Uthman Ibn Farooq | Hanbali Fiqh, Muslim Unity & Criticising Rulers | BB
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 08. 2023
- In this episode of the Blood Brothers Podcast, Dilly Hussain speaks with the prominent American preacher and debater Uthman ibn Farooq. #BloodBrothersBodcast #Dawah #Salafi
Topics of discussion include:
- Q&A on 10 (Hanbali) fiqh rulings Uthman ibn Farooq adopts.
- Would he give talks at a 'non-Salafi' masjid?
- Is there a framework for Sunni unity? Does there have to be uniformity in creed?
- Questioning Daniel Haqiqatjou about Deobandis.
- Online dawah beefs - is it healthy and necessary?
- Stabbing incident in March 2020. Fact and fiction. Was it a setup?
FOLLOW 5PILLARS ON:
Website: 5pillarsuk.com
Facebook: / 5pillarsuk
Instagram: / 5pillarsnews
Twitter: / 5pillarsuk
Telegram: t.me/s/news5Pillars
TikTok: / 5pillarsnews - Zábava
2:24 - Do you follow a madhab?
10:13 - What is the ruling on those that miss Salah ?
15:16 - Is the Niqab fardh?
21:28 - is Smoking haram?
23:35 - Is all seafood permissible?
25:43 - Is eating from McDonald's halal in the west?
32:16 - Fiqh of Divorce (3x talaq)
35:46 - Can we give salam to non-Muslims ?
36:35 - Do Salafis have respect for Madhabs?
40:33 - Would you give dawah or a talk in a Non-Salafi masjid?
45:59 - Can there be brotherhood with those that practice Istighstha or Mawlid etc ?
49:36 - Can there ever be unity with those who have a different Aqidah?
57:37 - His confrontation with Daniel Haqiqatjou last year.
1:04:53 - Can we unite behind a khalif with a different Aqidah ?
1:10:41 - issue of obeying the ruler
1:16:18 - Can you criticise the ruler ?
1:27:25 - Did you really get stabbed ?
Please pin this
@@imaadindoronly blood brothers admin can do that, im just a viewer
JazakAllah khair 🙌🙌
Jazak Allah Khairan
Remember the path or manhajj the prophet of Islam left for the ummah are the TWO WEIGHTY MATTERS the Qur'an and Ahlulbayt
Known is hadith Thaqalayn
Thank you
It is the mainly Salafi movement that have caused significant division's in the UK. No hanafi has ever gone to a Shafi and telling them they are deviant and need to follow 'quran & sunnah'. They have casues mass confusion and fitna amkngst the youth from the 1990's in the Uk.
I don’t think that’s true at all. No salafi goes around calling followers of the madahib deviants.. the only people they call deviants when applies to aqeedah which is a whole different topic.
@@aklimurraza2626 Sorry brother but you must be living under a rock if you think that is the case. I reside in Birmingham and since the the late 80's , we had literally salafis, almost militant into thier approach in our areas going around speaking to the youth telling them ridiculous things like imam Abu Hanifa only knew 40 hadiths ! Stating they are not following quran and sunnah. I have seen and experienced this personally so please stop with the nonsense
@@shaikhimi6458they still do it
@@shaikhimi6458
Some so called hanafis said a Shafii man can't marry a hanafi sister... like what?
@@ragpaysever2260
4 mathhabs are Athari in Aqida & salafi in fiq... what's Numan's mom's mathhab? what is difference in Usul of 4 mathhab in fiq?
Imam Ahmad made tabdi on kulabis who taught Mid life Hasan Ashari before he repented to Athari, proof he wrote Usul Dayana affirmed by Asakir, Dhahabi & I think Bayhaqi.
Allahumma baarik. Alhamdullah, Ya Allah. Many many so many syubhat that I have, Alhamdulillah with Allah's will, I come across this video and NOW, Alhamdulillah It make absolutely sense. It clear up of all my syubhat that I had
Jazakallahu khayran sheikh Uthman, May Allah grant you jannah.
-
"May Allah unite us upon Quran, Sunnah and the way of salafulummah"
(like sheikh Uthman said in closing of this video) ❤
-
Shaykh does good work defending Islam against the enemies of Islam, the muslim community appreciates this and hopes shaykh Uthman carries on with his work against the enemies of Islam
But makes a grave mistake honouring leaders/ figures in the salafi community
@@jeje4042why?
@@jeje4042 nothing wrong with that
He isn't a sheikh/scholar
@@abdullahassaffah he says in the video he is not I said it out of respect
The quality of this is a pure diamond بارك الله فيكم اخوتنا
Great Podcast & a well respected & well knowledgeable guest. May Allah swt guide us on the path of the Sahabah & we follow the Quran & Sunnah….. Ameen
Ameen❤
Remember brother, the prophet of Islam left TWO weighty matters the Qur'an and ahlulbayt for source of guidance after him
Not the sahaabah.
Pls check N Investigate
Fear Allah YA KADDAB! Allah PRAISED the sahabah. U rafidhi kaddab. We love the Ahlul Bayt, u are an evil liar.
MashAllah Barakallah, may Allah swt bless this ummah and the people striving for goodness and the pleasure of Allah swt
MashaAllah love this shaykh. Came to my local masjid on his tour to the UK and hugged him. And like him, I work in the science field too
Al-hamdulillah. Amazing guest you have here.
Masha Allah, may Allah bless and guide you both.
In all respect... He's incorrect...imam Maliks usool is that he would give preferrence to Amal ahle madinah over a saheeh hadeeth that has singular narration . Also this was not the dawah of the 90s and early 2000... The salafis would denounce following Madhab completely ...some of the super salafis as they were known back then would call Umar a biddati...Inna lillahi...for the ijtihad of 20 rakas
@@043ash i dunno brother
Sheikh I am a Maldivian , love this podcast, n if you want to know if you want to a maldivian you have to be a muslim as far as I know n the country by law is an Islamic country. Hope you vist there soon😊
Masha Allah fantastic interview. Full of very very important information regarding the situation of the ummah. She is very learned but also very humble. Great man
I want to see examples of Muslims critisizing rulers from the west that resulted in bloodshed in Muslim Countries.
