Taemin has put the exact words in my mouth. All 5 of them have such a distinct color to their voices and personalities but they come together to create a color of their own. You may have a bias in SHINee but you'll tend to end up loving all of them 😉
I'm a new Shawol who just decided to become a Shawol after 3 months of thinking, and I still haven't been able to choose a bias- I mean, man are all five of them talented, goo-looking, and gentlemen!?!?!! Gawd, I really can't! I'll start as an OT5! Gosh!
I'm a baby shawol from a little before dcm era and I have to say after watching this and knowing more about the members I feel a little sad not stanning them before. I am saddened that I did not recognize jonghyuns talent in particular until he had already passed. I may be a baby shawol and may not have supported shinee long or jonghyun while he was with us on earth but I'll support them and always love them.
ik this comment is from 3yrs ago, but i js got back into my k-pop phase and i knew about their song ring ding dong, but i never looked into shinee until a month ago. i’ve completely fallen in love with them. their vocals, personalities, just everything. i agree with you i wish i could’ve been there when jonghyun was alive and i do kind of regret finding them so late after they’ve been around for 15 years..
as a baby shawol of about 2 weeks can someone tell me where to start, the 12 years of content scares me and i dont know what to look for lol, if you have any recommendations for me to watch pls tell me thank you
Def the concert vids! There are a lot on yt. Just search swc v, swc iv, swc iii, swc ii, etc. And their Hello Baby. It can be cringey at first, but when you get through the first 2 eps, it gets funnier and cuter.
Welcome to SHINee World! I'm sure you'll enjoy watching all these contents. SHINee is so fun to watch, their personalities are really so lovable. Some random videos in yt can help you get started: Key being a mom to SHINee, SHINee Tom and Jerry moments, Key and Minho love hate relationship. If you want to get to know them more try reality shows Hello Baby, Yunhaman and One Fine Day. These are all series. Also some variety shows like Weekly Idol guestings and Knowing Brothers. Concert stages - almost all are in youtube. Try SHINee World 4 and 5 since they have eng subs. Just let us know if you need more info, we'll be glad to provide suggestions.😊
That was an interesting intro to SHINee. I felt sad watching Jonghyun looking so happy when we now know he was going through such inner turmoil. Such a great loss. I'm looking forward to Taemin finishing his military service so we can see them all back together again. He is an amazing performer as they all are. They all have such a lot of strings to their bows. Key and Minho crack me up and Onew is so down to earth.
Yes Jonghyun had said before that SHINee is one, eventhough they debut as a solo they still connected, and then Key, the one who want to continued the tradition and like Onew said he also wanna join the tradition.. now we only have to wait CHOICE😍
I consider them a one of a kind entertainers. Just discovered them during the pandemic and am proud to be a new Shawol. Each member is a superstar in his own right. I know their individual talent and charm will keep them in the limelight for a long time. I intend to catch them in concert with the 4 and Jonghyun in spirit. Forever 5 Shinee!
Earlier this week I was so sad and I was in such a bad mood that I only wanted to cry. I really don’t know why, because I’m not familiar with Shinee at all. I’ve seen Taemin and Minho in shows etc. but that’s it. Suddenly for some reason I felt the urge to watch the sad story about Jonghyun 😭. Well I cried and cried. When my mood got better I started to watch more about Shinee and the members. I must say their voices are so beautiful. Especially Onew and also Key has this special tone in his voice. I was really surprised that I liked their music so much. I’m definitely gonna follow them more 😁.
Just remember that Jonghyun was more than a "sad story." There's so many new people who have reduced him down to his death. He was our fun, loud, and excited puppy. He was a beautiful lyricists, poet and great producer. He is still SHINee. He loved his mother and sister very much. Also keep in mind, he didn't hide his depression, he was open about it. He supported LGBTQ community. He was not religious.
