115 - Understanding Balochistan
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 04. 2022
- First part of a series promoting unbiased voices about issues of Balochistan and Baloch people.
•
Subscribe to the channel and turn on your notifications. New video every Saturday 08:00 PM Pakistan Standard Time.
•
Join me on WhatsApp - wa.openinapp.net/ashir
Join me on Instagram - ig.openinapp.net/ashir
Join me on Facebook - fb.openinapp.net/ashir
Write to me: Gill@Maalik.com.pk
•
Watch Maalik Movie in HD - • Maalik HD || Banned in... - Zábava
Ashir I am local journalist from Dalbandin. You put the figures and facts in a brilliant way. I really inspired by your this v-log and hope to see more such stuff in future. Stay blessed and happy ❣️
Ady dalbandin a gadi e pat premio e
Gadi chun kany , wati sara jany ? Idha Balochistan masla discuss bayaga ent tra pa gadi e gepta
@@mohammadhassnibaloch8972 to dy boro parma gadi e pati MN maslaya Hal kni
balochistan does have a foreign support and it is india
Ali Raza: Waja shad abaad raho.
Voices of people from Balochistan need to be heard. Thank you for taking this initiative.
Allah Kay baaghiyon Kay Dil Aur deymagh par Allah nay mohur lagadi hay. Ye na sunn saktay Hein na Dekh saktay.
Thank you Asher for taking this on. I am from Balochistan, for four generations we have lived in Quetta / Loralai, my extended family still lives there. The story of Balochistan must be told.
Religious, ethnic and linguistic harmony was the hallmark of Balochistan, which is shattered now.
I had never heard the term "Choora" as a youngster growing up there, the first time I heard it was on moving to Punjab. The religious prejudice was the first of many cultural shocks I experienced.
Thank you once again for opening up Balochistan.
Can't wait to see the next episode. I have a feeling that this series will be watched by millions. We need dialogue.... honest and unbiased. Hopefully, this should unite us as a nation. Excellent Vlog!
Great idea to clear the confusions and delusions of Balochistan ,may this effort contribute to connect people to people and be the reward for aakhirah 👍🏻👌🏻
First of all, that's a great initiative by you. It will give us Punjabi's a broader perspective of things and a chance to hear out different opinions.
I have a few questions:
- How do Sardars accumulate their wealth in Balouchistan? Do they collaborate with the bureaucracy and military establishment? What are the sources of their wealth?
- The common Baloch has a limited media presence but why don't we see the powerful & wealthy Sardars contributing to creating awareness of the issues faced in Balouchistan?
- Politics in Balochistan? (A question to you Asher Bhai) - After the 18th amendment, who is responsible for Balouchistan? Who controls the politics and politicians? Do Baloch people question their elected leaders? Or in the first place, do they really elect their leaders or is it a pure 100% selection (You might need a separate video on this one)
Thank you,
100% valid Questions. Balochon k Sardar naa un k true leaders hain naa true supporter hain. Infact suicide attack un k Qilla pa hona chaheya .
100% valid Questions. Balochon k Sardar naa un k true leaders hain naa true supporter hain. Infact suicide attack un k Qilla pa hona chaheya .
100% valid Questions. Balochon k Sardar naa un k true leaders hain naa true supporter hain. Infact suicide attack un k Qilla pa hona chaheya .
The sardars accumulate their wealth form their business or just that they have a strong family tree and live off of the riches of their grandparents.
If they create awareness in the people that will undermine their power as people tend to look at the sardars as their saviors
Balochistan is in a pretty shitty state if you ask me. Iam a pasthun living in quetta and daily you can find people hating on the other because of there differences (at least from what i have experienced)
Great picks 👌 Answer to these will encompasses every aspect of their life,Ur questions demands a separate video. Hope he takes notice.
Lots Of respect for your this Initiative Thanks Ashir Bhai.....
U are the best thing happened to me on CZcams Asher. Great to know Balochistan this way. Anxiously waiting for the next part
Thank You!
It's a humble request please start this debate, we need to understand the entire Balochistan crisis and what is the way forward to it. Thanks 🙏
I love Baluchistan from the bottom of my heart. I have spent my childhood in Quetta. My Dad was the director general of survey of Pakistan. We had Baluch friends and hazara friends. All I remember is love and inclusion. Quetta has such a special place in my heart.
Everyone was good to you. Because you were daughter of DG survey of Pakistan...
@@chantara8458 what is this office survey of pakistan is it a name so strange >>>
@@ejazrahim4183 Yes dear it's a big department with offices all over the Pakistan. They do geographical survey of Pakistan. BTW what is so strange about it 🤠🤠🤠
Will look forward to your future videos on this topic, keep up the good work, Good luck!
OMG SO MUCH OF INFO WE WERE NOT AWARE OFF THANK YOU SIR
I look forward to your content, this feels like something that is much needed. I would like to share some thoughts which you can choose to turn into questions perhaps a series of questions for some of your tribal leader friends. The tribal code or way of life in general would seem to have common properties regardless of geography and culture, e.g. the one for all & all for one type of credo, the absolute sanctity of certain things like family units and women etc. All great values that increasingly seem to be romantic ideals to be aspired to never to be fully attained. Existence of autonomous legal and cultural codes that may clash with larger forces such as nation states & with the world increasingly becoming a more connected and less isolated, isn't this way of life almost obsolete? The most recent historical parallel may be the native Americans, shouldn't the focus now shift on re-educating the coming generations in a manner more in tune with the world as it is, because with the mineral wealth and natural resources they purportedly have, there will always be bigger and more powerful forces affecting the Baloch, whether its Pakistan, China or anyone else. So if any of this rings true, what are the thoughts of the Balochi tribal leaders on how they see the future for the Baloch?
Question: What Balochistan's people expect/want from people from other provinces to do so that people from other provinces can participate in making balochistan people life better? And from my side i really want to unite all and we should help each other to grow and make Pakistan a better place to live together.
No one can do any thing for those who cant stand up for their rights..... Their own sardars are oppressing them from decades and give them shit pieace of propoganda against punjab.... After 18 amendment in cont punjab has nothing to do with them.... But these morons still blame us
Well I would suggest you to understand Balochistanion, as Ashir Sir has said. Come to the same level than you will understand.
Very Good brother.... Actually people cannot do anything, its the state who is responsible for the wellbeing of its public. I also wanted to Contribute but i cannot contribute since i am not having that much resources to assist people.
@@muhammadimran-oy1xo but if we all come together we can make a change and we all heard a story related sticks. It's hard to break all sticks together but it's easy to break them one at a time. So it's very important that we all should come together to save Pakistan from people who are trying to break us by dividing and breaking us.
Balochistan lacks NGOs, we need some authority who can collect donations and distribute.
Ambulance system like edhi and chippa.
Education and employment encouragement in several sectors especially theirs.
Thanks so much for educating us, really appreciate your efforts. You're truly a hero!!👑
Thank you sir for taking this initiative.
May you get fruitful outcomes
Generally speaking on my interaction with a Balochi fish seller in Punjab, I was amazed with the respect he gave even I didn't know him while I bought fried fish from him. But punjabis are far behind in etiquettes and mannerism, we as punjabis give respect to others according to their financial status. Ashir Sir you are very right in your sayings
We weren't not far behind in etiquette and mannerisms. But right now you can say it is true as Punjab progress more and becomes more capitalistic and materialistic, seeing someone through their financial status is eminent
Punjaabi dangar hain
There are good and bad people everywhere. Do not generalize it.
