It's Good to Be Bad: Queerness & Villainy (feat. Joe Black) | Dreamsounds

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 26. 08. 2024

Komentáře • 101

  • @DreamsoundsVideo
    @DreamsoundsVideo  Před 3 lety +155

    This could not have been possible without Joe Black!!✨
    If you're interested in queerness, villainy, and drag, please support his work!🌈
    Here are some links:
    twitter.com/misterjoeblack​
    www.misterjoeblack.com/​
    czcams.com/users/misterjoeblacketc

    • @BBWahoo
      @BBWahoo Před 3 lety +2

      Unsure if you play videogames, but if you do, have you played MOTHER 3? There are queer coded characters called magypsies, and they assist the MC in their own way, they're viewed as non-binary but are very unique in how they present themselves. I personally think they're sweethearts.

    • @johnny196775
      @johnny196775 Před 3 lety +2

      I am gay.
      I have post traumatic stress disorder surrounding homophobia from coming out when I was young - about 40 years ago - and fighting for gay rights. I am clinically triggered by the public use of the Q-word to identify the LGBT+ community. When LGBT+ creators use that slur, it makes their product inaccessible to people disabled in the way that I am. This isn't at all uncommon among older members of the gay community. It essentially excludes us from partaking in your media and as members of the community.
      I understand the idea of 'taking back the language' but in order to do so, you have to deny the use of the slur to the group that ordinarily uses it as a slur; by inviting straight people to use the slur, you are actually normalizing it, not reclaiming it. By using it in your titles, you don't hurt any homophobic people, who don't care... but you do hurt other members of the LGBT+ community who don't consent to us being identified that way.
      I really wish that members of the community who wish to express themselves this way would consider the impact they have on other members - particularly older members who may as a result become shut out of the community.
      Please stop doing this.

  • @UnknownFlyingPancake
    @UnknownFlyingPancake Před 3 lety +327

    I think the confidence is a big part of it. They know they're going against what everyone around them stands for, but they don't care. They're completely shameless and I love that.

  • @Sophia3477
    @Sophia3477 Před 3 lety +272

    We can finally address the fact that Mal and Evie had something going on between them that was definitely MORE than friendship

    • @papersonic9941
      @papersonic9941 Před 3 lety +22

      You're telling me a Kenny Ortega film had a totally-not-gay pair? Unbelievable.

    • @Sophia3477
      @Sophia3477 Před 3 lety +39

      @@papersonic9941 the audacity to not make them queer after mal and evie had an entire duet about never letting each other go while looking at each other eyes and touching their foreheads

    • @Zvwry
      @Zvwry Před 2 lety +4

      I didn’t catch that vibe

  • @shockingheaven
    @shockingheaven Před 3 lety +175

    As a baby gay, I often rooted for the villains because I felt many of them were misunderstood and wouldn't be acting that way if they were accepted for who they were. However, I don't enjoy how they're now making them antiheroes rather than villains. I liked their villainy, it was cathartic and fascinating.

  • @bdm483
    @bdm483 Před 3 lety +153

    Being a (looking back) disabled kid, I always liked how their bodies were different from the heroes'... and how they weren't ashamed of that.

    • @DanielVCOliveira
      @DanielVCOliveira Před rokem +2

      Sorry for the ignorance but what type of disability makes you only realize it's a disability upon looking back?

    • @bdm483
      @bdm483 Před rokem +4

      ​@@DanielVCOliveira No, that's a good question. What I had are called 'invisible disabilities', which means that they weren't obviously apparent. Especially when I was young enough that it could have been a quirk I was going to grow out of.
      In hindsight, seen through the years, the diagnoses make sense. But at the time, I didn't have the words to ask for help, or even explain to myself what was happening.
      I just thought I was lazy, or silly, or weak, or naughty, or weird, or attention seeking. And the other students and teachers acted like I was those things, too. Lots of bullying.
      I'd try so hard to hide what was going on with me. I tried so hard to be normal.
      I was never a massive Disney person, but I did always like how many of the villains were out and proud about their body's quirks.

