Dhoni in ODI Gilli in Tests Here's the reason Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli Gilli avg - 35 Ms avg - 50 (Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
Dhoni in ODI Gilli in Tests Here's the reason Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli Gilli avg - 35 Ms avg - 50 (Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
I would also pick Gilcrist as a player because as a batsman and WC is among the best world has ever seen BUT add captaincy in the skillset and MSD wins hands-down
Just change the team, put MSD in Australian team where he gets to keep for great bowlers (with all due respect to our bowlers) and players who can stoop to low level sledging and resort to unethical tactics and imagine Gilly keeping to Kumble, Bhajji, Ashwin and Jaddu's guiles. There is no doubt that MSD's records will, still improve but that of Gilchrist may not be same as it's now! Though I'm a big fan of Adam Gilchrist!
@@jasminemedia6666no bro. That ausie great team and bowlers needed a captain like Ricky ponting. For that team still ponting is better captain than Dhoni.
I m a fan of Msd but I will pick ghilchrist.bcoz he was the reason Australia won 3 world cups as he played great knocks in 1999,2003 and his best in 2007 final.and he is the reason why I love the all time Aussie XI.
Dhoni in ODI Gilli in Tests Here's the reason Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli Gilli avg - 35 Ms avg - 50 (Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
Much better? Dhoni was by far the best wicket keeper As far as batting is concerned Gilchrist was an Opener and MS came down the order. Even if you like Gilchrist i wont ever go as far as saying any player as Much better than Dhoni
dhoni cant single handedly take game away...he is finisher in small scale games...watch 2007 world cup final...pretty much every game gilchrist and mcgrath were in australia had an xfactor...one could get wickets, and the other could take the game away in few balls...and that too at the time of no powerplay@@infomationtechnology9836
i can name 10 other top order batsman who are better than gilly.....name you name who is better than MSD in no 5-6?accept Bevan no one even have 4k runs at that pos.....
@@PiyushKumar-wq9jd Name me 10 openers in that generation who had better strike rate than Gilchrist. Apart from Sehwag, no one comes in that List. The Fact that Gilchrist also had to keep and open at the same time and maintain a strike rate of 97+ is what makes him impressive. Dhoni has played over 300 ODI matches consistnely thats why he has over 10000 runs. Michael Bevan and AB Devilliers were far more superior finishers to Dhoni.
@@aniruddhmurthy6970Typical IPL kid 🤣🤣 lol do you even know what finisher role is? abd Villiers batted at no 4 position and was not out only 12 out of 37 times in ODI when Sa won whereas for Dhoni it is 47/49 and Bevan it is 41/54 in ODIs. 🤣 Ab de Villiers is a finisher only for IPL kids 🤣 Gilchrist was a top order batsman with good strike rate I agree, but Dhoni is a better wicket keeper batsman hands down, even Sangakkara stands better than Gilchrist in an overall aspect. Gilchrist is better than Dhoni in Catching (in terms of Wk), Dhoni is greatest wicketkeeper ever no debate in terms of mind presence, stumping and Runouts. Dhoni have 10k runs coz he played 300 matches? Let me remind Dhoni hasn't played 76 out of 343 matches that he has played and in 53 matches he hasn't faced more than 10 deliveries. Source:- ESPN Cricinfo analytics. Still he had average of 50+ He's the only batsman in History to become no 1 Batsman ICC ranking playing just 38 innings. Dhoni started batting at no 6 position from 2007 Wc His rankings from then. 2006 - Rank 9 2007 - Rank 7 2008 - Rank 5 2009 - Rank 2 2010 - Rank 1 2011 - Rank 5 2012 - Rank 3 2013 - Rank 4 2014 - Rank 6 2015 - Rank 10 Not even Sachin Tendulkar, but it's Ms Dhoni (no 6 batsman) who's the only batsman in the history of Cricket who stayed at Top 10 ICC rankings for 10 consecutive years (2006 - 2015). Even modern day greats like Virat, Warner, Rohit, Williamson dream to achieve this.. Ab de Villiers is a good upper middle order batsman and of course he's a legend. But he hasn't achieved anything for his team in white ball cricket. He always underperformed in ICC Tournaments both as captain and batsman. Stop watching IPL and get some International cricket knowledge please. 😂👍 Kapil Dev and Sunil gavaskar are not mad people to say that Dhoni (AS AN OVERALL CRICKETER) is ahead of even Sachin Tendulkar in Indian Cricket History. Are they?. Get well soon. 😅
The fact is gilly is the idol of ms.. the roll model.. gilli is my favourate ever.. he is genuine.. clean.. and distructive batsman in opening lineup i ever seen
Dhoni in ODI Gilli in Tests Here's the reason Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli Gilli avg - 35 Ms avg - 50 (Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
MSD was a genuine match winner who will stay till end & win you the match guaranteed whereas Gilchrist was a pinch hitter like Jayasuriya who would change the face of the match in 5 minutes.
Dhoni in ODI Gilli in Tests Here's the reason Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli Gilli avg - 35 Ms avg - 50 (Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
@@TheChamnlerDhoni in ODI Gilli in Tests Here's the reason Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli Gilli avg - 35 Ms avg - 50 (Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
@@latasharma9678brother runs inning per dekho there is minor difference. But again Gilly is ahead in term of strike rate & don't forget Gilly played in early 2000 era whereas dhoni started late & continued till 2019. Odi cricket became a joke after 2011 worldcup specially with two new ball from both side & For a kind reminder Dhoni averaged 47 @6.
