@@nanyanguo1 I understand what you mean, friend, but Jacky released his first Cantonese album, "Smile" in 1985, nine years before Dimash was born on May 24, 1994. It's not really fair to compare. Mind you, I've been a Jacky fan for many years. Give Dimash a chance. He's mesmerizing.
@@IrisesInTheSun well am not as enamoured by D as his fans and had made my earlier comments after seeing their outrageous claims that he is better than Jacky , that he helps make Jacky famous to the world just bcos he did a cover of this song by Jacky. Jacky had won many prestigious music awards in his younger days including the World Music Award as the World best selling asian artiste . His international albums sales were close to that of MJ , a feat considering he is not singing in english and his sales were achieved outside mainland China market which was still relatively close to Cpop music at the time . Dont think D can ever top Jacky achievements nor is D a multi winner of any significant prestigious international awards.
Jacky is one of The Heavenly Four in HK, since the late 80's. The other 3 are Leon Lai, Aaron Kwok, and Andy Lau. For me, Jacky has the best voice out of the 4.
As a matter of fact, the other 3 are in this group, based only on their looks and popularity as actors. They are extremely good-looking, compared with Jacky. It would be quite true to say out of the four, only Jacky excels as a singer. As for the other three, I enjoy watching their MV, their singing is only acceptable as entertainment. I must say there are quite a number of other singers much better than the 3 but not included in this group of "heavenlies."
Jacky was a original singer before leon, andy, and aaron. The other 3 was original actors and aaron was a professional dancer before becoming a singer.
The way I see it is that Jacky has the real singing talent. Aaron has the energy because he is the youngest of the 4. Andy and Leon are more comparable because of their good looks. That's why only Leon and Andy's fans fight all the time on who's better. It was ridiculous.
Originally a Japanese song. Key in this in CZcams search. "Koji Tamaki - Ikanaide [1989]". Hope you like the original. Original singer, Koji Tamaki. Cheers.
Jackie is performing the Cantonese version here, titled "Li Xiang Lan." Some may wonder why the song has such a strange title. The original Koji Tamaki song was featured in the Japanese TV movie about 李香兰(Li Xiang Lan) also known as Yoshiko Yamaguchi (山口 淑子, Yamaguchi Yoshiko, 12 February 1920 - 7 September 2014) a Chinese-born Japanese actress and singer. She was the original singer of many songs which became Teresa Teng's signature tunes.
Different dialect but the pain still there from the original Koji to Jacky and Dimash is like different colors of the wind and every color it brings you still feel the chill deep down in your soul. Bravo 👏
Dimash also brought me here via Koji . I'm sure Dimash is proud of all his dears for reaching out to explore artists that he feels are worth covering. Can you imagine what Dimashes music library must be like? WOW
I had always doubted that why all people say Jacky Cheung is one of the best, when there are so many incredibly talented singers out there. After listened to this song, I know why.
His voice just really matches the song. He truely puts all his emotions into the songs and touched the deepest parts of our hearts. What a magnificent performance it is.
Dimash brought me here and I’m kind of disappointed about myself because I couldn’t make it to this video before. This version of the song is absolutely beautiful too!. Jacky seems to be a really good artist and I’m definitely going trough his other videos right after this. Love from México. 🇲🇽
Please do check him out :) Jacky Cheung is dubbed the 'God of Song' in the Chinese music community. He has so many hits that he still endlessly attracts fans and his songs are constantly covered in song competitions. Just last year he broke his own record and held 157 concerts . Many of the superstars in cpop also started out imitating his singing style.
