Jazz III Picks Comparison Shootout - Who beats the Dunlop Jazz 3
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 07. 2024
- Jazz III Guitar Picks Alternatives. Detailed review and direct sound comparison of the best jazz guitar picks.
▶ Jazz Guitar Equipment Recommendations - EU Shopping (Thomann): redir.love/thocf/znzfg0ps2l
▶ Jazz Picks Recommendations - USA Shopping (Sweetwater):
- Ernie Ball Prodigy Mini Picks: sweetwater.sjv.io/ernieballprodigyminipicks
- Gravity Picks: sweetwater.sjv.io/gravitypickseries
- Dunlop Jazz Series Picks: sweetwater.sjv.io/dunlopjazzseries
▶ Starter Packs with 5 easy lessons/songs:
guitarversum.com/shop/starter...
▶ Become a member of my channel and enjoy perks:
/ @guitarversumsandrashe...
*********************************
The following jazz picks are being reviewed and compared against the original Jim Dunlop Jazz 3:
- Timber Tones Jazzy Tones Bone Pick 2mm
- Ernie Ball Prodigy mini 2mm
- Gravity Picks Sunrise mini 3mm
- Gravity Picks Tripp mini 3mm
- Chickenpicks Badazz 3
- Dunlop Primetone 477 sharp tip small
I'm showing you each of these jazz guitar picks in detail. I put them on a levitation tool, that spins around, so you will be able to see them at every angle!
I'm directly comparing each of the jazz iii pick alternatives to the original dunlop jazz 3 pick. You'll see the diffenrencies and most important, you will get to hear them. I made a direct sound comparison in pro audio quality. So you'll have a perfect comparison between each of these jazz iii guitar picks and the dunlop jazz 3 pick.
I'll also announce a winner of this Jazz iii picks comparison, actually two winners for this jazz pick shootout, at the end of the video.
I made this jazz picks test, because I wasn't totally happy with my jazz iii pick from dunlop. It was way too thin for my taste. I like to have fat, non flexible picks for playing jazz. So I roamed the internet and local music stores in search for a good alternative to the jazz 3 guitar pick. Unfortunatly most were really sharp (with a pointy tip), so my search continued, until I finally had my 6 contestants to present to you this Jazz 3 guitar picks shootout video.
Which is your favorite jazz pick? What do you prefer and what are the criteria a great jazz 3 pick has to meet?
I found my perfect jazz iii alternative and I'll announce the winner of this review at the end.
At the end of the video I have a direct sound comparison, without the vocal mic bleed into the jazz picks review. Here's what you'll get to see and hear:
Ernie Ball Prodigy mini vs Jazz iii
Gravity Picks Sunrise vs jazz iii
Gravity Picks Tripp vs jazz iii
Timber Tones Jazzy Tones Bone Pick vs jazz 3
Chickenpicks Badazz 3 vs jazz iii
Dunlop Primetone vs jazz iii
I hope you like this Jazz picks test and give me a like.
Subscribe my channel:
czcams.com/channels/ita.html...
My Facebook: / guitarversum
My Instagram: / guitarversum
Hugs, Sandra :-) - Hudba
2:11 Timber Tones "Jazzy Tones Bone Pick"
4:50 Ernie Ball Prodigy Mini 2mm
6:55 Gravity Picks : Sunrise 3mm Mini
11:20 Gravity Picks : Tripp 3mm Mini
13:50 Chicken Picks : "Badazz III" 2mm
16:30 Dunlop Primetone 3mm, small (477P305)
18:50 Direct Sound Comparisons (use headphones!)
21:05 And The Winner Is...
Excellent review and great production. So far the best pick comparison I have seen. Looking forward to checking out more of your other vids.
Thanks, Steve! Welcome to the jazz ride on my channel 😊 🎶 🎸
Sandra,
I’ve been looking to experiment and/or replace my jazz pick. This is absolutely the best video I’ve seen. I love how you took your time giving us the sound samples of each compared to your Jazz III. I am a subscriber and love all of your videos. Please keep them coming!
Thanks for our kind words! A fan sent me a $50 Blue Chip pick (2mm Jazz 3 shape) and it sounds awesome. Just wanted to let you know, that this would have been my winner probably. But I got the pick after the test and it's easy too expensive.
Thank you! This is exactly the kind of video I need to see! I've been on a pick search for the last few years. Thanks to your video, I'm going to try a few, especially Gravity picks.
Nice job!
Thanks Matt! A fan sent me a Blue Chip jazz pick (2mm), after he's watched the video, and it's fantastic. But it costs $50 😱.
Being a Gearhead, I love these kinds of videos. I use the original Dunlop but I'm always looking for something different. Will check out the ones you've listed. Thank you for another interesting video, lovely Sandra.
I was surprised how different they sound and feel.
Very interesting review and terrific editing at the end to let us directly compare! To my ears, all the challengers sounded brighter than the red Dunlop Jazz III. I'm a fan of the Dunlop Ultex Jazz III. I think the material is a bit softer and gives an even darker more mellow tone.
great job on all your vids. very concise. I've been a fingerstyle player for 40 plus years, country blues mainly , but recently started dabbling in jazz. When I saw this vid I dug through my pick collection and strangly enough found a D'Addario Black Ice 1.5 mm pick that I received from Planet Waves as a gift with some purchase. It looks like the Jazz III except black. Very smooth and so far I like it. I'll work with it a while to see if I can get the hang of using a pick. Thanks for the pick review.
