Doctor Debunks George Floyd Fentanyl Death Theory
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 04. 2021
- This doctor expertly debunked the theory that fentanyl was the cause of George Floyd’s death during the Derek Chauvin murder trial.
» Subscribe to NowThis: go.nowth.is/News_Subscribe
» Sign up for our newsletter KnowThis to get the biggest stories of the day delivered straight to your inbox: go.nowth.is/KnowThis
For more Derek Chauvin murder trial coverage and world news, subscribe to NowThis News.
#DerekChauvin #GeorgeFloyd #BLM #News #NowThis
Connect with NowThis
» Like us on Facebook: go.nowth.is/News_Facebook
» Tweet us on Twitter: go.nowth.is/News_Twitter
» Follow us on Instagram: go.nowth.is/News_Instagram
» Find us on Snapchat Discover: go.nowth.is/News_Snapchat
NowThis is your premier news outlet providing you with all the videos you need to stay up to date on all the latest in trending news. From entertainment to politics, to viral videos and breaking news stories, we’re delivering all you need to know straight to your social feeds. We live where you live.
/ nowthisnews
@nowthisnews
Less than 12 hours after Floyd's death they had put out every thing he'd ever done.
But it took almost two weeks to find out that Chauvin had 15+ complaints from civil right violations, misconduct, and excessive force.
So here we go again, blame the victim who is now no longer around to defend himself.
Well, try as that weirdo may to try to obscure the truth, truth hurts + looks like karma, (ironically,) got him...
Although, yes, I agree with your statement.
It's mind-boggling, indeed.
Agreed. People quickly forget that we can't get the victim's side of the story.
Thank God his side of the incident was at least recorded.
Chauvin, Tao and the other 2 should have the EXACT same done to them, in the street near a dirty gutter in front of the world.
Obscure the truth, and otherwise distort it, cast aspersions too.
Make it easier to accept the lack of consequence, when you get away with killing a man. Cowards.
I recommend watching the defense otherwise youll be stuck in a confirmation bias world listening to clips everything you want to hear, like this.
Defense lawyer has been putting up a good fight.
Seriously... you'd think many of the folks who want Chauvin to be innocent would know better than anyone that a fentanyl overdose doesn't happen over an extended period of time. If you're going to go down, you'll go right away.
Accurate. It's extremely potent
@@tacobell4968 That’s your response? 🤣🤣🤣
They are just ignorant racists who don’t care because they can’t see a black man as a man. They love what chauvin did. They support it. They think cops should be judges and executioners because they don’t know what true love and empathy are and they don’t hold it in their hearts. The sad part is these vile people are in our communities. They wear badges they teach our children. It’s all of our jobs to expose and remove these racists from our culture
@@anatomicallycorrectmuppets8180 Sorry, but people are held to a standard in a country with rule of law. You have to show evidence, and the current evidence is heavily favoring the defense. What Chauvin did could've been handled much better. However, the evidence currently will not get him convicted.
I have had this same discussion with many here. Evidence of drug overdose happens immediately after ingestion. When I say that they try to falsify when he took drugs. Some wanted me to believe he did right in front of the police while handcuffed.
if the law somehow failed to convict them after this. we know the system is rigged.
If?!
Even if they do convict, we already know the system is rigged and extremely flawed. Outside this one tragic case there's is so much more to be fix.
Flawed yes. Rigged probably not. If it were rigged you would have never heard from this doctor, you would have had a jury far friendlier to Chauvin than would be even semi understandable, the other officers would never have been allowed to testify in the first place and critical evidence would have been denied from being presented. This isn't rigged. Flawed, absolutely.
It's been rigged
It's rigged but this time they couldn't stop justice cuz every organization and every blk person in America is present..when we step up it gets done ..periodtt
the system _is_ rigged. This is just another attempt to change it.
the fact that you can find people in the comments arguing the case of someone who kneeled on a cuffed persons neck even after he knew he had no pulse is really something else.
It's probably the trolls that subscribe to notifications so they can immediately comment and argue against others
i just don't get it. How could anyone say it didn't do anything when his knee is on the literal pathway for breaths to enter and exit.
it's beyond comprehension. it's difficult to grasp that someone of the same species can hold these views. some sort of cognitive dissonance i guess
the direction of his standards were correct in his training. you might want to see the while video where it appears he is on the neck, but actually the back
@@lavabender_taku but it wasn't. there is more than 1 video
It doesn't matter how intelligent and well informed this doctor is, there are still people claiming he is just assuming things lmao I'd like to know what kind of qualifications they possess to tell this to a licensed pulmonologist with 46 years of experience
The same qualifications that make them a better expert than Dr. Fauci 🙄
"Brains and gut instinct" are the qualifications I've seen waved around.
