Manson engine comparison with Stirling engine

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 3. 04. 2012
  • Prezentare motorului Manson si compararea lui cu motorul Stirling.
  • Věda a technologie

Komentáře • 90

  • @AwsomeVids83
    @AwsomeVids83 Před 9 lety +10

    That is one HELL of a torch!

  • @MrDfennema
    @MrDfennema Před 11 lety +2

    Very nice! Thank you for sharing. You made very nice machines. I am sorry for not understanding your language. I think you have explained that power output of the manson was smaller. I tried to build a manson too from an old copressor pump but failed.

  • @jlw1911
    @jlw1911 Před 10 lety +2

    Hi! Will they run on less heat? What is the bore/stroke for these engines?
    I love the unpolished look - very tough looking.

  • @EVgenrator
    @EVgenrator Před 11 lety +1

    Замечательная игрушка. Рекомендую усовершенствовать охладитель, и поставить регенератор. Это приведет к увеличению мощности. А еще можно сделать герметичный картер. И поднять рабочее давление до 10МПа. Тогда из двигателя таких размеров можно будет получить 1,5-2 кВт.

  • @n55m6a7
    @n55m6a7 Před 5 lety

    Foarte interesant, Felicitări pentru munca depusa, păcat ca v-am descoperit cam tirziu, m-am abonat ca să fiu la zi.

  • @vilmossimon4156
    @vilmossimon4156 Před 9 lety +3

    Felicitari!

  • @dumitrymd5557
    @dumitrymd5557 Před 8 lety

    Interesant si fascinant, dar de unde luam o sursa de caldura eco?

  • @lapua72
    @lapua72 Před 10 lety +1

    Bravo !

  • @stefanoturco5883
    @stefanoturco5883 Před 7 lety

    Does it 'possible to buy the Manson engine?

  • @wotan237
    @wotan237 Před 5 lety

    So which one is better ????

  • @leylacat7910
    @leylacat7910 Před rokem

    Frumos și interesant. Merci.

  • @albannach81
    @albannach81 Před 9 lety

    cam cu cat ai vinde un motor stirling ?

  • @drevilatwork
    @drevilatwork Před 7 lety

    cate putere produce gama-ul care-l folositi la centrala? si cam ce efficienta are? nu ar fi o idee de afacere un generator stirling ce sa concureze cu generatoarele peltier ce se vand in america 500$ pentru 50watts la tegmart.com. pentru cabane cu sobe nu conteaza efficienta asa mult cat fiabilitatea si zgomotul produs

  • @user-me9tk4ow4z
    @user-me9tk4ow4z Před 5 lety +1

    Can I order these engine to you?

  • @ElChokin
    @ElChokin Před 3 lety

    Muy bueno, saludos desde Punta Umbría-Huelva.👍

  • @user-gl2yr7fw9y
    @user-gl2yr7fw9y Před 5 lety

    День добрый из Украины, скажите пожалуйста а на заказ но больше размером и соответственно мощности не делаете. ?

  • @apostolsilviu9360
    @apostolsilviu9360 Před 8 lety

    Felicitari. Frumoase motoare.. La ce aplicatie folositi motorul mare? Aveti idee cam ce putere are?

    • @Pallarpad
      @Pallarpad  Před 8 lety +1

      +Apostol Silviu
      Motoarele Manson sant motoare cu aer cald cu circuitul gazului de lucru deschis si sant inca in faza experimentala in mai multe laboratoare din lume.Imbunatatiri serioase a adus Rupp si se numesc motoare Manson -Rupp.Eu am proiectata unul si l-am prezentata doar ca o curiozitate . Noutatea din mototrul prezentat de mine este ca lucrul mecanic este facut de cilindrul de lucru si pistonul de lucru este fix ceace mi-a permis ca lungimea motorului sa fie redus la jumatate.

  • @Jeffrey314159
    @Jeffrey314159 Před 8 lety +2

    If the the first motor is a Manson Engine, then it sure does start up very slowly. . . The Piston Cylinder walls must be very thick

  • @phuongtuyen8430
    @phuongtuyen8430 Před 7 lety

    Please guide to build a manson engine

  • @jds890
    @jds890 Před 4 lety +1

    hello vous pourriez m aider a en faire un ?

  • @Pallarpad
    @Pallarpad  Před 11 lety +1

    Yes !!!!!!!!!

