INDIAN Bishop cautions Catholic CHARISMATIC Preachers ( Joseph Dinesh)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 20. 06. 2024
  • Read the full document here - dioceseofmangalore.com/bishop...
    00:00 Intro
    00:44 Appreciation of the Charismatic Renewal
    02:00 Charismatic Renewal to the Authority of the Catholic Church
    04:20 Complaints against the Charismatic Renewal
    Catholic Apostolate
    Song on Fire Catholic Ministries is an Apostolate that uses the New media to present the beauty of Catholic Lifestyle, Communicate the Catholic Teaching, appreciate the fullness of Catholic Faith and defend the Catholic Church
    Support the Song on Fire Mission
    / songonfire
    Get in touch - songonfire16@gmail.com

Komentáře • 80

  • @allegrowesternmusicclasses3268
    @allegrowesternmusicclasses3268 Před 7 měsíci +3

    PRAISE GOD FOR OUR BISHOP'S DECLARATION.
    PRAYING FOR CATHOLIC CHARISMATIC EVANGELIZATION TO BE THE MAIN SOURCE TO PROTECT OUR SAINTLY CHURCH TO REMAIN THE SAME FOR EVER. AMEN.

  • @aaronnself
    @aaronnself Před 7 měsíci +4

    Very good action taken by our Bishop. God bless Him.

  • @jacksoncastelino04
    @jacksoncastelino04 Před 7 měsíci +12

    A very Good initiative by the Bishop.
    Praying for him, May God Give him Grace to Restore and Reform The Holy Mother Church.
    Praying for The Restoration of Traditional Catholic Faith.

  • @irenecastelino8827
    @irenecastelino8827 Před 7 měsíci +9

    Thank You JD for bringing out The Holy work of Bishop Peter Paul Saldanha.
    May God bless him for protecting his Flocks from All dangers .
    May God Grant him Grace to Be Courageous in defending The Deposit of Faith.
    May God help him to Restore The Lost Tradition and Traditional Catholic Faith and practices.
    God bless you Joseph Dinesh for working for The Restoration of Traditional Catholic Faith

  • @fr.franklindsouza2178
    @fr.franklindsouza2178 Před 6 měsíci

    I read whole document. But we need to guide the laity spiritually. Those priests who are in renewal ministry should accompany them. Bishop circular is very clearly mentioned about witnessing in life. I appreciate the courage in giving guidance by the Bishop.

  • @georgethomasn1504
    @georgethomasn1504 Před 7 měsíci +8

    Very good initiative...🙏🙏🙏

  • @jasonfernandes9713
    @jasonfernandes9713 Před 7 měsíci +6

    Bishop Peter has already proven to be a shepherd in charge by earlier asking the faithful to dutifully recite only the Nicene creed on Sundays and days of Obligation.
    God Bless His excellency and his efforts to sustain the catholic faith in Mangalore

  • @vbv454
    @vbv454 Před 7 měsíci +3

    Well said Joseph appreciate your CZcams clarification to Bishop’s Document.
    Regards,
    Fr Bernard

    • @godforgivesusinchristcruci5690
      @godforgivesusinchristcruci5690 Před 7 měsíci

