The Medical Harms of Hormonal and Surgical Interventions for Gender Dysphoric Children
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 03. 2019
- When it comes to treating young people who believe they are the opposite sex, who either suffer from gender dysphoria or self-identify as transgender, physicians have been instructed by their professional associations to provide "affirmative care." Transition-affirming therapies are virtually untested and inflict lasting harms: decreased sexual function, increased health risks, and sterility, just to name a few. Instead of providing parents with medical information and evidence-based studies, parents are told that these risky treatments will prevent their child from committing suicide, blurring the line between “informed consent” and “coercion.”
Still haven’t subscribed to The Heritage Foundation on CZcams? Click here ► bit.ly/2otKliy
Follow The Heritage Foundation on Facebook: / heritagefoundation
Follow The Heritage Foundation on Twitter: / heritage
Follow The Heritage Foundation on Instagram: heritagefou...
🚨 *NEW VIDEO ALERT* 🚨
In this episode of our new series, PolicyLAB, test subjects were tasked with assembling a mysterious device called a Stirling engine, an early alternative to the steam engine, and a machine that offers a perfect segway into a lesson about asylum reform - an issue critical to all Americans: czcams.com/video/Dy7A0cGV7JA/video.html
Do you give the slideshow that the presenters were showing the audience? If so, where can I find it?
I left a negative comment about monkey trials, not having listened to the video.
I am sorry.
You are all courageous people and deserve the Nations support
Logically,
Pure logic following the narrative is :
SINCE THERE IS NO PHYSICAL DETERMINING FACTOR THAT DEFINES SEX,
THERE IS NO MEDICAL INTERVENTION THAT AFFECTS OR CHANGES THE PHYSICAL BODY TO AFFECT OR CHANGE SEX!!!!!!
I believe that because this horrorific CRIME has been perpetrated most prolifically amongst the wealthy and/ or influential, that this is an outrageous attempt to introduce this criminality into a societal norm.
What people ( normal people) don’t realize is that these mutilations were done for purposes of occultism and Kabbalistic reasons, and reasons of Entertainment for the perpetrators.
Not for any mental relief for the victim.
There are also cases of persons who, because of being RAPED , who chose to be mutilated, as it might decrease their chance of being raped.
Going after the RAPIST is even more abhorrent, for the victim because of the repercussions , obviously.
It is time that we identify CRIMINALS, regardless of their genders!!!!
This is what John Lennon sang about..... “ All the Lonely People”.
When I was a junior in high school in 1990-91 we had a student in choir that everyone believed was a male.. even our teacher. We had a councilor come to our class one day and they talked to us about this student. Apparently, this student was actually a female and had been through some very traumatic events that had left her believing that the only way to survive without being harmed was by being a male. They were asking us that since we are a close group of friends if we could start acknowledging her as a female to help her accept being a natural female and realize it's okay to be female. I'm pretty sure if that was to happen today they would be setting her up for gender reassignment instead of helping her get over her trauma and accepting who she is.
@samo530 That is interesting. When I was at primary school in the 1970s I discovered an old American book from the 1950s containing advice for children and teenagers. "Into your Teens" it was called. Apart from some "old-fashioned" advice, such as for girls not to wear their hair in curlers in front of their father and brothers, there was also a chapter on "not wanting to be a boy or a girl" or rather "accepting your sex". The authors openly addressed this topic, which would tend to indicate that it was a common phenomenon. The advice went along the lines of: "Some boys wish that they were a girl, perhaps because they see that their sister gets more attention for her long blonde hair, or her pretty dresses, and some girls are tomboys and wish they could be a boy in order to play rough games. You have to learn to accept the sex that you were born with..." - That seemed strange to me as a girl of around 8 or 9, as I had never thought of wanting to be the opposite sex, nor had I noticed it in other children.
These hormones are destroying these kids and adults. Even hmsexuals, a young woman is living as a lesb, she was sexually abused by a girl very young. She does not get it even now. But the conflict with her sexuality stemmed from that abuse. She feels shes too deep into this lifestyle to walk away.
As a transgender male, there are a lot of women that undergo these things because of traumas that haven’t been worked through. However, it is incredibly foolish to make a generalization of all of us based on these minority of individuals. Not all of us have that mindset.
@@SingRaduga actually we have at least two opposing "societies" (maybe more) that seem to be forcing young people and even little kids, to go through painful procedures in order to be accepted by those
"societies". The question is which "painful procedures" are more painful and/or causing more lasting evil effects.Another question is what drives various societies into such harmful manipulation of their own children
@@mira0688 If one accepts the assertion that there even IS such a thing as 'transgender ' - in terms of there being some kind of transitory state between male and female or the idea that one can 'transition' to the opposite gender or sex - a slippery slope is automatically created.
How do I know this? I'm literally watching the slippery slope. It's here, now. The 'not all of us' routine doesn't hold anymore. The insanity is too widespread and too common. It doesn't matter that it's not 'all of you.' All that's required is that ENOUGH of you promulgate a dangerous ideology. It doesn't have to be all of you.
56:04
"A parent can actually cause a kid to be gender dysphoric - by affirming them."
It's legalized child abuse.
STYLER Wonder how many Pre-k and Kindergarten Teacher 👩🏫 👨🏼🏫 witness this year after year.
It's also munchausen by proxy 2.0
@crosseyedone single mothers often see the father in the little boy, and punish him since the cant punish the man that disappointed them. Its happening now to my 10 year old son.
@MsMarian Rogerssounds like you blindly defend all women, because vagina
@MsMarian Rogers Women can be just as horrible as men.
This angers me....I was a tom boy growing up....
Ann Marie Schrage-Glaviano me too.
Me too
I often find women, including my best friend, who grow up "tomboyish" tend to mature into outstanding women. My friend is my sister, she has femininity, but also more strength and mech skill than most men. It is no coincidence that this targets people who are similar.
