Fine Blizzard, You Win | 17 Years of Hints That We MISSED!

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 4. 09. 2024
  • Over 17 years, Blizzard have actually been telling us what future expansions were...
    Want some more lore? Check out our Lorewalking podcast: / 51683820
    Twitter: / bellulargaming
    Join our Discord! / discord
    Our game studio's website: www.coffeeboxg...

Komentáře • 709

  • @BellularGaming
    @BellularGaming  Před 3 lety +35

    Want some more lore? Check out our Lorewalking podcast: www.patreon.com/posts/51683820

    • @goblinounours
      @goblinounours Před 3 lety +2

      One little thing : Raden in Throne of Thunder raid had wounds on his body. Look at the textures of the wounds.
      It's the same moving texture as the anima you see in the vats around the golem encounter of the same raid.
      Coincidence? I think not.

    • @vuurvoske
      @vuurvoske Před 3 lety

      Will this be available on spotify too?

    • @pugernoufer
      @pugernoufer Před 3 lety

      It would be awesome if you and Matt could talk towards the camera, instead of at each other. It makes the viewer feel as if you're not including us at all. Just my 2 cents.

    • @andrejjelcic3675
      @andrejjelcic3675 Před 3 lety +1

      End time Sylvanas fight is a hint to her fight coming in 9.1 She drops a bow and a cloak in the next raid she will also drop a bow and item for back. She says: Watch heathens as Death surounds you. ... Rising into the sky as the second portion of the fight begins. She has eight ghouls serving her like her eight remaining Valkyr.

    • @jordan.trahanov
      @jordan.trahanov Před 3 lety +1

      Ever got into one of the Soulgrinder portals in Frostfire Ridge? When you enter one of these and kill all of the mobs that spawn... the portal to exit the scenario is named "Exit the Shadowlands"... weird :)

  • @kharnthebetrayer181
    @kharnthebetrayer181 Před 3 lety +1590

    The poop collecting quest back in TBC Nagrand was hinting at the current state of the game

    • @hz2035
      @hz2035 Před 3 lety +23

      KEKW

    • @elonmusk8603
      @elonmusk8603 Před 3 lety +27

      And the one in wotlk where the guy blows up the outhouse?

    • @ninacuk
      @ninacuk Před 3 lety +8

      ROTFLMAO

    • @Suicidalsheep
      @Suicidalsheep Před 3 lety +10

      **WoD enters the chat.*

    • @bryaneberly3588
      @bryaneberly3588 Před 3 lety +16

      Oh, look, it's an original thought about hating a game they keep playing.

  • @sharlockshacolmes9381
    @sharlockshacolmes9381 Před 3 lety +210

    The thing with wow lore is that it's impossible to be sure if it's really well planned in advance or just if they just leave scraps of story everywhere to then cobble them up together when they need to improvise a new story beat.

    • @matthewkudray4840
      @matthewkudray4840 Před 3 lety +45

      They 1000% just cobble it together with how many retcons they have

    • @nevermore7285
      @nevermore7285 Před 3 lety +5

      @@matthewkudray4840 They honestly don’t have many retcons. They leave a lot of mysteries and a lot of things open ended so they can tack more on and leave gaps for them to fill.

    • @sharlockshacolmes9381
      @sharlockshacolmes9381 Před 3 lety +19

      @@nevermore7285 they literally retconned the whole burning crusade, they may not be numerous but when they retcon something they retcon it hard.

    • @Grounders10
      @Grounders10 Před 3 lety +19

      As a writer that's... not far off how things tend to go. You might have a vague plan, but after a certain point you're looking back at what's been done before and going "So... what bits and pieces have I left behind that have implications I didn't consider before?" Admittedly, this can go well, or terribly. Really depends on the skill and creativity of the writer in question.

    • @sharlockshacolmes9381
      @sharlockshacolmes9381 Před 3 lety +2

      @@Grounders10 Yhea I get that the difference is that when you write something it's better to ave at least a vague idea of where your story ends. Whe you see Warcraft 1 or even WoW Vanilla you don't expect that the story is goign to end in a 6 way galactic war against demigods, that more what you expect from a final fantasy game. And that's clearly because since quite some tie now they don't seem to know exactly where they are going.

  • @BrianHitchner
    @BrianHitchner Před 3 lety +200

    Another link between the Mogu and the Shadowlands? The Divine Bell. It is: "A bell cast from the maker's flesh, shaped by stars' fire, and bound by the breath of darkest shadow." We know from Kyrian questlines that their vespers can be misused to debilitate and generate doubt. "The bell’s screaming voice struck fear and doubt into the hearts of the Emperor's enemies" - this line is describing the Divine Bell.
    Also, the pandaren created the Harmonic Mallet to change the Divine Bell's tone. "When they struck the bell with the mallet, the monks were able to create pure harmony". I see nothing but a direct similarities between the Divine Bell, the Harmonic Mallet, and the vespers and mallets the Kyrian use. If you combine this with the Anima knowledge the Mogu had... it certainly raises some interesting questions.

    • @smthng
      @smthng Před 3 lety +17

      Excellent find, dude. I just hope it doesn't mean we'll get a whole Mogu exp in like 2032

    • @pirojfmifhghek566
      @pirojfmifhghek566 Před 3 lety +30

      @@smthng Patch 16.1: Journey to the Bottom of the Barrel

    • @IBISMK1
      @IBISMK1 Před 3 lety +2

      Bravo dude, good find!

    • @emcrae4764
      @emcrae4764 Před 3 lety +1

      I mean, you COULD BE RIGHT?!! wow

    • @SM-vm6xr
      @SM-vm6xr Před 3 lety +1

      Wow mate. Couldn't agree more. That definitely raises questions.

  • @mattf9737
    @mattf9737 Před 3 lety +141

    I see it as less foreshadowing, and more shoe-horning after the fact.

    • @MastaGambit
      @MastaGambit Před 3 lety +6

      Yeah there's kind of a point at which foreshadowing stops feeling like foreshadowing when the wait for the payoff has been too long lol

    • @valeclaw1697
      @valeclaw1697 Před 3 lety +1

      A lot of it is also kinda vague to begin with, deathwing being believed dead for a time but never really was wasn't exclusive to that mentioned quest for example.