I play a V-pick, which I think is similar to the Gravity picks you've reviewed. It's also made from acrylic, but it has a triangular shape. It's very smooth. I really like it.
Yes, they are one of my favorites too. Nothing glides faster through the strings like acrylic picks.
This is a great video! Very impressed with how detailed you get and you're very personable as well. I'm new to the jazz world and glad to find another great channel.
Welcome to the jazz ride! 🎸 🎶
@@GuitarversumSandraSherman Thanks, Sandra! I'm so excited!
Best comparison so far, exactly what I was looking for, I want a longer lasting pick, because I keep wearing them out
Hello Sandra , Greeting's from Australia. Thank you so much for all your wonderful videos , I've been playing all my life and now I've hit 70 and still trying , this was a great shootout , we just don't see a lot of these picks down here , I've been looking all my playing life for a pick that felt comfortable and sounded good to me, last 12 months I've been using a John Pearse Fast Turtle 3mm , if you ever get the opportunity to try one , give it a go , took me quite a while to get used to it but the sound keeps
dragging me back . once again thank you for sharing all your knowledge . cheers, tt.
Thanks for this video Sandra. I learned a few more things I didn’t know that I didn’t know.😁
I saw the late great Joe Pass on a lesson dvd years ago and he cut the tip of his pick off and used only the tip. Of course he played hybrid finger style. And, of course, he was Joe Pass. He always said to do the easiest thing to play the sound inside your head(I’m paraphrasing).
Love your lessons, Sandra.
Oh really? I didn't know that he used only the tip of his pick! I love stories like yours!
I'm playing mostly with my fingers now but my favorite pick is a Blue Chip TAD 50. I also like Wegen picks from The Netherlands. I love the comments while you try the picks. You are so natural and real.
Hi Don,
I'm very much looking forward to the Blue Chip pick you'll be sending me. Maybe we have a new winner then 😊❤️
@@GuitarversumSandraSherman I will be very interested in how you like the Blue Chip Jazz 80. The reviews of this pick are spectacular.
blue chip is $75 for 1 pick very pricey
@@GuitarversumSandraSherman blue chip here in U.S.A R $75 FOR 1 PICK VERY $$$ HERE GUYS AND JAZZ NERDS HERE WHO OWN THEM SWEAR BY THEM.
Great comparison! Interesting video. Made me buy new picks to try out. You rock!
The cool thing is, picks aren't that expensive. (Although I was given one for $50 :-O)
That's why it's fun to check out different ones. GAS on a cheap level, lol
Waow, what a great review! Thank you. My favourite Jazz III-sized picks are: Nylpro plus, Acrylux Nitra (super smooth, barely any pick noise at all), Badazz 2.0 mm (roughness goes away rather quick after some playing) and Max Grip Carbon.
I've never heard of the first two. I have to check them out, they sound interesting. I wish I found something acrylic, that wasn't as pointy as the Gravity.
Hi Sandra, what a welcome and enjoyable review!
I got excited about the prospect of discovering a new possibility...pick wise, but your review has highlighted what I like about the small Dunlop 3 mm stuby ( clear purple )... which I think I will definitely stick with... not sure what its strummability factor is because I am not really inclined to strum much... perhaps it's because it's not a good strummer!hmmm🤔.
Anyway... great review, and I learned a new sound description...
Cloink, cloink!😁
For some reason I never liked the Stubby. But I know that a lot of people love it. It has a very good sound, it's just the handling I don't like. If you don't strum, it's probably the perfect pick for you! Cloink, cloink 😊
Kudos on such a well cut video. Your comparison cuts flowed well together and were very consistent, something that is surprisingly uncommon here on the tube.
I would also like to compliment your presentation style in your tutorials, you never come off as pretentious, and you're not a show off like some of the guy players I have watched, lol. Sorry guys, but showing off isn't encouraging. Enjoy watching your videos, thank you for the effort 🎵🎶
Thanks so much, Holly, for your kind words!
I tend to use a J. Dunlop big stubby 3 mil. ($3.50 American plus free shipping on ebay for a 3 pack.) I've used bone picks but after a time they make your fingers smell like you've had them in an unholy place. (great lesson Sandy)
thanks! this is the most important review for our basic tool😍
Hey, glad it helps!
Great comparison, I been using the Fender 358 heavy.
Same here, I've got a bunch of them and often use them. 358 are my favourite picks.
Thanks for the reviews Sandra! They all sound good in your hands! But I'm with you in the Ernie Ball pick and Gravity! I am using 2 now. The Dunlop Jazz JD 205 and D;Andrea Plec 1.5mm. The 205 is a bit bright and the Plec a bit dark and my strings are Thomastik Flat Wound Jazz Swing JS 112 (12 gauge) on a used Epiphone Joe Pass ii pro I just bought used....It is so hard to find the right pick!!!