  • @robinhahnsopran
    @robinhahnsopran Před 3 lety +180

    Hi! I'm an LGBTQ singer and performance artist with a Disney obsession. I just wanted to thank you so much for this thoughtful, nuanced look at villainy - I know how much work goes into these video essays, and it's so valuable to see ourselves in them. Understanding our representation helps us to understand ourselves.

  • @TricksterModeEngaged
    @TricksterModeEngaged Před 3 lety +60

    Being a confident, transgressive, stylish badass is such a power fantasy TBH

  • @casir.7407
    @casir.7407 Před 3 lety +67

    related to that expresiveness that joe mentioned, i think one of the reasons its such a pity that modern disney movies forego a villain or have a "twist villain" is that they still stick (with a few exceptions) to the same standards of beauty in character design since the 1980s -it cannot be understated how ariels design basically was the basis for every disney princess set after her. disney villains historically are designed with more exaggerated features, more expressive, more dramatical, which makes for greatly entertaining animation and of course musical numbers. a few disney movies take a page out of dreamworks and make characters that are "outsiders" to mainstream society (the biggest one that comes to mind is wreck it ralph) but even then the character design of the "villain" is softened and made to fit the rest of the universe of the movie: in a way, as disney has tried to make their heroes more like outcasts trying to find themselves or their place in the world, the more they have assimilated the villains to look as... well, part of that world.
    i do think this is also part of the reason they are making remakes focused on villains: with a new movie focusing on them theres new merchandise to be made and sold, except this time it has a bankable pretty face like that of Angelina Jolie or Emma Stone. and, just as these live action movies tend to have a darker, more self serious tone, the camp, the performance of evil and the fun in the excess is erased in favor of fashionable anti-hero characterization.
    i think thats why your conclusion on assimilation is so well done and needed. not much has changed in the world of disney, to be perfectly honest: there is always a system that works, a villain that threatens it, and heroes that must reestablish the previous order. more recent movies like Frozen 2 dip their toes in ideas of reclaimed land, imperialism and reparations, but they never truly change the overall system. villains, as maligned as they were, presented a sort of person, a sort of existence that was exciting and new and revolutionary: theres nothing of that in modern disney movies, which makes for pretty good but unmemorable fare.

  • @MissUlfang
    @MissUlfang Před 3 lety +28

    For me what appeals to villainy is the power. You can't take away rights and healthcare from a villain, they're too powerful. Even in a world that hates them, they find a way to survive. And when villains do eventually fall to the hero, they always go out with a bang.

    • @mastermarkus5307
      @mastermarkus5307 Před rokem

      As someone really into Red Dead Redemption 2 right now, I feel this a lot.

  • @emmahenderson2737
    @emmahenderson2737 Před 3 lety +30

    I had never thought of “I wanna be like you” as a villain song before - wow!

    • @HobGungan
      @HobGungan Před 3 lety +4

      Louie is sn antagonist, albiet a minor one

  • @Lily-wl2pu
    @Lily-wl2pu Před 3 lety +41

    There's no doubt Disney villains are great great characters with great personalities, they're cool and fascinating! So I don't like to see them becoming anti-heroes as well.. their back story could explain why they are evil in the first place, but it wouldn't change the fact they are evil. In my opinion an evil character appeals to the public only if they're a well written character, and I greatly appreciate "giving up" and being fascinated by them for that brief moment on the screen.

  • @amys688
    @amys688 Před 3 lety +17

    That point about villains often getting one song to showcase their whole self made me think of Long John Silver in Muppet Treasure Island - "Upstage, lads! This is my ONLY number!"

  • @coyoots
    @coyoots Před 3 lety +52

    dang, this video just helped me figure out why i love villains so much lol

  • @kevin_andrews735
    @kevin_andrews735 Před 3 lety +33

    Me: "It's power! It's power! It's how they're so powerful!"
    After 33 min Dreamsounds: "It might be power"
    Me:

  • @SpiffierShindigs
    @SpiffierShindigs Před 3 lety +25

    What a fantastic video. Shout outs to Jafar and Yzma.