Take it from someone who has traveled across Pakistan, from Khunjrab to Hunza to Karachi, to Gawadar, to Chitral, to Kashmir (lived there 17 years)... I've seen the worst of people (kind of) to the best of people just a few kilometers apart.
maybe the baloch was giving respect to you because he thought of you as a rich guy..and fellow punjabis know you are not that rich..ashir bhai is painting a far more rosier picture that it actually is...in balochistan a sardar is now a living manifestation of a wadera and chaudhary... read about what the bugtis did to their own fellow bugtis who tried to raise their voices against the bugti sardars..listen to the "aik din geo k sath with akhtar mengal"..you will understand what the sardars want..the way ashir bhai expalained sardari nizam must have been historically accurate but now its non-existent.. many baloch sardars are able to send their kids off to study in UK,US..how many regular punjabis can do that..i am from layyah and many of my friends are balochs who have settled in punjab in the last 2decades and they are just like us regular punjabis..none of them give the share of property to their sisters...they differentiate between their sons and daughters big time..
@@hamzamehmood1976 humanity is lesser here in punjab as compare to balochistan?
From KPK originally, early 90’s My fond memories Living in Quetta small area called Huda Minujan, walking by salted butter vendors and boiled egg sellers going to school.
Remember going to picnics on Hanna jheel, Hanna orak, pesheen.
Went to ziarat and understood why Qaid e Azam choose to live his last days on earth here.
Smell of Apples 🍏 I can’t forget! Dry weather and seeing my skin cracked on both my knuckles and cheeks.
Frigid Harsh winters huddled in one room burning a makeshift fire stove…
So many fond memories of my dear Baluchistan.
U have described it so beautifully that my love for quetta has grown more
Very nice initiative sir. Waiting for the upcoming session and a very good job from your side, telling the story of highly neglected people of Pakistan
Thank you Sir
I am very much inspired by your information about Baloch
You have started a very informative session .Jazak Allah
This incident has shaken the whole country to the core. This was very unfortunate that an educated lady, a mother of two young cute children did something unthinkable. We seriously need to look into the Baluchistan from every possible aspects and resolve the festering wound with sincerity.
One thing I noticed that she was mentioned as a lady in news, it was polite
May be she was blackmailed, and she did it to save her children from the terrorist, who made her to do the blast or they will kill her children
After shaocks are yet to become....
@@noone1722 we are still trying to comprehend how could she do it! I mean, when you live with your family, you develop a bond and commitment to it, especially when little children are part of your life. Was she psychologically too brainwashed and someone identified her a right subject to motivate her? How was she able to hide her intentions from her husband or he himself was her motivation to conduct this mission? This is a mind boggling case?
@@ferhansyed she saw the cruelties of FC and other hundreds of issues of balochistan and then thought she has to alert ⚠️ pakistan about it . No one has any time to brainwash an educated lady but we have eyes and can see the issues . No one listened to us and then some brave ones sacrificed themselves to get independence...
Fascinating and it will likely be even more when you delve more into this. Great initiative, indeed we must understand what different Baluchis are saying and what are the solutions according to them. My question: Why are so many Baluchis against CPEC when it can create employment for them and contribute in much needed development?
Because India/usa are against it. Tribal culture, whatever good you do in Their area, they think you trying to occupy their land / resources. Out of 45 countries where CPEC like projects initiated by china only in balochistan people are against it.
Baloch were not involved in the process Simply check all the job openings in the past 10 years that mostly require Punjab Domicile.
@@khawjafaisal I have checked - so many jobs advertised for Balochs, many of which they have taken too. Refrain from making incorrect generalizations. If you refer to total number of jobs advertised for Punjab province, obviously those will logically be more because it has far more population and activity.
Kudos for doing such a brilliant work of bringing this idea to limelight. This will surely let people to clear up the biased fog from their glasses towards balochistan and its people and culture and enjoy the utopian beauty of this wonderful province. Keep up the good work!
Beautiful ♥️ u just took me bak to my Balochistan ... how nicely how accurately and how sensibly explained ... such beautiful selection of words ...
Sir, my Question are following:
Firstly, I'd like to say that being a patriot, and a concerned citizen, i love Balochistan. I've many friends over there, though i am a Punjabi, but i understand all of the problems of Balochistan. And, i deeply regret what has happened to them, how they have been ignored.
1) Now, the question is: what can a concerned citizen of Pakistan, though facing the same level of poverty, can do for our brothers and sisters who live in Balochistan? I'm not rich, but I'm fairly educated, maybe I'm among the educational elite of the country. What can i do? How can i contribute towards reducing the pain of the people of Balochistan? I'm deeply concerned about them, their pain keeps me awake at night, it is depressing how they are living there without no water, no food, nothing. How forced one would be to pick up arms against their own country, and kill those who have no part in their misery. If i can teach, or teach People online, send some books to students. I'd gladly do that.
I'm not the fortunate one financially, but whenever i will be, I'd like to help. And, I'm sure there are many who want to help. What is the way to help?
2) There is a common notion in Punjab that the Sardars of Balochistan use all the funds, and store all the money in their houses. The money never goes to the people. Please, clear this misconception.
respect your deep feeling about my motherland.
your thoughts are commendable.
1st of all no matter how much of misery you are in you don't just start killing other people who have done no shit to you, 2nd I haven't watched the video yet, 3rd I know the situation is bad in balochistan and so is it in other parts of Pakistan, that doesn't give you the right to kill random people just cause you're demands weren't agreed with
Edit: to me it feels like it's a proxy + the poor common people are just being used by those traitors and terrorists
Be a voice of Baloch people and address their issues in your circle wid solutions so people can understand what is going on
@@playlist6264 I think we still dont know the reasons for these issues.
Who is responsible for the development of Balochistan after the 18th amendment?
Provincial government
Which development? Count me any project adter 18th amendment
Hazara ko Punjab SE aa ker busoon SE nekal ker mara hai punjabiyoon ne Kiya iss bande ki ghatiya soch hai khud tu ye bhag giya hai wahaan koi Kam nahi Mila socha ab Pakistan ko Ganda ker k hi paise kama loon lanat beshumar asher
federal and provincial both Corrupt mafia in the name of Democracy. Pakistani system is baldly Collapsed
@@12393813 that's what I'm asking, how much can federal government be blamed after 18th amendment
much needed to be told....great initiative .... looking forward to hear more.
This is very important information and awareness about Balochistan and its peoples, our peoples. I always tried to find real issues due to which we are standing at this level. Most of the time i am interacting with youth in Punjab based universities and colleges. i definitely try to keep aware our students about Balochistan. Again thanks Mr. Ashir
بلوچ غیرتمند قوم ہیں، ان کی values ہیں، الحمدللہ
I love them all 💕
I think people of balochistan should learn a lesson from South India. South Indian people were always marginalised and got stepmotherily treatment in India and now they are most developed and economically well off people across the India. No South Indian actor got any chance in bollywood and now there own industry is earning more than bollywood. They have travelled to gulf countries and established businesses over there e.g. lulu and Manama hyper markets and much more. So instead of finding reasons and blaming others and playing in the hands of hostile agencies, I thinks it should be finding new ways to prosper. Balochis have a considerable representation in gulf countries and a few have nationality of Oman and UAE, they are very courageous and deep rooted people, its all about realising your potential. I agree there is a huge potential of tourism in balochistan which cannot be utilised until there is peace. Its also a state failure that it cannot satisfy a population of merely 6 million. I think we all should work together with positivity and sincerity to address the grievancess.
Please accept the reality that there is poverty everywhere in Pakistan and no one is living a quality life. If we keep fighting each other, we can never prosper.