I'm watching from Beijing with love, and I recognised this song instantly as I've been listening to Dimash's cover. Couldn't ignore Stephen chow remarks on jacky cheung so here I am 😁💓
God bless the whole world in this difficult time with the COVID_19🙏. Dimash brought me here.... Amazing voice, beautiful, thanks Mr. Cheung.... I love Dimash, I was in his NY concert was Amazing.. I will not get tired of hearing this young man with that wonderful gift, I cannot believe that a single human being has so much in himself, passion, emotion, beautiful personality, a great heart, and a pure and unique technique. Love it! Also, a great coincidence and pleasant surprise happened to me Dec 9, in New York, day before the concert. When I was about to enter the NY library I saw Dimash's parents who were also entering, Dimash's younger brother was our translator ... that was a nice meeting..I had some photos with them ....❤❤❤❤
This is by far the most underrated song sung by Jacky Cheung ever. Why this hasn't blown up I don't know, but it being a live concert is impressive in itself.
nou chun fung, ngoh sam yan hoh nou chun fung suet bat chut sik jau sueng sung ye yue dong yue dim tau se do jiu pin jung wooi tou chi si mong mo faat sin dong mai jue ying mong nei tui sik jiu pin jung a jeung fa seoi mei hong yue bing sui bat dong kuut jeung you mo so suet wah hoh sik ngoh ngoh ting bat dung a si booi jau jim nung waak ngoh sam jan hung hoh yi gam jan dong jiu pin jung na hoh yi tau jiu pin jung paan jaau do si gan lit fung ye fong zung go ji ngoh nan cam nei fong zong wooi tou ya si mong ying chi bei dong to bei ying mong nei kuet sam yan nou jung English translation: Frustrating spring wind Why is my heart frustrated by the spring wind Can't speak up Drinking to bid goodbye Cold night wind Raindrops transmitted onto the photo Looking back is like a dream Cannot rebound Entranced, starring at you in the faded photo * Ah Like flower though not as red Like ice though not cold As though there are endless words Pity that I, I could not understand Ah Is the cup of wine thickening Or is my heart empty Why do I feel moved In the photo In the photo I could Wish to find The split of time Indulgent night informs me that it would be hard to trace your scent Looking back is also a dream Seems to be passive Avoiding to stare at you Yet deeply impressed in my mind
YOU SHOULD LISTEN TO ANITA MUI VERSION AT HER FINAL CONCERT BEFORE SHE PASSED AWAY, DESPITE HER PHYSICAL WEAKNESS, HER STRONG FEELINGS TRUMPS ALL THE OTHER SINGERS. SHE DIED A MONTH LATER FROM TERMINAL CANCER. SHE PUT HER ENTIRE SOUL IN GIVING HER BEST IN THE CONCERT.
Of all.... Koji tamayaki, full feeling, absorbing essence of his song. D'mash still young, good teknik but less experience than jacky cheung. Jacky.... Full technic and sweet voice
everyone sings beautifully, but Koji Tamaki is life, this is space, this is air and water. I cry every time I listen to Kouji Tamaki. feel real pain...love you , Koji Tamaki
I have heard this song in 4 singers and in different versions and languages they are both great and gifted skilled singers adored them but the original composer and singer who sang this is koji tamakis a legendary Japanese singer is still the best version full of emotion that made him different
@@pilarkan I can't open the link you sent I'm out of coverage right now but you know what is interesting now is that Dimash new version ikanaide at Tokyo jazz was incredibly amazing so full of emotions that goes down to your nerves he always wanted his listeners to be satisfied of his art his audience he loves his listeners so much he gives his best 👌 Mr Perfection 🥰
@@levelazn the original composer singer of this song ikanaide was koji tamaki a legendary Japanese singer I know this song I'm from Asia Philippines 🇵🇭 regards to you
Listened to Koji then come here, both are legends in their own ways. If Leslie Cheung ever did this in his life, it may be the closest to Koji but we will never know. Jacky is greatest in many songs but this, Koji's is my favourite version, after all, the song was originally written for his vocal. I live in the best era.
I’m here like most of you, because of Dimash. Not offending this very good singer. It’s that Dimash’s voice is so clean and his face is so tender, humble and transparent that even when he may not have the best diction, because doesn’t know the language, he did such a spectacular performance at The Singer and after. 🌷
AND judging from the comments, I assume many here can't distinguish the difference between Mandarin and Cantonese.... And for everyone who watched 'Love From Beijing' with it's original soundtrack (Cantonese), Stephen Chow sings the song. As for the dubbed Mandarin version, his voice is dubbed by Shi Banyu.
