ranking project sekai commissioned songs âŸ
VloĆŸit
- Äas pĆidĂĄn 16. 12. 2022
- hi guys! sorry for not posting in a whileđ
a certain đ someone đ took forever đ to tell us đ their opinion !!đ cough cough M
anyway
we only decided to rank group songs, although we might rank the other commissions (cup noodle, anniversary, etc.) at a later time!
timestamps
00:00 intro
00:23 l/n
03:46 mmj
07:30 vbs
12:00 wxs
16:08 25ji
20:29 outro
you can find the videos we used for each song in our playlists-
" insert group name commissioned songs"
also, again, please remember these are just our opinions!! we don't mean to come off as too harsh, but sorry if we do! hope you guys enjoy! - ZĂĄbava
![Ranking ALL 226 ProSeka Covers/Originals [AS OF 10/10/23]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/r2pXyBLWjCQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Iâd just like to say that the âyelling in lower caseâ in âClose to Grayâ is called belting, a technique of singing by which a singer carries their chest voice above their break with a proportion of head voice. (Also called high voice)
yeah ik that it's called belting, and it's def a difficult technique, but i was more talking about the way their voices sound muted in the song lol sorry that i wasn't clear on it -g
Close to gray in last makes me mad đ (Iâm an ena fan)
I wasn't expecting Honami songs to finally get the places they deserve, also finally people, who actually appreciate KanaTomo! I will forever stand by that it's Nightcord's magnum opus and the way sasanomaly wrote all the lyrics so carefully to fit with with everyone makes me tear up everytime.
FOR REAL honami songs are always so beautiful!!
I LOVE HARE WO MATSU AND STAGE OF SEKAI SMđ
@@grabsthot1939 stage of sekai is always stuck in my head its such a great song
HONAMI SONGS>>>>> ANY ONE ELSE
pls another Honami event
The Giga slander, I went absolutely ballistic for Ready Steady when it released its to goodđđ I agree that the boys don't have enough lines tho
i really like giga's work actually! it's just that ready steady doesn't really feel like a unit song and some of the mixing/vocal choices seem questionable to me lol, i prefer the virtual singer version a lot more - a
Every night cord song is a âŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸ101010101929303848404073910102938409227828192920193738392âŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸâŸ/10 and you canât change my mind
The close to Gray slander đ
W
The once upon a dream slander and Tenshi no clover slanderđđ theyâre some of my favorite songs, but Iâm super happy to see some praise for From Tokyo and If!!
ikr i can't believe they slandered once upon a dream like that đ - a
Emu's childish voice in Once upon a dream fits the song well, why do they hate her voice đ
MORE! JUMP! MORE! Getting last place and seeing that one person hate on Emuâs voice in Niccori Survey made me wanna scream-
some of these had me shaking my head lmao itâs nice seeing otherâs opinions
Lol fr
Flyer is better without vbs
Iâm not a minori fan, but angels clover is my favorite song!
i know smh i wish it was higher lolđ -g
Not almost all my favourite WXS songs being at the bottom đ
I appreciate the 88 stars one though!!
7:33 I think it depends on what type of music you're into (correct me if I'm wrong, but I noticed a pattern in which you like more happyish viby songs) but personally this is one of my favorites, I was very surprised to know people don't like this song, also akito and toya get quite a lot of lines but only in the full song, the partssekai grabbed is where they don't sing a lot, if you think about it this song matches street singing a lot, like idk Mirai is even bland-er than Ready Steady and it got a 10 LMAK
AAAAA "IF" AND "GEKKOU" SO HIGH đđ these are my favorite songs in their own units!!!!
machi and mirai should get more love
I LOVE IF WITHOUT IT BEING IN PROSEKA ALSO
@@reinqqq I feel you đ
THE ABSOLUTE VBS SLANDER HERE đđ Personally, flyer and ready steady are some of my favs and I even learned the choreo for them and I'm so glad u guys didn't hate on forward bc its so fun. No hate to you guys, I understand where you're coming from and I absolutely love that u placed from tokyo high bc it was one of my first favs
the jackpot sad girl slander hurt me mentally and physically
FINALLY! Lower oneâs eyes gets its well deserved recognition! Too many people hate on this song i hold close to my heart and it physically pains me.
wdym....? lower is one of their most popular songs..
wait people hate lower??
lower is popular tho đđđ
idk what yall talking abt i see so many people hate on lower âčïž
@@Lemon_Fiber idk what kind of videos your getting but lower is so popular, especially on tiktok mostly
bro the ready steady slander... i'm in tears i love that song
Rad dogs sounds like boss battle music and I love it
IF AND WORLDWIDE WANDER AS THE TOP 2 IS SO RIGHT!! def my favorite mmj songs. tenshi no clover would be at third place for me but i understand your opinions on it
not all 3 ichika songs getting so low wtf đđ they're such good songs and the way that the lyrics tie into the other songs and ichika's character is so good, and the little details in the songs, like a couple days ago i was up at 2am crying over ichika man đđ like made to order's slow pacing along with the instrumentals... i tear up every time i hear the song.