    • @taureleafsilver
      @taureleafsilver Před 3 lety +4

      Yzma's villain song being cut is a crime I will never forgive

  • @sarcomeresarecool
    @sarcomeresarecool Před 3 lety +36

    The other thing about Descendants is that not only does it have those songs in it, but all three movies are fundamentally about the VKs, especially Mal, trying to reconcile who they are and where they came from with the society they've since joined, which just reinforces all of that coding imo.

  • @jdprettynails
    @jdprettynails Před 2 lety +6

    I have an entirely different relationship with Mother Knows Best. I knew from the get-go how insincere the song actually was because EVERYTHING Mother Gothel says to Rapunzel is almost word for word what my mum has said to me. Her "I'm just saying cause I wuv you" line cut like a knife because of how real it was.
    I have a lot of complicated feelings about Tangled.....and now Encanto.

  • @tomokokuroki8189
    @tomokokuroki8189 Před 2 lety +6

    Nya, after watching this video I think I understand a little better the self-conscious dynamics of my stories, why many of the villains that I create for them are good friends of my main characters, the "heroes" don't care that they are villains and in fact, (while still being "good" them and "evil" the villains), they have an attitude of "Has your apocalyptic weapon broken? Leave it to me, maybe I can fix it."

  • @3dnygma
    @3dnygma Před 3 lety +35

    as always, great video. one of my favourite parts was Frollo's inclusion and how he does NOT deserve a seat at the Reclaimed Villaina Table 😂
    also I mentioned this in the lifestream already, but one movie that I think also has some nice references to Weimarer Cabaret is Muppets Most Wanted. the song "I'm Number One" sung by the villain Constantine and his sidekick Dominic Baday channels some true Disney villain energy imo.
    EDIT: finally, what you said about Scar in the live-action Lion King reminded me of the youtube vid "Disney: Gay Villains Made Straight (& Boring)" by Jessie Gender, can recommend that one

  • @Blablablablabla392
    @Blablablablabla392 Před 2 lety +7

    I love villains, I’m queer, mentally ill, and autistic and I see myself in the campy queer-coded villain. I started out loving Disney villains more than the heroes as a kid, and now I adore Batman villains. Characters like Riddler, Penguin, Scarecrow, and Two-Face aren’t explicitly stated as queer, but fans like me still see themselves in these characters and can see queerness in the characters.

  • @Kat-nq5jw
    @Kat-nq5jw Před 2 lety +5

    I feel like Ursula is Ariel in 10 years, if we’re talking about a queer view of the story. Ariel represents a young queer individual, someone who is still exploring their identity, but only in a way that would be accepted by mainstream society. Ursula is someone who is already secure in their queer identity, and no longer wants to conform to societal norms, but embrace every nuance of their queerness in the most eccentric way. I love it

  • @thetwilighthunter1150
    @thetwilighthunter1150 Před 3 lety +14

    Its weird how this video hasn't got many views yet. It was very well put together and I loved the discussion!

  • @halfblood100
    @halfblood100 Před 2 lety +3

    I think it also has do do with the confidence of the villains in these songs. They know who they are and refuse to compromise that, which is something most young queer people have yet to experience. So, this speaks to their desire to have that experience in this big and imperfect way.
    I think that this desire of Disney's to give them a reason, undercuts that unapologetic aspect of their character. Which is why many people who love them are so adversed to these reimaginings.

  • @paigntoncongress8660
    @paigntoncongress8660 Před 3 lety +13

    Oooh, Chopin's Nocturne in E flat major in a video about villains? Nice.
    (This will probably mean more to Philosophy Tube watchers.)

  • @foxliasgriffinYT
    @foxliasgriffinYT Před 2 lety +2

    i really need a playlist with all the lil songs you sing i love em so much waa

  • @Droggelbecher
    @Droggelbecher Před 3 lety +10

    Huh. I'd never thought there would be a day I'd say this: Thank you, H&M. In a weird, algorithmic way, you effing brought me here, and combined my taste for reality tv into something more interesting.

