Gaza Besieged, Jews Divided, & a World in Pain: Gabor, Aaron, & Daniel Maté in Conversation
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 02. 2024
- Gabor Maté and sons Aaron and Daniel got together in Vancouver BC to discuss what's happening in Gaza, Israel, and the worldwide Jewish community.
- Zábava
I am an anti-zionist Jew. Born and raised in Israel. I left to Australia when I was 18 with some family members. I stand with Palestine. I refuse to support the state of Israel. Dr Gabor is a voice of reason and wisdom. Thank you for turning this into a discussion of humanity.
Wish we have many people like you
Beautiful Human you are. God bless
I am curious, what does being a Jew mean to you? I’ll bet it means something very different from what most Jews identify as.
As a Palestinian I can’t thank the Mate family enough. The anti-Zionist Jews are giving us life right now.
So you’re not one of the many that support what Hamas did on Oct7? What do you think of those that do?
❤️❤️❤️
Mr. Fuller, as mentioned in the discussion here you should consider ALL facts, not only yours. Gaza suffers siege and blockade since 2 decades. What do you think of that?@@BabaBabelOm
@@BabaBabelOmDo you support 75 years and more of the occupation and torture that Israel did to the Palestinians. YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT OCTOBER 7 PALESTINIANS SUFFERED THAT 24/7.
Ludicrous, irrelevant question. You've clearly not understood a word that these men have said.
I am a Norwegian living in Berlin. I am not jewish and i am not Palestinian, but my heart is burning seeing the unjust being done toward the Palestinian people. I appreciate the sanity that the Mate family is displaying and I am shocked over the insanity that has riddled in the Israeli population
I was raised a Protestant Christian. My father became aware of Zionism during a brief stay in Israel/Palestine in the mid-1970s. He was a librarian and worked at a theological institute in the West Bank. He needed to transport boxes and enlisted the help of a Palestinian man who worked at the institute. He was graciously invited to meet the man's family, Christians who trace their Catholicism back to the crusades. In subsequent years, my father returned numerous times at Easter to visit his Palestinian friends including once with me. My father passed on his anti-Zionism to me.
Z!onism = Naz!sm
Beautiful to read
@@thinkbeforeyoutype7106
Antisemitic speech is hate speech.
Hate speech is in violation of community guidelines.
It’s also an ad hominem.
It’s a teenage way to approach a complex issue.
It would be like me saying,
Black Nationalism = Nazism… but not knowing anything about the history of Black Nationalism, other than watching a tv show trashing Black Nationalism.
@@thinkbeforeyoutype7106 noizism?
@@aaronfarkas6890do you know if this person supports black nationalism? If so, how do you know?
As a Muslim woman who studied trauma therapy, Gabor is one of my heroes and mentors. What an amazing human being. Thankyou.
SALaM, SHLAMa, SHLOMo, SHALoM, NAMASTe, PEACe.
The Israeli Knesset Needs Righteous Jews, Like Mate Gabor In Their Government, Whom Are Versed In The Ethics Of Torah [Old Testament].
I agree. An amazing human being.
Those wonderful human characteristics attributed to the Palestinians, is also present in religious Jews. The early Zionist members who suffered at the hands of the Nazi's wanted to change those decent characteristics in their fellow religious jews. They criticized them, calling them weak, and constantly turning the other cheek. What they wanted, was to build a new type of jew. A jew which mirrored the savage characteristics which they saw in the vicious,merciless, cruel Nazi's. From what we have seen in recent months, it appears they were successful.
Islam o fascists love this shill. Great way for the Islamiists to steer the conversation away from the 41 Islamist supremacist Apartheid nations that oppress Women, Gays, Christians, Jews and minorities.
@@den264 These Jews would have fought the Nazis. Gabor ‘s parents and mine might have lived.
You want Jews who do not resist those who seek their destruction. The Arab leaders who lived in the British Mandate cooperated with Hitler.
Thank you Maté family. You have integrity and you stand for justice. We must not be silent while witnessing injustice.
Hari Om! 💐
@@nyngal0770 Namaste 🙏
@@PerceivedREALITY999 namaste!
ΜΕΤΑΦΡΑΣΗ ΕΛΛΗΝΙΚΑ
hearhear
Thank you from the bottom of my heart. I am Jewish, and to hear you three express these truths is so comforting, it is so clear to me as well that what is happening is a disaster for both Palestinians and for Jews. May we all regain our humanity.
czcams.com/video/ti2lsdtlKoQ/video.htmlsi=NykmSvjou5s6fF_q
czcams.com/users/shortstcSCEXP3BDw?si=hkk9bGQGiUgOBBGE
Me too. Thank you for your words!
I would hope Gabor can do a deep dive into modern history and it's hidden aspects so he can reach that next level of growth he is so close to.
@@mral4381 ... is that a snotty way of saying "Forget the actual women and children and innocents being slaughtered. There is s much bigger political picture." ???
Perhaps you are the one who needs to do the 'deep dive'...?
What a great man You are Dr Mate, As an Iranian (who does not back any politicians), I send love & respect to you and the people with such deep thinking and moral values.
A shout out to Rae Maté, Gabor's wife and mother of Daniel & Aaron!! It is no accident that these men are extraordinary!!! 👏🏽🙌🏽👏🏽🙌🏽👏🏽🙌🏽
15 minutes in and all I was thinking about wow, what a great mother has to be behind these men ❤
Indeed! Absolutely. 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
Spot on ❤❤❤
@@dandounmshaikh
We stand with Israel!!
@@mayamichelle6741
We stand with Israel!!
