The Easiest Language?!

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 2. 11. 2019
  • If you liked this video, you will love reading my book: Around the World in 60 Seconds www.nasdaily.com/book

Komentáře • 27K

  • @aethex8821
    @aethex8821 Před 4 lety +4169

    "entirely new language"
    "Very similar to English"
    .

  • @WatercraftGames
    @WatercraftGames Před 4 lety +2887

    "x doesn't exist"
    Math teachers: *_TRIGGERED_*

  • @Cabin.NET_
    @Cabin.NET_ Před rokem +21

    Pidgin is like how I talk to my younger siblings 💀

  • @russelluwarejnr1273
    @russelluwarejnr1273 Před rokem +141

    As a Papua New Guinean, I can confirm that pidgin is indeed an easy language. But to people who understand English, they will understand this language even more easily

    • @avalanche5790
      @avalanche5790 Před rokem +5

      its probably harder since we're used to all the grammar and stuff

    • @mrman2478
      @mrman2478 Před rokem +2

      U Sabi wetin I dey talk abi una pidgin dey diffrent

    • @sardorbektalatov3078
      @sardorbektalatov3078 Před rokem +1

      It may be easy to the native speakers not for all who can speak English for example for I understood the context about 20%

    • @LukeAkop2000
      @LukeAkop2000 Před 8 měsíci

      I am also from png

    • @ja2307
      @ja2307 Před 3 měsíci

      It is esporanto

  • @VVSslimeball
    @VVSslimeball Před 4 lety +21915

    Problem: Too many languages
    Solution: Another language

  • @RichardiOS275
    @RichardiOS275 Před 4 lety +4712

    Drew: This language is crazy
    Nas: The Easiest language
    me: Chinese English

  • @AhmedGamberli
    @AhmedGamberli Před 7 měsíci +16

    The complicated grammar or the extraordinary vocabulary is not what makes English complicated. It's all about the grammatical difference between English and the local languages. A new language doesn't fix the problem. Because it's a completely new grammar structure which will most probably differ from the all languages across the world at least as much as English.

  • @thequiz007
    @thequiz007 Před 6 měsíci +9

    I appreciate the effort you put into creating such engaging content.

  • @kamilak8899
    @kamilak8899 Před 4 lety +1495

    Me: how do you say dinosaurs in pidgin?
    Pidgin: Bird

  • @jomama8631
    @jomama8631 Před 4 lety +3655

    Easiest language: pidgin
    Groot: am I a joke to you?

  • @movie9416
    @movie9416 Před 3 měsíci +5

    Eeay to understand for me.Thank you!

  • @alexsevdalinov8990
    @alexsevdalinov8990 Před rokem +3

    1:36 why these letters are out, but they can use :
    C ----> K
    Q ----> K
    X -----> KS
    Z ------> S

  • @kanzu7743
    @kanzu7743 Před 4 lety +1996

    Plot Twist: The Person Who Made This Language Was Actually 3 Year Olds.

    • @CoolJude
      @CoolJude Před 4 lety +17

      JakePlayzc ッ “a three year old”* not “three years olds”

    • @namelessghoul615
      @namelessghoul615 Před 4 lety +35

      @@CoolJude are u serious -.- this is youtube

    • @tantanta___9
      @tantanta___9 Před 4 lety +1

      😂😂

    • @kanzu7743
      @kanzu7743 Před 4 lety +9

      @Cool Jude 100123
      Who gives a SHET

    • @CoolJude
      @CoolJude Před 4 lety +3

      Gacha Potato ... I was just correcting

  • @theoceanusneptune3993
    @theoceanusneptune3993 Před 4 lety +3542

    Pidgin Language: **exists**
    English Teachers: am i a joke to you??

  • @amanyhassan8167
    @amanyhassan8167 Před 10 měsíci +2

    It's like your telling us a new languages THANKS 😀

  • @tristanunits6261
    @tristanunits6261 Před rokem +8

    As a Nigerian I can tell you this is not the official language of any African countries it is just a way of speaking English, and is incredibly different. If you spoke English to someone speaking pidgin you wouldn’t understand, pidgin varies from nation to nation too, so Nigerian Pidgin is the same as pidgin in Guinea Bissau. In the countries there are languages per region like Igbo Eshan and Yuruba.