Same and I still am but I know I'm not a man in the wrong body I'm a woman in the right body
It's actually none of your business. Have you tried Valium for all that anger ?
As a victim myself of parents with severe personality disorders I consider myself very lucky to have been born at a time when the fad among parents was ADD. I remember the “therapists” in their wood paneled offices who barely looked at me. Who prescribed me the same medications on the pens in their offices. There was never anything wrong with me other than the trauma of being raised by abusive alcoholics.
I am certain that if I had been born today, the “problem” with me would have been diagnosed as the fad of today and instead of begging my parents to stop forcing me to take amphetamines I would be instead lost in the terrifying and confusing fog of hormone treatments.
The truth is there has never been a scientific basis for these chemical interventions into developing minds. These mad doctors must be stopped. Children have to be allowed to develop and explore and experiment and learn and grow. The idea that patterns of thought should be locked in at an early age is simply empowering abusers and sociopaths who profit off the mutilation, physical and psychic, of the lost and confused.
Christopher...that was a powerful comment.
Too few people know the truth. I will dedicate my life to help change the world for the better and put an end to abusers and the like. We are all in this together.
Psychology, for the most part, is nothing more than a bunch of nonsense that has zero empirical basis yet parades around as if it's "science" as a chemist I hate nothing more than hearing humanities grads act as if they're scientists comparable to that of any of the STEM fields.
The amount of times I've had some clown try and tell me that there's scientific basis for their ridiculously extreme and misguided ideaological beliefs is hilarious, considering anything ever put forward as "scientific evidence" often does little more than demonstrate how beyond an individual's understanding and comprehension
, concepts like science and the scientific method are 😅
You know, farmers and veterinarians REGULARLY castrate and spay all kinds of animals.
Reminds me of the song,” Swing on a Star”.
People, as soon as you include the images in this presentation, CZcams will remove it faster than you can blink. This message must persist even if it means we can't view the whole presentation.
You're right!
You're right.. but maybe they could provide a link to the full presentation?
musicmansuperman Thank you. I was wondering why they didn’t show them. That makes sense.
So true!
There are some gruesome images on google of similar cases that I wish I could unsee. I am almost glad I didn't have to see the pictures included in this presentation. But that doesn't hide the fact that ignorance isn't bliss. We must spread the word of these should-be prohibited practices.
"Tell me what caused you to not want to be who you are?"
That is an AWESOME question!
How old were you when you decided what gender you were? ... ( wait, you just knew didn't you. But Transkids can't know? How pretentious of you )
A child knows it is trans and can make life changing decisions before it is legally allowed to make decisions for itself, drive and be independent. Honestly like a child knows what it wants for the rest of its life, it knows so little about the world and their own thoughts and ideas. Preposterous if their 18/21 and still want to transition, fine go ahead but before that is just child abuse.
@@dnw009 ..; and how old were you when you decided your preferred gender? You just knew didn't you.... but nobody esle can do that. How special you are !
@@louisavondart9178 - Do most children spend a lot of time thinking about what gender they are? Probably only if they are exposed to a lot of conversation about it. Those who have difficulties do for sure. But the majority just accept who they are without too much thought.
@@thumbprint7150 ... " Probably " is not factual. Those children who question their identity don't know why they feel different, they just do. Once they find out, through proper counselling, they can do something about it. Those children who dont think aboput their identity are simply NOT Transgender. It's not a matter of acceptance at all. You are either trans or you're not. You cannot make someone to be LGBT but you can make them into a bigot.
It's so disturbing that this was 2 years ago and things are even worse now.
4 yrs now and even worse... It's horrific ..
It's a nightmare 😭
I don't want kids because of how bad it is.
I know it's a lot of extra work, but this would be greatly improved if the speakers' slides could be cut in.
I think the reason they didn't do that is because CZcams would have banned the video due to those images. Just my thought on that, maybe not the case.
Prudence Dailey Agree. It would have been so much better than just looking at talking heads.
Is there a website to veiw the slides?
And effective for those who might be swayed
Firstly, why would anyone who is not a medical practitioner want or need to see these images unless it is a therapist’s opinion that it would be of benefit to a client? Shock images, on the whole, numb society. Consider cigarette packaging photos. They’ve not been affective in preventing sales whatsoever. Most people just block it in their minds.
To top it off, these genital images can and are used like porn by individuals. That’s something I would not want to add any access to.
Im schizophrenic. I have had other delusions as well, but as a woman I have had the delusion of being a man. Thankfully, I was treated for being schizophenic! And I know I'm a woman.
I've read your comment, and first off all I wanna say is I think you're a incredible human being. I'm a transgender person who happens to have Autism and everyone who is willing to talk openly about their mental health is a true hero. I'm wishing you very good success.
@@dakotachristopher5532 , Do you support the ideology of the transgender community? In the Christian Bible it says that the body is the temple of the *HOLY SPIRIT* . The surgeries that transgenders do to their bodies is disrespect to their own bodies. I advise parents to keep transgenders as far away from their children as possible, by force if *necessary* , and to keep their children away from transgenders. I accept your life choice, I do not have to like it and I do not. Jesus says to love your enemies. The *LOVE* that I show to transgenders is to respect their basic human rights and *NOTHING* more. The transgender community does not respect children and women and free speech and nothing needs to be added to that list. I hope you get over your delusional mental state. I would not want a person driving a school bus if they thought they could change from a person to a pop-up toaster any time they *IMAGINED* it to be so. That could put lives in danger.
I wish we could talk about this without people calling you transphobic..
the last activist who called my cousin in Ny that got his face smashed in from a baseball bat
Who cares if they call you transphobic??
*it is a very safe bet* , in fact, I would bet *ONE HUNDRED DOLLARS* that you do not know what the word 'transphobic' means.
@@KaileyB616 , IF YOU WERE A BLACK PERSON, WOULD YOU CARE IF I CALLED YOU A NI__ER??? FUNNY THAT IT IS OKAY FOR ONE BLACK PERSON TO CALL ANOTHER BLACK PERSON A NI__ER, BUT NOT ACCEPTABLE FOR A WHITE PERSON TO CALL A BLACK PERSON A NI__ER.
