UPSC से कुछ सवाल | कब तक करेगा UPSC मनमानी | Reforms in UPSC
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 07. 2024
- Telegram: telegram.me/muditgupta
In this video, Mudit Gupta will discuss the much needed reforms in the UPSC Civil Services Exam.
civil services,civil service,civil service exam,civil services exam,upsc civil services,civil services exams,evolution of civil services in india,upsc civil service notification 2024,why civil services,civil services study,civil services in india,civil services history,civil service age,study for civil services,upsc civil service,civil service syllabus,civil service question,upsc civil services result,indian civil service,what is civil service
#upsc #ias #ips
1st time in history of upsc exam
Such kind of video is released no coaching mafia no coaching hubs had the "himmat" to say all this openly....hats of mudit sir you became voice of so many voiceless helpless aspirants ❤
Kyu ki unka bussines khataare mae aa jayega
UPSC is the most opaque body ever!!
Well said
Well said
Well said
Nahh! NTA takes away the crown!
@@bababillenial7861bruhh are you dumb, NTA is 3 x 10^100 times more transparent then UPSC
You're are the only known teacher who raised this voice 😢 Thanks sir🙏
This video is the single most important thing for all UPSC aspirants. It should get viral. Sir is raising extremely vital issues and UPSC must address these if it wants to remain a transparent organization.
Some things I have come across which made me question the sanctity of UPSC-
1. A fellow aspirant of mine told me that he will give his mains exam from Jaipur (he has no connection to the city nor has ever been there). Why? Cz there is an insider info circulating in Delhi that papers from Jaipur have high probability of scoring good marks. Seriously ?!
2. I heard one of top ranker of 2019 interview back when he cleared- He said he cleared in 5th attempt but he has no idea how he got selected this time around and not his previous 2 mains. And this happens with many toppers, just hear them carefully. So if toppers are themselves not sure what is it that's really hitting the chord with the examiner then how is anyone sure ?
3. After Prelims 2023, I commented on one of Mudit Sir's video of how difficult CSAT was for people of non math background and questions were of CAT, IITJEE level whereas syllabus mentions up to Class 10th level BUT I had to delete my comment within 3 days cz some IITians ganged up against me n started saying that we are already the cream of this country and its good UPSC makes difficult CSAT so that fools like you get filtered out, high IQ is what matters, CSAT should be more difficult cz we automatically get an edge, IAS officers are mostly from the top tier colleges of the country so its fair and etc. etc.
I could go on with many other instances but what really is the need of the hour is that UPSC should do a lot of reforms now, high time.
1. Give answer keys within a week of Prelims and disclose cutoff.
2. Give Prelims result with names and category.
3. Give model answers of Mains and also release the answer copies of at least few top 20 or 50 or 100 recommended candidates.
The massive number of youth who appear for this exam will continue appearing no matter the number of years they are wasting cz the exam is such, it is an addictive loop of the hope that we can be better with each attempt. But we deserve these reforms. We seriously do.
Neet & IAS पूजा की स्थिति देखकर UPSC पर कभी आँख मूंदकर विश्वास नही किया जा सकता ।😢😢😢
"when tyranny becomes law, rebellion becomes duty"
~ Thomas Jefferson
Noted for essay
UapA😂😂
Essay mai Likhunga bhai.
Very true @muditgupta the credibility of UPSC is in question. A few days ago a friend had asked me how did I find courage to give an attempt after the NEET scam and I replied with confidence that UPSC has no such history of scams. Now, this faith is also shattered.
The question of prelims results cut off and answer key is also very important that they should release it after the exam not after a year.
You look beautiful Shweta music
Upsc epfo
Yes absolutely right....
Har saal paper ka pattern change hona, bina kisi logic ke answer key bna dena..ye sab pichle 3-4 saal se jyda ho rha hai, jabse Soni chairman bna hai😢
Very pertinent questions raised. UPSC's corruption has been in the news since long but it has been suppressed b heavy political prowess. It's time to unleash heavy social media pressure and bring UPSC on it's knees. Lets move towards transparency.
Every other teacher on and off yt is trying to sell their courses, and trying to persuade us to give one more attempt. Mudit sir u got some real guts to raise such questions. Kudos to ur strength sir.
