*The international law* is very clear on the South China Sea: - parts of it belong to some ASEAN countries including Indonesia 🇮🇩, - the rest of it is the international water, - no part of it belongs to China🇨🇳 or Taiwan🇹🇼.
When she was minister, I'm one of her supporter. Now watching this, I understand more that she is a genius ! As an Indonesian I'm very proud of her 👏🏻👏🏻🇮🇩
As an Indonesian law and compliance expertise, I can see Pujiastuti is not a politician, but she is know well about the importance of law and regulatory, which should be white and black. And that's the UNCLOS should be, there is no grey area, it should be white and black, right or wrong!
The Hague Tribunal has made its final and legally binding interpretation of the UNCLOS laws, which China 🇨🇳 signed. -The SCS issue is *no longer contestable and is beyond compromise.*
*China calls it fishing, Indonesia calls it crime* ~ Susi Pudjiastuti ~ 🇮🇩 This is the first powerful statement from ASEAN official and it's came from Indonesian women ❤️
I really like Ibu Susi's simple thinking. And I agree that she will become ASEAN Maritime President. If every country works together to mine marine resources, fishermen are free to legal fishing, and vessels are free to pass through the Malacca Strait. So China doesn't need to build military bases in Hainan, Spratly Islands, and Ream (Cambodia). China also doesn't need to build ports in Kyaukpyu (Myanmar) and Gwadar (Pakistan). Furthermore, the US doesn't need to build a military base on Palawan Island (Philippines), and they don't need to form AUKUS and QUAD. Indonesia also doesn't need to upgrade military base on Natuna Island.
I completely agrees with her. Everything. But the thing is, we simply have no option. China is stronger, that's the cold hard fact. We can do anything we want with illegal boats from other countries, but not china. We have no other option but to snuggle up with china. Why? because china is the sole superpower in the region. We can't play the power-balance game against china if nothing is able to balance china out. Not even the whole ASEAN have the capacity to do that. We need the US for checking china's growing hegemony. And if the US still tied and still focused to mucks around with Russians in Ukraine, and still ignored us in eastern part of asia, we will continue to have no option but to giddy up and appease china. Besides of that, other than china being the great power dominating the region, they're the only one who are there to help Indonesia to develop. There's no US company aproaching us to build smelting industries here. No US company cared to build universities and share their technologies with us etc. Japan and SK are unwilling (and are too far) for us to consider them as a substantial check for china. We need the US to invest here and balancing china out. But currently they still don't care about us. So yeah, that's that.
true small problem, enlarged just want to take advantage of politics XD. I agree, we only want peace. If you have your own conflicts, don't involve us and take advantage of yourself hahaha
Meanwhile in the Philippines, all officials are aimlessly wandering how to deal with the Chinese. This minister shames them all with her actions and resolve.
Susi has that courage, she won't be scared by anyone because she knows a lot about the sea. Make her the leader of the Asean sea, she will explode and ask to be sent to China's barracks fr protest.
I'm not sure if Susi really don't know about the dispute, or she want to keep it simple an pretend nothing's wrong, but China effort to make all of south china sea as their territory sea is because they want to secure their logistic route and to ensure China access to Hindia Ocean meanwhile US and their Allies present in south china sea is basically to block their logistic route. China pretend is about their "traditional fishing zone or their natural resource zone" meanwhile USA pretend about "they must protect their ally in south china sea because China already start the aggression". all of that culminating to the China's plan to reunified with taiwan A.K.A start a war with taiwan. USA really believe China will start a war in pacific, meanwhile china believe it's just an internal conflict that they must solve between themselves. to be a super power, China needs to have an access to Ocean either it's hindia ocean or pacific ocean. meanwhile USA don't want their enemy come to close to them. it's like Russia vs NATO scenario where in this scenario the one that get cornered like russia is the USA themselves. so all the effort that susi mentioned above, will be useless, because it's not really about illegal fishing, but the contest to be the ultimate defacto ruler of south china sea and pacific. China use their militia to harrass fishermen in ASEAN territory, meanwhile USA with their allies start building military base throughout pacific islands, it's just power play between two superpower country
oh come on, she not even the Indonesian Maritime Affairs and Fisheries Minister anymore. She just told about the policy she make. I think she does not have capable to answer that stuff about Indonesia military strategy. IMO
China has no territorial dispute with Indonesia. UNCLOS has provisions for traditional fishing rights of states. I believe that China has bilateral agreement with Indonesia to exercise its traditional fishing rights north of Natuna islands.