They are just fear mongering, it was just a dumb argument.
They don’t have the guts bro unfortunately.. scared they’ll be called terrorists. What a joke
Have you ever heard about the Arab Spring and how it was influenced by the Arab diaspora (mainly) on social media like Facebook or Reddit? Or were you too busy painting the walls of your cave?
@@human0_0skull must have been in that cave you’re talking about
@@human0_0skull akhi speak respectfully and show good manners, your meant to love me for the sake of Allah. The Arabs in those nations used social medias themselves to organise and take part in the Arab Spring.
In Egypt, Tunisia there wasn't bloodshed, Libya has conspiracy theories surrounding it.
Man, season 3 is off to an amazing start
Ya know that bro!!!,
Very informative podcast brother. Learnt a lot
As salaamu alaykum brothers, sisters, friends and foes.
Please like, share and comment on this video, as well as subscribing to the 5Pillars CZcams channel!
Jazakallah khayran.
Faruq need to provide his Masters Degree and actually provide evidence that he has one.
Shaykhs exposed him for not knowing basic Arabic and cant recite Quran properly.
The proof is out there.
Why allow this lying jaahil lie on Aimma of Islam?
And when the fitnah (trial, discord) occurred in the time of ʿUthmān, some people said to Usāmah bin Zayd , ‘Will you not speak to ʿUthmān?’ So he said, ‘Do you think that I have not spoken to him, just because you have not heard it from me? Verily I will speak to him concerning what is between him and me, without opening an affair which I would not like to be the first to open.’ [An authentic narration: Related by Ahmad (3/403) and Ibn Abī ʿĀsim (2/521)
So when they (the Khārijites) opened it, evil took place in the time of ʿUthmān . They opposed ʿUthmān openly, thus completing the tribulations, fighting and corruption, which has not ceased to affect the people to this day, was brought about. And this caused the tribulation to occur between ʿAlī and Muʿāwiyah, and ʿUthmān was killed for these reasons …
و عليك السلام و رحمة الله و بركاته
Masha Allah, may Allah preserve brother Uthman. Very beneficial talk.
Amazing and really useful podcast.
Sheikh uthman, you’re a good role model for the Muslims because you put in the work for Allah SWT, see how Allah has elevated you and made you loved worldwide, may Allah increase you in strength and guidance!
Ma shaa Allah, may Allah bless both of you, one of the most intellectual podcast I have watched, love and respect.
Mashallah a very calm and uniting discussion.
Just what we needed after the last Talk with Daniel Haqiqatjou didn't go well.
Which talk
Daniels has made a video as it seems like Uthman bin farooq is lying yet again.
czcams.com/video/8mTshPbfKzw/video.html
@@MisterSolitudeczcams.com/video/JUK_SRnRV7A/video.htmlsi=4CHylinc62OZUXbP
I love this guy. May bless his him abundanlty for his efforts. And you too dilly.
MashAllah, Great work Brother Dilly.
Great talk from Sheikh Uthman…
alhamdulillah i met this sheikh during one of his trips to mosque in scotland, asked about criticising of the saudi rulers. He had a good reply
What did he say?
@@AB-xx7hy And when the fitnah (trial, discord) occurred in the time of ʿUthmān, some people said to Usāmah bin Zayd , ‘Will you not speak to ʿUthmān?’ So he said, ‘Do you think that I have not spoken to him, just because you have not heard it from me? Verily I will speak to him concerning what is between him and me, without opening an affair which I would not like to be the first to open.’ [An authentic narration: Related by Ahmad (3/403) and Ibn Abī ʿĀsim (2/521)
So when they (the Khārijites) opened it, evil took place in the time of ʿUthmān . They opposed ʿUthmān openly, thus completing the tribulations, fighting and corruption, which has not ceased to affect the people to this day, was brought about. And this caused the tribulation to occur between ʿAlī and Muʿāwiyah, and ʿUthmān was killed for these reasons …
Bro don't leave us hanging like that 😂
May Allah preserve shaykh uthmaan
Ameen.
My first time listening to Shaykh Uthman and I’m blessed to do so. Jazakallah khair.
May Allah protect Shaykh Uthman and brother Dily
Alhamdulillah for Islam
The legend! 🙌🏽
Cant wait for the second one
I know Shaykh Uthman personally and he is one of the most amazing, humble, caring people on Earth. One of my favorite human beings and teachers.
Masha’Allaah shaykh uthman dealt with the questions. You can’t be concerned that the rulers of Muslim countries are kaffir but your living under a kafir ruler in the UK 😂 🇬🇧
On the issue of rebelling against rulers, I can respect the fact the shaykh did not blanketly deny its permissibility, like so many of these madkhalis, however he didn't make it clear what the conditions of rebellion and also criticism of rulers are. If this is something he studied in fiqh then it should be relatively easy to give an overview in this podcast, we will see if he does it in a second podcast...
Bro as always, such issues usually lie between the 2 extremes. I haven't seen that part yet where the sheikh said this, but my gut feel says on this matter the truth is somewhere in between what madkhalis and what Haqiqatjou and his gang say.
Sheikh ibn uthaymeen actually said it was permissible but mentioned clear conditions. Its on the masjid dar us sunnah channel. A VERY CLEAR, PRECISE video mentioning 4-5 conditions
Ka’b ibn ‘Ujrah reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Verily, rulers will come after me and whoever enters their audience, affirms their lies, and supports their oppression, they are not part of me and I am not part of them. They will have no presence at the Fountain. Whoever does not enter their audience, does not support their oppression, and does not affirm their lies, he is part of me and I am part of him. He will be present at the Fountain.”
Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 2190
Grade: Sahih (authentic)
@shoIslam - why is your name show Islam? Do you advice ppl to be open with Islam. If do good but be accurate in speech.
Also you error on so called Madkhalis, they say you can rebel but has conditions... too
Do you not see what happened to the muslim countries recently that revolt the leader? Now they are dead, and the same people who revolt want them back. Crying because the life was better.
@@amdol the problem is they understood the problem but not the cure. They needed to replace the leadership with an Islamic caliphate and not another secular democratic regime.
May Allah bless Shaykh Uthman
*_Masha'Allah, a brilliant quest._*
May Allah bless the Ulema of Deoband who upon the Quran and Sunnah
Ameen
They are not upon the quran and sunnah
Than why so many bidaah comes from them
@@maisamsadigi1658 Ikr
MashaAllah very good and conscience explanation to all the questions brother dilly posed may Allah bless ustad Uthman Ibn Farooq. We need well educated and well spoken knowledgeable people giving dawah. People who give dawah please stop dividing the ummah and start explaining your points with wisdom and knowledge without the pantomime and theatrics its getting unbearable now.
Mashaallah my respect for sheikh uthman gets bigger every time i watch him
Jazakallahu khair for such a knowledgeable and beneficial podcast,
As always sheikh rocks
I love listening to Shaykh Uthman. Clear, methodical, and always based upon evidence.
Yes. Alhamdulillah.
I love to listen to anyone who speaks the truth and brings evidence. Where is the evidence in what he said? Daniel made a video responding to this. Walahi it is depressing to see muslims engaged in this.
@@HumbleServantofAllah642 Uthman makes clear mistakes. The problem is he reads books with no teacher smh
@@m4fital2 no teacher?? don't about someone when u never really know them akhi.
Masha Allah excellent podcast 👌
May Allah bless and protect Sheikh Uthman and our great brother Dilly Ameen!
1:26:39
The answer of the sheikh is very very dangerous. Accusing Ulamaa who are imprisoned is NOT ok!
Hasbounallahou wa ni’mal wakeel.
And accusing all activists is NOT ok neither!
Where are your HUJJAJ of these imprisoned people in the muslim world that they have taken the g&uns on the streets ???
@@i.1303This massive discrepancy exists despite the fact that there is no gender bias in the law favouring females.
Whether you like it or not, the welfare system forces you as a man to pay for single women, many of whom, as you know, are degenerates.
Without welfare and all kinds of affirmative action promoting women in the workplace, women can't support themselves. The feminist welfare state just distributes the burden of taking care of women to all working men. So you, as a man, have the burden of financially supporting these women without any benefit in return, women who will berate you and call you an incel if you disagree with how stunning and brave they are.
Basically, Western liberalism forces you as a man to fund the lifestyle of women drinking, sleeping around with a new man every night, popping anti depressants like candy, going to the womens march on weekends to whine about how oppressed they are. You're literally subsidizing all that.
Women being free is not free. Someone has to foot the bill.
Islam says no. No one gets a free ride. You want to be taken care of. You have to be in a marriage as an obedient wife. And if you dont want to be an obedient wife, go be a burden on your father, who didn't raise you right. And if you don't want to live under your father's roof, go live in the wilderness or beg on the streets. See how long you last there.
5pillars didn’t do justice in this podcast. Uthman Farooq challenged the thoughts of deobandis again and is refusing to sit with deobandis yet claims to be willing to sit with them. To question the aqeedah of great scholars isn’t a light matter and needs to be challenged. Talk about unity is cheap when you don’t back it up
He is unfortunately like most wahabi/salafi/najdis T_T. May Allah unite us all. Ameen.
Deobandis do have a very little part that is no way related to Islam, I can vouch for it being a south Indian Muslim and living in a community encircled with people from nizamuddin markaz. The book they read is so called fazaile aamal contains lot more made up stories than discussing about sahee hadiths. May Allah protect and guide us all.. Aameen
@@alsalman007tube 😂 stop. Go read insha allah
@@alsalman007tube
Faruq need to provide his Masters Degree and actually provide evidence that he has one.
Shaykhs exposed him for not knowing basic Arabic and cant recite Quran properly.
The proof is out there.
@@khairt1731 jahil spotted 🚨
Loved it❤
We are truly blessed to have shiekhs like this. May Allah SWT reward Shiekh Uthman in abundance Allahumma Ameen ❤
Masha Allah, very good interview. Thanks for clarifying on Daniel’s discussion, I have great respect now for YQ and Sheikh Uthman the both of them from different positions show sincere intentions to unite the Ummah. Ya Rabb, grant us Aafia 🤲🏾
Umm did you not hear the part where he mentioned sheikh Karim Abuzaid’s refutation on Yasir Qadhi? I think you should go watch that akhi May Allah bless you
@@longegg-wind9577 , Karim abuzaid is another boot licker.
I’m still unclear on that cuz at the event DH clearly told him that he would’ve preferred to be contacted privately on those questions. One of them must be lying.
@@ahmedyamani7388
Brother don’t accuse fellow Muslim brothers of potentially lying. There was some sort of misunderstanding and we should move on. Don’t let it distract us.
@@sammu Brother both of them have been exposed lying at different times. This is nothing new, so me claiming that one of them has to have lied here is not a stretch giving the contradictions displayed.
Also everyone must be held to account, esp brothers with big platforms. We can’t just dismiss and sweep everything under the carpet.
I love sh Uthman. May Allah protect him and bless his work. The podcast was very beneficial as well msA.
I'd really look forward to a 2nd podcast to drill down into the political side. While it's very clear in Islam that we shouldn't rebel against our rulers for oppression alone, we can definitely criticise them. Umar ibn Al'Khattab himself was criticised and allowed it. Imam Ahmed in Hanbal publicly spoke out against the fitna of khalq al-Quran. There are many other examples.
However, rebellion is a different issue. The question here should be, is a ruler that actively *hates* Islam and Muslims still a Muslim ruler worth obeying? A ruler who's sole purpose is to shut down any and all Muslim work?