My housband is palestinian, i am german. Listen to you three brings tears in our eys. May freedom come to the palestinian. Thank you❤❤❤❤❤❤
❤🤗
@@jonathansamuel7033You have much in common with one of them. Germany committed a genocide against the European Jewish people and now Israel is committing its genocide against the indigenous Palestinian people. Like peas in a pod 😉
Better than you@@jonathansamuel7033
@@jonathansamuel7033ignoramus
Max Blumenthal said the Palestinian people are the indirect victims of the Holocaust. Food for German/Western thought
As an American Palestinian . I have utter respect and love to you all . I was recently on a zoom meeting with Gabor and Daniel . I’ve been following “ dad “ Gabor and now I’m introduced to his wonderful sons . Hats off for you all for being so humanistic and standing up for the oppressed . 🙏🏼❤️🩹
czcams.com/video/ti2lsdtlKoQ/video.htmlsi=NykmSvjou5s6fF_q
@rulabibi
“…you all being so humanistic and standing up for the oppressed”
I disagree.
If they were so humanistic why don’t they stand up for their own Jewish brothers and sisters, the innocent Israeli/Jewish civilian hostages?
Furthermore, why haven’t any of your American Palestinian organizations in USA condemned the massacres of 10/7?
@@aaronfarkas6890 Stop oppressing Palestinians! Asking them to condemn O7 is essentially asking them to legitimize the occupation. While sad and unfortunate, it does not take a genius to realize that living in a Kibbutz you are being hired as a human shield for the expected pushback by the people who have been ethnically cleansed. You cannot blame the oppressed for pushing against their oppressors whether military or civilians, and in this case whatever H did pales in comparison to what have been done to them, their families and their people.
♡You are free to disagree♡
Please receive my unconditiomal love and acceptance of your human right to choose
Wars everywhere all over this beautiful earth we call home are generated by private business interests that lead to massive profit for a few
The result is incomprehensible suffering for many
Innocents
May we all be free
@@aaronfarkas6890 No one comes at a people out of the blue with hatred and barbarism. It is a people that have been oppressed and oppressed and oppressed and, finally, in utter desperation, do desperate things. I DO NOT defend the attacks. Let me be VERY clear. They ARE heinous. But I am a Jew, a THINKING Jew, and I say to you; "Look for CAUSE."
1. Haifa Massacre 1937 2. Jerusalem Massacre 1937 3. Haifa Massacre 1938 4. Balad al-Sheikh Massacre 1939 5. Haifa Massacre 1939 6. Haifa Massacre 1947 7. Abbasiya Massacre 1947 8. Al-Khisas Massacre 1947 9. Bab al-Amud Massacre 1947 10. Jerusalem Massacre 1947 11. Sheikh Bureik Massacre 1947 12. Jaffa Massacre 1948 13. Deir Yassin Massacre - 1948 14. Qibya massacre -1953 15.Tantura Massacre - 1948 16. qibya massacre -1953 17. Khan Yunis Massacre 1956 18. Jerusalem Massacre 1967 19. Bahro Al Baquar in 1972 20. Sabra and Shatila Massacre 1982 21. Al-Aqsa Massacre 1990 22. Ibrahimi Mosque Massacre 1994 23. Jenin Refugee Camp April 2002 24. Gaza Massacre 2008-09 25. Gaza Massacre 2012 26. Gaza Massacre 2014 27. Gaza Massacre 2018-19 28. Gaza Massacre 2021
29. Gaza Genocide 2023 ... and still ongoing.
... any questions?
PS: your family dynamic is so inspiring. Unusual to see a father sit with his children and not speak over them, but listen and learn. Beautiful!
YES! Modeling by example
He learned that the hard way.. now they made it, good for them.
One of the most important conversations recorded to date. Grateful to the amazing Máté family. I’m Palestinian and I just want to sit and have dinner with all of you. Please please don’t stop spreading your important message. It has a deep impact coming from an entire family of strong, confident empathetic Jewish men. ❤️🕊️💚
Well said ❤
Respect & admiration to Gabor, Aaron & Daniel... love centered truth tellers.
💯💯💯
So what is the solution ?
One state without apartheid@@suejones830
Love this expression! I was thinking compassionate truth tellers, because they are so non-judgmental, same thing! ❤️
@@suejones830 the solution is for Israel to end the occupation.
Excellent discussion. I base my Jewish identity on humanism, drawn from the Haskala. The Palestinians are our siblings who deserve their land. We need to support them. Thank you!
As a Pakistani, I am a big fan of Aaron Matte representing real journalism in this age of deception, now that i know the whole family represent true Jewish values, i may say Dr Gabor and Mrs. Matte have raised real human beings. Very proud to be accociated with you all. Thankyou.
Aaron Matte is indeed a truly remarkable journalist
A Godsend in our benighted world
His investigative reports with Max Blumenthal are utterly compelling, courageous and irrefutably truthful
🙏🏼🕯🕯🙏🏼
Paris
Wonderful family! With love to you from Russia, and to all Palestinians and peace seeking Jews.
And are you a peace seeking Russian where Ukraine is concerned?
@@halifaxehI can't speak in his name but I believe he doesn't want to see the civilians of Donetsk being shelled like the Ukrainian extremist have been doing for the past 9 years.
I think you know the war started in 2014 when Ukrainian extremists and nationalists attacked the Donbass.
The last week Russia and DPR militias routed out Ukrainian military from Avdeyevka so that they can not shell civilians. One or two days later they shot HIMARS missiles into Donetsk as a "revenge", killing a woman and wounding many.
This one and the previous many were intentional. Russia might have killed civilians but never intentionally. Since the war is raging on the territory of the Donbass for two years and the majority is either Russian speaking or ethnic Russian, you may understand why.