*I WOULD BET ONE HUNDRED DOLLARS YOU DO NOT EVEN KNOW WHAT THE WORD 'TRANSPHOBIC' MEANS!!!*
they are going to be so many lawsuits in the near future. This will die out I hope and pray.
Roxanna Quan Let the lawsuits begin now!! Allow and support people to be comfortable in their bodies.
But for todays children who transitioned its too late
Transpeople have existed since Time Immemorial. New ones are born every day. They hold to the hope that Bigotry will die out one day. You can help by not wearing a sealtbelt and ignoring Stop signs.
transgender people do exist and yes many of them do know that by the time they are let's say 15. I see far too many people in this comment section say things like "we are letting 4 year olds become transgender and giving them horomes. If you think people who are lets say 15 have a high enough chance to grow out of it that it would overall be better to not have any medical intervention and let the probably quite high percentage that would grow up to be transgender have to go through the wrong puberty fully before transitioning then fair enough. In fact I think I would even maybe agree with that. If 50% of teenagers that have gender dysphoria grow out of it then don't transition kids but there are transgender people and they often know at around that age and you are not doing anything to help them during a time their bodies are changing in ways they hate. It's a lose/lose scenario either way. But all I ask is compassion for transgender people as you can disagree on transitioning kids with gender dysphoria, but far too often that is used to paint the transgender community with a child abuse agenda brush and spread hate their way. So i've rambled on but just be compassionate to gender non comforming people, it ain't easy for them.
Hopefully in time. Statue of limitations. Some don't realize problems until too late
I am glad I grew up in a different time. I wasn't super feminine. God knows what would have happened to me if my birthday had been in 2009 vs. 1959.
As another 1959'er, I couldn't agree more. It's a horrifying time for children.
I grew up in the 1980's.. and I was considered a "tomboy." I played sports with the neighborhood boys, climbed rocks and trees, and pretended to be a soldier. I used to wish I could pee standing up in the woods like my guy friends but I couldn't. If it had been 2019 they'd have pushed the whole transgender thing. I'm now a married woman (to a man) with 4 children. It was a phase that today's kids aren't allowed to have...
@@JtheCat3 me too i wanted to pee my name in the snow..i told my son that recently & he stopped in shock..he thought i meant i wanted a sex change..thats how badly they are brainwashing our children..my son has alot of friends that think they are bi or lesbian & these are small children how would they even KNOW
When I grew up in the 80's I wasn't a fan of sports and liked to read. If I grew up now, they'd probably have cut my balls off...interesting how at 18 I joined the Army, served honorably as a soldier in the Infantry, started my own business as an engineer and am very straight......it's just an institutionalized form of child abuse that they are conducting. A way to steal childhoods and any chance for people to start as children and move into adulthood slowly (the way you need to in order to become a healthy adult).
Without a significant turn around, this country has two generations before we fall into perceived anarchy and then a form of totalitarianism.
@@jeans7393 this is sadly so true, a friend of mine in a city school had a similar comment by her son
if gender is not a biological problem, why do you need to 'biologically fix' these kids natural biology
Skye Blue the perfect world according to these people would be no gender at all just a cesspool of sex and adultery
Ideologically motivated medical experimentation on otherwise physically healthy subjects....now where have I heard of this happening before?
Daniel Private Well said, sir.
Sounds like eugenics and generally morally bankrupt research.
Study the Tuskegee Experiment...
EXACTLY.
Kissinger, in speaking of working de-population tactics upon "the herd"........"We will......sterilize their children..."
Its so sad that when you raise the issue and say you don't agree with medical transition, you are labelled as hating these people. this couldn't be further from the truth. I graduated medicine, and am on my way to psychiatry. saying the have mental issues doesn't in anyway degrade them, I myself have chronic issue, why would I ever insult someone as being I'll or 'crazy'. they need guidance and passionate care, just as any patient in vulnerable position. I'm so sorry medical field has forgotten 'do no harm' principle. I know some day we will see this frankensteinism just as we see lobotomies - old, shameful and inhumane
As a little girl, I wasn't much interested in dolls. I wanted a train set, a chemistry set, a Meccano construction kit and a bow & arrows. I was a tomboy for sure. When my hair was short, people mistook me for a boy. I wanted to do woodwork at high school but was told that girls weren't allowed. Thank goodness I wasn't born in the 90's. They'd have tried to convince me to transition! Yikes! As an adult I've managed bands, installed/supported computer networks, managed a knife company, climbed the corporate ladder in male-dominated fields and even wore a suit & tie. But I enjoy being a woman.
And now I have a great workshop full of tools and machinery. I'm affectionately known as Bob (the Builder)
I love engineering sector of my life and also love needing a girl. But i can't understand why people want to change their sex organ and forcing children to do it as well.
I was a TomBoy, but I never saw Myself being attracted sexually/intimately with girls/women. It creeps Me out in fact.
I feel more comfortable around guys/men, females tend to bore Me with all the illogical drama & petty Bitch nonsense.
Anyway, I played with baby dolls to Barbie dolls and with boys toys/games too, racing sets with matchbox cars, base/basket/football. Fought like a big boy/man (learned from male family members). I love male-dominated action movies, very few love stories (Ghost, Mo Better Blues, Overboard).
My Father saw the future back in the 70's of what has come to fruition of guys today, not all are do nothings, but it's getting that way. My Father made Me as well as My Brother learn how to be a *_"Jack of all Trades,"_* like him. He made Me do the man stuff because he didn't want Me to have to depend on males to do everything for Me or *_rip Me off_* to build/repair things. Gardening, fixing cars, plumbing, carpentry, firearms, electrical, cooking, etc. I got lots of power tools too.
