Classical Musician's Reaction & Analysis: I CAN'T MAKE YOU LOVE ME by VOICEPLAY
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 06. 2024
- Join our CZcams community or Patreon to support the channel and for additional benefits!
/ @sirhairless
/ sirhairless
Sir Hairless reacts to VoicePlay's "I Can't Make You Love Me" (Bonnie Raitt cover)
As always, let me know in the comments of any songs or artists you'd like to see next, or anything else!
Check out my other reactions to VoicePlay in the VoicePlay playlist below!
• Playlist: VoicePlay
Check out my other acapella reactions at the playlist below!
• acapella
0:00 Preview
0:18 Intro
1:03 Reaction & analysis
19:16 Final thoughts
Special thanks to: Wadebowen Fan, Mary Hampton, *anon*, Anne-Marie Smith, Micah Olson, Shelley Oliver, Donald Quigley, Jas Pigot, Beverly Burch, William Flouro, Dónde está la biblioteca, Kat, Margo Bynon, David Bangston, Annette B, Margo Bynon, Dixie Burkhart, HDrider211, Rochelle Fisher, Laurie Reinertsen, Żaneta Kot-Skindel, Annika Ramhqvist, Anita Gupta, Ravyn, Russell McBride, Lana Simpson, Jewels, thisismetoday, G. Jazmin VG, Ms. Chuck Terry, Betsy Vondracek, Hans Flückiger, Nina Lopes, Kara L Joy, Coco Hol, peggy miller, Alan Hufstetler, Chris Hubbard, Jane McGee, Christopher Davis, Hitomi Ochiai, Dale & Carol Timberlake, Kat, Lisa Sharp, Emily D Civiletta, EmC, Becca Davis, Bettina Sade, Bonnie Deppen, Suzanne Damm O'Donnell, cofactorKarate, TJ in SC, Ellie Hartsfield, Panma, Amy Nance, B Sprak, Linda, NoNo, Dorothy Rosenberg, Nanci Flesher, Judy Williams, thisismetoday7423, Stephanie M, Chris Torkildson, Anna Kilvert, Tammy Kiernan, Margaret, Shelley, judith l, Eirene-Rose Skywalker, Megan Wheeler, Small Moments, Gerri Mesack, Paul Clark, Sally Kennett, Gerald, Stephanie Shifflett, Juliana Livingston, Mary Shields, Peter Hollens
#voiceplay #icantmakeyouloveme #bonnieraitt
==================
🔵 ATTRIBUTION 🔵
VoicePlay. I CAN'T MAKE YOU LOVE ME. CZcams. Aug 12, 2022, • I Can't Make You Love ...
================== - Hudba
Check out my previous VoicePlay reaction next! czcams.com/video/MKmbl_nok1Q/video.html
I absolutely adore you. That being said, thank you for another priceless reaction to Voice Play. Would you please do a reaction video to Geoff Castallucci's cover of Shenandoah ? I think it is one of his most beautiful covers.
@@marshayoung9387 Thank you That one is on my list for a future reaction 🎵
@@SirHairless Thank you❤️
This version always tears my heart out with Cesar so mournful. They filmed themselves separated throughout the house to accentuate the loneliness of the song. Geoff said they were all crying when singing, and he was in tears while editing. I think this is one of their best videos. If you want to see more of what EJ can do, please check out Voctave - they are sublime! A great example would be their Disney Princess Medley.
There are several songs that Voiceplay have done with EJ's brother Omar Cardona. Definitely check out Skyrim/The Dragonborn Comes and Dream On the Aerosmith cover.
I've never heard this group before, but man, that first lead singer's voice is absolutely gorgeous.
That’s Cesar DeLaRosa. If you want to hear more of him, he is also prominently featured in VoicePlay’s covers of Creep, Dream On, In The Air Tonight, The Lion Sleeps Tonight and We’re Good. But he has a piece of everything they’ve done since he joined a few years ago.