Look up the Wikipedia page on the 2010 elections and you will see. Provided you want to open your eyes and mind.
to all Jews*
@@mariamoooooo not the genocidaires. If you’re a peaceseeking Jew, you should have no problem with what they wrote.
@@halifaxeh Are you confusing people with their governments? I found your comment rude.
I watch Aaron on the Gray Zone and I have listened to Dr Gabor independently. I never knew they were father and son. Allhumdulilah (all praise is to Allah) the apples have not fallen far from the tree. Thank you gentleman. 🤲🏽
Me too. I was so pleased to find out that Aaron is Gabor's son. From what I've found Daniel is also a brilliant and kind human being. There is also a daughter, I'm sure she is also in the same league!
Me 3! Ameen
Amazing family, to stand for humanity even though they may face danger.
And Rae Maté seems to be a lovely human being too, as well as a talented artist.
I have always wondered, but I just found out today and it’s so beautiful. He raised them right ❤❤
A fine example of a good kind man who raised his children properly and tought them to think.
Hey Harun!! I just discovered you with Max. My God!! I been watching you and Katie, I guess I'm a fan now.
Dr Mate, if I could afford it, I need a real Psychiatrist instead of these Pharmaceutical Industry Compliance Officers they give us. I was diagnosed schizophrenic by a real Psychiatrist, who had a practice in the 70s. She had a little writing desk in the rear of her spacious temple, and I got to sit on a couch!! I studied Foucault in College, but in the Philosophy Dept and only when they published the compete History of Madness did I begin to understand.
Daniel, this family feeling is NOT NORMAL, I'm sure I will be reading your s*** soon enough. Give my best to your Mom.
@@thomassciaroni6942
Gabor is a gentle soul.
Too bad, he’s wrong about Israel.
We Stand with Israel!!
Yes’- taught his lids how’ to think!!!!!! Imperative!
GOD bless the Matés, the righteous, the truth teller and those who unconditionally serve humanity
Gabor is a gentle soul. Thanks for your service to humanity. I listen to you all the time to understand my own life and get perspectives on the pain and trauma
Me too! He has helped me understand so much about myself and my family’s intergenerational trauma from England’s atrocities in Ireland! Such a blessing to humanity!
@@halifaxeh
St. Gabor is a gentle soul.
Too bad He’s wrong about Israel
We Stand with Israel!!
@@aaronfarkas6890 too bad you have no clue what you’re talking about
@@halifaxeh
Glad to hear that Gabor helped you to understand your family’s inter generational trauma.
With respect, what specifically do I “have no clue what you’re talking about?”
Giving a specific example would help 🙏.
@@aaronfarkas6890 the part where you think he has no idea about Israel. You feel free to start with specific examples with reputable sources to refute what Gabor says and then I’ll feel free to give you some examples.
Excellent, I would not expect anything less from Dr. Gabor and the two fine sons he raised. I wish their sister was there too, may God Bless their family for all they do.
@@Loulu866I guess they are all "holy water" to your demonic soul... So, yeah your sentiments are understandable. You don't want to be vaporized!
@@Loulu866maybe you could listen once more, but with your heart. There is no hatred here, only compassion, for both sides.
@@Loulu866 Trauma response.
Truth hurts🤔@@Loulu866
@@Loulu866They are the ones who would not harm you.
Im so grateful for this conversation. Im a heartbroken Jew with family in Israel, its been confusing and awful.
That has to be difficult in so many ways. Big love to you.❤
You bring integrity and humanity to this discussion. I am thankful for all of you and a supporter of Aron‘s journalism.
As a South African that lived under Apartheid, I only have admiration for you Doc and your sons, especially Aaron. Keep up the good work gents..
Then you should know what the characteristics of apartheid were in SA.
I'm sure he sees that they are deeply set into Israeli society at present.
"Yes, Israel did sell arms to the apartheid South African government during the 1980s, despite international sanctions and a UN arms embargo imposed on South Africa due to its apartheid policies. This arms trade between Israel and South Africa was controversial and widely criticized by the international community.Israel and South Africa had a history of military and technological cooperation dating back to the 1960s. This collaboration included the exchange of military technology, joint weapons development, and the sale of arms. Israel was one of the few countries willing to provide South Africa with military assistance during its international isolation.This relationship between Israel and South Africa was a source of tension with many other nations that supported sanctions against the apartheid regime. The United Nations passed several resolutions and imposed an arms embargo on South Africa to pressure it to end apartheid and racial segregation. Israel's arms sales to South Africa, in violation of these sanctions, were viewed by many as undermining the international community's efforts to end apartheid.It's important to note that the relationship between Israel and South Africa during this period was a complex and controversial issue. Israel's government argued that the arms sales were not in violation of the sanctions and were aimed at promoting its national security interests. However, the arms trade between the two countries did draw significant criticism from various quarters and remains a subject of historical debate."
chat.openai.com/share/402308e9-5df8-462d-9c0b-7e478020246e
You bought your own false narrative lock stock and barrel.
czcams.com/video/ti2lsdtlKoQ/video.htmlsi=NykmSvjou5s6fF_q
I’m Muslim and my best friend is Jewish. I hadn’t spoken to him about Israel cause I thought we would be on opposite sides and I valued his friendship. He called me on 10/7 and I was highly surprised to hear he has the same attitude and feelings as these gentlemen!
He was the one who sent me this
Dr. Gabor you did such a wonderful job with these conscious young men, your sons. You should be so very proud.
The world would much better place with people like yourselves. As a muslim I have immense respect for you
You brought tears to my eyes as a Palestinian American. What an extraordinary father, who brought up extraordinary sons. You give me hope for humanity, and I appreciate you for taking the time to create this video. Thank you from the bottom of my heart.
brave indeed !
