How Putin's forces ‘deliberately starved’ Ukrainian civilians in Mariupol, Ukraine: The Latest
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 06. 2024
- Day 834.
Today, we bring you the latest military updates from the front lines and discuss a recent report that alleges Russia deliberately starved civilians during the siege of Mariupol.
Contributors:
David Knowles (Host). @DJKnowles on X
Francis Dearnley (Assistant Comment Editor). @FrancisDearnley on X.
Dom Nicholls (Associate Editor, Defence). @DomNicholls on X.
Hamish De Bretton Gordon (Former NATO Tank Commander). @HamishDBG on X.
Roland Oliphant (Senior Foreign Reporter). @RolandOliphant on Twitter
Catriona Murdoch (Senior legal consultant at Global Rights Compliance). @CatrionaMurdoc1 on X.
Articles Referenced:
Hamish’s article: www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024...
Roland’s article:
www.telegraph.co.uk/world-new...
Chalke Valley History Festival:
www.chalkefestival.com/
Subscribe to The Telegraph: telegraph.co.uk/ukrainethelatest
Email: ukrainepod@telegraph.co.uk
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Starvation has always been the primary weapon of siege. Most starvation in history has been quite intentional.
Yep. Russia killed millions of Ukrainians by starvation in 1932-1934.
Russia has a long history of using food as a tool to control people in regions it means to assimilate and it seems they see no reason to desist.
Like in Gaza.
Yes. What a horrible species we often are 😞
@@ericp1139 In almost every book of the Old Testament Bible. God willed it.
Daily stop for me, this podcast. From Finland. Slava Ukraini!!
Ты-же в курсе, что лозунг "Слава Украине!" - это нацистский лозунг, калька с аналогичного немецкого? У него было два официальных лозунга: "Героям Слава!" и "Вождю Слава!" - оба, в оригинале, сопровождались зигованием. Тоже зигуешь дома, перед зеркалом?
@@user-ee9dl2yq1ehe's from finland, collaborators, what else to expect.
Excellent newscast.
⚠️ The deliberate starvation of Ukrainian citizens in Mariupol during 2022 is significant.
Especially, as it was the 90th year since the 'Holodomor' took place in #Ukraine that killed millions of Ukrainians during 1932-33.
Many historians conclude, that the famine was deliberately engineered by Stalin to eliminate a Ukrainian independence movement...
🇺🇦
#standwithukraine
How come then over a million Russians and a million Kazakhs died too?
Stalin’s incompetence.
Fact: Stalin starved 6 million Ukrainians, and even stole train loads of top soil from Ukrainian farms.
There was region-wide collectivization of farms that started the famine, not only in Ukraine. Ukraine though suffered the most as Stalin blocked aid and free movement out of the starvation zone.
@@fiddlinfool1 The Holodomor targeted Ukrainians in Ukraine, Kuban', and other regions.
@djape1977
Many historians agree on both sides that Ukraine suffered the most, as four million had died or been killed, due to being targeted by Stalin.
The other one million were a mixture of ethic groups with many ethic #Ukrainians among them who lived outside #Ukraine 🇺🇦 in other parts of the former USSR.
Re the devil's advocate argument for the starvation of Mariupol: I find it hard to see the military necessity of a siege in a war which is itself an illegal war of aggression.
I find it extremely hard to believe the necessity of ukrainian army defending inside cities.
@@djape1977defenders against an illegal invasion can defend whatever territory they choose.
@@anthonyhulse1248an example of Paris in 1941 comes to mind.
It was declared to be an open city and nobody died.
That's an example of army taking care of it's civilians
@@djape1977 France surrendered and had to be rescued by outsiders, what an idiotic comment. Another example would be Stalingrad, which was flattened but helped break the back of the German army.
@@anthonyhulse1248 - sure but, using your own civilians as human shields is the lowest of the low ?
I’m an American and listen to every one of your shows. I believe it’s some of the most important journalism of my lifetime. I’m 44 years old and a very strong supporter of the sovereign democratic Ukraine in their fight for survival against a fascist authoritarian Russian dictatorship. Keep the outstanding work! I just wish I could work for and with your team somehow by spreading awareness of this podcast here in America.