@@kavyasharma5388 You are just an IPL fan,which is played on flat dead pitches. Real cricket fans know what Gilchrist was and how deadly he was for the opposition 😜. Dhoni was nothing in front of Gilchrist
@@PoojaSharma-ze1uj know every stats w.r.t Sachin-Mcgrath duels. In AUS & INDIA in tests, Sachin averaged well against Mcgrath . In odis, in India Sachin had the clear upper hand. In odis in AUS & neutral venues Mcgrath had the upper hand .... So its almost even even.
@@mohanlal-tw5lp Sachin dominated McGrath in 1996. In 1998 the most successful year for Sachin, McGrath didn't play. Sachin was bullied by McGrath since 1999. Compare this to Lara . Lara had 3 double centuries against Australia when McGrath played. 2 in Australia and 153 in 1999 was one of the greatest test innings of all time. Tendulkar has zero double centuries against McGrath.Even in 2003 series when Tendulkar was struggling McGrath was not playing. McGrath played with Tendulkar
@@marlonsamuels6432 Sachin -Mcgrath duels were more or less even stevens and Sachin possessed respectable record in both formats when Mcgrath played. Comparing Lara-Mcgrath to Sachin-Mcgrath doesn't make sense w.r.t context because despite Lara definitely played Mcgrath convincingly better, Sachin's record was pretty good in its own . It was several other aspects that made Sachin a better over all batsman to Lara .
Actually I am watching cricket since 2001 but still I will prefer dhoni ...I like gilli but dhoni has an edge not as a batsman but if u want overall package ...
@@DivyanshYadav-ti9ebYou prefer dhoni beacuse you are indian. Just tell me who is the only player in the world to score 3 consecutive 50+ runs with 100+ S/R as a opener in WC final?? it was no t20s bullshit era. Bowlers were deadly back then but gilly was more deadly
@@rahatmahmud5435You are saying about that 3 50+ innings in Wc final then Dhoni also had 91* not out in 2011 Wc with the brilliant Captaincy display. Show me another Wicketkeeper batsman with 50+ avg in Odi playing in middle order 5-6-7 having more than 10000 runs in which more than 6500 runs scored under his own captaincy. Show me another batsman who takes less innings(38) than MSD to become no. 1 odi batsman. We are not choosing Dhoni becoz we are Indian we are choosing him becoz becoz he did better. Gilly was not captain and he had the luxury of ponting ,Martyn symond and bevan like match winners after him in Odi but Dhoni didn't had that luxury still having more runs than Gilly with better avg showing his skills and mindset under tremendous pressure of cricket loving crowd. You can choose Gilly if you want opener but as a wicketkeeper batsman having Captaincy and finishing skills it belongs to Dhoni.
I think the comment box forgot who is the fastest to reach at 1st in odi ranking of batsman and also the man who demoted himself in the middle order instead playing at no. 3 and even gautam said that if he would have batted at no. 3 always he would have broken all the records♥️♥️ By the way no hates to other players but it is truth that if dhoni hadnot sacrificed his no.3 for team then he would be one of the best indian batsman along with sachin sir🙂🙂 Gilchrist was very very good but mahi at no.3 was just 💥💥💥💥💥
Gilchrist was in a league of his own. Amazing keeper & destructive batsman in any format of the game. His hand and eye coordination was at another level.
Gilly always Gilly as a keeper & and a fantastic hard hitting opening batsman , gentleman of the game which was rare in Australian cricket team. Legend absolutely legend
Dhoni in ODI Gilli in Tests Here's the reason Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli Gilli avg - 35 Ms avg - 50 (Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
Gilly started and rocked Sanga came and ruled And then Dhoni came and conquered These three changed the perception of what was a wicket keeper basman these three were first batsman and wicket keeper sanga and Msd to even went on became one of the greatest captains also for there countries and the world in over all
Dhoni in ODI Gilli in Tests Here's the reason Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli Gilli avg - 35 Ms avg - 50 (Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
@@SasukeUchiha_x1 what is there to cry? Gilchrist can easily be the greatest cricketer ever if cricket didnt just focus on batting and batsmen. Bowlers dont get that limelight and wicketkeepers even less. Gilly was and forever will be the benchmark for a wk batter. The greatest No. 7 in test history. An automatic choice.
Any educated person will pick Gilchrist who won 3 world cups, 2 champions trophy, captained Australia to test series win in India and also won one IPL trophy. He did everything
Sachin got out on this man's ball. Hit a 4 and got out on next ball. That memory from 2003 world cup is pretty hard to forget even though I was a kid back then.