6:36 I had the opportunity to watch and hear this LIVE and it was the most amazing thing I had ever heard. The passion really pierced through my heart. I will never forget that moment. His voice was so amazing and unbelievable. I feel like I can't truly describe my experience hearing him live because every word feels like an understatement.
Why? It's never too late. I am a fan for 11yrs now and they still always surprise me everytime they release new music and content. They are so dedicated to their craft and i always enjoy seeing them. them being around for so long only means that you will never run out of content to discover 😌 just take it one step at a time. Welcome to SHINee World 💎
wow, i really would have loved jonghyun to the moon and back. i'm definitely going to listen to his music and when i can read fluently in korean, i'm going to read his book
thanks so much for making this guide, i am introducing my mom to shinee and its so common for these intro videos to try to be funny or to be not as serious so its nice to have something that really shows the best of all the members that i can show her
My forever bias is JJong. I'm so happy. I can get back to Shinee again. Bcs i was kinda lost and can't be able to watch anything of Shinee w/o Jonghyun especially back in 2018. It was hard but thanks Taemin for his hard work. He just everywhere these past couple of years. I can avoid him and I know that JJong wants us to support this baby and i almost forgot how much I like other members. It is still hard tho. JJONG was always there at the center. Anyways each of them are so amazing.
I knew SHINee with 'ring ding dong' and I really liked this song but I didn't knew it was kpop so I waited some years and now I am a shawol🥺 and 'ring ding dong' is really special to me haha. I have always wonder who sang this song and when I knew I was like : fuck lmao I am dumb
thank you for the updated guide. it is indeed very helpful for babywols out there.. very informative yet compact & not lengthy.👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽 i really really hope you will make a 2022 edition, because clearly, 2021 is a very productive year for all shinee members😌🙏🏾 there's one important info that was not mentioned for minho in this guide: yes indeed he doesn't have a solo album, BUT he released a solo song "I'm Home." for me, this is a basic info if one wants to know minho more. also, since it was already mentioned that he is "focusing on acting," it would have been better for new fans to get a glimpse of that by maybe adding a 30secs clip from one of his movies (minho's segment in this guide was the shortest).
It's my pleasure to support these wonderful artists They are so precious to me And I will always support them And thanks a lot for supporting them till today They are actually the finest and best out there, they are beyond kpop or any tag And as human beings too they are the most amazing idols and their bond is too solid with each other Still they are not acknowledged as much they deserve which really makes me feel bad I wish they would get the acknowledgement and recognition they deserve I'm not saying this coz I'm their admirer,I'm an admirer coz they are legendary in and out
so I'm kind of a baby kpop stan, I only got into it this year in february-march through my now ults, and since I'm only into 4th gen and a few 3rd gen groups I decided to try and get into at least one or two 2nd gen groups. now my ults, I know some of them are shawols and one of them loves taemin, and I saw this thread of shinee being extremely funny on twitter and after that I knew I had to start my 2nd gen exploration with them, and I was right cause they seem lovely. I'm really excited for taemin to finally come back so all of them can be together and I'll do my best to catch up with all the music before that happens!
Thank you!! It was so nice going down memory lane and your focus was wonderfully put together!! Also why haven’t I seen this before 16:22 Can you tell me where it’s from?
