【字幕】新加坡前外交部長楊榮文：失去美國支持 香港還有沒有希望？ 新加坡已不把香港放在眼內？ 習近平怎樣救了中國？ 《大師訪談錄》（2024-03-01）
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 02. 2024
- 亞洲金融中心第一的位置屬於香港還是新加坡，幾十年來爭論不斷。而近兩年討論格外激烈，稱港與星的競爭已見分曉？港經濟表現不佳與國家安全法有關？新加坡人是如何看待競爭的呢？
習近平上任後為何追究周永康、薄熙來、令計劃？在這個人情、關係根深蒂固的社會，他如何應對腐敗？讓我們一起聽聽新加坡前外交部部長楊榮文的分析。
#楊榮文 #灼見名家 #習近平 #新加坡 #香港 #腐敗 #亞洲金融中心 #國安法 #中國
🌟歡迎訂閱本頻道，觀看更多楊榮文系列CZcams影片：
第一集： • 【字幕】新加坡前外交部長楊榮文：以巴熱戰之後...
第二集（本集）： • 【字幕】新加坡前外交部長楊榮文：失去美國支持...
第三集： • 【字幕】新加坡前外交部長楊榮文：未來5年中國...
第四集： • 【字幕】新加坡前外交部長楊榮文：六四事件後新...
第五集： • 【字幕】新加坡前外交部長楊榮文：中華文明為何...
第六集： • 【字幕】新加坡前外交部長楊榮文：中國怎樣處理...
全集： • 【字幕】新加坡前外交部長楊榮文縱論天下：中美...
加入成為會員，優先看新影片和獲取獎賞：
/ @masterinsightmedia
追蹤Facebook、Instagram專頁，攝取名家智慧：
/ masterinsightcom
/ master_insight_media
訂閱WhatsApp頻道，一手掌握重點分析：
tinyurl.com/22jkxcm4
習主席是偉大的领导人吗？事实胜于雄辩。歷史自有公平答案！今天中国由一窮二白变成世界领导强国，人民温度飽有書读，無論科技軍事都在世界佔一席位，共产党怎能说没有功勞？国家由零开始几十个年頭有此成绩，简直是人类歷史罕见成就。今日身為中国人应该感到驕傲。美国及其盟友现在合力打压香港，少不免要渡过一段艱難时期，但香港本身産业过于單一，是时候要发奋图强，跟星加坡之爭根本不值一提，应该各自發展自己優势，做大做强，第一第二只是庸人自扰，有飯食才是根本之道
你也說得對，等待歷史評價習近平，毫無疑問鄧小平改革開放是一個偉人，江澤民至胡錦濤，也有很偉大的貢獻。至於本屆期待著。😅
確實係明智之言。
喺香港（同新加坡）有好多人喺殖民統治下長大或喺西方接受教育，佢哋對中囯共產黨反感，儘管有大量證據表明中國在過去50年中喺各個方面都取得了非凡嘅進步。 中囯共產黨並不完美，冇一個執政黨/政府係或曾經係。 但是，就為14亿人民帶來實實在在嘅成果而言，冇戰爭，冇殖民其他國家，冇竊取其他國家嘅資源，冇經濟剝削，我相信喺人類現代歷史上從未有過噉嘅例子。
只剩下5 千年 long long 的根。
是的，客观比较务实的评论。港公务人员太有小聪明服役英殖民政府，也善于与各大家族隐隐约约混日子，如今望北看风向。Georgie boy 和 Kishore只能在外头炫，老早就不在新加坡领导核心。但，嘴够溜达还是有人当他们是嘉宾。😁
@@clementihammock7572 說實話香港官員包括你平民在內沒有一個比 Brigadier-general Yeo 的頭腦聰明，他是外交部長見過各國的領導人比你對世界政局懂的多的多，別人是看門道你只是看熱鬧差太遠了吧。
我是新加坡人，我們與本國人民接觸時，從來沒有去討論與香港競爭的。更多的是，新加坡小島國，如此脆弱，如何在世界潮流，大國夾縫中求生存。所以我們更憂慮的是如何提昇自己，能夠很好的生存，從來沒想過和誰去競爭。也許是因為種種現像，導致大家認為新加坡和香港在競爭吧。
Ouett⁰wopeo
是香港人自己覺得吧，是一種不自信之表現😄
香港人是小心眼和没自信的一群人。
他们很多人都认为自己是伪英国人不是中国人，他们已习惯由中国得好处，以前中国管不到他们，而现在情况不同了，所以他们觉得很不安。
新加坡是一个主权国，自己决定自己的命运，与香港完全不一样。
香港人与台湾人的心态是一样的。想由中国得到所有的好处，可是又想当个独立国，自由的与他国摸肩擦背。
不用太擔心比較，新加坡是個國家而香港是個城市有所不同。星港互補各有優勢，合作工贏是正道！祝願世界和平🙏
所以李光耀才会去美国求奥巴马总统重返亚太 掐死中国同时好给新加坡一个机会
楊榮文先生好一句：「I think he saved China」。楊先生的回應非常客觀公正，且是事實，不偏不倚。楊先生與習主席都值得我們尊敬….