lol
That "sovereign democratic" Ukraine has banned all opposition parties, closed down all opposition TV channels and has imposed martial law to prevent any parliamentary election. Furthermore, the President whose mandate expired at the beginning of this month, has failed to pass on the role to the Speaker of the Parliament as required under the constitution. Democratic? Hahahaha
@@user-wu1dv6jk5s I had a feeling a Russian bot or Trump cultist would reply 🤣🤦🏻♂️
no elections = no democracy
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Russia is a Barbaric Pirate state built on gangsterism , Francis is right , Ukraine is THE story and congratulations on your award which is well deserved , your podcast is , I think , the most important out there , we are in a very dangerous place and the next 5 years will shape our world for years to come , as a concerned citizen I firmly believe that Russian rhetoric re the Nuclear option is nothing but hot air and no one has said what the reply of the west would be if Putin was stupid enough to 'press that button'
And wat does that make ur country? Wat were u doing in syria, libya, and Iraq again? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I can't believe they don't have gas masks
Maybe someone should tell Grant Shapps
The UK leads the world in production of gas masks. They provide them to the US military. Maybe Britain could provide 100K to Ukraine. It would solve the problem.
They dont need them. There was one isolated incident of non lethal CS gas being used which of course it should not have been according to the laws of war, never mind that it can be used without limit on civilians.
Keep up this excellent podcast. It's always a pleasure to listen to it😊
Propaganda
Congratulations for winning the best newscast award from Colorado USA.
The ads are relentless
Get premium 😮
@@Azov777 I am holding the line for the boys
Yeah, these F#@k-ers can't get through a video without cramming sh!t ads down our collective throat.
I am seeking new from this organization through other media. I shouldn't have to pay for news via a premium account.
get F.Ree.Tube
Ye ol Red Sea Fleet never stood a chance.
Go beg for money
Sure they did
Keep up the great work guys, every day after work (since the beginning) I listen to your podcast!
Thx gents
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Milei could give a damn about Ukraine. He needs to put himself in a picture frame that makes him look good.
That merc must have had some serious work done as the back is just hanging on a thread with the roof missing
The podcast's reporting certainly deserves to receive awards. Your coverage of the resilient civilian and military response has given me ever greater respect for what a people can achieve in such adversity. I have followed this war's impacts since the first days and value this podcast's reports.
Now watch the UN ignore it, and blame Israel for the nth time this month...
Pusillanimous Putin
"Fair is foul", so too the air.
'Look! the emperor walketh bare!'
As he struts down marbled halls,
They gasp and shriek, 'he has no balls!'.
Mariupol..it was terrible😢
The city is being siege and then there is starvation. That happens during a siege. Hell that happens during a war. Why didn't the AFU evacuate the civilians out of the city? The AFU has evacuated entire front lines due to an impending Russian offensive. The Russians have done the same. The AFU is doing better on that front, so that is good. Doing something NATO would have never done.
Its not like they havent had years to move into russia and carry on with their lives .
Why should they give up their land?
I wonder when this war is over, if this channel won't run out of relevance on singing one tune.
This will not age well
Congratulations on the win. 🎉
whaT WIN?
Keep editing those comments Frank!
When I crossed the border into Poland the other night, young guys were being taken off the bus by the soldiers doing their draft stuff.
Human rights, European values
@@djape1977 exactly.
What a joke clown country Ukraine is.
It might be good in a short term but in the long term it's not a good idea! Everyone seems to get excited when Russia loses a 30 million piece of equipment but the immigration crisis in the United States alone is costing $150 billion dollars never mind every other thing that's going on
Such racism and xenophobia! Ignorance too.
Gives the US a very bad image in the world
*Pardon: Ukraine The Latest voted Best NEWS Podcast. (I'd left out the word News.)
“The Holodomor, also known as the Ukrainian Famine,was a man-made famine in Soviet Ukraine from 1932 to 1933 that killed millions of Ukrainians”.
Понятие голодомор придумала украинская пропаганда. Голод был во всём Советском Союзе из-за неурожая в 30-е годы XX века
Голодомор выдумала украинская пропаганда. Голод в 30-х годах был во всём СССР из-за неурожая
ЛОЖЬ !!!!!
It is true, Ivan.
@@user-jn6bk5ic2h how are your roubles doing today botnik?
Most cou tries do over the cou ter though right
When does g7 decide what europe does with assets. Also eu is on the hook to pay for it if it goes south right... us said they cant due to getting it passed congress... missing details is important... japan canada us deciding what eu tax payers need to cover right
(I'm sorry, side note here: WHAT IS WITH ALL THE AD INTERRUPTIONS!?!? The Telegraph never used to be so horribly cut up into little bits like this. It's awful!)
I'm paying for ad-free YT and there are no interruptions. Much more pleasant!
Use an Adblocker, ive not had an advert on CZcams for a couple of years.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Didn’t once see telegraph post about Israel starving Palestine loool 😂
Dont laugh at that mate.
35:00e stuck with the Telegraph because we are sticking with Ukraine. All of the freedom-loving world is supporting Ukraine! Slava Ukraine!