Am from the southern part of Africa and for the past few months I have been watching the videos of Dr Gabor Mate.I love them to bits.I have the greatest respect for this upright man and his sons.Palestine will be free one day.
Bless u descendant of shuudaa❤❤❤ and every Palestinian in every corner of the earth
@@joegibsonzulu2599
“Palestine will be free one day”
Please define, “free”
Free of Jews?
Ethnic cleansing of Jews?
What kind of government are you referring to?
One State, or two state solution?
@@joegibsonzulu2599
Israel will be free one day.
Evil cannot hide its true identify forever. Israel has shown its true colors. Condemning Israeli war crimes is not antisemitic.
You clearly haven't read Hamas Charter, have you !
@@paulamarsh1 Which one? Have you?
@@paulamarsh1 cope harder, bot
@@paulamarsh1 and you haven’t read the Zionist mandate. It’s to rid the country of ALL but Jews. And that idea started in the late 1800’s.
I heard from an ex-IDF soldier. He said Israelis are told Arabs will be their slaves. Is that what they are taught?
@@paulamarsh1 Hamas is to Israel as ISIS is to US ...let's talk about it ....
I can’t tell how refreshing and uplifting it was to hear your views on what is and has been happening in Israel and Gaza! Finally some sane and realistic viewpoints. My soul feels better for having listened to this podcast.
Syria, Lebanon, and Palestine whole heartedly received Armenian refugees escaping genocide in 1915. They lived in those countries in peace, and became a part of the mixed and rich fabric of the region. They contributed and enriched the culture of the region, to the arts and to industry. They maintained their faith, their language, and culture. They intermarried and thrived in peace.
Before Israel all the inhabitants of this ancient part of the world with all its different ethnic groups and all their different faiths including Jews lived in peace.
Just a historical note for Israelis to dwell on and think of what they have done to the Palestinians.
Yes, indeed! They lived in Peace and harmony until the civilized world decided to send their surrogates to destroy the region, which had been prosperous and self-sufficient for centuries! 🙏 🙏 🙏 Peace in the region!
I love this "family" conversation. I am not Jewish, Arab, Israeli or Palestinian but am outraged by the whole situation in the middle East and not just since Oct. 7th.
Me as well.
It seems to me that this conversation is a big part of the path to peace.
Same here.
Hope G@/ G@d@t sees this and learns to realise ???
At 6:50, Dr. Gabor Mate summed up the situation perfectly. " In the effort of the Jewish people to escape a nightmare, they ended up imposing another nightmare on another group of people." This man is a true hero and gem for mankind..
i think its worse than that, they have made ptsd a social characteristic, and they seem to have been doing that for a long time. the 4 holidays dr mate mentioned seem like a weird kind of child abuse from the outside, merry '' everybody hates us and kills us day'' times a year is gonna skew a persons self view and view of others. so the escape from the nighmare, isnt just imposing a nightmare on others, its kinda guaranteeing a new nightmare, '' everybody hates us and wants to kill us'' giving rise to '' what the hell theyre all gonna hate us anyway, so lets go beserk on them'' i've been tryin to build a case for the claim that zionism is thee worst thing thats ever happened to the jews, and hoping it makes it more of a phenomena imposed on them as oppsed to something they did. there is of course the fairytale version of zionism which is a beautiful story, an oppressed people going back to their homeland and building a safe paradise, and i honestly believe if zionism hadnt insisted on an ethnically pure state for jews, this paradise could have happened.
what about hamas burning babies alive
The thing that is interesting about Gabor is how selective his history is.
He talks about how the Vietnam war changed his perspective.
How he saw Americans massacring Asian people.
What happened after America left? Massacres. Mass famine. All brought on by the governing powers.
These morons prefer "self-determination" even if it means horrible oppression. Just look at how Vietnam treats its indigenous tribes today - as tourist attractions who must be preserved for $$$.
These idiots are very well meaning, but they happily will doom half of the planet to greedy tyrants.
Except that the Jews who escaped the nightmare of Europe in the 1930s and 1940s, who managed to survive the Nazi annihilation project, were treated like dirt, mocked and derided in the newly formed Israel of the late 1940s and 1950s.
Just one question: didany of you watch thé vidéo taken by Hamas on October 7 ? If not, please do so and then come back with your comments.
Thank you so much, Dr. Mate, Aaron and Daniel.
Thank you, the gentle Maté trio, for your love and generous humanity, ❤
Thank-you for acknowledging my pain being Jewish and in shock and dismay over treatment of Palestinians. My views have caused conflict with family and a sense of deep loneliness.
"On n'a pas tous la chance de naître orphelin."
Henri Laborit
🫀🇨🇵⚘
Sad to say, in the big picture, the deligitimizing policies being pursued by the state of israel is throwing "its own people" under a moving bus, and itll moatly be people admiring the shiny black of the wheel on their way out.
It is what it is. I am deeply disappointed too.
I am from Northern Ireland ,. My father Brendan Duddy is known as the Secret Peacemaker ( BBC documentary by renowned journalist Peter Taylor) we suffered awful atrocities for hundreds of years . The impact of the trauma is immeasurable. He was a consultant for the Tavistock Institute and worked regularly in Israel with many many great people . He went to Palestine to talk to people which was his form . I feel so sad that Ireland is such an example to the whole world and we know although not perfect there can be peace .Shauna Duddy ❤
❤
🇵🇸❤️🇮🇪
❤
By engaging in a protracted and violent conflict with Palestine, Israel creates a situation in which there is a present and continued threat to life and safety, a threat that is clearly external and concrete. The internal experience of annihilation anxiety is made manifest, and thus can be contended with, controlled, literally combated. One could also argue the related point that Israel’s military and occupation policies serve to create international distrust toward the state of Israel which then becomes--and is interpreted as--anti-Semitism, further concretizing the external threat. Loewenberg illustrates the fact that the state of Israel is a psychotic state, founded on trauma and repeating its trauma and projecting its trauma in a Freudian repetition compulsion on a scale so large and deadly it resists comprehension. " p90 Jewish annihilation anxiety : diasporic legacies of trauma Alexandra T. Samets Smith College (2015)
Thank you.
