Quran Proven!? Scientific miracle of the seas not mixing examined
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 04. 2022
- Non-Muslims mock the idea that the Quran could be from a divine being, but Muslims respond with proof that it is from God: it contains scientific facts that were unknown in the 7th century, but since have been proven. Commonly called "scientific miracles," these claims must be tested to see if they hold up to scrutiny. Previously, I developed five criteria to do just that.
In this video, I am attacked by a jinn who spreads these claims, trying to get me to believe in the "miracle" of seas not mixing. Fortunately a have my trusty blanket to protect me, and the criteria to guide me. But will I survive the jinn attack, or will I take my shahada?
An Indonesian translation can be found here: • Video
Support me on Patreon: / reasonedanswers
or PayPal: www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted...
Like on Facebook: / reasonedanswers
Follow on Twitter: / reasonedanswers
Feel free to email with any questions: thaddeus@reasonedanswers.com
Sources cited:
- 1 John 4:1 (ESV): "Beloved, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God, for many false prophets have gone out into the world."
- "The Seas not mixing with each other ┇ Quran and Modern Science" by IslamSearch • Video
- Quran 55:19-20 (Sahih International): "He released the two seas, meeting [side by side]; Between them is a barrier [so] neither of them transgresses."
- Marine Geology by Ph. H. Kuenen
- "Do Two Oceans Meet in This Photograph?" by David Mikkelson (Snopes) www.snopes.com/fact-check/two...
- Quran 25:53 (Sahih International): "And it is He who has released [simultaneously] the two seas, one fresh and sweet and one salty and bitter, and He placed between them a barrier and prohibiting partition."
- Shaih Bukhari 3238: Narrated Jabir bin `Abdullah: that he heard the Prophet (ﷺ) saying, "The Divine Inspiration was delayed for a short period but suddenly, as I was walking. I heard a voice in the sky, and when I looked up towards the sky, to my surprise, I saw the angel who had come to me in the Hira Cave, and he was sitting on a chair in between the sky and the earth. I was so frightened by him that I fell on the ground and came to my family and said (to them), 'Cover me! (with a blanket), cover me!' Then Allah sent the Revelation: "O, You wrapped up (In a blanket)! (Arise and warn! And your Lord magnify And keep pure your garments, And desert the idols." (74.1-5)
- Sunan an-Nasa'i 933: It was narrated that Aishah said: "Al-Harith bin Hisham asked the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ): 'How does the Revelation come to you?' He said: 'Like the ringing of a bell, and when it departs I remember what he (the Angel) said, and this is the hardest on me. And sometimes he (the Angel) comes to me in the form of a man and gives it to me.'"
See also: the original source of the viral photo in the thumbnail: www.flickr.com/photos/kentsmi...
#ScientificMiracles #ScientifcForeknowledge #SeasNotMixing
----
Muslim "miracle" video is copyrighted and used in accordance with fair use (see link above). Images and videos of "sea" boundaries are copyrighted works, used in accordance with fair use. All other material is public domain or royalty free work used in accordance with its licensing agreements.
This video is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 (CC BY-SA 4.0) license. You may freely share and modify this video however you see fit provided you 1) give credit by linking back to the original and 2) release any modifications under the same license. Full legal details can be found at: creativecommons.org/licenses/... - Zábava
I put a lot of extra into the editing of this one, so please let me know if you think this is worthwhile. To get the chance to help improve my videos with your feedback before they are published, please join me on Patreon: www.patreon.com/ReasonedAnswers
This video is even more entertaining in light of the video I mock: czcams.com/video/oUAQy14g0Qc/video.html
I like the content, and the editing, of course. Keep it up!
That was a lot of work. Pretty cool. CZcams just recommended me this. It was a bit hard to follow while you were doing the fake freezing bit but it was pretty cool. It was interesting and not borinIg at all. I think you did really good. The title caught my attention. I was going to just click to dislike the video because of the title but I watched it and I like it. If you get a dislike it's probably by someone who didn't watch it and read the title haha. Just ignore that. You did great.
hello.considering that a verse after the water/sea verse, mentions about coral.so could the water topic be about coral reef waters.
I read that coral waters requires salty water for survival and that fresh river water mixing with ocean salty water is no good for coral reef waters.
“by the way, did you know the bell is an instrument of Satan” 🤣 💀
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Hells bells czcams.com/video/etAIpkdhU9Q/video.html
THIS is the best video I seen from you brother T...! I mean, fantastic editing, humor (I almost woke up my sleeping wife from laughing!) , and great refutation overall with information. This was class! Your hard work paid off.
To be honest, I found the acting to be a little *too* much.
@@Draezeth Thanks for the honest feedback!
The only miracle of Islam is it's believers believing without understanding and memorizing and recitings without comprehending..
Brother Thaddeus u r getting creative..Hope ringing of bell is not loud for you.
I'm Fisher man here in central America. I've seen many of those . We called it two waters. Dos aguas. That happy when to currents collide . You'll see lots of trash there . In the Caribbean people go to see if they find coke 😉. Floating there
Thanks for the first hand experience! So basically, not a fixed border and directly observable to anyone with a boat. Damn, double fail for the "miracle" claim it seems.