    • @pogo8050
      @pogo8050 Před 3 lety

      @@valeclaw1697 anyone with basic comprehension skills would know deathwing was destined to show up at some point. Be it through “he was always alive” or “no he’s a zombie”. There was no way Deathwing would never return

  • @thenerdbeast7375
    @thenerdbeast7375 Před 3 lety +43

    Lei Shen really was a villain of many talents.
    Wielded titanic power from consuming the heart of a titan watcher.
    Was up to all that anima business with golems and fleshcrafting.
    Even dabbled in old god powers with the Sha.

    • @throrgrim6844
      @throrgrim6844 Před 3 lety +2

      @Valyron90 so they just made him the personification of the horde? ok. what's wrong with that? garrosh is the only horde character i respect. he didn't pretend the horde were good guys.

    • @hannoverfist5628
      @hannoverfist5628 Před 3 lety +7

      @Valyron90 …..‘‘twas just lazy writing……they had an arch nemesis with zero previous mention…on a newly discovered realm/ continent……. Making Garrosh the end boss just let them avoid telling Lei-shins backstory…..he’ll they barely wrote any panda lore….. they really could have made an amazing character…….just didn’t try

  • @realofficialbrandon
    @realofficialbrandon Před 3 lety +170

    Everyone knew deathwing was alive prior to cata, he was never confirmed dead, people just thought he was trapped on outland

    • @GregHafer
      @GregHafer Před 3 lety +22

      I thought he was dead considering I killed him in Warcraft 2 and watched his body explode.

    • @ToyokaX
      @ToyokaX Před 3 lety +9

      IIRC, In the book triology War of the Ancients, I'm pretty sure it's written that he's located in Deepholm along with the Dragon Soul and he finally escapes during Cata when he's done being put back together by his goblin minions.

    • @MrFox1231
      @MrFox1231 Před 3 lety +19

      About outland black dragons... Still a bit annoyed that Sabellian have never been brought up again. One of Deathwings sons and he has a probable consort. Just doing nothing, in outland for years.

    • @realofficialbrandon
      @realofficialbrandon Před 3 lety

      @@ToyokaX War of the Ancients happened a very long time before Warcraft 2 though, during War2, Deathwing was helping out the Horde but the last time I read War of the Ancients trilogy it was like 2008 lol so I may be missing something

    • @realofficialbrandon
      @realofficialbrandon Před 3 lety

      @@GregHafer lmao yeah; true, a lil puff of orange fire

  • @jonatankapral4816
    @jonatankapral4816 Před 3 lety +144

    He manages to have 2 shirts in one video. Asmon could learn.

    • @yerac8430
      @yerac8430 Před 3 lety +1

      I thought I saw 3, representing 3 eras of wow

  • @maxmustermann146
    @maxmustermann146 Před 3 lety +66

    Regarding stuff featured in Vanilla: When you level through the starting zone in classic as a forsaken, most of the Apothecarys you do quests for are quite outspoken about how the plague they are in the process of developing will eventually be used against ALL living. And that this is the plan of the banshee queen.
    Later at wrathgate one of them even tries to fulfill this mission but I think it was too early and so Sylvannas helps the horde

    • @devilskiss8421
      @devilskiss8421 Před 3 lety +14

      Its not foreshadowing its just remembering the plot that you started

    • @ferocis2255
      @ferocis2255 Před 3 lety

      @@devilskiss8421 Good to know you work for blizzard, so tell me what's coming next?

  • @TheJohnney07
    @TheJohnney07 Před 3 lety +206

    DK starting zone had you ported to the “shadowlands” to receive a undead horse.

    • @Zhanrock
      @Zhanrock Před 3 lety +55

      The wraith Walk ability that has existed since legion explicitly mentions "Stepping into the Shadowlands" as part of its' flavor text for DKs.

    • @corypopowich7046
      @corypopowich7046 Před 3 lety +27

      Shadowlands as a concept was well established long, long, long before Shadowlands as an expansion came about.

    • @aaronyayger
      @aaronyayger Před 3 lety +1

      @@corypopowich7046 Legion doesn't really count as "long, long before" lmao.

    • @corypopowich7046
      @corypopowich7046 Před 3 lety +22

      @@aaronyayger ...It was long long long before Legion lmao. As far back as vanilla. Even further, beyond into the old RTS games iirc.

    • @wrigglenight93
      @wrigglenight93 Před 3 lety +10

      They called it the "Realm of Shadows". It was pretty clearly a stub of an idea at the time

  • @ilikepiedontu
    @ilikepiedontu Před 3 lety +52

    One thing that isn’t being talked about it the bfa brawlers guild ending. There is a piece of paper that is given to you after completing it between two ethereals. One line reads Movers of Fate. We are changing the very order of the universe.

    • @regularspecial1
      @regularspecial1 Před 3 lety +5

      I assume those are e supposed to be brokers

    • @ilikepiedontu
      @ilikepiedontu Před 3 lety +1

      @@regularspecial1 Thats what i was thinking too, probably meant to be but for the sake of keeping shadowlands secret it was intentionally left a little vauge.

    • @djbrandao
      @djbrandao Před 3 lety

      Do you guys remember that daily in TBC with the ethereals that you had to phase void/death to actually see the enemies (more ethereals and some mana rays)? Maybe their lore wasn't entirelly established back then when they were conceived as ethereals but I too se a relation about them and the brokers. In legion there's also an ethereal who tells us not to trust some or many of them (I believe someone actually asks if one specific ethereal is inside the Draenei's ship to Argus and that you should be vigillant about his presence, but can't remember for sure).

    • @clogs4956
      @clogs4956 Před 3 lety

      Oh, heck: the Auditors of Reality?

  • @arishiasol
    @arishiasol Před 3 lety +45

    If I remember correctly, the questline to tame Gara the spirit beast in WoD makes hunters travel to the shadowlands.
    It also happens in the DK intro to tame a horse.

    • @thomasboys7216
      @thomasboys7216 Před 3 lety +8

      You can also add the Uuna pet questline onto there as well. Rumour has it, or rather the WoW Secret Finding discord, that there is some hidden interaction with Uuna and the Shadowlands.

    • @MrFox1231
      @MrFox1231 Před 3 lety +5

      But back then shadowlands was practically just Azeroth/Draenor but everyone are ghosts, and maybe the occasional corporeal blue dragon.

    • @tzoanast1061
      @tzoanast1061 Před 3 lety +7

      There is a difference between the "Shadow realm" "Spirit Realm" and "Shadowlands".

  • @themysticidiot
    @themysticidiot Před 3 lety +46

    These were all amazing hints, but the most mind blowing thing was the shirt change at the end!