  • @DNRaDJK
    @DNRaDJK Před 10 lety +4

    I am a known Tool Junkie in my circles and I love these "engines". Being also that I am a practical type, do they serve any purpose or do you builders hope they will serve some purpose some day or is this more of a hobby??

    • @carmelpule6954
      @carmelpule6954 Před 6 lety +3

      Many people do things and behave in a certain manner just because it gives them enjoyment and want to wrack their minds in solving problems and improve known processes. It is this human function that keeps may people happy.

    • @Shindinru
      @Shindinru Před 5 lety

      There are large Sterling Engines that do actual work, mostly as water/well pumps.

  • @jimmartin7899
    @jimmartin7899 Před 7 lety

    Would a copper glow plug with a closed evaporative acetone system run your Manson engine?

    • @faneardelean601
      @faneardelean601 Před 7 lety

      Jim Martin km

    • @jimmartin7899
      @jimmartin7899 Před 7 lety

      How about a crystal graphite rod heated with a low voltage induction coil? And what does km mean?

    • @jimmartin7899
      @jimmartin7899 Před 7 lety +1

      Design a V - 10 Sterling enging with crystal graphite rods in each piston that are heated using low voltage induction operated off solar panels. Use a transmission designed to work with Sterling engine to operate a high voltage power generator to charge a capacitor and battery banks. 100% off grid renewable power generation. Fane does this sound about right to you hay scat head?

    • @mistert9144
      @mistert9144 Před 7 lety +1

      You are heating the engine with electricity then converting that heat back into electricity. It would be easier to aim mirrors at the engine. And it takes a massive solar grid to provide sufficient voltage to recharge a battery bank. It would be better to store power in air compressors.

  • @Pallarpad
    @Pallarpad  Před 7 lety

    Generatoarele stirling au un randament de 10-25 ori mai mare decat Peltierul.
    Vizionati postarile mele cu ultimele motoare stirling realizate in mod industrial.

  • @dalsenov
    @dalsenov Před 6 lety

    Domnule Pallarpad ,din ce localitate sunteti?

    • @Pallarpad
      @Pallarpad  Před 6 lety

      Almaskamaras - Ungaria cod 5747

  • @dalsenov
    @dalsenov Před 6 lety +1

    Exista vre-o relatie intre capacitatea cilindrica si puterea pe care o poate scoate un Stirling?

    • @Pallarpad
      @Pallarpad  Před 6 lety

      Formule empirice pentru ateliere nu am gasit. Sant ecuatii foarte elaborate dar pentru lab. de cercetari unde se considera volume ideale gaz ideal etc.Fata de alte motoare termice nu numai capacitatea cilindrica concura la puterea unui motor Stirling,depinde de presiunea de lucru de gazul folosit de temperatura partii calde si reci a cilindrului de refulare, de marimea volumului "mort",de fercarile intre piesele componenete in miscare,de materialele folosite,de raportul dintre volumul gazului de lucru si suprafetele de contact si mai ales de regenerator.Formulele sant foarte complexe si nu intotdeauna se adevereste in practica rezultatul obtinut teoretic.Sant o serie de programe de simulare dar nici ele nu dau intotdeauna rezultate .Oricum te ajuta mult un program de simulare,dar,experimentarea pe viu ,experienta si flerul constructorului dau rezultate scontate -cel putin la nivelul meu -.Cand esti un lup singuratec cum sant si eu este foarte greu.Vezi postarile mai recente unde arat la ce rezultate am ajuns.
      Cu respect Pall A.

  • @robertwhite143
    @robertwhite143 Před 4 lety

    That's the way to do it, no poxy t- lights there👍😉👍

  • @karancsi
    @karancsi Před 11 lety

    Szep es jo gratulallok hozza, csak amint latom nagyonsok es nagyon meleg levegore van szuksege a mukodeshez talan ettol jobbak a vakuummotorok.De vegulis nem az a lenyeg menyi ero van benne hanem az epitesuk allat is mit tanul az ember.... es a HEUREKA MUXIK :)

  • @bjl1000
    @bjl1000 Před 9 lety +1

    Not much torque , what is wrong with it? Putting in a lot of BTU but no power.

  • @tici8949
    @tici8949 Před 11 lety

    Acest motor stirling gama se poate adapta la o centrala pe lemne de 80 kw ,adica sa antreneze doua pompe de recirculatie si un ventilator de combustie?