At the end of the day, those who say rebellion is haram would still follow those who rebelled if their revolution is successful even if they think it's haram to do so.
Much of the salaf rebelled and fought against the rulers FOR OPPRESSION. For example Abdullah ibn Amr was being oppressed by having his property taken away by the Ummayyad rulers and when asked by someone to just let it go so he wouldn't die, he replied with the famous statement of the Prophet (saw) : "Whoever is killed defending his wealth, he is a martyr". There are many more examples from the tabieen who were in constant battles against the Ummayyads for their oppression
The secular rulers of today that are consistently dismantling the Sharia and oppressing Muslims by killing and imprisoning them are much worse than the Ummayyads or Abbasids or Ottomans
@@wakemeup38 what do you think criticism will lead to? you dont know what you are talking about
thenks for the video
Jazakum allah khair
Imam Malik didn’t obey the rulers so he was almost beat to death and imprisoned
Imam Ahmad Bin Hanbal too, when he opposed the mutazili rulers asking him to declare that the Quran is created.
@@vol94 and Hussain ibn Ali didnt obey Yazeed so whats this nonsense u must obey the ruler
The point is that
They didn't obey the ruler when they asking them somthing against islamic laws. So if the ruler asked them somthing with no Islamic conflict then they have to obey him as mentioned in Qur'an and Sunnah.
@@e.k874you have to obey the rulers when they rule with sharia and not with democracy and as long as he doesn’t order you to do something which is haram (like i Imam Maliks time) or Shirk/Kuffr (like in Imam Ahmads time)
hell no i will not obey the munafiq zionest lover arab rulers of UAE BAHrain etc @@adrenalin4122
Shiekh Uthman has amazing knowledge, Alhamdulillah.
This was an excellent episode, you really did your homework Dilly and asked precise, need to know questions
He was very clear and we ended up seeing an authentic unequivocal discussion
We all agree on the unity of all Muslim ln Sha Allah
The guests greatest argument is "you don't know the situation."
Brother Dilly should’ve asked him about Shaykh Yasir Al-Hanafi responding to his invitation to sit with ulema
I appreciate Sheikh Uthman and his desire to bring the ummah together. That being said, I find something very wrong with his stance on criticizing rulers. He switched back and forth between Khalifa and ruler. Then when he said "why don't you go to those countries and say the same thing" and the brother responded "well they will arrest and kill me", the sheikh responded "exactly". So we are just supposed to be completely silent (as the oppressors want) while they arrest and torture our scholars? While they sell out to the west? As they work with foreign intelligence agencies against the Muslims? As they destabilize other countries, installing and propping up more oppressors? Changing the school curriculum to pervert the masses? Introducing fitnah where it didnt exist before? All while inviting foreign soldiers to establish themselves on your land? If the argument is that blood will be shed, my response is that blood has already been shed and is being shed. I'm not saying that the people in any specific country should just get up and start fighting the government, but calling it out seems like a reasonable first step.
And when the fitnah (trial, discord) occurred in the time of ʿUthmān, some people said to Usāmah bin Zayd , ‘Will you not speak to ʿUthmān?’ So he said, ‘Do you think that I have not spoken to him, just because you have not heard it from me? Verily I will speak to him concerning what is between him and me, without opening an affair which I would not like to be the first to open.’ [An authentic narration: Related by Ahmad (3/403) and Ibn Abī ʿĀsim (2/521)
So when they (the Khārijites) opened it, evil took place in the time of ʿUthmān . They opposed ʿUthmān openly, thus completing the tribulations, fighting and corruption, which has not ceased to affect the people to this day, was brought about. And this caused the tribulation to occur between ʿAlī and Muʿāwiyah, and ʿUthmān was killed for these reasons …
@pvcrma1 I understand, but what is the solution? Do we sit back and stay quiet while the ummah deteriorates? Our children continue being brainwashed in schools? Countries being destabilized? I'm not suggesting armed conflict. I'm not even claiming to have an answer, but is saying that allowing Halloween celebrations in the Arabian peninsula haram too far? Is saying that the rulers allowing clubs and bars in the land of the sahaba are wrong for doing so, being a khariji? Is speaking out against arresting, torturing, and executing scholars equivalent to calling for violence? I don't think so. Sitting silent and hoping for the best doesn't seem like an intelligent solution. If the people there know it but are unable to speak because of a direct threat of arrest or death, the rest of us have to be silent? If you run your country in such a way, armed rebellion is a NATURAL result. This is a rule that has been seen time and time again in history. Muslim lands or not.
@@Melhimri The solutions are many:
- 01. Learn Aqeedah
- 02. Return to the Sunnah
- 03. Repentance
- 04. Go back to the way of companions
- 05. Change our condition [13.11]
Let us be realistic. The masaajid are practically empty and the potential of the Muslims are only seen on Fridays/Ramadaan/Eed etc.
We want victory whilst we are far away from the deen of Allaah! Does that even make sense?
@pvcrma1 that all sounds nice and I'm not discounting it. But, again, our scholars are being locked up. The scholars being promoted by the government are teaching government sponsored Islam. The companions challenged the oppressive rulers on many (and I mean MANY occasions). Many of our most famous scholars were arrested and tortured for publicly disagreeing with leaders.
Let me just summarize the situation. The leaders are pushing the population into more and more western ways: introducing clubs, concerts, gambling, bars, mixed events, etc. They are also jailing, torturing, and killing anyone who criticizes them. Then you have a group of people who are saying criticizing them is haram and you are a khariji if you do it. The way of Islam is not to just sit at home and pray. It's قول و عمل. You speak and take action. The Prophet (pbuh) praised speaking a word of truth to a tyrant. If we just sit at home and pray (which was not the way of the Prophets or the companions), and forget about enjoining good and forbidding evil, you are just as blameworthy as the leader. Recall the hadith when Allah was going to destroy a city and the angels said there was a faithful man amongst them. Allah called for his destruction first. Go read about the sahaba and how they openly criticized Hajjaj ibn Yusuf on multiple occasions.