  • @sethbrodie
    @sethbrodie Před 3 lety +106

    How could you forget the giant turtle skeleton with the Pandarian structure on it's back? On the shores of the Swamp of Sorrows?

    • @copyninja8756
      @copyninja8756 Před 3 lety +3

      Easter egg

    • @azahel542
      @azahel542 Před 3 lety +21

      Those were everywhere, even in some quests in darkshore.

    • @MrFox1231
      @MrFox1231 Před 3 lety +11

      Those were minions of the old Horde. "Giant Turtle (Warcraft II)"

    • @Klaus1871
      @Klaus1871 Před 3 lety +4

      There was also an eastern style bridge in Swamp of Sorrows I think

  • @Tommyov
    @Tommyov Před 3 lety +32

    You forget the caverns on time cataclysm bosses. The Tyrande fight where she goes crazy with elune magic... that's nightwarrior stuff, the dark environment = shadowlands?
    Slyvannas was also a boss there and her place was fillled with burnt trees... so we had hints since cataclysm that she was going to burn a world tree!

  • @anubis24354
    @anubis24354 Před 3 lety +66

    I'll hand it to them, they're good at finding things to tie in that existed before.

    • @beardedbastard4990
      @beardedbastard4990 Před 3 lety +8

      Lol they tie things to the past: people make fun of them.
      They do new things: people make fun of them.
      I'm convinced WoW fans just want the same expansion stretched out for the life of wow.

    • @Kylora2112
      @Kylora2112 Před 3 lety +7

      @@beardedbastard4990 Fans: "WE WANT SOMETHING DIFFERENT!!!"
      Blizz: *makes something different*
      Fans: "NO! THAT'S TOO DIFFERENT! WE WANT SOMETHING MORE LIKE THE LAST EXPANSION!!!"
      Blizz: *introduces things similar to the last expansion*
      Fans: "WHY DOES BLIZZ KEEP REUSING CONTENT!!!"

    • @frostdracohardstyle
      @frostdracohardstyle Před 3 lety +3

      @@beardedbastard4990 Its not always what you do, its how. They do a lot of things and people tend to only focus on the negative. This has nothing to do with WoW. Its human nature.

    • @nomeatbag
      @nomeatbag Před 3 lety

      @@frostdracohardstyle i agree, same thing is happening with the pokemon franchise and i dont even played a single pokemon game.

    • @beardedbastard4990
      @beardedbastard4990 Před 3 lety

      @@Kylora2112 basically

  • @atibamaule
    @atibamaule Před 3 lety +2

    In TBC, when you meet Arator Windrunner in the inn at Honor Hold he predicted his Father Turalyon's death.
    To us, the player, he says Quote "I was only an infant when my father was deployed to this wasteland. All that I have ever known of him is what others have told me. Do your dreams change, ? Mine do not. I have one dream: A crimson skyline envelops me as Legion, numbering beyond comprehension, battle in the distance. I kneel before the body of a man, presumably my father, and weep. As he is gasping for air, his body wholly crushed, he whispers something. Despite every effort, I am unable to hear what he is trying to tell me."

  • @Piromysl359
    @Piromysl359 Před 3 lety +174

    I don't think it was foreshadowing, but rather they created lore based on those hints.

    • @Akabans999
      @Akabans999 Před 3 lety +20

      I would bet they skimed trough varios fan fictions took wath they liked put it all in blender and after mixing it all pretended that they are very original & wath not

    • @ahtilah1194
      @ahtilah1194 Před 3 lety +7

      Actually, his recent telling of the Burning Crusade Lore video of what we knew at the time, reinforces this. They had two conflicting ideas on who corrupted Sargeras, being the Draenei and the Dreadlords on their own official website back in Burning Crusade.

    • @ahtilah1194
      @ahtilah1194 Před 3 lety +11

      @@Akabans999 You set yourself up for disappointment if you ever expect an original telling of any story. We all are inspired by past works, there is very little in the sense of innovation when it comes to story telling. Instead, we all build upon and add our own personalities into them.

    • @NomicFin
      @NomicFin Před 3 lety +5

      I think it's likely a mix of both. A lot of the stuff seems like they built on concepts they had introduced in earlier expansions but weren't originally designed to lead to anything in particular, but there's also some stuff that does feel like the writers already knew what would be happening in a future expansion (or later in the same expansion) and were putting hints of it in the game. Like Wrathion wanting to prepare the world for the Legion's return was a pretty obvious sign that the Legion would indeed return in a later expansion.
      After Cata Blizz is stated to have started planning ahead on the lore, so at that point they should know what the next expansion would be, and even have a rough idea of the expansion after that, and could start setting things up before it hit.

    • @Sykretts
      @Sykretts Před 3 lety +8

      Yeah, no game company thinks about their stories 10 years in advance. The most they plan for is 2-3 years in advance. Revisiting old lore tidbits to expand upon is a good practice, and blizzard follows it as much as possible. Calling it "foreshadowing" is the mother of all stretches.

  • @gemini_starr
    @gemini_starr Před 3 lety +6

    I can’t believe this. They’re working backwards. There’s no way they were thinking forward so many years in advanced when they keep “rotating” writers. They took random old content and then built on that.

  • @andreasnorberg8285
    @andreasnorberg8285 Před 3 lety +19

    They shit out plot threads left and right and some they expand on and some they drop. blizzard has been doing the shotgun method for a long time. Write 100 vague random things today and then stitch 1 of those things together with whatever you decide to write in 5, 10 or 15 years.
    The "hinting" doesnt seem as amazing when you realise they are hinting at literally anything and everything.

    • @CogniVision
      @CogniVision Před 3 lety +2

      Exactly.

    • @Marcustheseer
      @Marcustheseer Před 3 lety +1

      not realy those hints are very spicific youre just salty you didnt see what they hinted at.

    • @addiematt5736
      @addiematt5736 Před 3 lety +1

      @@Marcustheseer it's as if these other people think a whole ass body of work that's spanned 17 years could be written down in one teabreak or 4-months worth of rummination. Clearly out of their league with how writing and revisions on this scale work.

    • @qpSubZeroqp
      @qpSubZeroqp Před 3 lety

      Exactly

    • @Marcustheseer
      @Marcustheseer Před 3 lety +1

      @@addiematt5736 i think its very impressive how they managed to tie it all together over 17 years of wow,there is stuf out there thats done allot worse.