  • @funny1048youtube
    @funny1048youtube Před 11 lety

    does this engine need a cold side like the stirling engine

    • @carmelpule6954
      @carmelpule6954 Před 6 lety

      Every engine in the universe, including the creation of wind , needs a difference in temperature at different localities.

  • @izidorioseverinocosta8475

    Opa em quanto é o preço de motor aí

  • @quadraturadelcerchio
    @quadraturadelcerchio Před 11 lety

    complimenti vivissimi.Purtroppo non capisco la lingua;non potrebbe scrivere la traduzione in inglese nel video?many compliments! i'm very sorry, but i don't undestand your language,please write in english ..

  • @sierraecho884
    @sierraecho884 Před 6 měsíci

    Manson engine: Does not reuse the same working fluid instead sucks in new air and expells it.
    Stirling engine: Uses the same working fluid in a closed system (better efficiency and the possibility to use helium instead of air).
    Conclusion: Manson engine is inferior efficiency wise, that´s why no one uses it except in demonstration pieces.

  • @estrelinhamariliamendoncah4895

    onde vende desse preciso

  • @marci3776
    @marci3776 Před 7 lety

    úgy látom, gondok vannak a hatásfokkal. ehhez egy hőerőmű kell, hogy leadjon 5 watt teljesítményt.

  • @liveuk
    @liveuk Před rokem

    That's a gamma Stirling engine

  • @stelicadamian5274
    @stelicadamian5274 Před 5 lety

    Sint din jud.Giurgiu. vă salut .mă straduesc să construiesc și eu o sobă raket din filmulețul dumneav noastră. Dintr-un tub oxigen medicinal.diametru corespunde d 130 mm cu 800mm .vă mulțumesc mă bucur că v-am găsit pe internet și mi a-ți dat interes de-a să face și eu o sobă raket din filmulețele arătate. Multă sănătate: Stelică

  • @stefanoturco5883
    @stefanoturco5883 Před 7 lety

    yes

  • @stefanoturco5883
    @stefanoturco5883 Před 7 lety

    Și "este posibil să cumpere motorul Manson?

  • @user-op2pc3qu6w
    @user-op2pc3qu6w Před 4 lety

    Да уж , и это показывать? Хорошо, что для разогрева ядерное топливо не пришлось использовать.😂😂😂

  • @PALM311
    @PALM311 Před 4 lety +1

    If you need that kind of heat to get that thing going you've done something wrong

  • @aggabus
    @aggabus Před 7 lety +1

    induction heat coil ...?..
    efficient..aye

  • @cristianpopescu78
    @cristianpopescu78 Před 9 lety +1

    Scapa compresie la greu.Dar e interesant.O munca frumoasa

    • @Pallarpad
      @Pallarpad  Před 9 lety

      Nu scapa compresie!!!!!!! Motoarele Manson elibereaza aerul la fiecare rotire a arborelui cotit. Vezi principiul de functionare a motoarelor Manson.

    • @cristianpopescu78
      @cristianpopescu78 Před 9 lety +1

      Pallarpad Asa! interesant.Eu am gandit un motor cu aer care prin constructia lui sa permita un raport foarte mare Volum\suprafata schimb de caldura,durata mare pe schimb la aceeasi turatie,putere mare la joasa turatie,in ideea de a folosi caldura solara,de a permite dimensiuni f mari-puteri mari,temperaturi joase.Ma gandesc la stocarea energiei sub forma de caldura -e mai simplu e convertibila in energie mecanica-electrica-termica .

    • @petrepetree3397
      @petrepetree3397 Před 6 lety

      Cu alte cuvinte,,,,jos şapca,,,

  • @mohamedfarid7499
    @mohamedfarid7499 Před rokem

    you speak English or Arabic ?

  • @aleksandrustinov74
    @aleksandrustinov74 Před 8 lety

    Автор , а где вытеснитель?

    • @user-dc3zi8yg1i
      @user-dc3zi8yg1i Před 7 lety

      вытеснитель между поршнем и горячей головкой свободно бегает.

  • @jerrybaker9855
    @jerrybaker9855 Před 7 lety

    ok iget it now it is a hot air engen cool

  • @verygoodvibes
    @verygoodvibes Před 7 lety

    one of the least efficient engines ever but still very cool. one caveat is that you can use heat or cold energy from many different and unusual sources.