VoicePlay usually gives all the vocalists a featured moment or two in every song. It’s one of the things I love about them. 😊
You should check them out! They're amazing. You'll notice different members, some have come and gone. You may also want to check out the bass's solo channel, his name is Geoff Castellucci, the long haired gentleman in this video. "I See Fire" is a good starter. Something to mention, every man you see on the screen is Geoff, sometimes in costume, and every voice you hear is his. Just remember, for either Voiceplay or Geoff wear good headphones or use excellent speakers, watch videos to the very end, and enjoy!💙
I think you will enjoy "In the Hall of the Mountain King" .... something completely different from Layne's fantastical imagination 😉. This song is just beautiful - did you notice how they are not only in different rooms but also never make eye contact with the camera? Thanks again for a great analysis! 🌹🕊
I just commented about that except how Cesar looks right at the camera briefly at 14:15 here. I love his camera smolders. ❤
@@thisismetoday7423do you think they intentionally ask Cesar to look at the camera at least once, or he just sneaks them in every take knowing that they’ll have to use one?
@@SirHairless - now that is the million dollar question! 😉
@@SirHairless I’m not positive but from what I’ve seen in their behind the scenes videos they are all given their own creative freedom on how they want to express themselves during their parts. I think Cesar is just the more likely one to look at the camera like that because of his personality. I really hope you get to see him off set sometime. He’s a fun, sweet and sassy charatcter for sure! The VoicePlayers fell in love with him on his first feature with the guys which was “We’re Good”. Please add that one to your recommendation list, it’s really great! 😁
I love your smile at the beautiful opening. I get goosebumps every time at Cesar's tone in this. EJ's closing lines are a perfect bookend to the opening. The Cardona family have amazing vocal abilities.
Oh man! This VP rendition always rips out my heart! I just can’t get enough of those tight harmonies & soulful vocals!
This is one of the saddest songs I've ever heard. It is one of my favorite Bonnie Raitt songs. VP made a wonderful tribute to her. Love it.
EJ also did a cover of Go the Distance with VP that is *chef’s kiss*
Well, almost made it without crying. Cesar kills me. This is so beautiful and sad. They always bring the feels ❤
They did record a finale with all of them sitting outside on the porch with the sun setting behind them. Geoff chose not to use it; each one of them alone was the better aesthetic.
Another visual, none of them looks at the camera. None except Cesar that is; he can't resist that one side glance.
This is one of my favorites from them. For something a bit, well a lot more frenetic, try their version of their acapella version of In The Hall Of The Mountain King. Trust me.
This is one of my favorites! Love Cesar's vocal quality, and it's always fun seeing one of the Cardona brothers as a guest singer
EJ is wonderful. Check out Voctave's 'O Come, All Ye Faithful' ... EJ is the soloist and is just phenomenal.
This is one of my favorite VP covers. The song is about someone going through a complex cocktail of intense emotions that they are struggling to control. Really like hearing your analysis of what is going on musically to support that.
This one stole a couple of deep sighs from me… it’s such a soulful heartbreaker and lovely performance by those talented guys! Your insights were very interesting as always, and I love when you reproduce the notes you identify with your voice - it sounds beautiful and perfectly in tune (at least to me). Thank you very much!
All the feels in this one. This was a request from Cesar and Geoff said even he was in tears doing the editing.. And just so you know, the guys pronounce Cesar as in Julius. No stress on the second syllable. :)
I thought it was just his accent though I did see someone tell him to pronounce it C-Zar.. I’ve seen Cesar comment to pronounce it Sea-Sir. I usually say like the salad because I like food 😂
@@thisismetoday7423 I see some very odd suggestions at times. Like telling people to pronounce Eli as L-E. :)
@@christinestromberg4057 ha! I’ve seen that, too. I prefer saying like jelly because again… food 🤣
Haha yes I was told they’re pronounced “C-zar” and “Ellie”
@@SirHairless Right, Eli rhymes with jelly, or belly. I've seen it advised as L.E. which is quite odd. And Cesar is just like the salad, or as in Julius Ceasar. the spelling is different but the pronunciation is the same.
First of all Bonnie Raitt is the absolute best. She's a blues singer and blues guitarist. She recently won a grammy. Maybe you could review a few of her songs. As usual Voiceplay does a great job.