Sir unacademy se jude the jo bht high fees leti thi tb sir usi ko promote krhe the bhaiya 😂
notice krne ki baat hai ki agr kisi or exam mein agr koi mis happening hoti hai to us field k teachers turant bachcho k haq ki awaaj uthane aa jate hai...utube pr protest krte hai..bachche protest krte ...par upsc m itni jada opaqueness hone k baad v aajtk ksi v teacher ne koi ek comment Tak nii ..itne bde bde bn gye bachcho ki kamai kha kha k be it divyakirti , awad ojha , mrunal or anybody. koi is baat k lie kbhi nii bolta. 2023 ka exam itna unfair tha pr phir v kisi teacher ne ek comment Tak nii kia..infact sb apna csat ka course expensive kr die...sb apne utube channel pr apne aap ko ese show krege jese ye hi sbsebde gyaani most honest being pr sb bhooke hai...koi pese ka (ojha) koi shohrat ka( divyakirti)..koi bchche ki haq ki baat nii krega...jitna jada opaqueness hogi system utna hi coaching industry flourish kregi...sb mile hue hai ( it's not a meme ) it's is a reality...
Moreover,there is no carbon copy provided to the aspirants of the prelims exam..how the hell can we check with the answer key that I was getting so so marks and claim after 1 year of examination..this is high time for a major reform
Ye exam ek chutiyapa hai,,, nothing related to knowledge, conceptual clarity, Hard work smart work nothing if D_Day in your favour only then anyone can get success in this loop ➿ else for 99% it's waste of time money and energy.
Sorry for my bad words
Thankyou very much sir for raising voice in favour of aspirants as usual. Big Respect ❤🙏
Right bro.. only 2 hours decides the hard work of 2 years
Ekdum sahi baat bola hai bro. Aur iss exam ke liye apne jawani se 5 -10 saal barbaad karne wale aspirants se bade chutiye aur koi nahi
D-Day matters the most
@@Ansh-ip4qf Yes it's a gamble of D-Day,,, after 2 years of hard work and smart work and everything!
He is not only a teacher....
He is the voice of millions of aspirants, who may never know what mistakes he made during his preparation....
Thanks for this video sir....
This is RTI....
If there is democracy that exists in this country please ensure transparency.....
This year they didn't even release the name list of prelims qualified candidates. After the allegations on Birla , this is what UPSC came out with that it is better not to release the name list.
Very true
I wish we could do something against it😢
Nd despite getting 109 in gs and 173 in csat acc to vajiram answer key i didn’t qualify it I don’t know how
Did they release the answer key?
@@ankurkumar55😢
Finally someone dared to talk the truth👍🏻
UPSC Seems like the biggest time-pass of this country. We need reforms in Govt. Exams.. it's getting shittier by the day
You are absolutely right. People blame students that they waste years but don't question the UPSC..in this age and time it has to reform and curtail the time they take for the exam. There are always 1-2 Q are for omission. Do they sleep while preparing the question paper that after the exam is over they realise that we set a question wrong. Bhai then Don't use such language that you yourself is not understanding in the attempt of making paper difficult.And answer key and cutoff has to published immediately. No excuse for that. Sheer autocracy of this institution who asks questions about democracy and transparency in the exam. And ethics paper is just a joke. What are they trying to check by making people write 9 papers with total subjectivity.
I have given 4attempts till now. In my previous attempts i was never doubtful about the results published by upsc but iss saal ppl scoring good marks in csat gs have failed whereas some others with less marks have cleared. There's definitely something fishy about this prelims result
I think we shouldn't waste our 20s and 30s in this exam. I'm 30 now unmarried and unemployed woman depressed going through a lot medications bhi chal rhe h it was my 4th attempt. 🙏 better to go or look for other jobs
@@Msharma30Why don't you try ssc CGL ? After entry of TCS ssc has become so much transparent. Answer key releases on time you get to see entire paper. Questions checked by computer software
@@vishakhasanglikar9000actually this year I made up my mind for ssc cgl. I even filled the form for general age is 30 as I'm obc so I got a relaxation hopefully I clear this exam this should be my first and last attempt for ssc cgl.