  • @HobGungan
    @HobGungan Před 3 lety +9

    27:00 This perfectly encapsulstes why I tend to prefer movie musicals over the stage versions even if the singers are not the best technical singers. Why I'll take Marlon Brando's "Luck be a Lady" over a "better" singer any day of the week.

  • @gamewrit0058
    @gamewrit0058 Před rokem

    33:90 "Like I could as stealing back the vocabulary" really resonates with me.

  • @littlenothing1068
    @littlenothing1068 Před 3 lety +17

    This video was fucking bomb, 10/10

  • @voidify3
    @voidify3 Před 3 lety +3

    I've watched too much Philosophy Tube, that piano piece that started toward the end of the camp section activated my fight or flight response

  • @Caterfree10
    @Caterfree10 Před 3 lety +8

    See I’m never sure how I feel about the recent trend to rebrand Disney villains as anti heroes in remakes like Maleficent and Cruella. On the one hand, I feel like it adds to the characters’ development and I’ve always loved 3 dimensional villains more than two dimensional ones. On the other hand, I think they were fine and totally fun on their own without the rebranding. Granted, no remake will truly erase the originals imo, but still. I mean, I could even wax on about how much I’d love a Sephiroth redemption in FFVIIR, but I don’t like, expect it bc of Seph’s infamy as a villain in video games. That gets like, an essay unto itself however ahah.
    But yeah, I love both complex and simple villains so my feelings toward turning villains into anti heroes is so mixed, I don’t know how I feel about them.

  • @DaniPopplio
    @DaniPopplio Před 3 lety +5

    I feel like your videos help me know myself better and understand many things in my younger self, thank you very much 💖

  • @rioisnotokay-ipromise-6115

    I think that possible answer to add one is one that is much more simple. It’s even written in the title! It’s good to be bad.
    Bad, signifying homosexuality, as it’s been viewed as a negative thing throughout history.
    And a villains entire mantra is that it’s actually *good* to be like that. Therefore, it’s good to be gay. The villain clearly outwardly celebrates it. Although expressing this differently, it’s still a celebration of themselves. Be it how evil they are or how powerful, they clearly love themselves for it. Even if shunned by society, they keep loving and celebrating! And that’s meaningful!
    It’s like pride!! A celebration (however that celebration is expressed) of difference and “inherent bad-ness” but in a person!
    A villain offers us a space that for once, explores being “bad” as good. It’s good to be bad.

  • @Val.Stanton
    @Val.Stanton Před 3 lety +6

    Your videos are always so thoughtful, I love them so much! Thanks for another great one!

  • @kropotkinnie
    @kropotkinnie Před 2 lety +4

    haven't watched this video yet but as a gay™ i weirdly REALLY miss the days of true disney queercoded villains, not antiheroes but just straight up villains. their shamelessness and confidence was so fun and let's be real, villains are always more fun to admire than heroes. there's a reason why most disney merch is of their old villains and not the good guys or new antiheroes. i really miss that, even if it wasn't great representation, because it felt like shameless queerness and atypicality rather than this new age hush hush lack of that.

  • @unouni2548
    @unouni2548 Před 3 lety +9

    Oh God I hope Disney doesn't ruin this Cruella! I think Emma Stone is a great actor and I know it's produced by Glenn Close, but they've done so much damage to their villains lately that I'm not sure what to believe.

  • @ambergong7201
    @ambergong7201 Před 3 lety +4

    I am so ready to watch this over and over again!

  • @HoneyBee-qf8kn
    @HoneyBee-qf8kn Před 3 lety +5

    this is fantastic. like everything is so well done, so accessible, super interesting, and just overall perfection 👌🏻

  • @chubbyhubby2065
    @chubbyhubby2065 Před 2 lety +6

    Can't really call Cruella an anti-hero if she wants to kill and maim puppies-

  • @matthewdrummond1340
    @matthewdrummond1340 Před 3 lety +3

    I like the saying on your shirt during the interview

  • @sheccabaw
    @sheccabaw Před 3 lety +4

    Yessss I love this!