  • @duineeireannach6588
    @duineeireannach6588 Před 4 lety +1210

    Pidgin: *Exists*
    Pigeons: *oh yeah, it’s all coming together*

  • @valvenevercountsto3863
    @valvenevercountsto3863 Před 4 lety +12159

    It sounds like if an American was trying to speak Chinese

  • @user-hp3yy3we1i
    @user-hp3yy3we1i Před 8 měsíci +2

    I LITTRALY wanted my teacher to be like nas ; that's one minute see you tommorow

  • @TokyoBee
    @TokyoBee Před rokem +7

    There are actually different types of Pidgins and Creoles that are mixtures of the different languages represented in that area. For example, Papa New Guinea Pidgin and Hawaiian Pidgin may be similar with syntax and grammar, but vocabulary and phrases would be slightly different. Language is such an interesting thing. Pidgins are one of the coolest aspects of language, I feel.

  • @grave1234
    @grave1234 Před 4 lety +504

    This is how toxic 8 year olds talk
    in call of duty lobbies

  • @umaryuldashov9209
    @umaryuldashov9209 Před 4 lety +27166

    When you realize that you've been speaking Pidgin not English

    • @kcalb2382
      @kcalb2382 Před 4 lety +270

      Hahah yes

    • @tka3
      @tka3 Před 4 lety +619

      When realised speak Pidgin English not

    • @idkman7483
      @idkman7483 Před 4 lety +51

      My language here

    • @Haydunk
      @Haydunk Před 4 lety +161

      Wen u realse at me be spekn pidgin nat englis

    • @dumby1778
      @dumby1778 Před 4 lety +9

      Lol

  • @nadunlochana2956
    @nadunlochana2956 Před rokem

    I love this language cause I don’t know to do anything to participate AND it makes me feel smart since I just understand it. Throw in a bit of world peace and it’s perfect lol

  • @arza3716
    @arza3716 Před měsícem

    Esperanto was made as a second language for the whole world but only some people learnt it around the world but it’s in its second generation of native speakers

  • @excelsme480
    @excelsme480 Před 4 lety +22089

    Its the easiest language for people who speak english.

    • @qxraxx9007
      @qxraxx9007 Před 4 lety +402

      AxellsMe Not really, all you need to know is the English alphabet and how to pronounce the letters.

    • @irwincrook567
      @irwincrook567 Před 4 lety +569

      @@qxraxx9007 Not really. Your voacbulary should be enriched by English. A Chinese speaker would find it still difficult.

    • @joeflemo64
      @joeflemo64 Před 4 lety +85

      IKR if you were speaking to someone who was talking this language you would most likely understand a little they are saying

    • @KipsTr
      @KipsTr Před 4 lety +83

      For me this language is very useful. I am Italian and as I think you also know, in Italian the words are pronounced as they are read. So a language like this where just reading a word to pronounce it well is just perfect for us.

    • @elwasonbbmamarre7730
      @elwasonbbmamarre7730 Před 4 lety +8

      Es el español perro

  • @tiela.
    @tiela. Před 4 lety +5321

    Pidgin is broken English.

    • @BunEsub
      @BunEsub Před 4 lety +106

      Emaza得. My parents speak pidgin

    • @tiela.
      @tiela. Před 4 lety +34

      Crazy-Fehlize I’m mixed race but half Cameroonian and my father speaks Pidgin it’s broken English

    • @user-zq1cb4mv5g
      @user-zq1cb4mv5g Před 4 lety +32

      Lol pidgin reminds me when i was in kindergarten i didnt know english so i speak like pidgin cause i pronouned it kinda wrong my teachers Try so hard so i can understand it and now i know english i so happy i speak spainish and english

    • @tracado80
      @tracado80 Před 4 lety +15

      @@user-zq1cb4mv5g it looks you still have what
      To learn
      Just kidding but you you didn't type totally right

    • @kajajq6777
      @kajajq6777 Před 4 lety +2

      Emaza得. No one ask

  • @helpthisasian
    @helpthisasian Před rokem +1

    Night KaiKai sounds even harder to say than dinner honestly

  • @mimmi46-tl5mu
    @mimmi46-tl5mu Před 9 měsíci +3

    we speak am very well in Nigeria

  • @Mike-rz8qb
    @Mike-rz8qb Před 4 lety +1470

    online chatting is pigin

  • @metso3612
    @metso3612 Před 4 lety +669

    2019: Hey, how’s it going my my man?
    2050: hwy jmik

  • @Trebuh62016
    @Trebuh62016 Před rokem +1

    i had an excellent english teacher so i managed to fully learn how to speak english in 2-3 years

  • @FairPlayClubChads
    @FairPlayClubChads Před rokem +1

    For me french is one of the hardest language but its also the most precise one

  • @ace-4634
    @ace-4634 Před 4 lety +1544

    Person: “There is too many languages and it’s confusing. *Lets make a new language*