So let's grow together ❤
excellent job! looking forward to see your next video
Thanks aashir bhai for making this interesting series.
100% agree with u. lived in Quetta from 1986-1989. currently living in Lahore.
my question
what is the solution now?
in my opinion it should be politically solved, rather than by force.
kindly answer
at the end i love my country and want every Pakistani citizen to have their rights.
❤️❤️
It's the need of time to tell the people about Balochistan
Ashir Bhai apny buhoooot achi batin buhoooot neek neyti sy kin Allah Pak apko mazed himat dy
Such a beautiful story.... Thanks for bringing it to light!
Your patriotism is commendable....
I have been asking you about Balochistan since 2018. Thanks God, Finally you have decided to pin down your information and experience on Balochistan. The question that has been unanswered to me and I would eagerly ask you about Balochistan are as follows:
1. The tribal leaders are really sincere to do two things for their people? First Devolution of power and second is fairly distribution of resources?
2. What have they done so far in their personal capacity to uplift the life of their people?
3. Do they accept if a layman or a very common man become the leader of the tribe?
4. Very important question, what made Balochistan so much disintegrated from Pakistan?
5. Why we do not see such desperate voices from these sardars (elected people) but from separatist parties like BLA?
6. Do they really represent their people in parliament? What legislation have they done for the betterment of their people in Balochistan?
Very much relevant and valid questions that need to be answered.
بنیادی بات وسائل کی کمی
دوسری بات خود ساختہ عوامی نمائندے جنکو ریاست سپورٹ کرتی ھے حقیقی عوامی نمائندوں کی بجائے ، جنکو عوام سے کوئی دلچسپی نہیں صرف سرکاری وسائل لوٹتے ھیں وه
ایک مثال سے سمجھانے کی کوشش کرونگا آپ کو
آپ کا ایک گھر /مکان ھے جو بیس ہزار فٹ پر بنا ھے اور اسکے ھر کونے میں ایک کمرہ ھے اور ہر کمرے میں ایک بندہ رھتا ھے
ایک دوسرا گھر ھے جو دو ہزار فٹ پر بنا ھوا ھے اور کمرہ دوسرے سے جڑا ھوا ھے اور اتنے ہی لوگ اس گھر میں بھی رہتے ھیں
اب آپ مجھے بتائیں کہ کس گھر کی تعمیر اور دیکھ بھال پر زیادہ پیسے لگتے ھیں ؟؟
Bro here is a big misconception which people don,t know, the sardari system which u see tody in balochistan is not the system which balochistan had during khan kalats era, this system has been imposed by britians, during khan kalats era sardars had no such powers or wealth, they were choosen by their tribes people through voting, they were like governers, britians empowered these sardars, distributed lands among them so they could over throw khan of kalat from power, after independence khan kalat was thrown out of power and these sardars were owned by the establishment.
@@gulmuhammad5158 Britain really knew how to mess things up and sugar coat it :(
بھائی میرا تعلق بھی بلوچستان سے ہے میں ایک پنجابی ہوں میرے دادا پارٹیشن کے بعد انڈیا سے ہجرت کرکے بلوچستان آئے تھے آپ لشکری رئیسانی صاحب سے سوال کرنا چاہتے ہیں تو سب سے پہلے انسان بلوچوں اور پٹھانوں سے یہ سوال کریں کہ ان کو اٹھنا بیٹھنا پڑھنا لکھنا جاگنا سونا طہارت کرنا اور جانوروں سے انسان بنایا کس نے ہے آپ کو خود بھی پتا ہے کہ اگر بلوچستان میں پنجابی نہ ہوتا تو یہ جیسے آج باقی صوبوں سے 50 سال پیچھے ہیں اگر پنجابی نہ جاتا تو شاید یہ تو سو سال پیچھے رہ جاتے۔پنجابی استادوں نے ان کو آرٹس پڑھائی اور سائنس بھی پڑھائی اور شعور بھی دیا۔ہم جب کہتے ہیں کہ بلوچستان والوں کی بدقسمتی ہے کہ ان کو ایسے سردار ملے تو یہ صحیح بات ہے مجھے یہ بتائیں کہ کیوں بلوچستان کے پٹھان اور بلوچ سردار کھرب پتی ہیں لیکن ان کی قوم کو نہ پینے کا پانی ملتا ہے نہ اچھے گھر ملتے ہیں اچھے اسکول ملتے ہیں نا اچھی یونیورسٹی ملتی ہیں نا اچھے میڈیکل کالج ملتے ہیں اگر کراچی سے پشاور جا کر فیکٹری لگ جا سکتی ہے اور شمالی علاقے میں فیکٹری لگ سکتی ہے تو کراچی تو بلوچستان سے زیادہ دور نہیں ہے کیوں نہیں انہوں نےگھی کی فیکٹری یا آٹے کی فیکٹری یا کوئی کپڑے کی فیکٹری یا کوئی پلاسٹک کی فیکٹری یا کوئی سیمنٹ کی فیکٹری یا کوئی ماربل کی فیکٹری انہوں نے کیوں نہیں لگائی ۔اللہ اللہ کرکے ایک سیمنٹ کا پلانٹ سپیزنڈ کے پاس لگا تھا تو وہاں کے سرداروں نے بھتہ مانگ مانگ کر اس کو بند کرا دیا اور بھگا دیا آپ کہتے ہو ان سرداروں کا قصور نہیں ہے مجھے یہ بتائیں کہ اگر ہر حکومت کا یہ حصہ ہوتے ہیں اور اسمگلنگ سے لے کر اغوا برائے تاوان تک یہ ہر کام کرتے ہیں ہر پوزیٹو کام سے بھی کما تے ہیں اور حرام زدگی والے دھندے سے کما تے ہیں تو انہوں نے اپنی قوم کو شعور اور تعلیمی ادارے کیوں نہی دیے۔کیا جوتا بنانے کی فیکٹری کپڑا بنانے کی فیکٹری فرنیچر بنانے کی فیکٹری گاڑیاں اور موٹر سائیکلوں کے پلانٹ کیا ان میں سے کچھ بھی نہیں کوئٹہ میں لگ سکتا تھا یا بلوچستان کے کسی علاقے میں لگ سکتا۔؟۔لشکری رئیسانی ہی نہیں یہ تمام سردار اس چیز کے ذمہ دار ہیں۔۔ سارا بلوچستان بنا بنایا مٹیریل تو دوسرے صوبوں سے منگواتا ہے لیکن خود کیوں نہیں بناتے یہ لوگ۔۔۔جس پنجابی نے ان کو گ دھونی سکھائی اس پنجابی کے یہ دشمن ہو گئے۔۔اگر ان کو ایف سی اور فوجیوں نے لتر مار تھے تو مجھے یہ بتائیں کہ وہاں کے سیٹلر پنجابیوں کا کیا قصور تھا جنھوں نے ان کو لتر مارے اور ان کے علاقوں پر قبضہ کئے یہ ان سے تو لڑتے نہیں ہیں اور الٹا وہاں کے معصوم پنجابیوں کو گالی دیتے ہیں اور مارتے ہیں اور وہاں سے بھگاتے ہیں۔