@@Msharma30 great even apply for Railway NTPC , syllabus is similar to SSC and age limit for general is 32...
@@Msharma30 pls take care of your health
We support you! Why are names not released in the 2024 prelims result?
Bhailog ,, please must like the vedio so that y jyada se jyada se spread ho jaye..( aaj tak maine CZcams P koi faltu vedio like nhI kara nahi comment kara ,, but y vedio hum sab k liye h so please take action,,
THANK YOU MUDIT SIR🙏
Reforms ke nam pe UPSC age kam karegi taki aspirants exam de hi na paye. Magar structural reforms kabhi nahi karegi. Like the government, UPSC is stubborn and maintains its ivory tower stature.
4 hrs and only 4.5K views, this tells everything. Anyways, hats off to your courage Sir
I think not just teachers but also selected toppers should make upsc accountable
Unka ho gaya toh sab changa si nhi hota unhe bhi isme contribution krna hoga
Himmat chahiye is tarh se facts btaane ke liye 👍👏👏
Sir, aap 100% sahi baat bol rahe hain.. har govt. exam me scam karke candidates ki age or attempts khatam hoti hain bas.. General category ka toh aab zindegi khatam hai har govt. sector mein.. humlog ka jo age or attempts jaate hain usko koi thik nehi karta.. koi nehi sochta..
It's true sir upsc me v dhandhli hoti hai but koi janta nhi😢
Upsc epfo paper
😢😢😢
This ias Pooja case is really embrassing for upsc, it raises 2 critical issue, nepotism and fraud, fraud can be dealt by legal action but how they can curb this nepotism in upsc
My only question → regarding prelims answer key..
Aisa bhi kya secret ki jldi release nhi krte😢
We have filed a case last year asking about the ANSWER KEY of Prelims before the release of Prelims result, Hindi Translation error and other irregularities in UPSC, but till date even after a year UPSC is not able to reply on those points and courts are also not entertaining. All these articles 14, transparency, RTI, writs are just restricted to Laxmikant and not applicable in reality.
Bro can I get your contact I have also filed a complaint I need your advice
Thank you sir for raising your voice against this body.. Now I think UPSC is as similar as NTA.. Maybe corruption happens there too, but we neither know nor see..😢
Yeh hamesha se hi hai bas unhone bahar aane nahi diya kabhi
Sir
1) even if UPSC is bringing new changes to CSE exam, they should inform before hand, for example if they have decided to remove optioanal they should infrom 2 to 3 years before hand from the effective year,
2) even prelims answer key they are not releasing right after prelims ABSOLUTELY NO SCOPE FOR IMPROVEMENT
3) 2024 prelims NAMEWISE LIST not released any APPROPRIATE REASON FOR THIS?
Salute to sir, at least he is speaking.
Anjali Birla ne Na kisi coaching me mock test diya or Na hi ek bhi Mock interview diya to me ye puchna chahta hu ki aisi kaisi intelligent hai Om birla ki beti jo bina ek mock test diye bina ek mock interview diye IAS ban gayi wo bhi achanak se ???
DIVYA TANWAR ..Ek aam ghar ki Ladki jisne 2 baar upsc crack kiya..phle IPS or doosri baar IAS allot hote hote sirf EWS certificate ki wajah se rh gya...i think she is 100% under EWS. And, this Pooja daughter of Civil servant ..under PWBD category...then why didn't she appeared for medical test before test...6 times..this is clear sign of misuse of authority. This is a blind Justice violation of Due Process.😢
Bilkul...but UPSC chalange kiya tha ...but issko judgment.....isske fewer me dediya issliye.....
Upsc bhi Sab changa si wali mentality ke saath chal rha hai...we need a Transparent and Fair UPSC
Bhai log app hum kun bhuljatae hai ki upsc is just an exam conducting authority khel to sab upar wala ka hai to why to blame upsc???
She had political support from politicaian
Go to Pakistan
Baki बडे बकवास करणे वाले teacher कहा गये जैसे ओझा.विकास दिव्यकिर्ती ..sir plese kuch to किजिये आप hm आपके साथ है .ये सब बंद होन चाहिए transperancy होनी चाहिए
Superb sir, you are raising all the rightful questions.