Lnie wrote: "I'd like to know what kind of qualifications they possess to tell this to a licensed pulmonologist with 46 years of experience"
No one will believe this doctor until the day they might need him to stay alive. That's when the attitude changes.
I trust science over opinions.
He's not just a pulmonologist, the "According to the American Thoracic Society, Tobin is "the supreme scholar of critical care medicine and editor or author of seven extraordinary textbooks on the subject." The Lancet described his textbook Principles And Practice of Mechanical Ventilation as the "Bible" of the field of mechanical ventilation.[2]" that's from his Wikipedia page.
It's the same qualifications that told them to follow Trump's comment about drinking disinfectants to stop COVID.
There is so much scientific evidence coming from this guy it is impossible to defend.
People are just gonna say he's lying or paid by soros or sum.
@@sensible1163 you can't lie about established scientific facts. He didn't state HIS own opinions only, he backed his interpretations up with verified scientific studies and verifiable facts anyone can fact check looking at the videos of the incident.
And also the whole establishment against him that cop guy is f*cked
@@sensible1163 they gonna say that the scientific data he provided is false, cause someone on facebook said otherwise
@@moniaber997 The people that would say this man is lying are so far gone it’s useless to try to make sense of their thoughts.
why was floyd saying he cant breathe way before he was even put on the ground? hmmm
This expert did a great job at explaining this to the jurors!
@Nixon Eli Afraid NOT wittle buddy. That pig is going to prison.
@Nixon Eli link it then
@Nixon Eli
Stop licking boots, its bad for your health
@Richy G Yes it is just you.
The Pulmonary Expert literally says "With Fentanyl you can expect a respitory reduction of 40%, which means you would see a depressed respitory rate of about 10 breaths per minute"
Floyds respitory rate was around 22 breaths per minute.
The average breaths per minute is 12-22 (I was trained at 2-20)
He didnt say opioids dont cause respiratory depression...He was just saying that Floyds respiratory response doesnt match what someone dying of fentanyl would be showing.
You literally didnt watch this very well...
Let's pray these jurors aren't racist cucks cause I'm tired of living in a world where race is an issue
So this guy claims he can tell it wasn't fentanyl just by looking at him. Why was he saying "I can't breathe" before he was even on the ground?
This doctor gave a compelling testimony. Surely, it should be enough to secure a conviction.
@funky chipmunk By “their version” you mean that they think all blacks deserve to die. Typical. 🙄 And it’s appalling. 😠
It won’t be. There is just too much evidence both ways that they can’t prove Chauvin guilty without reasonable doubt that HE was the reason of the death of George Floyd. If it were any different, democracy would be at risk because the court system was made this way.
@@davidstrow8441 the doctor just confirmed that Floyd died as a direct result of Chauvin’s actions.
@@stephenmurphy2212 this doctor may have shared his expert opinion, but he isn’t the only doctor that will examine this. Many will and some will disagree.
@@stephenmurphy2212 also just cuz someone thinks George Floyd died to drug overdose doesn’t mean they want all blacks to die. That is a massive generalization and a bit extreme don’t you think?
Derek's lawyer is sweating profusely right now 😁
Not as profusely as Chauvin.
The prosecution’s next witnesses don’t even agree with doctor so
@@samanthagirikhanov2796 liar
he done lol I love it
@@alfredavina7202 Bo I’m not. They called the autopsy doctor and his testimony conflicted. Try watching the whole trial.
Now that is what I call an expert witness.
No one in their right mind would risk losing their medical license to defend chauvins poorly built case.
@Sugar Shane Yeah, you're right... stupidity and money triumphs honor.
@Sugar Shane this expert literally wrote the book in the field of his expertise.. no quack doctor would be qualified enough to counter his testimony
His case is compelling.
@Sugar Shane Prosecution would pick them apart
St Fentanyl Floyd
He wasn't paid to give his testimony he did it for free.
Richy G How is that a warning sign?
Maybe he was paid too give such results by interested parties. Can't tell anything now, looking at the situation nowadays you can't trust anyone .
May God be with you all.
@@mastershifu7 what parties? Who are you accusing? And if he's saying this for, are you saying he's lying? God is very displeased with you
@Richy G warning sign for the guilty cop and his lawyer? That this guy isn't up for sale? Yeah, they should be worried.
@Richy G whatever makes you sleep at night
wow this testimony was very well done. so great to finally hear a respiratory specialist discuss his cause of death after having to endure completely unqualified Fox News hosts tell the public he died of an overdose for almost a year
This dude admitted to not conducting the autopsy and knew exactly the cause of death just by watching the video lol sounds like a fabricated opinion to me
@@722Moo Yeah, one of the leading opinions in ventilation probably doesnt know the visual signs of respiratory distress...Riiiiggghhtttt
@@722Moo The medical examiner who performed the autopsy testifed Floyd wouldnt have died without Chauvins interaction, and labeled Floyds death as a "Homicide" in his original report, and stuck by his opinion.