مجھے یہ بتائیں کہ پنجاب میں کسی پٹھان یا بلوچ کے گھر میں پمفلٹ پھینک کر یہ کہا گیا کہ اس کو یا سے نکل جاؤ ورنہ کل تم کو گولی سے مار دیا جائے گا ؟پھر ان لوگوں نے یہ غداری اور حرام زدگی وہاں کے سیٹل پنجابیوں کے ساتھ کیوں کی کیوں ہمارے گھروں میں پمفلٹ پھینکے اور کراس کے نشان لگائے ہمارے گھروں پر۔۔ہم کو وہاں سے جان بچا کر بھاگنا پڑا۔۔اگر بلوچ اور پٹھانوں میں اتنی ہمت ہے تو ہم سے ہمارے علاقوں میں آکے کیوں نہیں لڑتے ہم ان کو بتائیں کہ پھر پنجابی کیا چیز ہے۔۔آپ کا تعلق کیوں کہ بلوچستان سے رہا ہے میں جانتا ہوں کے آپ کو بلوچستان کے عوام کا دکھ ہے لیکن وہاں کے عوام کا دکھ انہیں سرداروں اور حرامیوں کی وجہ سے۔۔ہم نے خود 12 لاکھ کی گاڑی رئیسانی کے بندے کو تین لاکھ روپے تاوان دے کے چھڑوئی۔۔اور ہمیں یہ بھی کہا گیا کہ اگر تھانے میں رپورٹ کیا تو پہلے تو گاڑی گئی ہے پھر تم چلے جاؤ گے دنیا سے۔۔۔یہ سب بدمعاش ہیں ۔میری بات یاد رکھیں جس دن بلوچ کھڑا ہو کر ان سو پچاس سرداروں کا خاتمہ کر دے گا وہ دنیا کا سب سے امیر اور ترقی یافتہ بلوچ اور پٹھان بن جائے گا۔۔کیوں کے گیس ان کے پاس ،کوئلہ ان کے پاس ہے سونا ان کے پاس ہے تانبا ان کے پاس ہے گوادر ان کے پاس ہے سمندر ان کے پاس ہے پھر بھی یہ غریب ہیں کچھ فیڈرل گورنمنٹ ان کا حق مارتی ہے اور جتنا بیس پچیس پرسنٹ ان کے صوبے کو ملتا ہے تو وہاں کے سردار کھا جاتے ہیں اپنے بچوں کو آکسفورڈ کی یونیورسٹیوں میں پڑھاتے ہیں اور عام بلوچ پٹھان کو یہ کہتے ہیں کہ پنجابی تمہارا حق کھا گیا ہے مارو پنجابیوں کو۔۔۔کیا آپ نے بلوچستان کی دیواروں پر یہ نہیں لکھا کہ پنجابیوں کا قبرستان بلوچستان بلوچستان۔۔ کیا ہم نے یہ لکھا ہے پنجاب کی دیواروں پر کے بلوچوں کا قبرستان پنجاب؟ یا پاکستان ؟ان جاہلوں کو یہ نہیں پتا کہ پنجابی پنجاب میں بھی مار کھاتا ہے اوربلوچستان میں بھی مار کھاتا ہے پنجاب میں یہاں کے وڈیرے اور زمیندار اس کا حق کھا جاتے ہیں بلوچستان میں بلوچوں کے وڈیرے اور سردار کھا جاتے ہیں اور الٹا پنجابی کو دونوں صوبوں میں مار پڑتی ہے۔۔۔۔ان کو یہ بتائیں کہ بلوچستان میں دو لاکھ پنجابی رہتا تھا جو کے اب صرف پچاس ہزار رہ گیا ہے اور ان کو یہ بھی بتائیں کہ کبھی پنجاب نے بھی کسی بلوچ کو پنجاب سے نکالا؟بلوچستان میں کوئی بھی بلوچی یا پٹھان کسی پنجابی استاد سے مقابلہ کرکے دیکھ لے یہ پٹھان بلوچ آج بھی پاؤڈر کو پوڈر لکھتے ہیں۔۔۔ان سے یہ پوچھیں کہ اگر ان کو میٹرک یا بی اے بھی کسی نے کرا دیا ہے تو وہ کس استاد نے کروایا؟۔۔ان سے یہ پوچھیں کہ انہوں نے کتنے پولیس والے پنجابی کتنے پنجابی ٹیچر ؟کتنے پنجابی بنکر کتنے پنجابی دوکاندار اور کتنے پنجابی غریبوں کو وہاں پر مارا ہے۔۔۔۔؟لشکری رئیسانی تو سیاست میں ہے ودود رئیسانی کا دھندہ آپ کو بتاؤں یا آپ کو پہلے ہی پتا ہے۔۔۔امان اللہ نوتیزئی کا دھندا بتاوں ؟محمود اچکزئی کی سمگلنگ کے بارے میں بتاؤ ں۔؟چمن کے سود خوروں اچکزئیوں کے بارے میں بتاؤں ؟بھائی بلوچستان کی معصومیت آپ باقی پاکستان کو بتا سکتے ہو لیکن وہاں کے رہنے والے اور تنگ ہو کے جانے والے پنجابی کو نہیں بتا سکتے۔۔جب ہم وہاں سے نکلے تھے تو میرے باپ نے کہا تھا مجھے کوئٹہ کی نالیوں میں خون بہتا ہوا نظر آرہا ہے۔۔ وہی بات ہوئی پھر وہی سول اسپتال کے آگے یعنی کے وکیل مارے گئے اور نالیوں میں خون پڑا ہوا تھا اور ہزاروں کا خون بھی گرا ہے۔۔۔
I honestly don't have much hope left for this country. I don't know how we made it this far but I'm sure we can't go too far if what's been happening lately continues to happen.
Exactly
Afganistan dekh beta tune abhi tension dekhi ni zindagi me
@@Ali-ld6tg osi side pe jara hai
@@Huzaifakiani47 kider jara ha bhai sab good ha
@@Ali-ld6tg آگ لگے بستی میں
Great initiative Ashir Bhai....Looking forward for more videos..
Please dont stop....everybody needs to know the other side of story.
Huge respect sir! I love your narrations and thought about things. Totally unbiased..
It was a treat to watch and listen the 30 mins long video.. but you said and tried the people to understand is in deep contrast with what Majeed Achakzai did in Quetta in broad daylight to run over a poor policeman ...
Good initiative sir!! This series will be a service to the People of Pakistan.
Question: i still don't understand the reasons behind the force disappearances and abduction of baloch students. What is the point of view of agencies on this.
I sincerely hope your Million dollar question is answered with veracity and diligence while providing a complete background for vast comprehensive understanding & perceptions of both sides, the abductor and abductee.
IMHO Mr Asher needs to do a complete program on this question.
I would also like to get an answer for that. Looking forward to Ashir Sahib's opinion .
بہت سادے ہو بھائی جان آپ کہتے ہو کے بلوچ طالب علموں کو کیوں اغوا کر لیا جاتا ہے میں بھی اس کو بہت برا سمجھتا ہوں لیکن جواب ہمارے سامنے ہے اس عورت نے چائنیز کو کیوں قتل کیا ان کی چائنا سے کیا دشمنی ہے؟ اور کس کو فائدہ ہوا کون چاہتا ہے کہ سی پیک بند ہو کو چاہتا ہے پاکستان کے ساتھ جو چین جیسی طاقت کے تھوڑے بہت اچھے تعلقات ہیں وہ ختم ہو جائیں ایسے موومنٹ کو چلانے والے اور سپورٹ کرنے والے کو اٹھائیں گے نہیں تو اور کیا کریں گے،
@@mir3877 after suicide attack by an educated woman it's necessary to check everyone
Anti state log har mulk mein disappear hote hain
YES agreed and full support sir please start your initiative
Go for it champ... you havin a good strategy i guess❤
Lookin forward for the other episodes!!!
