Alpha Labs - Does a Bad Network Switch RUIN your streamer?
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 09. 2023
- We love to dive a little deeper than others. That is why we love to sit in the lab and investigate stuff. This time we are going to show you the influence of a network on jitter. We grab a Volumio Primo streamer and torture it with noise and a noisy network switch. Just to show you what it does to the sound.
More information: alpha-audio.net
Support us on Patreon: / alphaaudio - Věda a technologie
Excelent videos as always - ultimately becoming very, very interesting. In two words : Great - thank you.
As a take II, any plan to test different cat /brand cables, eventually Ifi lan silencer?
Excellent video - thank you!
Thanks!
Always appreciate the effort that goes into your videos thanks
Does it really affect the analog XLR output to amps and the output from amp to speakers so it really is hearable? undependet of say and stereo costing €2500 and upwards in eternity.
Yes
So what switch to buy, or I can just get decent Netgear/D Link with LPSU?
What about LAN galvanic isolators, would the help here?
Yes... that would work perfectly
Jaap, can you please test what those little lan-isolators from iFI or Pink Faun do in that scenario + also the question is an optical network the way to go (yet there are no streamers as far as I know with optical network input)?
We tested those as well. They do something. But don't use them in serial config... they can reflect the noise as well.
The Hifi Rose rs130 has a optical network input
@@grandebufalife As does the iFi Neo Stream, and new Linn streamers. MSB has implemented their own version of optical connections (propriety protocol), but not for connectivity input. We have the iFi Neo Stream in the upcoming test sunday, but we will use the regular ethernet connection.
You can hear what an optical connection does in the livestream where we listen to 11 different switches, including an optical connection. Just browse back in the livestream archive of this channel.
Love your videos man! Already subscribed. Question - if physical LAN connection can inject noise then why not use only wifi?
I'll be grateful for your response.
The wifi radio in the receiving device also introduces noise.
@@TheAlphaAudio i plan to use a Adum3165 based USB isolator after my pi before it connects to a xmos/crystek reclocker (powered by LPS) which feeds my dac via coax.
Will such an adum based isolator be sufficient to mitigate noise & jitter introduced by LAN or Wifi?
That's why I use to my source (streamer) optical fiber and don't have to use "audiophile switches" :). Great job like the rest of the videos!!!
thank you!
Ok..but when out trough a DAC ..playing music can you hear the difference between a “higher end switch “ and a regular ( industrial) switch 🤔
Yes
@@TheAlphaAudio Why nobody has proven that in a double blind test?
What is a switch?
I have a full fibre router less than a year old and a galvanic bridge on my ethernet cable. Is a switch another thing you add to the ethernet line? If so is it only something you need if your router is not the best?
I am within a few weeks of spending another £1400 on a streamer, a linear power supply and cables but I thought that was it, don.
Google...
Very interesting as always, thank you!
Is there any future plan to test the influence of different routers?
No, not really. A router does not have any influence once you have a switch connected to your streamer. I always advice that, for connecting directly to the router is not ideal in terms of noise.
@@TheAlphaAudio thank you. I have a switch next to my streamer and it worked wonders :)
I am always interested in improving further, i think using a low noise power supply will improve things even on the router
@@audiotom3855 You can try this for yourself of course. I did, out of curiosity, and in my case it doesn't.
@@audiotom3855 You can try. I never heard a big difference once I installed a decent switch with nice power supply.
Amir will be having more sleepless nights after this.
This isn't a competition or anything. We do what we do, they do what they do. Both is fine. Just don't stir up a fire that we are not looking for, we rather put our energy on HiFi equipment and investigating why we hear what we hear.
Amir the software engineer? Who cares… he has his cult - let them go drink the red koolaid together. I’m here for the audio and music!
I can only carefully calculate
Guess that if he will choose/
find it in his interest to analyse-
research the influence of low
quality switch on the output
performance of a streamer
he will sleep quite well this night and all the coming nights.
In the morning, he will wake up
and do what he is doing for a living…
I can also carefully assume that
He will focus on the end of the
Chain under the common sense
modern approach of - The manufacture/designer have to
Execute electronic audio +electro acoustical 2023 updated engineering know how.
No more, no less.
Be blessed, healthy, creative, free and prosper.
Amir actually isn't interested in proof that these things matter. He seems to only be interested in promoting his ideology....his faithful belief....that things like categorically *can't* matter. And, because of this broad based assumption, that he is permitted to dismiss them, mock them, and gaslight them. Because he claims "sCiEnCe!", he is unrebuttable.
That's his worldview. And the view of the goon squad that he cultivates on his forum; he corrects exactly zero people in his goon squad who assert the above. Therefore, he's aligned with it.
@@nathankimmett8803 I am an electrical engineer. Grew up with electronics design, before there was such a thing as a personal computer. Once that was invented, I also got into software so have both skills.
I really like your measurement, very helpfull!! In comparison with Amir's measurements, it shows it should be done from two angles! As some people said, it's not Amir not right or you have the answer, BUT it needs a combination of several measurepoints and therefore I prefer your approach!! Keep going, will definitely support your channel! Thanks a lot!
