Lobsang Sangay with Chinese Students Q&A
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 10. 2012
- On October 12, 2012, Tibetan Prime Minister Dr. Lobsang Sangay spoke at UMN Law School as part of a two-day visit to Minnesota. The audience was largely Chinese students. Dr. Sangay gave a frank assessment of the current state of affairs in Chinese occupied Tibet. In particular he detailed efforts to bring about a constructive dialog between Tibetans and Chinese.
Following his opening comments, students were invited to ask questions. This is a portion of the Q&A, featuring the comments from Chinese students. The opening statement is posted separately @ • Lobsang Sangay with Ch...
He just made a time from his busy schedule and had a nice talk with us in our college and I can tell that he is an amazing person and such a great leader !
He shared us his story from how he started from being just a normal poor village boy to being a Harvard student and now the President!!
I hope Tibetans get their country back really soon which rightfully belongs to them!
More power to you Sir 👍
Thank you
What a good leader the Tibetans have elected! I feel proud to say that in one way he is a product of India!
We have a lot of leader like him
@Pine Joi man u r pig like ccp n mouse tse tung.
He is, he was born and educated in India and did further studies in States.
He is a product of Tibet not India
@@urgyenshelling5591 ok brother, you win!
Tibet i stand with you
@Pine Joi First of all, where the hell are you from?
@Pine Joi fuck you
Tibetans are atleast lucky to have a leader like him..
@Pine Joi you are bloody shit everywhere. Don't you have work to do? Are you useless?
@Pine Joiyou are expecting chinese passport from person who is not allowed to see the tibet for decades ?
The Dalai Lama will spark separatism. Is the Tibet flag banned ?
@Pine Joi lmao, then why do they have to flee ? Why China has to shoot and kill them like animals while they try to flee through the Himalaya ?
qualities of a peaceful leader .......i see in P.M. dr lobsang sangay. PEACE TIBET .
@Pine Joi how can i believe you that he is Lying? you are a liar.
@Pine Joi u r thr every comments in wtever video's ccp bitch
@Khyung Lharje JARROONGGGG,U R EVERYWHERR
I had the pleasure of meeting Sikyong Dr Lobsang Sangay during his 2017 Australia tour. Many Aussies and Tibetans came to hear his speeches. Tibetan community here is very small but dynamic. Many Australians support it. Many long and happy years to him.
hi pine joi, its just his accent, like thousands of university lecturers, PHDs, Drs, professors, etc, who talk with heavy accents.
@Pine Joi english is not his mother language.he is Tibetan.
@Pine Joi For ur kind information,English is just a language not knowledge,he has acquired knowledge through lots of hard work in his field and now u CCP are scared of losing Tibet.Btw I have seen a youtube video of ur own Chinese secret service agent who ran away from ur own government and disclosed the information of how ur secret service agents work like spreading hate and manupilating everywhere in comment section of Tibetan related issue.Fuck off
@Pine Joi he done higher education than you and has doctoral degree. Ahaha you just that disappointment kid in your Asian family
@Pine Joi he was a student at Harvard university, he studied laws, he was also a professor there.
i admire this man! he's totally aware, articulate, knowledgeable and convincing
kshis13 this kind of official can't exist in government environment in China
Pine Joi He's a Harvard law graduate, what have you achieved?
Pine Joi Harvard Law Class of '04 search it up on the internet it's not that hard to find.
Pine Joi you can't even get into harvard let alone law school so stay petty uneducated prick🤣
@Pine Joi I don't know why but I really want to laught out loud at you..
as he explained the situation about Tibetans in lhasa, it brought tears to my eyes.
haha boo fucking hoo, tibet is was and always will be a part of China, 1.3 billion people says so =) history says so, and most important of all reality says so =)
obsidianstatue ohh! it means 1.3 billion lires
obsidianstatue ok, from where u have studied Tibetan history,?
@@obsidianstatue oh I have never thought that you are a scholar in tibet history... Never say something so easily which is totally not true...
@Pine Joi I don't believe you or whatever you say...
The reason why British colonized India is the same reason why Chinese have colonized Tibet today:to exploit the local resouces and enrich themselves. It is that much plain and simple.
Your comment ignores some important differences. The British did not try to destroy the culture and identity, the very seperate existence of, India. They did not try to make India part of Great Britain. Also, when Britain was giving India back its independence, and all other colonial powers were beginning to do so, China was beginning to colonize Tibet and has continued do so while no one else, to speak of, is doing this sort of thing, any longer. So, you can say, if it's what you are saying, in a way, that China is only doing what Britain and other have done, but it's what they have done 60, 70, 80, 90, or more than 100 years ago and have, since then, all, basically, stopped doing because it was wrong then as it is wrong, now.