I'd never even taken full notice of that D5 above Layne's solo there, thanks for pointing it out!
O. M. G...you HAVE to jump into Voctave! I saw them live and they are amazing! Try Disney Princesses, Great Movie Medley, All Is Well, Prince of Egypt Medley....whew....anything you try will knock your socks off. Also, beware of Kate Lott, the choral piccolo.😯
It always amazes me (in a disappointed way, if that makes any sense) that this VoicePlay video doesn't have more views. I love the original by Bonnie Raitt, and this version certainly does the song justice - still heartbreaking, in a beautiful way.
This is one of the few VP songs that I can think of where there is no beatboxing, just finger snaps - Layne joins in with the other members in singing, and while he doesn't really get a solo, his contribution is definitely heard.
As the arranger, Geoff had pretty much total artistic control of the video, and chose to film everyone singing by themselves. He apparently had a final shot of everyone on the porch together, but decided against using it as he felt it would detract from the isolation he was going for with the video.
A beautiful song and video, and a great reaction and analysis!
Voiceplay can do no wrong, in my opinion. Incredible analysis as always! Also, I really hope you will add Voctave to your list of groups to react to. They are PHENOMINAL! Their top soprano is for highs what Geoff is for lows. It's a larger group, more of an ensemble, but their musicality and technicality is pristine! I don't even know what to suggest for where to start. Like Voiceplay, literally everything they do is amazing! Also, again like Voiceplay, their arrangements are stellar!
Awesome analysis mate...keep 'em coming... this is by far the most criminally underapreciated voiceplay cover imo, don't understad why cause it's wonderful
I completely agree! I can’t believe the low number of views on this one. It’s downright criminal.
EJ Cardona is the brother of Omar Cardona, who happens to be Cesar's best friend and did several songs with Voiceplay already, eg "The Dragonborne comes", "Carry on (wayward son)" and "Whiskey in the Jar" (which all are highly recommended). Oh - and "Dream on" (yes, the Aerosmith one), of course.
I think both EJ and Omar are great singers. 😊 I liked "Go the distance" very much.
I heard the reason they got EJ instead of Omar on this one was because Omar was competing on The Voice at the time. These brothers really are amazing! I also love Superstition which Omar was also featured. Oh, and Sleeping in the Cold Below! ❤
@@thisismetoday7423 True - how could I forget those two...
@@marge2548 Because there are so many good ones lol My problem is ever picking a favorite song of theirs. It usually happens to be whichever one I am listening to at the moment 🥰
@@thisismetoday7423 "Because there are so many good ones" - Yep, that's true.
There are two Cardona’s they feature. EJ and his little brother Omar. Both have such incredible diction, power, and control. There is no denying their vocal abilities. Dream On by voiceplay features Omar and is a must listen. Anything they do with the Cardona’s is next level.
E.J. is a regular with Voctave. They're a bigger a cappella group than PTX, VP or HF, but I love them. Maybe at Christmastime you might take a look at their "O Come, All Ye Faithful" on which EJ solos, or my favorite version of "Mary, Did You Know?" on which its lyricist, Mark Lowry, solos. EJ is among the group on that one. IDK, but they may be copyright protected. EJ's brother, Omar, also sings on occasion with VP. Check out their version of Aerosmith's "Dream On."
Great reaction, Sir.
I was introduced to Bonnie Raitt by a blues lover. I have always loved her since I first heard her.
VoicePlay does it justice. Their own spin on it is really lovely.
💖R/A🎼
EJ and Voctave are special to me. I'm a dedicated Homefry and appreciate Voiceplay, but if you hear EJ's "O Come All Ye Faithful", 17:26 you will want to celebrate Christmas in June!
I really enjoy your reactions. I will admit that I have a 12 year obsession with KPOP groups, EXO in particular, because of their use of harmonies. I happened onto Voiceplay and I became enchanted with this group too. Your reaction really helps me know what is going on musically and that it enhances my enjoyment of the genre. Please continue!