also i don't think for stage of sekai it's a good range for ichika, in her solo cover she struggles to hold onto the notes a lot (the range is best for honami and saki, since the song is higher compared to most l/n songs)
real made to order best
ă1ăand 88 completely deserve number 1 in their respective categories. Iâll admit that as an EN Sekai player I may not be the best to judge them, but ă1ăis absolutely heavenly and 88 just scratches that piano itch in my brain (+ the vocals are great and the VS doesnât sound overly robotic). I havenât heard Mirai or If yet (songs havenât come out on EN server and I didnât care enough to look into them unlike with 88 and Gekkou), but Iâm a bit disappointed with how strained Toya sounds in some of the transitional parts in Mirai, like heâs out of his vocal range but not enough to use falsetto. Doesnât seem like a terrible song overall though. Admittedly my opinions differed a lot with most of the N25 songs (Mafumafu bias makes me like Cellphone Love Story and Composing The Future a lot more, Lower Oneâs Eyes is slightly less good to me because I hate its Expert chart for being so hard, and IDSmile is also slightly less good because Meiko was not tuned very well at all), but I donât find myself quite being able to disagree with the rankings because I can definitely understand where people are coming from with those points (plus letâs be honest basically all of N25âs commissioned songs are good, the only one that arguably isnât is Close To Gray which isnât even too bad until you get to the chorus). Overall, great ranking but Newly Edgy Idols deserved higher
If is amazing actually wtf how come no one told me??? Itâs definitely one of the best MMJ songs. My opinion on Mirai hasnât changed, I still think that Gekkou is better (and so are Flyer and the two new commissions that came out after this video). What Kind of Ending Do You Want? deserved higher, and finally Nijiiro Stories appreciation (I flip flop between it being meh and it being amazing every once in a while). And Niigo and VBS have mostly banger commissions (with the notable exceptions of Close to Gray for the former (still think itâs meh) and Ready Steady for the latter (Forward is also kind of meh, Anhane duet was good but the original song isnât that good)
Seeing ready steady at 11th place made my soul disappear, it's my fav song too with An and Touya :')
THE IF AND WORLDWIDE WANDER ATTENTION THEY DESERVE!!! amazing ratings, I agree with A the most, but as a flyer fan Iâm quite saddened by it being second last⊠also teratera is actually really good if you listen to it for awhile!
Nice ranking, even if M called basically all my favs "boring/nothing special", also the honami love is greatly appreciated
3:20 honestly w opinion for a good sing fr
All my fav L/n song (Made to order, Ryuusei no pulse, Teratera) at the bottom ;-;
anyway great video â€
It's genuinely hilarious how all 3 Ichika commissioned songs are at the bottom
88* is my favorite WxS song, and Infinetly gray is my favorite N25 song. So yeah, that transition *hurt.*
If,Mirai and 88 stars are my fav commissioned song in each unit
Nijiiro stories is underrated
Not even One nice thing about Emu, I've got my eye on you M
âEmuâs Vocal so annoyingâ
Me : broke my phone
bro i respect this list simply because cinema and tondemo-wonderz don't have top spots and you guys are real ones for that tbh
I love like every song so seeing some so low on the list made me sad but the 1st place ones were really good!
Thank you SO much for doing If justice I'm tired of seeing it getting hate in so many ranking videos, it's a beautiful song where all the girls get to really have their moment to shine! Haruka is the star of the song, as she should be since it's her focus, but the line distribution is brilliant and everyone is able to do their best without anyone being forgotten. Tsukuyomi have made this song brilliant with moving lyrics and amazing instrumentals and man I could talk about it all day!! I love If!!!
I just realized so much of leo/need and wxs songs are commissioned
[1] at number 1 for L/N is so true, Parasol Cider I was glad it was in top 5, Gekkou finally getting some respect (it doesnât hurt that each version {Vocaloid, VBS, and real version} slaps, Nijiiro Stories getting some damn respect, ID smile at the top is no surprise.
I kinda disagree with Close to Gray, iâd say its average like 7/10. The only thing that bothers me on that song is that the beginning sounds like a ringtone/alarm.
I AGREE WITH YOU I SOO AGREE WITH MY TOP 3 BEST PJSK CHARAS AND THAT IS......