台独份子，西方国家领袖，非常讨厌习主席，因为他使中国强大。
WOW
我认为本质不是为了反腐，或者主要目的不是为反腐，而是以反腐的名义来清除对立政治派系。
@@ManjuTiger 你的回答还是植入了自己的成见：反腐是为了清除对立政治派系。
@@ManjuTiger 因为蛙岛就是这么干的，所以认为其他地方也是一样
BG George Yeo is right. I am Singaporean and we don’t really care about how well or badly HK is doing. We don’t even talk about HK amongst ourselves. We only care about our own well being， which is a handful already. Most of the CZcams videos that compare HK and Singapore are made by HK or pro independence Taiwanese CZcamsrs. That says a lot. I also agree with him that Xi saved China.
Xi Jinping do not have any china rivals alive today 2024 to take over the china throne. smart.
Hong Kong was set-up to fail from the GET-GO of the British hand-over back to China in 1997. No past colonial masters would their evil salt will pass the opportunity to plant "Poison Pills" in their former colonies as a sort of COLD REVENGE for having them kick-off from their pedestal of power. Hong Kong was no exception, as did Singapore/Malaysia, India/Pakistan, Israel/Palestine, etc. Now that the former British Empire has been reduced to mere “Wanabes”, and had since been replaced by an even more dangerous warmongering tribe, aka Americans, who deemed that nothing is ever too low for consideration in its singular pursue of global hegemony.
@@meganfoxbf He has plenty outside of China. I can name Biden, Trump and a few others who are not on the same level.
xi jinping is smart , he do not any rivals in China alive today 2024.
@@stayprepared2388America is even smarter; they get close allies to kill their enemies.
George Yeo knows China. 老許常常講：無論你點評價習主席，他的打貪掃貧絕對青史留名，功在國在民！💪
但新加坡 台湾都公开公务员财产 人家
確认台湾真的是… 有吗?
But George Yeo he not really know about China 🤷🏼♂️
😅@@weinixiong999
@@weinixiong999 別把台灣和新加坡的廉潔誠信相提並論，台灣的總統的1.5個博士論文是見光死的見不得人的，這種事在新加坡早就被滾下台了。
@@weinixiong999 民X黨幾時變得這麽廉潔？菜出訪時空軍一號走私香菸被稱爲超買。
杨先生的确对中国进行了非常深入的研究，且受华人文化影响，更理解中国的发展理念。不得不说，习在任这些年，中国的官场和到极大改善，尤其是地方政府。如果在15年前，你去地方政府办理某些事，经常会折腾一天时间，时间都花在了跑来跑去（部门之间），且服务态度都非常差。而现在，哪怕是房产这样重大的事情，都可以在1栋大楼内1小时左右办理完成，且服务态度非常友好。这是百姓最直观的感受。看到外网经常说习的反腐只是打压其他的势力，但看到去年两位关键部门部长（习亲自提拔）先后被免职，我想如果还说这是派系斗争。。。难道是习自己与自己做斗争吗？
可是，为什么他自己提拨的人也变成了腐败分子，改腐败改了个寂寞，这本身不就是个大笑话
@@kkk-ih8xf 你知道养的儿子就一定是好人吗？
@@kkk-ih8xf 忠奸难辨，很难懂吗
@@kkk-ih8xf 这两个人根本不是因为腐败被免职的好不好
只有强权+明君，才可能在中国这种集权体制造就一个盛世。
如果有其他派系，重大改革也是无法完成的，会造成内斗。
纵观中国历史朝代，每个朝代末期，都是派系林立，这时候哪怕君主励精图治，也无力回天。
所以一个明君，一定要是具有非常手段，还要具有崇高的理想，同时还要能在浑水中爬到高位。
这实在是太难了。所以历史上力挽狂澜的领袖少之又少。
看提問的香港人，和回答的嘉賓，看出香港人是醒目但十分短視，這也是香港現在困境之基本原因。
或者直白一點，香港人最大的目標，儘快搵足夠錢，移民英美，再返香港搵錢，退休英美做2等公民。誰都不想在這裡老老實實干實事，越聰明的越不會。
所有中國首富都係！問題係做中國人冇保障
@@cd7707a佢講嘅就係你啲咁嘅人，聰明不過自私！
一國兩制前趕緊賺錢，一國兩制這個窗口期。
@@peggychu2365打幾個字，你就知道我聰明，又知我自私？ 其實我想表達嘅就係講人係要小心unconscious bias。問一個問題講一句說話就認定咗人哋係某一類人真係咁簡單。我好好奇其實你話我自作聰明及自私係咪好有快感啊？有冇高潮？
典型的沒有民族自信，崇洋媚外信奉白人優越
不同意他說賄賂是中國人的文化。賄賂是人類的文化。西方新聞時不時都有他們政府賄賂新聞。Donald Trump and Joe Biden 就是例子。不過他們懂得如果逃避法律責任。
美西方尤其美國, 識得去包裝, 稱為國會遊說團體。勁!