Dimash just brought me here and I thank him. Jacky Cheung has a beautiful voice.
He does.
asia legend Jacky Cheung Dimash is not his level ,
@@nanyanguo1 I understand what you mean, friend, but Jacky released his first Cantonese album, "Smile" in 1985, nine years before Dimash was born on May 24, 1994. It's not really fair to compare. Mind you, I've been a Jacky fan for many years. Give Dimash a chance. He's mesmerizing.
@@IrisesInTheSun well am not as enamoured by D as his fans and had made my earlier comments after seeing their outrageous claims that he is better than Jacky , that he helps make Jacky famous to the world just bcos he did a cover of this song by Jacky.
Jacky had won many prestigious music awards in his younger days including the World Music Award as the World best selling asian artiste . His international albums sales were close to that of MJ , a feat considering he is not singing in english and his sales were achieved outside mainland China market which was still relatively close to Cpop music at the time .
Dont think D can ever top Jacky achievements nor is D a multi winner of any significant prestigious international awards.
Dimash is the best
Jacky is one of The Heavenly Four in HK, since the late 80's. The other 3 are Leon Lai, Aaron Kwok, and Andy Lau. For me, Jacky has the best voice out of the 4.
Peter Lim and cant deny that the other three sucks so bad. No talent in singing or whatsoever.
All 4 are good. From each his best. Hk peace.no more violence ♥️
As a matter of fact, the other 3 are in this group, based only on their looks and popularity as actors. They are extremely good-looking, compared with Jacky. It would be quite true to say out of the four, only Jacky excels as a singer. As for the other three, I enjoy watching their MV, their singing is only acceptable as entertainment. I must say there are quite a number of other singers much better than the 3 but not included in this group of "heavenlies."
Jacky was a original singer before leon, andy, and aaron. The other 3 was original actors and aaron was a professional dancer before becoming a singer.
The way I see it is that Jacky has the real singing talent. Aaron has the energy because he is the youngest of the 4. Andy and Leon are more comparable because of their good looks. That's why only Leon and Andy's fans fight all the time on who's better. It was ridiculous.
Originally a Japanese song. Key in this in CZcams search. "Koji Tamaki - Ikanaide [1989]". Hope you like the original. Original singer, Koji Tamaki. Cheers.
Hiroshi Yamashita true
Koji Tamaki is God. (Tamaki Koji wa kamisama) His talent is irreplaceable in this generation.
Jackie is performing the Cantonese version here, titled "Li Xiang Lan." Some may wonder why the song has such a strange title. The original Koji Tamaki song was featured in the Japanese TV movie about 李香兰(Li Xiang Lan) also known as Yoshiko Yamaguchi (山口 淑子, Yamaguchi Yoshiko, 12 February 1920 - 7 September 2014) a Chinese-born Japanese actress and singer. She was the original singer of many songs which became Teresa Teng's signature tunes.
@@IrisesInTheSun Thank you.
Original version by Koji Tamaki from Anzen Chitai is the best.
Different dialect but the pain still there from the original Koji to Jacky and Dimash is like different colors of the wind and every color it brings you still feel the chill deep down in your soul. Bravo 👏
Hello Realm , how are you doing ? my name is Alex and I would like to know you more Please!
Dimash also brought me here via Koji . I'm sure Dimash is proud of all his dears for reaching out to explore artists that he feels are worth covering. Can you imagine what Dimashes music library must be like? WOW
This song is absolutely beautiful. It makes me cry. 😍😍😍😍
The best version I've ever heard... Love Jacky Cheung ...
I had always doubted that why all people say Jacky Cheung is one of the best, when there are so many incredibly talented singers out there. After listened to this song, I know why.