Gilchrist can easily be the greatest cricketer ever if cricket didnt just focus on batting and batsmen. Bowlers dont get that limelight and wicketkeepers even less. Gilly was and forever will be the benchmark for a wk batter. The greatest No. 7 in test history. An automatic choice. Plus people shouldn't be blind over more ODI runs made by Dhoni. Gilly made those runs as an opener and 9600 of them. Needless to mention, in a much competitive era (WI, SL, Pak, were much better, only NZ was maybe worse) He made 9600+ runs in ODI cricket, not a mere 4-5k. A time when hardly anyone even crossed that many runs in ODI. Most tests hundreds by a wk batter and 100s all over the world in the most beautiful and destructive fashion. Also for IPL kids, show me Dhoni's IPL player of the tournament award even after playing so many years while Gilly just played 5-6 seasons that too after retirement. What a legend and what a man. Even technique wise a way better batter. Flair wise, stats wise, there is just no match for Gilly. All this with due respect to Dhoni. Our national hero.
Gilchrist was their trump card in Test and ODI Matches. He used to score runs at such an alarming pace before the opponent realizes they are defending the match than trying to attack the other batsman.
In those days very few cricketers had strike rate above 80 or 100 rare and scoring 120 ball 100 was seen good. But few cricketers very pkaying t20 mode in ODIs before t20 became a thing. 1.Gilchrist 2.Sehwag 3.Afridi 4.Ricardo Powell 5.Jayasuriya
Dismissals/inning in all 3 formats Gilly 1.865 AB 1.784 MSD 1.363 Away tests avg - Gilly 49.70 AB 55.24 MSD 32.54 Away ODIs avg - AB 54.20 MSD 48.65 Gilly played in different era. Away T20I record (SR matters more here)- MSD 33.82 avg, 123.31 SR AB 27.93 avg, 133.13 SR Gilly 22 avg, 145.59 SR MSD is better than both in only captaincy. (Source - cricinfo & howstat)
Gilchirst -> Better wicket keeper and game changer Dhoni -> Better overall batter, strategist and captain Dhoni had a sharper mind than Gilchrist, for sure!
Jisko semi final aur final ka importance pta ho tournament ka wo hamesha gilchrist ko pick krgea.. If you have best team then captaincy become easier like ricky and dhoni but when wickets starts to ctumble then glichrist like crunch player comes to rescue and that too in quarter,semi or final.. 2003,2007 one man show
In sub continent conditions dhoni was far far better than Gilchrist but in bouncy pitches Gilchrist was ahead of dhoni..facts will support my statement
In my opinion both are great wicket keeper batsman but their role was totally different as batsman.Gilchrist used to give great start to australia whereas dhoni role was to finish the game which he did many times.starting and ending both are important.
Gilchrist is built different.....but I will pick them both in my all time 11.... Gilli and sehwag is my ultimate opening pair.... followed by Hayden Sachin and dhoni
Ma dhoni is a great captain but those who think that he is better than Gilchrist in terms of talent has never seen Gilchrist played he is the reason other wicket keepers started batting as well. He was a match winner for the greatest cricket team ever in the history of the game
I have been fan of Gilchrist since Sachin times but it was Dhoni who made be watch cricket again because I rarely saw someone playing the game actively on field like Australians before he became captain. One is best catch taker behind the wicket, and other is best at stumping. Sadly, MS never became an permanent opener like Rohit and Gilchrist was from the time when openers in ODI used to be perfect. I mean most of them used to score 100 without getting out and some of them were better hitter than Rohit.
Dhoni in ODI Gilli in Tests Here's the reason Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli Gilli avg - 35 Ms avg - 50 (Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
Gilchrist had the luxury of Haydos, Langer, Ponting, Martyn, Bevan, Symonds and look at Dhoni it was only after 2008 he had a Prime Sehwag, Sachin, Gambhir, Yuvi, Bhajji & Zak later he had the likes of Rohit, Virat & Raina Not easy being a WKB in Indian team 😢
For 90s kids and being an Aussie fan , Gilchrist was a spectacular captivating mf Scarlet witch against every other bowler , God o God I still Love him ❤
As an Indian, my pick too would be Gilchrist, given his Test Record both as a keeper and batsman... It's much, much better than Dhoni... And that is how, at least I rate a player...
As a keeper, Gilchrist has records better than Dhoni?? Do you even know the abc of cricket dude? Or just thede random shorts are your source of knowledge 🤣🤣
@kvbnmkkm145 Do you have an idea of what you are talking about?? Are you sure you are not really on medication?? Look at Gilchrist test record, and MSD would die for such a record... Flat Track Bully Generation doesn't understand Cricket one bit and you are a prime example of the same...
@kvbnmkkm145 Your problem, sin and crime is that you are an IPL fan... You are only as good... Great game of Cricket is unfortunate that people like you follow it...
Gilly is a principal/ roll model of wicket keeping school . He could have ask this question to dhoni. Being an Indian we always afraid of gilly during Aussie bowling . And this guy play at right time when there is a need . And this guy scored many overseas century in test than perform in their own country. So it’s obvious anytime Mr. clean Gilly .
The biggest difference is Gilchrist is a clutch player unlike dhoni who failed mostly in important games. Also Gilchrist have better strike rate even though he played on older generation
Wow all the Indians commenting Gili and in the video McGrath clearly says being an Aussie he has to select Gili. That’s patriotism and look here Indians as usual just individual fans😂.