As I type this I'm at Jonghyun....that being said no I haven't checked out much of his solo stuffs (it's on my to-do list) but him in that red suit....oh my SHAWol heart can't take much lol
Thank you for this guide, I'm just starting my journey with them, they're amazing. Can I ask you two things about credits? 1) where did you see Minho has 40 songwriting credits? In the official top 100 list(updated till October 2020) the only member I can find is Jonghyun with 79 and the last of the list has 27 credits... Why Minho isn't there? 2) for the composing credits, is there an official list or you had to count yourself? Oh and isn't Onew a main vocalist? Just saw it in other guides
Hi. Seeing as there's no reply yet from the creator of this guide, I'll try to answer your queries. 1) I don't know the source of Minho's writing credits cited here but I first learned about it when I was reading Minho's Wikipedia page. 2) Again, as I don't know Korean, I mostly know of the song credits in Wikipedia's discography section where they have tracklistings of each album. Lyricist, composers, and producers are listed there. The group positions you've seen here were the ones each member had when they debuted. Jonghyun said that there are no main vocals in SHINee. That all of them are vocalists. Also, Onew confirmed this in a recent SBS special interview that they have gone beyond this as each member sings main or lead vocal interchangeably in a given song. In addition, in a translated tweet, an Amazing Saturday cast, described SHINee members as brainiacs. That's a fact. Each of them have a Masteral Degree under their name. I hope that I've helped you in a small way by replying to your comment. Have a nice day :)
@@ophirelda3368 Thank you very much for your reply! 1) still I don't understand why Minho isn't in the official list, if he has 40 credits he deserves to be there. Even if he only wrote his rap parts, because I know for sure that some on the list are credited just for that and not for the entire songs. 2) I always watch the credits there too but I hoped there would be an official composition list as well since it would have been easier to know everyone's number of credits But I thought Taemin was just a vocalist when they debuted and the video says lead vocal. Anyway SHINee is a very talented group in terms of vocals(well not just that, but we are talking about that) so I get it's difficult to put the main, lead and sub labels on them and also it's smart and right(to me) that members sings more or less in function of how much they fit one song. It's just that I'm so used to learn the position subdivision that I expect it for all the groups.
@@MorePara8 You're welcome :) 1) Yes he deserves to be in the list. I wouldn't have known if I didn't read his Wikipedia page. 2) Well I hope so too. I really wish there's also an official list of what each member contributed to the song or album aside from lyrics and music composition, like if they participated in developing the concept, creating the choreography or designing the outfits in the promotional teasers and MVs, and also MV editing and directing like Taemin did with his Criminal MV. Taemin debuted as the main dancer. He didn't even have solo lines in Replay cause his voice was so underdeveloped during that time. Taemin said in an interview that he didn't want to debut because he felt so unprepared and he thought he will be debuting with trainees the same age. He gradually became a lead vocal and then main vocal. Until Taemin dragged me into Kpop (Lol) I didn't even know about this positions in a group. But I'm so glad it doesn't really apply to SHINee cause all of them are all-rounders.
@@ophirelda3368 1) I don't understand how an official list can make such a mistake... 2) I totally agree, it would be so interesting and it would give the members every credit they have. Also I think just one credits subdivision should be chosen for everybody because somebody have lyrics/music/producer and some others have lyrics/composer/arrangement. They should be more clear. Yeah I noticed he had barely any line that's why I don't get why the video says "lead vocal" if it's meant to be the debut position. Anyway Taemin had really an incredible development as a vocalist, we can hear his improvement throughout SHINee's discography and also have his solo activity and his presence in Super M as a confirmation of what he has accomplished.
@@MorePara8 1) Maybe a more accurate list exist that we don't know about cause it wasn't translated into English? 2) I agree. It would make everything much clearer for us who are interested to know these stuffs. I just learned a lot through other Shawol's comments who have been fans since the beginning and have witnessed everything. One example is the fact that Taemin is the one responsible for his song Press Your Number to have an electric guitar in the music. Yes. Also, a Shawol who frequently watched his solo concerts have commented of how much Taemin improved, in the sense that he sounded so much better live. And that comment was in 2019. Imagine his improvement now? One thing about Taemin is that he really has superb musicality. Each of his moves has a meaning to it. The reason why I think his dancing is so unique. He doesn't just go off with strong, sharp movements all the time. He goes into character and embodies the song.
idk how to feel about you not mentioning jjong's passing...on one hand it has its pros because people often tend to reduce his entire life and legacy to his death which is incredibly ignorant but on the other you'd expect a detailed guide to a band note that one of the members hasn't been around for years
April 30, 2022 What is the song at 7:54? Deja boo I found the answer from another comment. Thank you to that person. Please put the song titles up or link the videos if you ever make other videos. It's not easy to find the songs they're singing and a big thank you to the people who do help out by telling people who ask " what song is (fill in time stamp)? " because it's difficult sometimes to find the exact song because I always try finding the same music video and sometimes I can't find the same one for the life of me.