I really enjoy the JD 205s. Haven't tried D'Andrea yet but I'll be sure to. I'm pretty new to jazz in general but really I'm loving this new world of music. Is there a particular hollow body or semi-hollows that's on the affordable end that you think is a great first jazz box? I've been playing for a long time now but new to the genre. I hear both Epiphone and Ibanez offer great bang for buck value as well as Godin if one wants to pay a bit more
@@grawman67 In the years that I have been playiing (still a beginner) LOL, I would never buy a guiitar over say $1200 and most of my guitars were in the $500 of lower price range. I also try to buy used which would even knock those prices down. My preference in order would be Ibanez both hollow and semi, then Epiphone. These are the guitars I have gravitated to when I first jumped into learning jazz. Now if you can get a Godin I heard they are amazing guitars. Currently I play as Easrman AR371CE for a hollowbody that I bought used for about $700 and D'Angelico Premier Mini DC semi hollow that I also bought used for about $800. My other favorite jazz guitar and if I was only to have one would be my Fender 50's road worn telecaster. Yes, telecasters using the neck pick up are excellenty jazz guitars. Check out the channel of Tim Lerch on youtube. He plays a tele and man what a jazz sound he gets!
Very helpful review!
Thank you, Brian!
Nice Video!
My favorite pick is the Dunlop Ultex Jazz iii XL. Love the texture from the raised lettering
Yeah, that's quiet helpfull against slippery picks.
I have been using Ernie Ball prodigy mini for roughly a month now absolutely love these phenomenal picks for strumming and shredding. Even though I personally like every aspect of these picks I want to test out what a Dunlop jazz 3 would actually feel like but I am unsure if it is worth buying since they’re particular identical. I love your comparison between the guitar picks really well done and reliable thank you.
This is awesome! I like the look of the Sunrise pick. And you say it plays smootly? I will check it out. Not sure, though, if my local music store has those.
Hello Sandra nice idea this pick comparison😎 I have been using Jim Dunlop Big Stubby for many years (small)
It stays in my fingers like glued😄
The Stubby is a favorite to many. I never really was able to get good grip with them. But they sound good.
My personal favorite Jazz IIIs are the Ultex Jazz III XL and the Primetone Jazz III XL 1.4 mm. Honorable mention to the John Petrucci Primetone.
My Blue Chip Jazz LG 35 is my real favorite, but it's too expensive for me to recommend unless you're a huge pick nerd like me.
A dear fan sent me a Blue Chip and I love it! But I don't use it that often, bc I'm afraid to lose it. You know how fast those things end in a parallel universe, right? 😊
@GuitarversumSandraSherman I've paid the Bluechip pick tax and had to replace it before. I spent the extra $10 on the wooden case for it and haven't had an issue losing it since.
I love ur vids and ur great lessons!
Thanks ❤️
As a bass player I often use Ernie Ball Prodigy Triangle 1.5-2.0mm, it is very stiff, heavy and sounds great on thick bass strings.
Wow, didn’t know that picks can produce that differerent sounds. Thanks.
I never cared much for the sound, more for the haptic. This test opened my eyes too. The differences are even bigger when you play it yourself, than listening to recorded sound. The instant response is totally unique to each pick.
Hi Sandra, I also like my Prodigy Pick! I tried the 1,5 mm and the smaller sized ones too, but my favorite is still the same one you chose. I like the Wegen Picks when playing my Dupont MD50 because they just feel "Right" and sound very good. Have you tried the Guzz 3 Pick yet? It's quite different than the Wegen but that's good! Because it gives you some variety, but is still has everything you are looking for in a Gypsy Jazz Pick. Thanks for another very informative and interesting video Sandra!
For Gypsy I use a Wegen, small, 3.5mm pick. It's very cool, although it produces a little too much cloink noise. I'll have to try the Guzz you mentioned.
Hi Sandra, my fav pick is Pickboy J-pick jazz, d'addario acrylux nitra, and Eric Jhonson jazz iii..so far is the best pick for jazz and perfect substitute or upgrade for standard jazz iii imho, and also you should try Gravity standard mini and Taylor thermex..you're a great teacher! Thank you. Greetings from Indonesia☺️
I discovered the D'addario Acrylux pucjs after this video. I wish they made them in 2-3mm. I be acryluc materials for pics. So smooth. And the shape is perfect, just like the jazz 3. But they're so thin.
Great comparision! I play mostly the red jazz III and Ulltex (small and normal) and the max grip carbon, but last year just 0.86mm celluloid reduced to the size of jazz. I liked the prodigy and the primetone the most from all you reviewed here. As an allmost intermediate blues player, I experiment with different picks, reshaping them, and with selfmade ones. I like to have a warm, rich and mellow sound with velvety hights.
The jazzIII Ulltex did sound less bright after filing a ca. 33*-35* polished bewel on both sides till the tip (like on a dagger). The polishing allows a smoother glide with less stringnoise and a mellow sound. The micro-roughness induces high frequencies stringvibration during the glide. It also will happen to the acrylic picks. I made myself a 3mm out of dental acrylic (I'm dental tech), with the same 35* bevel. The sound was nice and mellow round at first, but after time the microscopic chiping produces more trebble even with the worn off tip.
The manufactured shapes of picks often need fineadjustments to personal likings...
The roughness of the badass III would be my to go pick for metall (...but have to learn it first...)