So the 82% of humanity is not freedom loving?
Slava ukraini 🇺🇦 🇺🇸
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
utter garbage
15:05 Not only this war, Netenyahoo will not be happy lmao. 😂😬🤣
Pootins agony already started
What agony, who's pootin?
Joe Biden seems to poop his pants on regular basis
I'm still waiting for the ICC Chief Investigator's report on Bucha - it's almost like it was a complete fabrication ?
Twice in the UN Russia has asked for the forensic reports and twice been met with silence !
Of course it was. Speaking as an art historian, to a trained eye a naturally random distribution bears no resemblance to a visual composition consciously designed.
oh yeah, and MH17 was full of frozen bodies, shot down by Ukrainian jet and was an assassination plot against Putin. Wacko.
No, massacre really happened, but it wasn't Russians that did it.
Do your homework, Russian propagandist.
Hey Brits...
Take our President PUTIN's peace proposal before us Americans march thoug London.
London is a cute little place.
Keep it that way
Stop the lies
Is using starvation considered a war crime?
To put this “Russia and Venezuela are building rockets together” thing into perspective: outside the biggest cities, 48 percent of Russians do not have an access to indoor toilets.
In America they just use the sidewalks these days...
Is different in Ukraine? They don’t have outside toilets anymore?
so many idiots with such levels of stupidity among the English and Americans 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@richardmarsden1897Piss off, Q-nut.
- 99% of Ukraine doesn't have access to electricity, fresh water, or a flushing toilet... horses for courses... what's your point other than every Russian has a shovel and a washing machine (stolen from Ukraine) ?
21:38 This guy gets Maximum Comedy Gold Points. Every statement a Joke.
LOL! They all sound like Hobbits with their silly, ignorant and juvenile drivel.
Spot the Russian bot. 🙄
@@TheMagicLemur Spot the NAFO chump
@@TheMagicLemur Spot the gulible mantra blabber 😬
@@SirKeefyKeef Spot the Russian bot who offers insult instead of reason. 🤦
Imagine gambling with Nukes
Ukraine should have never poked the bear.
Explain that.
Russia illegally invaded the internationally recognised sovereign democratic country of Ukraine. Ukraine did not incvade the Russian Federation. End of story.
What have bears got to do with any of this?
@daydays12 illegally huh. Tell me about Syria , Iraq , Afghanistan, Libya , and all the other countries the Weat illegally started wars with
Russia made it pretty clear that adding more Nato countries on its border was a red line.
This idiot is a troll - bot from the
®°°§k@ bot farm. Not even worth a response.@@daydays12
@@daydays12it’s probably a bot mate
@@edtabor1165 🙂
Air parity .. .. .. .. this is Orwell level stuff.
@johnknight8152
Troll incoming!
Beware!
Kremlin trolls wage an information war and pedal lies.
Their Ministry of Truth is srcond to none.
They may be losing, but their lies and spin will ensure they always pass over silence what was done in Mariupol.
It is staggering and truly disgusting.
They enjoy Western freedom of speech online, but not in their Great Mother Russia where core values and humanity are sorely lacking in a climate of Russian public's acceptance and even support.
Let's welcome all the hard work to expose their lies.
LOL
The Reform party in Canada was also a movement in the Western provinces with spread anger in those provinces against Eastern centric parties as the Conservatives were perceived to be.
Furthermore, the Tory vote in Quebec went to the PQ.
It is fair to say that the Reform party is essentially regional party in for England.
austerity, a tory tactic. pootin is a tory.
Div
@@TheHappyhorus :slow clap:
"they were quick to point out they werent using nuclear warheads"
why "quick"? compared to what? should they be slow? should they not inform of this at all?
is this news or pure propaganda and editorialising?🤨
Besieged cities don’t get supplies, that’s sort of the definition of a siege.
Russians organized several humanitarian corridors for civilians to leave, Azov stopped them.
Remember that when it's a Russian city under siege
A clear sign that things have radically changed is the use of the term "the Israel Project" in contrast to discussions of Israel, the state. Its days are numbered and will disappear as the thankful end of an antiquated failed experiment as was the Third Reich and the Soviet Union.
A clear sign that things have radically changed is the use of the term "the Israel Project" in contrast to discussions of Israel, the state. Its days are numbered and will disappear as the thankful end of an antiquated failed experiment as was the Third Reich and the Soviet Union.
@@djape1977 nonsense. ruZZia bombed the humanitarian corridors. Look it up.
Any crime related to Netanayu is a waste .The US says so
Deliberate starvation of over 2 million people in Gaza enthusiastically endorsed by Tories and Labour.