    • @andrewthecelt3794
      @andrewthecelt3794 Před 7 lety

      Lousy torque on stirling & manson engines though too

    • @verygoodvibes
      @verygoodvibes Před 7 lety

      still , you did an awesome job with it. i believe there are ways to greatly improve the torque. Keep up the good work!

  • @gmeast
    @gmeast Před 3 lety +1

    ... NOT MUCH of anything from all that heat.There's No comparison to the classic Sterling cycle.

  • @QF2653
    @QF2653 Před rokem

    Enormous energy input for so little output.

  • @jimmartin7899
    @jimmartin7899 Před 7 lety

    Could you use graphite with a hertz frequency generating diode to cause the graphite to turn red hot to power the cylinder and get rid of that blow torch?

  • @durgo88
    @durgo88 Před 7 lety +1

    Il rendimento più basso di sempre!

  • @ademstoner
    @ademstoner Před 10 lety

    Oksijen kaynağı ile okadar çok enerji harcandı ki. Hiç gerek yok yani

  • @lapua72
    @lapua72 Před 10 lety

    Manson-Motor / Manson Engine

  • @dalsenov
    @dalsenov Před 6 lety

    Nimeni nu pare sa construiasca Stirlinguri de marime medie.

  • @drevilatwork
    @drevilatwork Před 7 lety

    foarte incantat sa vaf ca sunt romani care se ocupa de motoare de aer cald

  • @colinsalter3516
    @colinsalter3516 Před 3 lety

    Would cost a fortune run.

  • @gt2x443
    @gt2x443 Před 11 měsíci

    Hier ist DHL der zuverlässigste Paketdienst.

  • @jimmartin7899
    @jimmartin7899 Před 7 lety

    Could you design a Stirling cycle cold engine that operated off liquid air from the knowledge you now have?

  • @justtinkering6713
    @justtinkering6713 Před rokem

    Boy that sure doesn't have much torque, does it.

  • @mihaitavasilas3655
    @mihaitavasilas3655 Před 7 lety

    ma intereseaza un stirling gama vreu sal cumpar va las adresa de imail: vasilas.mihaita@gmail.com

  • @jimmartin7899
    @jimmartin7899 Před 7 lety

    Why not design a Stirling engine that could operate off a simple solar panel set up with an electric motor that produced liquid atmosphere in a closed system that filled a tank with a bell siphon that emptied into an insulated tubing with aluminum cylinders of cold gas Manson engines with gadolinium bearings ( magnetic bearings) on all moving parts on the cold gas Manson engine no need for oil products and to reduce vibration. V-10 and V-20 large cold gas Manson engines powered by liquid atmosphere with the liquid atmosphere boil off vapor returning to tank to be reformed into liquid atmosphere. Then rewire large drum motors into generators with magnetic bearings each having a vacuum spark gap that kept a capacitor and graphite power cell banks charged up. Then have a redundant system to operate it all if there is no sun light for the solar panels. By generating a liquid atmosphere cold gas Manson engine electrical power generator. Using graphite power cells to build up liquid atmosphere to fill the system then have the system run in cycles using the cold gas engine to generate electricity off the liquid atmosphere while recharging the graphite power cells. If constructed correctly it would almost be free energy and you could even generate a self running air conditioning unit that was also electrical power generator has well. Hay you think it would work?

  • @gustafromanov7860
    @gustafromanov7860 Před 6 lety

    A great fail 😏

  • @Khwartz
    @Khwartz Před 7 lety +1

    English ! please ^_^

    • @Pallarpad
      @Pallarpad  Před 7 lety +4

      Sorry, I do not speak the language of Shakespeare

    • @Khwartz
      @Khwartz Před 7 lety

      Pallarpad Okay ;-)

    • @MasterShot-ke1mr
      @MasterShot-ke1mr Před 6 lety

      Pallarpad then why are you posting in the language of Shakespeare? Shakespeare was an English playwright he did his plays in English you fucking moron.

    • @Pallarpad
      @Pallarpad  Před 6 lety +5

      I know the work of playwright Shakespeare and the idiot was your mother when she gave birth to you.

    • @jeric_synergy8581
      @jeric_synergy8581 Před 3 lety

      @@MasterShot-ke1mr , that's right, be a dickhead.

  • @MasterShot-ke1mr
    @MasterShot-ke1mr Před 6 lety +1

    This is very irresponsible and things like this should be banned because somebody might burn their fingers.

    • @Pallarpad
      @Pallarpad  Před 6 lety +5

      Not all people are as idiot as you !!!!