  • @marcosvmsdm
    @marcosvmsdm Před 3 lety +10

    At 14:00, even before the Cataclysm xpac, Yogg Saron in Lich King say that in his death:
    "Your fate is sealed. The end of days is finally upon you and ALL who inhabit this miserable little seedling. Uulwi ifis halahs gag erh'ongg w'ssh."

    • @djbrandao
      @djbrandao Před 3 lety +1

      11.0 is actullay within the lines "Uulwi ifis halahs gag erh'ongg w'ssh."

  • @MarkusWernig
    @MarkusWernig Před 3 lety +19

    after the cataclysm happened there was a rather large tree stump or root near Rut'theran which clearly showed the silhouette of a pandaren brewmaster. but maybe it was just me seeing things

  • @thefinalskarm1754
    @thefinalskarm1754 Před 3 lety +8

    I definitely remember "heh it's just like arthas walking into lorderon"
    The moment i saw Uther turn to Anduin i knew, yep this boy corrupt.

  • @Margonite
    @Margonite Před 3 lety +31

    Aaaw you missed The Frozen Throne's tower defense bonus level to actually meet and unlock the Brewmaster hero for its following mission!

  • @Brittway
    @Brittway Před 3 lety +8

    Going back to the Mogu and anima, they were harvesting a keeper, meaning that the Titans had procured that method of creating "life" at some point from the Shadowlands. Either that or that anima is a resource in other realms of existence and isn't exclusively from the Shadowlands.

    • @rodrigobogado8756
      @rodrigobogado8756 Před 3 lety +4

      Blizz confirmed in an interview that the anima used by the mogu is not the same thing as the anima in SL

    • @willc3272
      @willc3272 Před 3 lety +4

      @@rodrigobogado8756 What about the golem that looks the same?

    • @jtowensbyiii6018
      @jtowensbyiii6018 Před 3 lety +1

      Anima is confirmed by the shadowlands to be in every realm of existence as we literallytravel to multiple realms in one of the dungeons

  • @ilikepiedontu
    @ilikepiedontu Před 3 lety +72

    Let’s think about Anduin and Bolvars role here. Remember back in classic when they were side by side in life at Stormwind? They’ll be together again in Death. A king and Reagent reunited through death.

    • @Czeron01
      @Czeron01 Před 3 lety

      I was thinking of this the other day!

  • @Juicelot
    @Juicelot Před 3 lety +14

    I think we're 100% getting the Necromancer class straight after Shadowlands. If you think about it, we have no way to control the undead in Azeroth now that the Helm of Domination is destroyed. What better way to introduce the necromancer class?

    • @Mejoche
      @Mejoche Před 3 lety +3

      Don’t death knights control the scourge...

    • @Arakius1
      @Arakius1 Před 3 lety

      But we now know where spirits go. Would it not be even worse to raise dead now?

    • @Arakius1
      @Arakius1 Před 3 lety +1

      Also China.

    • @Joe_Potts
      @Joe_Potts Před 3 lety

      @@Arakius1 technically since we know souls are currently flowing into the Maw, i.e. Hell, raising them would probably be a bit more merciful. Would you rather take maggots or eternal torture? on second thought maybe the maw is better....

    • @lancebockelman8756
      @lancebockelman8756 Před 3 lety

      Lock/DK have long since taken any function a necro would have

  • @Tijuanabill
    @Tijuanabill Před 3 lety +5

    It would make sense that new people writing the story after the original people left, would look to the older info to try and flesh something out from it. I have no illusions that Blizzard thought this whole story out in advance, and are just following the script as written. A script that never leaked, over the course of two decades, incidentally. If nothing else, the story would be better than this, if it were all planned out.

  • @TaliesinMyrddin
    @TaliesinMyrddin Před 3 lety +20

    17:40 my headcanon is that Jaina read about Teldrassil burning in the set of Krasus' prophecies she was given when she briefly led the Kirin Tor, and that's why she wasn't super shocked when she heard about it in the pre-BfA cinematic

  • @Margonite
    @Margonite Před 3 lety +18

    Isn't there an NPC in the questline "The Prodigal Lich" (vanilla Silverpine/classic) that foreshadows Kel'thuzad's return? He's passed off as an old cray-cray hermit craving some book but now that I see this video it all comes back to me.

    • @guyriley3452
      @guyriley3452 Před 3 lety +1

      lmao which time are you talking about him coming back? because hasn't it been like 3-4 times now lore wise, not tryna be a troll just tryna be an ass :P

    • @Margonite
      @Margonite Před 3 lety

      @@guyriley3452 well technically we ran into him in Maldraxxus! But yes, you're right

  • @janb
    @janb Před 3 lety +10

    6:20 "few months ago".. Actual critical hit on my soul!

  • @onyroo
    @onyroo Před 3 lety +5

    There’s also a distinctive Pandaren bridge in Swamp of Sorrows that’s been there forever.

  • @danp4313
    @danp4313 Před 3 lety +4

    Another little tease is in Ashenvale, one of the quests to kill the demons gives you rings as a reward all named "xxxxx of Argas" and I think its cool and funny too that clearly there was some hint there that demons came from Argus, but Blizz just didn't know how to go about the spelling haha!

  • @cultist1762
    @cultist1762 Před 3 lety +7

    Yet wow showed in the Beast Mastery hunter weapon in Legion that Yogg'Sauron was still alive then declared that all the Old Gods were dead after N'zoth was defeated.

  • @Saiku
    @Saiku Před 3 lety +36

    You mean 17 years of retcons.

    • @kylesmith564
      @kylesmith564 Před 3 lety +1

      dont comment if your not gonna watch the video

    • @jamestomlin5525
      @jamestomlin5525 Před 3 lety

      @@kylesmith564 he's entitled to his opinion, my gnomie

  • @rishis5860
    @rishis5860 Před 3 lety +2

    Don't forget the Death Knight artifact power nodes where you see the Lich King talking to you about you always being somebodies tool or instrument. There's a few of them throughout Legion.

  • @onyroo
    @onyroo Před 3 lety +2

    The Inky Black Potion, which is my favorite item in game, is made with 2 parts from the Shadowlands.

  • @ImaLiveQ
    @ImaLiveQ Před 3 lety +36

    The secrets that wow does is amazing. It's always exciting to see the community get together for these type of lore nuggets

    • @MikeTall88
      @MikeTall88 Před 3 lety +10

      The "secrets" are created when they create new lore though.
      Makes it less impressive when they were not planned.

