Right it’s not fair that’s he’s trying to kill his niece but James trying to kill his own brother to but David killed James because he’s trying to hurt his daughter so he had Emma back from James I didn’t like James who does that to his own family
Am I the only one that thought that them standing at the edge of the dock afterwards was really dangerous? I was just like "WHAT ARE YOU DOING YOURE GONNA GET PUSHED IN, OH PLS DONT GET PUSHED IN!"
Generally that doesn't happen what happens is James falls into the river and when he falls into the river what happens is that his body falls apart and then what remains is his soul and his soul is trapped in the river
Literally, it is SO confusing which is which for James and Charming. I mean, I know Josh is acting out both of then but can't they wear different clothing so you can tell them apart? But I guess the writers must've done that on purpose to make it more interesting
This scene would have been so much better it if it was Killian who had punched James for trying to hurt his girl, and then handed him over to David to finish him off. It would have been so much cuter if Killian pulled her to him and checked her over for injuries and they shared an adorable and passionate kiss and everything, and then afterwards he just held her and whispered words of comfort and UGH MY CAPTAINSWAN HEART NEEDS MORE
But a selfish person like James would hate David for 'stealing his thunder'. He even said so, David killed the dragon which earned him glory, James wanted that glory.
Yeah, that's the thing. How would he know what happened in the Enchanted Forest after he died? His unfinished would have been slaying the monster, becoming king or both. David would have nothing to do with it since neither have them met since Rumplestiltskin taken James from their mother.
Idk if someone remembers this but when Snow White met charming he said his name was “James” I was so confused so Snow White meant James first okay for real I’m confused 🤷🏻♀️
this show was really horrible to David's family. why couldn't Cruella's words about James's anger on David in 5x15 be true? why taking away his redeeming qualities? and this season could've had a whole episode could be about a complete family reunion about them. David, James, Ruth and Robert. I mean sure as hell the father had an unfinished business and the mother seriously never wanted to meet her the other son? why they threw away this kind of chances for less likeable storylines?
Cause There Is No Redemption For James, King George Brainwashed James To The Point He Believed In The Same Things George Believed In... He Proved That When He Stole The Giant's Gold And Left Jack To Die... I Doubt That There Was Any Good Left In James For David To Save Especially After All Those Years With George
@@Franandlar none of what you said excuses this show's and this season's lame attempts towards Nolan family even if James was irredeemable, there was still a chance for a family reunion. Robert obviously had an unfinished business and Ruth sure as hell had a reason to meet the son she never got the chance to connect with. Even if that kind of storyline would end tragically, that kind of episode would be so much better than what they gave us about Hook's backstory, someone who's centric episodes are easily the weakest lamest episodes in every damn season
@@altinaykor364 They Told Enough About The Nolan Family As Far As I Was Concerned To The Point That I Knew Those Characters... The Last Thing We Needed Was A Padme/Anakin Moment On Mustafar Where James Kills His Parents...
@@Franandlar no they didn't! They completely forgot about them and the influence they could've had on the underworld storyline, David's character and stronger potential aka one of redeeming qualities for the mess show gave us in S5.and worst part is that they used them a season after, once the underworld storyline was over and literally could've end there and for what? Another drama for CapitanSwan! David is the one who loses his father, a chance for a family reunion, put a positive impact on his family and it's still CapitanSwan that needs to have focus😶 don't reply to me to excuse all of this ever again And Anakin Padme you're talking about, hah! OUAT would've never gone that dark! They're not even as talented, creative and defiance as Disney movies, and even if they made a less interesting storyline, it would be so much better than another of Hook's boring weak ass episodes on every damn season! so don't reply to by trying to excuse that either👎 and by the way, If homicidal murderers in this show have redeeming qualities, James who was on worst terms just an asshole, could've had as well, cause news flesh, there are so many people like that in real life that are still not beyond line😐😐😐
Cause Charming got everything he ever wanted. The glory, the fame. Charming was known as basically the best knight/king in the EF, James wanted that. But James is a selfish prick and would never be able to reach that level of good.