Transparency is the least we can expect from a constitutional body.
Under the cloak of integrity and secrecy, UPSC has had its way like Intelligence Agencies do in courts & public forum. But, ultimately, it is a constitutional body and must be made answerable to the public greivances.
In my preparation journey, i also believe that upsc is fair deal but after this i feel sad abt upsc which is become also a currupt body. After neet upsc will also cross check its methods and criteria in many areas, ethics paper they added but its moral values they forgot.
Mudit sir a great respect for u, ur step is really comedable for us.
Yes very very important topic for upsc aspirants sir..bhut jaruri hai model answer jari karna and answer key time par dena..
Mudit sir hatts off
5:57 What a question sir , proud to be your student and subscriber in CZcams.
Good point raised
You're a brave guy
No one else has talked such things openly before
You are True sir hame prelims dene ke baad ye pta hi nhi chalta ki humari glti kia hai, mains ka to adhar pta hi nhi, to akhir hum khudko sudahre kese☹️☹️, sir humari avaj banne ke lie thank you so much
Its upsc incompetency that they have set 5 wrong question in gs paper not fate/bad luck of aspirant we should demand cancellation of this year prelims and ask for reconduct of exam. 5 wrong question were (nec, syndicate, they both have translation error), and the other threee factually wrong were ( women reservation bill ( both statement one two were wrong, no answer possible), flying fox (factually wrong, both statement wrong), isotherm (hemisphere ) not mentioned. This is 10 marks which is more than 10 percent of the cut of if is between 95-100). And also deletint the question does not make it a level playing field. Let take a example of translation error a person who got it correct and no fault of his own will fall from 94 (as their 47 question were correct in net)to 91.8 and those who has not attempted will jump from 90 to 91.8..and those who got it negative will jump from 90 to 93.18. This is seriously a scam if 5 percent of question is wrong in an exam where every single marks matter. We should file cases in court, file pm grievances, raise our voice. This whole 5 question has changed the scenario. I am sure they have deleted 3 question and given 2 wrong answer for women reservation bill and isotherm as both of them were also wrong. It has affected more than 5-10k students who were getting marks above 95( if we assume atleast 1000 people are on 1 marks near cut off). We are not talking about controversial question like radar, red Sea, parasitoid etc.. This is nothing less than a scam. We should raise complain to upsc and fight it out. Seriousl aspirant suffer because of upsc incompetency to set correct question and it is not human error 5 wrong question cannot be termed as human error. Human error is one or two question not 5 question. No one on earth can justify these 5 question as correct. They have stooped to the level of state pcs. Its better to raise our voice like last year people raise voice against csat and we the result csat paper was set according to syllabus. I myself was getting 98 in gs and 90 in csat but failed prelims. 93 without controversial question. Let report against upsc...it better than crying and blaming it on our fate.. Accepting upsc mistake like every year..
@@gravitydrive-mg2gl valid point others must look this seriously
@@poetrybypranav294 yes...all. Coaching Institute should raise this.. It was nothing less than a scam. If their is such incompetency and carelessness in setting question paper that 5 of them are wrong. Forget about controversial question.
Kaafi serious issue hai.. Mass mai grievances daalo.. Bina uske kuch nahi hoga.
Interview mein toh sab ka sab subjective hai
@@Himalayan291 interview se pehle hi khela kar de rahe hai prelims mai hi.
This was all needed . After back to back failures of exam taking institutions even the UPSC the high level institution in India is losing its integrity and ethics.
Thank you so much raising this issue it is high time to raise such questions ignored from years.
Sir, 2020/21 aspirants were shouting against this due to COVID, but no one from teacher fraternity came in their support.
Axar mere dimag me bhi sawal aate the jese answer key par aaj tak kisi teacher ne is baare me baat nahi ki dhanaybad apko ki is baare me aap ne awaj to uthai
You've asked very genuine questions sir.. 😢
MUDIT SIR you have really pitched in really Serious and Valid questions for "THE UPSC" to reflect upon. Each and every aspirant who is sincerely preparing for this exam will definitely relate to this video and I hope that adequate measures are taken to make this process a transparent one. KUDOS to you Sir. 🙏
Thank you very much sir itna courage se bolne ke liye...aise sawal aajtak kisine nahi uthaye
No birla got hurt in this video
Model no. 69 💀
Thanks for raising the voice sir ...