I was speechless watching this discussion. It was impartial, honest, and factual in solely keeping to the retelling of historical accounts and events that actually took place and spoke unbiasedly to the need to preserve the basic rights and humanity of all people. I applaud Mr. Gabor and his sons for having the courage to stand on the side of Humanity and Truth. Thank you for holding this discussion.
Justice and Freedom for ALL
Stop Genocide
Stop Occupation
لك لايك بس خايفين من الحظر ❤😂
As a human and Palestinian from Gaza, I cannot thank you enough Dr. Gabor. You give us the hope
Do you support Hamas? And what do you think about releasing the hostages? 🤔
@@CM3Dave
Of course he does.
That’s why he won’t answer your question.
@@CM3DaveDo you support genocide? What do you think about innocent children being mass murdered everyday? 🤔
@@aaronfarkas6890could be many reasons: maybe the electricity has been cut off, no internet to reply or perhaps because unlike you Troll he’s surrounded by lots of dead bodies and just trying to survive the best he can in these dire circumstances. Clearly this conversation was too intelligent for you to look past your own bias and ever put yourself in someone else shoes because to you there just the other. All who support what IDF/Israel are doing also have blood on their hands because you choose to support genocidal manic Zionist government. Peace to the real Jews like Dr Matè and his family all all the Jews all over the world who are standing in solidarity with the Palestinian people (Not Hamas) and the Truth! Which you wouldn’t know it even if hit you on the head.
@@CM3Daveit’s incredible how many people bring this up when pleading for freedom for the Palestinians people. Maybe you should ask people whether they support the extremists running the Israeli government.
I was horrified when a Jewish friend told me told me that Palestinians were not a people, that there was no such thing as Palestine or Palestinians, that they had no right to any land, and had no right to exist. When pressed, she confessed that she wanted them wiped out, that they had to be exterminated because they weren’t human. She also demanded that I stand with Israel in all things, which I wouldn’t do. And she’s never changed her mind. Before this war started, she initiated contact with me again. I asked if she’d changed her mind. She hadn’t. It’s heartbreaking. I know that the friend I love is still in there somewhere.
You know she actually is there and I also know beautiful and super loving Israeli Jews who absolutely speak with absolute contempt for all ARABS. ALL our sins take away our wholeness, our logic, our compassion and our capacity to heal. Listen to this conversation several times and allow the possibility for your mind and heart to feel the divits of their needs for approval, acceptance, support and their capacity to reconnect and heal. Consider reaching out to her and maybe some others to listen to this....The very act of our presence with this maybe an act of loving connection.
X I O N I S M eats up the core of the soul, leaving a fragile thin shell behind.
Still miracles happen.
Give your friend enough space. Sometimes affective space takes, weeks, months or years.
Don't think you lost a friend. Your friendship will be back, once her conscience is revived. Pray for her, and silently wish her well🙏
Repeating a conversation, despite knowing its result is frustrating, and might not allow your friend to reach the right conclusion.
You are important to her changing her mind without saying much and any other anti-Zionist person in their lives they will need to talk to. Challenges should be towards how much due diligence they are doing to understand the opposition's perspective including meeting them.
I have to disagree with you and tell you that whoever wishws a whole population ro be wiped out is simply pure evil
Antisemitism is a crime. Antizionism is a duty.
Gabor maté, you are a shining light💥
And it reminds me of this great Jewish spirit, which I adore so much.
Thank you from Australia (land never ceded) this anti-zionist, anti-colonialist Jew.
I stand now and always with the Palestinian people. Love and solidarity ❤️🗝🇵🇸✊
❤
✊🏻Australia! Indigenous peoples! ✊🏻
❤️
@@R.IAmEnough yes, you are. More than enough, because you are able to see injustice and speak up against it. Because you are not ok with people abusing others, even though they were abused before. You are not looking for turning the tables, but justice for all. You are also can appreciate to see this in others. Others who want to sit at the same table, not just looking to turning it.
I am also an Australian anti zionist jew and its great to know Im not alone
Maté family are extremely inspiring. All Jewish Canadians should watch and listen to this video
LOL. millions of Muslims lives in Israel and some even serve in the military.
Jewish people everywhere should watch this. All people everywhere should watch it.
The woman in the movie 'wonder woman' should see this.
@@GARRY3754
We Stand with Israel!!
@@halifaxeh
We Stand with Israel!!
Dr. Maté, I am such a grateful person of your work. I later discovered Aaron's work. Today, I discover Daniel. You guys are simply amazing. Turning pain to love and compassion. Insisting on Truth, be it inconvenient or not. Much respect and admiration from Paris.
Daniel is a masterful musician.
Thank you for a most enjoyable and reflective conversation. As a Palestinian American, I needed this therapeutic break during the ongoing mayhem. A fine dad who raised an equally fine sons
Respect. A dignified Jewish family, and honest. Thank you for understanding what it takes to be humane. Thank you for raising your children equally.
This family makes me feel less ashamed to be Canadian, their presence gives me hope that our future won't look like our past
Thank you for this comment. I am watching the Canadian government from thousands of miles away, having retired somewhere completely different. But it's still uplifting to listen to people like the Mates USA.