Sridhar Kaushik ུ
Pine Joi guys don’t use tik tok it’s Chinese
@Pine Joi ok when tibet became part of china.??explain
@naranhan2010 u ass ,only during your pig head Mao Tse Dung time Tibet was occupied by CCP before than that whatever dynasty (Ming /Qing ) they has no access .All u were taught in school is fake as how much your Id is ...
Free Tibet, thats it. We Indians welcome your freedom and your Master will always welcome the student become one again.
@Pine Joi Kashmir belongs to India....India has more thn 5000 yrs relation with Jammu and Kashmir. But Tibet Invaded by crazy fucking China. #free_Tibet
Total nonsense. Right now the Chinese government subsidies Tibet billions of dollars each year. Economically, China would be better off without Tibet.
every words, every sentensec he says hits me so damn hard.
That's Dr. Lobsang Sangay for you.😎😎
Stop getting technical, as far as my eyes and ears tell me, Lobsang Sangay is a genuine Tibetan.
I was born in Thailand.from Chinese parent and I feel my Chinese blood. only one thing I don't like about Chinese goverment is its policy to suppress Tibet. Think about China being suppressed by the Japanese and the European colonialism.
you are not Chinese .liar .I am a Chinese in China .
He is one of the best leader, Respect.
@Pine Joi so u r here too..
@Pine Joi because of you people we have no choice.
@Pine Joi i am nt talking about china.i am talking abt my country tibet.and what u guys doing in tibet..poor chiness like u
@Pine Joi we tibetan had no choice whn mouse tsetung chiness enter in tibet .my grand parent were killed in prison.and please dont teach me about history of my country..we r diff ..
One day truth will win.destroy wht u like in tibet.forget about my country .1st free china from pigs like u
damn he is so enlighted!!
the monasteries acted as universities, and hospitals. Often times, families would send their younger sons to monasteries to protect the integrity of their land. The monasteries had an economical, educational, and social value. As for the theocracy, the Dalai Lama can come from any social status. He is then taught by the best scholars that Tibet can offer. The most educated man in Tibet becomes its leader.
I admire his composure and calmness.
excellent ... i salute you lob sangay
Tibet is freedom!!!!!! Tibed not depending to China...
I wish you happiness to all Tibet people
Thank you 🙏 u are right the true is Tibet is not part of China.
@Pine Joi oh please leave it 😒
@Pine Joi ok
Tibet was forcibly taken away from the peaceful Tibetans. One can see proof of this from various footages from independent observers available on youtube. The movie "seven years in Tibet" also highlighted this issue.
China is a nation that has no notion of human rights or coexisting peacefully. The only language it understands is one of force. This is not just about Tibet. Chinese are now slowly getting into Nepal, Bangladesh etc. The seem to be intended on expanding their "repressive" empire. INTERnantional community should unite and stop this menace.
i love his achievement and struggle...
@Pine Joi what about ccp .can thy speak a lil english.
Thanks you a lots, Dr. Lobsang Sanggey We all are loved you always....!!!
I want to thank India . a big thank you on behalf of my Tibetan fellows
@Pine Joi czcams.com/video/7ZyOA1hj_lc/video.html
I will forever stand by an Independent Tibet because I grew up with these sentiments and the current treatment of the Tibetans further fuel my beliefs. However, I also hope that you don't settle for the current manifestation of China. I hope that you will bring shame upon those who need to be shamed, and bring forward the leaders who will change your country for the better. I hope you won't hide the mistakes, and defend your nation blindly, but fight for a better future.
tibetans are the savers of world,its sacred land for indians and a living place for tibetans,china should leave tibet and go to were it belongs, China should give respect to tibet like what india gives and make it a independent nation. We should have big hearts,tall stature to accept and accomodate good peaceful ppl and give what it belongs to them. that doing will be seen as china is not a rogue nation, but a responsible nation and it grows respect towards it.
Thank you very much our Chinese brothers and sisters, for your concerns and care about us. I really appreciate and pretty sure that we can and will do our best.
answered appropriately
The repressive regimes in the past (including British colonials) have always used this argument that we have done something good, so our rule is legitimate. British actually told that they had a duty to improve the lot of the Indians as they were living in poverty and by 1947 when British left, India was in much greater poverty.