In batting Gilchrist is better specially in test .... But dhoni with his mind always help in taking 1-2 wickets during match so it depends on team strength
It's as simple as that Captaincy - Msd against anyone in the world Wicketkeeper - Msd Again against anyone in the world Batsmen - No doubt it's Gilchrist, Msd might have an edge in ODIs but Gilchrist is head and shoulders above Middle order batsman in tests .
That's a really easy question... though I love dhoni more, he is my captain 🧢❤ answer is Gilchrist, a far more superior breed, those who understands cricket will definitely agree with me.
I'm am Indian..it's still gilly for me..he was just being kind...there is no comparison! It's like saying Sachin or pointing which is a better batsmen...and putting Ponting ahead because he was a great caption... Sachin was miles ahead it's not even a question!
Gilchrist for those who watched cricket in 2000s
He was a beast
he ruined my childhood. if Gilchrist or Hayden kept batting more than 10 overs i used to switch off the TV
Yes he was
@@SamareDoTelkeYup....
Phir to aisa hmehsa hoga kyuki aus me sirf Gilchrist hi nhi sbke sb aise hi hai 😢😢😢
Player like Adam Gilchrist are born once.
Dangerous opening Batsman in 90's in Aussie team
He ultimately Destroyed Indian Bowler in 2003 WC final
Squash ball 😂😂😂
2003 tho kuch bhi nahi 2007 may to dhaga khol diya sri lanka ka
@@maharathipradyumna7Don't laugh because reality doesn't change india lost the final
@@maharathipradyumna7allowed tha
@@AshishSingh-ef5yqthis time also India lost
As a captain/Keeper -- Dhoni
As batsmen/Keeper --- Gilly
Dhoni in ODI
Gilli in Tests
Here's the reason
Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli
Gilli avg - 35
Ms avg - 50
(Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
Will choose gilly and ponting for captain no need a wk captain 😂
@@latasharma9678 Nice argument buttressed by numbers.
@@latasharma9678dhoni 84 times not out bhi raha hai. Isiliye average itni jyada hai.
@@axeaxe4178 ok let's keep average aside still 1.1k more runs in 18 innings?
Being an Indian, I'd also pick Gilchrist as a player and keeper.
😂😂only u😂😂not me
I always go for greatest batsmen msd❤❤
Dhoni in ODI
Gilli in Tests
Here's the reason
Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli
Gilli avg - 35
Ms avg - 50
(Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
Only player
Keeper? Oh come on man MSD is the greatest wicket keeper batsman of all time.
I would also pick Gilcrist as a player because as a batsman and WC is among the best world has ever seen BUT add captaincy in the skillset and MSD wins hands-down
Just change the team, put MSD in Australian team where he gets to keep for great bowlers (with all due respect to our bowlers) and players who can stoop to low level sledging and resort to unethical tactics and imagine Gilly keeping to Kumble, Bhajji, Ashwin and Jaddu's guiles. There is no doubt that MSD's records will, still improve but that of Gilchrist may not be same as it's now! Though I'm a big fan of Adam Gilchrist!
@@jasminemedia6666gilly can perform anywhere
@@jasminemedia6666no bro. That ausie great team and bowlers needed a captain like Ricky ponting. For that team still ponting is better captain than Dhoni.
@@jasminemedia6666if gilly was in indian team then he would have more records
Gilly is also good captain he won test series in india where pointing was not playing.
I m a fan of Msd but I will pick ghilchrist.bcoz he was the reason Australia won 3 world cups as he played great knocks in 1999,2003 and his best in 2007 final.and he is the reason why I love the all time Aussie XI.
I am Indian but huge fan of Adam gilkhrisht batting as well wicket keeping..he is nice humble person.
Dhoni in ODI
Gilli in Tests
Here's the reason
Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli
Gilli avg - 35
Ms avg - 50
(Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
I am a huge MSD fan but Gilchrist was much better
Any day....!!! Gilchrist
Much better?
Dhoni was by far the best wicket keeper
As far as batting is concerned Gilchrist was an Opener and MS came down the order.
Even if you like Gilchrist i wont ever go as far as saying any player as Much better than Dhoni
Dhoni wasn't any less aggressive batsman in early days..after becoming captain he gave up his position for others
@@Pa1zangilchrist also played 7 , I think u only watched him in t20
dhoni cant single handedly take game away...he is finisher in small scale games...watch 2007 world cup final...pretty much every game gilchrist and mcgrath were in australia had an xfactor...one could get wickets, and the other could take the game away in few balls...and that too at the time of no powerplay@@infomationtechnology9836
As an Indian, I also prefer Gilchrist for sure.
i can name 10 other top order batsman who are better than gilly.....name you name who is better than MSD in no 5-6?accept Bevan no one even have 4k runs at that pos.....
@@PiyushKumar-wq9jd Name me 10 openers in that generation who had better strike rate than Gilchrist. Apart from Sehwag, no one comes in that List. The Fact that Gilchrist also had to keep and open at the same time and maintain a strike rate of 97+ is what makes him impressive. Dhoni has played over 300 ODI matches consistnely thats why he has over 10000 runs. Michael Bevan and AB Devilliers were far more superior finishers to Dhoni.