It's "Rainy Blue". Onew covered and performed it on their first Tokyo Dome concert. You can watch his full performance here : czcams.com/video/TmuC_gxum5Y/video.html
Jonghyun is the most talented person ever exist in kpop history.
One of a kind
YESSSSSSS 💙💙💙💙💙
I didn’t even know he could rap packed with talent
He's everything
SO TRUE. IF ANYONE ARGUES, THROW THEM UNDER THE BUS SORRY BUT I DON'T MAKE THE RULES.
Taemin has put the exact words in my mouth. All 5 of them have such a distinct color to their voices and personalities but they come together to create a color of their own.
You may have a bias in SHINee but you'll tend to end up loving all of them 😉
What song was Taemin singing in the second clip? (In the purple suit)
@@taammiia3336
It’s called Love!
That’s certainly true. I would say my bias is Minho but it’s difficult to justify when any one of them could be.
I'm a new Shawol who just decided to become a Shawol after 3 months of thinking, and I still haven't been able to choose a bias- I mean, man are all five of them talented, goo-looking, and gentlemen!?!?!! Gawd, I really can't! I'll start as an OT5! Gosh!
I'm a baby shawol from a little before dcm era and I have to say after watching this and knowing more about the members I feel a little sad not stanning them before. I am saddened that I did not recognize jonghyuns talent in particular until he had already passed. I may be a baby shawol and may not have supported shinee long or jonghyun while he was with us on earth but I'll support them and always love them.
ik this comment is from 3yrs ago, but i js got back into my k-pop phase and i knew about their song ring ding dong, but i never looked into shinee until a month ago. i’ve completely fallen in love with them. their vocals, personalities, just everything. i agree with you i wish i could’ve been there when jonghyun was alive and i do kind of regret finding them so late after they’ve been around for 15 years..
Shinee easily has the strongest vocal line in kpop history
Minho talking about lonliness hits hard
SHINee 5 vocals, 5 dancers 5 visuals and 5 rappers. 5HINee forever. Thanks for this guide. Recommend for babywols.
I am babywol
Among the members , Jonhyun exudes the Superstar aura. He suits the center position well.
Onew has a spectacular voice!
icb I'm starting stanning shinee just rn, I wasted years of my life
seriously. i don’t know what took me so long 😭
im not even a stan of this group but undoubtedly, onew is one of the best vocalists I've ever seen
as a baby shawol of about 2 weeks can someone tell me where to start, the 12 years of content scares me and i dont know what to look for lol, if you have any recommendations for me to watch pls tell me thank you
Def the concert vids! There are a lot on yt. Just search swc v, swc iv, swc iii, swc ii, etc. And their Hello Baby. It can be cringey at first, but when you get through the first 2 eps, it gets funnier and cuter.
You can watch one fine day , that was like a reality show when they travel !! It's funny and you get to know them more deeply
Welcome to SHINee World! I'm sure you'll enjoy watching all these contents. SHINee is so fun to watch, their personalities are really so lovable.
Some random videos in yt can help you get started: Key being a mom to SHINee, SHINee Tom and Jerry moments, Key and Minho love hate relationship.
If you want to get to know them more try reality shows Hello Baby, Yunhaman and One Fine Day. These are all series.
Also some variety shows like Weekly Idol guestings and Knowing Brothers.
Concert stages - almost all are in youtube. Try SHINee World 4 and 5 since they have eng subs.
Just let us know if you need more info, we'll be glad to provide suggestions.😊
@@shawoolie5232 thank you so much!
@@karlamc8575 thanks!