🤮 talking about UNCLOS here while ignoring UNCLOS in Scarborough shoals, Spratly island. what a disgusting hypocrite. PRC has no right to be claiming the North Natuna Sea.
bu susi ini bagus,,sangat punya visi dan misi,,masalah terlalu idealis sehingga tdk mau bekerjasama engan pihak lain,,paahal i pemerintahan butuh kerjasama,,bu susi ini mirip ahok yg tdk terlalu disukai birokrat karena selalu berjalan sendiri dan bergerak dengan pikiran idealis,,pikiran bu susi ini seperti para aktivis yg mengganggap semuanya harus benar dan sejalan dengan mereka,padahal ada banyak faktor yg mempengaruhi kebijakan seseorang apalgi di negara berkembang seperti indonesia,,kalau mereka hidup di negara maju seperti singapura mungkin bisa diterapkan visi idealis mereka,bu susi juga banyak di tentang oleh nelayan soal kebijakan CANTRANG untuk nelayan,,dia membuat keputusan yg menurut dia baik tapi menurut nelayan tdk,,itu membuat banyak persoalan soal kebijakan ini..seharusnya bisa didiskusikan bukan dibuat kebijakan baru diskusi,,ini lah karena terlalu idealis tapi tdk memahami kultur indonesia yg belum IDEAL.
North of Natuna sea, which is part of China claim as their territory, so Indonesia has no right to catch the illegal fishing if it is not resolve between the two countries. What she had done is beyond her right to blow up other ships.
If you understand your jumping words then be sure that 'that is exactly the truth,' without caring about any further examination then obviously your words don't mean anything and you don't understand anything. 🙂
No one owns the ocean. It's God who own the ocean. Politics is a business. I don't want to argue about China conflicts between the boundaries of Philippines, Indonesia, Vietnam Taiwan and etc. I don't think that there something wrong if there are Chinese Vessels, Ships and Boats are running around in our own Territory. As long as China don't do any crimes against humans. The Question is? Why we feel safe if Americans are going in our Own Ocean territory. We doesn't think that Americans are strangers at all, but if Chinese People just visit our own Territory we think that Chinese are enemies. It seems like we think that Americans are heroes, once they visited our own Oceans, but we doesn't think Chinese are good if they're visiting are Countries in Southeast Asia. We need to unite us one nation, one foundation because we are neighbouring countries. Americans are far from us. We are discriminating our own Race, we are fighting us neighbouring countries. We Southeast Asians and East Asians have the same color type of skins, heights but honestly most of us are fighting a lot with so many issues like genocide, cultural differences, cultural discriminations and the differences between Political Rules or Law.
So u mean china is god? So the same skin color could claim any territorial over another as long as the don't kill each other?? pretending like nothing happen ? u sounds perfectly like chinese troll
*The international law* is very clear on the South China Sea:
- parts of it belong to some ASEAN countries including Indonesia 🇮🇩,
- the rest of it is the international water,
- no part of it belongs to China🇨🇳 or Taiwan🇹🇼.
When she was minister, I'm one of her supporter. Now watching this, I understand more that she is a genius ! As an Indonesian I'm very proud of her 👏🏻👏🏻🇮🇩
She should run as the President of Indonesia...
As an Indonesian law and compliance expertise, I can see Pujiastuti is not a politician, but she is know well about the importance of law and regulatory, which should be white and black.
And that's the UNCLOS should be, there is no grey area, it should be white and black, right or wrong!
Well said..Bu Susi. so articulate
🤔 saying n doing are poles apart…the phrase…easier said than done says it all! 🙄
The Hague Tribunal has made its final and legally binding interpretation of the UNCLOS laws, which China 🇨🇳 signed.