Dental acrylic sounds interesting! Have you ever tried to make a pick from scratch from that material?
Guitarversum Sandra Sherman
Yes, I made a silicone mold in the shape of the small stubby pick. Never tried an acrilic from the market, but dental acrilic is kinda sticky to the fingers, with bit of sweat even more. 😃
Does it sound any good? Because the sticky thing is definitely a good thing. Maybe you found the perfect material to overcome the neverending story of slippery pucks! That would make you a millionaire! (If that happens I want a lifetime free pick supply 😁)
Guitarversum Sandra Sherman
An innovation!😃 Oh, that would be something haha. The pick sounds very nice to my untraind ears, mellow, not bassy, not scratchy, and the rounded tip I made specifically to have soft hights on the thin strings. All angles and curves have an impact on attack and sound and feel....besides the properties of the material😊 I suppose there is almost nothing left, that is'nt been tryed out as pick-materials in the past 70 years or so... ( I even tried a brush for strumming😂)
Ofcourse- lifetime supply 😉
Guitarversum Sandra Sherman
Ich würde Dir, liebe Sandra, irgendwann ein paar selbstgemachte plecs aus Dental-Kunststoff schicken. Werde dann nach Kontaktdaten fragen. Habe wenig Freizeit, daher kanns bissl dauern... Ich werde mir Deine Spielweise anschauen und die picks entsprechend gestalten.... da gibts entscheidende Feinheiten...😊Weil ich blues sound im Kopf habe, weiß ich nicht ob die picks dem jazz gerecht werden können...Wäre aber sehr neugierig, ob sie Dir entsprechen. ... (vielleicht werd ma millionäre😂) Nur eine frage: magst Du ne Delle, oder n flaches pick? Delle fühlt sich kontrolliert an. Du weißt immer , wie und wo die Ecken stehen. mache es so, daß Du spürst ob Du mit Spitze oder Rundung spielst. Welche Stärke wäre angenehm? Kann jede Dicke machen😊 (mein Gedanke tendiert zu 2 oder 2,5 bis 3mm (eine Delle läßt sie aber dünn anfühlen und sie hopsen nicht raus)
Great video, I went through quite a few before finding that the John petrucci jazz 3 are perfect.
They are a bigger in size, though, aren't they?
@@GuitarversumSandraSherman yes but only slightly, I find they have the perfect amount grip (due to the jp logo) and because the picking end is polished they glide across the strings very well. I was very apprehensive buying a " signature pick" but petrucci had a lot of input and it really shows.
I agree with Karl. The Petrucci jazz III are my go to pick but the Prime Tone is also in my pocket.
I've tried so many different shapes, sizes, thicknesses and makes of picks (including Jazz III) over the years, but always "returned home" to my "one and only" favourite type of pick: the small teardrop "358" shape pick. Any make and material I can get my hands on, I'll try! I've got quite a collection of them and use them in different thicknesses (from 1mm up to 2mm or more) and materials, depending on the guitar, scale lenght, string gauge and even amplifier. So I have quite a palette of tones but 358 shape is the only one I'm 100% at home with, I find them very precise and agile. If I had to choose just one, it would probabily be the Pro Plec D'Andrea 358, 1.5mm (which is also the smallest 358 pick I know). I also have an Ernie Ball Prodigy, white, 2mm 358 shape pick. I see that most jazz guitarists love Jazz III shape... anybody else loves 358 picks?
More important than anything is what makes you feel comfortable. You'll perform 100% better.
Oh yeah, I had a Gibson pick like that when I started. Used to be my favorite. I've since moved to the Dunlop Tortex 1.14 mm purple stubby jazz pick. It's been a solid pick. ❤
I've recently purchased a variety pack of Ernie Ball's 2.0mn Prodigy, so far I really like all of them. I've never been a person to only use one type of pick, ADPD = Attention deficit pick disorder. Thanks for the review.
ADPD 😁
Bonjour Sandra,
Encore un super sujet, complet et très bien expliqué.
Merci Sandra
En plus elle parle français ??
Merci beaucoup, Patrick! Which pick do you play?
@@GuitarversumSandraSherman Je joue depuis 2 ans avec les Dunlop "primetone sharp 3 mm "sur les cordes "D'Addario 10-48 filet plat ECG 23" sur ma "GIBSON ES 335",
mais suite à ton excellent comparatif, je viens de commander les "Ernie Ball Prology 2 mm".
et encore félicitations pour tes cours très pédagogiques.
Cordialement
Patrick,
@@patrickschwartz4861 I envy you for that 335 😊❤️
I recently switched from jazz3 to gravity 003 picks. They are acrylic and have a very loud and clear top end without sacrificing mids or bass. They feel extremely slippery and the tip feels quite sharp which allows for very fast playing and feels great. They are even slightly smaller than the Dunlop Jazz3 which might not be for everone. Current cost is about 4 Euros per pick.