打正招牌, 有法律保護貪腐添。
佢哋將佢合法化！政治獻金根本就是賄賂，但合法化，就唔係貪污！
加國合法大麻，就冇販毒和吸毒問題！
說得好，鴉片戰爭的前後，英國以免費鴉片賄賂中國官員以方便英國商人向中國民間販賣鴉片暢通無阻，英商亦以金錢賄賂英國官員議員，英政府以軍艦和槍炮做英商的後盾，此係近代西洋貿易史上的最經典之作。
作為一名海外華人，完全同意杨荣文准将的观点，習近平是一位將會名留青史的中國領導人。果敢得剔骨療傷，成就了中華民族偉大復興的中坚力量。👍
作为海外华人，我的看法和你一致。继续加速
我曾经就坐在杨荣文隔壁桌吃饭，不管你是贫或富他都会很客气的与你配合拍照片做纪念。很友善。
名留青史还得加一条：祖国统一
@@ssdon2000 兩岸兩國各自安好各自幸福。台灣人的92共識就是民調92%維持現狀與獨立自主。什麼統一都是惶上的春藥，居民該操的心是孩子的未來。
@@ssdon2000 祖国统一还算啦，最关键的是在经济领域把中国带到世界第一。当然，主要是时间不够，不然可以在军事和科技领域，把中国带到世界第一。
然后，台湾统一算个屁大的事。
香港應該改革去殖民化，高官或問責官員及所有公務員退休後移居外國的一律取消長俸，別浪費納稅人的錢。
百份百認同你的講法！
香港因为使用美西方定义的新闻自由标准，所以被美国操控的主流资信媒体天天洗脑奴役意识形态，你试想日军侵略屠杀大陆人，如果中国人现在很向往崇拜日本会是无法想象的，但台湾做到了对日本崇拜，香港黄撕也做到了对英国向往。该猥！！！
是的，香港去殖民化后，真正脱离英式的政治、经济、法治、人权、教育、医疗等制度，也必然快速变成大陆化，回归中国母亲的怀抱，融入大湾区，脱离国际地位，变成一个不折不扣的大陆城市。可以预知未来的香港，跟新加坡已经没有共同的优势可以互相比拼，香港只能跟相似度相近的大湾区城市相比， 失去国际优势的香港未必可以超越大湾区的城市呢！😅
@@sapphoophoon2141 “人比人、比死人”自已做好自已，為何硬要與別人比，什麼大陸化，有何不妥，為何大陸超越我們，正正就是香港人不肯跳出自已的圈，總覺自已比大陸優勝，誰不知香港這隻自以為是的兔仔早已經輸掉了！現在看清楚那些西方所謂民主大國，已經去到山窮水盡，黔驢之技，只剩下『抹黑』一招，真的到了黔驢技窮囉！。
不同的时代不同的角色@@sapphoophoon2141
George Yeo is right. Singaporeans don’t think of competing with HK because it always focus on how it can better itself to survive amongst all the big countries around it. HK is lucky to have China backing it. It is sad that the young generation in HK does not see it that way..
Yes indeed, the Young Hong Kongers are fortunate, China will never allow it to fail. Unlike Singapore, we don't have a " God Father " we are surrounded by Muslim Countries with different Religious Beliefs. We must learn to live in harmony with our Big Neighbors otherwise Singapore will be swallowed up. Do you think the Western World will come in to support Singapore ? I doubt so....Singapore must survive on its own , we can't afford to take sides !!!
Jonathan Pak/ Singapore
@@user-dy5fh5du6o Exactly! Fortunately, Singapore is blessed with a great founding father who leads it to where it is now and continues to stay focus in what it does best. czcams.com/video/VexrmTacOAA/video.html. Speech by Mr Lee Kuan Yew which hopefully, youths in HK and Taiwan could understand czcams.com/video/VexrmTacOAA/video.html
事实上大部分香港年轻人对于新加坡都没有什么概念。
@@user-dy5fh5du6o 也许正是因为香港背后有中国，才不够珍惜，而新加坡时刻处在居安思危的情境中，才会客观地审视自身并不断进步，可以说新加坡侨胞在中华文明的现代化改革有很重要的贡献。
杨先生说的很符合实际，新加坡整个领导层认知度都与世界潮流及实际情况相符，因而制定符合新加坡长远发展的国策并得到坚持与贯彻，所以新加坡虽国小却行稳致远，而且国力及影响力得到保持甚至积极向上，功不可没。习近平上任的时候，当时我们认知是，不查腐败亡国亡党，严查腐败亡党。目前看来，有严查腐败，但是习近平的决策团队已经有相当的稳定度，所以腐败指数已经相对以前低很多，但是国家大又一党执政，国民又是从一个贫弱国家向历史复兴的快速爬升过程中，腐败无法根治是肯定的。但是目前这个国家是有希望的。
Actually people in Singapore doesn't talk much about other country. Maybe they talk more about going to J.B. for food and shopping.