@@yobrodontshoot1130 that medical examiner said he died from asphyxiation.
Sounds like reasonable doubt to me
@@722Moo I think you'll find nearly every disagreeing opinion essentially boils down to what people consider "reasonable" doubt. A possibility existing is not the same thing.
People who think he died of fenantyl are absolutely disgusting and horrific...
Those people are spreading lies that was told to them. Most of them are well aware that fentanyl is a hoax, they just wanna continue spreading that lie.
Tell that to shills like Coondace Owens, “officer” Tatum & the such...
All Republican tokens are the worst pieces of 💩
imagine not being able to breath LMFAO
I disagree. Some of them yes, but not all of them. It's a dangerous drug and I doubt any of us are drug/respiratory experts, so it seemed plausible. That said, now that we have heard from a couple different experts on the matter, it's clear that's not the case
@@douglasboyle448 No, but many of us are ex-addicts. All opioid overdoses are instantaneous. There is no prolonged consciousness. Tolerance is built rapidly and excessively when you use it regularly. There’s a lot of fear-mongering about fentanyl in general, but most people will be on it at some point during surgery, where it’s used routinely for general anesthesia. A tiny, tiny, tiny dose may kill someone with no tolerance to it, but if you’re a regular user, you could take 100x that amount and it won’t even effect you.
The people who still say it was drug use despite all of the evidence to the contrary *are* disgusting. They’re choosing to believe in stigma, shame and false information about drugs instead of the truth. They’re disgusting because they want to dehumanize a man who struggled with substance use disorder to blindly support a murderer in uniform.
If this testimony does not get him convicted, nothing will.
Agree
Always nice when a piece of science confirms something that was already obvious.
@CZcams Moderator Obviously watching videos is hard for you.
@CZcams Moderator
That's the point tho. He would have died way earlier based on how and why the drug kills you.
Not only is watching videos hard for you, but apparently so is reading. You clearly misunderstood the other person’s comment.
@CZcams Moderator
In this case I believe the Dr. was saying that if the cause of death was just fentanyl he would have not been able to sustain the breathing he was trying to do for as long as he was able to.
Of course the drug is deadly and surely did not help in the dire situation he was in but the point is still being made that having a knee on his neck, stifling his breathing for so long, is what caused Floyd's death.
@CZcams ModeratorYou think that resisting arrest means you deserve to die?
"According to the American Thoracic Society, Tobin is "the supreme scholar of critical care medicine and editor or author of seven extraordinary textbooks on the subject." The Lancet described his textbook Principles And Practice of Mechanical Ventilation as the "Bible" of the field of mechanical ventilation.[2]" - this guy is THE authority on pulmonology.
😯😯😯
That’s awesome, except the American Thoracic Society has nothing to do with drugs...
“It is a nonprofit organization focused on improving care for pulmonary diseases, critical illnesses and sleep-related breathing disorders.”
I copied that straight from their website
@@MtS1900 apparently copying and reading is not an indication of intelligence
@@MtS1900 when pulmonary diseases are caused by drugs ... they study them. That's medical science
Yup fallacy of authority right here...
Do we really need to have 4 weeks of this trial when everyone has seen the video and knows Chauvin is guilty? This is a perfect example that US is a failed state.
There shouldn’t be a trial at all. Read the autopsy and watch the policy body cam footage.
This is incredibly stupid. Please.
Failed States? Or failed country? 🤔 maybe both....
Maybe none....
Or maybe........ 👀
As much as I think Chauvin is guilty. There needs to be a trial. Chauvin's track record, the video, eyewitnesses, and the autopsy are enough to put him away but they need to follow protocol. There are a lot of wrongfully convicted who got to prove themself as innocent because of the trial system. The system isn't perfect but at least there is one.
@@tacobell4968 Thanks to women and the left, the country is failed. We walked away from God and no longer have providence. Buckle up.
It's looking bad for Chauvin !
Lol this is you
"I watched a 9 minute clip of exactly what I want to hear therefore i know everything!"
@@722Moo Well it is a doctor giving very compelling evidence to be fair
@@722Moo it’s called a well trained professional explaining science that is incomprehensible to people like you.
Um...it looked bad for chavin when we first saw the video of him kneeling on George Floyd for 9 minutes....we really DIDN'T need this trial.
You've not been watching the whole trial then.
Can your science explain why it rains? YES! YES IT CAN!
Seeing this was like finding a pot of gold. Thank you for being yourself.