@@oncer95 never said it was. Only implied that James grew up to be the perfect strong, brave prince. But sadly Ego got in the way and he was killed, which lead to his dad getting David as a replacement. Thus allowing everything James should of had, the princess, the glory and fame end up going to David
Wait! That was David who fell!! Look at a different scene and David (Prince Charming) was wearing a grey shirt and James was wearing a plaid shirt. David is the one who fell!
That would've been a cool plot twist though! David being the one thrown in, but they all think it was James then they take James back and he wreaks havoc on Storybrooke, although then we would've lost David... :( But it still would've been pretty cool... And sad...
And the award for Uncle of the year goes to... James!
Exactly
For the worst*
pretty sure hades has him beat when it comes down to it.
James: *pulls out a knife*
David: Whoa, okay, I'm sensing a distinct drop in the friendliness of this fight - EMMA YOU CAN BLAST HIM NOW
Does anyone notice how Hook asks if Robin(baby) is okay??? Heart is melting!
Yeah i saw it on instagram so i had to come watch it he is the best father
O yes, mine heart too
it's the bare minimum
James is literally trying to kill his niece...their extended family has so many issues...
Right it’s not fair that’s he’s trying to kill his niece but James trying to kill his own brother to but David killed James because he’s trying to hurt his daughter so he had Emma back from James I didn’t like James who does that to his own family
this scene must've been fun to shoot. It takes the phrases "stop hitting yourself" and "you're talking to yourself" literally lol
Yeah for real 🤣
Yup 😅
I know 😂😂
Am I the only one that thought that them standing at the edge of the dock afterwards was really dangerous?
I was just like "WHAT ARE YOU DOING YOURE GONNA GET PUSHED IN, OH PLS DONT GET PUSHED IN!"
Yeah me too I was so worried that Cruella was just gonna come back and push Emma and David into the water!
Ya me to
God I wish That James got more Screen Time Because Josh Dallas did an Incredible Performance Making Prince James a Darker Version of Prince Charming.
When James fell to the river of lost souls the souls took him to the water and then James loses his soul and stays in the river forever
Generally that doesn't happen what happens is James falls into the river and when he falls into the river what happens is that his body falls apart and then what remains is his soul and his soul is trapped in the river
Ohhh ok
Literally, it is SO confusing which is which for James and Charming. I mean, I know Josh is acting out both of then but can't they wear different clothing so you can tell them apart? But I guess the writers must've done that on purpose to make it more interesting
James was probably a Josh Dallas stunt double for the fight in this scene. it still must've been fun to shoot
Very true
Any time they are not in the same shot together or it’s a far away shot, it’s not josh.
James wears light clothes
You think this is confusing.... Allow me to introduce you to the og of this twin caricature.... I.e Kuni and Muni lemel.....
ThatTubaGuy is freaking awesome for putting all of these together for Oncers!!
Thank you so much!!!
This scene would have been so much better it if it was Killian who had punched James for trying to hurt his girl, and then handed him over to David to finish him off. It would have been so much cuter if Killian pulled her to him and checked her over for injuries and they shared an adorable and passionate kiss and everything, and then afterwards he just held her and whispered words of comfort and UGH MY CAPTAINSWAN HEART NEEDS MORE
YES OMG
This was awesome
how is david James unfinished buisness if they never enen met
Guy was basically a jock. Moron should've been blaming King George
But a selfish person like James would hate David for 'stealing his thunder'. He even said so, David killed the dragon which earned him glory, James wanted that glory.
Yeah, that's the thing. How would he know what happened in the Enchanted Forest after he died? His unfinished would have been slaying the monster, becoming king or both. David would have nothing to do with it since neither have them met since Rumplestiltskin taken James from their mother.
This fight scene is epic but it’s quite funny that he had to talk to himself and fight with himself 😅
Farther saves daughter
Idk if someone remembers this but when Snow White met charming he said his name was “James” I was so confused so Snow White meant James first okay for real I’m confused 🤷🏻♀️
David just use his brother name, because he must take his place and play prince James all the time, but his name still was David.