@@MAli99923jazakAllahu khairan for your concise answer. We often forget that to change a situation, we must change ourselves. Speaking out against rulers will change nothing, the best is to focus on yourself and leave the rest to Allah (سُبْحَانَهُ وَ تَعَالَى)
اللهم بارك
Alhamdulillah Beautiful 😍
Many of these comments hurt to read. Have shame people!!
This is your brother, a very respectable brother at that subhan Allah! yet you call him names and critisize him. If this is how you treat a fellow muslim, i wouldn’t dare think how you'd treat an enemy.
Calling names, I agree maybe not but Shaykh Uthman and all scholars of Islam are fallible thus are not above criticism
Faruq need to provide his Masters Degree and actually provide evidence that he has one.
Shaykhs exposed him for not knowing basic Arabic and cant recite Quran properly.
The proof is out there.
jahil spotted 🚨@@khairt1731
He should not delve in issues that there is legitimate disputation and seek to sow discord and disunity.
Subhan'Allah you will never find A true Muslim speak ill of his Muslim brother in public, no matter what happens, not to revile him or insult him. And if he finds a mistake or false information from him in the deen , then he corrects the matter without mentioning his name.... This is the path of our Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him, the companions,and the our salaf .. Now you find many who claim to be a Salafi while They even don't know what his Muslim brother right upon him !! backbites and hurts his Muslim brother, making a whole videos about only to convince ppl to get rid of him! Almost making him a kaifer!! Acting like they have good attantion! When they do nothing but fitnah and divided the ummah, they Only use the word Salafi to justify what they doing! May Allah deal them all.
ameen. unfortunately this is what we see today, bashing each other on a super public platform, these are serving themselves not Allah
making public amr bilma3ruh nahi 3an al-munkar is permissible and was done by the salaf
"When Muslims will curse each other in public" This is one of the signs before day of judgment that will invite Allah's anger and lead to the destruction of the muslims.
Your correct brother. The people of Iman control their anger and refrain from such backbiting/slandering of their Muslim brethren. Alhamdulillah, Salafists only makeup less than 2 percent of the Ummah, but they are platformed online and have incredible amounts of money at their disposal. I fear for the Ummah
@@AB-xi9im be exactly like a salaf, then go out and expose your brother. you cannot even pray like the salaf, fast like the salaf and you want to publicly criticize like the salaf, possibly this is what lead syrians to the complete disintegration of their nationm you still didn't learn from other's mistakes and you want badly to reproduce their same mistakes, walahi ajaeeb
@@HumbleServantofAllah642 what is this gibberish type english
Excellent podcast, jazakallah'khair
Masha Allah!
Jazaakumullaahu khayran
his arabic is extremely weak
Nobody is perfect may Allah SWT reward him for the good he does in spreading tawheed
@@argbbonanza shouldnt claim to be a shaykh whilst making school boy errors
@@argbbonanza he cant even recite quran properly
@@argbbonanzaFaruq need to provide his Masters Degree and actually provide evidence that he has one.
Shaykhs exposed him for not knowing basic Arabic and cant recite Quran properly.
The proof is out there.
jahil spotted 🚨@@khairt1731
Very dissapointed in Uthman ibn Farooq. He turns out to be on the Madkhali manhaj. If I was there I would have asked him some hard questions where I am sure I wouldnt have gotten a straight answer. First question: If disobeying the rules makes on a Khawarij then tell me, what is Ibn Saud, who overthrew the Sharif of Makkah in a violent coup with the help of the British? Second question: He considers modern national state rulers as muslims. Tell me, if they dont apply the Sharia then does that make them Taghut? And if they are Taghut, then they cannot be muslims and we must not obey them. Third question: National state goes against the nature of Islam, which is all about destroying falsehood and uniting the people under ONE imam. How can Sh. Uthman be in favor of national state rulers, if it goes directly against Islam?
Your questions are loaded with baseless assumptions and a clear agenda to create corruption, sitting in your home while calling for civil war and rebellion. The methodology of Iblees, the way of those dogs of the Hellfire.
@hamzanocap maybe you never went to school but valid criticism is important way to challenge a disputed claim and see if it holds up to the truth. Criticism does not cause "rebellion". Absurd ideological nonesense that's fed to you by state sponsored "scholarship"
Sitting in our home swith our critical faculties in check and the ability to criticise non muslim goverments we live under and question them for opression, and also the Muslim ones. No double standard like the confused lot.
FYI salafis have criticised foreign rulers themselves and ibn baz even called saddam a kafir, so it's a weird double standard pushed to preserve the power of the gulf despots
The differences between Rabee al Madkhali and other salafi scholars are political. They share sam fiqh and aqeedah even though each scholar contradicts themself many times. Wahabbism was created for political control and sabotage of the ummah. The madkhalis are just another wave of this sect.
He answered the questions about the rulers and rebellion with evidence from the quran and sunnah. The deen is based on quran and sunnah, not your emotions.
@usmanchaudhary1765 he didn't really. He offered the same tired replies. Not once did he refer to Quran and Sunnah when he spoke about why we can't criticise foreign leaders. Like why can't a Muslim in UK criticise the horrible actions of mbs?
His rationale of why they shouldn't is absurd and based on his assertion that doing so harms the youth in the country. Such a viewpoint is absurd as it tries to make criticism of a foreign stranger the reason a youth or his family is persecuted, instead of the OBVIOUS elephant in the room; the tyranny of the ruler. His view point is essentially saying the random criticism is causing harm not tyranny and opression of the one being criticised. He didn't refer to textual evidence for his argument, rather his person reasons.
Masha Allah!!! That was neat!!! Thoroughly enjoyed it. Have great respect for Shaykh uthman. May Allah guide us all and keep us steadfast. Ameen.