-The SCS issue is *no longer contestable and is beyond compromise.*
I need minister like susi again
*China calls it fishing, Indonesia calls it crime*
~ Susi Pudjiastuti ~ 🇮🇩
This is the first powerful statement from ASEAN official and it's came from Indonesian women ❤️
The rest of the world call it "traditional sh!ting ground"
I really like Ibu Susi's simple thinking. And I agree that she will become ASEAN Maritime President.
If every country works together to mine marine resources, fishermen are free to legal fishing, and vessels are free to pass through the Malacca Strait. So China doesn't need to build military bases in Hainan, Spratly Islands, and Ream (Cambodia). China also doesn't need to build ports in Kyaukpyu (Myanmar) and Gwadar (Pakistan).
Furthermore, the US doesn't need to build a military base on Palawan Island (Philippines), and they don't need to form AUKUS and QUAD.
Indonesia also doesn't need to upgrade military base on Natuna Island.
Skrang spa yg mulai, spa yg rspon, dgn pihk luar yg mulai (bnyk ngara pnciri ikn br mcem2) ap bolh buat kita rspon, sbaik mungkn smpe smua ny trkndli
Susi should be the next president if Indonesia wanna maintain its sovereignty
sayangnya Bu Susi sudah disingkirkan 😢
She’s wonderful Indonesian women ❤
Please add subtitles indonesian
She is not what the media has portrayed her...
I completely agrees with her. Everything.
But the thing is, we simply have no option. China is stronger, that's the cold hard fact. We can do anything we want with illegal boats from other countries, but not china.
We have no other option but to snuggle up with china. Why? because china is the sole superpower in the region. We can't play the power-balance game against china if nothing is able to balance china out. Not even the whole ASEAN have the capacity to do that.
We need the US for checking china's growing hegemony. And if the US still tied and still focused to mucks around with Russians in Ukraine, and still ignored us in eastern part of asia, we will continue to have no option but to giddy up and appease china.
Besides of that, other than china being the great power dominating the region, they're the only one who are there to help Indonesia to develop. There's no US company aproaching us to build smelting industries here. No US company cared to build universities and share their technologies with us etc. Japan and SK are unwilling (and are too far) for us to consider them as a substantial check for china.
We need the US to invest here and balancing china out. But currently they still don't care about us. So yeah, that's that.
Bu Susi is a Superwoman
true small problem, enlarged just want to take advantage of politics XD. I agree, we only want peace. If you have your own conflicts, don't involve us and take advantage of yourself hahaha
Best minister in Indonesia of all time!
She should become the high judge of asian seas. Not a politician.
BASED
Meanwhile in the Philippines, all officials are aimlessly wandering how to deal with the Chinese. This minister shames them all with her actions and resolve.
❤
Susi has that courage, she won't be scared by anyone because she knows a lot about the sea. Make her the leader of the Asean sea, she will explode and ask to be sent to China's barracks fr protest.
I'm not sure if Susi really don't know about the dispute, or she want to keep it simple an pretend nothing's wrong, but China effort to make all of south china sea as their territory sea is because they want to secure their logistic route and to ensure China access to Hindia Ocean meanwhile US and their Allies present in south china sea is basically to block their logistic route. China pretend is about their "traditional fishing zone or their natural resource zone" meanwhile USA pretend about "they must protect their ally in south china sea because China already start the aggression".
all of that culminating to the China's plan to reunified with taiwan A.K.A start a war with taiwan. USA really believe China will start a war in pacific, meanwhile china believe it's just an internal conflict that they must solve between themselves.
to be a super power, China needs to have an access to Ocean either it's hindia ocean or pacific ocean. meanwhile USA don't want their enemy come to close to them. it's like Russia vs NATO scenario where in this scenario the one that get cornered like russia is the USA themselves.
so all the effort that susi mentioned above, will be useless, because it's not really about illegal fishing, but the contest to be the ultimate defacto ruler of south china sea and pacific. China use their militia to harrass fishermen in ASEAN territory, meanwhile USA with their allies start building military base throughout pacific islands, it's just power play between two superpower country
oh come on, she not even the Indonesian Maritime Affairs and Fisheries Minister anymore. She just told about the policy she make. I think she does not have capable to answer that stuff about Indonesia military strategy. IMO
Klo aku liat bu susi ni nyk liat pak karno ps wwancra dgn wrtawn luar (siluet ny asli mirp bgt) bhkn "lbh mirip" dri (maaf) ank2 ny bliau sndri
China has no territorial dispute with Indonesia.