I would like to ask the following questions:
(1) Are sardars really rich and are they somehow blocking the trickle down effect?
(2) Do common Balochis really hate common Punjabis and if yes then why? Why millions of people be blamed for the actions of few elites and bureaucracy who are building their personal empires by illegally using the national resources from all over Pakistan?
(3) What are the short term and long term initiatives, general public especially the students from all over Pakistan can take to help their Baloch brothers?.
بھائی بلوچستان سے سارے سردار اور نواب کا سرمایا اکھٹا کریں تو کراچی یا لاھور یا پشاور کے ایک سرمایا دار کی دولت سے کم ھوگی
عام پنجابی سے عام بلوچستانی کوئی نفرت نہیں کرتا ، یہاں صدیوں سے پنجابی آباد ھیں اور پیار و محبت سے رهتے ھیں ایک دوسرے سے رشتہ داریاں ھیں اب تو
بہت سے مسائل کا ذکر کیا ھے عاشر نے اس ویڈیو میں اور بہت سے اور بنیادی مسائل بھی حل طلب ھیں آج تک جنکا تعلق مرکز سے ھے
5% حصہ بجٹ میں اور پچاس % رقبہ ھے تو بنیادی سہولیات کیسے ملینگے لوگوں کو ؟
Ap k question hi Questionable hyn.
@@laljan5900 apki doosri baat theek hai lekin Karachi mein baloch sardaron ke paas bohot bare bangle aur gariyan hain , Pakistan mein 2 Rolls Royce hain jo duniya ki mehngi tareen gari hai aur un mein se 1 ek baloch sardar ke paas hi hai ab khud CZcams pr search krienge interview miljaiga
آپ کے دوسرے سوال کا جواب تو عاشر نے خود ہی دے دیا ہے بات شروع اس عورت کی ہوئی تھی اور آدھی وڈیو میں بس ہم بلوچ یہ تم پنجابی یہ ہم بلوچ یہ تم پنجابی یہ ہم بہت اچھے تم بہت برے ہم غیرت مند اور پنجابی بےغیرت بس یہ ہی ان کی سوچ ہے ہزاروں سال پرانے کلچر میں پھنسے ہوئے ترقی کے دشمن تبدیلی کا خوف نے ان کو اتنا جاہل بنایا ہے ان کی مثال سنو کہ چوکی سے گاڑی گزرے اور عورت بیٹھی ہو تو چوکی والا نہیں روکتا یہ ہمارا غیرت مند کلچر ہے 🙄 یہ کھسرا تھا جس نے دھماکہ کیا 🤨 عورتوں سے ایسے کام کراتے اور پھر مثالیں سنو ان کی،
کیا دوغلہ پن ہے تعریفیں قبائلی نظام کی اور اپنی زندگی کینیڈا جیسے سیکولر، ترقی یافتہ اور قبائلی نظام سے نفرت کرنے والے ملک میں واہ واہ واہ، ان سے پنجاب کی ترقی ہضم نہیں ہوتی خود تو کچھ کرنا ہی نہیں سوچ ہزاروں سال پرانی ہر قوم میں اچھے برے لوگ رہتے ہیں دوسروں کی صرف برائیاں دیکھنا اور اپنی صرف اچھائیاں دیکھنا کیا منافقت ہے ماشاءاللہ وہ مثال تو انھوں نے دی کہ ہمارے ہاں عورت کو برہنہ کر کے نہیں چلایا جاتا لیکن یہ کیوں بھول گئے کہ کچھ دن پہلے کی ہی بات ہے کوئٹہ میں کسی لڑکیوں کو بلیک میل کرے کئی سال تک اُن کے ساتھ ریپ کیا جاتا رہا اور بے شمار لڑکیاں تھی کچھ سامنے بھی آئی اور باقی نہیں اُن کی ننگا کر کے وڈیو بناتے رہے بلیک میل کرنے کے لئے وہ کون تھے پنجابی؟؟؟ شکر ہے پنجابی نہیں تھے ورنہ دن رات انھوں نے تماشا کرنا تھا قومیت کے نام پر، اپنی قوم کے تھے اس وجہ سے اس واقعے کو دبا دیا نام بھی نہیں لیتے اور سچ اور جھوٹ کا پتہ چلانے کے لئے ملزم کو جلتے انگاروں پر چلانا وغیرہ اپنے گند کو چھپاتے ہو اور دوسرے پر شور مچاتے،
بارہ کروڑ کی آبادی کے صوبے کے جرائم کو دو کروڑ کے صوبے کے جرائم سےملانا، ہر قبائلی یہ ہی سمجھتا ہے کہ اُن کا قبائلی نظام اور لوگ بہت اچھے ہیں باقی برے بس پنجاب کے ہاسپٹل ان سے بھرے ہوتے ہیں بھاگ بھاگ کر پنجاب آتے ہیں اپنے گھر گاوں اپنا کلچر چھوڑ کر پنجاب کی طرف بھاگ بھاگ کر جاتے ہو،
کینیڈا کا سسٹم اور لوگ اچھے تھے اس وجہ سے تم کینیڈا آئے یہ قبائلی اتنے اچھے ہوتے تو پورے پاکستان سے لوگ ان کے علاقوں میں بستے جیسے یہ پنجاب میں آہ کر بس جاتے ہیں بس جس کی جتنی دوڑ جس کی کینیڈا تک کسی کی پنجاب تک،
جس طرح کی زندگی یہ کینیڈا میں گزار رہے ہو اس طرح اگر بلوچستان میں گزارتے تو لوگ ان پر کیسے کیسے گندے الزام لگاتے کے یہ تو بہت بے شرم اور بےغیرت ہیں.
پنجاب کو پاکستان سے نکال کر دیکھو تو افریقہ کا کوئی جاہل، بھوکا اور قبائلی مُلک رہ جاتا ہے.
@@laljan5900 کیوں کہ بلوچستان کے سرداروں کے سرمائے اس وجہ سے کم ہیں کیوں کے ان کے پاس اتنی زری زمین نہیں نا انھوں نے صعنت پر توجہ دی بس لوگوں کو نالائق ہیں
My father served in the military for 24 years. Out of that time he spent 20 years in Quetta alone and remaining 4 in other different parts of the country. He absolutely loved that city but he always told us that the Sardars and Nawabs were enemies of their own people. It's them who don't let any development happen in Balochistan, don't let their people get education and are hell bent on keeping their people in dark ages. And I honestly believed all that until I dug deeper into the issues leading to their separatist movement and how badly the state handled all that.
There's just too many lies we're told as kids about this holy land that isn't so holy in what it's been doing to its own people.
اگر سردار اتنے برے ھیں تو سرکار کیوں مثنوی /خود ساختہ سردار بنا لیتا ھے
مکران ڈویژن میں کوئی سردار نہیں ھے وه کیوں ترقی نہیں کر سکا ؟ یہ جس خاتون کا ذکر هو رہا ھے وه مکران کی تھی جہاں کوئی سردار نواب نہیں ھے اور مزاہمت سب سے زیادہ اس علاقے میں هو رہی ھے ڈاکٹر اللّه نظر اور دوسرے لوگوں کی سرکردگی میں ، کیوں ؟
7 million bloch live in sindh with out dera ghazi khan
Please enlighten - what were the reasons with examples that your father gave. You can't dismiss his account. Tell us. Thanks.
teke hai pir Makran mien tu koi sardar nai hai bhai, waha Q kuch nai hua hai...