Another pick that kind of grew on me is the Hense "Happy turtle" Jazz3 version. It is quite expensive costing 20 Euros, but it has a very smooth and warm sound with beautiful overtones and the feel against the strings is unlike any plastic. It's pointless to describe. Just get one and see if you like it. I would compare it to a Dunlop Jazz3 Ultex or maybe the Petrucci pick, both of which sound and feel slightly duller tho. Since the price of the Hense pick is 4 times that of a Dunlop I'm not sure if I'd replace it in case I lost it. But I'm very happy with it and wouldn't go back to a nylon pick any time soon :)
I,ve also been playing bufallo horn picks which I think sound very warm and organic and produce bright overtones, but they wear down quite fast and The tip is too thick to play fast..
Have to check out the Hense pick. Never heard of it. A fan sent me a Blue Chip Jazz pick, 2mm, that costs $50 😱. It sounds awesome and the handling is great too. The winner of this test, the Ernie Ball, sounds dull compared to the Blue Chip. But the Ernie Balks are still my go to picks. I'm always afraid to lose the expensive Blue Chip 😊
Good review.
The gravity Trip looks like a very versatile alternative to me. Do they make larger sizes as well? I'm not that fond of the mini picks...
I use Jazz III XL's (regular and Ultex, depending on my mood and the guitar and amp I'm using). Lately I ran into Dunlop Primetone sculpted picks too. I am very fond of the 3 mm version, which is easily getting me into gypsy jazz territory. Great stuff, especially if - like me - you don't use a very tight pick grip.
Yes they come in all sizes. I have a screenshot of the website in the video, where you can see all the options of shapes, sizes and others.
Amazing comparison as I'm a member of the jazz III cult myself. I was disappointed with the chicken pick at first too, but the roughness disappeared after a couple hours of playing and I'm really happy now
I have two chicken picks and the raughness remained. I love them for aggressive power chords, though.
@@GuitarversumSandraSherman Surprising, I´ll definitely try your top choices :D
Dava control Jazz Grip Delrin. Stiff, rubber grip, small never breaks a string like my old black Dunlap picks. Available at Amazon.
How thick are they? The Dava controls I know all have a flexible tip.
@@GuitarversumSandraSherman 1.5 MM according to a secondary web site. The Dava company sight does not give a thickness. I don't feel like they flex at all, but I can hold them tight or loose to get a different attack and they don't slip around because of the rubber grip. Definitely worth a try.
You should consider the V-Picks made in Nashville. Great selection and great sound. I used to use Gravity until I discovered V picks. No comparison. Great picks and even greater company. Check them out.
Yes, I know the V-Picks. They're excellent, but triangular shaped. I wanted the size of the original Jazz 3 pick.
@@GuitarversumSandraSherman NP. I understand. I love the V-Picks. BTW, I hope you haven't forgotten. I am still anxiously awaiting your chord-melody version of Nature Boy. Be well.
Thank you! : )
Sandra, that was a great Jazz III picks comparison video. I switched to the red Dunlop Jazz III picks this year from the Fender 351 Heavy. Because of your video I bought a pack of the white Ernie Ball Prodigy Mini 2mm picks, yet to arrive. Side note: In your latest videos it's clear as a bright sunny day that you're looking slimmer these days. What's your secret to getting slimmer?
Thanks so much or the kind words. Let me know what you're thinking of the Ernie Ball picks!
As for the weight, I've counted calories, bc that really showed me what I eat and have me a feeling for Weltausstellung better or worse. I also try to not eat for 16 hours (early evening till next morning) on about 3 days per week. The last meal I eat is always rock of protein. Proteines are a fat burner over night.
@@GuitarversumSandraSherman I ended up buying the Dunlop "Jazz III Variety Pack" (one each of red nylon, black nylon, Tortex Jazz, ULTEX XL, ULTEX, Max-Grip Carbon Fiber) to try one each of Dunlop's Jazz III style picks, one 6-pack of the white Ernie Ball Prodigy Mini 2mm picks, one 3-pack of the Dunlop Primetone Sculpted Plectra 1.4mm Jazz III, and one BlueChip BC Jazz 50 pick. After spending one week practicing guitar with each of those different picks my top three preferred Jazz III style picks are:
3. Dunlop Primetone Sculpted Plectra 1.4mm
2. red Dunlop Jazz III
1. BlueChip BC Jazz 50
The white Ernie Ball Prodigy Mini 2mm pick came in 4th place. I liked the Prodigy Mini's 2mm thickness. Although it has almost identical dimensions to the red Dunlop Jazz III the Prodigy Mini's all-around bevelled edge made the pick feel in my hand smaller than it is. Also Prodigy Mini's pick tip felt too pointy (maybe because of the bevelled edge) to me.
I like your practice of not eating for 16 hours (early evening until next morning) 3 days per week to help you stay slim. I do the same!
I use the white tortex jazz III the black nylon 1's in X-L THE SMOOTH BLACK tortex 1'S JAZZ III IN XL and D'Addario planet wave black ice stiffos and the purple stuby jazz 1's from dunlop and john petrucci signiture picks from J-dun-lop as well
Dunlop 208 for lead and the JazzIII for essentially everything if needed. Also use Dunlop 1mm b/c they are nice on round wounds but less on flats, and Tortex Yellow for blues, rock and anything not jazz.