For me they are all the most handsome member in kpop boy group..our princes of kpop💎💎💎💎💎
theyre literally kings ‼️
That was an interesting intro to SHINee. I felt sad watching Jonghyun looking so happy when we now know he was going through such inner turmoil. Such a great loss. I'm looking forward to Taemin finishing his military service so we can see them all back together again. He is an amazing performer as they all are. They all have such a lot of strings to their bows. Key and Minho crack me up and Onew is so down to earth.
Im a new fan of SHINee 💙
Welcome
Welcome to SHINee world
Same
How is it going?
ME TOO RATHER WE TOO @WORK NEW FAN OF #SWEETLOVELY#SHINee A WORLD CLASS MULTI TALENTED KPOP GROUP🌈❤️🙏
If you stan SHINee or listen to their music, support them, follow the members YOU HAVE GREAT TASTE KEEP GOING.
This video took me back in memory line. It has been 13 years and they are still shining!
i just realized that taemin, jonghyun, key and onew had the same format of album artwork of their album.
Yes Jonghyun had said before that SHINee is one, eventhough they debut as a solo they still connected, and then Key, the one who want to continued the tradition and like Onew said he also wanna join the tradition.. now we only have to wait CHOICE😍
then there's minho with chase
@@someone-re7sq "the puzzle is complete with this last piece" 😭
@@ishii-00001 i cried when i saw it on his album. shinee is truly very unique.
i’m 18 and i’m wasting my life not stan them from debut. now i’m baby shawol and i’m really happy with them.
I consider them a one of a kind entertainers. Just discovered them during the pandemic and am proud to be a new Shawol. Each member is a superstar in his own right. I know their individual talent and charm will keep them in the limelight for a long time.
I intend to catch them in concert with the 4 and Jonghyun in spirit. Forever 5 Shinee!
why do my eyes water everytime i hear onew sing
im not even that emotional wtf😭
Cuz he sounds so good🛐
the onew effect ✨
cus he's onew
he has that ✨effect✨
that's because it's onew
this vid rly hits diff when comeback day is exactly 500 days after i became a blinger (which was also the day i heard my first shinee songs) 😭❤️
Earlier this week I was so sad and I was in such a bad mood that I only wanted to cry. I really don’t know why, because I’m not familiar with Shinee at all. I’ve seen Taemin and Minho in shows etc. but that’s it. Suddenly for some reason I felt the urge to watch the sad story about Jonghyun 😭. Well I cried and cried. When my mood got better I started to watch more about Shinee and the members. I must say their voices are so beautiful. Especially Onew and also Key has this special tone in his voice. I was really surprised that I liked their music so much. I’m definitely gonna follow them more 😁.
Just remember that Jonghyun was more than a "sad story." There's so many new people who have reduced him down to his death. He was our fun, loud, and excited puppy. He was a beautiful lyricists, poet and great producer. He is still SHINee. He loved his mother and sister very much. Also keep in mind, he didn't hide his depression, he was open about it. He supported LGBTQ community. He was not religious.
6:36
I had the opportunity to watch and hear this LIVE and it was the most amazing thing I had ever heard. The passion really pierced through my heart. I will never forget that moment. His voice was so amazing and unbelievable. I feel like I can't truly describe my experience hearing him live because every word feels like an understatement.
do you know the name of the song?
@@ml5545 It's "An Encore"!
I've seen them live a few times too. Just hearing Colorful and Beautiful especially, I still FEEL his voice. Goosebumps everywhere
i'm the new shawol so this helps a lot thanks!!
You are so welcome to the amazing SHINee World 💎💎💎💎💎
@@TR-dp4es thank you!🥺
bro they’ve been around for so long i feel like it’s not okay that i’m stanning them in 2021😟
Why? It's never too late. I am a fan for 11yrs now and they still always surprise me everytime they release new music and content. They are so dedicated to their craft and i always enjoy seeing them. them being around for so long only means that you will never run out of content to discover 😌 just take it one step at a time. Welcome to SHINee World 💎
Most talented group
Nice focus and mix of new and older material. I linked it on Twitter right away.
i love they clips you choose to present every member, they were perfect choices!