  • @whalencetacean
    @whalencetacean Před 4 lety +2242

    Germany meanwhile: *Donaudampfschifffahrtselektrizitätenhauptbetriebswerkbauunterbeamtengesellschaft*

  • @Penguinlover0
    @Penguinlover0 Před rokem

    I actually lern this language rn and i cna speak it around the world so ty nas daily for thius language

  • @AugustineDaniel-sl3nf
    @AugustineDaniel-sl3nf Před 9 měsíci +7

    YES..
    IM FROM PAPUA NEW GUINEA 🇵🇬 AND PIDGIN IS MY LANGUAGE

  • @iWildChxld
    @iWildChxld Před 4 lety +2928

    This sounds like if a caveman was trying to learn English

  • @nospeakingyt8130
    @nospeakingyt8130 Před 4 lety +616

    When you realize that you're not wrong you just speak Pidgin.

  • @acupoftaewithsugaandkookie8048

    This is how my little sister speaks
    When your ma’am corrects your grammar
    You: ma’am this is just another language

  • @CaptainLogan330
    @CaptainLogan330 Před 11 dny +1

    My grandpa actually spoke that language when he was a boy

  • @theodoresipols1192
    @theodoresipols1192 Před 4 lety +662

    This sounds like a caveman version of English.

  • @circleboi4900
    @circleboi4900 Před 4 lety +1060

    English: "I dont know anything"
    Pidgin: " me no know what what"

    • @anishmathewjose9374
      @anishmathewjose9374 Před 4 lety +13

      lol i laughed so hard :)))))

    • @_slay1214
      @_slay1214 Před 4 lety +2

      lmao😂😂

    • @girl4737
      @girl4737 Před 4 lety +4

      Mi no no wat

    • @lk7l252
      @lk7l252 Před 4 lety

      I'm laugh lot lot🤣🤣🤣

    • @ldqbaz
      @ldqbaz Před 4 lety +4

      "aku tidak tau apa apa". sounds normal in Bahasa Indonesia. so why it language not nominated as the most easiest

  • @S10Editz12
    @S10Editz12 Před měsícem +1

    He dident say “That’s one minute see u tomorrow “💀

  • @Bombastic_moment
    @Bombastic_moment Před rokem

    In tagalog coffe filipino says kape school paaralan shoes sapatos chair upuan or silya towel says tuwalya

  • @bigscaryhacker8403
    @bigscaryhacker8403 Před 4 lety +1402

    (Me watching this video).
    My mum: can I come in ur room?
    Me: YU NO KEN KAM INSAIT

  • @suchangburagohain
    @suchangburagohain Před 4 lety +2082

    English : Genius, brilliant, prodigy.
    Pidgin language : Big Brain

  • @SoulTheDarkKnight
    @SoulTheDarkKnight Před 9 měsíci

    Im not american but i learned english pretty fast because in the quarantine there was nothing to do except for surf around the internet and it was pretty fun so to communicate and understand things better i learned it but without like any difficulty because i wasn't determined or anything it happened without any like training you can call it i guess it just happened with time

    • @kakarotgoku3869
      @kakarotgoku3869 Před 2 měsíci

      How old were you when you started learning English?

    • @SoulTheDarkKnight
      @SoulTheDarkKnight Před 2 měsíci

      @@kakarotgoku3869 around 6-7 years old

    • @SoulTheDarkKnight
      @SoulTheDarkKnight Před 2 měsíci

      i just realized even in this comment i made my grammar wasn't that good i guess i was still learning

  • @leeduong4301
    @leeduong4301 Před 2 měsíci +1

    Pidgin sounds like “pigeon”

  • @or6169
    @or6169 Před 4 lety +2982

    "English is actually pretty difficult to learn"
    "This is an entirely new language"
    *"very similar to english"*
    *that's a bruh moment for sure*

  • @piradex6871
    @piradex6871 Před 4 lety +1766

    When you already occasionally spoke pidgin

    • @chain3612
      @chain3612 Před 4 lety +10

      @PiradeX We know how speak Pidgin

    • @noonxrs
      @noonxrs Před 4 lety +34

      @@chain3612 yis wi no haw spik Pidgin

    • @Devauron
      @Devauron Před 4 lety +6

      @@chain3612 pidgin better fraum English

    • @zahmth
      @zahmth Před 4 lety +1

      what you mean?

    • @MaeKura
      @MaeKura Před 4 lety +20

      @@zahmth yu no hav spek pidgin?