Really? How are the Canadians treating their indigenous? When your country is clean come and tell others how to live
@@yaelbrisker They said *less ashamed* . Is that not humble enough for you? If it isn't, then I think you nee to take a look at yourself instead of condemning others.
What good does shame do, to people who usually haven't anything? It does no.good. The people who should be ashamed of themselves, aren't, sadly. We don't need more people who are ashamed of themselves, we need regulated people who can help and stand up against injustice. Much more helpful.
@@yaelbrisker literally my point, I guess you're not familiar with gabor's work in the indigenous communities....
My deep respect and love and appreciation to this beautiful family.
Dr Gabor Maté
Some of what you said about trauma helped me. I managed to identify, externalise and over 7 days let it go
So big respect 👍😉
As a moslem from middle east i would say i always loved DR gabor Mate and ARON ,i did not know about Daniel which i am happy to know ,love you all three and may be healthy and long live .respectfully .
Dr Gabor Mate must be a proud father to have his two sons become, like himself, such evolved, and compassionate human beings. Needless to add, both Gandhi and Mandela would have rejoiced to see all three of them upholding their beliefs in humanity, truth, and non-violence ❤
💯
Such great men, thank you for your soul searching words. Powerfully brave
Thank you Dr. Maté and sons from a 1956 Hungarian refugee from Budapest; who grew up and raised family in CT. It was tough for my parents and those living in Hungary, First Germany occupied our country and then Russia. My dad was taken by both sides being a radio man. Nothing what it seems I learned but we are one spiritually and need to support each other in love. Love even our enemies. Love you all.
Seven minutes in and a peace is settling, a weight lifting, your words are so soothing.
Your words come from your hearts. You speak with deep sorrow - for yourselves and your people, but more importantly for the people who are suffering under siege in 2024, and they soothe those of us who are neither Jewish nor Palestinians, nor Arab but have had distress thrust upon us, and watch helplessly.
Thank you for handling the subject with such deep respect, and not speaking up just to seperate yourselves from those being looked upon as evil by the rest of the world.
May God bless and protect all of you, and count your efforts worthy in judgement.
So well put. I agree with you 💯
I also agree - it is the absence of any aggression or hostility that makes you really want to listen to this conversation. Very calming.😌
@@valtracey6180 yes, very calming.
@@Lalallalu 🙏🏽♥️
Thank you.
Very humble men, so honest and caring! They know what is really going on and what has gone on for the past 80 years! And they go out of their way to spread their knowledge and their humanity! God Bless the Mate’ family!
Moral indignation expressed calmly, as a feigned moral superiority, isn’t humility…. Honest… caring? For? This is ideological capture and ahistorical indifference …
Gabor looks like someone who was tortured and made to say what he does.
What lacks humility and caring here is your statement. @justinfuller5912
@@BabaBabelOm Gabor asks us to look at history. And its a question of acknowledging and attempting to understand the reality of what took us to this place now.
@@BabaBabelOmreality hurts 🤕🤕
Wow, such insight, beautifully expressed. God bless you. Freedom and justice for Palestine and peace to all.
Thank you all for your courage and work to spread the Truth and Justice against racism, ignorance and Zionism
I was born in Palestine 1945 l agree with all of you You all are blessed keep aware straggle especially our Gabor. M J
I didn't realize that Aaron was Gabor's son. Makes sense now where he gets his moral courage. Hearing your thoughts coming for a Jewish family is really important, thank you to all of you for doing this.
It’s a revelation! So cool to see the family championing humanity ❤❤
Just realized also and I've been listening to both of them for some time now. But somehow not surprised ❤
Just finished watching. You 3 got me in tears. May Allah give me n my generations to come the strength to be truthful n compassionate like dr. Maté n his sons. Thanks Maté family. Free Palestine!
Three extraordinary, beautiful, thoughtful and powerful men. What a rare sight.
Thank you gentlemen for this wise, informed and humanist talk. To me, it breaks the feeling of isolation not buying in the mainstream narrative(s).
Thank you. This conversation honors the highest virtures of Jewish thought and humanity. We move closer to peace through dialogues like this, based in compassion and love. God bless you.
All backgrounds have high virtues
Yes it does and it respects the suffering of the past. It’s astonishing to me that living descendants of holocaust survivor’s voices are routinely ignored but I’m so glad they are raising their voices and for people like you, calling for peace and compassion ☮️ ✡️ ☪️
yes it does. our values are humanist, we yearn for justice for Palestine and Palestine's emancipation from oppression.
And that’s the difference between good Jews & Zionist Jews-
@@mehyaraus
“Descendants of Holocaust survivors voices are routinely ignored”
Not sure what you mean by that, as there are organizations that support the needs of second generation Holocaust survivors.
I’m a descendant of a Holocaust survivor... I also know many other descendants of Holocaust survivors.
Among us descendants, the views of St. Gabor and his two Apostle sons, are not representative of mainstream Second Generation Holocaust survivors.
St. Gabor’s voice is one of the very very very few similar second generation Holocaust survivor anti-Israel voices.
On a personal level, calling Israeli behavior as “genocidal”, is deliberately provocative, intellectually dishonest and antisemitic.
The US House of Representatives, the European Union, Bahrain and the UAE reject charges of genocide brought by SA.
As a Metis elder I have long admired the work of Dr. Mate and his work on generational trauma. Now I’m thrilled to be following the work of his brilliant sons, Aaron and Daniel. I understand the generational trauma of the Jewish people. It’s truly heartbreaking. But I’m completely devastated that the Palestinian people have been for over 100 years until this very second experiencing trauma that will last for generations to come. Thank you for this meaningful and important conversation. My respect and love to you. Praying for peace in Palestine from Winnipeg 🙏
When did the term “Palestinian” begin? Wasn’t it Arafat around 1967?