      *Clergy Anti Scriptural Preaching - false Gospel -br Jhonson Sequira's Gospel (JCILM) is authentic*
      The Preaching
      Of the Bishops
      And priests is Anti Scriptural
      They
      Are *against* the
      Manifestation of the charisms
      Thus they betray
      The very purpose of God
      To His People
      They want
      Spiritually impotent Gospel
      And
      The gospel where
      Work of the flesh manifest:
      Thier oratory skills in sermons
      And in Retreats,
      Engineering skill,
      Psychological tricks and skills,
      Educational skills,
      Organisational skills,
      Anthropological skill
      And
      Running business
      In the name
      Of the Lord/
      In the name of mission skills
      To be exhibited
      Bishop and priests are
      Anti Charismatic gift:
      Anti healing Ministry
      Anti Deliverance Ministry
      Anti Gift of tongues
      And anti other Charismatic gift
      Bishop in the circular
      Cautions
      Not to seek after
      Charismatic Gifts
      And
      Quotes John of the cross
      Jhon of the Cross' Teaching
      Anti scriptural:
      It is against the
      Teaching of the Lord,
      Teaching of the Apostle
      Peter and Paul
      Remember John of the cross
      Lived in a
      Time
      Where the Church has
      Driven away the
      Holy Spirit out of the Church
      And
      Only at Vatican II
      Pope opened the doors
      To the Holy Spirit
      And
      Charismatic Renewal
      Emerged afterwards
      Therefore
      John of the cross
      Needs to be corrected !
      (Cantalmessa says
      Christian Theological institute
      In Europe
      Have kicked out Jesus)
      Jesus commanded to
      Heal
      And deliver
      Apostle Paul teaches
      1 cor 14:1
      Make love your aim,
      And *EARNESTLY DESIRE*
      The *spiritual gifts*,
      Especially that
      You may prophesy.
      John of the cross Teaching
      Violates this
      Revealtion in scripture
      Bishops and Priests
      Because of their pride
      Exhibit bias on
      Praying in Tongues
      This is against the
      Scripture
      I cor 14:9
      Therefore,
      My brothers and sisters,
      Be eager to prophesy, a
      And do *NOT FORBID* Speaking in tongues
      They say
      Marian Devotion
      Is not an end in itself
      But a means to go to Jesus
      But when Charismatic have
      Reached to Jesus
      By adhering to the Gospel
      They want to
      Pull them out of Jesus
      And
      Force them
      You go to Mary and saints
      (Again and again
      Invoke Mary and saints)
      All Marian Devotions
      Rosary,
      Aparations
      Etc
      Even discerned and
      Approved by the Church
      Belongs to the
      Private revealtion
      They don't add anything
      To the Revealed Word of God
      No bishop
      No priest
      Can compel or force it
      Upon the faithful
      It may be Catholic
      But Unchristian
      And it is a grave offence
      To compel
      It is the abuse of the
      Spiritual authority
      Catholic Bishop/priests
      Preaching/practice is
      Against making
      New Disciple of the Lord
      From other faith
      It is
      A direct violation of
      Christianity
      This is not Christianity at all
      This is
      Anti Jesus Christ practice
      They want tradition
      Not
      Life in the Spirit
      The other day
      A priest had held a meeting
      It was on all saints day
      Since people had missed
      The mass
      Some of them requested
      Him for mass
      He said
      "It is not an obligatory mass,
      You don't have to feel bad
      If you had missed it
      It is an optional mass"
      Poor priest
      Instead of telling
      I am not interested/
      I don't have time /
      I don't have heart
      He was so diplomatically
      Trying to pacify the
      Request
      By Playing the trump card
      Of obligation
      And non obligation
      And you expect the
      Gospel of Grace to be preached
      By the clergy?
      Authentic charismatic Renewal
      By the clergy?
      "Charismatic Renewal"
      "Charisms"
      Not obligatory
      They say
      Sunday mass and
      Days of obligation
      And the rosary that we
      Compelled you to pray
      That is your prayer life
      And
      Not the relationship with God
      Through Charismatic Renewal
      They will say
      Fundamentally
      Bishop and priests
      Violate
      All these scriptural Teaching
      They practice wrong
      Therefore when
      Person like
      Brother Jhonson Sequira
      Preaches authentic Gospel
      They can't tolerate it
      And judge his Preaching
      As anti scriptural
      (Though I have
      Difference of opinion
      About certain Teaching
      Of Jhonson...
      But such faulty Preaching
      Are plentiful among
      Catholic priests themselves;
      Greatest faulty Preaching
      Is supressing charisms)
      Jesus said
      In 14:12
      "Very truly I tell you,
      Whoever believes in me
      Will Do The Works
      I have been doing,
      And they will do
      *EVEN GREATER THINGS*
      *THAN THESE*
      Because I am going
      To the Father
      But priests and Bishops
      Get extremely jelous
      When laity do
      Greater things
      And
      When crowd gather
      Out of jelousy
      Insecurity
      Money minded
      Commercial priests,
      And spirituality
      Currpted by Clericalism
      They
      Try to put obstacles
      To the lay Ministry like
      Br Sajith,
      Br Prakash etc etc
      And ignorantly say
      "Preachers drawing
      Attention to themselves"
      No no no !!!
      No Prakash
      No tk George
      No Sajith
      No Wilfred
      Have ever asked the crowd
      To worship us
      We have and all the laity
      Have pointed out to Jesus
      Exceptions may be there
      But many more priests
      I can show who
      Draw attention to themselves
      Therefore
      Will you print a circular
      And
      Suspend the
      Catholic priesthood ??????
      Bishop and Priests
      Practice false Gospel
      Therefore our authentic Gospel
      Sounds
      "False Preaching"
      To them
      Bishops and Priests
      Your discernment
      About the Charismatic Renewal
      And the
      Lay Ministries
      Has gone
      Absolutely wrong
      Because
      Your Teaching/Preaching
      And practice of
      Christianity is wrong
      You have
      Substituted the
      Your Gospel of Law and flesh
      To
      The Gospel of Grace
      Preached by Jesus
      And
      The Apostles
      It *is a curse*
      Just to depend on
      Clergy Preaching
      Because Their Gospel
      Is intended to
      Keep the believer in Bondage
      Intended to preach
      Impotent Gospel
      Clergy Preaching is
      Secular
      Not Spiritual
      (Exceptions Noticed)
      Kindly forward it to the Pope, Bishops, cardinal, priests, and lay leaders.... I own responsibility for each and every word spoken here....
      Loving
      Wilfred Sunil Rodrigues
      God Forgives us in Christ Crucified Ministries