The best thing China can do is to walk away from Tibet. They have no right over a people they do not understand and respect.
the difference is british invade india
but tibet is part of china.
eiji kenji I agree with you, Tibet is belongs to China since Qing Dynasty. When i was a student in some Nepali schools my teachers used to tell histories such as ''Nepal also invaded Tibet many times but every single invation Chinese Army came in a very big number and pushed the Nepales out from Tibet. I am not only taking Chinese side nor Tibetan side, my good wishes is to both (Chinese and Tibetan). I think the Tibetan living in Tibet are happy being with China. TIBET WAS, IS AND ALWAYS WILL BE PART OF CHINA.
kasa0405 wtf who are you to tell tibet is part of china.
+kasa0405 what you said,,,nepal invade tibet,,,,haaaaa,,,,joke of the day,,,,,plsssss,,,,,haaaa,,,thank god your teacher didnt said,,nepal invade usa,,,,haaaa
+kasa0405 what you said,,,nepal invade tibet,,,,haaaaa,,,,joke of the day,,,,,plsssss,,,,,haaaa,,,thank god your teacher didnt said,,nepal invade usa,,,,haaaa
I'm watching this again and again because the answers are so satisfying.
free tibet
Such a calm and on to the point reply....Love from India 🇮🇳
Excellent we are proud of you Sikyong la
Tibetans and Uighurs . Hope you all have freedom in near future.
Mr. Prime Minister, You are doing a great job representing Tibetans all over the world. It is true, the Chinese govt. did try to destroy this peaceful land. A people who wish to live their life with the edict, "Harm no one" have been harmed so much by a vicious govt. like
China. I wish that all Tibetans will soon be allowed to enter their own country which is being monopolized by a govt. that does not belong there. FREE TIBET!!
we dont really hate chinese ppl. there r chinese student here in india and we dont look at them with enemity. some r even great frnds. its just the gov that we have lil grudges ..... hope the will wake up to tibetan plight soon...
@Pine Joi "you have never been to tibet". That's the problem dummie. We can't brother.
this man is a clean and bright personality...... respect and love from india to the PM and tibetan people ..........jai ho
Dynamic Leader with excellent speach delivery. Hope we Indian can help more to the exiled tibetian for there fight for homeland.
I like him, lobsang sangey, very learned.... 👍👍👏👏
Calm, composed, at the same time talks authoritatively to wards their people, I heart fully support your urge for homeland.One day or the other other tibet will get freedom,.
I watched his interview with the Australian National Broadcast many years ago. I have lots of admiration for this great man. ❤️👍
That Chinese male media received awesome answer....lobsang🔥🔥🔥🔥
@Khyung Lharje Rare to see a 小粉红 with a Tibetan name..
@Khyung Lharje Exactly, only you would think so, phony idiot. One who has no respect for culture and traditions, what will he know about Dharmic languages and scripts, instead comparing them with "pubic hairs". Pity on you, man..
Free Tibet 🇮🇳
@Pine Joi oke , but are we ready 2 lost around millions of. PPl then we free the china Kashmir .
@Pine Joi show me ancient documents , and then we give your land . Oh wait . What the cccp destroy all ancient document and land mark . So there is no VPN work . Damn it too much long joke . 😂😀😂😀😀😂😀😂😂😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀
@Pine Joi mr.VPN. Translate this . " हम आपके वजूद से पहले भी यही थे । और जब वजूद में नही होगे तो भी हम लोग यही होंगे " your communist party not believe any lama . So you m.m. why you acknowledge me . Give me strong Nazi document I believe . Mr.VPN. Don't do google cause they track you for your lovely party as per order . Use dns server technology if you watch you tube. . oh no so long joke. 😀😂😂😀😀😂😀🤣🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣🤣😀🤣😀😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣🤣😀😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣😀🤣
@Pine Joi #free. - Taiwan , macaow , Hongkong 😂😀😂😂😀🤣😀🤣🤣🤣🤣😀🤣🤣😀🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😀😂😂😂😀😂😂😀😂😀
@Green Scenery another VPN .🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
He is brilliant who will certainly bring Tibetan peaceful atmosphere to live in tibet , look at tibet now , its like a detention zone , ghetto ... I’m a Han Chinese , I don’t care if Tibetan could have their own government as long as the Chinese could look straight at the real history out side from their governments network , I think Han and Tibetan could live peacefully whether there are one country or two regarding that if the Chinese authority is there
you are not chinese! 兄弟，你是哪里人？
Even you are no Chinese but words bring hope
@@user-vd9nz2uq2g of course he is not in China .he high probably is a banana .