Mock trial. You can't scream I can't breathe if you can't breathe
not true you absolutely can speak while being choked.
@pumpkin pie according to what?
If you've seen someone under the influence of Fentanyl you would know this isn't how they behave. You're lucky to get any response from them.
Unless they had meth in them too... which he did.
@@fourfiveone Ok. Floyd shouldn't have been a career criminal and then he would not of died lol.
@@wimschmied3800 should’ve been a good man like derrick who totally didn’t have 15+ complaints but hey i mean that was in the past 🤷♂️
@@omars1369 Firstly, his name isn't Derrick it's Derek, secondly I never said he was a good or great man I merely pointed out that George Floyd was a criminal who broke the law seriously multiple times it was inevitable he was going to get himself killed through the life he chose.
@@wimschmied3800 so you wanna play the judge, jury and executioner? There’s a system so people can be judged fairy and not just being executed all the time
Chauvin is a criminal, killing Floyde in plain sight while he begged for his life. The end.
If the thug walks, it’s going to be a very hot spring/summer.
And it should be if that’s the case.
:)
Covid will be eclipsed and pass on to "on other news"
@Deus Vult. always nice when the racists identify themselves.
@Deus Vult. how many civil rights violations was george floyd reported for? oh right, none. chauvin on the other hand...
Doctors Tobin (seen here) and Thomas, both top of their field, took no fees for their expert analysis and testimony in this case because they recognized its importance. They saved the state tens of thousands of dollars and guarantee that the defence cannot provide an expert with better reputation or credentials. I'm profoundly grateful to them for proving to me that there are truly good people in this world.
The fact that they aren't being paid is a bad thing. Tobin has never testified in court before. He's not being paid. So why is he there? Political motives seems reasonable.
@@NickElliottOutdoors that's about the dumbest thing I've ever read. The defense "experts" were uninformed and didn't bother to do any research or even listen to the testimony. One admitted on cross that everything he'd said was wrong and the other tried to say that three people on top of someone isn't a use of force and suggested that Mr Floyd had a heart attack unrelated to anything the defendant was doing. They'd also tried to peddle their "expert opinions" to the prosecution before peddling themselves to the defense. Expert testimony is supposed to be testimony from an expert, not someone who's an expert at testifying for money.
@@pattygould8240
What I'm hearing is "the prosecutions witnesses were experts because I liked what they said"
Even though you have the use of force experts on both sides lining up on many things.
I stand by what I said about being paid. That is the norm. Testifying for free is odd and it does not make your motives clear. Ask any solicitor.
@@NickElliottOutdoors you aren't hearing what I said. I'm thrilled with what those expert witnesses said, they only helped the prosecution with their ineptitude.
I'm guessing that you haven't even watched the trial.
@@NickElliottOutdoors I heard guilty, guilty, guilty, bail revoked, remand into custody. It appears that the jury watched the same trial I did.
The fact that he wants to defend himself means he got no shame.
Cops know they rarely ever get in trouble. They're also part of the justice system. Judges typically take their account of events over all other accounts of the incident.
That's a little harder to do this time around. I hope he gets convicted, but I honestly wouldn't be shocked if he didn't, or just got a very light sentence, or probation.
Are you saying chauvin wants to testify?
@@calilove6445 sounds to me like reasonable doubt
@@calilove6445 idk this trial feels really different. Lots of law enforcement testified against him. I'm cautiously optimistic about conviction and sentencing.
At least it seems everyone can agree that this is an abuse of power. hopefully some bigger change can grow from it
@@722Moo Lol! How?
Opioid overdose causes respiratory failure.
Fentanyl floyb
In other news, Floyd died from fentynal
Source?
@@ryancruz1876 look it up
That's the most doctor-looking doctor I've ever seen lol.
🤣🤣
Yeah fareal tho 😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂
What a crock
I appreciate this guys very scientific testimony. Well done.
It literally stops your breathing. Lies
How much do you think they paid "Doctor"...
He seems drunk.
I appreciate and commend the fact, he offered his expertise for free to help the case! 👏👏👏
It was cringe when Nelson asked how much he'd normally charge. He makes it way too obvious how desperate he is, I think he'd often be better off not asking the witnesses anything.
@@zapador That is actually a super routine question to ask expert witnesses. It happens in almost every case... Nothing against this guy because he did great, but that is normal. Also offering free help to a high level case means he gets a large amount of publicity, which leads to a ton of $$$.
what cause? all you are doing is defending a criminal..
Thank you for not showing the horrific clips of this heinous act. It is heart wrenching enough just to hear the testimony.
I gotta applaud this too! Although a link to the clip for reference might have been a good idea
I watched it live during the trial and it was heart wrenching. I am glad I watched it though. Dr.Tobin explained everything so well. He is such an intelligent man.