@@aniruddhmurthy6970Typical IPL kid 🤣🤣
lol do you even know what finisher role is?
abd Villiers batted at no 4 position and was not out only 12 out of 37 times in ODI when Sa won whereas for Dhoni it is 47/49 and Bevan it is 41/54 in ODIs. 🤣
Ab de Villiers is a finisher only for IPL kids 🤣
Gilchrist was a top order batsman with good strike rate I agree, but Dhoni is a better wicket keeper batsman hands down, even Sangakkara stands better than Gilchrist in an overall aspect.
Gilchrist is better than Dhoni in Catching (in terms of Wk), Dhoni is greatest wicketkeeper ever no debate in terms of mind presence, stumping and Runouts.
Dhoni have 10k runs coz he played 300 matches?
Let me remind Dhoni hasn't played 76 out of 343 matches that he has played and in 53 matches he hasn't faced more than 10 deliveries. Source:- ESPN Cricinfo analytics.
Still he had average of 50+
He's the only batsman in History to become no 1 Batsman ICC ranking playing just 38 innings.
Dhoni started batting at no 6 position from 2007 Wc His rankings from then.
2006 - Rank 9
2007 - Rank 7
2008 - Rank 5
2009 - Rank 2
2010 - Rank 1
2011 - Rank 5
2012 - Rank 3
2013 - Rank 4
2014 - Rank 6
2015 - Rank 10
Not even Sachin Tendulkar, but it's Ms Dhoni (no 6 batsman) who's the only batsman in the history of Cricket who stayed at Top 10 ICC rankings for 10 consecutive years (2006 - 2015).
Even modern day greats like Virat, Warner, Rohit, Williamson dream to achieve this..
Ab de Villiers is a good upper middle order batsman and of course he's a legend. But he hasn't achieved anything for his team in white ball cricket. He always underperformed in ICC Tournaments both as captain and batsman.
Stop watching IPL and get some International cricket knowledge please. 😂👍
Kapil Dev and Sunil gavaskar are not mad people to say that Dhoni (AS AN OVERALL CRICKETER) is ahead of even Sachin Tendulkar in Indian Cricket History. Are they?.
Get well soon. 😅
@@darkcoder638 You said that I watch IPL, I do watch IPL along with Internationals.
Gilly as a WK > Dhoni
@@darkcoder638stop crying mahn
If only you’d just said “Gilchrist” without making it conditional on you being an “ Aussie” Glenn 😮
You are so right. Being an Indian i would pick Gilchrist as wc and batsman.
Gilchrist was such a beast player. 140s in wc finals. Dream for many indian so called superheroes barring the 2011 and 1983 team.
The fact is gilly is the idol of ms.. the roll model.. gilli is my favourate ever.. he is genuine.. clean.. and distructive batsman in opening lineup i ever seen
Anytime adam Gilchrist
Dhoni in ODI
Gilli in Tests
Here's the reason
Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli
Gilli avg - 35
Ms avg - 50
(Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
MSD was a genuine match winner who will stay till end & win you the match guaranteed whereas Gilchrist was a pinch hitter like Jayasuriya who would change the face of the match in 5 minutes.
@@kachua810no need ms bevan the best finisher is there for aussie
Once Gilchrist sir told ms is not the second Gilchrist its First ms dhoni even this legend is fan of sir MSD ❤
You are correct.
It doesn't mean he is fan of msd he just respected him
That's actually a really easy question
It will always be Gilli no second thought
If u don't include captaincy, then no chance for Dhoni
Ponting hai uske pass
Dhoni in ODI
Gilli in Tests
Here's the reason
Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli
Gilli avg - 35
Ms avg - 50
(Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
@@TheChamnlerDhoni in ODI
Gilli in Tests
Here's the reason
Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli
Gilli avg - 35
Ms avg - 50
(Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
@@latasharma9678brother runs inning per dekho there is minor difference. But again Gilly is ahead in term of strike rate & don't forget Gilly played in early 2000 era whereas dhoni started late & continued till 2019. Odi cricket became a joke after 2011 worldcup specially with two new ball from both side & For a kind reminder Dhoni averaged 47 @6.
Dhoni doesn’t stand a chance against Gilchrist😂😂😂.
Pov you are football fan
@@kavyasharma5388 You are just an IPL fan,which is played on flat dead pitches. Real cricket fans know what Gilchrist was and how deadly he was for the opposition 😜. Dhoni was nothing in front of Gilchrist
@@Dragon_Ball_Z70ya your father made spin friendly pitches to flat pitch
@@Dragon_Ball_Z70pov - you are a zimbabar supporter (flat pitch bully)
@@Dragon_Ball_Z70 and you don't know how lethal prime 2009 and 2010 version dhoni was and Gilchrist was a cheater no need to say 2007 wc final😀
Big fan of Gilchrist
Mcgrath was nightmare for Sachin. His average dipped against Australia whenever good length master Mcgrath played
it is 50 50 ... Sachin destroyed Mcgrath several times and Mcgrath got Sachin out cheaply several times ....
@@mohanlal-tw5lp it is nit 50-50. Check stats. Mcgrath outplayed Sachin.
@@PoojaSharma-ze1uj know every stats w.r.t Sachin-Mcgrath duels.
In AUS & INDIA in tests, Sachin averaged well against Mcgrath . In odis, in India Sachin had the clear upper hand. In odis in AUS & neutral venues Mcgrath had the upper hand .... So its almost even even.