Thank you! Appreciate it!
It is the output of the DAC that counts. So it makes a lot of sense to measure that output as Amir did.
Beste, niet direct een vraag over het netwerk maar wat is jouw idee over het volgende.
Als je moet kiezen tussen een stream van AAC 128 kb/s of MP3 320 kb/s welke is volgens jou de beste kwaliteit?
Met vriendelijke groeten, Danny.
320 mp3
@@TheAlphaAudio Thank You 👍🏻
Very nice now measure the output of a dac so we can all see how huge impact it makes, right?
👍💥
Sommige zweren bij 2 of zelfs meerdere switchen in serie. Jullie dit als eens getest? Wel interessant namelijk om dit te onderbouwen
We hebben daarmee geëxperimenteerd. De isolatie kan verbeteren. Klank matig is het hit or miss...
@@TheAlphaAudio heb nu 2 netgears in serie lijkt wat meer rust te hebben, maar geen wereld verschil
@@domenicofpv6490 precies... hit or miss... maar ik werk liever met één goede met mooie voeding.
@@TheAlphaAudio wat is een goede? Heb 2 keer de netgear gs (uit jullie test) met lineair powersupply
@@domenicofpv6490 LHY maakt goede en betaalbare. Farad is prachtig. Pura met de Dodo ook.
Thank you for yet another informative video. Your finding of measurement changes is very useful to know. I have experienced the sound differences with better switches, but the naysayers are already out and about by the looks of it. No matter what comments you get your work is valued :)
@@baronvonaux8294 each to their own, i know what i hear and wouldnt part with money if a component wasnt audibly better, to me, noone else. Alpha do the technical tests as well as actual playback sessions, far more comprehensive than others - its a lot of work so be respectful. There are many things in hifi both digital and analogue that can be changed with all sorts of options and opinions and there is the 'cant possibly make it better' and cost/benefit angles. At the end of the day you can lead a horse to water but doesnt mean it has to drink it....
The Fix List!!!
1. Ferrite Beads on that network cable
2. Galvanic Isolation on the port
3 . Power the switch with a clean linear source.
(The circuit are built with a variance to manage noise)
A more complete test would verify any true effect confirming change from input to output
Or just buy a good network switch.
Just to clarify, 100ps of jitter is 0.0000000001second peak-to peak change, which then goes through a DAC anti jitter circuit and a PLL lock in which will pretty much intergrate this intto something an awful lot less. Nice measurements, but lack context.
100ps jitter is very, very audible... Also, we measure more than just jitter. Phase noise LowFreq modulation, clock stability, etc is also influenced by noise from a network. I would suggest to just sit down and listen. Especially a decent power supply will be audible in a good system.
Jitter is also additive, it will not always be removed and yes that jitter is absolutely audible.
@@TheAlphaAudio "100ps jitter is very, very audible."
Is there any published double blind test that support this claim?
@@TheAlphaAudioA turntable causes also jitter as the rotation speed is also not 100% accurate. Even the signal encoded in the groove causes a varying resistance - also the vinyl itself which is never 100% flat.
If 100 ps jitter would be "very audible" then listening even to a high end turnable would me an acoustic nigthmare.
That’s why Fiber media convertors are your friend.
Keep all that junk away from your dac.
Not always...
Show us!
Proper implementation of course.
@@cameronrector178 we have a complete article about that. And a blind test. Check our website.
Now everybody who can hear the difference between 9 and 10ps of jitter, please raise your hands. Thank you, now the ones that can hear the difference between -120 and -130db of noise. Thank you again. Btw, doubly shielded Cat6 ethernet cable is a few cents per meter terminated and you can get very well implemented switches with properly galvanically isolated ports (as per the Ethernet standard) starting at $30 or less.
Ok
All of that isn't important. The signal on the network does not care for the noise etc. This means the dac and clock shouldn't care either. If any of those parts are influenced by the noise on the network your problem is not the network but the dac (and clock). I know the expensive dacs are almost holy parts in the setup but they are goldmines for company's. In reality they are so cheaply build they can be influenced by noise on the network. With a good dac (even cheap ones) this isn't the case. A good dac has no problem with almost any level of noise on the network. As long as the digital signal can be read and the handshake still works there should be no issue. And if it fails your music pauses or totally stops playing but it will not decrease in quality, there is no loss of bass or space or whatever, it will just stop. So throw away that dac, buy a good one and be done with it.
Which DAC do you suggest then?
No it does not.
You are funny...
please measure what is comming out of dac outputs.@@TheAlphaAudio
Ruin, no. Negatively influence yes.
@@IHearEverythingDude how? I would need to run it through an A/D converter.... I tried it a couple of times: it doesnt work. Also: I measured the clock that feeds the dac... how much proof do you need?
@@TheAlphaAudioyou can’t convince people to look who don’t want to open there eyes. Please don’t try to appease to the audio science crowd.
There are lots of audiophiles who want to learn and see and don’t worship Amir the software engineer…
Keep up the great work - thank you!