Bhaii please advise me .can we all start separation movement as well.i am from south Punjab all Pakistan including Afghanistan eat our wheat and crops but we don't have even proper hospital or school or any future for our children. Same for sindh, same poverty for most Pakistani.So we should start separation movement??? By the way do other countries of the world don't have problems??? Do they broke their country in to pieces???
Very balanced and informed opinion. You are very unbiased. Love your works.
Nice concept brother
God bless you for such great work
Question: We saw videos of Nawab Akbar Bughti's house on Aik din Geo kay sath, where his lawn was lush green (I am sure that other sardar's houses are same as was of him) yet ordinary people of Balochistan do not have water to drink. Therefore we in Punjab has this perception.
Thanks. Great initiative. It helped to understand situation with unbiased approach.
But something not matching with what you've narrated. Majeed Achakzai case is completely contrasting to what you've narrated.
Secondly, please correct if wrong. In Punjab, issue can be escalated against oppressor whether he is feudal, landlord or industrialist through media or common people can raise voice against it but this is unthinkable in Balochistan. This is what as per my experience while living in Balochistan as an outsider.
AOA sir
Good to know that you are too a gramarian like me but with time diference of may be a decade.
I am currently in faisalabad and I agree with the stance you put out on cultural difference.
Me being a punjabi, brought up in Quetta and now living in Faisalabad have some concerns about balochistan.
I know that we can not blame the sardars for the disparity in the living standards of people living in Punjab and Balochistan. But we also can not free them from this blame
These sardars are rulling the balochistan from decades. they are educated but lacks the basic pillars of governance.
Some body has to take the blame. if they has not deteriorated the balochistan, they atleast could have stopped it.
Great Initiative taken by you sir.Thanks for starting these truth stories.We are in search of truth.Please share complete issues of Balochistan and the solutions for solving all issues.Thanks
Sir, I appreciate the way you look at things and bring them into the light. Always record your videos alone rather than bringing others to your show as you did in the last few videos.
True, Balochistan is the only province where I got astounded just visiting Quetta. Poverty was evident even in the capital. No educational facilities are there. People are below the poverty line.
The government of Pakistan should give a special package to the people of Balochistan.
Hope to see a new video with fantastic ideas about Balochistan.
You are a genuine loyalist. Huge respect for you.
Question.....
1 سٹیٹ جبری گمشدگیوں میں ملوث ہے؟ وہ یہ کام کیوں کرتی بجائے ان کا ساتھ دینے کے؟ اور کیا سٹیٹ کے بجائے بلوچی تنظیمیں ملوث تو نہیں؟
2 آج تک آنے والی حکومتوں کی عدم توجہ کی وجہ سے بلوچستان کا یہ حال ہے۔ ایک علاقے کی ترقی کا باعث وہاں کے MNA's اور MPA's ہوتے ہیں جو اپنے علاقے کے لوگوں کے مسائل حل کرنے کی کوشش کرتے ہیں۔ تو کیا وہاں کوئی ایسا فرد موجود نہیں؟ یا ہے اور اس کی حکومت سنتی نہیں؟
3 میڈیا کیوں کورج نہیں کرتا؟
Waiting for your next video about this topic bcz aur koi etni khaas baat ni krta
Aap ne maalik film to bana Dali
Par aaj logon ko ye batane se katrate hen ke
Balochistan ka asal masla wahan ka system hai
Jahan wadhera sab Kuch harap karta ja Raha hai aur public ahsas e mehroomi se labraiz hai
Kitne Ghost schools Hain Balochistan Mai
Kitne roads hain
Basic health units hain
Jo wadhere ke pait ne samaye huye hen …?
Your analysis is true for some places, but not for the entire Balochistan, and please refrain from criticizing the author for his past achievements who had the guts to show the real face of the society to the society despite getting the movie banned from the box office and then releasing it on CZcams and other platforms.!
Came across your video by chance. An excellent narration I must say. This is a part of Pakistan we don't hear much about except for the abductions and the attacks. Looking forward to learning more. Thanks and best wishes.
Sir thanks for help. This problem must be deeply understand now
When u were discussing Bal8chistan's economy you forgot Hub Industrial Estate which probably contributes 80% of the provinces GDP. Also would love to hear your views on how much money Bugtis got for Sui and how much of that was actually spent on the tribe. Also why despite Baloch CMs no development happened in Balichistan - despite constitutional amendment that empowered the provinces. Yes. Baloch have been wronged but local sardars are equally guilty in exploiting that nation. Let's see if u can change my mind through this series.
ٹوٹلی غلط بات
Total fraud
@@laljan5900 Not enough, you must give logical reasons.
True true
As being a punjabi citizen of balochistan i would say that if only the Sardars has to change the fate of the province than why are we even calling Balochistan a part of the country? I hv great respect for the state and i m a patriot of the Country, but i too have frustration within me for the injustices hv done to my province despite being a punjabi in Balochistan...... Why there is no motorway in Balochistan thousands of ppl travel daily from quetta to karachi route, dozens of accidents happen daily, cuz its a single road and dosen't suit this amount of traffic its just an single example, the list is long enough.....
So someone will ask this qts that when ur taking Gas, gold, minerals from balochistan still ppl arent hving gas, hv to travel karachi for medical treatment.....
What are you giving it back?????
Pakistan Zindabad
Sir 1 sawal. Un nawab sb se zaroor pochiye ga k wo kaise nawab ban gye agar itni ghurbat hai wahan py
punjbais se puch lena ju gas le rhaa balocho ke
@@gauravlingwal4601 tum India ki Baat Karo BC
@@gauravlingwal4601 is tarha tw baloch bhi bohot kuch le raha ha punjabi ka ! punjabi aur baloch bhai hain ! Agar wo ye samjhen tw ! and plz stop spreading hate !
@@duvah shut up hum bhai nh ha tum punjabi dushman ho hamary
Thankyou so much sir....you are great...we really need to understand that
Tamaam balocho’n ki taraf say apka bohat shukriya positive bat karnay k liye. Hum blkl bhi state ko nuqsan nahi ponchana chahtay leikin hamain majboor kia gaya aisay iqdaam uthanay pay!
On the point of providing a minimum baseline of humanity/dignity, haven't there been cases of people of sub-tribes being driven out of their land ?
Another question in all ignorance and humbleness, do private prisons exist, run by the Nawabs/Sardars/Tumandars?
Would be really grateful if these questions are brought up in subsequent discussions.
So true....don't forget bugti tribe and what good grief they provided to it's tribal people....these bugtis are insane and inhumane to say the least....Ashar saab zara ziyada biast ho gaye
Kuch nhin hy aisa bhai punjab men beth kar baten sun kar aiven hii na ykeen kro...bugtis are inhuman 😝😝😝akbar bugti k time kbhi balochistan sy koi banda nahin uthaya gya usk baad halat sab k samny hen... musharaf jaa kr pory dera bugti py operation krta hy aik borhy shaks ko marny k liay jo k country ka aik respected politician tha...by the way akbar bugti was a graduate from oxford...so aisy suni sunai baton py ksi ko jalad na declare kro .....humary balochon mn insan ki specialy aurat ki jitni izat aur value hy wo shayed kahin aur nahin....muj sy lahore men ksi ny poocha ap balochon ki bivi agr baat na many tu ap osko kia goli maar dety and I was like wtf😝😝itny brain washed punjab k log....koi banda research b krta evin suni sunai baaton py hi chlty rho
never heard private prisons by sardars but yes heard private prisons are currently in run by our beloved army .
Prisons and torture cells are run by death squad sardars under the supervision of Pakistan Army. 90 percent sardars in Balochistan are backed by the government.