I really didn't mind, I was a _TomBoy._ Electronics/computers - hard/software I learned some knowledge from My Uncle & elder Cousin and I learned the rest on My own.
I refused to allow My Sons to turn out like some of today's do nothing guys, passing all My knowledge to them.
My Daughter is truly a girly girl having no interest in manly chores, that's okay, but I warn her to try to learn how to do some things, a knowledgeable man may not always be available. All 3 are adults now.
When it's time to take off the jeans, T-shirts & workboots I transform into a butterfly, hair styled, painted nails, pantyhose, ultra-feminine, lingerie and dresses topped of with classy perfume. People don't recognize Me & can hardly believe it's Me.
@@MemoGrafix Gosh, you sound a lot like me! I have 2 daughters. The first is very feminine (did modelling & hairdressing) but the second (sigh), born after the first was already married, became gender dysphoric at age 23. "They" is on hormone therapy and now looks like a hairy male. The weird thing is that "they" was such a girlie girl until she had a relationship with a man who was in transition to female. The irony is, after 3 years, he left her for a feminine woman, to whom he is now engaged!! Heartbreaking. .
I'm a transgender man, and I still know that their are lots of tomboy out there.
I bet the Amish children have no confusion. They haven't been exposed to psychoogical damage caused by Big Brother.
I can imagine this being a tv show now.
Breaking Amish: Transgender edition
The best argument against hormone blockers is that they prevent orgasm. Enough said lol
Right???
I was on antipsychotics for years and experienced a lot of sexual dysfunction. My doctor's told me that it's fine because I'm not with anyone at the moment. So without their consent and knowledge I stopped the medication. I felt more energized and my dysfunction slowly went away. I haven't felt this good in years. If you do your research you'll learn antipsychotics kill the human body and most people on these die prematurely. Look it up. Doctor's everywhere prescribe these things. There's tons of medications out there that damage people. Just so happens that the spotlight is on transgerderism because they finally started targetting kids. Most of the population could give flying fucks about people not in that age range.
@@chrissmith8830 - Did the original condition for which you were on anti-psychotics persist or did you find alternative treatment for it? They are very powerful drugs but they do assist some people with severe illnesses. It is a balance of risk. Often the risk is too high but what are the available alternatives say for schizophrenia?
They started experimenting on jazz real early he didnt stand a chance and i think the whole family looks strange
Hearing her nearly break down during her speech is so heart wrenching. We need to show this video everywhere around the world!
I wonder how long it took her to learn to act that well. She's Oscar material !
Demonic psychopaths, cutting off perfectly good body parts and destroying a child, just because they're a little confused. smh So evil!
well, I know a lot of pastors and priests are sexual predators but I didn't know they cut off body parts as well. Thanks for the info.
Since when were children allowed to medically transition? They literally have to be 18 to "cut off body parts"
@@skrttskrtt8355 clearly here they don't have to be
@EricaYE6. when you have to fearmonger and lie to further your agenda mabye you have the wrong agenda.
If this video was around 5 years ago, It might have saved me a lot of heartache. This panel is right.
So sorry to hear that. I hope you are OK.
Thank you. I was in advanced nursing working with trans patients and the discussion of using blockers and hormones in children was beginning to quietly be discussed. I was horrified but thought, there’s no way this will happen. We don’t mess with development unless we know the outcomes. We don’t play God and we definitely don’t cut off healthy tissues. We are cautious with pediatrics. This generalized insanity that has taken over our society is deeply frightening. It makes no medical sense. It’s a cult at this point that is being funded by the corporations and the government. From Covid to Transing kids, it’s been a fast track to a sterile, medically dependent population. I’ve never felt like such a conspiracy theorist in my life as I have the last few years. I do not recognize the world I live in anymore. Children cannot consent. Women require safe spaces. Biology is relevant and matters. Children are being intentionally misled. Changing someone from the outside seems a pretty twisted way to address mental and emotional distress. Nothing about these responses make sense. There is no such thing as longitudinal data because it’s still experimental and deeply ideological. So much about what is being done, goes in direct contradiction to everything we do know about mental health, development, and cognitive maturity. Munchausen by proxy is likely the issue with smaller children. Extortion and blatant lies to the kids and the parents. Forcing therapists and medical professionals to keep their dissent silent. This is a much bigger deal than malpractice. This is an intentional effort that’s playing into the societal fear response. It’s evil. Genuinely. It’s a cult of unbelievably evil people at the helm and many more who are afraid to speak up.
100% agreed…. And it’s not like all these people are stupid….there are intelligent people buying into this cult-think!
Well said!!!!
This is horrific. How did we get to this?
Josef Mengele’s got nothing on modern “medicine”. Thank you to everyone on the panel for your courage! So few in the medical community (I’m a RN) are willing to stand up to this madness! Thank you, thank you, thank you for sharing! 🙏🏻
I am also a RN- adolescent mental health, inpatient. I have first hand experience in this BS!
Josef Mengele was a privileged youth who went to a private school.
He looks like an abused child in the class photos.
I posit that this treatment back then , as today, was the norm in this class of society.
John Money Josef Mengele same initials same methods!
*YOU ARE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT!!!!!!* Been Saying this for some time. These 'gender affirming' surgeries are like experiments done on helpless prisoners in *NAZI CONCENTRATION CAMPS!*
@@blugreen99 having the same initals makes you gilty. it must be a sign from heaven.
So instead of a Doctor giving his medical advice to a patient he just has to agree with what the patient is diagnosing themselves with? A trans kid saying hey doc I’m trans.. doc says “okay let’s get you started on some blockers”
Crazy hay I wonder if that the case can I go to the doctor and say hay I have cancer an the doctor yes yes and puts me on kemo with out any test to see if I really have cancer this is sad and crazy no child should be going through this why are we say that boys are girls and girls are boys if I want around saying I was a rabbit I bet if be getting told by a doctor and therapy saying to me sorry but you a human being not a rabbit how crazy this would is now
Therapist question to male patient: How do you know that you're a woman?