I absolutely love your accent I feel like you learned English from a New Yorker maybe someone from the Bronx but then I'm picking up some like Wisconsin accents as well and then that's laid with your beautiful Austrian accent Love it so much you are an awesome person also the pick information is great Don't get me wrong
That's so sweet of you. I don't really like my accent. Spent some time in the UK as a kid (almost everywhere), my Dad is American, but I grew up as a German native speaker. Well, as long as I don't sound like Arnold Schwarzenegger :-)))
I've been using the Chicken Pick Badazz for a few years. Now I have some more to try out. Thanks
I like the chicken pick for power chords actually.
Great job on the pick shoot out. Have you tried the "Timber Tones Grip Tone Mini Buffalo Bone - Single Pick"?
I don't think so. But I'm not too fond of that bone or horn material.
Thank you
I mostly play with my fingers, but the Dunlop 207 is my favourite pick! Round tip, good grip, clear tones without the plastic scratch sound.
Great choice!
Hey, super Video! Ich auch habe versucht differenzierte Picks, aber diese in jenem Video kannte ich noch nicht. Hauptsächlich das Problem mit der string noise konnte ich nicht lösen, noch. Ist nicht eine falsche Spielweise der Grund für diese noise?
Nein, das string noise kommt nicht von einer falschen Haltung. Es stimmt zwar, dass es leiser wird, wenn man den Pick gerader hält, aber der Pick gehört nun mal leicht schräg gehalten.
Oh, how cool is that? I play a purple Dunlop 2mm, but it's a larger one.
I played that one for about 15 years, until I realized it's too large for me. Ever since I play smaller picks, they don't slip through my fingers anymore.
I find jazz picks a bit small. I use a Dunlop Andy James. Same sort of shape as the Ernie Ball but larger. Thanks! Love the videos!
Cool choice! I wanted to try the Dunlop Prunwtibe John Petrucci, but it's too large for me.
@@GuitarversumSandraSherman I do like the taper at the edges of both. I gave a John P to my guitar teacher (also Jon P!). He had been using a pick for over 20 years and has switched styles. Thanks for the "Greetings from Austria". I toured your country with Eidelwiess Bike Tours out of Mieming and spent some time there on other rides. 2 friends and I were on Grossglockner on a pristine summer day! A priceless memory from a beautiful country.
actually, "Motorcycle" tours!
Tx Sandra! Personally for me is Wegen 3.5mm Triton for playing Gypsy Jazz
Yes, I love the Wegens too for Gyosy jazz. I play a 3.5mm Twin. But regarding Jazz it's way to clacky for me
My two favorites are Dunlop JD JazzTone 204 and Dunlop Primetone 477R305
The Primetones sounds amazing! I just haven't found my perfect shape yet.
Just a small point. The Ernie Ball 2mm Prodigy has several different types. Which one did you use?
Large Shield
Mini
Multi pack
Sharp
Shield
Standard
Teardrop
The mini. It says that in the video, though 😊
@@GuitarversumSandraSherman Oh my bad. Thanks. The word 'mini' was so mini, that I missed it. Have now changed my online order for these. You have such a global influence Sandra :-))
I like the gravity trip but I'm using the trip by gravity I'm using the trip standard to it also has three edges I think you were reviewing the mini but I have the I think it's the regular since I'm blind I can't tell if I think I'm using the regular size but it does have three different points so for me it's the gravity trip standard to Great review thank you my autocorrect is terrible but to confirm I'm using the trip standard 2
I reviewed the Mini AND the Tripp Big Mini. I think the Tripp only comes in this one size, named Big Mini.
Great video. Have you tried the Dunlop Jazz 3 Tortex picks? You can get up to 1.5 mm.
Yes, they are quite good.
Have you tried the Dunlop Flow picks. The Andy James and John Petrucci Flow picks? I really need an imput because they are not available in my country and I have to know how they are before I actually import them from US.
They are excellent, but a bit larger than the jazz 3 shape I love so much.
In condition of high gain , distorsion or any metal sounds effects thermosomething , acryllics even ultex chirp like hell.I tryed lots of picks and materials.Nylon and tortex are much noiseless than all.Nice video.
Thanks for the tips!
@@GuitarversumSandraSherman With welcome.I forgott one piece of conclusion.The chirping is more pronounced when you play fast , if you play jazz or bluesy licks they are fine.
Möchte empfehlen, Dunlop Prime Tone SCULPED in verschiedenen Stärken - 1,5 bis 3,0 mm - anzutesten, da Material fester als Dunlop III, also auch nicht kratzt, und SCULPTET = schräg angeschliffen. Leichtes Drehen des Winkels zur Saite ändert Ton von weich (=entlang des Schliffs, up und down-sPleks angeschliffentroke) zu impulsiv und heller (= entlang der Kante des Schliffs up und down). Dazu bei vielen Modellen sind alle drei Seiten des Pleks angeschliffen, = viel Variation in einer Hand, und sie klingen eher nach Akryl als nach Plastik. Dass die Pleks größer als Deine kleinen Jazz III sind, stört nicht, probier es aus. PS: Deine Videos sind einfach toll und sehr sympathisch.
Die muss ich echt mal antesten. Aber was die Größe angeht bin ich schon sehr picky (hach, was für ein Wortspiel 😊). Die keinen passen so perfekt.
I used the jazz 3 picks for years but finally found a pick that blows them away, Zenfire picks. They make a pick they call the Phat Jazz. It is almost exact in size and shape to the Dunlops but the zenfire has a wicked good grip and twice the tone and feel. I'm not going back.