    • @SM-vm6xr
      @SM-vm6xr Před 3 lety

      @Nana Well said friend. It actually is very delightful.

  • @cainabel6356
    @cainabel6356 Před 3 lety +19

    The Draenai and the Broken were the same. You have that confirmed in BC and Legion. When one of the Broken, a Draenai corrupted by the Fel, responded to being one of Draenai. It was confirmed before that, in BC. They just retconned it.
    Right now, Blizzard is into retconning everything, or just destroying everything.

  • @moscanaveia
    @moscanaveia Před 3 lety +5

    Shadowlands had been an endearing feature that provides depth to the lore since forever. There is the whole Sylvanas story where she waltzes through Hell after committing suicide, but DK's also visit the Shadowlands to pick up their deathcharger in the starting quest. They call it the "realm of shadows", sure, but it is a place of death where the horse you had sacrificed gets sent to, and you have to steal it from one of the dark riders of the realm. There is also the quest to find Azuregos in the Horde's questline in Azshara. Neither are particularly teasy or foundational for Shadowlands lore, but are somewhat establishing of the role the realm of the dead had in lore for the longest time

  • @laertesindeed
    @laertesindeed Před 3 lety +4

    There was yet another huge hint that you missed from the Mists of Pandaria expansion. When you do the Throne of Thunder raid and unlock the Ra-Den raid encounter....then defeat Ra-Den, he has some lines of dialogue before he disappears. He says, and I quote....... "But there is a yawning chasm of darkness beneath you, mortals. Vast, endless, and all-consuming. I do not believe that you can correct this doomed course. But...you have earned the right to try. Farewell."
    Which is clearly a hint for their idea of the Shadowlands and the Maw. Maybe even an implied reference to "correct this doomed course" being something about "The Purpose" which is still being revealed slowly.

  • @TomEpQm
    @TomEpQm Před 3 lety +1

    There's also very distinctly Pandaren wreckage on the shores in the Swamp of Sorrows back in vanilla

  • @irtehdar2446
    @irtehdar2446 Před 3 lety

    In vanilla there was a bridge in swamp of sorrows being obviously of pandaren design. Its related to a treasurehunt quest chain that would take you all over the world. The quest text for that chain even states that this bridge is of foreign design.
    Those giant turtle skeletons are pretty common across the original 2 continents. They are all along the coastlines.

  • @Zaradorian
    @Zaradorian Před 3 lety +9

    I dont know how long I've been waiting for someone to bring up the anima from MoP

    • @SlarkeSSC
      @SlarkeSSC Před 3 lety

      The MoP anima isn't related to SL anima at all, Danuser specified that in an interview.

  • @key1862
    @key1862 Před 3 lety +1

    The hard mode of Darkvein in Nathria doesn't have an Anima Golem in the encounter, or spawn one, you just have to bring the pet that drops from the boss and have it out when the encounter starts. It then gathers the anima in the area and after a certain time grows into a full size Anima golem.

    • @kevinglusing3797
      @kevinglusing3797 Před 2 lety

      This is true, but I'd posit that the fact you CAN get it to do this is because of their shared history. Comments above mention that Lei Shin was dead for a while before the Zandalari brought him back, and he was super prideful. It's likely he was being reformed in Revendreth during his time in the Shadowlands and came back with the knowledge of their anima such that he could create the golems.

  • @Endslikecrazy
    @Endslikecrazy Před 3 lety

    I think you might have missed one from vanilla but it could just be me and i wouldn't mind if anyone can prove my wrong with some actual hard proof and not just mindcanon.
    The quest to awaken the NPC in the wailing caverns has some interesting bits or text in there, not just that.
    The flower (corrupted flower) you take from the wailing caverns which is thought to be the cause of why the NPC was in a "coma" in there, you bring this flower to archdruid hamuul (if i remember correctly) in thunder bluff and the moment you get there and deliver it hamuul he asks you how did you get it and continues on to say something along the lines off:
    Dont concern yourself with this plant or the corruption, it is something that is completely outside of our grasps (i assume in terms of power and standing within the factions and just in the general world) and that we should let hamuul handle it and to never bother thinking about it again.
    And then we continue to deal with the exact same type of corruption in val'sharah and the dream in legion.

  • @mykulpierce
    @mykulpierce Před 3 lety +2

    The Forsaken potentially betraying the horde is basically in the Forsaken introduction.
    Which ultimately plays out already in wrath of the lich King's wrathgate

    • @AnatharFrost013
      @AnatharFrost013 Před 3 lety +1

      True I mean a good 90 % of the Forsaken quests in both Classic & BC involved perfecting the Blight/Plague of Undeath all of which foreshadowed the betrayal at the Wrathgate

  • @TherealDavos
    @TherealDavos Před 3 lety +1

    This is maybe far fetched, but in vanilla, Hakkar yells on aggro: Pride heralds the end of your world.. And in mist, pride and the sha of pride itself was a huge thing. Probably just a coincidence

  • @ub3rfr3nzy94
    @ub3rfr3nzy94 Před 3 lety +2

    Right, time to make a follow up video finding all the hints we have now for 12.0

  • @losophy4588
    @losophy4588 Před 3 lety +9

    There is a Reliquary of Souls cube in the Maw. Did any1 here noticed it as well?

  • @Knownasnemoo
    @Knownasnemoo Před 3 lety

    In vanilla wow theres a dead turtle with a pandaren-like hut on top of it, found on Mist's Edge in the north coast of Darkshore. There is even ropes from the head of the turtle skull to the shell. Theres also a small bridge in Swamp of Sorrows that is very ornate and looks like it is designed by no common race on Kalimdor or Eastern Kingdoms.

  • @superplatinum
    @superplatinum Před 3 lety +81

    Blizzard: and for my next trick i pull 17 years out of my own arse

    • @Nyxnik
      @Nyxnik Před 3 lety +1

      ty for the laugh ^^

    • @deployed246
      @deployed246 Před 3 lety

      You just described every neverending franchise.

    • @azahel542
      @azahel542 Před 3 lety +1

      Yeah, a lot of the hints mentioned here just show how the lore they had planned was quite different. Hell, if you look at the character descriptions for Legion alone you see how the lore direction on that expansion alone was different from what happened.
      Worse yet, the hints point to something much better than what we ended up with...