Mash'Allahu may Allah protect us from the fitna Ameen Ya rabb
Excellent podcast welcome to the UK shaykh
Enjoying good and forbiding evil is the deen of Muhammed and Allah. Sheikh Uthman is wrong here. If the ruler promotes evil, we call it out, he is not our Prophet. Same goes for our parents
Do it in the presence of the ruler the same way you do it in the presence of your parents
@@longegg-wind9577 Of course. And if my parents were public figures i would also make the same statements. This is the deen of the Rasool(PBUH), it's not to be played around with
Ka’b ibn ‘Ujrah reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Verily, rulers will come after me and whoever enters their audience, affirms their lies, and supports their oppression, they are not part of me and I am not part of them. They will have no presence at the Fountain. Whoever does not enter their audience, does not support their oppression, and does not affirm their lies, he is part of me and I am part of him. He will be present at the Fountain.”
Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 2190
Grade: Sahih (authentic)
The asl is private, only scholars who understand nuance can criticize in public...
Project guiding Light has very good videos on this issue imo. BarakAllahu Feekum 🏳️🤲🏼☝🏼
Ma Shah Allah 🥰
Afghanistan: ~1.2 million
Iraq: ~1.1-1.6 million
Syria: ~500,000-600,000
Yemen: ~233,000
Lebanon: ~120,000
Libya: ~50,000
Egypt: ~10,000
Sudan: ~2.35 million (including additional conflicts)
Pakistan: ~70,000
Uzbekistan: ~2,000
Indonesia: ~100,000
Nigeria: ~30,000
Mali: ~10,000
Somalia: ~500,000
Palestine: ~110,000 (including additional conflicts)
Turkey: ~40,000
Bahrain: ~100
Saudi Arabia: ~10,000
Azerbaijan: ~30,000
Iran: Already included in Iraq's estimate
Algeria: ~1.21 million (revised)
Kashmir: ~70,000
China (Xinjiang): ~10,000
Bosnia: ~100,000
Romania: ~1,000
Total: Approximately 9.85-10.35 million deaths
Daies should just admit that almost all Muslim Ruler have not implemented the Shariah and are guilty of Istibdal(replacing the laws of Allah with other kufr secular laws and system) and Istihlal (Make halal what Allah made Haraam and Vice versa) which are MAJOR KUFR, BUT we are unable to remove them Physically and the harm outweighs the good hence we should not rebel.
This could have been an honest point of view rather trying directly or INDIRECTLY trying to defend these rulers. Your gonna be questioned for that on the day of Judgement.
And when the fitnah (trial, discord) occurred in the time of ʿUthmān, some people said to Usāmah bin Zayd , ‘Will you not speak to ʿUthmān?’ So he said, ‘Do you think that I have not spoken to him, just because you have not heard it from me? Verily I will speak to him concerning what is between him and me, without opening an affair which I would not like to be the first to open.’ [An authentic narration: Related by Ahmad (3/403) and Ibn Abī ʿĀsim (2/521)
So when they (the Khārijites) opened it, evil took place in the time of ʿUthmān . They opposed ʿUthmān openly, thus completing the tribulations, fighting and corruption, which has not ceased to affect the people to this day, was brought about. And this caused the tribulation to occur between ʿAlī and Muʿāwiyah, and ʿUthmān was killed for these reasons …
@@MAli99923 So are you Comparing the Khilafah of Uthman RA to the modern day western backed secularist nationalists rulers of the Muslim lands?
@@biggytough2586 Are you saying Islam changed??
Also do you know difference between Quran 5.44 - 47... 3 situations where they don't rule by Allah's law but three different rulings?
I don't think he does know it lol
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543
I hope u don't live in the west & criticizing muslim rulers :)@@biggytough2586
Usman said don’t criticize the ruler publicly from 1:17 only privately again this is also been debunked by bro Hajji of how the salaf criticized the ruler publicly not privately
What Bro Hajji said was debunked too. Bro Hajji doesn't know
You're openly quoting a Khariji? Subhanallah, fear Allah.
Bro Hajji is a Deobandi
His whole existence revolves around fighting Madkhalis.
And when the fitnah (trial, discord) occurred in the time of ʿUthmān, some people said to Usāmah bin Zayd , ‘Will you not speak to ʿUthmān?’ So he said, ‘Do you think that I have not spoken to him, just because you have not heard it from me? Verily I will speak to him concerning what is between him and me, without opening an affair which I would not like to be the first to open.’ [An authentic narration: Related by Ahmad (3/403) and Ibn Abī ʿĀsim (2/521)
So when they (the Khārijites) opened it, evil took place in the time of ʿUthmān . They opposed ʿUthmān openly, thus completing the tribulations, fighting and corruption, which has not ceased to affect the people to this day, was brought about. And this caused the tribulation to occur between ʿAlī and Muʿāwiyah, and ʿUthmān was killed for these reasons …
Salaafi Aqeedah is you cannot criticise MBS. You can criticise rulers like Morsi who have some ghayrah for the Deen.
I believe there needs to be a part
wa'alaikum assalam wa rahmatu'LLAHI wa barakatuh
May Allah bless you sheikh Uthman ❤
Usman tells Daniel so your not a scholar, so you don’t teach fiqh. Why is Usman khan teaching Fiqh and Aqeedah because he said he’s also not a Scholar? This guy is super deceitful.
Learn English then comment.
Mashallah
Brother Dilly , very rarely u have disappointed in this interview.
“Look at evidences”, you have your evidences, the other side has theirs.
wdym by you have your evidences & other side has theirs ?
Is adopting Greek philosophy is what Rassoul Allah, Sahaba, Tabeen & four imams were on ?
People of desires & innovation will never change.
@@dcanebreezy5784the day you can explain to me that you are not even 2% of the Muslim population and the rest are on the sunnah are wrong I will give you time to speak. Otherwise without knowledge, listening to a few speeches - do not talk.