Male patient: Because I feel like a woman.
Therapist: Give me all the feelings that a woman have?
Male patient:.........................
.....breaks down in tears:
Therapist:: So YOu are woman then so have HTR and these surgeries then.
That sounds loony to me. as if emotions were only exclusive to one human sex i.e women. the Transgender ideologue sounds like pseudo science to me like Astrology for example.
the patient would be more honest with himself and society if he answered "because my penis feels hard when i dress like a woman"
It's sad that we have to explain basic biology to seemingly educated people...
Child abuse
Thank you for a tremendous panel discussion...this needs national airtime...
no reputable National TV chain will give air time to a Hate group.
@@louisavondart9178 what hate group? Everything here stated is fact
@@louisavondart9178 You are the hate group...using your psychological problems to disenfranchise other young children. The truth is your pedophiling advocates would not allow it but this isn't going to last very long. When people truly discover the atrocities committed on their own children no accusation of 'bigotry' or 'transphobia' is going to hold them back.I look forward to that day. They are just not as informed right now but wait until they find out what monsters have been doing to their own children this whole time. This is not about you. You should have avoided going political or using other peoples' children for your own agenda and vendetta. You need to GTFO of womens' sports as well. In the end, you might have to be completely ostracized from society due to the harm you have caused. If you're looking for a hate group, look in the mirror.
@@louisavondart9178 AMEN.im glad some are seing through the bigotry.
@@mistersunshine1330 lies on top of lies are not facts. this is obvious hate propagander. it is following an obvioys script.
Hormone blockers, hormones and surgeries that reshapes or removes healthy body parts and organs for children...No.
Children can argue to start on puberty blockers at 8, but can't drink liquor until 21, or smoke, or get a tattoo , and in NYC they can't buy a large soda. They can push to have a permanent surgical procedure done , prior to the age that they understand long term dangers to their own actions,. This age is believed to be aprox 25 years old. More important 95% of "gender questioning" kids out grow this issue prior to completing a normal puberty period. The risk of suicide does not change post surgery, actually it creates more mental health issues when it doesn't accomplish what they thought it could do. At least for this century, no male to female is ever going to have a baby let alone even have a period.
I read a comment by a pathologist, in a hundred years or more, if we find a trans woman buried in the woods, they will not say "this was a trans woman" Nope, thru DNA and bones they will say they found a male body.
Datsun Man You are spot on and I couldn't agree with you more!!
@@tedscott This is very wrong, VERY wrong. It's disappointing so many people agree with you, especially when you link no sources yet give disinformation.
1. Yes, children can start puberty blockers near 8. It's completely safe, it's been done well for decades for children who develop too early. Source for that claim : www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/puberty-blockers-may-improve-mental-health-transgender-adolescents
Another study concludes that "Current evidence does not support an adverse impact of gender-affirming hormone therapy on cognitive performance in birth-assigned either male or female transgender individuals".
Source for above: www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0306453020301402?via%3Dihub
2. Minors as young as 14 (rare cases, must be very clear cut, 16 is usually the age they transition medically) can get SRS (Sex Reassignment Surgery), but it is VERY safe. At that point, it has to be medically and scientifically proven that they have dysphoria to have it done. Detransitioning as you implied, is VERY rare, and actually isn't done because they were wrong about their gender identity, but rather the discrimination they get from being transgender. 3 people from a sample of 3,398 transpeople had detransitioned, making a 0.088% willing to detransition. Source for the above 2 claims: mermaidsuk.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/charing-Cross-study-nhs.pdf
3. Your claim of 95% of gender questioning minors growing out prior to normal puberty period is outdated by 8 years (made in 2009, by the Endocrine Society) you also failed to mention the source, so I had to go looking for it (those wondering, it is Endocrine Treatment of Gender-Dysphoric/Gender-Incongruent Persons: An Endocrine Society Clinical Practice Guideline/ link to a revised update of it corrects it: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28945902/). Again, your evidence is crude, and outdated.
4. Your claim of those transitioning is COMPLETELY wrong it's hilarious. A study conducted by Cornell University (Link for the claim: whatweknow.inequality.cornell.edu/topics/lgbt-equality/what-does-the-scholarly-research-say-about-the-well-being-of-transgender-people/) states that of 55 studies on transitioning , 51 indicated that transitioning had POSITIVE effect on the mental health of the patient. The remaining 4 being mixed, and null.
Another study in 2018 (Link: www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6223813/) explains that "quality of life raises dramatically with ‘Gender Affirming Treatment’, the nature of which is detailed extensively in-text.
"
5. You are correct that no MtF (male to female) patient is ever going to birth a baby (with modern technology), and yes, no one is going to look at a male skeleton of a transgender women and say it was a biological women, but that is a biological stance, where transgenderism is sociological, and psychological.
Your comment is so false I'd remove it if I were you. These are blatantly lies, and I have just proven you wrong with multiple studies. It is outrageous that I even have to put aside an hour of my life to prove something so trivial to someone who can't even understand basic biology, basic social terms, and basic evidence.
(edit is for grammar, fixed "These blatantly lies," to "These are blatantly lies,")
- Thanks, a transwoman :)
@@MT-nh5eg You are so right. You are also very valid. I have no idea where this "kids are being *forced* to chop body parts off" mentality came from.
edit: wait minors can get SRS woah
thanks for the info
Datsun Man ought to be recalled
Children need a phsycologist, not a surgeon! This is fucking disturbing!
it's sad that what it takes for people to wake up to foolishness is people getting hurt and making decisions that they later regret instead of just, you know, people rallying around others with some common sense
Why are people like you who have great common sense, SO FEW AND FAR BETWEEN?
The first lady who spoke Elaine really touched my heart. I swear you can feel her sense of fear! Thanks for sharing your story!
I hate to make light of such a serious subject but I will. South Park had an amazing episode called " Mr. Garrison's fancy new vagina ". As humorous as the episode was, the underlying message was strong. I suggest anyone with a young gender confused child, allow them to see it.