@@naveed7437 Army doesn't need goons to run torture cells , such a childish thought can only come from an illiterate person
Dear Ashir Azeem,
I also want to add my sorrowful question to your list. I hope it fulfills your To Be Asked questions criteria. Firstly I really appreciate your content, I too am an international student studying on scholarship in Germany, I feel a huge difference and only if I pin my agrument to freedom, In Pakistan we are even deprived of that so Thanks alot for spreading awareness.
My question is sir, I myself am from a very humble background from deep mountain ranges of Pakistan: Karakarum (41 km to Gilgit City, Takes 3 hours to reach with 4×4 SUV), In our village we don't have any carpeted roads, No hospitals, No highersecondary school, No electricity, No gas, Just like balochistan people of GB are also murdered brutally on their single known all season route to their home land. We also gained our independence on our own without Pakistan's help and above all we as a whole province for the last 80 years neither have our own representation in NA nor in Senate (We sometimes ask ourselves either we are even considered citizens or not). But with due respect we struggle with peaceful protesrs. We don't blow our selves up and kill people, why is that Balochs are becoming a hurdle instead of rectifying our beautiful Pakistan?
Because there no legal way in Pakistan to take their basic human rights in Balochistan and there brother even some time the lady and young girls was kidnapped by intelligence so if some one again and again kidnap and torture and through your beloved ones bodies which was Drilled on head and much so what will you do exactly.
You have a chance to be listened in the largest house of Pakistan called parliment, and if you can't convince your representatives to fight your cause in house then I guess you need to understand where the problem really lies. Seperatist movements is going to strike Balochistan much deeper e.g. no tourism no industry, increased poverty etc. I think fighting for the cause is much better and having a blessing of electing your representative is much greater blessing. we people from Gilgit are even deprived of that why is that we are not blowing ourselves up rather providing safe heavens for tourism and fighting our case in silence through peaceful protests. Why can't balochistan learn from Gilgit?
Because GB has 99% literacy rate. The most educated region of Pakistan. That's why
You are right bro.we appreciate GB people for their peaceful behavior
Well I don't think roads and infrastructure is not causing hate for Pakistan to Balochistanis because majority of Baloch people live in Karachi and other parts of Pakistan Real problem is we are allowing terrorist organizations like BSO to function in colleges, universities which are brain washing Baloch people and putting hate for Islam and Pakistan so they can go beyond edges against us.
Zabardast as always!
Wonderful. Anxiously waiting for next episode.
Dear Ashir, a question for the tribal leaders, I hope you'll add this question since it is a hard one.
I once saw sohail warraich's interview with nawaz akbar bugti, and there were two cruel practices observed by him:
1- Why did he use to walk people over coals? How is that justified considering the fact that he was highly educated?
2- Sohail asked him about his lawn which was perfectly green, and to quote him "apkay ghar ka lawn aur garden tou sarsabz o shadab hain, jabke bahar logon ko pani pina nasib nahi". Does this not show the cruelty of the leaders of Balochistan?
Exactly i remember that part from interview garden one. Its also on youtube.
Their sardars never want to develop balochistan nor they want their ppl to b educated
After watching this I really wants to hear the real problems of Balochistan!
I guess all life I was hearing the lie.....!
Please Reval the truth!
Waiting for the next season
simple In-Human attitude of our educated class,
fr example Karachi walay opposes quota system, that was placed to help rural areas, same quota system also exist in India, for Scheduled Caste / Backward Area, and contrast to Pakistan, there educated class supported this
czcams.com/video/uzyV_hPASxg/video.html
Watch this you would better understand the issue
Very brilliant effort. And very heartbreaking the way we have dealt with people of our own motherland
Thanks Asher ,Najeeb from Toronto
I have traveled to Balochistan coastal areas and love it... Although econimic condition of those cities are worse than versy small cities in Punjab...
Why didn't Balochistan get more diverse and populated? is it the climate conditions? lack of econimic activity? security? I'm wondering will Balochis appreciate if govt makes it a tax free zone (just have some provincial tax)? Wouldn't population grow there this way, if businesses flourish, more taxes would be collected and spent on people there?
ah commented a minute ealier, I later on hear you talk about taxes 🙂
The problem is the lack of industrialization. This can never be achieved without stability and peace. They even drove out teachers who were from other provinces so there is a lack of diversity as well.
They have high mortality rate as well
Bcs of lack of resources
Dear sir thanks for highlighting the Balochistan issues . Although you are Christian by religion we consider you the son of soil and Baloch . The balochism doesn't base on specific religious ideology and you know many christians sikhs and Hindus recognize themselves Baloch and Baloch welcome them . You are requested to present the solution of the problems so that the peace and prosperity may ensure in the area .
Allah hum sb Pakistani bhio ko hmesha sath rakha
great idea to clear the confusion .
What a information I have got. Great Analysis... Hope we do something for beloved balochistan
Question 1 - “Why there is a difference of life style between the life style of a Sardar and his poor tribesmen who work under him? “
Question 2 - “Sardars forms the Baluchistan government, why there is corruption in Baluchistan government?”
Question 3 - “Can any Sardar give us any example where they have improved the lifestyle of there people by educating the children of their poor tribesmen families as they educate their own children”.
Question 4 - “If you visit Baluchistan you would find people living in Stone Age, whereas the children of their Sardars study in the best universities and colleges in Punjab. How come if sardars really care about their tribe men such a thing is possible? “
Children of sardars live in europe
Balochistan is ruled and runined by these Sardars. They do t let any good happen to them to keep their rule. This sardar and wadera system needs to be demolished.
Wonderful initiative sir. But not recommended to start off with a feeling of disgust for Punjab, which seemingly you seem to develop seeing one odd regrettable incident. I love my country and that love includes people lovely people of Baluchistan. Being your big fan allow me to say that there is an element of naivety in your opinions regarding factor of outside interference to create this wedge more deep between Baluch and other part of country. There are all sorts of Sardars in Baluchistan and chowderies in Punjab. Good and bad both. Although tribal culture is much stronger there as compared to Punjab but that is not necessarily beneficial for populous just like any where else. Monopoly of resources is not good anywhere. Extreme Brutal incidents by headstrong elites can be seen both at Baluchistan or any other part of Pakistan. I would suggest to talk of beauty of Baluchistan and problems of Baluchistan but not at the cost of degradation of any other part of Pakistan. BTW Sir, because of this deep divide between Baluch and Punjabis being created by outside influences, in last 5 to 8 years most punjabis are being forced to leave Baluchistan which spent their whole lives there just like your family just because they were punjabis . Baluchistan is no more a homogeneous place as you left it. I also spent several years of my life at Quetta 8n particular and Baluchistan in general . In my opinion learned people like you should make an effort to reduce the deep wedge between Mighty Baluch people and other part of country specially Punjab. There are few very wonderful values possessed by Baluch but so are by other provinces. I personally love to be at Quetta and other part of Baluchistan and always love to go back there but the element of outside interference with the help of FEW elites cannot be completely disregarded. Really sorry for long remarks and they are not intended to hurt someone feelings . Only an effort to show a wholesome picture instead of a partial one,. Pakistan zindabad
Sorry sir, with due respect id disagree with u. I am a punjabi myself born, raised and settled in punjab. Wht sir Asher has said as his observation about happening in punjab is so very true in current era. In my fathers days of youth i e 70s to 90s punjab yet had a social fiber based on, families, gujar, awan, arain etc but in time with population, unchecked wealth and ethical degradation. The punjab of today is totally as stated. Its a lawless land where elite and rich (might) have the right and privileges and neither the state nor social fiber of the society can shield a poor a woman or a child. So in my humble opinion, lets for once hear an open and candid opinion without being judgemental. We didnot do that in the 60s and lost the East Pak. We need to be wiser and more open minded as masses in present era, not to see it get repeated again
Dear Najam sb, I think Mr Asher does not have anything against the Punjabis. It's just that he has been stating brute facts.