3: Toya
2. Mizuki
1. HONA CHAN MOCHIZUKI
this was so fun to watch! very well made video and i enjoyed reading all your opinions :))
13:05 "What Kind of Ending Do You Want?" It's prob my favorite WxS song with "88". I really like the vocals there, tbh. Everyone sounds perfect and the lyrics is really beautiful. I like the vibe in general
I always love these videos even if I don't agree with them lmao. Super agree on Stage of Sekai, Worldwide Wander, and Mirai AND TRICOLOGE TRICOLOGE IS SOO UNDERRATED
Thank you for From Tokyo Appreciation đđđđđ»đđ»
To sum up my feeling after watching this and compare it to my own feeling
More Jump More, Tenshi no Clover, Ready steady so lowđ€Ł
the charts determining placement really bothers me⊠whyyyyy?đ otherwise great video! :)
usually it's not a big deal but sometimes the song gets tied to memories of playing the chart lol also thanks! - a
13:07 R.I.P. Also, If CYBERPUNK DEAD BOY is basically a VBS song thatâs accidentally been given to W x S, then What Kind of Ending Do You Want? is basically a Leo/need song sent to W x S. I truly like all of Ruiâs commissions a LOT, especially Becoming Potatoes and CYBERPUNK DEAD BOY! I agree with plenty of other ProSeka fans that Rui has high-tier commissioned songs. I think Neneâs commissions also sound so beautiful and amazing overall!đđ I find her first commission unique since it features *two* virtual singers and only Rui and Nene sing along with them (Tsukasa and Emu didnât sing *any* lines in Nijiiro Stories despite the fact that both of them appear in the 2DMV for that song). The only other commissioned song that is a duet by default is 17:36 . I think I changed my mind about Tsukasaâs commissions, 88â ćœĄ is my favorite and Tondemo Wonderz is my second fave
[1] is so underrated i LOVE the honami cover
the Becoming Potatoes slander was forgiven for putting niijiro stories 2
and seeing niigo rankings is so hard because every song feels robbed that's how good they are
i disagree with almost the entirety of this list but it was so fun watching you guys give your reasons for your ratings, loved the video!! (m i have a personal vendetta against you bc of ur leo/need ratings watch out /lh)
The fact that I wanted to give every niigo song a 10 (and 11 to lower) made me realise just how much I love their songs
NIJIIRO STORIES 10/10? I'M SO HAPPY đđ
Mirai being no1 for vbs makes me so happy
DREAM PLACE at 11th place hurt me so much âčïž
MY HEART IS BROKEN... READY STEADY IS LAST đ
stella is my fav l/n, shihos cover is everything i need in life.
1 AT THE TOP FOR LEONI SO TRUE.
I was worried about your ln opinions bc people tend to be harsh on them but then i saw your username and hinomori themed account and⊠yeah i can trust you with my life
shiho focuses vs getting a bad commissioned song (impossible)
this video has a good range of opinions its refreshing to see! Especially w forward which is a song people are so unnecessarily harsh towards
I cried on Jackpot sad girl. Itâs my favourite song everâŠ
I like how is in the 1st place, it really rocks
THE SLANDER OF MORE JUMP MORE
I agree with so much of this but close to gray hurt me đđ
I appreciate the ready steady slander
omg NIJIRO STORIES APPRECIATION YESSSS!!!!!! iâve always loooved that song and i never see people actually praising it :(
An's face in beat eater jump scared me the first time, it still scares me ngl
What a great video! YOU have a new subscriber :)
Ok Made in order slander again
I like this song ngl
Maybe bcs the composer written a version of every vocaloid singingk(I'm not sure)
Thank god Metamo and Parasol in top 5 but I like Tenshi no clover
Others I pretty agree but niijiro just doesn't get my vibe
My second is (update)Mr Showtime
1st is ofc 88
I love how they put a song by mafumafu and made it super cool
Really enjoyed this video
IDSMILE my beloved it always slays đ«¶
Finally, justice for Mirai! I always see people ragging on it or rating it very low in these types of videos despite it being a bop.
MORE JUMP MORE WAS WHAT NOW????????!!!!! 100/10 song đđđ
i know đ, i used to love more jump more so much bc its duch a fun song but i once played it like 15 times in a row trying to fc so now every time i play it i think of failing to fc it so many times lol - a
@@hinomoriis6868 lmao yah I havenât been able to fc it on master mode Sadge
so real for ă1ă, IF, 88 stars and IDSMILE in 1st place (and awake now in 7th, peaky peaky in 4th, stage of sekai in 3rd, and lower in 3rd)
im so sad about what sort of ending do you desire being so low lol qwq but apart from that, these rankings are pretty good
when I saw close to gray very low on the ranking, I was hurt, I loved the song since the beginning, but I understand very well, Itâs tone is not really otherâs types and may seem dull if you know what i mean, and the water noises may ruin it too, but I still believe that it remains as one of my favorite nightcord songs, as i fell in love when I first listened to it. (Sorry if this explanation doesnât make sense lmao)
SAME I LOVE IT SM ITS THE FIRST SONG I PLAYED WHEN I GOT THE GAME
Yesss I love it too the ena cover means the world to me
TO JAIL YOU GO. Ready steady is magical
ALL OF MY FAVORITE SONGS FROM EACH UNIT ARE AT FIRST PLACE HRLP???? so true w opinions all of u
As a Vivid Bad Squad stan, I hate how low you put Flyer and Ready Steady, every Vivid Bad Squad song should be at least a 7 or 8
Jackpot Sad Girl at 12 hurt my mental health
Time to listen to Young Girl A and Lost Umbrella on repeat
Not the Infinitely Grey slander lmao.