More EJ, and Voctave couldn't hurt, thanks
Geoff is the master of five part harmony
Thank you for another VP reaction. Your analysis (complete with alliteration) always increases my admiration for these beloved covers.
I like/love a song and after your analysis, Sir Hairless, I become aware of the intricacies of it and gain an even greater appreciation ... Thank you!
There are so many things to love this one: Cesar's solo, EJ's riffs and runs, Layne's singing part, Geoff's arrangement and bass, Eli's crazy high part, and lots of juicy chords. Your breakdown add another wonderful layer to this!! Great analysis!!
oh man, I've been waiting for you to do this one, it always gets me in the feels...very nice!
Last night 5/5/24 I was scrolling through a line of TikToks on YT and heard this from a man recording in his car and thought it so wise I had to write it down. I regret not having gotten his name. I came back to this VP reaction today, 5/6, and realized what the man on TikTok had to say was a restatement and expansion of the meaning and words of this song. He said, and I quote, "You’ll never be enough for the wrong person, but you’ll never be too much for the right person. So never go out of your way to convince somebody to love you properly, because you are special. You are unique, and you are not meant to be with everybody."
Great reaction and breakdown!! If I was FORCED to pick my ONE favorite tenor in a cappella these days... it would be EJ. from Voctave. If you want to hear him featured in a beautiful classic, try Voctave's version of "O Come, All Ye Faithful." To be honest, this song isn't my favorite, but that's the song... not the group. The GROUP does a fantastic job with this one!
I’m planning on using a Patreon request for this one when Christmas rolls around. EJ KILLED that song. Murdered. Dead. ☠️ Mary Did You Know is my actual favorite from Voctave though. ❤
You mentioned Voctave, I definitely think you would really enjoy this group. Absolutely beautiful voices. One of my personal favorites is a collaboration with Kirstin Maldonado of Pentatonix(“Disney Love Medley”)
Awesome reaction! If you want to see and hear more of E.J. And expand your acapella repertoire…..check out Voctave “O Come all ye faithful” so yea Christmas. However he is one of the members of Voctave and sings in all of their songs…I’d strongly encourage you to add to your acapella reactions with Voctave! You won’t be sorry.
I have loved this song for a long time. Love the chords, the lyrics, Bonnie Raitt’s raspy voice, the heart breaking emotion and exposed vulnerability. I always enjoy VP’s arrangements but I have to admit I miss the piano and the intimacy of one voice. This said, I can’t wait to see your react to Voctave. It’s ALL good but My two favorites are Disney Love Medley (ft Kirstin Maldonado from PTX and Jeremy Michael Lewis) and The Great Movie Medley (amazing tribute to John Williams’ movie scores). I’m sure you will enjoy their work. Thanks again. 🤗
You should checkout their version of the Little Mermaid. It's so fun!
Another perfect reaction to a perfect cover of a perfect song. I knew it was a marvelous arrangement, but as usual, you pointed out many intricacies that I didn't realize were happening. Sir Hairless, it's high time someone introduced you to a somewhat different style of modern a capella: you need to check out Voctave! I recommend their Great Movie Medley for starters. (Hint: all the music is from John Williams, but they sneaked in one of his great themes that's NOT from a movie.) By the way, E. J. Cardona's little brother Omar is a frequent collaborator with VoicePlay.
Thank you! Voctave are on my radar
@@SirHairless Great! I'll be watching for it! Wish I had more time for CZcams---a lot of your non-a cappella reactions look intriguing. Maybe when the semester's over . . .
🕸🕸🕸 .. this is a very important song Sir Hairless , from a very important musician. This song has always hit me right in the stomach. For all these years, it always stirs so many emotions. I knew Voiceplay would elevate the harmonies, and they certainly did. The vocals here are spine tingling. By now .. I am sure you have been told that Bonnie Raitt is not just a singer , but also a great song writer and a legendary guitarist. She is widely recognized as one of thr great blues guitar players , not only in women , but one of the best ever.
I will recommend a song from her early recordings that you might like. It is
" Give It Up Or Let Me Go " .. enjoy !!