,,,. and where to for next holiday destination ..
Hahaha
Cheap cheap cheap...like a chirping bird
Probably also talk about the funny stuff happening in Malaysia like halal bakuteh issue and banning 1975 concert.
同意扬荣文的说法。习近平突显中国今天的地位，现有的中国GDP已经超越多个大国，东升西降指日可待。伟大的中国加油！
President Xi is really caring for the population,taking care of the overall wellbeing, livelihoods n lives. The Chinese people are really enjoying good karma this life. You people must have done something very great/kind/good in your past lives. Enjoy n support n work with your hardworking leadership team who really care for the people💪👍👏 😍❤️🙏🙏🙏
Serene, 无需引用“伟大”类似词语。 中国加油，不是更好吗？
@@KevanMajere33为什么不可以引用 伟大？自己觉得自己的祖国伟大有问题？
the problem people are not hapoy with Xi is he tries to solve all problems at the same time and he is power hungary while economy is in decline.
Singaporean here. When we discuss HK, we discuss where are the best places to eat and shop for holidays. Economic competition is the last thing on our minds.
可能是香港媒体和某些博主比较热衷拿香港和新加坡做对比；新加坡媒体和官方，人民几乎不提超越香港；这新加坡没有把香港当初假想敌的气氛。当然，某些重叠性较高的领域面对竞争在所难免，但新加坡的出发点不是想打跨香港，强夺其拥有的。新加坡只想做对的事，正确的决定。
早报时不时刊登此类文章。当然，纯🇸🇬本土人绝大部分是不怎么懂中文的，所以早报的读者一般是new residents、🇨🇳人，和🇲🇾人。
Riz又是你？又是你国的拦叫会飞
香港的富是背靠祖國把香港作為一個對外窗口而賜給予香港的特殊窗口機會而富起來，當然也是香港人雙手勤勞努力打拚來的富，絕不是美英賜的，前特首鄭月娥說過美國以前從香港每年获利 3000億，美在香港是最大利益者，其次是英國。
美国是如何获利的？
@@liveinkaruna : 貿易順差
如果你不是明知故问，那告诉你，就是通过美元霸权和人才掠夺让美保持了贸易顺差，比如美国生产廉价衬衫可以，但生产收集、智能汽车不行，你以为美国怎么维持它所谓的高端生活@@liveinkaruna
就像台湾一样，每年从大陆赚取1000亿美金顺差，从美国专区几百亿美金逆差，它还以为美国是它爹
@@liveinkaruna 不谈经济之前也是亚洲谍报之都，就这一点五眼联盟不会轻易让香港好过
杨荣文是很有智慧和洞察力的人才！
李光耀时期的官员杨荣文、马凯硕等很多有很高的政治素养，公正的原则，很高的眼界，客观的世界观，又接地气。👍
HK is not in trouble. It’s growing slower than few years ago is the result of global slow down & our high expectations of post COVID recovery.
If we compare with other countries HK is in good shape.
BTY . Good interview & well said Mr Yeo
HK is in good shape. It is just HKers are not happy that they are no longer the best in Asia.
My Hong Kong friend told me Hong Kongers or Chinese have what it takes to overcome all odds. Hong Kong was great not because of the British, but the locals themselves. They make things happen….this is also what I observed. Just organize a FO party to people like Jimmy Lai, Agnes Chow etc and make it a grand FO and move on.
Trust me, HK and Taiwan have way way way more potential for great growth than Singapore.
I fully agree with what George Yeo had said. Singaporean rarely compare with HK'er on economic conditions. I was a Singaporean since 1992. When I moved to Singapore in 1990 , HK at that time is better than Singapore in all economic aspects. My reason of moving to Singapore is all because there is no racial discrimination against Chinese in Singapore. Openly I never say it . I just said Singapore has better life style. Later on when Singapore starts to overtake HK in economic terms I still wish HK the best. This is not a zero sum game.
Singapore wants to be top class which I don’t see anything wrong, while Singapore always seeks for win-win not comparing to win competitions unlike hkers, they always compare hk to sg that’s pointless.
大家好 ! 當今太多熱愛和平黨國的同胞們(包括千人計劃中和全球人類命運共同體等)已經放棄咗邪恶國外工作讀書同其居留權等。開始疯狂哋回歸強大的祖國參加參與其發展而發達又成名咗唄 ！😷 🎉
美國絕不會希望中國好，這是無容置疑的，任何對此有異議的，那就是不喜歡中國好的，這很明顯。
美對香港是關心自己國家利益 千萬不要想成是支持 有利益你趕他們都不會走 沒有利益離開是時間問題
No No No we are a himble nation and will nvr look down on other country🎉❤we will extend help anytime.
Hong Kong have China in the backyard. HK will never be (you don't do better under UK either) sovereign nation and is part of Greater China. You have all the security and future within a greater part of China. So is Taiwan. You don't need UK and USA/ West as they are declining and it's Asian Century.