  • @joshuadoehr5468
    @joshuadoehr5468 Před 3 lety +13

    The lore is so rich and clever. Such a shame competitive culture within the game dominates and all the dynamics of the game supports that way to play the game. I used to love the content and play the game with folks who were really sharp on the lore and we actually looked forward to content revealing the story. i don't know anyone who actually follows or cares about anything other than progression in the gameplay which used to be the bonus and not the center of the game.

    • @Rosie_Bellle
      @Rosie_Bellle Před 3 lety +6

      I've always done LFR raids just for the cynematics and lore tidbits. I usually avoid cutscenes from current content that I haven't seen yet because I'd rather experience them as they were meant to be in game. Just makes them better in my opinion.

    • @dpalmerama
      @dpalmerama Před 2 lety +1

      @@Rosie_Bellle Me too! I've always loved the lore of WoW and been more interested in enjoying the story more than having the best gear etc. In fact, someitmes I go on lower alts to work through the loremaster achievement so I can wait till it's easier to progress in the later game.

    • @Rosie_Bellle
      @Rosie_Bellle Před 2 lety +1

      @@dpalmerama Yea..... I'm a bit of an altaholic >.>

  • @omarcomming722
    @omarcomming722 Před 3 lety +2

    I mean, most of these only look like hints retroactively because Blizzard is reusing terminology and half-assed concepts from previous expansions :D Willing to bet that Shadowmoon clan Shadow Lands had nothing to do with SL as it is now, same with Anima golems in ToT.

    • @omarcomming722
      @omarcomming722 Před 3 lety +1

      @@notTheUsualG Yeah but I meant it wasn't a hint for the Shadowlands as we have them now, or a foreshadowing for the expansion.

  • @joshkrause2977
    @joshkrause2977 Před 3 lety +2

    Don’t forget in wrath of the Lich King deathnight mounts come from the Shadowlands.

  • @Serilaene
    @Serilaene Před 3 lety +1

    22:50
    Soradormi's eventual/possible death isn't what drove Nozdormu crazy to begin with. It was seeing his own death.

  • @IprenKills
    @IprenKills Před 3 lety +18

    There is a quest in vanilla, in the Barrens, where you literally find "Chen's Empty Keg" and have to return it to a brewmaster. Pretty cool!

    • @darchendon7926
      @darchendon7926 Před 3 lety +7

      Chen Stormstout was in WC3 frozen throne, helpin out rexxar and rokhan like a bro

  • @zelick0711
    @zelick0711 Před 3 lety

    I am not sure if this has been mentioned before but back in TBC Arator the Redeemer(son to Turalyon and Alleria) in the Honor Hold inn had this to say. "I was only an infant when my father was deployed to this wasteland. All that I have ever known of him is what others have told me. Do your dreams change, ? Mine do not. I have one dream: A crimson skyline envelops me as Legion, numbering beyond comprehension, battle in the distance. I kneel before the body of a man, presumably my father, and weep. As he is gasping for air, his body wholly crushed, he whispers something. Despite every effort, I am unable to hear what he is trying to tell me." Not sure if this has already been fulfilled or if we might have something coming in 10.0 with Turalyon's death.

  • @BaldChimpanzee
    @BaldChimpanzee Před 3 lety +15

    all nice and fancy Michael, but DOES THAT CHANGES EVERYTHING?!

  • @jonathanatwood8303
    @jonathanatwood8303 Před 3 lety +4

    There is a bridge in swamp of sorrow that has a pandarian design

  • @jerry1dc
    @jerry1dc Před 3 lety

    Anduin has been involved with onyxia, wrathion, death wing tbagged storm wind, nzoth’s gaze was more focused on stormwind(everyone said that horrific vision was harder than orgramar), seed of corruption is a spell warlocks have.
    Anduin’s been groomed to go evil for years. He started to crack in bfa.
    My guess is that when Azeroth does wake up she’s a void titan and anduin will be her avatar.

  • @Chunthoor
    @Chunthoor Před 3 lety +1

    There is a clue in BfA that I have only ever seen a video about from a single CZcamsr from Germany.
    In "The Negotiation" video from patch 8.2.5 you can see between second 0:17 - 0:19 how Anduin climbs up the stairs. But if you look closely and compare the model with the model of Arthas from Warcraft 3, you can wonder if it's really Anduin climbing up the tower there.
    I've always wondered why no one ever noticed this, or why no one ever talked about it, but after the events in Shadowlands, I think this "hint" should definitely be taken into consideration.

  • @kevinglusing3797
    @kevinglusing3797 Před 2 lety

    This may be the Mandela effect going on, but I distinctly remember back in the day (as far back as vanilla) there being quests and dialogue around the Shadow Lands when we questioned the existence of the spirit keepers (for resurrection). Somebody said they were heralds and they brought us back to life because as heroes of the world it wasn't our time yet. That Azeroth had a special connection to the Shadowlands (then Shadow Lands) that allowed our souls to come back rather than pass on to be judged. I've tried to discuss this many times at least since before they announced Shadowlands, so I know I'm not just thinking back to the expansion reveal.

  • @atlasthegoon1643
    @atlasthegoon1643 Před 3 lety

    There is an orc on the ledge in shadowmoon valley just before you fly over to the netherdrake area. If you speak to him he mentions not only Ner'zhul but also the shadowlands. This is a BC npc. Thought that was pretty cool!

  • @TheShatarEUisMyHome
    @TheShatarEUisMyHome Před 3 lety +1

    I mean, sure they planned stuff years in advance, but the story progresses like once every 6 months. And the progressions are dramatic, sure, but they don't tell long stories.
    The whole lore could have been written over a weekend.

  • @FratinandMadrik
    @FratinandMadrik Před 3 lety +3

    23:59 I think you forgot to add the visuals of the globe...

  • @AlyxSharkBite-2000
    @AlyxSharkBite-2000 Před 3 lety +4

    The valkyr in the warrior order hall say *I exist in the shadow lands"

    • @shrekofrivia6821
      @shrekofrivia6821 Před 3 lety

      also gorak tul said he will meet us in the blighted lands(probably the bad side of ardenweald) when he was defeated in waycrest manor

  • @Nirual86
    @Nirual86 Před 3 lety

    Part of me wonders how much of that stuff was conscious foreshadowing rather than just random bits of world-building that they actually remembered when it came time to create the next expansion. Any of these visions of the future for one could've just as easily been random ideas they thought of to make things interesting. And its not like the threat of a Legion return was some wild new idea.

