.. but believe me, when it finally happens, you will know beyond a shadow of a doubt it is THE ONE.
    Just hearing the words tears me up.
    Also, Mat will surprise you.
    TGH had the best twist in the whole series IMO, "Five will ride forth". Best sacrifice ever.

    • @MrSmokinDragon
      @MrSmokinDragon Před 2 lety

      Well, Rand has the greatest Character Progression, but Nynaeve is a very close second.

    • @gebs123
      @gebs123 Před 2 lety

      Spoilers for the end of the final book:
      The "Five will ride forth..." line can apply to the EF5 at the final battle.

  • @hoi-polloi1863
    @hoi-polloi1863 Před 5 měsíci

    Late to the party but hey, nice review! I've always loved Nynaeve the best, ever since book 1. The heroes always leave their sleepy village; it's not often the sleepy village chases them down and tries to drag 'em back home!

  • @simplyaarya7821
    @simplyaarya7821 Před 3 lety +10

    Oh Nononono! How could you do that, without me finishing the second book?:(

  • @TheBardOfTheRedHand
    @TheBardOfTheRedHand Před 3 lety +1

    TGH spoilers:
    My personal favorite Wheel of Time book, and a common top fiver for the fandom at large! I’m glad you enjoyed TGH! This book really feels like Jordan was channeling not only heroic fantasy but the old pulp Swashbucklers. I love his ability to both fully embrace and subversive tropes. He was the master.
    “Uh oh Egwene and Min are captured, it’s up to Rand to save them! Oh nevermimd they escaped on thanks to Nynaeve and caused a bunch of noise and damage”
    The ending of the this book from “Five Will Ride Forth” is my favorite section. I regularly reread the ending. I find it one of the most cinematic endings put to page.

  • @soniaalmeidadias5794
    @soniaalmeidadias5794 Před 2 lety

    Listening to you I realized you are right. Clothing does have an important part in the way characters are portrayed, viewed and developed. After pausing for 3 years, I have now restarted the series where I left it, volume 7. Waiting for your review on the ones I read already :)

  • @cameronf5647
    @cameronf5647 Před 3 lety +10

    Favorite of the first 4 for me. I’m on Fires of Heaven

    • @equdarkmatter-2621
      @equdarkmatter-2621 Před 3 lety +2

      Damn I am on Fires Of Heaven too xD
      Gotta say The Great Hunt is my least favorite of the 5 books (I still love it) because of the Selene plot and Fires of Heaven is my favorite even tho it is the slowest of them just because I love Nynaeve

    • @cameronf5647
      @cameronf5647 Před 3 lety +2

      @@equdarkmatter-2621 yeah I’m like 350 pages in and I agree it is slow but it’s so good and making you realize how many different conflicts there are. There’s Couladin, Caemlyn, Cairhien, The White Tower, Mazrim Taim, etc… I have no idea where it’s gonna go and I love it

    • @katiewright3309
      @katiewright3309 Před 3 lety +1

      I just started Fires of Heaven myself!

    • @totesmagotes213
      @totesmagotes213 Před 2 lety

      Fires of Heaven is fairly slow but I think it has she best third act of any of the books up to that point. Keep up and don’t sweat the circus!

  • @rodrigo3732
    @rodrigo3732 Před 3 lety +6

    I am still in the middle of book 4,but the great Hunt is still my favorite so far.

  • @lorel747
    @lorel747 Před rokem

    Hey man its been a year, im reading the series along with your reviews and it's rsally fun sort of like discussin the book with a friend after finishing it, I hope you continue to make more

  • @rolandbecks4022
    @rolandbecks4022 Před 3 lety +1

    Just finished the complete series, man you've got a long way to go, and i mean...a loooong way. But MAN, what a ride it is! I will follow these video's just to reflect on it some more.

  • @jaimegibbs2751
    @jaimegibbs2751 Před 3 lety +5

    I have not yet, but, i am excited to start this series... 🙂

  • @videoslv4626
    @videoslv4626 Před 3 lety +8

    God I missed your reviews!!

  • @Merecir
    @Merecir Před 3 lety +1

    About Rand taking back the chest.
    From the Fain POV we can figure out that he can not sense Rand when Rand is in the 'flame and void' state.
    So it is not until Rand returns to normal that Fain realize that Rand was there.

  • @Liesmith424
    @Liesmith424 Před 3 lety

    It's so great to see people enjoying this series for the first time. Makes me want to do a re-listen of the audiobooks.

  • @owls9185
    @owls9185 Před 3 lety

    I literally share exactly the same opinions on everything you just said. Your channel is really starting to grow on me and I cannot wait to discover the rest of WOT alongside everyone here

    • @owls9185
      @owls9185 Před 3 lety +1

      AlsoI havent seen anyone talk about Egwenes experience being a 'mage-dog' and her snapping once shes freed. It was one of my favorite part of the book seeing what a toll it had on her and then having Nynaeve be the one to help her process her anger in a more just way and therafter being merciful herself, what a fantastic moment man I loved it so much...