I wish onew to sing blue live
oh yes! blue is such a powerful song, it deserves a live performance
He might in their online concert 😉
@@Julianna_w I really hope. I love ree that song. Fits onew so well!
wow, i really would have loved jonghyun to the moon and back. i'm definitely going to listen to his music and when i can read fluently in korean, i'm going to read his book
Thank you!! I have known about them for a while, but finally getting to know these legends. What amazing people.
thanks so much for making this guide, i am introducing my mom to shinee and its so common for these intro videos to try to be funny or to be not as serious so its nice to have something that really shows the best of all the members that i can show her
Welcome to all the new Shawols!!
SHINee hits my heart like no other group
My forever bias is JJong. I'm so happy. I can get back to Shinee again. Bcs i was kinda lost and can't be able to watch anything of Shinee w/o Jonghyun especially back in 2018. It was hard but thanks Taemin for his hard work. He just everywhere these past couple of years. I can avoid him and I know that JJong wants us to support this baby and i almost forgot how much I like other members. It is still hard tho. JJONG was always there at the center. Anyways each of them are so amazing.
they're so talented omg i wanna stan themm
I knew them since I'm a kpop fan but I just decided to stan them. Thank you for the video. Also I share my birthday with Onew lol
jonghyun and taemin's voices are just >>>
Welcome new Shawols 🥰
I just recently started stanning Shinee, I think it's a bit late but they're so talented and I love them 😭 Thank you for this guide ❤️
Welcome new shawols!!! Were excited to have you!!!
I knew SHINee with 'ring ding dong' and I really liked this song but I didn't knew it was kpop so I waited some years and now I am a shawol🥺 and 'ring ding dong' is really special to me haha. I have always wonder who sang this song and when I knew I was like : fuck lmao I am dumb
thank you for the updated guide. it is indeed very helpful for babywols out there.. very informative yet compact & not lengthy.👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽
i really really hope you will make a 2022 edition, because clearly, 2021 is a very productive year for all shinee members😌🙏🏾
there's one important info that was not mentioned for minho in this guide: yes indeed he doesn't have a solo album, BUT he released a solo song "I'm Home." for me, this is a basic info if one wants to know minho more.
also, since it was already mentioned that he is "focusing on acting," it would have been better for new fans to get a glimpse of that by maybe adding a 30secs clip from one of his movies (minho's segment in this guide was the shortest).
I've been shawol since 2012 but I'm still watching this because it's SHINee.
you should have so much more likes, this was so helpful!! thank you 💞
We can all agree Taemin is the best dancer in kpop history 💎🕴🏻
this was such a good guide! as a long time shawol i like it very much
Yesss I absolutely agree with guideeee. You showed the side no "guide" has showed so far TVT
this is precious 💖
love the vid
nice,
SHINEE IS BACK
FOREVER LOVE AND SUPPORT
This video is amazing u did amazing when it came to research
Jonghyun and minho are probably my biases
It's my pleasure to support these wonderful artists
They are so precious to me
And I will always support them
And thanks a lot for supporting them till today
They are actually the finest and best out there, they are beyond kpop or any tag
And as human beings too they are the most amazing idols and their bond is too solid with each other
Still they are not acknowledged as much they deserve which really makes me feel bad
I wish they would get the acknowledgement and recognition they deserve
I'm not saying this coz I'm their admirer,I'm an admirer coz they are legendary in and out
As a blink, I think Shinee is the most talented group kpop has ever produced
TAEMIN NEEDS US VOTE FOR HIM AS BEST MAKNAE 2023 ON KING CHOICE
I really like this guide😍😍😍
I drop my heart here
thank you for the video !!