British mandatory Palestine wasn’t “Palestinian” and Palestine was a epithet to describe the JEWISH nation 2000 years ago.
Prove me wrong.
There is (or was, may be removed) a video on YT showing Golda Meir admitting that she´s a Palestinian and that she had a Palestenian Passaport. Prove me wrong!@@BabaBabelOm
@@BabaBabelOmso the land was empty?
@@BabaBabelOmJesus walk on Palestine not Israel under Roman occupation. Israel was divided into two nations.
May God grant prosperity and strength to your great people.
I can't even begin to describe how much I admire all three of you for speaking about this against all the pressures around you. THANK YOU SO MUCH for speaking the truth. God bless you.
Dear Dr. Mate and esteemed sons,
I wanted to express my sincere gratitude for your courageous advocacy on behalf of the oppressed. Your voices, steeped in education and empathy, serve as a guiding light in these tumultuous times. Your unwavering commitment to spreading awareness and encouraging empathy is both commendable and inspiring. Dr. Mate, your personal journey, from being a Ziyonist to rewiring your thinking through empathy and firsthand experience, is a testament to the power of compassion and understanding. Your willingness to share your transformation is not only brave but essential in fostering meaningful dialogue and change. I deeply appreciate your dedication to sharing the complexities of your experiences, including the challenges and triumphs. In a world saturated with biased narratives and misinformation, your commitment to truth and authenticity is invaluable. Thank you for using your platform and privilege to amplify the voices of the marginalized and advocate for justice. Your efforts are making a tangible difference in shaping a more inclusive and compassionate society.
What a beautiful dialogue between father and sons. I am a Christian living in the US and found this conversation to be very informative.
Gabor one of the wisest men of time and he explains in such a way we can understand. He's very well read also ❤
❤Gabor Mate MD PhD ❤
This family has given me hope as a Palestinian in the diaspora, honestly you have all the right to speak on our behalf because you have been voices of the voiceless in our communities as well as fighting off ignorance and Zionism all at once. Much love and I truly hope you continue for all the innocent lives yet to save in Palestine. Justice for all.
Thank you Gabor, Aaron and Daniel. Very courageous of you to sit down and have a discussion like that. It is giving so much strength and hope to so many people and encourages others to speak up.
This very eye opening… I grew up in Argentina as a Christian Evangelical and we were taught in church to always defend Israel because they were God’s chosen people. I never question that till some of my friends traveled to Palestine… also hear Miko Peled testimony about his life experience as born Israelite.
@@celiafish I travelled to Israel in 2018 , I saw Arabs and Israeli working together I asked what all this about you guys hating each other ? I learn they the Arabs benefited from all of Israels benefits for their people but when there is an uprising they join with those in Gaza , remember Israel gave up Gaza In 2006 for peace , but Hamas used it as a launching pad to shoot rockets at Israel .. money was sent to build bomb shelters , it’s sn every day occurrence! there are two sides of the story. I’m disappointed you had to be told but you listened to lies and you believe the lies . I I blessed to say I read the Bible , I saw how much God loves his people if your friend is a catholic she will believe the lies. I find it a betrayal we have nothing I common with Islam they are the anti Christ so many Christians are persecute because of Islam. Look at Nigeria and Assyria they are murdered by islam, the anti christ won’t be the Jews because God will open their eyes to see him , scripture is very clear they will mourn whom they rejected but remember this because of the Catholic Church persecution in the name of Jesus they struggle to believe but! There are about 50 thousand messianic Jews living i Israel , God will give them a new heart and write his law on their heart he will put his spirit in them , and they will be his people and he will be their God And so all Israel will be saved. Don’t believe the lies that’s demonic. If you want to be curse by God , just say bad things about Israel . You will learn . He will curse those who curse Israel he will bless those who bless Israel . You said you are from
Argentina , your president was in Israel and two Argentinian Israeli hostages was rescued . It was the evil of Hamas , consider the innocent babies burnt alive , some beheaded by Hamas put the babies in hit oven i front of parents. Did you know? And the reason you should support Israel , Jesus is Jewish and he is returning Jewish he is not going to Rome and certainly not to Saudi Arabia , but Jerusalem ! they gave us the Bible all the prophets are Jewish who heard from God and they wrote, theres is the law , In fact as his feet touches the mount of Olives Jerusalem will split. The Bible say to pray for the peace of Jerusalem they may prosper that loved thee .
@@celiafish
Hi - before you criticize something you’ve never experienced - except what you’ve heard from other people, why not visit Israel yourself?
I think you’ll be pleasantly surprised.
Don’t believe the propaganda that St. Gabor and his Apostles are spewing.
His views and the views of his sons, are fringe and on the extreme left.
The USA, European Union, Arab states like Bahrain and the UAE don’t agree with his views in Israel.
Check Israel out for yourself.
Judaism and zionism are two separate entities. Peace to all Israelis and Palestinians 🙏🕊
@perceived your talking about things way above your pay grade. You have no clue about Judaism or Zionism. They are one in the same.
@@mitchl.7276did you even listen? I don’t think so.
@@mitchl.7276
Zionism: a racist ideology based on ethnocracy created by a people looked down on and brutalized by "Aryan" Europeans. It's chief founding members being antisemites themselves (Europeans are not a Semitic people).
Judaism: an age old faith and founder of the Abrahamic faiths.
@@mitchl.7276and you are speaking beyond your education! It is possible to be De-indoctrinated and de-propagandized - if there is a willingness to face the truth.