Right?? Just loop his song. Jackie can put me to sleep any night of the week.
I believe jacky here was already out of his "prime" but still really good obviously
you mean yourself?
One of my top ten best song ever...I missed those days
Very beautiful song.. With deeply love inside..
Love this song and its meaning . Dimash sings it beautifully also
Dimash brought me here. From Utah USA 🇺🇸
same here
J Smith,
Jacky Cheung Hok Yau, brought me here.!!Colorado, USA.
Same here from Utah USA, no offense but I prefer Dimash.
same here 😂
Same from new zealans
His voice just really matches the song. He truely puts all his emotions into the songs and touched the deepest parts of our hearts. What a magnificent performance it is.
Очень нравится эта песня! Готова слушать и слушать!
from beijing with love - stephen chow brought me here
Adiwarna Publications & Distributors Me too😂😂😂
Adiwarna Publications & Distributors solid comment
Same😂😂😂
Me toooo
La Di da Di da 😂😂😂
Excellent. Yet another version I'd not heard.
Dimash brought me to this channel. Wonderful song. Thank you Dimash ❤️
My Chinese almost-lover brought me to Jacky Chan with so many of his songs expressing our feelings. Soulmates for always. Thank you, Jacky.
He is jacky cheung.........not jackie chan!
he is asia legend singer Jacky Cheung and not jacky chan who is the kungfu stunt actor . However both are from hongkong.in China
Dimash brought me here and I’m kind of disappointed about myself because I couldn’t make it to this video before. This version of the song is absolutely beautiful too!. Jacky seems to be a really good artist and I’m definitely going trough his other videos right after this. Love from México. 🇲🇽
Please do check him out :) Jacky Cheung is dubbed the 'God of Song' in the Chinese music community. He has so many hits that he still endlessly attracts fans and his songs are constantly covered in song competitions. Just last year he broke his own record and held 157 concerts . Many of the superstars in cpop also started out imitating his singing style.
I prefer the Cantonese lyrics of this translated song as compared to the Chinese version.
Japanese make lots of beautiful songs and music..
He's big here in Hong Kong. Thank you for your appreciation.
Check out lst his song Farewell Kiss . It was this song that catapult him into superstar fame.3 decades ago.
@@joyeveryday186 Cantonese is a Chinese dialect. Same as Mandarin.
Classic, much love from California
wow ce violon ... cette voix ! superbe chanson.
Superb version. Beautiful! 💜
Love how he deliver his music...it touched my hesrt do deeply...u cried a lot...dimash brought me here....
Woww, I love his voice
I have been binge watching Koji Tamaki and it led me here... The song was so great it was made into a Chinese version (?) Superb in its own way 👍
Love the violin, the voice and the suit. Great performance. Respect.
First heard this song years ago, but it always gets me in the feels.
Maravillosa canción y maravillosamente interpretada, lo que pasa es que Dimash la ha transformado en algo sublime, de otra dimensión...
I'm watching from Beijing with love, and I recognised this song instantly as I've been listening to Dimash's cover. Couldn't ignore Stephen chow remarks on jacky cheung so here I am 😁💓
😊
God bless the whole world in this difficult time with the COVID_19🙏. Dimash brought me here.... Amazing voice, beautiful, thanks Mr. Cheung.... I love Dimash, I was in his NY concert was Amazing.. I will not get tired of hearing this young man with that wonderful gift, I cannot believe that a single human being has so much in himself, passion, emotion, beautiful personality, a great heart, and a pure and unique technique. Love it!
Also, a great coincidence and pleasant surprise happened to me Dec 9, in New York, day before the concert. When I was about to enter the NY library I saw Dimash's parents who were also entering, Dimash's younger brother was our translator ... that was a nice meeting..I had some photos with them ....❤❤❤❤
woah, thats lucky, having Dimash's brother as a translator. Dimash is excellent, love from China
How wonderful you had the opportunity to attend the concert dd Dimash in NY. Hope see him someday. He is unique, he is so talented 🌺
This is master piece by Jackie.. One of his best live performance..