Omfg lol. South Park was one of my favorite shows when I was in 4th-5th grade. I remember that episode when it first aired. I thought it was so silly and rediculous that he was gay, became a woman, then became a lesbian who was attracted to another man who transitioned into a lesbian woman. To this day it's like wtf. Lol
Trans people become lifelong medical patients. 😢. It breaks my heart.
We are all lifelong medical patients lmao. Do you not take medication for anything at all?
growing up I made everyone call me "Lil D", only wore boy clothes, and everyone knew at birthday parties to give me the boy loot bag etc... Lord knows what would have happened to me these days lol
I have been dealing with Gender Dysphoria since the age of Five Born a boy but knowing deeply I was not quite right. It was a along hard battle (not helped by a society more confused then I was) to get my self to a point I was comfortable in my own skin with out transitioning. Had this sort of thing been happening when I was a kid I can tell you Id have killed my self after the realization that I was butchered mentality and physically and lied to by those that where suppose to Protect and help guide me. I am so glad some are speaking out.
@Ryan Smith Happy to answer that. Thanks for asking. At five I began to notice I enjoyed the compony of girls more then boys and where most boys would cringe at being in the slightest feminized (Older sisters putting makeup on them as an example) I was not effected and in fact liked it. I also preferred girls clothing and That was also what brought it home to my poor parents. I knew I was not right and knew that who I was was did not match properly who my physical body represented. Hard to really describe but I hope that helped a little. :) This was every day I felt like this, nearly every time I got a haircut Like a BOY or went clothing shopping as a Boy it was even harder. but it was a continual nagging urge or instinct if you will that I was a Girl despite what my body showed. I am lucky that I am more analytical then most or I doubt Id have dome to terms with it as I did.
@@coyotej4895 All of your reasons are gender stereotypes. It sounds like you were influenced by strict gender stereotyping either at home or in your community. Nothing was ever wrong with you.
@@FirstNameLastName-wt5to Not true, Nature/God is not designed to fit Human standers of Perfection, Fairness, or Just. So whether due to some genetic quark, or the drugs or Alcohol my Mom may have been doing while pregnant back in 66 I came out with a minor cross in the wiring of my brain. I am ok with this, See I know it was not My fault so I stopped worrying about it. As to how I grew up, Well it was any thing but stereotype. An Irish Germen Adopted in to an Alaskan Native Family with one part adhering to Native beliefs and the other Catholic. I learned to look at all sides and fiend the truth in the muddy middle. Society is messed up but not in the way many would like us to think. Those who make money off creating hate Fear and confusion now days have had it easer because of the ground work laid in the past by those who sought to control the money of Europe. A group that had learnt it was dangerous to be the one on the thrown so they remained behind them, whispering in the ears of power Getting rich and controlling the destinies of nations by preaching there narrative of morality. Turing sex in to taboo so they could hold its sway over mankind hostage and make the masses do there bidding. That group however bad at least had a foundation of Morals at its center that kept it mostly in check. Now days the new despots have thrown off that tether and forgo there morals to achieve new and more terrifying heights of evil. They use that which we all share, against us. Our differences. Age, particular skin, eye, hair colors. Even genders now are used to beet us in to submission. So While I thank you for the sentiment I know why I thought the way I did. The question is one each person needs to ask them selves in those deep places below the layers of masks we where; Do You?
@@FirstNameLastName-wt5to , MALE AND FEMALE. WHAT ARE YOU CONFUSED ABOUT?
@@coyotej4895 You need therapy.
So sick, perverse & depraved!! GOD HELP US FROM THIS EVIL!!!
not everyone belives in god hun
8? Omg! This is sick! These are sick, sadist people masquerading as healthcare professionals. My heart hurts.
Just by your name, I'm assuming you either are or are a supporter of Jazz Jennings...
In the 1990s transgender clinics were all about watch and wait and not encouraging children. There were strict criteria and gatekeeping to protect children. What happened?
Obamacare required insurance coverage
Excellent point about the body positivity movement.
These 6 Words from a former transgender identifying person are ones CZcams won't allow you to hear: czcams.com/video/JBL2bIZtfQw/video.html
Great post. Is there a way to see the slides for this presentation?
Thank you for speaking the truth and advocating for the children and people going through this.
The respected Doctor somewhere around 25 min concludes with "avoid the puberty blockers and remove testes and ovaries at 4 years old". This was done even earlier than 4 years old I believe and did not end well for the victim. Look up Dr Money
T H I S I S S A T A N S W O R K.
change my mind...
*human's work.
There is zero proof Satan Exists. This is a fact. It should change your mind.
TRANSPOCALPSYE NOW. Lays it out well..you can find his video's on you tube..TRANSPOCALPSYE now....or..MRE9...OR MRE...MRE.ARCHIVES...hidden in plain sight.....tell LIE vision......PoLIEtician....satan.lucifer.and unholy spirit of deception. Ephesians..2...to 6.....satan..wants God's creation to suffer and be destroyed...man and woman...............Satan. Will give u so called fortune and fame..for your soul.watch ..TRANSPOCALPSYE now...MRE..mre9..he lays it out well.
this is what Hannah Arendt explained in Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil,,, it s human banal and cruel stupidity
I agree 100 percent. Pray that this lie be exposed and erraticated. Protect our children from the lefts attacks on their minds and bodies. Amen.
I dont understand HOW DOCTORS ARE ABLE TO THIS TO SUCH YOUNG CHILDREN!!!!
@MsMarian Rogers It should be illegal and unethical to give any kind of blockers to a 18 year old or younger
@MsMarian Rogers It should be therapy not surgery not hormone blockers but therapy. And if doctors cared about those children that's what they would recommend not to change them into something that they are not.