No we need to see this bc racists still don’t get it. They did this to Floyd
@@TheLuscious I agree but unfortunately racists don't get even if they see it. They act like he shouldn't have been a drug addict. They refuse to believe the drugs did not kill him no matter how many experts say Chauvin killed him. It's so frustrating, but racists have always been frustrating to me
I found it unbearable just to hear the doctor count the breaths against the dark screen. Such an incredibile testimony.
With the millions of people who have watched the video why is there still so many who think he died of a fentanyl overdose?🤦🏻♀️
They're Russian trolls.
Question, what does fentanyl mean?
@@adriancomia6618 fentanyl is a drug
dumb people dont have a reason
@Christopher Hoch just because you desperately wanna believe that doesn't mean it's true.
This doctor is a hero
He's not a hero, he is an EXPERT.
Not really
Damning testimony; very patient and slowly explained everything. Fantastic job by the expert!
Science, social studies, and language arts classes all in one when listening to this breathing expert. The detail of wording to explain the tense and heavy atmosphere of every situation and easily looking back on what happens in certain scenarios. I could listen to him talk for hours.
@Richy G
The guy was lying? What gives that impression?
@Richie G
He gave scientific evidence to back him up which was accurate. The only way to call fraud on this is if the video was edited to change the rate of breathing. Which it wasn’t. (And for the love of god don’t turn this into a new conspiracy)
Now you must give evidence debunking this doctor and evidence supporting your claim (which the doctor did. Debunked the notion of fentanyl being the cause and used science to support his claim)
FACTS DON'T CARE ABOUT YOUR FEELINGS
This guy didnt even do the autopsy lol its all opinion
@@722Moo imagine being a hate crime apologist. your mother would be ashamed.
@@722Moo Please feel free to share your opinion since you're clearly more knowledgeable.
@@722Moo Are you joking?
If he wasn't high on drugs, then why was he acting so lonely during the initial arrest?
People didn't believe the witnesses
Okay...fine
But there have been how much doctors with different viewpoints tht came with the same conclusion
And people STILL DO NOT WANT TO BELIEVE
Atp God needs to come down and tell you guys
Are you also going to believe the medical experts the defense presents?
@@JB-iu7jq You do realize that the prosecution gets to cross-examine all witnesses?
@@artisticcannibalism1350 Yes?
"IF" Chuavin is found guilty, this testimony is why!!
Crowder should test this. Stop his breathing for 9 min and see what happens.
@KING SOYBOY could you please show some examples?
@@jimbojigs368 voter Fraud allegations
The world gets better, that's what happens.
@@jimbojigs368 You already know the examples
You just think it doesn't break TOS because you like it.
Just admit it and be done with these games.
Crowder is what happens when someone's ego becomes inflated by debating 18 year olds.
The defence attorney breaks out in a cold sweat when someone counters his agenda
Blaming Floyd's death on fentanyl in his system when he had Chauvin's knee crushing his airway stopping him from breathing is like blaming stage 4 cancer as the cause of death if somebody died in a horrific car accident that completely destroyed the car and driver.
@Deus Vult. But it didn't, he has abused drugs for years, the only time he died was when a cop knelt on his neck for 9 mins.. He could have died any moment before then..
@Deus Vult. It can, but it didn't, as this expert explained very clearly.
@@honorquestThen why didn't he?
It's actually even more illogical considering he had non-lethal amount of fentanyl in his system.
Love this doc. The guy is extremely knowledgeable
For once being a med Major makes understanding this easy
You don't really need to be a Med major to understand this lol.
@@Kentrantran true but having the knowledge to understand everything and calculate it needs to be taught. Congrats on OP for going into a true field of help.
@@lololollololol2894 every job is helping. Even the people that work at trash facilities.
Looking at southern Italy when the trash men went on a strike some years ago you could see that the whole system was falling apart.
I myself have one of the best degrees from one of the best German universities as a Dipl.-Engineer (Mechanical engineering in the field of material science, material compounds, damage analysis)
Yet I would never say that a person working in a bakery, a nurse, a social worker or someone else is less of help than I am. Everybody contributing in any way, be it entertainment, research, production, politics, care and other fields, is working hand in hand with each other.
Yep just any medical training makes this easier to understand.
@@Kentrantran of course not. But not everyone understands what’s being said nor do they actually understand the science of it like those in my field can.
Respect! He knows what he’s talking about!
I'm glad you guys took the consideration to not show the video, you guys are wonderful and deeply respectful.
"Nooooo you can't just watch the video and see that Floyd was resisting the entire time"
The Media pranks you again normies xD
"Alright George didn't die from a fentanyl overdose case closed, now it's time to buy some more mansions!"