@@mohanlal-tw5lp Sachin dominated McGrath in 1996. In 1998 the most successful year for Sachin, McGrath didn't play. Sachin was bullied by McGrath since 1999. Compare this to Lara . Lara had 3 double centuries against Australia when McGrath played. 2 in Australia and 153 in 1999 was one of the greatest test innings of all time. Tendulkar has zero double centuries against McGrath.Even in 2003 series when Tendulkar was struggling McGrath was not playing. McGrath played with Tendulkar
@@marlonsamuels6432 Sachin -Mcgrath duels were more or less even stevens and Sachin possessed respectable record in both formats when Mcgrath played. Comparing Lara-Mcgrath to Sachin-Mcgrath doesn't make sense w.r.t context because despite Lara definitely played Mcgrath convincingly better, Sachin's record was pretty good in its own . It was several other aspects that made Sachin a better over all batsman to Lara .
Only kids prefer dhoni because they don't have idea of what kind of player AG was ...the real OG
Actually I am watching cricket since 2001 but still I will prefer dhoni ...I like gilli but dhoni has an edge not as a batsman but if u want overall package ...
@@DivyanshYadav-ti9ebYou prefer dhoni beacuse you are indian. Just tell me who is the only player in the world to score 3 consecutive 50+ runs with 100+ S/R as a opener in WC final?? it was no t20s bullshit era. Bowlers were deadly back then but gilly was more deadly
@@rahatmahmud5435You are saying about that 3 50+ innings in Wc final then Dhoni also had 91* not out in 2011 Wc with the brilliant Captaincy display. Show me another Wicketkeeper batsman with 50+ avg in Odi playing in middle order 5-6-7 having more than 10000 runs in which more than 6500 runs scored under his own captaincy. Show me another batsman who takes less innings(38) than MSD to become no. 1 odi batsman. We are not choosing Dhoni becoz we are Indian we are choosing him becoz becoz he did better. Gilly was not captain and he had the luxury of ponting ,Martyn symond and bevan like match winners after him in Odi but Dhoni didn't had that luxury still having more runs than Gilly with better avg showing his skills and mindset under tremendous pressure of cricket loving crowd. You can choose Gilly if you want opener but as a wicketkeeper batsman having Captaincy and finishing skills it belongs to Dhoni.
I think the comment box forgot who is the fastest to reach at 1st in odi ranking of batsman and also the man who demoted himself in the middle order instead playing at no. 3 and even gautam said that if he would have batted at no. 3 always he would have broken all the records♥️♥️
By the way no hates to other players but it is truth that if dhoni hadnot sacrificed his no.3 for team then he would be one of the best indian batsman along with sachin sir🙂🙂
Gilchrist was very very good but mahi at no.3 was just 💥💥💥💥💥
Gilchrist was in a league of his own. Amazing keeper & destructive batsman in any format of the game. His hand and eye coordination was at another level.
Dhoni is great captain and finisher and gilli great wicket kiper and great batsman
Gilly always Gilly as a keeper & and a fantastic hard hitting opening batsman , gentleman of the game which was rare in Australian cricket team. Legend absolutely legend
Offcourse Gilli ❤
Dhoni in ODI
Gilli in Tests
Here's the reason
Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli
Gilli avg - 35
Ms avg - 50
(Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
Gilly started and rocked
Sanga came and ruled
And then Dhoni came and conquered
These three changed the perception of what was a wicket keeper basman these three were first batsman and wicket keeper sanga and Msd to even went on became one of the greatest captains also for there countries and the world in over all
As a indian 🇮🇳 i wll pick Gillcrist in my team
Anyday pick Dhoni as a WKB he can get the best out of your bowlers too and add to that the lighting stumpings he is a great asset than any other WKB
Gilchrist>>>> dhoni ✔️no hesitation
Keep crying your heart out.....
Dhoni in ODI
Gilli in Tests
Here's the reason
Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli
Gilli avg - 35
Ms avg - 50
(Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
@@SasukeUchiha_x1 what is there to cry? Gilchrist can easily be the greatest cricketer ever if cricket didnt just focus on batting and batsmen. Bowlers dont get that limelight and wicketkeepers even less. Gilly was and forever will be the benchmark for a wk batter. The greatest No. 7 in test history. An automatic choice.
All of them Dhoni McGrath and Gilly all are legends❤️
Gilcrist is not only a benchmark for wicket keepers but could be easily included in the top 5 all time best cricketers.
Any educated person will pick Gilchrist who won 3 world cups, 2 champions trophy, captained Australia to test series win in India and also won one IPL trophy. He did everything
Both are legend❤
In ODI dhoni
In Test & T20 gilchrist
It was a very easy question actually. The rest of world is not blind
Gillii was a beast ❤
Best batsman and wicketkeeper for catching-gilly
Best captain and wicketkeeper for stumping-dhoni
Best odi 11
Sachin
Gilchrist
Lara
Kallis
Inzamam
Yuvraj
Flintoff
Warne
Akram
Mcgrath
Steyn overseas murli in Asia...