Fastastic answer from Tibetan Prime Minister.
Great.
I have high respect for you.
With you Tibet
Also, you should also know that China, one of the most powerful global economies, wouldn't be so altruistic as to insist on keeping Tibet for its own sake. There are obvious economic and political gain. Stop deluding yourself into thinking that you are doing something good for us. The world knows China's top priority is money, and that human lives, both Chinese and Tibetan, are dispensable.
we need same discussion frm ur side. its blessing to us
Proud of u..!!
Lob. Sengye la..!!
Indians in the comments seem very educated and enlightened, I am pleased at their intelligence！同志们做好三哥的忽悠工作！
Thanks दम है तो इंग्लिश में लिखना पूरा मूर्ख
Proud to say that we got president like Dr lobsang sangye 🙏
when you reach an argument, most of Tibet will be yours. But I don't see Tibet as just U-tsang. I see it as Kham, amdo, and u-tsang. I want full autonomy, full independence.
This guy is articulate; Tibetans are blessed to have a leader like him. I wish one day your homeland becomes less totalitarian and you can return. Love from India ♥️
He deserves to be as president of Tibet and to joined in UN security members to talk and discuss the matter as just now carrying on.
I’m actually very impressed by his answer. May Jesus Christ bless him. I’m a Tibetan Christian & I love both Tibetan and Chinese. We are human being & we should love our neighbors. That’s the law of 10 commandments 🙏
"We are never a part of china how can we be seperatatist" good point, except every country on earth recognizes Tibet as a part of China and many many Tibetans living in Tibet agree with that.
Tibetans do not hate China or the Chinese people but many do hate the Chinese Communist Party & Chinese colonial rule over Tibet. The CCP has oppressed Tibetans for the past 60 years. If your country was invaded by a foreign power, you would also develop strong opinions. But the Dalai Lama always preaches compassion, even to your enemies. We just want our freedom. Isn't that what all people want?
He knows how to lead a Nation and he is the best one till now 🌸🙏👌🙏🌸.
very helpful talk.
Yes, that is right!
We all need freedom and human rights and even like you said we are struggling since 60 years ago.
chinese people....understand this from tibetan,we dont hate ya'all! we just got problem with the chinese gov....and i know ya'all do too.....LOVE & PEACE...lets live with harmony and compasion...thats all we need....
Great leader ,exemplary leader,visionary leader
For a Chinese person living in the city, 3 children might seem plenty, but for a nomad, who relies on their children to help take care of the lifestock, 3 is really not enough.
Well said, Doctor Lobzang Sangye la.
The man is spilling facts let's be real
I think modifications is necessary in China's handling of its own people, and its minority nations. and I am glad, that I have been able to made you consider modification. The biggest crime you can ever do against your own nation is calling it perfect. rather than defending, covering, and hiding its mistakes. you need to broadcast the mistakes, shame the politicians, and push for change.
WOW what a brilliant individual, speaking nothing but facts and not missing a beat. I can see a better future ahead for Tibet. FREE TIBET
Very cool, even headed and articulate Prime Minister!
I WISHED CHINESE STUDENTS COULD ASK QUESTIONS TO CCP OF LEADERS OF CHINA WITH SAME IMMOTION. I DOUBT IT CCP MEMBERS WOULD ALLOW IN SUCH MANNERS.
Great leader!! God bless Tibet
I know of the great economic achievements that China has made in Tibet. Congratulations.
Fuck u... Haha
When Khampas and Amdos came to Lhasa, after they lost everything. Lhasa became nervous. And the idea of partnership became nullified. So, hordes of Tibetans escaped. The policy the Tibetan government in exile holds, is a partnership. not independence. so, your government can talk to dalai lama and reach an agreement.
if you still believe that China has a right over the minority nation, then I also hope that you would open your eyes to conditions of the minorities, and fight on their behalf. instead of saying they are lucky, and they don't know how to be grateful to all that China has given them, I hope you open your eyes to their plea. At the end of the day, they are minorities, and part of being minority means your voice is often times drowned by the majority.
not sidetracking. it is an example of China's complete disregard for living things. A country that distraught won't be able to respect the natural resources of Tibet. I am saying China is unfit for Tibet. It will turn it into a reflection of itself, and destroy Asia's main water source. It is a very important discussion. Global warming is a very relevant discussion, and integral in the current debate. water is indispensable for all, and for Tibetans, its natural resources is important.
Lonsang la , very nice talked .