  • @Linkman95
    @Linkman95 Před 3 lety

    In a bit of world building, the 3 princes fight in Icecrown has 3 mirror like portals to the princes previous fights, suggesting they had some idea what they wanted venethyr to be

  • @surtfire3280
    @surtfire3280 Před 3 lety

    Another small thing is the DK ability wraith walk added in 7.0 which literally said 'Sidestep into the Shadowlands' in the ability text. So DK's have basically been casually entering the shadowlands since legion.

  • @scottiericker2285
    @scottiericker2285 Před 3 lety +4

    I can't believe u missed guldan speech in night hold

  • @Jackpkmn
    @Jackpkmn Před 3 lety +1

    Literally no one thought bfa was gonna be a strictly faction war expansion. Old god involvement was called on day 1 of its reveal.

  • @reinoldi1097
    @reinoldi1097 Před 3 lety

    Even in classic there are turtles in auberdin ( beach north for example) with turtles and panda looking houses on them.
    And there is a quest for it.
    Quote :
    Description
    More sea turtle remains lie beached along the coastline. This particular set has an abandoned carriage attached to the turtle's shell. Perhaps this creature was driven to the shoreline by unknown beings rather than beaching itself as some of the other remains suggested. Greymist murlocs now make the remains of this creature their home, feasting off the carrion.
    In the carriage, you find a box with strange markings on it; perhaps Gwennyth Bly'Leggonde in Auberdine can make sense of it.

  • @joshuaferguson1200
    @joshuaferguson1200 Před 3 lety

    I remember the manual for WoW, when it talked about the factions and stuff (at least in the battle chest) either directly stated or heavily implied that the forsaken joined the horde, but sylvannas was planning on betraying them at some point.

  • @samwheat2480
    @samwheat2480 Před 3 lety

    I believe there is a similar turtle corpse in Ashenvale, in the naga area of the coast near Blackfathom Depths. This turtle actually has a saddle like attachment to the shell! I saw it while questing in TBC classic and was so shocked.

    • @samwheat2480
      @samwheat2480 Před 3 lety

      It looks like those could be a turtle used by the Orcs in the second war.

  • @ShepMvS
    @ShepMvS Před 3 lety +1

    I think Yogg Saron in LK vision foreshadowing too, not directly but still : "He will learn... no king rules forever; only death is eternal!"

  • @YourSooFakeSauce
    @YourSooFakeSauce Před 3 lety +5

    25:00 I didn't miss a thing Bell. I just saw you changed shirts.

  • @TylerT49
    @TylerT49 Před 3 lety

    Something cool I noticed in TBC prepatch before I decided to quit right before TBC launch: There's construction at the entrance of SW harbor started, with scaffolding on both sides of the wall and dynamite, and speech references towards to by the construction workers. Also Deathwing is referenced in Classic in a book near Chromie.

  • @faznanbadri6854
    @faznanbadri6854 Před 3 lety

    During Maiev's Campaign to chase Illidan, if player skill up The Warden's Blink skill to 1 sec cooldown, we able to blink into secret spot during Underwater Ruin collapse sequence after Illidan absorbed the Eye of Gul'dan, what do we find in the secret spot? A Pandaren Wanderer.
    The game even throw us a bone, giving us multiple units of Huntress so we can light up black spot with Sentinels.

  • @Kevkoss
    @Kevkoss Před 3 lety +10

    Wasn't WoD Ner'zhul representing Void aspect of cosmology?

    • @alexanderrahl7034
      @alexanderrahl7034 Před 3 lety

      Well...
      I don't know where you got that idea.
      There's no way a guy as ugly as him, went to beauty school. Lol

  • @eldritchdonkey6090
    @eldritchdonkey6090 Před 3 lety

    In Vanilla there were apothecaries that were investigating oozes and who talked about them being the blood of old gods, which is interesting because it puts oozes in a different light.
    There was a whole quest line in un'goro and UC about it.

  • @ddis29
    @ddis29 Před 3 lety +1

    pandara got a decently large write up in warcraft d&d. at the release of cataclysm all of the d&d material was made non-canon but it is a fascinating glimps of the lore in an earlier state.

    • @kevinglusing3797
      @kevinglusing3797 Před 2 lety

      And slowly a good portion of it continues to be tweaked/used in a similar fashion coming out over time as recently as this expansion. When you use the anima toy that lets you teleport somewhere random, it can sometimes put you in pandaria on a mountain with a lone pandaren talking about being a sorcerer. :)

  • @Nillami
    @Nillami Před 3 lety

    Hmmm, as I remember, there was one junk item that you could get I think from fishing daily quests back in WotLK, a picture frame with a pandaren on it. I remember it because my friend loves pandarens and back in the day he was an nelf warrior - and back then he already said that once pandarens will be playable he will change to one. On sure he did that :) That one junk item was a thing he kept, he didn't vendor it.

  • @feywinterfox9630
    @feywinterfox9630 Před 3 lety +1

    AWESOME!….now maybe in 20 years we will find out what the deal is with the circle out in the Forest?!

  • @leykosminotauros
    @leykosminotauros Před 3 lety +1

    What about the cataclysm dungeon where we get to fight Jaina (we did that in BfA), Sylvanas (we will do in SL), we saw Tyrande lose faith and fall into darkness (moon warrior) and if I remember correctly Baine which we haven't seen anything yet.

    • @kevinglusing3797
      @kevinglusing3797 Před 2 lety

      Baine watched his homeland get taken twice. Once in Cata with the dungeon and again in the Emerald Nightmare raid. Then he was taken in Shadowlands. Maybe when we come back, Thunderbluff will be gone?

  • @TheAdventureMentor
    @TheAdventureMentor Před 3 lety +1

    7:56 It's funny you mention Admiral Taylor because I just recently discovered his spirit on the outer ring path of Oribos.

  • @_slasherxr8
    @_slasherxr8 Před 3 lety

    out of this entire video im happy i learnt one thing, i always thought we ended up at the Shadowlands but i didint realise they were two seperate words back in WoD , it makes more sense now , Thanks bellular :D

  • @mastarceef4000
    @mastarceef4000 Před 3 lety +1

    There is the Ogre follower Tormmok who talks about Legion and the Gorian Empire when you find him in Gorgrond

  • @Amgarrak
    @Amgarrak Před 3 lety +28

    Bellular: "Well you see they were working on legion at the time during mop, but likely due to the movie they went with wod instead"
    Me: Wow that is actually depressing. So the reason we had one of the worst expansions was literally a movie tie in.