UNCLOS has provisions for traditional fishing rights of states.
I believe that China has bilateral agreement with Indonesia to exercise its traditional fishing rights north of Natuna islands.
🤮
talking about UNCLOS here while ignoring UNCLOS in Scarborough shoals, Spratly island. what a disgusting hypocrite.
PRC has no right to be claiming the North Natuna Sea.
Why we're so weak 😂
bu susi ini bagus,,sangat punya visi dan misi,,masalah terlalu idealis sehingga tdk mau bekerjasama engan pihak lain,,paahal i pemerintahan butuh kerjasama,,bu susi ini mirip ahok yg tdk terlalu disukai birokrat karena selalu berjalan sendiri dan bergerak dengan pikiran idealis,,pikiran bu susi ini seperti para aktivis yg mengganggap semuanya harus benar dan sejalan dengan mereka,padahal ada banyak faktor yg mempengaruhi kebijakan seseorang apalgi di negara berkembang seperti indonesia,,kalau mereka hidup di negara maju seperti singapura mungkin bisa diterapkan visi idealis mereka,bu susi juga banyak di tentang oleh nelayan soal kebijakan CANTRANG untuk nelayan,,dia membuat keputusan yg menurut dia baik tapi menurut nelayan tdk,,itu membuat banyak persoalan soal kebijakan ini..seharusnya bisa didiskusikan bukan dibuat kebijakan baru diskusi,,ini lah karena terlalu idealis tapi tdk memahami kultur indonesia yg belum IDEAL.
China follows the nine-dotted-lines. They deemed that area not just as economical exclusive zone but sovereign territory.
China built the highspeed railway system for Indonesia. It would have to compensate Beijing if it had indeed blown up a Chinese fishing boat.
do you seriously think China is doing charity by building some infrastructure projects in Indonesia?
you are either so naive or so dumb
explain why indonesia build their offshore gas project right at the north of natuna sea right now?
@@closeslide436
Same explanation as why do you plant flower trees at the edge of the land area of your house. Anything wrong with this?
@@Dan8254 yes, because the flower you planted is at the disputed land that your neighbor claimed they owned it
@@closeslide436
Who disputed that? Anybody else or any international body can back up the shameless claim from that stinky neighbour?
North of Natuna sea, which is part of China claim as their territory, so Indonesia has no right to catch the illegal fishing if it is not resolve between the two countries. What she had done is beyond her right to blow up other ships.
Big proved that jokowi is a china-pro president but too shy to admit
Ha?
@@wdotme If u watched the video why this lady ex-minister no longer the minister of fishery in jokowi's 2nd term, u'd understand
If you understand your jumping words then be sure that 'that is exactly the truth,' without caring about any further examination then obviously your words don't mean anything and you don't understand anything. 🙂
No one owns the ocean. It's God who own the ocean. Politics is a business. I don't want to argue about China conflicts between the boundaries of Philippines, Indonesia, Vietnam Taiwan and etc. I don't think that there something wrong if there are Chinese Vessels, Ships and Boats are running around in our own Territory. As long as China don't do any crimes against humans.
The Question is?
Why we feel safe if Americans are going in our Own Ocean territory. We doesn't think that Americans are strangers at all, but if Chinese People just visit our own Territory we think that Chinese are enemies.
It seems like we think that Americans are heroes, once they visited our own Oceans, but we doesn't think Chinese are good if they're visiting are Countries in Southeast Asia. We need to unite us one nation, one foundation because we are neighbouring countries. Americans are far from us.
We are discriminating our own Race, we are fighting us neighbouring countries.
We Southeast Asians and East Asians have the same color type of skins, heights but honestly most of us are fighting a lot with so many issues like genocide, cultural differences, cultural discriminations and the differences between Political Rules or Law.
So u mean china is god? So the same skin color could claim any territorial over another as long as the don't kill each other?? pretending like nothing happen ? u sounds perfectly like chinese troll
Listen Carefully 3:26