Thats the funny thing. Cruella and James just love to make others auffer
This scene would look so weird to onlookers
this show was really horrible to David's family. why couldn't Cruella's words about James's anger on David in 5x15 be true? why taking away his redeeming qualities? and this season could've had a whole episode could be about a complete family reunion about them. David, James, Ruth and Robert. I mean sure as hell the father had an unfinished business and the mother seriously never wanted to meet her the other son? why they threw away this kind of chances for less likeable storylines?
Cause There Is No Redemption For James, King George Brainwashed James To The Point He Believed In The Same Things George Believed In...
He Proved That When He Stole The Giant's Gold And Left Jack To Die...
I Doubt That There Was Any Good Left In James For David To Save Especially After All Those Years With George
@@Franandlar none of what you said excuses this show's and this season's lame attempts towards Nolan family
even if James was irredeemable, there was still a chance for a family reunion. Robert obviously had an unfinished business and Ruth sure as hell had a reason to meet the son she never got the chance to connect with. Even if that kind of storyline would end tragically, that kind of episode would be so much better than what they gave us about Hook's backstory, someone who's centric episodes are easily the weakest lamest episodes in every damn season
@@altinaykor364 They Told Enough About The Nolan Family As Far As I Was Concerned To The Point That I Knew Those Characters...
The Last Thing We Needed Was A Padme/Anakin Moment On Mustafar Where James Kills His Parents...
@@Franandlar no they didn't! They completely forgot about them and the influence they could've had on the underworld storyline, David's character and stronger potential aka one of redeeming qualities for the mess show gave us in S5.and worst part is that they used them a season after, once the underworld storyline was over and literally could've end there and for what? Another drama for CapitanSwan! David is the one who loses his father, a chance for a family reunion, put a positive impact on his family and it's still CapitanSwan that needs to have focus😶 don't reply to me to excuse all of this ever again
And Anakin Padme you're talking about, hah! OUAT would've never gone that dark! They're not even as talented, creative and defiance as Disney movies, and even if they made a less interesting storyline, it would be so much better than another of Hook's boring weak ass episodes on every damn season! so don't reply to by trying to excuse that either👎 and by the way, If homicidal murderers in this show have redeeming qualities, James who was on worst terms just an asshole, could've had as well, cause news flesh, there are so many people like that in real life that are still not beyond line😐😐😐
Hook should have punched or pushed or done something to Cruella for threatening his girl
aye you are correct my friend
+MrDredd1231 ba dum crash 😜
+MrDredd1231 "rolls eyes"
hook due to having pushed Cruella into the River of Lost Souls when she was about to escape
One of the bad things about twin fights. Is that you don’t know who’s winning.
I legit forgot James and David are played by the same actor. The difference between the two is very noticeable!
one question why james wanted to kill his brother I mean Prince Charming
Cause Charming got everything he ever wanted. The glory, the fame. Charming was known as basically the best knight/king in the EF, James wanted that. But James is a selfish prick and would never be able to reach that level of good.
@@emilish624 It's not David's fault he died
@@oncer95 never said it was. Only implied that James grew up to be the perfect strong, brave prince. But sadly Ego got in the way and he was killed, which lead to his dad getting David as a replacement. Thus allowing everything James should of had, the princess, the glory and fame end up going to David
talk about a fate worse than deeath
Prince James impersonated David Nolan
Yes Real Prince Charming is David Nolan
Wait! That was David who fell!! Look at a different scene and David (Prince Charming) was wearing a grey shirt and James was wearing a plaid shirt. David is the one who fell!
Or did they switch shirts?
James switched their shirts beforehand to make Emma, Robin, and Hook to think it was David so they wouldn't suspect anything
That would've been a cool plot twist though! David being the one thrown in, but they all think it was James then they take James back and he wreaks havoc on Storybrooke, although then we would've lost David... :( But it still would've been pretty cool... And sad...
Daisy Fae snow white be a lost soul too. They share the same heart.
Switch James switched so Emma would think that’s her dad not uncle
Why cruella don’t use her powers to fight?
Her only magic is controlling animals
do you remeber Cruella can use her Mind Control Breath Powers on Animals not on Humans
That's james not David fell off
Everyone: Omg Lana is such a good actor to be able to interact with herself. 😍
Josh Dallas: *Disappointed Cricket fan meme.*
“Am I a joke to you?”