  • @ladelteravada
    @ladelteravada Před 3 lety +5

    What's your take on the level of horror? I think Goblin discussed it a bit ago on how WoT is much darker than you might realise just reading it.. see the slavery aspects of the damane, the fade nailed to the wall, the prisonroom, feeding dark friends to trollocs etc. Looking forward to see how dark the visual series get

  • @erikburen6066
    @erikburen6066 Před 2 lety

    I am currently on book 11 after starting the Eye of the World over 5 years ago. Hearing you talk about TGH, I realise how much I've forgotten about what happened. Seems like I'm going to have to start the series again as soon as I finish...

  • @billmilligan7272
    @billmilligan7272 Před 2 lety

    Ingtar's end is what hooked me on this series, a couple decades ago. Took me completely by surprise, and made me trust RJ's vision.

  • @makaki6900
    @makaki6900 Před 3 lety +2

    Aaaa
    I didn’t remember the scene with mat saying I will not betray you
    It’s time for a reread

  • @CheyenneSedai
    @CheyenneSedai Před 3 lety +8

    Cairhien is hard for a lot of people pronunciation wise. you're close. the proper way of saying it is in the glossary

  • @jaysheth1541
    @jaysheth1541 Před 3 lety +4

    I was waiting for it for so long.... It is a very special Book in the series.

  • @jaysheth1541
    @jaysheth1541 Před 3 lety +2

    My favourite chapter is Blademaster... Rand fights with Seanchan Blademaster and How Ingtar redeems himself. Seanchan were way more terrifying than all the Fain and Darkfriends combined... Ha ha! Fain nailing that Fade on the wall was horror of another level. I don't remember but do we see an Aiel for the first time in this Book...
    I loved the pacing of this Book.... What a ride!
    For many many books now ... You will miss this Pacing 😉
    I request you to not give up during Books 8, 9, and 10. By the end of Book 11 you will feel rewarded and grateful for your patience with the series.
    All the best!
    I am on Book 11 right now and it is awesome! 🌼💖

    • @michael305m3
      @michael305m3 Před 3 lety +1

      Please don’t contribute to the “slog” fear, if people go into those books expecting a slog they are more likely to find one. The slog didn’t exist for me, don’t give someone low expectations for a book before they read it

    • @jaysheth1541
      @jaysheth1541 Před 3 lety

      @@michael305m3 Sure .. am sorry
      I did enjoy those books and was going to mention why people saw it as slog when in fact they are deeply engrossing.
      The thing that worked for me was that I was not rushing through those books. I took my time with that. Allowing myself to think on Egwene story line involving so many subtle threads of psychology and politics mixing. I just loved Books 8 to 10. But am just wanting the new reader be prepared to take it slow to really enjoy the journey of reading.
      Am really sorry about coming across like that. I am sorry.

    • @jaysheth1541
      @jaysheth1541 Před 3 lety

      Sure .. am sorry
      I did enjoy those books and was going to mention why people saw it as slog when in fact they are deeply engrossing.
      The thing that worked for me was that I was not rushing through those books. I took my time with that. Allowing myself to think on Egwene story line involving so many subtle threads of psychology and politics mixing. I just loved Books 8 to 10. But am just wanting the new reader be prepared to take it slow to really enjoy the journey of reading.
      Am really sorry about coming across like that. I am sorry.

    • @michael305m3
      @michael305m3 Před 3 lety +1

      @@jaysheth1541 no need to apologize lol, I agree with u on how they should be enjoyed slowly and how it allows u to enjoy them more

  • @destro6971
    @destro6971 Před 3 lety +1

    Nynaeve is a character that change d a lot for me from the first time to the reread. 1st read was late teens/early 20s and I hated her a lot. 15 years, 2 kids, and all that living made me appreciate her so much more. 🤣

  • @hardstroker947
    @hardstroker947 Před 3 lety +1

    My favourite book in the series. Nothing beat me jamming to music at 2am as Rand and the Heroes of the Horn storm Falme. It was also the first time i read over 200 pages in one sitting (from Cairhien to Falme). Fuckin fantastic book, even if some of the elements aren’t touched upon again.

  • @reaganorton1710
    @reaganorton1710 Před 3 lety +1

    I loved this book!! Probably my favorite of the series. The characters are so well done and I enjoy the story.

  • @johnalexander2039
    @johnalexander2039 Před 3 lety

    Ahh!! I am so excited for you to read the next books!

  • @AFriendRemembers
    @AFriendRemembers Před 3 lety +5

    Glad you enjoyed the politics- will be interesting to see if that stance changes as we go deeper and deeper.
    But it is a good book

    • @ManCarryingThing
      @ManCarryingThing  Před 3 lety +4

      I hear it becomes less adventure-fantasy and more political-fantasy as it goes along

    • @BlueSun_
      @BlueSun_ Před 3 lety +1

      @@ManCarryingThing
      It ebbs and flows between the two (and other sub-genres) as you go between different sections and POVs

  • @trinketspirit
    @trinketspirit Před 3 lety

    i just finished the great hunt today and it was such a great read. i was so excited to see all the characters progressing and am definitely interested in where mat’s character is going, i feel as if him being the one to sound the horn means something. so i guess it’s on to the dragon reborn!