I made my comments because I traveled to Tibet before and know how people live there. I believe there is always some misunderstanding between Han and Tibetan but it is not that severe that people tried to burn themselves. Most self-immolated people are monks or former monks so I would rather feel shame that the senior monks brainwash the young people for their political purpose...
Lobsang sangay is spilling facts
Great speech.....
But the question here is whether the tibetans in tibet right now are all suppressed. However, the truth is that most of them are actually helped by the development there.
great conversation.....one day Tibet will free
When cultural revolution was happening, China did realize that Tibet was very different from their own country. They realized that the method they used to over-throw the nobles in China, couldn't be implemented in Tibet. As theocracy, and monastic culture is so deep-rooted. They had a separate policy(in my opinion, smart move). However, that dual-policy was not extended to Kham and Amdo.
history could have been very different, if Kham and Amdo weren't so brutally treated. Otherwise, Mao's policy towards Lhasa was not atrocious. The lhasa people were obviously mistreated by the army, but not to the extent that a partnership between China and Tibet couldn't be possible.
Salute you sir proud to be your under rule.
Please stay trong, Tibet people
You are a Tibetan and an Indian... ❤️❤️
Just a quick comment on what he said about not being able to go to Tibet. There are plenty of Tibetans from other parts of the world traveling to Lhasa some even took videos and interviewed locals. What prevented him from going is his title his position in the Tibet government in exile.
Buddha bless Tibetan and this great leader Lobsang sangay
Chinese construction of railways system and other means Of transportations has cost indigenous peoples do more harm than favour...it was built with intention to influx the huge masses of Hans Chinese into Tibet.. Chairman Mao, built to conquer the Tibet's territories back then... Should we be feel grateful for Chinese to build these concrete building by exploiting our own resources.. Our resources were used to built everything that you see in TAR.. So, it's absurdity to feel through that way... Chinese are not doing anything favour for us now and then... So don't give that shit on us ...
I wish we can elect u once again !! 2021
Use example of HK compare with Tibet is not good, different condition and different history as well as different culture, many many difference.
+王相益 honestly wat so different at the point he compare...
i bet you better watch again and question yourself
@Pine Joi Before China invaded Tibet was free. After the fall of the Qing, the 13th Dalai Lama declared independence
I respect the beauty of the idea. I also acknowledged that there were failures in implementations. I also know that the older political system is no longer suitable for the modern times. however, for its time, it was beautiful. if we drag it into the current times, then it will be backwards and potentially evil.
🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
The world humanitarian organisation should look at them and gave back Tibet independence I am from Malaysia free Tibetan 💝💝💝🙏🙏🙏👍
Tibet is part of China. More autonomy for Tibet is tantamount to separating Tibet from China. We will never allow it. No matter how the Dalai Lama try to put pressure on us, the Chinese people will always support our government on the Tibetan issue. Tibetans can accept this reality and get on with creating a better life for themselves, or they can continue this counter-productive confrontation. We are ready to carry on the effort to fully integrate Tibet into China, no matter how long it takes.
And 14 children would have been fine once, but because there are so many rude intruders, the living space in Tibet is bec oming increasingly packed, and the natural resources, increasingly diminished. WTF.
Wow 👍👍👍❤️🙏👏👏👏👏👏
I actually agree. I am not very fond of feudalism myself. I am glad Tibetan government in exile has shifted to democracy. I am not fully satisfied, because the transition is very superficial at the moment, but I do think that the shift will allow other transitions to unfold more easily.
I don't ignore the economic prosperity. However, you also cannot deny that majority of the people benefiting from this economic prosperity are Chinese. You also cannot deny that most of the government officials are Chinese. Therefore, you also cannot deny that the reasons I stated above are enough to cause severe resentment. Being treated as a minority in your own nation is absolutely unfair.
ཡག་བྱུང་སྲིད་སྐྱོང་ལགས།
You tibetan?
🙏🙏
i am proud to say that we have better, logical, smarter, more educated etc, better president than US president elect Donald Trump
And yet you didn't free from China
kerry wangnao tibet was occupied in 1945, he was elected around 2010s, you dumb ? And the reason of our land getting occupied shows that China is the dirtiest country with no morality. Tibet is not a country of armies and soldier like we are ready for a war. Tibet is a place of wisdom and compassion. Sole place of Buddhism, Chinese distroyed 90 percent of the monasteries and killed millions of monks. You still think it’s Tibet’s fault? Tibet trusted China as a friend. And then they took over it, along with other countries, now they are almost having a war with India, coz China are trying to take over indochinese border area, claiming it’s theirs. So you should know all these facts before u say something.🤍