Everyone knows the army and beaurecracy is dominated by people from Punjab, which is understandable because of the population of Punjab and the standard of education there is way better than the rest of Pakistan, but what our point of discussion here is that how this ruling class which obviously includes other provinces has been and is dealing with the Baloch conundrum.
Further, I agree with you to some extent on the point that there is deep rooted hatred from Punjab. Because, I live in Karachi, and I've seen this hatred rise is the recent past. This is because common middle class people here believe that Punjab is being developed at the expense of Sindh. This includes poor infrastructure, high street crime rate, and what not. And yeah this is because of multiple reasons, some say its the curse of 18th Ammendment and PPP's rule in Sindh. But, the narrative of Punjab being developed at the expense of Karachi is by far the most popular.
@@pfarhanzafar1 Bangladesh ko Pathan dictator ayub Khan tareen or Pathan dictator yahya Khan ne banaya or urdu speaking ashraf ke waja se bana
@@hasanrizvi7410 Punjab apnay peso se developed howa ha Jo kaam bhi howa ha Kisi 7 percent ke pesay se nahi Zara sialkot ke exports check kro baqi har soba apna kamaye apna khaye or Punjabi pak ke abadi ka 45 percent han Jo har feild main han or Zara Pathan dictator ayub Khan tareen or Pathan dictator yahya Khan or muhajir dictator Musharraf ke karnamao ko yad kro
@@basitawan5959
Now, I understand why Baloch's are compelled to take up arms. Thankyou for engligtening me brother :33
Spot on. Good analysis.
Appreciated ashir
Question: what is the real issue of Baluchistan? Is there any foreign/ Indian interference? Why BLA was formed? What are the limitations of state/ Army while dealing with Balochs? What about the minerals/ gases/ gold in Baluchistan? Why state is not spending enough on Baluchistan?
Illetracy Education is main problem
India is successfully utilizing the poverty and lack of development of Balochistan
RAW CONFESS THAT INDAIN AGENCY DIRECTLY INDIRECTLY INVOLVED IN THIS GAME
We are fooled by all. Baloch are innocent and highly sentimental. Everyone I using us spoiling us, our today and tomorrow 💔
@@GHost_hunter07777 u will lost Baluchistan if u bark about kashmir iam in ur state Balochistan
Is there someone whose reading my comment can start an NGO (so the rest of us can join and support it) specifically for Balochistan.
1)Ambulance system like edhis
2) Shelters
3) Electricity via solar power
4) Employment opportunity and skill practice
5) Education opportunity. Their reciprocal seats or sepearates should be increased in other provinces to provide them more oppurtunities and stability?
----
General awaam
1)Learn your actual history through unbiased lense
2)Encourage cultural exhange and respect for different mother tongues
3) Media representation for Baloch
Yes we want to support ..start a platform and all can join start it from social media....Balochistan is also part of our country and we need to stand for it's peaceful growth.
you will probaly get killed
Thank you for this insightful talk. Stay blessed.
mashhallah sir i m listening to you first time..more power to you..pakhtoon from somwhere of tribal area
Shaari's ultimate sacrifice shows that there must be a cause that she considered above all (family,future,life) and this act was message to people of 🇵🇰 & slap to those who thinks oppression is the only answer for Balochistan
Free Khalistan and Nagaland, Love pakistan 🇵🇰
Stop justifying terrorism
@@yasirpk2002 I'm not but l assume you didn't like the truth that Balochi(s) needs dialogue&support of other countrymen so someone need to stand up for them
Well let me put forward some facts. Although its very difficult to give logics in today's Pakistan as people are so much personality oriented that they even can't hear against them considering them some super humans. So your admirers may absorb this.
1. Referring your Lahore incident, there you saw land cruiser wala only beating poor man but recently we saw land cruiser MPA killed a poor traffic sergeant and no tribe came out to beat him as you were saying and he living freely.
2. We see cruelty by nawab bugti where people are made to walk on burning coal bare footed. No tribe men beat them for such cruel acts. Sardars in Baluchistan move in a cavalcade and no poor man can dare to come in their way. By mere giving one example of some nawab sitting on floor does not mean all is well. Why don't these nawabs give same status to poor.
3. Here in Punjab, people are so hospitable that a baloch can roam around freely and live freely and people are living and no Punjabi is bothered but in Baluchistan, a Punjabi can not move freely and you know this very well. You were talking about Baloch people picked up by authorities, and you must know who are picked up but what about those Punjabis been killed in Balochistan and no one is ever caught so where actually guantanamo bay is.
4. I have been to Quetta and there you will see common Balochi giving tanay to Punjabis and here in Punjab no one will give you tanay of being Baloch. And this is Quetta, so think about inner Balochistan.
And let us have some moral to say that she was a terrorist and she did the worst instead of finding excuses for her terrorism. Then every criminal has some justification. Two years back 3 terrorist ladies were caught I think from Turbat and they were forced to release just playing women card and Baloch card but we know that Prophet Muhammad SAW even did not intend to spare her daughter.
We need to live together and should have courage to say what is right and what is wrong.
blame game isn't gonna change anything...most positive thing about this video is. not the content itself but the mere fact that someone is giving the information about balochistan and representing them,makes this video good.We really cant keep throwing the dust under the rug and need to engage in healthy arguments to solve the problem
1. You can't just pick each of his sayings and label it with wrong or right.
2. Also, everything has a reason if punjabis arent liked by the ppl of Balochistan that is because there are large number of Punjabis instead having all the opportunities within their province. They still move to Balochistan, prepare their documents and working on govt. Jobs boss around and living that life which Balochistans are supposed to have.
3. As you said punjabis dont harm ppl of Balochistan that is because they already have enough on their plates. and They arent is insecure, that someone will be stealing the life opportunities that I am supposed to have.
Ashir Sir you are an inspiration in many ways.
thank you Aashir for helping us understanding Baloachistan
2 Questions:
1: Why Army is taking over the control and making a suppression rule on Baloch?
2: Balochs are being treated as same as Muhajir's are being treated in Karachi by jaahil sindhi people., so how can we get rid of these hell people or group?
I love the way you described Balochistan and bring tears in my eyes. I am from Punjab and totally agree that we should stand for each other, listen to each other and heal each other. May God help you and bless you and may God make us one of those who can raise the voice for voiceless. Respect and love for God loving Balochistan. Live long Balochistan! Live long Pakistan! Ameen!
Just say great analysis for understanding real problems of Balochistan. Appreciated
Very nice Sir Ashir Azeem sb good initiative. I am from Balochistan too, and voice of Balochistan needs to be raised
A wise, clever, and brave step to expose the truth . May Allah be with you in this hard journey.
Sir ap ka darama dhuwan bahut shok say daikha tha kisi zamanay main
behtren janab
Hats off to you sir!!!love from a baloch...you highlighted the basic issue
Beautiful video and keep up the good work
thanks to discribe Balochistan in sach a beautiful and clear way...
Thank you for clearing so many misconceptions
Thank you Sir, you are great proud of you!
That is great sir for openly talking about Balochistan problems and showing the right faith to the people of all countrie
Mann you defined everything deeply and its absolutely true !
Excellent service
May Allah bless u.. do it sir its the most one of us can do