Singapore does not compete with Hong Kong per se, we are striving and competing within the global economy. Why only Hong Kong ? I hope Hong Kong people stop using Singapore as an excuse and start thinking of other aspect of improving and growing economy. Don't just use financial , wealth management and property sector to drive growth and development. Your Per Capital GDP is well behind Singapore. Why ?
Compare it in this way. Look at what Singapore offers as it competitive edge and see if HK government can do. See what Singapore has done beyond your own development.
In addition to Financial and wealth management, Singapore GDP has a high and well diversified tech manufacturing sector in Petrol chemical, Precision engineering, Semi Conductor design and manufacturing, Biomedical, Biomedicine and pharmaceutical, transportation as in Air and sea logistics hub, aeronautical engineering, IT Smart nation initiative , Artificial intelligence and constant Research and development,. Singapore invest heavily in high technology and education and see innovation to improve productivity with a limited land mass and population.
The most important thing is to stop comparing and start working on HK economic growth and development.
I always like Hong Kong, and like a peaceful and prosperous Hong Kong 🇭🇰 ❤
Selective prosecution on corruption due to rule of man. Inherently deep rooted in Chinese culture 升官发财。As he said Singapore is blue then this isn't practised in Singapore. Had Singapore continued its education policy based on the Chinese or Taiwanese model then corruption in Singapore would be as rampant as CCP ruled area. Taiwan to a certain extent has low level of corruption due to its independent law enforcement & judiciary.
Always refreshing to hear Mr. Yeo speak. The gem of Singapore.
Great that WP released him from PAP and his wisdom can be shared with singapore and the rest of the world.
Indeed, Singapore Government and Singaporean by enlarged don't have such kind of mentality of looking down or stepping on others to rise. Singapore mentality is to improve ourselves and everything just falls in place. In other words, we compete with ourselves not with others. That's way there is hardly and anyone from Singapore talks about Hong Kong or Taiwan or other countries not doing well. It's just like studying in school, one can only get good results by studying your own. You cannot get good results by hoping that the others get lousy results.
Or rather we wish, but others never got lousy result. Easy things never happened. So the only way to study and get good result.
HK has a negative mindset! Stop worrying about others' achievements, instead have your own goals. Be inspired not threatened by others. Celebrate and utilize our similarities to our advantage. Don't be divisive nor focus on differences and negativity. Singapore leaders have the same positive growth mindset like that of China as well!!
Similar to China
香港特區不是一個國家，沒必要跟獨立的星國比較。畢竟香港永遠不可能獨立也不能有自己的軍隊和聯合國會員。所以香港特區還是和澳門特區比GDP就好了。i❤XiangGang！
香港经历了19年黑暴，还有一大堆黄丝和黄官员，还觉得这是中共把他们害的，真是绝了
还有台湾省
The questions posted by the audiences were quite hostile. That lady questioned Mr Yeo and wanted him to explain (on behalf of Singapore government) does Singapore wants to overtake HK; and when Mr Yeo praised XJP the host (and some audiences) seemed uneasy and must bring in Communist Party of China (CPC) to frame the whole thing as dictatorship. I see no hope in HK.
Compare and contrast Singapore vs HK 20 years ago may be a meaningful exercise. But looking at the GPD composition now, the two places are so different, it's not even relevant.
There is this saying... Winners focus on winning, losers focus on winners. The fact we start seeing a rise of comparisons between Hong Kong and Singapore by Hong Kong base media outlets goes to show the increased insecurity of Hong Kongers.
Singapore have always model itself after Switzerland, the desire to be an oasis in a desert. Something that had been achieved.
Taiwanese media outlets frequently use Singapore as an example to criticise their ruling party's ineffectiveness or to blame the ruling party in China for political blockade.
Hong Kong media outlets use Singapore as a tool to highlight about the things that Hong Kong is still better than Singapore.
South Korea is so far ahead that they don't even bother comparing. They're probably only pitting themselves against the former number 2 economy of the world which is Japan.
Singapore is comfortable enough to be an oasis in a desert.
Hong Kong hardly crosses the mind of Singaporeans, except for a food holiday. We really do not think or talk about competition with Hong Kong as an economy or with their people.
But strangely sometimes we encounter Hongkong colleagues who behave like we are in competition and get all sensitive and political… it doesn’t even cross our mind. We are happily doing our own thing and see no reason to compete with them.
名題應是：美國失去了十四億中國人民伙伴支持究竟還會有昔日嘅美國嗎？
what a shame to hear question on whether Singapore is competing with Hong Kong. do your job properly, think about synergy and win win rather than always treat others as enermies and rival.
我非常尊重的前外交部长👍👍👍❤
西方帝国对香港人的殖民教育非常深的引向，连自己民族认同也淡化了。这次真正回归祖国怀抱，十年后再看香港， 我相信一个有祖国作靠山的香港，一定是灿烂辉煌。
😂
控制殖民地就需要，分化解构文明共识，国族认知混乱，民族意识淡薄，去雄性化改造。。。。日韩，台岛都是这些问题……
好阿Q呀...竟如此天真無邪.