There are fresh-water wells in the sea before Bahrain which apprear in such a way that the fresh water rises to the top of salt-water. The Arab fischermen in that area knew about them long before Mohammed mentioned it in the quran. Of course the freshwater from those unterwater wells does mix with the salt water and there is no barrier between them.
Good observation. No miracle here, any way you slice it. Guess I better cancel my plans to shahahada at the next Zakir Naik event.
@@ReasonedAnswers Good reasoning on your part. But lets see what zakir naik comes up next to persuade his followers.
Any source to this please
@@ReasonedAnswers hey brother any references to this bahrain claim
*Greetings from Indonesia to all my bros & sists in CHRIST all over the world. "HE" bless us all 🙋 🙏*
In the Islamic world 🌎 this observable phenomenon needed a revelation from up above the 7th heaven by Allah as a scientific miracle.
Well this is a religion that needs instructions on how to wipe oneself, so it's not surprising. :)
😂🤣 Bishop T's quite the thespian. Please, give this man an Oscar.
I laughed my head off and almost fell of my chair as I watched you wrapped in a blanket receiving Wahi from angelic beings in the ringing of bells...lol
God bless you Brother, keep the videos coming...
This comment made my night. Thanks so much.
@@ReasonedAnswers Yes Bro, a good effort needs to be appreciated.Keeping you and my other brethren in prayer.Hope I can support your ministry soon.
@Juliet Abraham Your prayers are much appreciated! 🙏
@@vladimirputin7672 Trust only a filthy mouth ummi abdoooooool to make a vulgar comment.Read Sura 6:101....miskeen lah ya yafooor he needs a consort to have a son so Mary can have a son without a husband....but Lah cannot.Why U hiding your identity with a nonabdoolian name like your Ggod lah who speaks from behind a veil Sura 42:51....I have the last laugh...
This made my day
Blanket doing justice
I love it!!!! You’re getting great at this!!!
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
This sounds like a claim made by shake ibn fibbin, the masaha
Does Uthman push scientific miracle nonsense? (Real question - I actually don't know.)
@@ReasonedAnswers
Yes he does. DW had made a video on how ibn fibbin uses verses in the ko-ooran to tell his audience that the big bang theory was mentioned in it.
Did you sit in the freezer for that one?
I live in Switzerland and we have a bunch of glacier lakes. Why didn't I think of that. Because the glacier lakes look exactly like this. this milky light turquoise color.
Thank you for the video.
Good to see you here since I made the video specifically for you. :)
Nice brother 👍
Why didn't anyone tell me this before? Where's this shat-tada I keep hearing about, so I might take it?
Hmm, I think it goes "I testify that there is no bathroom etiquette except allah's and muhammad is the of the odd stone messenger."
@@ReasonedAnswers My Midleestern's a bit rusty, but here goes nothing:
*La ilaha il Yehoah, Moshe raseul Yehoah.*
Where are my virgins? What, do I have to die first? DAMN, I hate buyer's remorse.
Richard Dawkins once rather cheekily,while visiting the science lab of an Islamic school in England,demonstrated to a young girl,she was of course clad in hijab,and he made salt water and fresh mix in a test tube,thus pointing out that the Koran may have been a little bit out!
Haha, that is pretty funny.
I enjoyed video. Got to the Problem with Quaran and exposed it Scientifically and kept you entertained the whole time where time passed without feeling every minute of the time. Solid Work
Thank you for the encouragement and feedback!
@@ReasonedAnswers yw enjoy
The answer to that verse is quite clear and everybody misses it: it is refering to the two seas: the sea of Galilee (sweet) and the Dead sea (salty), connected to each other and "magically" becomes one or the other. (we know the phenomenon, and it happens elsewhere, like the Caspian sea). We know Muhammad knew this region, either being native (revisionist) or traveling (traditional), by other such verses as saying the Quraysh pass by Lot's wife day and night (also Dead Sea area) - Sura 34:134-137
That's another possibility. There is just no way to make it miraculous, I'm afraid (except imagination, which doesn't count).
🤣😂lovely bells oh wait... this reminds me of a bewitched profit🤨
Hey, hey. Let's be fair. The bewitching was a totally separate incident than ringing bells (which apparently happened at every "revelation.") 😄
Thank you for your ministry 💖🙏💖🙏💖🙏💖
'Science' in Islam means 'mumbo jumbo nonsense'
For example, hadith "science" means hadith 'mumbo jumbo nonsense'
'Science' (or scientific) miracles means 'mumbo jumbo nonsense' miracles
Islam loves to redefine words, so I think you are on to something! When a Msulim says the Quran is scientific, they aren't lying, they have just redefined "scientific" to mean "nonsensical." It all makes sense now! Thanks for clearing that up. 😁
@@ReasonedAnswers So we should believe in Christian Sky daddy who was defeated by Jacob in wrestling match. 🙈😂😂
The fart was mentioned 1400 years ago .
Muhammad also.
Biggest Islamic miracle: Islam still existing. lol
Fact! ... Give it 100 years and Islam will be a shell of its former self I think. The internet akbar allah.