Ok conservative 🤠
What qualifications or experience do you possess that make you an expert on the topic “desired”?
@@cornflakes8358 what about it
@@Freefs1 idk what about it
Its sad thats theres so many CZcams Doctors on here trying to Debunk this real one.
Lol..good one..too funny👍❤️
Thats all science is. Debating each other really
@@722Moo oh you’re also a pulmonologist with 46 years of experience and several textbooks one of which has been hailed as the “bible” of the field of mechanical ventilation who provided testimony to this trial for free?
Or you could just watch both sides of the trial and know that this doctor gave opinion and conjecture. For one his assumption is based on body weight being evenly distributed which is absurd. I’ll debunk that real quick by standing on one leg. Amazing science. 😂😂
@@LukeOBrien92 no im not, but science is all about debating each other. If someone conducts a study and finds that fentanyl OD is what killed George Floyd, is that not science too?
People really be trying to argue against one of the most recognised scholars in the ATS.
Yeah, that's exactly what court cases are.....
The autopsy disagrees w this doctor so yeah
@@samanthagirikhanov2796 nah the autopsy didnt show that he should have died that day
@@yonisbadar2129 Yes it did. The prosecution is literally arguing that he used so much drugs that he had a tolerance for that amount because the amount in his system especially coupled with his heart condition is enough to kill someone.
A real doctor has spoken!!!!!! Not to mention with yrs of experience so tell me where are the fake doctors that said otherwise 🤔🤔👂🏼👂🏼👂🏼
Of ffs this is the prosecution’s case and then the defense calls witnesses. That’s how trials work. And even before that, the state called the autopsy doctor who disagrees w this doctor so even in the states own case it’s not consistent.
ever heard of bribery
Drugs are no joke, I don't trust any expert who have never experimented with narcotics and psychedelics.
That’s a lie. I have cystic fibrosis and no one can tell by my breathing on the outside.
Biased much? CNN is that you?
Mr I love to live in fantasy! Enjoy
This is literally an expert in the field... so the only biased one here, is you.
@@Krensharpaw Claiming bias doesnt mean I disagree.
In otherwords, his lack of oxygen was not for a lack of breathing, but because his chest was compressed.
So I guess the defense of "the knee on his neck was just a coincidence" is pretty much demolished.
He failed to explain why he couldn't breathe while there was no pressure on his chest because he would have to explain the pulmonary oedema in his lungs (symptom of fentanyl OD btw)
@@basedboi9149 but he did, just not in this video
@@rain_mendoza2000 It doesn't even matter at this point since the coroner himself said there was no sign of brain damage. This guy built his entire argument around the idea that the officers killed Floyd and going into research with bias is dangerous. Most importantly, it simply contradicts real life experience: It is factually impossible to strangle someone from the back, it would impair his ability to breathe, yes, but a healthy individual would never under any circumstance die from it, and I'm saying this as a BJJ practitioner.
@@basedboi9149 if someone is under the influence of a drug that impairs his breathing then a chauvin type of guy kneels on his back and adds on the impairment for 7+ minutes, would the affected person be alive? If a drunk man was crossing the street and someone hit him, would you blame the alchohol. GIVE ME AN F-ING BREAK. If you really are smart, you would be talking dumb🙄🙄🙄. Your clients need to 🏃🏻♀️🏃🏻♀️🏃🏻♀️🏃🏻♀️
@@munyau3 Chauvin had no idea what drugs he was on and he was conducting a lawful arrest. He was also told to "Hold for EMS" which is exactly what he did. Oh and just so you know Floyd died of a heart attack not lack of air. His lungs were full of fluids (pulmonary oedema, symptom of fentanyl OD) which is why he couldn't breathe.
Two more doctors and medical examiners up today to give evidence. It's very damning for the defence.
I work at an ER as a mere janitor, in L.A. We are a non trauma center, specializing in repository, stroke & heart attack. We get fenty ODs regularly. First off, when a patient complains that they can't breath the staff basically pander to them, but the rule of thumb is: if you can talk you can breath. Apparently, if they can say "I can't breathe," they have to be able to breathe to say anything. Based on that, I dont understand how Chauvin's knee, on the side of his neck, while Fenty Floyd wouldn't shut the f up, can be the cause of his loss of air in take? And, point of fact, why is this even a point in the trial, at all? Becuz it is a fact that Fenty Floyd swallowed ALLLLLL the fenty he was supplied with to sell, in his attempt to 'get away with it.' As he is a vile street dealer, he carries individual servings, as opposed to "weight"; individually wrapped/packaged. What is NOT told in all this is why this Dr.'s observations of a video are even considered; wouldn't a simple drug test reveal if Fenty Floyd OD'd? Apparently, not. In the ER I work DOCTORS CANNOT TEST FOR FENTY!!!!!! They rely on the patient's honesty when asked, "what did you take?" If just one of Fenty Floyd's packages was wrapped improperly, and ONE tiny grain got out in his stomach, for whatever reason, say seeped through the plastic sandwich bag wrapping commonly used, it would kill him in minutes, possible seconds. Note, when the ambulance got there he had not been DEAD 9 minutes. It seems like a nuanced point but there is a difference between not breathing for a prolong period of time and being dead. Perhaps if the ambulance personnel had used Naloxone right away, they could have saved Fenty Floyd so he can beat more women, perform more crimes, and sell more Fenty, but they didn't. So, in my take, Floyd deserves it, totally, but if someone else killed him, it was the Ambulance personnel. They listened to the crowd and treated Fenty Floyd for something other than a Fenty OD and he succumbed to his own Karma.