Your description of the vocals here with Voiceplay are so great and educational. You really do hear much more than the average listener. 🎼🎼🎼🧞♂️🏆🧞♂️🎼🎼🎼
Happy to hear this cover if appreciated by people who know and love the original song! Both were a new experience for me 🎶
This was beautiful. Thank you for your analysis. I can't wait for you to discover Voctave. 😊
I adore how you react...since I'm a VP junkie, I hungrily listen multiple times to catch all the nuances...you do it superbly, giving more oomph to this aleady superb cover. As a dabbler in the music world (piano, guitar, recorder) I recognize and appreciate the talented singers sharing their gift with all of us. I wish you could do all their covers. But, while I will watch all your reactions for their brilliance, VP is on my radar. Blackbird, by Geoff and his four clones is my all time favorite, if you were wondering what other cover you might try next😊❤😊❤😊
This is Voiceplay's quiet masterpiece. I love the dissonance in this one. The house is set up for each person to be alone.
they are very good at these sadder songs
Oh no SH, this is one of my favorite songs and I was hoping you’d analyze the original. But now it’s too late. You already listened to it. 😜
Well at least Voiceplay did a great job with the arrangement. It was missing the desperation of the original. But it was still beautiful.
And your analysis was impeccable as always. ❤
Adele also sang a wonderful rendition, that always makes me cry 😢❤
One of the songwriters came up with the title after having read a story in a newspaper about a man who shot at his ex-girlfriend’s car.
In court he told the judge: "I learned, Your Honor, that you can't make a woman love you if she don't." 😂
Cooking? You are a chef! At last I figured it out!
I wish I could cook like a chef!
@@SirHairless I wonder if I will ever learn more about you??
@@susiepingleton3614 I'm sure you will! I just won't reveal my occupation
@@SirHairless Fair enough! Possibly you inherited a huge fortune and will never have to work? Your work is your love of music! Bravo?
@@susiepingleton3614 I wish that were the case! I work a job 9-6 and do CZcams outside of that 😅
Usually when I see your new r/a posts, I stop and grab my headphones straightaway. I saw this title this morning and reflexively hit my emotional breaks. I returned to your page periodically throughout the day… hoping I’d misread the song title. May I request a monthly limit (or at least only once weekly) to doing songs that actually give me chest pain?? And drag me right back to life moments like this one, so soon after Broken Vow? I’ve tried to comment twice on that, it was so beautiful, but just can’t form words. Bonnie Raitt’s performance, as in Lara Fabian’s , … well I just can’t separate the place these songs plunge me back in time to…decades.. the songs and the life experiences become forever entangled, intertwined. So if you could be so merciful as to spread songs like this a bit further apart, I’d be ever so grateful What saved me from it being any worse was the intermittent pausing and discussion. I was so struck by the placement throughout the house of each one in solitude. That was a brilliant decision for this piece. Ok, gah, and now it’s time for something completely different! Going to go search for Joyful and Silly for a bit.
I’ll second that. How about their Hall of the Mountain King!
Wow, and emotional one for you! Sorry about that You'd better have a word with the Egg members who request these songs 😉
Hopefully you still managed to enjoy the performance! 🙏 And I trust you found your joyful and silly?
@@SirHairless Ha, yes, oh my, I did get quite carried away in the moment..you may have noticed I can get as enveloped by lyrics as the musical piece. And yes, my never-fail cure? Superfruit! While they definitely do serious & emotional, they nail joyful and silly fun I’m all better again!
I hope you had the weekend adventure you’d hoped for..and welcome back!
I really appreciate the depth of your analysis; you do a wonderful job of explaining the dynamics and draw attention to thing that I don't always pick up on an initial listen. Thanks for sharing your expertise and your reactions!
Thank you
Love your analysis and VoicePlay!
If you want to be really stunned and amazed by E.J., you really must check out O Come, All Ye Faithful by Voctave. Voctave has so many amazing videos, you will love them!
Beautiful
Fantastic analysis as usual, good sir. I hope you'll check out Voctave soon and have your mind blown, heh heh! Cheers! //Rick
As always, incredible reaction and analysis. Thank you!