You are genuinely a role model for all the teachers out there !!!
Each and every point at every stage of the exam has been addressed so well.
This can come only from the person who is genuinely empathetic for every aspirant out there !!
Thanks for being the person you are sir !!! You genuinely deserve all of our respect .....
Thank you sir for raising voice we all are with you
Upsc need reforms to come clean about answer key,marks of candidates after every stage within result dates.If they can check result of each candidate of 5 lakh approx in 20 days then also they can compute individual marksheet n put on result tab of result day. SAME NAKRE USED BY Sbi on electoral bonds pr jab fatkar pdi toh hawa nikal gyi.Make it a twitter trend guys #UPSC COME CLEAN
upsc should immediately release answer key just after the exam and it should release cutoff and marksheet just after the result of each phase
Bilkul shi kha aapne sir phli baar kisi teacher me hum baccho ke bare me socha
Yes sir.
Apki baat logically sahi .
Najariya bdla h .
Mje to lgta tha ki UPSC bht. Hi fair or honest h .
Iske or ek case h om Birla daughter,s .
We r agree with you sir.
Thank you so much sir for raise voice for us 🙏
True very true even UPSC should release evacuated answer copies. To err is human and those check copies they are also human . All human makes mistakes 🙏 UPSC is the most opaque body.
Truth is always bitter Sir...thngs a lot for this video
Recently the mains copy of 50 candidates of UPPCS (PCS-J) were exchanged which was brought into light after one candidate saw his copy via RTI.
UPSC doesn't even allow to candidates to see the mains copy... what if same thing happened in upsc?
True sir
... And the amount of hard work we are putting for this exam is extremely difficult but we don't give up being as a medial class family this is our dream but.. problem does not end here now csat difficulty, engineering students medical students.. which student from humanities background they dont fight with upsc only they fight with them also...
Absolutely the correct question should be raised the process is such that it keeps the aspirant in a loop where he can question only himself
First of all UPSC should stop those candidates who got any services in order to get their desired service they keep on giving attempts and eat our seats who's struggling clearing prelims
They should release answer key plus marks with prelims result.
Instead of reducing age they should take exam within 6 months I came here when I was 22 now I'm 25 and gave only 2 attempts but my half age passed waiting for whole one year
Right.. we should write about it to PMO through letters😊
Very true every year more than 100 people are reselected wtf is wrong with upsc
@@ash_1212 yeah I mean only 100 students are satisfied 50 students of reservation are satisfied and rest all give paper and it's obvious I don't know how it happens but selected candidates never fails hm sb yha chutiya baithe hai
Respect for you sir ....no coaching has raised these issues and specially answer key released after one year
Thanks a lot sir for raising this problem....
No teacher pr mentor came forward except for selling courses
Thanks a lot sir
Hope there will be reformed in this opaque unaccountable organisation..
#Reform UPSC 🗿
I felt the same whenever ,watching these mock interviews by retired officers and some coaching institutes would invite the officers who are in service for answer writing sessions.
I definitely see a flaw in the examination system ...100 Questions in Prelims is a lottery... Reintroduce Optional in Prelims or Increse the number of Questions and Scrap useless CSAT ... Otherwise students from non technical background will suffer.
An eye-popping vdo, sir ! Kudos for bringing out these hardcore insiders .... UPSC itself needs to sit for the exam , the questions of which hv to be by us
My name is Gaurav Bankawat and I m a Divyang person. At present I m an Rajasthan Administrative Services officer.I cleared UPSC in 2015 but DoPT rejected my candidature saying that I m not fit. I challenged it in Central Administrative Tribunal, Delhi.and won the case. DoPT challenged it in Delhi High Court but there also I won but DoPT again rejected my candidature despite of 5 member medical board declaring me fit. I have been fighting for justice for last 8 years.