Best test 11
Cook
Hayden
Lara
Sachin
Kallis
Steve waugh
Gilchrist
Warne
Akram
Mcgrath
Again murli or steyn depending on condition
Best t20 11
Gayle
Mcculum
Surya
Devilliers
Maxwell
Pollard
Afridi
Rashid khan
Archer
Bumrah
Malinga
“Iam gonna ask a really tough question”
Yeah tough question for you.
I respect MSD. One of the best captains in the cricket history. But Gilchrist is really special. Gilchrist is the greatest wicketkeeper batsman.
Gilchrist the God of ICC knockout (99, 2003,2007)
Sachin got out on this man's ball. Hit a 4 and got out on next ball. That memory from 2003 world cup is pretty hard to forget even though I was a kid back then.
Will pick both
Gilchrist as a pure batter
Dhoni as a keeper and captain
I pick Gilly ...he is cool like MS ..
Gilchrist can easily be the greatest cricketer ever if cricket didnt just focus on batting and batsmen. Bowlers dont get that limelight and wicketkeepers even less. Gilly was and forever will be the benchmark for a wk batter. The greatest No. 7 in test history. An automatic choice.
Plus people shouldn't be blind over more ODI runs made by Dhoni. Gilly made those runs as an opener and 9600 of them. Needless to mention, in a much competitive era (WI, SL, Pak, were much better, only NZ was maybe worse) He made 9600+ runs in ODI cricket, not a mere 4-5k. A time when hardly anyone even crossed that many runs in ODI. Most tests hundreds by a wk batter and 100s all over the world in the most beautiful and destructive fashion. Also for IPL kids, show me Dhoni's IPL player of the tournament award even after playing so many years while Gilly just played 5-6 seasons that too after retirement. What a legend and what a man. Even technique wise a way better batter. Flair wise, stats wise, there is just no match for Gilly.
All this with due respect to Dhoni. Our national hero.
Opener - Gilchrist
Finisher or Middle Order - Dhoni
Both are legends
That's A PRETTY Easy Question!!
GILCHRIST ANYDAY!!
No Second Thought AT ALL!!
LUV U GILLY!!❤
Gilchrist was their trump card in Test and ODI Matches. He used to score runs at such an alarming pace before the opponent realizes they are defending the match than trying to attack the other batsman.
In those days very few cricketers had strike rate above 80 or 100 rare and scoring 120 ball 100 was seen good.
But few cricketers very pkaying t20 mode in ODIs before t20 became a thing.
1.Gilchrist
2.Sehwag
3.Afridi
4.Ricardo Powell
5.Jayasuriya
Dismissals/inning in all 3 formats
Gilly 1.865
AB 1.784
MSD 1.363
Away tests avg -
Gilly 49.70
AB 55.24
MSD 32.54
Away ODIs avg -
AB 54.20
MSD 48.65
Gilly played in different era.
Away T20I record (SR matters more here)-
MSD 33.82 avg, 123.31 SR
AB 27.93 avg, 133.13 SR
Gilly 22 avg, 145.59 SR
MSD is better than both in only captaincy. (Source - cricinfo & howstat)
gilchrist was a beast incarnate during his prime
Lol....gilchrist was way better as wicket keeper batsman
In my view, Akram and McGrath were the greatest I've watched in cricket.
Deccan chargers was my favorite team because of Gilchrist and they even won once.
Gilchirst -> Better wicket keeper and game changer
Dhoni -> Better overall batter, strategist and captain
Dhoni had a sharper mind than Gilchrist, for sure!
Iam an indian Ms dhoni good capital but Gilchrist is best wicketkeeper of all time
As a technical batsman yes, as a wicketkeeper dhoni is little ahead.
@@priyanshunegi3833 as a wicketkeeper bhi Gilchrist hi better hai.
Jisko semi final aur final ka importance pta ho tournament ka wo hamesha gilchrist ko pick krgea..
If you have best team then captaincy become easier like ricky and dhoni but when wickets starts to ctumble then glichrist like crunch player comes to rescue and that too in quarter,semi or final..
2003,2007 one man show
Dhoni is nothing in front of Adam Gilchrist but dhoni fans can't digest this but it's true that Gilchrist was a beast
In Gilchrist era no one was near him.... after that dhoni became the ace
Gilly was the best. Australia dominated for over 10 years. He was one of the main contributors.
In sub continent conditions dhoni was far far better than Gilchrist but in bouncy pitches Gilchrist was ahead of dhoni..facts will support my statement
In my opinion both are great wicket keeper batsman but their role was totally different as batsman.Gilchrist used to give great start to australia whereas dhoni role was to finish the game which he did many times.starting and ending both are important.
No comparison, as a 90s kids overall intrest in cricket drop after Gilchrist, McGrath and Warne retirement.
Gilchrist is built different.....but I will pick them both in my all time 11....
Gilli and sehwag is my ultimate opening pair.... followed by Hayden Sachin and dhoni
1. Gilli
2. Sanga
3. Dhoni
You don’t need finishes in a world team. The calibre of start Gilli can get can set a team winning from the beginning.