  • @feanaro2712
    @feanaro2712 Před 3 lety

    I really appreciate that Nynaeve is your favourite character. I’m interested to see what you think of her development over the rest of the series.

  • @benb.8170
    @benb.8170 Před 2 lety

    This book... I was really pretty low on Eye of the World, but when Jordan opened things up with The Great Hunt, flexed his metaphysical time bending skills, employed a crazy expansion of his story, the characters... you got it right, Man. This one leaves you wanting more (as does basically every other book in the series). In spite of their flaws, the journey is always a lot of fun.

  • @notjazz.
    @notjazz. Před 3 lety

    Definitely subbed🤣 can’t wait for the rest of your reviews because it really does just get better and better. 4&5 is goated but so is 12&14. But 6,7,8 is also so good🤣 great hunt definitely up there too tho

  • @Red_Belly
    @Red_Belly Před 3 lety +4

    love your reviews, man!

  • @cynthiaholmes5124
    @cynthiaholmes5124 Před 3 lety +2

    I really enjoyed the great hunt 👍🤠🙂😃

  • @bcfortenberry
    @bcfortenberry Před 3 lety

    Love the book and I enjoyed your review. Nynaeve rules consistently and Mat improves post-dagger.

  • @angelamengualcortinas3614

    Currently on book 10 and I must say that The Great Hunt for now is the second best Wheel of Time book I've read. I think its greatest acomplishment is that it solidifies the tone of the story for the rest of the series. It feels less whimsical and a bit darker than The Eye of the World and the rest of the series kind of goes that path.

  • @MrJohnp93
    @MrJohnp93 Před 3 lety +1

    My head Canon is that Selene used just a little bit of compulsion on rand

  • @marinhobrandao
    @marinhobrandao Před 2 lety +1

    I've just finished The Great Hunt as well.
    Moiraine has been my favourite character by far, but indeed, in the second book, she is no longer that high above, and she is even not so present, while Rand and Egwene fake the center and mature progressively.
    I've been a bit frustrated with Mat, as I expected him to be more important and play a stronger role. I hope he and Perry will take more attention in the next sequels.

  • @ep41312
    @ep41312 Před 3 lety

    First time reader here too (halfway thru book 4 rn), and I completely agree/felt the same exact way about the Horn. Glad I am not alone lol

  • @quinnzender
    @quinnzender Před 2 lety

    I like your thoughts on Fain.. I think you're going to enjoy his arc in the last book ;)

  • @antekpatyk9425
    @antekpatyk9425 Před 3 lety +1

    TGH is so far easily my favourite book of the series. I really liked where the stories went especially Rand, along with a lot of great things with others, even with people who don't get a lot of screen time like Fain (who's like my 4th or 5th favourite character in the series so far, on book 5). Really, the only complaint I had with it is that it rose my standards for the series that so far it hasn't been able to reach again.
    9/10

  • @thejellydonut7587
    @thejellydonut7587 Před 3 lety

    I'd kinda forgotten about this period of Mat's character. He's gotta have one of the most interesting full series arcs of any character in the series.

  • @phnome123
    @phnome123 Před 3 lety

    Mat grows around book 4. You'll going to love his POV.

  • @djhokasha7410
    @djhokasha7410 Před 3 lety +12

    This was a very good review. Advice for book 3: Be prepared to have a heart attack.

  • @favrewanab
    @favrewanab Před 3 lety

    Oh by the way: that fireworks scene you said was unnecessary. Don't forget about it.
    Jordan had a thing for putting seemingly little unimportant scenes in his earlier books and then bringing elements from them back later.
    I would constantly look back into earlier books. I would read a scene and be like.......... wait?!? Isn't that so and so or didn't we see that in book so and so?!?! And I would go back and search through the books and read where the current scene was foreshadowed and would just sit there amazed.

  • @morinked4078
    @morinked4078 Před 3 lety

    "trying to avoid...people" - LOVE IT

  • @kylegrefe4399
    @kylegrefe4399 Před 3 lety

    So I've been rereading WoT, and I must say, I appreciate Verin so much more the second go around. Only on The Dragon Reborn in the reread right now btw.

  • @Tonys77Home
    @Tonys77Home Před 2 lety

    Waiting for you to finish book 3. That's the point where i was hooked. On my 5the reread

  • @ilikecomicstoareallyproble8617

    I remember when I read the part where Mat blows the Horn of Valere made me bust out laughing because it was so insanely random and completely in character for him.

  • @pterozactyll
    @pterozactyll Před 3 lety

    I just finished the series a few weeks ago and watching you go through them with it fresh in my mind is a treat! Dovie'andi se tovya sagain ;)