    • @aliceshaletdsouza8252
      @aliceshaletdsouza8252 Před 7 měsíci +1

      Please pray for the restoration of Traditional Latin mass

    • @jdosvd
      @jdosvd Před 7 měsíci

      ​@@aliceshaletdsouza8252why are you spamming Alice ?
      We heard you and you are 100 % correct ! Please do Not spam !!

    • @aliceshaletdsouza8252
      @aliceshaletdsouza8252 Před 7 měsíci

      @@jdosvd Please Pray for The Restoration of Traditional Catholic Faith

    • @jdosvd
      @jdosvd Před 7 měsíci

      @@aliceshaletdsouza8252 Oh No ! Too Late for that as the apocalypse is at the doorstep.
      Urgent Prayers for those going to hell please.
      Queen and Mother of the Last Times Snatch us out of the clutches of Evil 😈

  • @dailymanna6806
    @dailymanna6806 Před 7 měsíci +1

    Please share the document link

  • @RyngkatPhawa-gz4mw
    @RyngkatPhawa-gz4mw Před 6 měsíci

    What is sale of indulgence

  • @abrahamphilip6439
    @abrahamphilip6439 Před 5 měsíci

    Led by one who sits in the chair of Peter , who made an Image for the rebellious Apostate Martin Luther --

  • @rosejoseph9987
    @rosejoseph9987 Před 7 měsíci +1

    One community holds the reigns it's moved from being led by the spirit to the flesh.
    Wrong people sitting in high seats. Resulting in chaos within the Renewal.

  • @neenutomi316
    @neenutomi316 Před 7 měsíci

    From the " My Heart Will Triumph " by Mirjana of Medjugorje
    On the contrary, Our Lady has taught us that the blessing of Jesus only comes through a priest. “Their hands are blessed by my Son,” she said, and she often repeats that our priests do not need our judgment; they need our prayers. Many people abandon or reject faith because they find fault in a priest, but this is only an excuse. God will judge priests on how well they carried out their missions and He will judge us on how well we treated them. St. Francis of Assisi held a similar view. When parishioners from a nearby village complained to Francis that their priest was living in sin, he went with them to their village. The residents expected Francis to admonish their wayward shepherd, but instead Francis got on his knees and kissed the priest’s hands. “All I know and all I want to know is that these hands give me Jesus,” said Francis. “These hands have held God.”

  • @rosejoseph9987
    @rosejoseph9987 Před 7 měsíci +3

    Excellent..

  • @aliceshaletdsouza8252
    @aliceshaletdsouza8252 Před 7 měsíci +1

    Excellent decision taken by Our Bishop .
    God bless you brother for bringing this to Light.
    I pray all must follow strictly The Catholic Theology handed down to us from ages.
    Praise be to God

  • @piuspinto176
    @piuspinto176 Před 7 měsíci

    Bishop is visiting temple for what, to preach the gospel. Did he have the permission from Pope to visit temples. Is he giving a good example to the faithful.