Thankyou for this😍😍😍😍😍
I just started to Stan them today. Can old shawol help me?😩
Me- I stan to much kpop groups, i can't go to anothe-
CZcams Recomandation - Detailed Guide to SHINee
Also Me - I got no time to lose
Oh this is awesome
Based on KOMCA, jonghyun is credited in 79 songs
Thank you💖
Beautiful videooo
im watching this as if i dont already know everything here-
Thanks for the video ❤️💎💎💎💎💎
so I'm kind of a baby kpop stan, I only got into it this year in february-march through my now ults, and since I'm only into 4th gen and a few 3rd gen groups I decided to try and get into at least one or two 2nd gen groups. now my ults, I know some of them are shawols and one of them loves taemin, and I saw this thread of shinee being extremely funny on twitter and after that I knew I had to start my 2nd gen exploration with them, and I was right cause they seem lovely. I'm really excited for taemin to finally come back so all of them can be together and I'll do my best to catch up with all the music before that happens!
Thank you!! It was so nice going down memory lane and your focus was wonderfully put together!!
Also why haven’t I seen this before 16:22
Can you tell me where it’s from?
Hi! Idk if you've found the answer already but it's from the SHINee Special Party The Shining 😃
It’s from a VCR that was apart of that Shining concert!
Thank you so much...
As I type this I'm at Jonghyun....that being said no I haven't checked out much of his solo stuffs (it's on my to-do list) but him in that red suit....oh my SHAWol heart can't take much lol
Why is it that o suddenly want to get super invested in SHINee as a group 11 years late????
Wow wow with this video you made me a baby shawol
Right jonghyun all the group talented fore me specially jonghyun
Thank you for this guide, I'm just starting my journey with them, they're amazing.
Can I ask you two things about credits?
1) where did you see Minho has 40 songwriting credits? In the official top 100 list(updated till October 2020) the only member I can find is Jonghyun with 79 and the last of the list has 27 credits... Why Minho isn't there?
2) for the composing credits, is there an official list or you had to count yourself?
Oh and isn't Onew a main vocalist? Just saw it in other guides
Hi. Seeing as there's no reply yet from the creator of this guide, I'll try to answer your queries.
1) I don't know the source of Minho's writing credits cited here but I first learned about it when I was reading Minho's Wikipedia page.
2) Again, as I don't know Korean, I mostly know of the song credits in Wikipedia's discography section where they have tracklistings of each album. Lyricist, composers, and producers are listed there.
The group positions you've seen here were the ones each member had when they debuted. Jonghyun said that there are no main vocals in SHINee. That all of them are vocalists. Also, Onew confirmed this in a recent SBS special interview that they have gone beyond this as each member sings main or lead vocal interchangeably in a given song. In addition, in a translated tweet, an Amazing Saturday cast, described SHINee members as brainiacs. That's a fact. Each of them have a Masteral Degree under their name.
I hope that I've helped you in a small way by replying to your comment. Have a nice day :)
@@ophirelda3368
Thank you very much for your reply!
1) still I don't understand why Minho isn't in the official list, if he has 40 credits he deserves to be there. Even if he only wrote his rap parts, because I know for sure that some on the list are credited just for that and not for the entire songs.
2) I always watch the credits there too but I hoped there would be an official composition list as well since it would have been easier to know everyone's number of credits
But I thought Taemin was just a vocalist when they debuted and the video says lead vocal.
Anyway SHINee is a very talented group in terms of vocals(well not just that, but we are talking about that) so I get it's difficult to put the main, lead and sub labels on them and also it's smart and right(to me) that members sings more or less in function of how much they fit one song. It's just that I'm so used to learn the position subdivision that I expect it for all the groups.
@@MorePara8 You're welcome :)
1) Yes he deserves to be in the list. I wouldn't have known if I didn't read his Wikipedia page.
2) Well I hope so too. I really wish there's also an official list of what each member contributed to the song or album aside from lyrics and music composition, like if they participated in developing the concept, creating the choreography or designing the outfits in the promotional teasers and MVs, and also MV editing and directing like Taemin did with his Criminal MV.