Aapne sahi bat uthai h sir ji,thak you😊🙏...we are with you 😊
Have no words, mudit sir... You are truly a man of integrity. ❤
You have raised some genuine questions which UPSC must answer.Thanks on behallf of all aspirants sir.
Thank you sir for raising the voice. You're going a great job. May be now UPSC will atleast reform to some extent.
Thanks for raising our voice..at least some one understands our pain🙏..Even I am unable to comprehend why they haven't released NAME LIST this year.
Exactly!!!!!
Yes every year they used to release
Actually not just CSE, this year they did not release name list in CDS result. I cleared that & i was eagerly waiting to see my name in a UPSC document,but days passes, then weeks, then months, i kept checking. But nope, they’re not gonna release it from now on.
Sir I do feel the same ... Here I will share my experience of upsc capf 2023 and civil service prelims 2024...
In prelims 2024 my marks were 94.88 excluding disputed ques and I didn't get selected and one candidate got selected despite having 92 marks.
In capf 2023 the cutoff for obc candidates was 321 out of 600 and they haven't released marksheet even after one week of final result..
My marks in paper 1 were 127.6 with official answer key and in paper 2 i have completed my paper with good answers and my overall interview was excellent and still not in the list .....
Brave of you to have raised this! Good job sir❤
Final result ke baad ak reserve list aati hai usme bhi jugaad wale ho jate hai
I think DoPT should remove ethics paper at all because practically both upsc and DOPT are neither willing nor able to follow even an iota of it....shame on such defunct organisations ....they proved that there is only one ethics-Might is right!
Thank u sir for ur concern u r doing very good job for aspirants ...
Sir jo kha vo ek dm correct bola aapne , hum thak chuke shi me ,ye sab sunkar bhut demotivated ho gyi , sab coaching valo ko fee se matlb hai , ki tyari kro sab hoga
Great sir
Speechless
❤❤
You have raised every concern ❤
Thank u sir for raising this issue.
Thanks Sir.... for raising our voice ❤
Exactly sir your every video is worth watching.❤
Commendable 👏👏👏
Yes sir i am agree with you
Thankyou for raise the voice
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
सच तो ये है की UPSC केवल अंग्रेजी माध्यम और अमीर घरानों और आईआईटियन वाले विद्यार्थियों को ही आईएएस बनाना चाहती है
Exam nikalo bakchodi naa karo 50%agar nhi aa raha to khud me hi koi kami hai khud ko badalo dekho naajra apne aap badal jaayega
@gorav18323 🤫
@@dharmendraias why do you get offended?
seems you got input to become ias.UPSC is also froad just like NTA.
@@hincularthechangingindia5267 rote raho exam na nikle to upsc ki kami hai bhai tumhara kuch nhi ho sakta mai 3 mains likh chukaa hu mera mains accha nhi jaata upsc ki kami nikaalu yaa apni.....
@@dharmendraias gadhe ho to kaise mains niklega.uppcs-j ki copy badal ja rahi,koi exam batao jaha ye sab na ho raha ho,upsc apfc ka hi dekh lo,baki upsc ne transparency ke naam par kya kiya.
sab tumhare jaise born blind nhi paida hue,dekhte hai,sunte hai aur bolte bhi hai.offended feel hona hai to ho jao
Bilkul sahi kaha hai aapane Bhaiya ji
Aaj baaten vahi kahi hain har student janana chahata hai
#NamasteBhaiyajii..❤️💕
Name List Isliye Jari Nhi Kia Taki SCAM krne me easy ho....
Shame UPSC
thank you so much sir for raising this issue
Salute to u sir.. 🙏U r d real hero...finally someone understood d real face of upsc 🙏
Valid point & commendable step sir
Thanks for raising our voice sir 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Haa sir ji ....bilkul 🙏🏼.....aap sahi bat bole hain.....bahut behatar sahi bat.....
Kya baat hai sir.......Matlb maza hi aa gya....jo swal hamare man me 2 saal se tha aaj apne usko public ke same rkh diya... sir itna support ke liye thank you.
Genuine issue raised bhai you🎉
Thank you so much sir......🙏
Thank you sir jai hind.