Unlike botted comments
Can't breathe and talk at the same time. Guy probably had a heart attach
👏👏💯💯
Yes, I will take the word of some random rambling dude claiming to be a janitor over a doctor with 45 years of experience in pulmonary medicine. So compelling.
Well, this didn't age well.
It can't be fentanyl because he was breathing too much. Did not expect to hear that. But that it wasn't the fentanyl should've been obvious by the amount in his blood.
11ng/mL
@@722Moo Which is way below a lethal dose
@@johndy247 lol ok expert
@@722Moo Experts testified. Lethal limit is 20+ ng/ml. Well above Floyd's level.
@@matthewbadley5063 ok you try it then
Someone give this man an award 👍
Well this didn’t age well….
Just Convict Chauvin Already.
Remember the titans quote: "come on Sherman, leave NO DOUBT! "
So the doctor says the fentynal is expected to slow the breathing down to a certain point (I don't know if he's talking about a lethal amount) then says the fentynal isn't effecting Georges breathing, but like, he did have a lethal amount of fentynal in his system as per the autopsy, so how exactly does that work
Many people who are drug users gain tolerance levels for drugs. What may be a lethal dose for one person, isn't for another. So this idea that he had a lethal amount in his system isn't really backed up with evidence. If he was a big time drug user, then he could have a tolerance for it. That would explain how he was talking to the police for almost 20 mins before having problems breathing.
@@Krensharpaw fentynal is a beyond powerful drug, even for people with a tolerance, rubbing the pure form on your fingers will make you OD if you don't get almost immediate narcan shots. I feel like the doctor should have added to his testimony what amount of fentynal achieves those expected results he was talking about.
@@hiimbob77 Then you should tell the medical examiner this since you're claiming to be more of an expert than even them.
@@Krensharpaw I'm not claiming to be smarter than anyone, just accurately reflecting how dangerous fentynal is even for people with a tolerance
No, he had a non-lethal amount per the autopsy.
Wait, so his primary argument wasnt anything concrete like the level of drugs in floyds system but rather counting breaths of a giy able to speak?
Lol 😂😂 this whole trial was a farce.
There are some very decent people in America and I hope they throw the book at Chauvin!!!!!!!
The whole reason George Floyd was laying face down is because he said he couldn’t breath when he was sat in the back of the car. If he already had trouble breathing before Chauvin got involved I think it’s fair to say it’s at least a contributing factor.
Minor details the mob will ignore
Floyd requested an ambulance that took 29 minutes to arrive! Probably new diversity hires
i've recently been kicked in the head by a horse so im inclined to believe internet commenters over this pulmonologist
Yea well I have probably had more kicks to the head by horses than you ever had, just one last week and I understand what the expert medical witness's say. Getting kicked is not an excuse to believe Facebook
Facts are facts ya’ll 🤷
Not really a fact, this dude had an opinion. He didn't even do the autopsy
@@722Moo he’s a doctor. And you’re just mad because he practices evidence-based medicine and actually knows his stuff.
@@722Moo well if you watched the trial they brought in people who have conducted an autopsy on Mr Floyd
This comment section was refreshing compared to the ones under news channels. The amount of people still using these arguments was sad.
This ‘doctor’ needs his medical license REVOKED!!!
Youre mad because the doctor relies on facts 😂
"ive done it millions of times" that man is a straight up liar, there is not a lot of things people do a million time in their life lol.
you when you find out what hyperboles are😱😱😱😱
Million of times…
How old is this guy
Thank god for Dr Tobin what an incredible man
THIS DIDNT AGE WELL LMAO!!
why bc a pos ex LEO officer got stabbed
@@KC-gf8islmfao nah because the junkies autopsy report got leaked
Nono you guys simply don't understand. A knee to the neck can't possibly be the reason why someone is suffocating.