Taemin debuted as the main dancer. He didn't even have solo lines in Replay cause his voice was so underdeveloped during that time. Taemin said in an interview that he didn't want to debut because he felt so unprepared and he thought he will be debuting with trainees the same age. He gradually became a lead vocal and then main vocal. Until Taemin dragged me into Kpop (Lol) I didn't even know about this positions in a group. But I'm so glad it doesn't really apply to SHINee cause all of them are all-rounders.
@@ophirelda3368
1) I don't understand how an official list can make such a mistake...
2) I totally agree, it would be so interesting and it would give the members every credit they have. Also I think just one credits subdivision should be chosen for everybody because somebody have lyrics/music/producer and some others have lyrics/composer/arrangement. They should be more clear.
Yeah I noticed he had barely any line that's why I don't get why the video says "lead vocal" if it's meant to be the debut position.
Anyway Taemin had really an incredible development as a vocalist, we can hear his improvement throughout SHINee's discography and also have his solo activity and his presence in Super M as a confirmation of what he has accomplished.
@@MorePara8
1) Maybe a more accurate list exist that we don't know about cause it wasn't translated into English?
2) I agree. It would make everything much clearer for us who are interested to know these stuffs. I just learned a lot through other Shawol's comments who have been fans since the beginning and have witnessed everything. One example is the fact that Taemin is the one responsible for his song Press Your Number to have an electric guitar in the music.
Yes. Also, a Shawol who frequently watched his solo concerts have commented of how much Taemin improved, in the sense that he sounded so much better live. And that comment was in 2019. Imagine his improvement now? One thing about Taemin is that he really has superb musicality. Each of his moves has a meaning to it. The reason why I think his dancing is so unique. He doesn't just go off with strong, sharp movements all the time. He goes into character and embodies the song.
Could you tell me the name of the song at 18:03 ? I’m baby JP shawol. Thank you.
Jonghyun 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Tnx for video👍👍👍👍👍
Omg when they debuted I am only 3 yrs old
idk how to feel about you not mentioning jjong's passing...on one hand it has its pros because people often tend to reduce his entire life and legacy to his death which is incredibly ignorant but on the other you'd expect a detailed guide to a band note that one of the members hasn't been around for years
April 30, 2022
What is the song at
7:54?
Deja boo
I found the answer from another comment. Thank you to that person.
Please put the song titles up or link the videos if you ever make other videos. It's not easy to find the songs they're singing and a big thank you to the people who do help out by telling people who ask " what song is (fill in time stamp)? " because it's difficult sometimes to find the exact song because I always try finding the same music video and sometimes I can't find the same one for the life of me.
MINHO 💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋
Me is new fan. Can someone tell me Onew's song in 1:26?
Es que debutó bien nene mi Taeminie
Hiiii👋🏿
Como faz pra ve eles reagindo ele mesmo
❤❤
Song at 6:55 ??? Someone plz tell me the title!
why am i watching this im a shawol already dfdfs
OMG WHATS THE NAME OF THE SONG AT 12:03
Can anyone tell me what the songs at 21:07 and the end of the video are? :) ty!
Love-taemin
Omg what is that guitar song Minho is singing solo?? 😍 I need to know 😭😭
Honesty by Shinee
not me watching this after being a shawol for 8 years and knowing everything about them
What song is 6:57 ?
help whats the song called for minho's first clip ? with the guitar ? ty
Shinee - Honesty
2:37 what is the song I don't remember
new shawol
Welcome to shinee world💎🤝
@@ciaralam6661 thank you
Jinki also act In Some series
1:21 can someone tell me the name of the song or what performance is it?
It's "Rainy Blue". Onew covered and performed it on their first Tokyo Dome concert. You can watch his full performance here : czcams.com/video/TmuC_gxum5Y/video.html
I just learned that Onew is just 3 days older than me lol....