  • @benburke3015
    @benburke3015 Před 3 lety +7

    20 seconds in and I love this!!!

  • @ewestendorf13
    @ewestendorf13 Před 2 lety

    I’ve been binging your channel lately 🖤 Joe Black though!!! 😻

  • @esbeng.s.a9761
    @esbeng.s.a9761 Před 2 lety +1

    They just feel so exspreseve and alive. They don't care what you think about them, and they have the power to do so, they dont ask they command, and then they loses it all
    I think villian speak to people who are scared of how the world will react when they let loose and just stop pretending to be something else. But the most import thing about disney evil they have fun while being themself, they know who they are and what they want and will fight toeth and nail to get it

  • @t.mutabilis2497
    @t.mutabilis2497 Před 3 lety +3

    your channel is great. love your videos. another fantastic one!

  • @tempesttossed6029
    @tempesttossed6029 Před 3 lety +5

    Great video. Only suggestion is in a more top-down angle for the camera at the beginning.

  • @lautarosio8561
    @lautarosio8561 Před 3 lety +6

    This will be surreal and I love it

  • @wallacephillips9880
    @wallacephillips9880 Před 3 lety +5

    Out of all the Disney Villains cliches, (watch the Ms.Mojo video about that) the only cliche I don't like is the "Acting Effeminate" one. I understand it makes the villain seem more over the top. But if we're going to have more positive LGBTQ+ representation in the future, the "acting effeminate" trope need to stop.

  • @gamewrit0058
    @gamewrit0058 Před rokem

    12:30 I also prefer my villains to be villains and not anti-heroes. An antagonist doesn't have to be a villain, but if you're going to have a villain in the piece, let them be a villain.

  • @bloodblues85
    @bloodblues85 Před 3 lety +2

    Can't wait! :D

  • @merelymayhem
    @merelymayhem Před 3 lety +3

    amazing video!!

  • @dianadunord4494
    @dianadunord4494 Před 2 lety

    Many thanks for this video. I think is very helpful for Queer people

  • @gayhomosexuallll
    @gayhomosexuallll Před 3 lety +4

    Amazing video

  • @monikabinnberg2557
    @monikabinnberg2557 Před 3 lety +2

    Oh I am too late. But the Video is fantastic, your work is always good

  • @collectmybrains
    @collectmybrains Před 3 lety +1

    Love the opening.

  • @enzmondo
    @enzmondo Před 2 lety +1

    I wonder if this was written before Agatha Harkness showed up in WandaVision. Agatha All Along definitely gave us a new traditional Disney villain, heavily queer coded and ultimately unapologetic.

  • @1marilynable
    @1marilynable Před 3 lety +4

    I'm a drag queen and love doing a disney villain in my acts sometimes !

  • @bsharahourany154
    @bsharahourany154 Před 3 lety +7

    Okay but can we mention how Disney is actually doing lgbtq content? It's on hulu and freeform already, it's all Disney. And how did no one mention the boy in the dress at the end of the Disney Plus Godmother movie

  • @DanielVCOliveira
    @DanielVCOliveira Před rokem +1

    Very eye opening from a cis hetero perspective

  • @twistysunshine
    @twistysunshine Před 3 lety +4

    This was so good!!

  • @crystalm1915
    @crystalm1915 Před 3 lety +1

    omg i LOVEEDDDDD this videooo

  • @SpiffierShindigs
    @SpiffierShindigs Před 3 lety +2

    (already have liked, commented and subscribed, but here's another comment just for the algorithm)

  • @johnstockman5683
    @johnstockman5683 Před 2 lety

    Gregg Araki is without a doubt, one of the greatest directors to ever be

  • @afailurueditoruwu2492
    @afailurueditoruwu2492 Před 2 lety +1

    dreamsound did you ever consider making a cover channel

  • @miticaBEP07
    @miticaBEP07 Před 3 lety +2

    Two words: Donquixote Doflamingo

  • @stevenbradley1969
    @stevenbradley1969 Před 3 lety +1

    Love your videos

  • @shockingheaven
    @shockingheaven Před 3 lety +1

    This is really great

  • @Velvet.Unicorn
    @Velvet.Unicorn Před 2 lety

    Wait. I Haven't Seen Curella But A Clip You Showed Shows Dalmatians Being Apprehensive Around Her.
    Does She Still Want To Kill And Skin Them ?!
    Is Disney Trying To Make Me Like Someone That They Are Portraying As Still Wanting To Do That ?!