  • @rosejoseph9987
    @rosejoseph9987 Před 7 měsíci +1

    It's become communitarian.. only one community controls the charismatic renewal

  • @prakash62468
    @prakash62468 Před 7 měsíci +2

    Wonderful narration

  • @mauricedalmeida167
    @mauricedalmeida167 Před 7 měsíci +3

    Lot of evil is crept into Holy Catholic Apostolic Church, Let Bishop be a true leader of Christ Church to bring back the flock from heretical teaching to lead them to Jesus Christ. And God bless you brother for your work

  • @edwinperis6440
    @edwinperis6440 Před 7 měsíci

    1 cor 4:5 so do not go on passing judgment before appointed time , wait until Lord comes *** .

  • @FrancisChinna
    @FrancisChinna Před 7 měsíci

    If people die because of food poison will you say don't eat food? Be good do good

  • @indiradixit2175
    @indiradixit2175 Před 7 měsíci +3

    What does it mean to be catholic? Can someone enlighten me?

    • @irenecastelino8827
      @irenecastelino8827 Před 7 měsíci +5

      It means to be a True Christian.

    • @godforgivesusinchristcruci5690
      @godforgivesusinchristcruci5690 Před 7 měsíci

      @@irenecastelino8827
      You are thoroughly mistaken dear brother if you have thought only the Catholics are the true Christian

    • @aliceshaletdsouza8252
      @aliceshaletdsouza8252 Před 7 měsíci +3

      Please Read The Catechism of The Catholic Church

    • @benedictdsilva3954
      @benedictdsilva3954 Před 7 měsíci +1

      The word catholic means universal...small c
      When capital C is used it means Roman Catholic..
      The church was catholic.
      Only under Emperor Constantine it was called Roman Catholic. The Orrhodox church were also there in the 1st century..

  • @indiradixit2175
    @indiradixit2175 Před 7 měsíci +1

    Buddy u gotta paste exact link else how to believe u

    • @irenecastelino8827
      @irenecastelino8827 Před 7 měsíci +3

      It's in the link. Go to INTERNOS. You will find the letter from Bishop to his beloved people

    • @indiradixit2175
      @indiradixit2175 Před 7 měsíci

      @irenecastelino8827 can u tell me what does it mean to be a a follower of Christ?
      Also what's the evidence that Christianity is a true religion? And Jesus had supernatural prayers..

    • @aliceshaletdsouza8252
      @aliceshaletdsouza8252 Před 7 měsíci +1

      ​@@indiradixit2175Read Holy Bible and The Catechism OF the Catholic church for Enlightenment

  • @kiranmi
    @kiranmi Před 7 měsíci +8

    Excellent action by the bishop. I wish he had gone a little further and banned the charismatic movement from his diocese. It is originally a protestant movement.

    • @SongonFirecatholicIndia
      @SongonFirecatholicIndia  Před 7 měsíci +7

      No I don't think the Charismatic renewal should be banned ! You can't cut out the crop just because of the weeds

    • @codewalters
      @codewalters Před 7 měsíci +2

      What is the problem with the charismatic movement

    • @aliceshaletdsouza8252
      @aliceshaletdsouza8252 Před 7 měsíci +4

      As a Mangalorean , I agree with you sir .
      Our Bishop should bring back The Traditional Latin Mass in our Diocese and Help The Traditional Catholic Faith to Grow.
      So That once again Mangalore Diocese can give many more priests to The Holy Mother Church like in the Past

    • @aliceshaletdsouza8252
      @aliceshaletdsouza8252 Před 7 měsíci +1

      ​@@codewaltersProtestant in origin

    • @tamaramartin5144
      @tamaramartin5144 Před 6 měsíci

      Catholic Charismatic is not Protestant but a movement of the Catholic church.

  • @nathaliamartis8004
    @nathaliamartis8004 Před 7 měsíci +12

    You say bishop gave the guidelines for charasmatic preachers. Why are you so concerned about preachers like br.mario Joseph, Vincentian Priests' and others' who work day and night fasting and praying to save people by giving them the Word of God and telling people the importance of meditating, memorizing the Words of God. What spirit do you have? Sit and check your conscience instead of making bla..bla..