Rohaness the best version= dimash kudaibergen version
@@FeathrineAugustusAurora yess I'm with you, Dimash is out of d world..
One of my favorite singer other then beyond
I love this song 🌻♥️👑
Очень красиво и проникновенно, браво!!!
Браво!! Чувственно...
This is by far the most underrated song sung by Jacky Cheung ever. Why this hasn't blown up I don't know, but it being a live concert is impressive in itself.
Its original (行かないで by Tamaki Koji) was very popular in Japan
The song is kinda controversial in china. Maybe thats why
I loveeeeeeeeeee it ... I think one of the best song of Jacky Cheung :) ...
Not technically his song tho 😕
@@Adam-xy4ny he has made this song his own. and popular ever since he sang it decades ago.
Ok :) ... @@Adam-xy4ny
Jacky.... the legend... you can't deny his powerful voice. He is one of the best.
The eponymous named person of this title song - Li Xiang Lan born in Manchuria was a singer in three languages - Chinese, Japanese and Russian.
nou chun fung, ngoh sam yan hoh nou chun fung
suet bat chut sik jau sueng sung
ye yue dong yue dim tau se do jiu pin jung wooi tou chi si mong
mo faat sin dong mai jue ying mong nei tui sik jiu pin jung
a jeung fa seoi mei hong yue bing sui bat dong
kuut jeung you mo so suet wah hoh sik ngoh ngoh ting bat dung
a si booi jau jim nung waak ngoh sam jan hung
hoh yi gam jan dong
jiu pin jung na hoh yi tau jiu pin jung
paan jaau do si gan lit fung
ye fong zung go ji ngoh nan cam nei fong zong
wooi tou ya si mong ying chi bei dong
to bei ying mong nei kuet sam yan nou jung
English translation:
Frustrating spring wind Why is my heart frustrated by the spring wind
Can't speak up Drinking to bid goodbye
Cold night wind Raindrops transmitted onto the photo Looking back is like a dream
Cannot rebound Entranced, starring at you in the faded photo
* Ah Like flower though not as red Like ice though not cold
As though there are endless words Pity that I, I could not understand
Ah Is the cup of wine thickening Or is my heart empty
Why do I feel moved
In the photo In the photo I could
Wish to find The split of time
Indulgent night informs me that it would be hard to trace your scent
Looking back is also a dream Seems to be passive
Avoiding to stare at you Yet deeply impressed in my mind
Toji voice is so soft and smoooth while jaki is so powerful and intense
Love the violins
i hear it at first by Dimash.
This is a blessed song in all language is amazing and all of them singers singing.
amazing song
Perfect. Beautiful !!!
The Violin & Voice 👍👍👍
Красивое исполнение👍
YOU SHOULD LISTEN TO ANITA MUI VERSION AT HER FINAL CONCERT BEFORE SHE PASSED AWAY, DESPITE HER PHYSICAL WEAKNESS, HER STRONG FEELINGS TRUMPS ALL THE OTHER SINGERS. SHE DIED A MONTH LATER FROM TERMINAL CANCER. SHE PUT HER ENTIRE SOUL IN GIVING HER BEST IN THE CONCERT.
can you paste the link here. Thanks
The best song
Of all.... Koji tamayaki, full feeling, absorbing essence of his song. D'mash still young, good teknik but less experience than jacky cheung. Jacky.... Full technic and sweet voice
Man his suit is awesome!
wow Li Xiang Lan is a very good song
Like xiang lan stephen chow
@@mathdude96 also that singer who sang this song in stephens movie sings well
everyone sings beautifully, but Koji Tamaki is life, this is space, this is air and water. I cry every time I listen to Kouji Tamaki. feel real pain...love you , Koji Tamaki
He's the best!!!
love, from Korea.