Yes it dose,u could clearly hear George floyd screaming he cant breath,how do u ignore that,and than clame that the knee couldn't have killed him,when George floyd Cleary screamed he couldn't breath,is really disrespectful, there are doctors nurses agreeing that he died on the knee situation,and u come up wanted to change facts
Wow this just shows people have an excuse for everyhing. Like really he died of fentanyl while there was a guy literally chocking him.
Well yes, if you go to stab someone who is hit by a car moments before you get to them, you probably haven't commited a crime. Part of a fair trial is letting them make whatever defence they want to try. But now we've heard from an expert (because I'm pretty sure nobody in the comments is one), we can properly put that theory to rest
Yes, because he was having trouble breathing prior to any restraint, and he was high as a kite before police presence, and fentanyl overdoses are known to cause trouble breathing, and cause death due to hypoxia (which some examiners rule to be the cause of his death). This case isn't as clear-cut as you think.
@@Un1234l sure, we've just got multiple experts all explaining why that can't possibly be the case...
@@Un1234l Even assuming fentantyl overdose was the main cause, that still does not explain the cop adding to hypoxia by being extremely close to snapping his neck! With how rampant opioids are, cops are expected to be trained to know when someone is undergoing respiratory depression and cease combative measures and initiate rescue. Programs in which cops are being furnished Narcan (an opioid rescue) are becoming more common place due to how much they encounter this. Also your mention of "being high as a kite" makes no sense. Cops need to act accordingly based on present info. If a dude is comatose on the ground, I am not going to rely on him "being high as a kite" to preemptively use force. I'm going to rely on the fact that the due lost consciousness and had no pulse. That murderer was still on his neck minutes AFTER they couldn't detect a pulse. It's easy to say it's not clear when you're not making the efforts to make the facts more obvious. All fatal respiratory depression are hypoxia, but not all hypoxia are due to respiratory depression. In this case, the leading pulmonary expert is saying the hypoxia was due to physical obstruction of the lung. Use common sense and stop dancing around the current evidence.
@@Un1234l It's extremely clear-cut if you just watched the video, which you obviously didn't.
Shallow breathing did. . . . Wait. . What does FENTYL cause?? Shallow breathing???? Whattttt
Shallow breathing can be caused by compression of your chest, diaphram, and airway. Your diaphragm is not like a bicep or thigh muscle, it has a very specific task and cannot be trained to resist compression... If you compress it long it will not be strong enough to contract with the resistance placed on it.
@@christopherramirez332 well of course. . I was just mentioning. . So can FENTYL overdose. . That's why he was complaining if not being able to breatg while sitting in back of cop car and before he was in ground. . . .
This man is so impressive
fentanyl hits you as fast as anesthesia. It’s instant, an expert to explain that is necessary as an expert to explain how you need air to breath.
Floyd had drugs in his mouth up until the time of him laying on the ground. Half chewed speed ball in the back of the cop car
@@722Moo lol okay
This doctor was the man I inspire to be, just loook at him, how he talk, how he conveys the information is just surreal!
The lawyers did a great job with this testimony. The doctor is one of the Best, if not the Best in the pulmonary field in the US. Ensuring not only a damning testimony to Chauvin but also the defense just can't get a better doctor than him.
Gotta love the Irish
I don't think he's Irish lol
@@JacobC479 Educate yourself before stating your beliefs! Dr Martin Tobin - born in Kilkenny, Ireland in 1951. Medically educated in UCD, Dublin, Ireland. Why would you say you don’t think he’s Irish? Doesn’t match some stereotype you believe to be true???
@@JacobC479 You mean the Dr with the Irish accent?!
@@rootsquare doesn't sound Irish to me, sounds more like a German/British accent mix to me. He could be I just think of Irish accents sounding like Conor McGregor lol
@@JacobC479 Conor McGregor has a very specific Dublin City accent, we dont all sound like that. He is definitely Irish!
Think this guy may need his licence revoking frankly.
Drop Derek Chauvin Off In The Hood, We’ll Take Care Of Em.
Ich hasse diesen Lügner!
How about the kneeling on the neck? Maybe that had something to do with his death
Already discovered that he was kneeling on his shoulder blade
@@722Moo no it was on his neck, have you not heard the testimonies of several eye witnesses and so much video evidence. are you blind?
@@user-en2hu6wp7pdidn’t the video footage show him kneeling on his shoulder?
Hmm. Interesting that autopsy reports show differently than what this quack says from looking at body cams and that never examined the body.
all he had to do was not resist of course cops shouldn't be putting their knee on your neck but it's common sense to know that when a cop wants to put you in cuffs he's gonna put you in cuffs no matter what
He was a fn druggy
Game Over Man!
‘The Fall of Minneapolis’ watch it and then get back with me.
I'm now worried for the doctor...!
Video evidence speaks long after the ....