Again, most lay muslims are not aware of deep creedle issue so you rubbish unstatistics are not real.
do u know islam more than Sahaba ? Quboori@@mnuhs5
Even sufi in my country knows that Allah swt is above his creation on his throne.
Do u know that old ashairah believed that too ? :)
won't waste my time with 2% rubbish stats ignorant@@mnuhs5
Try getting a proper Hanabli scholar on that would be better.
Facts.
Faruq has a fake Masters Degree
Hanbali scholar not the Wahhabis
jahil spotted 🚨 @khairt1731
Well he should try and get you instead...so that we will see what you have
I'm not hanbali I'm shafii asharii. So I love hanbali and their schoolers. Not the khashawia(خشوية) like ibn taymiyya, Abdullah ibn abdulwahhab, ibn favzan, etc.
Alhumduliah for the pod cast my allah reward you alhumduliah
Long overdue!
SubhanAllah....
Questioner Got NO-*Chill for a Second* to Him...
Lol
* He Went RIGHT INTO Questions that Brothers who have BEEN Practicing Islam for DECADES Wouldn't Ask/ Concern themselves with.
* Good in a Way
* Then Again - Not So Good (in a Way,)
----------
Either-Way :
It Is Allah(swt) That Guides Men & Women to the Straight Path.
AlHumdulillah
People in comments are jokes, judging the dude on anything and everything, you guys should focus on your own lives and if its that important to you maybe you should go put in the work like these dudes and then get on a podcast and say what you gotta say. go fix yourselves. Bunch of scholars in the comments .
💯
I know right. No one is infallible at the end of the day. Shiekh Uthman says he is a student of knowledge at the end of the day. Arrogance has just increased with the internet and keyboard warriors. No one actually is humble enough to sit down with a scholar and learn from them. Anyone taking knowledge for the sake of Allah become more humble, any other motives and they became arrogant.
Not ruling by the laws of Allah is considered Major Kufr according to many Scholars, so it’s not a condition that one expresses their disbelief verbally, also the view that we don’t live in those lands and therefore we shouldn’t comment on their affairs is incorrect since we are one Ummah and what happens around the World concerns us and affects Muslims in different ways both economically and politically, but he’s correct in that the right procedure should be followed in addressing the matter, unfortunately what we see in the Muslim lands is sad from both the ruling governments and the people.
My scholar, ibn Abbas رضي الله عنه said it is Kufr less than Kufr (I.e. minor kufr.).
Ka’b ibn ‘Ujrah reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Verily, rulers will come after me and whoever enters their audience, affirms their lies, and supports their oppression, they are not part of me and I am not part of them. They will have no presence at the Fountain. Whoever does not enter their audience, does not support their oppression, and does not affirm their lies, he is part of me and I am part of him. He will be present at the Fountain.”
Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 2190
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according
Do you, your acquaintances, and the generality of myslim laymen rule by what Allah has ordered in your own homes these days?.. Hmm, yet here we are NOT making takfir on Muslims based on that. The rulers are a reflection of our own inner state as muslims. You want umar in charge act like those under umar at his time. We can complain all day, but NOTHING will change until we take accountability and apply the shari'ah to ourselves. There is no denying that there's corruption in land, but who is it to blame really? We've turned away from the shari'ah and we act like it isnt our fault.
@@pursueexcellence7737 that saying is well known from ibn Abbas (RA) but it’s context doesn’t apply to the one who makes laws to govern and judge the people in the land, what you are quoting is to do with judging in a matter away from the shariah, ie, not applying the command of Allah in a particular matter or so, not in cases where the actual laws are codified and are contrary to that of the shariah, this distinction is well known,
@@getout0101 Who before you preceded in this (wishy-washy) distinction of the difference between it being kufr Akbar and As-ghar being "judging in the land" and "judging in a particular matter"?
Because there are over 30 salaf who have reported ijmaa' that a father not ruling by the ruling of Allah by allowing his child to have a girlfriend is commiting major kufr when he believes Allah has not made it haram, otherwise, it is only a sin.
Absolutely loved this Alhamdulillah. We are blessed to be able to attend this discussion. Jzk khair blessed brothers
Daniel Haqiqatjou has answered about the stuff that was discussed about him
Unfortunately, he is not Hanbali. He looks at the adillah, meaning he is deeming himself knowledgeable enough to do tarjeeh of the scholars' positions.
Yeah because he’s not a BLIND follower like his family who were hanafi were when they weren’t even following the Fiqh of the ahnaaf…you dummies don’t respect knowledge you respect sheep smh
the level of arrogance is extreme on someone who lacks basic nahw lol
You need to grow up
Aren't u allowed to do so after u reach a certain level of understanding of fiqh?
The idea is to always go back to Allah and his messenger ﷺ if there is confusion on something
@@maazmustafa2322 In principle, a student can study the adillah of the madhhab. They can understand them or fail to understand them. They may personally be swayed to one position over another WITHIN the madhhab. However, a student of knowledge needs to reach a higher level within the madhhab to actually say which of the two positions is preferable from within the madhhab's principles. This is the level of being a murajjih in one's school. Are there ulema' like this today? yes. But I do not believe Brother Uthman is at that level. He is doing some good da'wah work alhamdulillah. One cannot simply do tarjeeh willy-nilly on the basis of their personal opinion. They need to be schooled in the principles of the madhhab so that their understanding represents a madhhab understanding and not an individualistic understanding. And Allah knows best. I hope I represented the idea well. May Allah bless everyone on this thread, Salafi or otherwise
The problem are the Madkhalis and many false Muslim rulers, do you not get that?
the problem is arrogance coupled with ignorance towards the Quran and sunnah.
@@muslimresponse103How do you feel about MBS buying a picture of Isa (AS) for millions? Also making the adhaan lowered and opening clubs?
@@Figleaf-Bicarbonatehow do you feel about your own sins and disregarding the Quran and sunnah to follow your own emotions and feelings?!