I have heard this song in 4 singers and in different versions and languages they are both great and gifted skilled singers adored them but the original composer and singer who sang this is koji tamakis a legendary Japanese singer is still the best version full of emotion that made him different
czcams.com/video/9kQ6s_KYNMA/video.html try this vid
@@pilarkan I can't open the link you sent I'm out of coverage right now but you know what is interesting now is that Dimash new version ikanaide at Tokyo jazz was incredibly amazing so full of emotions that goes down to your nerves he always wanted his listeners to be satisfied of his art his audience he loves his listeners so much he gives his best 👌 Mr Perfection 🥰
where did you hear about this song first , just curious, since its an asian language song ....
@@levelazn the original composer singer of this song ikanaide was koji tamaki a legendary Japanese singer I know this song
I'm from Asia Philippines 🇵🇭 regards to you
Agree with you 💯. Koji just makes you feel vulnerable and imparts a feeling of loneliness.
Listened to Koji then come here, both are legends in their own ways. If Leslie Cheung ever did this in his life, it may be the closest to Koji but we will never know. Jacky is greatest in many songs but this, Koji's is my favourite version, after all, the song was originally written for his vocal. I live in the best era.
Koji singing style is so smooth and soft while Jaki is so intense and powerful.
@@patchanasunthonphusit4892 100%! Each of these brilliant singers has their own character
@@patchanasunthonphusit4892can’t agree more!
Ai VN nghiện bài này ko nhỉ
2023,還有人在聽？
Beautiful cover!
To Yoshiko Yamaguchi, autum is so strong, made everyone so sad.
so great version! different of DImash, but good voice and emotion! thanks jacky!!
Yes the Cantonese version is good too. I heard it before.
Beautiful
Soulful,overwhelmingly...
Wow he is so handsome
PERFECT
Stephen chow and anita yuen 🥰
Wow still give me shivers😢
I’m here like most of you, because of Dimash. Not offending this very good singer. It’s that Dimash’s voice is so clean and his face is so tender, humble and transparent that even when he may not have the best diction, because doesn’t know the language, he did such a spectacular performance at The Singer and after. 🌷
听过最好的版本👍🏻
Netflix from beijing with love brought me here.
AND judging from the comments, I assume many here can't distinguish the difference between Mandarin and Cantonese....
And for everyone who watched 'Love From Beijing' with it's original soundtrack (Cantonese), Stephen Chow sings the song. As for the dubbed Mandarin version, his voice is dubbed by Shi Banyu.
I am one of those who has trouble distinguishing the difference as well. I will have to read more about it. New to eastern music.
If you're Chinese and speak the language you can tell the difference.
It’s all foreign to us.. lol. But beautiful!!
Original or not, it's not important to me. I hear all: kojitamaki, jaky cheung and dimash. All of them make my heart frozzen.
super-bravo
Still good. Best song to feel alive/dead.
Koji....
Jacky...
Dimash...
Джеки это песня души.И я не попал бы сюда если бы не Димаш и фанфик на Сергея юркина с его Агдан.
สิบปีแล้วยังฟังอยู่เบย
My idol
Tremendous GOOD.
DIMASH BROUGHT ME HERE...
Dimash brought me here
el tema original es mucho as lindo,,,la interpretacion de koji tamaki,es lejos la mejor y que decir de DIMASH ,MASITRAL
That's beautiful..
originally by TAMAKI KOJI - IKANAIDE the original more sad than this one
This is one of my favorite songs until I heard the Koji version. I have to say that Koji is evern better
It is extremely hard to say who sing better Toji tamaki or Jacki
Remind me of how Chow Sing Chi sang this song lol
Koji Tamaki's version is more heartbreaking....
In terms of singing and music .
anh 7 đưa tôi đến đây ^^
Don't forget Kenny Bee, deep raspy
This is the cantonese version
Dimash just killed this song for every other singers.
Anyone got a high def version of this song?
❤️👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Srepen chow
2021?
I think 2002 or 2003
Is this Cantonese?
Yes, this song has a mandarin version but Jacky never sang in his concert
prreeeettttt...