  • @xxtentacionfan990..
    @xxtentacionfan990.. Před 10 měsíci

    france and spain is hard for me but i gonna understand right now and i can say many thing in english without learn it i started like 1month before and i know nothing just know it of games, videos, tv shows, like x's, and slangs and for me in english speaking is more difficult for me than writting.(im from hungary)

  • @roseyquinn3707
    @roseyquinn3707 Před rokem

    My mom was in Preu most of her life and she went to a English school tho

  • @e46racers
    @e46racers Před 4 lety +1686

    Jokes on you this language was created when russians started playing csgo

  • @misuri1368
    @misuri1368 Před 4 lety +682

    This language sounds like tourists who don't speak English perfectly...
    “You no come inside”

  • @sharky9079
    @sharky9079 Před rokem

    They have that here in hawaii where I am

  • @zaku2552
    @zaku2552 Před 4 lety +1287

    "English is hard"
    Entschuldigung?😂

    • @zaku2552
      @zaku2552 Před 4 lety +5

      @Jimi Harju kyllä

    • @distressedbrain
      @distressedbrain Před 4 lety +20

      Finnish:
      Let introduce ourselfs.

    • @thatsabruhmoment6999
      @thatsabruhmoment6999 Před 4 lety +57

      Ever heard of Chinese?

    • @svdenterdragon
      @svdenterdragon Před 4 lety +16

      @@thatsabruhmoment6999 ever heard of polish

    • @lol-tm9mx
      @lol-tm9mx Před 4 lety +16

      german ain't hard to but that's probably because im dutch and it's similar to german :')

  • @squid5301
    @squid5301 Před 4 lety +3617

    English isn’t hard to learn
    source: I’m russian

    • @sheiverain
      @sheiverain Před 4 lety +20

      for germans it is

    • @zellto2120
      @zellto2120 Před 4 lety +113

      ​@@sheiverain it's not tf? every normal german person who is not completely dumb can speak english at least relatively good. i'm german as well and i speak english better than my own language lmao.

    • @sheiverain
      @sheiverain Před 4 lety +9

      @@zellto2120 you write the word that is taught to be written capital in literally first grade not capital

    • @demoriginal
      @demoriginal Před 4 lety +2

      Memerman9000 i like ur pfp

    • @J-KCs
      @J-KCs Před 4 lety +17

      No, it isn't. I am from hungary and the english language sounds so fucking too simple, and easy like I can't tell it.

  • @eunjaelee5872
    @eunjaelee5872 Před měsícem +1

    "This is a real problem around the world" It's not a problem. English is world-wide language that everyone has to learn. So if they can't speak english, not our problem. Also the simplified version of english is harder.

  • @moviebg4662
    @moviebg4662 Před 7 měsíci +1

    English is extremely simple compared to the most languages like there is lack of word forms, object genders, many tenses and much more so its simple to understand.

  • @MaGiiCalStArZ1
    @MaGiiCalStArZ1 Před 4 lety +698

    “U no ken kum insite”
    *me talking to my Brazilian gold digger* no babie

  • @lollol4237
    @lollol4237 Před 4 lety +708

    If my English teacher see's this video he is going to get a terrible heart attack.

  • @Cello69.
    @Cello69. Před 4 měsíci +1

    Pidgin: our language is easy and breaks all grammar rules.
    Ebonics: hold my beer.

  • @ReaLegend
    @ReaLegend Před rokem

    I guess i already knew how to write/say this languague when i was 6yr old

  • @pachia2794
    @pachia2794 Před 4 lety +1233

    This just looks like if a little kid just learned to talk

  • @metal9076
    @metal9076 Před 3 lety +2149

    Roblox players: ive discovered a new language by accident...

    • @airen8009
      @airen8009 Před 3 lety +8

      Lol

    • @d1va565
      @d1va565 Před 3 lety +2

      😂

    • @shavingmypiano
      @shavingmypiano Před 3 lety +9

      Launage is tags

    • @mega_chair9507
      @mega_chair9507 Před 3 lety +7

      For me its language of
      AJAJAJAJAJJAAH
      SKILL ISSUE AJAJAJJAAJAJ
      EZEZEZEZEZEZEZEZE
      AJAJAJAJAJJAJAJAJ
      EZEZ AJAJAJA SKILL ISSUE NOOB TS NOOB AAJAJAJAJ