@MsMarian Rogers Respectfully, your using the term "Trans child" I dont believe there can be a "trans child". It's the adults around that child that have confused them. When I was a kid, I enjoyed playing all things boy. I was very much a tomboy. My parents let me be me. I was not made to feel strange or different or not RIGHT! Or told I was a boy inside. Adults have Created this problem.
@MsMarian Rogers A child can't and shouldn't make decisions so important. The human brain is not fully and completely developed until the early 20's of age. They can't recognize the long term consequences of any decisions that they make. We need much more research on all of this.
@MsMarian Rogers Its sad, very very sad!!
Really appreciate these people speaking up in this. To me it prompts a lot of questions. For one, I'm really curious about the history of this issue. How did we get here? The Michael Bailey example (mentioned by Marian) was took place around 2003. This was before the internet made transgenderism issues common knowledge to people like me, but there was already enough transgender activist influence in institutions to completely destroy his career. When and how did these people gain influence? Also with Walter's surgery happening in 1983 that implies that these gender transition surgeries were going on for a lot longer time. Have these medical practices always been going on? Even long before it was more popular?
Thank you for your bravery in bringing this to light, and providing us with such a genuine, logical, and thought-provoking education on this subject.
I often find women, including my best friend, who grow up "tomboyish" tend to mature into outstanding women. My friend is my sister, she has femininity, but also more strength and mech skill than most men. It is no coincidence that this targets people who are similar.
They hate women and men who are gender non-conforming yet still know they are men and women. Butch women and effeminate men who don’t transition shake their whole worldview. They hate to see it 🤷🏻♀️
tomboy is a gender expression while being trans is a gender identity
@@skrttskrtt8355 🙄
A teen transgender male(born female) violently killed her mother in the U.K several months ago. She had just started transitioning. I wonder did those high doses of testosterone attribute to that? 🤔🤔
You realise that they don’t give out high doses of testosterone, they give out enough to make your testosterone levels similar to a male of your age and they conduct blood tests.
@@fayenotfaye It's no guarantee that the transitioner isn't abusing , taking more than prescribed.
Could the "Fundamental TRANSformation of America" really mean THIS?
Look at the timing here....
The Boston CH is now infamous for the MEDICAL KIDNAPPING and torture/torment/ medical and psychological abuse and neglect of Justina Peltier; and other children have suffered also, in their infamous Bader 5 psychiatric section. This outfit is connected to Harvard; and the lot of it is SHADY.
Thank you all so much for sharing!
I am glad to see that these people and professionals are speaking out and telling the truth about the harm and abuse being done to kids by the gender industry.
The surgeries done on minor children are like experiments done in NAZI concentration camps during World War II. Any doctor that would do such surgeries belongs in a prison for the criminally insane. There is no change from male to female or vice versa and to describe such surgeries as 'care' is one of the most monstrous lies ever told.
The ultimate question is - what if someone feels he/she/it should be dead? Should medical profession jump on it for 99,99 $ ?
From being a three year old child who just witnessed their parents horrible arguing or an aching 64 year old man who had it enough on that particular day - whatever the reason is - should someone grant them their wish?
Should we just waltz in on a clinic on a bad day and end it all?
This absolute freedom of living and thinking without boundaries and anything sacred or meaningful to cling to is a path into complete destruction of any sense of meaning of life - that is if you are not perfect in your body and your soul, then you're good to go, according to very smart people - all the rest damaged units can form a line for euthanasia.
I am 35 years old and i am sorry if my comment is offensive to anyone, that is not my intention but i didn't know left from right up to my 25th birthday when it comes to life. I mean, maybe i'm specially slow to develop person but i don't understand how children can understand concepts of sexuality and it's impact on the rest of their lives. How can a child make an informed decision on mutilating its genitalia?!
I understand that there are complex matters and issues and i will never be able to understand everything but to me all of this is sick and agressive cultural influence and mind distortion - children are exposed from the moment they are born into sea of information and some of them get completely lost in that world and crazy society hits the last nails on their coffins. Why can't everyone that feels transgender at least mature while being counseled and helped while growing to their full body/mind developement and at least push through to 21-25 years old and then make that level of decision. I just don't understand how did the medical science approved all of these procedures when it comes to children.
You are absolutely right . Why does all this have to be done while they are children. Big Pharma and surgeons making money. Disgusting.
It is good that we only have two sexes in life Can you imagine if we had three
Terrell L. Howard is ok
There are generally two sexes. I think your point was supposed to undermine transgender people, and you should've used "gender" instead of "sex" to undermine transpeople, but you couldn't even do that...?
@@MT-nh5eg Oh my !!
A MT I think he meant if there were 3 genders/sexes
Please don’t go into veterinary practice.
I wouldn’t want you treating my pet cockroach
Poor kids
I’m not sure if I really want to see all the slides, especially the surgical stuff! The idea of medical and surgical intervention before the age of 18 is horrifying.
Will there be a video that includes the power point presentation?
They probably won't because it would probably be labelled as pornographic or sexually graphic!
@Moon Rise Oh yeah! You know they'll do that because they want that promoted!
These are the true brave and courageous people!
Would be good to let your youtube audience see the slides the panel refers to!
You are a great man Walt. I think you should know that.
"There's graphite on the ground."
"That's hate speech."
If you don't let kids drive, smoke, drink, etc,etc, etc! Why are they letting kids make these more impact full decisions?
Happiness comes from within don’t seek it elsewhere. Being a science experiment is never the answer!! We have become blind as a species and nature only made gender as a way to continue life on earth. You can like anything you want, you don’t have to change your body to like certain things
Where are the transcripts or copies of FOI requests mentioned at 26:00? I couldn't see any on the Heartland site.
My niece was a “dog” from age 3-4. She insisted on being called by my dog's name and she wore a tail. She out grew it. I am pretty sure she has Asperger’s, but she is a fully functioning adult. She is an ICU nurse, wife and recent mother. I believe many of these people are on the spectrum too and surgery is not the answer.