@@jueic 那你们继续保持你们所谓的优越感吧，反正现在大陆人也不鸟你们了，你们爱咋样想就咋样想。不过香港是中国的领土，中国也不允许你们搞乱它。至于这片土地上的人嘛想好好生活就早点融入，别还是认为现在还是香港带着中国在走，你香港现在资本、人才、工业、科技、文化哪一样有优势，只不过是提前吃了时代的红利以前做为一个窗口而已。现在一个已经是全球第二大经济体的国家还需要你们来指点？早点收回你们那无知的优越感，别跟我说你们有民主自由啥的，现在这些词已经臭了，你们还在像宗教一样膜拜那是你们的事，你们自己开心就好。不想融入还是早点去西方混吧，想走随你们。中国的人还要一心一意谋发展，没空离你们在这边叽叽喳喳的，赶不上时代是你们自己能力不行，别找什么借口
If you look at youtube videos alone, those that always use Sg as a comparison are made by ppl from Taiwan, Hongkong and China. Hardly anyone from Sg. Sgreans care about their own bread and butter issues and internal affairs. No time to spend time comparing. Not productive at all.
Singaporeans are just political apathetic. Anything unhappy, just complain to government. Rather than making videos, complain to MP more efficient.
U are so very right!! Hope others will realise it. Sg mind its own affairs
標題有誤導。究竟美國甚麽時候支持過香港？請問如何失去一些從未擁有過的支持？😮
這一貫洗腦手法，其心惡毒。
美國確有支持過香港….搞顏色革命同分裂國家😢
之前一直都有为建设东方间谍之都添砖加瓦啊
有啊，当年的香港是亚洲间谍中心🤣🤣🤣现在是不是就不知道了
香港曾经是间谍之都，美国投入很大🤣
新加坡人少去谈论别人比如香港，台湾，马来西亚等....偏偏他们整天吵着跟新加坡急。整天躲办公室里去想新加坡在背后做什么...在网络上视频，不停硬拉新加坡做比较. 反而新加坡网络新闻一直安安静静的，做天气预报。
非常同意
但香港伤了大国大陆民众的心。我5年内不会考虑去香港旅行，我不想去那里因为说国语而被人翻白眼，受到“特殊关照”。我宁愿去澳门，新加坡和马亚西亚。
当地民风就是那样的，非常粗鲁，连白人到那里也是如此评价的，🇲🇴还可以。🇸🇬风气实际而已跟🇭🇰差不多可能略好点，只不过是一个全社会改用英语的🇭🇰。
Riz拦叫你卡，还到处抹SG
主持和发问都阴阳怪气的，只有杨先生对答够直爽！
HKG actually heavily relies on Beijing's strong support. Too bad so many people don't realize it.
4.5 BG has nailed it! Sg people just are too concerned with own matters. Outsiders shd not overthink
Well Said...👏👏👏👏👏
The HK people just don't know the history of Singapore. Before 1959, everything the British owned in Asia, they sent to Singapore. The question is why not HK? They know that they are only leasing HK and must return HK by 1997. Did you know, the HQ FARELF (HQ Far East Land Forces, the British Admiralty/Naval Base, and the RAF bases are all in Singapore. There was the RAF Tengah, RAF Sembawang, RAF Seletar, RAF Changi all in Singapore. There was also the the BMH (British Military Hospitals(2) at Alexandra Road and the Sembawang Naval Dockyard. In fact Singapore was a British Fortress. All the facilities have been put to good use by the Singapore military. Seletar Airbase has been converted into an Civilian Aerospace Centre where Rolls Royce/Prat & Whitney and others have various MRO (maintenance, repair, overhaul) facilities and currently expanding. Just imagine, the feelings of the British when leaving Singapore to their feelings, when leaving Hong Kong. The Singapore of today never changed the names of roads, buildings due to its historical value.
压根就不是，是新加坡的战略位置。
The British were also leasing Singapore from the Johor sultan for 200 years. Well actually almost all their colonies were leased.
從來不只是想著必要與中國香港省競爭, 但幾乎每個國家，作為一個新獨立的小島國，我們必須具有競爭力才能在全球舞臺上生存。香港背後有一個非常強大的國家, 新加坡沒有,儘管它是一個獨立的國家.
I believe if Lee Kuan Yew is alive today, he will have additional written admiration for Xi. You have to really think deeply what he wrote about Xi and the person he associated him with and look at current world affairs. But I guess the Americans already knew through their tapping.
非常中肯的评价，很难得
我们的财政辩论围绕着AI, 怎样培养AI人才产业,你们还在执着第一第二名🤣🤣🤣
Silly question from lady audience abt comparing spore n hk. We sporeans r not bothered with hk😢 Hongkong is very lucky to have China behind them. We dont.
Very strange, in Singapore we do not talk about HK, but in HK they think Singapore is the reason of their trouble.