Gully cricket ke culture ko 4rab ne international level pe pahuncha diya, proud moment hai yeh! 🌍🏏
One of the greatest Captain ever and greatest of all time MSD Onwer of all trophy ❤😊 no doubt he is dangouros batsman and ⚡ lightning fast stumping ❤
Ma dhoni is a great captain but those who think that he is better than Gilchrist in terms of talent has never seen Gilchrist played he is the reason other wicket keepers started batting as well. He was a match winner for the greatest cricket team ever in the history of the game
Being a Dhoni fan I would pick Gilly too. He is just that good
It’s a luxury. No other team has. That is true. Sri lanka loose 2007 CWC due to outstanding performance of gilly.
Any day Gilchrist any day ... destructive
Dhoni in Odi and Gilchrist in tests.....dhoni was rank 1 odi batsman for 700+ days + 2 times icc odi batsman of the year....
If he has to lose 1 million then ask the same question......he would be honest
As a wicketkeeper always Gilly but as a finisher always Dhoni and as a captain
Both are the best in their respective eras, Dhoni's captaincy puts him ahead of Gilchrist....
I have been fan of Gilchrist since Sachin times but it was Dhoni who made be watch cricket again because I rarely saw someone playing the game actively on field like Australians before he became captain. One is best catch taker behind the wicket, and other is best at stumping. Sadly, MS never became an permanent opener like Rohit and Gilchrist was from the time when openers in ODI used to be perfect. I mean most of them used to score 100 without getting out and some of them were better hitter than Rohit.
Dhoni in ODI
Gilli in Tests
Here's the reason
Dhoni played 18 inn more than gili but have over 1.1k more runs than gilli
Gilli avg - 35
Ms avg - 50
(Here's the fact also is ms played at lower order/middle order still have 1.1k more runs in just 18inn)
Gilchrist had the luxury of Haydos, Langer, Ponting, Martyn, Bevan, Symonds and look at Dhoni it was only after 2008 he had a Prime Sehwag, Sachin, Gambhir, Yuvi, Bhajji & Zak later he had the likes of Rohit, Virat & Raina
Not easy being a WKB in Indian team 😢
Opener Gilly & Dhoni at 7 . Both are world record holder.
For 90s kids and being an Aussie fan , Gilchrist was a spectacular captivating mf Scarlet witch against every other bowler , God o God I still Love him ❤
As an Indian, my pick too would be Gilchrist, given his Test Record both as a keeper and batsman... It's much, much better than Dhoni... And that is how, at least I rate a player...
As a keeper, Gilchrist has records better than Dhoni??
Do you even know the abc of cricket dude? Or just thede random shorts are your source of knowledge 🤣🤣
@kvbnmkkm145 Do you have an idea of what you are talking about?? Are you sure you are not really on medication?? Look at Gilchrist test record, and MSD would die for such a record... Flat Track Bully Generation doesn't understand Cricket one bit and you are a prime example of the same...
@kvbnmkkm145 You don't even understand what Cricket sounds like, forget ABC of Cricket, dude... You are just a childish, know it all, piece of shit...
@kvbnmkkm145 Your problem, sin and crime is that you are an IPL fan... You are only as good... Great game of Cricket is unfortunate that people like you follow it...
@@kvbnmkkm145Try to watch international cricket more than ipl kiddo
Gilly is a principal/ roll model of wicket keeping school . He could have ask this question to dhoni. Being an Indian we always afraid of gilly during Aussie bowling . And this guy play at right time when there is a need . And this guy scored many overseas century in test than perform in their own country. So it’s obvious anytime Mr. clean Gilly .
The biggest difference is Gilchrist is a clutch player unlike dhoni who failed mostly in important games. Also Gilchrist have better strike rate even though he played on older generation
Forget about batting both Gilchrist and Dhoni are the best wicketkeeper also
Best thing about mcgrath he is never fake 😅
Wow all the Indians commenting Gili and in the video McGrath clearly says being an Aussie he has to select Gili. That’s patriotism and look here Indians as usual just individual fans😂.
Gilchrist was great fielder
In batting Gilchrist is better specially in test .... But dhoni with his mind always help in taking 1-2 wickets during match so it depends on team strength
It's as simple as that
Captaincy - Msd against anyone in the world
Wicketkeeper - Msd Again against anyone in the world
Batsmen - No doubt it's Gilchrist, Msd might have an edge in ODIs but Gilchrist is head and shoulders above Middle order batsman in tests .
Gilchrist & sangakara is pure luxury to have in team.
If you have ponting as captain then go for Gilchrist for wkb but if you want a captain who can bat nd keep wickets go for MSD
That's a really easy question... though I love dhoni more, he is my captain 🧢❤ answer is Gilchrist, a far more superior breed, those who understands cricket will definitely agree with me.
I'm am Indian..it's still gilly for me..he was just being kind...there is no comparison! It's like saying Sachin or pointing which is a better batsmen...and putting Ponting ahead because he was a great caption... Sachin was miles ahead it's not even a question!
Both are legend
It would be really a tough question if he has to pick between Gilchrist and Sangakkara .
Without the Captaincy skills: Gilchrist
WITH captaincy: DHONI all the way!
Gilchrist all time No 1. No question ❤
Obviously Gilli, why is that even a question?
Better keeper
Better batsman
Gilly was thousand times better no comparison ❤❤
GILCHIRST any day any time
Just look at the innings Gilly played in wc against India
He totally ate Indian bowlers.