  • @AshArrowCommunity
    @AshArrowCommunity Před 2 lety +1

    I came out to my mum as non-binary in August. She still doesn’t except me :( also I might be pansexual but I’m not telling mum. Because she will never except me…

  • @oddarite
    @oddarite Před 2 lety

    Aha! My thing for villains isn’t just me! *returns to swooning over anime men*

  • @amandaandherstuffedanimals1308

    I think you should talk Snagglepuss at some point he may not be Disney but he definitely has to me Has so gay qualities again I think he’s one of the first interpretations of that in cartoons

  • @jamoore418
    @jamoore418 Před 3 lety +5

    Sorry if I missed this but did we discuss why Maleficent isn't queer coded?

    • @hodgrix
      @hodgrix Před 2 lety +2

      Right. I believe she is. She's tall, has masculine bone structure, lean, dramatic makeup... erhmm.. drag queen??!

  • @ybunnygurl
    @ybunnygurl Před 2 lety

    I remember as a little kid always thinking that Captain Hook was gay and I'm pretty sure it's me was his partner.

  • @deboralee1623
    @deboralee1623 Před 2 lety

    haven't seen the word "urning" in decades.
    hmmm... ?what is "Ode on a Grecian Urn _really_ about?

  • @veganagev2062
    @veganagev2062 Před 3 lety +2

    ✊🏻✊🏻✊🏻

  • @kiahvmp_
    @kiahvmp_ Před 2 lety

    What does ur shirt mean by Fail better 🧍🏾‍♀️

  • @froufroudeluxe
    @froufroudeluxe Před rokem

    I still can’t believe how dirty they did Joe on drag race

  • @CasperdaGreat
    @CasperdaGreat Před 2 lety

    Holy crap Jake you’re such a good musician and singer

  • @fishy658
    @fishy658 Před 3 lety +1

    !!!

  • @ozloop69
    @ozloop69 Před 3 lety +2

    I think my take away from your show today is that the LGBTQ family likes being seen as being a villain we enjoy it it is unique really was Curella DiVall a lesbian or a drag queen is she a real female Ursula from the Little mermaid I question why is she a bad female or a good drag queen giving people what they’ve asked for and then letting them experience the good and bad at LGBTQ people really evil or have we been treated is evil are we presented as being evil and therefore we own it as members of the family we own that so it cannot hurt us being called queer was an insult it’s not now we change that.

  • @jesonsastak2205
    @jesonsastak2205 Před 3 lety +5

    I strongly disagree about what you said about Descendants, for me descendants is nothing more then an ever after high rip-off and descendants destroyed eah because of course it's Disney. I would like to hear your opinion about eah thought...

    • @papasscooperiaworker3649
      @papasscooperiaworker3649 Před 3 lety

      what's eah?

    • @jesonsastak2205
      @jesonsastak2205 Před 3 lety +2

      @@papasscooperiaworker3649 Ever after high a really neat show that also had a doll line. You can't find all of the episodes online and the movie (I think) also a guy named negative legend made a wonderful video about the show

  • @Amy-si8gq
    @Amy-si8gq Před 2 lety

    im here, im queer!.. sturdy shedinja gives me fear T^T

  • @ragmondead
    @ragmondead Před 2 lety

    Interesting video, but you kinda went back to Joe Black a comedic amount of times.

  • @oneandonlyprecarious
    @oneandonlyprecarious Před 2 lety

    Puipui