这是我第二次听到这个说法，即：习拯救了党。第一次，是专门跟跑国内新闻的记者，当时从她口中听到这个说法，让我一愣。下意识觉得，形势有这么严重吗？是不是过誉了？或者她的说话习惯如此吧
但是这一次，从一个国家的非常专业的前外长口中听到，让我很震撼。前后一映照，得到相互印证。让我对习的尊重更加重三分。
国内网络基本上不公开讨论领导人，但是在油管上除了各种铺天盖地丑化他的新闻，还是能看到几位专家学者对他的客观评价的，而且和这位前部长结论一致，而国内虽然不讨论，但是在那几个比较下沉的网络社区，还是能看到普通人在评论区的讨论的，毕竟这十年风气的转变真的是感同身受
終於等到今日了
He’s right we don’t talk about Hong Kong in Singapore lol
Excellent insights by Singapore ex-FM on Hong Kong and China. Hong-Kongers should be proud of the national security law or else it will be a chaotic and lawless society. If there is no social security, it is useless for Hong Kong to follow the failed democratic system.
I like to hear more alternative and less biased voices from the guest.
He is the guy able to tell the current situation of Hong Kong outside the storm between US and China.👍
Yeo is a pro china guy. He should relocate to China. I watched a few of his talk and interview and he gave biased view. Hahaha
香港比新加坡幸福多了，因为有大陆在背后支撑，我们新加坡是一步一脚印的走出一条自己的路！
What a great speech.
此君言論差已。香港從歸中國之后是其中一省、以中國今日富強有过于美欧无不及、何來沒了美國而香港不保往日?相反美歐經已漫漫向下、正如江河日落。
作為香港人，我也不會和新加坡比較，我們在香港生活好好的，吃喝玩樂樣樣有，挺好的
👍👍👍👍👍👍
从杨部长、马凯硕这些前新加坡政府体系官员的表现就可以知道新加坡的成功不是偶然的。他们的格局、视野和洞察力完全超越世界上绝大部分的官员和学者。无论是现场的主持人还是提问者，他们发言所体现的背后的心态，就完全可以发现香港的问题所在，就是从来没有考虑做好自己，也没有正视自己的优势或不足，总是将问题和希望寄希望于外力或外物，这种心态可能也是香港发展中最大的问题。
殖民地心态。
那位女士有關新加坡超越香港的問題非常可笑，人家根本就不care超不超越香港，人家只care自己是否比過去更好了。這部分香港人的心態亟需改變，不要再整天care是不是被哪個城市超越了，把你們的精力放在怎麼謀發展吧，香港發展了自然就不怕被超越。
While Mr Yeo talks from his perspective, viewers can choose to believe or not to believe. The fact that when US is putting china as the ‘greatest competitor’ or ‘greatest threat’ means that China must have done something right in the last decade, u cannot become a ‘threat’ to mighty America if u are not good enough. 😊
China has done right in joining WTO and attract foreign investment and technology transfer. But since 2012, whether it is doing the right thing is a debatable issue. China economic structure and model have run out of steam. The economic restructuring will take years. In the meantime, China has to live with slow growth. Solving the property bubble is critical, also the Government (locals and central) debts will determine how China is going to progress.
加油❤
Agree. The consequential leader at this moment.
Thanks george!
👏👏👏❤️👍insightful a loyalist a peacemaker an. asset contributor to the world . Proud Chinese 👍👏❤️
👍👍👍
Singapore city does not talk much about Hong Kong. Singapore city will become 2nd largest Financial Centre after New York with London Brexit and without EU as backyard. ASEAN has 660mil pax. Singapore is 100% English speaking city.
继续做英语文化殖民系统坚定的一环而已
Very well said, one of the very outstanding man around........Host : You think he saved the CPC? George Yeo : I think he saved China.........
台灣評論員蔡委員說：
香港人視英國為上帝！
那麼新加坡視尾角又是什麼⁉️
新加坡人没有统一的上帝。我们都可能给美国、中国、还有自己的政府一个大中指。社会安全稳定，人民安居乐业，孩子们有书读、每年有钱出国旅游，这就是上帝。
@@Diderot68 你说的， 是金钱就是上帝。
3141亚细安说了不选边利益最大化
@cancanjaker1620 So？有问题 吗
@@jjjq4505 有的。任何金钱至上的人和社会，终究会被淘汰。
新加坡人談到香港只會提到某某明星而已 ！香港太自以為是😊😊😊😊
謝謝.
人活着不是單靠食物,而是清洁、信实、,公义的信念.