@@ReasonedAnswers You mean I could be an ordained imam just by filling out a form and growing a beard?! Hot damn! Lol
@@ReasonedAnswers In your dream.
@@andanandan6061 If your level of "thought" is typical of Islam, then it will probably be more like 50 years.
One of Islam bigest miracle is Prophet Muhammad himself. Despite unlettered, Didnt boast magic miracle that Christian love so much just like how Quraish Kufar in 7th Century demand for magic miracle from Prophet, He (pbuh) manage to transform all pagans and cross worshipers together with racist jewish to be his follower. He created law in 7th Jahliyah Arab just like Moses brought law to the jews. That is why He is Rated as No. 1 most influencial figure and Jesus pbuh put in third place bcz He (pbuh) didn't complete his mission instead He (pbuh) got hijacked by Paul. Unfortunate but let us wait his 2nd coming. Do you think He'll welcome lawless Trinitarian Christian when He himself insisted to keep the Law ?
I think this might have it's origins in an ancient idea of the world of darkness and the world of light, each having sources of bitter water and sweet water respectively. Remember that the great rivers of mo's little world come from jenna...
That's a good point. If I remember correctly, the hadith speak of the 4 rivers of Jannah, but strangely two of them connect to earth.
@@ReasonedAnswers Nah they're all rivers in the near east/central asia. Euphrates, Nile, Jaxartes, and Oxus. In many ancient cosmologies the fresh(good) water came from heaven and the salty/bitter water(and sometimes the worldsea) ultimately coming from the underworld. With the earth(s) as the barrier in between.
@@ReasonedAnswers Ok found the hadith you were talking about in Bukari. Yeah that account of the isra only mentions the Nile and Euphrates. Sahih Muslim has a hadith that names the four rivers.
Muhammad thought the sky was a sea, a sea of fresh water. The key insights are: "Between them is a barrier [so] neither of them transgresses." and "He placed between them a barrier and prohibiting partition." This barrier is the vertical distance between ground and sky. These two "seas" only mix when it rains. Muhammad didn't know about the water cycle.
Your overall suggestion is backed by al-Taberi and al-Qurtubi and no doubt others, so it's plausible. However, I am curious on this line: _"These two "seas" only mix when it rains."_ Was that just your statement, or do you think that is something the Islamic texts teach? If the latter, can you be specific?
@@ReasonedAnswers See my pages about the two seas for my complete reasoning. See: Koran - Two Seas?
@@AndrewMartinNZ Will do!
22;46
"Indeed, it is not the eyes that go blind, but the hearts."
Indeed, your heart has gone blind. Turn on your mind and maybe the heart will follow it out of Islam.
@@ReasonedAnswers no, I'm not a polytheist like you
@@939o2jdheieiusuenbfjdjebhdjej I'm not a polytheist, but thanks for confirm your mind is off... Prove me wrong by answering this simple question: what is the best evidence that Islam is true?
@@ReasonedAnswers there are many proofs that Islam is true, but I want to show you this:
The meaning of "Islam" is: submission to the will of God.
So, all prophets were muslims, also Jesus.
@@939o2jdheieiusuenbfjdjebhdjejUm, all religions teach submission to God. What makes you think Islam has the correct form of submission and to the correct deity?
Brother ☺️
This vedio was useful for me. I will expose the Lie of Sheikh Uthmans lies tomorrow in Bible or Quran Channel with Our dear brother Anthony. God bless you for your research.
Islam: What They Dont Tell You has recently made a video about this titled "Part 40: Waters Never Mix: The Honest Truth" be sure to watch.
Will do
"But the Bible says.."
Ah, the swiss army knife of Islamic "apologetics."
lala is a mouse!!! His prophesies are coming true
description seems untrue. Mockery ? The real mockery here is Christian depiction of God that somehow look like sky daddy. Atheism mockery to theist came from this. 🙈
Changing the topic because the lie about water not mixing humiliates Islam?
What exactly is untrue? Please be specific. Facts aren't determined by your feelings.
And while you are at it, please give us one good reason to believe Islam is true, or admit you have none and your confidence is based solely on non-Muslims being sub-human trash according to your "god."
We arent the ones whose god looks like Adam and the Antichrist.
@@toomanymarys7355 Islam is an Abrahamic religion. Meaning Abraham is a descendant of Adam. So I fail to see the point of your comment.
@@toomanymarys7355 the number of the anti-christ is 666. The number of the Islamic caliphate is 666 and they wear this number on their right hands and foreheads.
And Walking saint zombie in Jerusalem after Jesus resurection seen by " MANY" was real. 🙈😂
Changing the topic because the lie about water not mixing humiliates Islam?
Nice red herring fallacy. Do you claim that the Quran contains "scientific miracles" or not?
@Andan Andan are you ashamed of your "prophet"😏😏... What more silly things are in that stupid Quran apart from false claims of *scientific* miracles??
The quran speaks of Christ as well. Even the quran said that christ is in heaven with the father and will one day return. Every religion acknowledges Christ. Since you probably don't know if that's how you speak the word Christ is Greek for Messiah.
I found this ad and loved it
Thank you for the kind encouragment!