    • @linolopes9245
      @linolopes9245 Před 7 měsíci +3

      What are you trying to achieve by having the last word even after the bishop has said what he has to say. You speak as you know it correct you know it best let us see how long you last.

    • @aliceshaletdsouza8252
      @aliceshaletdsouza8252 Před 7 měsíci +1

      Don't be a blind follower. Read Holy Bible and The Catechism of the Catholic church.
      Know The Faith

    • @edwinperis6440
      @edwinperis6440 Před 7 měsíci

      Romans 14:4 who are you to judge the servant of Jesus before his own master he stands or falls and he will stand , for the Lord is able to make him stand

  • @juliodcunha193
    @juliodcunha193 Před 7 měsíci

    Some people has insecurity complex

  • @rosejoseph9987
    @rosejoseph9987 Před 7 měsíci

    Directors of retreat centres encourage laity to start new centres...deviations away from Catholicism

  • @jacksoncastelino04
    @jacksoncastelino04 Před 7 měsíci +5

    Vivat Christus Rex

  • @aquavivafernandes7360
    @aquavivafernandes7360 Před 7 měsíci

    Since Roman Catholic Church goes as one under the Pope, the decision of all the Bishops should be the same and not Bishop of Bangalore only, as far as the Theology or the Doctrine of the Church is concerned. This is what I believe. Please correct me if I am wrong.

  • @godforgivesusinchristcruci5690
    @godforgivesusinchristcruci5690 Před 7 měsíci +1

    Oh thank you Since you have put bishops circular for priests in a public forum,
    I will point out Theological Errors in that circular... And send it to all the clergy and laity
    I too was thinking how to handle it....
    When you have gone on public about it, before the bishop himself and clergy and you going on to worship that circular, I will point out the errors....

  • @cliffordfernandes8472
    @cliffordfernandes8472 Před 7 měsíci +1

    I have written to the Vatican to make you the Next Pope. !!!😂

  • @benedictdsilva3954
    @benedictdsilva3954 Před 7 měsíci

    Well a good initiative but what about correcting the wrong with other non Charsmatic Catholics..lay faithful and priests... some are attending Hindu idol worship and some dancing at another Hindu festival..Some priests singing secular pop songs in Church..
    And look at where the Church is going with the Synod..You are talking about preserving the tradition of the Church..A senior Bishop in US was removed from office who was in favour of the tradition Latin mas ( which is more prayerful )
    Some things which were never there in the Church may now enter... so where is the question of ' tradition' ?
    Mary has a role in the Church..
    Do Catholics know the difference between veneration and adoration ? Do you know ?
    Do you even know all the 10 commandments ?
    Just because one Bishop has a view doesn't mean that other Bishops in other dioceses will have the same.
    I know that a Bishop in my diocese would consult a priest for a certain things and then put his Impramatur..
    Most preachers who don't agree with Catholic teaching anyway leave and form their own church..

    • @SongonFirecatholicIndia
      @SongonFirecatholicIndia  Před 7 měsíci

      Whats your point Benedict ?

    • @benedictdsilva3954
      @benedictdsilva3954 Před 7 měsíci +1

      @@SongonFirecatholicIndia My point is stop criticising those preachers...They are at least teaching people to trust God's Word.
      People have problems or they'll end up putting flowers and candles before a statue...
      It seems your have some personal problem with those preachers...
      Quite often lots of rubbish is spoken from the pulpit. Would you speak up then ? Like one priest said Jesus didn't really ascend to heaven literally
      Or another one says there is no hell. It looks like you just want viewership. And most of those people don't know much anyway...

    • @SongonFirecatholicIndia
      @SongonFirecatholicIndia  Před 7 měsíci

      what if the teaching is not inline with the Catholic Understanding ?

  • @piuspinto176
    @piuspinto176 Před 7 měsíci

    Moreover you are a wolf in the form of sheep, you criticized Fr Joseph, are you more knowledgeable than Fr Joseph. Do you have more knowledge than Fr Joseph regarding CCC.

  • @codewalters
    @codewalters Před 7 měsíci

    Whether led by Lay or Clergy they are all capable of corrupting the chtistian teachings.