    • @ChainedPhantom
      @ChainedPhantom Před 3 lety +11

      And not even a GOOD movie.

    • @booodka
      @booodka Před 3 lety +1

      Think of it this way, had they placed legion in it's place, then legion would have been considered shit with so much removed content, and legion content was pretty sweet

    • @andromidius
      @andromidius Před 3 lety +1

      @@ChainedPhantom It is frustrating how there were elements that were good. But there were some really bad choices that ruined it all. It should have been a full CGI movie, not a weird mix with... uh... not the best acting?

  • @szeplevente88
    @szeplevente88 Před 3 lety +11

    In classic when you look up the sky above you while you're dead, you can see the swirl above you, is that supposed to be a hint for shadowlands maybe?

  • @harkenrebirth
    @harkenrebirth Před 3 lety

    You also forgot to mention the thing with Medivh where during Legion, we did Karazhan... we see Medivh alive and him sayin.. "It may be simpler to shut a door than pass thru it. But sometimes a step into the unknown is required to break the bonds of fate" It is probably him talking about what would end up hapening at the end of Tomb of Sargeras. Where Illidain opens a portal to the Legion Homeworld. Yes. But where does he flie of to? He doesnt fly out into Azeroth.. But into the Nether. Where? Medivh is an all powerfull being. That is able to fight the avatar of Sargeras with HIM inside of it. Not the remnant fueled by fel we fight in the Tomb of Sargeras. But at the same time... Was this a hint at Shadowlands? The massive hole in the sky.. a doorway into the shadowlands as they may call it. And we dont close it.. We go thru it. .. But That Demon hunter thing.... i remember talking to people about that Demon Hunter order hall globe. But i didnt know what those 2 landmasses were called. Only that i saw some extra land mass on the map for some reason. They just said it was nothing special. Just some error or that it was suposed to be Broken Isles. Even if it didnt look that way to me.

  • @bobjones4427
    @bobjones4427 Před 3 lety

    MoP had tons of lore. There was Ra-den, when you beat him in Throne of Thunder saying "Wait! I am... I am not your enemy. You are powerful, more powerful than he was, even... perhaps you are right. Perhaps there is still hope.
    But there is a yawning chasm of darkness beneath you mortals, vast, endless, and all consuming. I do not believe that you can correct this doomed course.
    But... you have earned the right to try. Farewell." Ra-den could have been referring to the old god N'Zoth. Possibly trying to prevent the resurrection of Y'Shaarj since the titans actually killed Y'Shaarj and Y'Shaarj cursed Pandaria with shadows of his former self.
    Then Wraithion foreshadowed the whole Legion invasion while making the legendary cloak.
    MoP also hinted that Y'Shaarj could possibly come back since the mantid seem to think he/it will come back and will align with Y'Shaarj if/when Y'Shaarj does come back.

  • @HavocHounds1988
    @HavocHounds1988 Před 3 lety

    I noticed the Kul Tiran marines and the Zandalari in Azsuna and had already started thinking those two islands would be added in the near future.

  • @andromidius
    @andromidius Před 3 lety

    I think the more interesting question is - what is in the game now that is teasing future expansions? Sure, its all conjecture. But it might be interesting theorising what's coming further down the road.

  • @SM-vm6xr
    @SM-vm6xr Před 3 lety

    Didn't know junk loot could also contain so much important piece of information. Very much suprised & intrigued by the video & also by the comments where people are mentioning other missed hidden hints like links between the kyrian & the mogu etc.

  • @NomicFin
    @NomicFin Před 3 lety

    The one thing I find very interesting is the Vanilla-era reference to a Legion cult called "Argus Wake". We learned in Legion that Argus was the "capital" of the Burning Legion, but we already learned in TBC that it was the former homeworld of the Eredar/Draenei (and since all the Eredar that didn't leave the planet with Velen got turned into demons, we could infer that Argus would have either been destroyed or taken over by the Legion). But Blizz wasn't planning even one expansion ahead when they made vanilla, so it's weird that this random cult worshipping the Legion just happens to be named after what would later be revealed to be the former homeworld of the two Legion Lords. Especially as far as I can tell Argus is a name Blizz made up.
    Best I can figure is that they used the name in Vanilla because it sounded cool, and then decided to use it as the name of the Draenei/Eredar homeworld in TBC because they had already established the word having some connection to the Legion in Vanilla in that questline.

  • @EVillJr
    @EVillJr Před 3 lety

    There is also a shirt or chest piece that describes elune and other loa being surrounded by void beings that drops in legion.

  • @bluursito7241
    @bluursito7241 Před 3 lety +30

    Blizzard watching this: SHIEEEEEEET DOOOOOOOOD, MAKE THIS CRAP BEFORE THEY FIND OUT IT WAS AN ACCIDENT

    • @Boredonthejob
      @Boredonthejob Před 3 lety +3

      TIL Asmon = Blizz

    • @smthng
      @smthng Před 3 lety +3

      @@Boredonthejob Bobby Kotick whenever he sees a rise in the sub count: WE'RE POPPIN OFF DUUUUUDEEESSS

  • @HavocHounds1988
    @HavocHounds1988 Před 3 lety

    The channel Shinies and Luckydos did a video about the Bloodstones a couple years ago, I recommend checking out their channel. They don't upload videos often, but the ones they have are really good.

  • @wowow322
    @wowow322 Před 3 lety +8

    What about stuff in the shadowlands npw that may be hinting expansions ahead? Why not go into any of that?

    • @karehaqt
      @karehaqt Před 3 lety

      Because that will be a new video in the future.

    • @avidcollector869
      @avidcollector869 Před 3 lety

      there probly isnt a new xpac, shadowlands killing it right now

    • @Saintlel
      @Saintlel Před 3 lety

      @@avidcollector869 One of the most successful MMOs on the market is dying, xd

    • @monosophy691
      @monosophy691 Před 3 lety

      @@Saintlel I love the qualifiers that have to be added to that now. Next it will be one of the most successful western mmos, then one of the most successful tab targeting based western mmorpgs

    • @Saintlel
      @Saintlel Před 3 lety

      @@monosophy691 Nah, FFXIV is still leagues away from WoW in terms of playerbase, FFXIV was losing to BDO on steamcharts for a long time lmao
      And I don't think there's a western MMO that's going to surpass it, New World will tapper off and Ashes only competes with shit like Lineage and BDO so