No, they´re not the same@@mitchl.7276
A most healing and humbling conversation... a true gift to the incredulous bystander.
Deeply grateful, thank you.
What an inspiration you two juniors are - a testament to your father's greatness. Amazing family. Much love to you all.
I have the highest admiration for Dr Gabe and his 2 sons, to speak so openly about this conflict. You are very courageous
Dr. Gabor Mate'
Was featured on democracy now many years ago. Those suffering trauma...are ALWAYS haunted by it. He wrote a book called ... In the Shadow of the Hungry Ghosts. I just recognized Aron Mate as his son.
He was with DN! also.
These are real Jews. Thanks guys
@@ComommonlyCensored They live according to the beliefs their religion teaches.
@@ComommonlyCensored "being taught" You are conflating an abhorrent political ideology that starts with the letter Z and a religion.
@@ComommonlyCensored "Which one" The "real Jew" has little trouble rejecting "Z"ism for the abhorrent ideology it is.
@@ComommonlyCensored A "real Jew" would never give their own trash comment a thumbs up like you do.
@@ComommonlyCensoredperhaps one is a Jew and one is a Zionist?
Thanks a lot for sharing and telling us the details about Palestine and Israel. Truth is always coming out.
What an insightful, thought and soul provoking conversation. 🙏🏽
This is powerful. If only those in Israel would truly listen to this with an open heart I feel like these men could go a long way to healing the minds of those zionists filled with anger and hate. Thank you 🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪
There are those Jews within Israel who feel this way,they maybe few but they face an awful lot of hate and marginalisation and judgement.
@@upendasana7857yes and its a much worse position to be in emotionally. You are caught in a terrible schism. Feelings of rejection and feelings of complicity and the guilt going in both directions. A Palestinian arab has no such internal conflict or alienation. So the vocal ones in Israel are such tough cookies.
Beautiful conversation and truth sharing.
I am not Jewish nor Palestinian, but Canadian with German born father.
We've never sat to have such rich conversation. My dear dad at 88 still thinks he had a "great childhood" having been a child during the war.
Thank you for enriching my life. Gabor we've met twice. Edmonton for Compassionate Inquiry, and Melbourne for Childhood Trauma conference. Much gratitude, I've learned so much in this conversation.
As a Jewish woman, Thank you all so much for what your family is doing to open the narrative and tell people the truth.
Such an honest , insightful and informative program upholding humanity ! Thank you so much ,ro the Mate family !
They should play this video in all schools.
Yes. And on 60 Minutes. Mainstream western media.
Such a great family. Such great people.
Every US politician should listen to this
Amazing family shining a bright light on the tragic Palestinian situation. Hoping the jewish community hears you and rise against the injustice committed under their name. Keep spreading the truth❤
What an incredible family! Three people sharing their experiences, which must be extremely difficult for them, yet there is not a hint of hatred or hostility, just a simple sharing of truth, despite its ugliness, with compassion and humility. I sincerely hope that it reaches the hearts of their fellow Jews who are stuck in trauma, hatred and revenge. There is no blame, just an understanding of how we have come to this and an invitation to put things right. We love you all and pray for freedom and peace for both sides ❤️
Beautifully put. 💯
Gabor, Aaron and Daniel thank you for making the world a better place . People like the Mate family give us all hope and are bright lights in these dark times in history.🇵🇸🇿🇦🇾🇪❤️
So very true. Well said!
The Gabor Family are Loving People with Integrity and Soul..
You and your family are Beacon of light into the utter darkness of this cancerous madness. Thanks again❤
I cried during a large part of the debate and my shame for being Israeli came back! Perhaps its my Swedish Jewish father who took me to Sweden where the authorities condemned Israel frequently over the years and no antisemitism was seen but a massive message of support from the Swedish people to the Palestinians AND Israelis to reach peace!
The Ultimate shame is those in power, you are a good man. Let’s pray for peace and compassion ☮️ ✡️ ☪️
Leave Palestine then , why are you choosing to be a colonial invader while you are Swedish.
But your very existence in Palestine is anti peace why don't you get this? You're occupiers. You've already sinned. Now leave if you want peace leave.
Right, it's not about hating jews. Judaism has produced some of the most incredible people in history.
Criticizing Israel, especially for their actions since 10/7, IS NOT ANTISEMITIC
I hope G@l G@d@t see this and learn.
I am very thankful for this conversation. Many of us in the United States are walking around in a dystopian nightmare of gaslighting by our government and authority figures. There is a void of moral authority...a void of enlightened leadership here that is frightening. The recent passage of a resolution in the House equating zionism with antisemitism is one example. Please keep speaking about this, and speak louder! Dr. Gabor Mate you have done a beautiful job raising your sons!
Knowledge is power.
Please share this informative video.
Healthy knowledgeable debates evokes humanity.
Gaza is our last wake up call.
You men are a blessing to the world. Thank you for your courage and unyielding authority to Truth. I salute you
The wonderful Matè family, we appreciate your true understanding of the ongoing Palestinian plight.
I would love to hear Mrs. Maté in the conversation. She must be a remarkable woman. Thank you guys for using your platform so responsibly and compassionately. May we awaken through this painful situation.
I agree
What a beautiful conversation. What beautiful human beings. What humanity! ❤ I genuinely love all 3 of you. Dr. MATE IGE FOLLOWED YOU FOR QUITE SOME TIME. It’s a pleasure to meet your sons! There is no surprise they turned out as wonderful human beings having a father like you. ❤
Bless you Dr. Mat'e for Bringing Humanity to the Table !
Respect to Dr. Gabor and his sons for their courage, compassion, honesty and humility!
My heroes! Thanks so much for being the best self loving Jews out there!