@@Figleaf-Bicarbonate MBS is not infallible nor should he be judged with such a standard. First of all you don't know his intentions, it could be to purchase it so that it isn't on public display, seeing as the painting was supposed to be shown at a gallery in Abu Dhabi in 2018 but since MBS purchased it, nobody has laid eyes upon it to the public's knowledge since 2017.
Making the volume of adhaan was in response to complaints from citizens, so your qualm on that issue is with the residents, not the one acting on ther complaints, and lowering the max volume affects someone's deen how? Does it go in the Qur'aan and Sunnaah to lower the volume of the adhaan? Aren't we supposed to be a considerate people? If everyone recited at the top of their lungs during salah nobody in the masjid would be able to concentrate.
The clubs opening, I can only find news on a club opening in Jeddah in 2019, which the GEA of SA stated they did not authorise, but rather the organisers took advantage of a license granted for a different event altogether to open the club. So everything is not as it seems. Either way, it should be removed but again, that shouldn't effect your ability to practise your religion and be the best Muslim you can be.
BaarakAllaahu feekum.
@@Figleaf-BicarbonateHow about you worried about your sister, your mom and dad at home. Why do you stretch your hand where it doesn’t reach?🤷🏽♂️ Does knowing him bought the picture increases your eman?? How about you leave things that concern you and focus on things that concern you.
Just know that I love you for the sake of Allah.❤️❤️
I'm definitely gonna watch this
Very important interview and very few interviews like that
Asalamualaykum.
Peace be upon you all. We need our brothers from other perspectives such as Shamsi and Abu Mussab to come on the Blood Brothers podcast. That would be box office. I think there is great good in these guys.
May Allah bless Shaykh Uthman, amazing may Allah accept all our good deeds and erase our bad deeds. Ameen.
Big up Dilly, 5 Pillars and the team.
Difficult to get Shamsi. He only sits with and promotes Salafi speakers. :)
Shamsi has deep arrogance will never let Him to seat with alot of Muslims may Allah guide him
what's wrong with salafi ?
Aren't Salafi the ones who follow the Three first gen & against platonic Philosophy of Ashaira & Matruidhi ? Aren't Salafi following Athar of 3 first generation(which are the best generations according to Rassoul Allah ? )
Do modern Ashairah follow Abu hassan Al Ashari ? they oppose alot
Aren't Ashairah similar to Jahmiya & Mutazila and many scholars repented from it & went back to Rassoul, Sahaba, Tabeen & 4 imam Aqeeda!
Why would anyone follow abu hassan who came after 4 centuries with philosophy and Jahmiya Mutazila beliefs? Who himself repented from Philosophy:) (isn't that what made Nassara trinitarians ? by following philosophers who came after centuries ?) you never lean.
Same with Abu Hamad Al Ghazali who dove into greek philosophy & made innovations, kufr beliefs & statements? but repented from it.
Al Nawawi repented too.
Isn't innovation into our Deen what caused division?
Aren't people of desires & innovations who devided The Ummah ?+ hypoctis OFC@@suhaibsyed4152
@@dcanebreezy5784 bro I am a Salafi myself. I was just telling y Shamsi won’t come to a podast with an Ashari. A daee is not supposed to mix with deviants & be seen by his followers mixing & getting along with people of wrong beliefs. It sends a wrong message & causes confusion amongst the followers & seekers of true path
It's disappointing seeing Br. Uthman being so close to becoming a madkhali.
Doesn't he see how these rulers are LITERALLY fighting Islam? Not only in their countries, internationally!
Hasn't Br. Uthman seen the tens of scholars jailed in Saudi for example?
Same notion from my side. He reiterates the Madkhali defence against the rulers.
Do you deny a clear narration from the Messenger pbuh? Or is your desire to call out the rulers stronger than your submission to Allah and His Prophet? Name calling those of the Sunnah is not new, that is all you people of desires have.
@@hamzanocap The clear narration when the Prophet PBUH says: that the best of martyrs is Hamza, and a man stood up to an oppressive ruler? Or the narration when he PBUH said the Ummah will no longer have any weight/effect if it doesn't say to the oppressor: you are oppressive? (obviously I'm paraphrasing)
@@Addakhel Was the ruler Hamza stood up to Muslim...?
@@hamzanocap Rulers that dont apply Sharia are Taghut, their outer appearance doesnt matter bro. Wake up brother, its not about calling out rulers. Its about our heartfelt desire to live in an islamic state, with a Muslim ruler that applies the Sharia.
nice.
masha allah
May Allah reward you brother Dilly for bringing the case of brother Daniel's "inqusition". That scene had really left a bitter taste at us,it was really unnecessary putting brother Daniel into that situation.
Daniel put himself in that situation.
Daniel put himself in that situation and got schooled
@@ABC-wi6vt😂😂
Don't think it was unnecessary at all. It was better. Only ones who feel bad are hard-core Daniel fanboys. He was brought on stage to clarify his own stance to us laymen. That's what it was - a clarification IN HIS OWN words but fanboys understood it to be a humiliation of Daniel.
The last part of Daniel taking shahadah with a salafi touch was just added as a light hearted joke to calm down super salafis
@@wally86_sorry brother, I doubt that. Everyone could clearly see Br Daniel schooled the panel trying to question him. The 'Sheikhs' tried to put Deobandis under the bus, but they got schooled about that also.
Brother Uthman rocking the Louis Vuitton loafers, mashaAllah!
Sheikh i understood the meat part what about eating fish from the same places? Mcds or bk
This was the loveliest and the most awaited discussion for me. My beloved Shaykh Uthman wearing cool 😎 1:34:00
I ask Allah to preserve him and reward him immensely for his knowledge and his works and his tireless efforts day in day out. Love you for the sake of Allah, Shaykh ❤
Furthermore, beloved brother Dilly Hussain - I almost forgot - may Allah reward you for being neutral and impartial yet again for hosting this discussion. As you did in the past between Shaykh Israr and Shaykh Abdurrahman.
Some people are good at being neutral? 😂