Cool, I need to check them out, bc I've never heard of that company.
The dava control pick ho guive you the flex you want when you need it to achive the best control possible but it could be a little bit longer to masterise
In Guitar Shops they always recommend the Dunlop Jazz 3, so I never tried another. My fault. What about different materials?
There are plenty of different materials. Buffalo horn, Delrin, Acrylic..
I love acrylic picks. Check out the Gravity Picks or V Picks.
what is your opinion on Teardrop picks? Those little elongated ones, like D'Andrea 358 or something, I've found some that are quite heavy and sharp just like a jazz III. Ordered a bunch to check them out, but I'm wondering why they are so unpopular, I've never seen a single guitarist using them... But they sell so many varieties.. who buys them lol??
I used to play the purple Dunlop 2mm pick for a very long time. It was the de facto standard for jazz guitarists back then. But I always found them rather big for my small hands and I had little control over them. They always slipped out of my hands. The smaller jazz 3 size is oerfect for me (and it seems for many others too), bc it sits right in the groove of my index finger.
@BlackonBlack, 358 samall teardrops (of all brands) are my favourite and if I had to pick just one, it would be the Pro Plec D'Andrea 358. I also wonder why they're unpopular... I find them very comfortable, precise and agile.
@@daegabmusic59yes, i've also tried the Ibanez John Scofield picks (the teal ones) they are quite good. I like the grip of the tear-drop, However i mainly use Huge triangle elastomer 2,2mm picks just for their amazing tone
I like the Dunlap Jazz III 2.0 mm, and sometimes the Dunlap Jazz I which is very rounded and gets over the strings easily.
The Jazz 1 is great for strumming!
Have you tried D'addario Black Ice, Tortex Jazz III, or the Gator Grip Jazz III?
Tried the Tortex Jazz 3. They're good, but too bright for me.
Interesting video even though I'm strictly a fingerstyle jazz player. I'm not sure if I even own a pick. 🤔😄
My favourite pics are Dunlop Jazz 208 3mm
What is your favorite jazz guitar pick and why?
Heavy Fender 358 (small Jazz/Mandolin Pick) for me. i play Tele, Hybrid picking, and the 358 picks come closest to the sound of my Fingernails.
@@bluesbox does the 207 have a round tip?
@@robgreene1776 I've never heard of that. I'll look it up. Didn't know that Fender has small shaped picks.
358 picks (I have many different brands, materials and thisknesses of them), My hands are very small and they are the smallest, most agile and precise picks, for me... they seem to be so unpopular that it's not easy to find them in shops.
Try swiss picks jazz mini. They have different jazz picks made of different materials and also different thickness they are great
Oh, I've never heard of that company. Gotta check it out. Thanks! ❤️
@@GuitarversumSandraSherman No problem! I used them all the time but im a metal player but either way they are amazing guitar picks!
have you tried the new dunlop flow picks? they're bigger than the jazz 3s but not as big as standard ones. they also come with gauges upto 3mm
the flow picks are very similar to the primetone picks except they have width to them which you didnt like about the primetones, so you might actually enjoy those
I tried them quickly in the store and they felt huge, although they are just a bit larger than the jazz 3. Maybe inkl give them another try.
Haha! They have two variants (the standard which are a bit smaller that range from .73-2.0 and then they have the jumbo ones which also start at 2.0-3.0) id recommend the 2.0 (standard which is color black) i know it's kinda confusing because they have 2 kinds of 2.0mm available. Just be sure not to use the green one since that's the slightly bigger 2.0 version
Oh, thanks for the info!
Your guitar playing is so beautiful.
Oh, thank you ❤️
Gravity picks (2MM polished) for me!
Sandra, I was hoping you'd include a wooden pick here, but I'm guessing they're too dark sounding for your taste?
Oh yes, on my search for a new pick I tried wooden picks as well. But yes, they are way too dark and dull sounding for me.
Dunlop Jazz 3 Max grip are my favorite. I will have to try some of the ones you tested here though. Thanks for the shootout Sandra.
I used to play the max grip for a while, until I realized, that I can't rotate that pick for strumming, die ti the max grip riffles.
Try the wood picks there great
i actually sand down my picks so they dont slip when i sweat
try it
Fuck, that's GENIUS
I wouldn't call it genius, but yes practical lol
@GC 3 Easy tiger.
i use the wheel of a riveter on the tip of a small soldering iron. The heated wheel turns around the tip, where it is fixed with little washers and a guitars belt pin. It stitches tiny holes, and the pick gets a sandy, grippy surface.
Ok so i just got my Ernie Ball Prodgy Minis today. Brilliant!! Great tone and great for hybrid. Thanks so much for your recommendation.
Yeah! I still like them and play them on a daily basis.
The red Jazz III changes its sound once it is worn out compared to the black one which is consistent
Oh really? I didn't know that. I heard one of them is stiffer,the other a bit more flexible. I really never noticed much of a difference. I played the red one instead of the black one, for the sole reason I could find it better on my black couch, lol. Thanks for the info.
Guitarversum Sandra Sherman
I like the red one because it is brighter. But I dislike changing picks every 3 months. I use the black one and never have to change, for years.