Captured mercenaries of the Georgian National Legion in Ukraine, recognized as a terrorist organization in Russia, have said that they were trained by NATO instructors, including those from Sweden and New Zealand, with the Main Directorate of Intelligence of the Ukrainian Defense Ministry acting as the organizer. A video of their testimony has been released by the Federal Security Service (FSB).
One of the POWs said that he had been trained at a base of Azov, a terrorist group recognized as terrorist in Russia. Since 2023 he has been "trained by NATO instructors".
Another prisoner stated that after signing a contract they "went to Liman (in the Nikolaev Region) and a couple of days later they moved to training grounds."
"There were instructors from Europe, NATO instructors - Swedes and New Zealanders - who instructed the trainees in tactics, the operation of drones, how to move about in pairs and groups of three, and assault technique." A female instructor who introduced herself as Shannon, from New Zealand, taught medical skills.
"The training took place in Kiev, a former tractor factory, the ATEF," another POW said. "During the training, supervisors from the Main Intelligence Directorate [of the Ukrainian Defense Ministry] came there periodically. Foreign instructors also came to observed the training process. "I know that I am a Georgian citizen, I am a mercenary, yes, I fought for money," he confessed.
A fourth prisoner said that on Polish territory he failed to join the "international legion" and had to join the Georgian one. The ideology of the Georgian Legion, he said, was Russophobia: "kill Russians and do not to take prisoners."
"They indulged in looting rather than defended positions," he stated. "They gave incomprehensible orders to shoot civilians under the pretext that they were saboteurs, throwing grenades at Azov personnel." According to the POW, when he saw once an Azov officer shoot a civilian, he approached him, but did not see any grenades or weapons on the killed man. He also testified that the chiefs of the Georgian Legion trained their subordinates in reconnaissance and sabotage and promised a cash reward.
- nothing new, America has been training international terrorists for over 20 years ?
- nothing new, America has been training international terrorists for over 20 years ?
Hahaha nobody believes your Kremlin lies, fool.
More crappy Russian disinformation. 💩
I follow this pod closely. But poor pronunciation really grates. Please can these professionals say “New klee are”. It is absolutely not “nookeler”.
We all remember how Zelensky's soldiers did not let civilians out of Mariupol, but for some reason Putin is personally to blame😆
putler killed 300 russian speakers in a Mariupol theatre. Go peddle your filthy lies elsewhere vatnik.
- even Amnesty International called out Ukraine for using human shields ?
Lies lies and again lies! What can be accepted from russian bots.
The propaganda used here is telling.
It was NOT Zelensky who said "not even a fly will escape!"
Wasn't it the members of Azov that were preventing civilians feom leaving the combat zone despite Russians establishing several humanitarian corridors?
Amnesty international reported on Ukrainian army using the civilians as shields.
No Azov was seen warning civilians that Russia was shelling the evacuation routes. Russian forces were bombarding the area of Mariupol where some of the 200,000 people gathering to try and flee the city. Many of the roads had also been mined
Typical genocidal Russians.
@@foilhat1138interesting. I distinctly remember a video of soldiers with Azov patches shooting up a civilian car on a checkpoint just outside Mariupol. I guess I shouldn't believe my own eyes.
Also I remember Russia organized humanitarian corridors for civilians to leave.
Remind me please, why was it necessary to defend inside the city?
Ruzzia was using those routes to kill Ukrainians.
Nope - that's crappy Russian disinformation. 💩
22:23 Football analogies are lazy journalism but patronising condescending rubbish.
Pathetic.
No they're not: it's the Euros.
Want Lazy journalism? Try Moscow State TV!
Football analogies are great. Ukraine has a goalie and the crowd behind them. Ruzzia has 12 Vinnie Jones, no goalie and very few (but very deluded) supporters.
@@anthonyhulse1248 🤮🤮😂
@@anthonyhulse1248 It just intrigues me that old guys love to watch young men in shorts running around getting all hot n sweaty, seems a bit of a weird way to pass their time. 🤪😬😜
@@SirKeefyKeef mmmmmmm 🙂 Women like watching young men in tight shorts playing rugby. Why should that be I wonder!
ICC is a waste of time.One standard for Putin and different standard for Israeli PM
Holodomor.
Reich changed to EU, but propaganda is the same.
Unbelievable amount of absolute nonsense these people speak
Garbage propaganda
🤣🤣 try harder
Gonna cry, Putin’s cuck slave?
r u even human ...? certainly cannot string a sentance together ...a feckin nightmare world ..
No need. Current reporting ensures Russian Bot reactions every time!