Performance-wise it definitely was quite good back in the day... Well given that they killed 25ji and there was a 4 month gap between that and Jackpot Sad Girl and those are the only two event commissioned songs for the group before 0.5 anniv. You don't really have much choices. No I genuinely do not wanna spam the unit songs over and over I'm so tired of them (stop playing A Future Written as Regret every Vlive sobs)
Story-wise this ties so hard with Ena's set ESPECIALLY with Nomad. But without the story to hinge on the song is pretty straightforward artist anxiety and moral crisis (ie. Is it really bad to draw for attention) but that's just my take.
It is pretty good, they definitely could perform it better these days
Also yes the fountain sounds at the beginning is horrid I pretend it does not exist
Why is close to grey the last song that song slaps beat wise đ (I so agree with you with moonlight though that song just vibes)
i agree with the [1] comment, it definitely does sound nostalgic
7:32 nah bro i actually like that oneđ i love itđ
the âit reminds me of mario kartâ got me rolling on the floor laughing
I completely agree on Top 3 Nightcord songs those are my favourites
i love how if was actually the highest rated mmj song, and the haruka complements!!! i always thought that haruka's cover was really elegant and i'm glad everyone agreed.
whoever said once upon a dream is good ily âčïž
Theres a lot of Lâs but also some Wâs.
Mid ranking but nice effort đ€đ»đ€đ»đ€đ»đ€đ»
Why do everybody hate ready steady so much? Its one of my favs đ
when what kind of ending do you want came in 8th i think i died cause i love tuyu songs so much and its one of my favorite wxs songs if not fav pjsekai songs đ
actually nvm 88 got 1st im not mad at yall anymore
I literally love almost all of niigo's and wxs's commissioned songs I can't with what you guys rated đ PLEASE WHY IS CLOSE TO GRAY, ONCE UPON A DREAM, JACKPOT SAD GIRL, WORLD HASN'T EVEN STARTED YET SO LOW. *I CRY TO THEM SOMETIMES* I CAN'T đ ALSO WHY IS KANADETOMOSUSORA SO HIGH!?
atleast I agree with all the 1# songs (although some others are _my_ 1# because yea opinions differ but I don't disagree)
because kanadetomosusora best
@@wrhgjjbj it's boring.
When it comes to "Close to gray" I never really liked the full sekai cover but the single Ena's cover? I felt like it was made for her absolutely perfectly.
1 being in top 1 we love to see it
Honestly valid, all I have to say
Finally!!! Nijiiro stories gets the love it deserves!!! It is so underrated and low in so many peoples list đđđ
The Wall slander
The wall and voices are tied 1st they are SO FEELđ
m-made to order is really good w-wdymđ
i was screaming and crying at all of m's ratings WHY DO YOU HATE EMU AND MINORI !!!!!! (/lh)
17:48 âa classic, and a fun song to playâ that is the most ai bot npc work project in front of a stadium 2000s advertisement sounding comment ever
æ„æŹäșșăźç§ăăăăăšăšăŠăèȘăăȘăă§ăăă©äžćŻ§ăȘäșăŻäŒăăăŸăăđ
I love Kanarese Tomosusora and IDSMILE
MIRAI AT FIRST WHAT!? ILY GUYS OMG
ya'lls rankings for jackpot sad girl and saisei hurt but bug and idsmile made up for it
the mmj slander đđđ also kimi no and rad dogs imo should be rated higher.
the piano and violin solo within rad dogs rly shares the testament of toya's story and his journey to VBS - gives chills every time
i'm someone who knows japanese, and kimi no yoru's lyrics is sob-causing. also during the full cover, mizuki gets choked up in the second pre-chorus. hits rly deep.
all my fav songs got 1 except cinema o: but ive been abig mirao fan rn
EEEEE CANT WAIT FOR BUG ON EN!!!!!
kanade had the best opinions !!!
NO WAY I LITERALLY THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY PERSON EVER TO LOVE NIJIRO STORIES SM THAT ITS MY FAV OF ALL TIMEđ„čđ„čđ„č