For me, anyway. Maybe it’s placebo??
I like the DAVA Jazz grips.
I see some people here already said they use them. Last time I checked em out, they had flexible tips, which is a no go for jazz picks. Maybe they have different ones now?
Guitarversum Sandra Sherman The DAVA control picks are the flexible ones. The grips are much stiffer. www.davapick.com/picks/jazz_grip
Mine is Jim Dunlop Big Stubby 3 mm.
A favorite for many! That's a great pick.
Have you tried Dunlop jazz 3 tortex it’s quiet on the strings
Yes, they're good picks, but I prefer the Prodigies
Have you tried the max grip jazz iii it has a higher quality plastic / nylon and sounds better ( I think 😅)
Yep, tried that obe. Has a really good grip, but turned it down, bc I sometimes turn the pick 90 degrees when I do Swing comping (strumming). The elevated grip scratched the strings and I got stuck between strings.
All the thumbs down were from Vietnamese Water Buffalo Great video!
😁😁😁
You might really like the Dunlop jazztones I believe it’s 2.4mm and a hair smaller than the jazz iii
Dunlop jazztones? Gotta check em out.
Iron Age picks are good as well if u wanna try
Never heard of them. Will Google it.
I know i am a little late but Do you know any picks that sound just as smooth as thumbs
No, bc they all have more attack than a thumb. Maybe the things some bass players use, made of felt?
Guitarversum Sandra Sherman thanks for the reply!🙂
I bought the Tripp 3mm, 1 size up from the Jazz3. Although the size was just what I was after, it has an annoying characteristic of making a sound like a tink on a pipe when hitting the strings, whereas the Jazz3 doesn't. $11.70 for 1 pic, shipped...ouch.
Some picks have that click sound, but I didn't hear it in the Tripp. Maybe it's the way we hold the pick differently?
Bravo for this excellent video!
I tested a lot of picks for jazz ...
I really like the D'Andrea Pro Plecs, some V Picks, the Dugains, but my favorites are the Dunlop Jazztone 205. (The 305 are good, but like you, I don't like fingerprints ... )
I did not know the Ernie Ball Prodigy, I will try to try them !
Thank you very much
Will have to check out the D'Andrea. Are they small or regular sized?
@@GuitarversumSandraSherman Differents shapes exist, but the D'Andrea Pro Plec 651 is a little more bigger than the JazzIII but has the same shape
It's not easy to find them , it's a problem
Plus 1 for Wegen picks.
i just got the Eric Johnson jazz 3 , a lot darker than the original .. I'm back and forth with back them.
I've never tested that. I always wondered, if there's a difference, bc all those endorsement jazz 3 picks look rather identical.
Good science.
How the picks play through the strings for smoothness and speed is equally important as the sound...yet not much emphasis on this..
Didn't I mention how smooth the acrylick picks flow through the strings, as opposed to the Chicken Picks for example?
You probably did..my apologies..i cut out before the end of the video
Have you heard of wegen picks? these are excellent...
Try to find Pee Wee picks from Fred Kelly Thumb Picks in America. Best I have ever used. They are small "jazz picks" .
What is the single pickup guitar in the stand behind you? Is it an Eastman?
It's an Eastman 805 CE.
@@GuitarversumSandraSherman Price aside, would you consider it a good guitar for someone who is just beginning jazz?
@@kathleenmclean86 Is a great guitar, but not the easiest to play on. Archtops are generally a little hard to play. They're usually huge. Please watch my video on gear recommendations and amp settings:
czcams.com/video/-6Tylw4gf0E/video.html
Halo madam. Which is harder white prodigy or black prodigy for 1.5mm picks?
I don't know. Is there a difference in color? I only know the white ones and they're 2mm.
@@GuitarversumSandraSherman just asking if u like the 2.0mm or 1.5mm better. Sorry my english is not good.
@@rockpinch5177 Oh, I see. The fatter, the better. I wish they had a 3mm version 😊
What about dunlop jazz II you know it ?
Eres la mejor
Claudio
Tierra del Fuego Argentina
It had a rounder tip. It's not so precise. I sometimes use it when playing swing guitar (strumming the chords).
Sandra is a honor to me you respond me
I decide for dunlop jazztone 207
It use Rosenwinkel my hero je je
You are incredible person God bless you
Sorry my english Is vas
Suerte total Sandra repito con tu respuesta me has honrado
No a la guerra
GRACIAS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Termine comprando la jazztone 207
Error. Punta muy redondeada, debi elegir la jazz 3
Acá en argentina con el costo de envío pague cada 207 unos mil pesos. Compré 3 o sea tres mil
siendo un salario de 100 mil en promedio
Caro el hobby
Abrazo Sandra y amigos !
"I get stuck between strings..." - proceeds to play better than I could ever hope to!
Hehe 😊. But the right pick (for you) can still help. But then again it's practice and getting into details. I once tried to figure out the best angle to cross strings smoothly in various scenarios (coming from a downstroje or upstroke etc) . I spent a few weeks on that and it changed my playing for the better.
@@GuitarversumSandraSherman Oh, I understand' I admire your talent and your practice work always shows. I will try some picks that you like. I enjoyed your review.