這種高質量回答，但在youtube已經16個小时，但點贊只有一千多個，稱贊習主席的評論到目前只有三十九個點讚，可知香港今日已經黃到出汁，很多人被西方洗腦，楊先生說一句非常好，整個新加坡都是藍的，可知香港很多蠢人。你看看習主席過什麼生活？美國幾任總統過什麼生活？就知誰是為國為民？
拜登儿子：要学我啊，我就糟蹋乌克兰，不霍霍美国也说不过去，小霍还是有的
西方国家的领导人，只是个上班的领导，也需要靠ppt和托词应付董事会，需要对外搞发布会，假期能休息就休息，能甩锅就帅锅，做的烂就跟人比谁更烂。中国的领导那是一家之主，是很操心方方面面的。
习的哥哥，姐姐，小老婆和私生子会让你知道过什么生活？？？你今年三岁认识共产
@@jjjq4505 呵呵，你这总抹黑手法，其实正是西方竞选语言。造谣就行了，耸人听闻就行了。证据？莫须有。
2312，对啦！吹到天上会飞
Hi guys, what does GY means when he said singaporean is blue and not yellow?
Singaporen Chinese doesn't like to call themselves as yellow skin Chinese.
Perhaps that indefinite blue make Singapore difference.
During 2019/2021 HK has riots and they were categorized into yellow and blue camp. Yellow is the one that is anti Chinese, pro western , in their words , democracy. Blue is pro china, support one country, one system. Nothing to do with skin color.
2019 Hongkong pro democracy rioters wear yellow, pro government wear blue. Singaporeans are well known to support their government for an orderly society.
@@OnMusicSoon1
Well said !
I concur with BG Yeo.
6:49 "Xijinping to me is the greatman because noone can tackle corruption like he did."
Words of wisdom.
Amusing that Hongkongers still look at Singapore and even China with skepticism.
楊榮文最後那段敘述，道出不為人知的中國。讓人明白習主席的不尋常之處。
美國支持？？😂😂標題好好笑
我初中的时候，学生、大人打架斗殴，死人是很正常的事。我上高中的时候，路上碰到乞丐是很正常的事。我上大学的时候，去政府部门办事被板着脸是很正常的事。我刚出社会的时候，农村没有汽车是很正常的事。
我今年三十多，看到了中国在经济和文化的快速繁荣，看到了中国人从追海外产品到了民族品牌，看到中国人逢洋必舔到文化自信道路自信。
经济上主要是胡温铺的路而已，习上台正好水到渠成。当然，治安方面我承认习是下狠手了，街头帮派什么的一扫而光，不好的是各种风月场所也一并扫没了😂
Hong Kong is in a transition from an old era that was dominated by vested interests that inherited their positions from the colonial days. Now the vested interest network has been cracked, and a new one is forming. Inbthe interim it looks as if Hong Kong is sinking because the okd interests are pulling out faster than the new one is building. But I believe over time Hong Kong will emerge stronger than before and hopefully more equitable than before.
Singapore is 100% English speaking city. Singapore just to manage a good relationship w/ Indonesia Pancasila and Malaysia Rukun-Negara who has 300mil pax to become 2nd Largest Financial Centre. Such as Taylor Swift concerts 2024 that Muslim countries not allow to do it. [Win-Win] - Spore talked to Biden and Indonesia/Msia talked to Xi Jiping, as neutral.
HK had Father British empire backing in the past, and Mother China then, which flourish for decades, Singapore an orphan for decades and under LKY leadership; rainbowED... There's nothing to compare except leaders
如果新加坡只是靠美國而維持的經濟，不出五年，一定玩完。
the question lady is Emily Lau?
卿姐、she has a lot of bull in her back yard. Silly question
That’s why Yeo said all SG are “blue not yellow” since Lau asked provocative questions.
They all still living in 90’s, thinking China and the party as a black white TV stage
@@bkwliang8582hi can enlighten? What does blue mean?
@@bkwliang8582what does blue and yellow mean?
真知灼见
Saya merlion mighty 🙂 Peter 60
I didn't know that Xi Jin Ping tackled corruption in China. But if he did, then he did well for China. He may not be China's hero or savior, but this anti-corruption will be a huge thing in China.
is not about how weak is hk now which makes sg so strong relatively...is how long for hk to take back what she once owned & earned with or without cn political influences...she could come back soon with the taichi optic cpu to fight tw chip's giant...but the time takes so long & the central govt may not be willing to shift the state of art developing base to hk fr peking.
好一个兩边都要吃！he knew the politics stuation and, how to maintain both country of relationship , we call it in law
The lady who asked the qn abt SG crushing HK needs to know a simple fact .. the SG economy has been ahead of HK by GDP per capita for abt 20yrs ... n the gap is widening
The only sectors in HK.that are larger than the same in SG is the financial n real estate sector .. n that is largely because HK is part of the PRC for the former .... n because real estate is key for govt income in HK ....
So plse ... SG is already way ahead of HK .... except for the financial industry.
Can’t agree more!
非常認同
George Yeo is more suited to be an academic. He is intelligent but sometimes naive. He should give more insights on the betterment of Singapore instead of trying to be a wannabe global statesman and commenting on topics he is far removed.
Naive? I think he's full of wisdom.
social networking is also prevalent in western world
what does BG George Yeo means by singaporeans are blue not yellow ?
In HK's context blue is pro police/government/current establishment; yellow is pro "democracy"
i wanna know too...