THIS ALLEGED 'GENDER AFFIRMING SURGERY' IS MORE THAN 'NOT THE ANSWER' ... IT IS LIKE EXPERIMENTS DONE ON HELPLESS PRISONERS IN NAZI CONCENTRATION CAMPS DURING WORLD WAR II.
The doctors doing this are monsters, and they will face a reckoning, either in this life or the one to one. God help us.
How can I get the slides that he presented?
Sharing this immediately! Many thanks to the honest men and women involved in telling the truth about this, finally!
This is Frankenstein science.
there was a time i thought USA was a great country and wanted to live there. Now im scared of it . It is rather mad country, where money is valued above all moral and biological needs.
Is there a way to see the slides for this presentation?
why doesn't this have more views?
Share it with your friends!
this is already 3 years old ... and it is only getting worse.
Why can't we see the powerpoint?
So what can we do to make a change?
Wish the video included the power point slides.
why are the photos in the event not available to youtube viwers?
Pls show the power points
3 years later..... it's way WORSE!
Amazing Pannal 👏 thank you, all of you 👏🙏🏼👏
What's up with not letting us see the illustrations and photos discussed. Showing nothing but the speakers' face is depriving the viewer of a large part of the speaker's message.
All this really needs to be rehashed and shared like crazy RIGHT NOW. They are attempting to remove the First Amendment with this nonsense like they did in Canada. NOT TODAY COTTON!
I have hypogonadism and I just couldn't imagine purposefully messing up your hormones.
Love and peace to All.
Can I get a few links to the studies mentioned? I can't find anything when I Google it.
I wish we could c the slides
How come we don't get to see the image slides?
Probly because CZcams would flag the video. Sounds like some graphic visuals.
I can't believe only 38k views more need to see and hear this
Most people do not think it's any of their business and many realise that this is BS spouted by a Hate group.
@@louisavondart9178 are you for real????? These people are talking facts and doing the right thing by speaking out many have whistleblown and walked away from their jobs because they do not support this.. so go educate yourself and not just information put out by transgender organisations/charities
@@lisaw5605 ..I'm Transgender, or was. I'm legally and physically a woman now, no matter how much you might disagree with that. So, I am intimately aquainted with the subject both on a personal level and with the science involved. There is nothing in what these people say that is truthful. They are bigots and cowards because they know they can't be prosecuted for spreading hate as Transpeople are not protected by law. ps... it's none of your business anyway so why are you sticking your nose in?
@@louisavondart9178 no you still are scientific fact also you do not know me of anything about me so don't tell me it's none of my buisness I'm shocked you are an adult... these people are NOT bigots they all have personal experiences and id take theirs and thousands of others words other a CZcams troll
@@lisaw5605 The Heritage Foundation is listed as a Right wing Hate group. I guess you would fit right in there with them. ps... your message is full of grammatical errors. A lack of education seems to be a pre-requisite for bigotry.
Does anybody know a therapist with common sense who treats teenagers / children?
Excellent Talk.
You are not your body. I have so much empathy for the gender-changed man on the panel. Lovely man. Thank you.
Yes he needs his own CZcams channel although they would shut him down.
I want to post this on my social medias but I know no one will listen
You'll be yelled at for being transphobic. It's basically a cult by now. No one is allowed to criticise it.
Because this is so publicized many vulnerable teens have temp doubts only to fully resolve in a few yrs. I've seen this
Boy: "Daddy, I feel like I'm a girl"
Father: "No son, you are a boy! You are my handsome little man and that's the very awesome thing about you! I love you!"
This is the solution!
SOULSafeProductionZ ironically that is how most of trans things happens , boy sees that daddy gives more care , love and attention to his daughter so boy want to be a girl to have the same amount of care , love and attention
@Tonya Antony why, in your opinion, is being something that you're not more "awesome" than you being the great the way you came out of your parents?
Last I looked, DNA doesn't care about your feelings...If you were born a boy or vice versa and a DNA test is performed, no matter what you cut off, tuck in, augment or use pills to supress, the test is going to show your original birth gender
@@ulforcemegamon3094 so that's how they all happen? When sonny sees Daddy being more affectionate to babygirl? Hmmm...
What about when sonny never had a sister? I can almost guarantee that many male transgenders chose to go that direction and had no female siblings...
What about when the only stimulation is because the parent wanted a girl so bad that they treat the very impressionable young boy like a girl and because he is still young and doesn't know any differently AND because the most influential adult in that boy's life is teaching him pure foolishness, he follows along??
@Tonya Antony if sex shouldn't matter then that goes for telling the person that they should move forward with trying to be the sex/gender they are NOT...
It doesn't just go for me or people like me telling them they SHOULDN'T [try and change their sex, since ultimately it's futility anyway)...It also goes for you and people like you telling them they SHOULD...
If you think sex doesn't and shouldn't matter, you should shut your mouth just like you would probably like me to shut mine...
Let's be fair for real.
@@SOULSafeProductionZ i said most , not all , your points are valid as there are alot of histories like the one you talk about
I was all tomgirl...I loved to do what was labeled as male things..I am 71, yes today..thankfully I was a!lowed to just be me..who embraced..climbing high in the trees..speed horse events..mostly boys and men at the time....drag racing..poker..working on cars..high high heels..ruffled blouses..yes..I grabbed from what was labeled..male and female activities....undercooked playing with dolls..have them away..I preferred to be with my animals.dogs, cats, pet duck,.rabbit,.birds and my loved horse of 26 yrs
that was a gender expression not you question your gender identity, learn the difference pls.
when i was 9 i wanted to be a boy, i think because i was told not to do certain stuff like climbing, playing food ball and so on, but my cousins who is boys was allowed to do anything they wanted to do. my parent told me i will grow out of it. by the time i was 12 i didn't want to be a boy anymore, i didn't even want to play with boys either. is a shame that parent of this day and age cant handle their children cuz of outside interference. also i realise this is a Western problem. they think they are smart but they are not.
You guys should edit the video to show the slides