As always....love watching your brain process what you're hearing..and then hearing your analysis is even better. I i can see your eyes accessing things in your brain if that makes sense?? You catch so much more than so many other analysts that are super talented themselves.
Do you have perfect pitch?Synesthesia? ...or what do you attribute your musical attention/ability to?
Thank you
Haha thanks for the question! I don't have perfect pitch, but instead have relative pitch (which is defined by everyone differently and I believe comes at different 'levels' / on a spectrum)
The synesthesia question is very interesting, and I'm not quite sure how to answer it tbh! I think it's a bit too objective in terms of definition; all I can say is I 'feel' the music and can't really describe how Not a very helpful answer I know, sorry! In terms of attention/ability though, every musician excels at a different area. I spent a lot of my free time growing up trying to learn things by ear at the piano, and creating transcriptions of songs I liked, and then started doing arrangements. Also, a lot of my favourite music is from the Renaissance and Baroque periods - especially choral polyphony - so that probably helps listening out for different parts 🎶
Nice alliteration! But you forgot "stupendous" and "special," and "super."😉 Very interesting info, and great reaction!💙
I have so many notes!
1. Not to take away from anyone else because I really can’t pick a favorite in this group, I love them all so much. But Cesar is the MVP in this one. He does have such a beautiful voice but the way he expresses himself is equally as beautiful. Something I bet most people don’t notice... -No one looks directly at the camera in this entire video except Cesar at 14:15 here. I’ve noticed it in most of their videos, he finds a moment to look into the camera at us. Even if the other guys do it as well, it’s different the way he does it. Like he’s really looking into your soul.
2. I love the set choice for this video, they are all alone with their thoughts like you would be if going through what the song depicts.
3. I think this is the first time I’ve heard you audibly chuckle and it was during Eli’s solo.
4. EJ is also featured in Go The Distance which is also stunning.
5. I literally can’t wait for you to react to Voctave.
6. Yes, that was Layne you picked out singing.
I am a more prominent Home free fan but this was lovely - really nice job VP - my ears are singing. I have always loved Geoff. Nice breakdown, Sir.🥚- this is my only Sir emoji - where do you get those cute ones?
@@LaurieRein I belong to his CZcams membership and that’s how I have the extra cute egg emojis ❤️
@@thisismetoday7423 oh, I’m a Patreon member - I wonder if they are on that - never looked - thanks for heads up (so to speak)!
Thanks! I like those little details like the one you mentioned about Cesar looking at the camera 👀
@@LaurieRein unfortunately Patreon doesn’t offer custom emojis 😢
Your reactions help me to appreciate the music even more. Thanks
VoicePlay did a magnificent job with the arrangement and execution of this song. Just pulls at the heartstrings. Thanks for reacting to this song!
Thanks for this reaction to this song. It is beautiful and shows the emotional depths to VoicePlay. Quite a few of the comments below suggest reacting to In the Hall of the Mountain King next. Absolutely! I appreciate the soulful, emotive side of them so much when they bring their talents to songs that are pure fun. That one is a Layne arrangement so a contrast to a Geoff one.
This is a very special song for me - George Michael cover. The best.
Another great reaction/analysis! Thank you!
Hola desde Argentina... Cómo me gustan tus esplicaciones! Genio total!.. hacen que disfrute aún más la música de mi grupo favorito... Gracias!!! Un abrazo a la distancia 😊
I am just recently hearing VoicePlay’s work for the first time. It began with their rendition of “Daddy Sang Bass” which I liked. Con’t from there to Soundgarden and Metallica songs, and I’m pulled more in their direction. This is such an emotional yet also tired and resigned song. Overall I like what they chose to do.
It'd be great to see you listen to Teddy Swims' very heart-ful cover of this song. I love the Bonnie Raitt original.
❤❤❤❤❤
Please do Teddy Swims’ version of this song. He is an incredible singer and songwriter, with a couple of new singles that are fantastic!
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Please react to Jackson X Bi Bi release a new single feeling lucky Mv just check it out Thx 🙏
Saw your face get red, eyes get watery and swallowing hard….😢😢😢