    • @lilifame7571
      @lilifame7571 Před 3 lety +22

      Wow a nice #### I #### ####

  • @timothymaefunu4454
    @timothymaefunu4454 Před 8 měsíci

    I know pidgin i am from Solomon Island too but at guagalcanl

  • @Haah_lah
    @Haah_lah Před rokem +1

    My sis said:Launge for lazy people
    Me: heh thats my dream

  • @phatpengu
    @phatpengu Před 3 lety +1004

    “Pidgin”
    Me: *says the word*
    Me: *p i g e o n*

    • @chandlersmonica.9287
      @chandlersmonica.9287 Před 3 lety +19

      How about thinking that the language is named after pigeon becuz in ancient times pigeons were used as a communication source ( sending letters etc. ) So the language does the same it helps communicate. ,😅😅

    • @racketchallenges6813
      @racketchallenges6813 Před 3 lety +6

      Me: *pidgey*

    • @mrsprite399
      @mrsprite399 Před 3 lety +1

      @@chandlersmonica.9287 good point. I agree

    • @cat-mr2tw
      @cat-mr2tw Před 3 lety +2

      you pidgin yes pigeon no?
      xd
      lmao
      yes
      you no kam inside me room >:(

    • @elcapatazsnb
      @elcapatazsnb Před 3 lety +3

      Piglin

  • @matiascarvajal2304
    @matiascarvajal2304 Před rokem +1

    who is gonna tell him that every Latin American mom already knows it

  • @valvihk3649
    @valvihk3649 Před rokem +13

    I am a fluent Russian and Ukrainian speaker. I studied Japanese and Arab. English is the easiest language that I came across. You don't have to be perfectly fluent, most English speakers are not. They think their language is the hardest because they didn't study English grammar. Neither did I, and I went to American school. I learned by listening and started speaking fluently within 6 months.

  • @snuckle2421
    @snuckle2421 Před 3 lety +886

    If that is similar to english, then what happen for those who never heard English?
    *Error 100*

  • @craftycrafts1526
    @craftycrafts1526 Před 4 lety +698

    “They thought that there were just too many languages so they...
    Made an entire new language”

  • @Medkit_Healer
    @Medkit_Healer Před rokem +1

    Bro imagine you’re meeting a friend and he said “wanna eat KaKa”

  • @kemalsunalinmekanicennetol5746

    Okey bat aym so cuul raight

  • @justsomekirbowithoutamusta1852

    Germany: *laughs in Rindfleischkennzeichenettikettierungsüberwachungsübertragungsgesetz*

    • @DominikFXO
      @DominikFXO Před 4 lety +45

      Alles klar

    • @DecrareOld
      @DecrareOld Před 4 lety +59

      warum ist das ein wort?

    • @FlickerAL
      @FlickerAL Před 4 lety +10

      Säntier

    • @d4rkm334
      @d4rkm334 Před 4 lety +27

      Das ist kein Wort oder? Ich meine welcher Manfred hat das schon wieder erfunden brudda

    • @caca5492
      @caca5492 Před 4 lety +9

      Wollte ich auch Sagen english ist nicht so schwer wie deutsch

  • @muttosaur1813
    @muttosaur1813 Před 3 lety +877

    “There is too many languages in the world”
    Proceeds to make a new language

  • @Skylermaxwell13
    @Skylermaxwell13 Před rokem

    I learned how to sing alphabet in English backwards in second grade I also know how to write the whole alphabet in cursive and that wasn't also in second grade

  • @valentinlechner4079
    @valentinlechner4079 Před měsícem

    Yeah a pidgin language is basically a simplified language or a language that develops when people who don’t have the same native language try to communicate with each other.

  • @aisakataiga4880
    @aisakataiga4880 Před 4 lety +887

    "Too many languages"
    *makes another one*

  • @joofers7856
    @joofers7856 Před 4 lety +676

    Pidgin: I am the easiest language
    Sims language: am I a joke to you?

  • @Girlerfec
    @Girlerfec Před 10 měsíci

    I'm Filipino but I trained English because I want in america when I grown up

  • @delish9637
    @delish9637 Před 6 měsíci

    Wow I just heard abt this language and I’ve just realized that I’m fluent in it too 😂

  • @gameshorts3356
    @gameshorts3356 Před 2 lety +1418

    *me speaking in pidgin*
    *my sister : fix your English*
    *me : it’s not English*

  • @elsaoldenburg3811
    @elsaoldenburg3811 Před 2 lety +5894

    Every English beginner is unknowingly a fluent in Pidgin.

    • @shianism2772
      @shianism2772 Před 2 lety +44

      Probably

    • @SuperDzack
      @SuperDzack Před 2 lety +18

      Yes

    • @w-1169
      @w-1169 Před 2 lety +17

      Yes true icecap

    • @ryu._j1n
      @ryu._j1n Před 2 lety +27

      Yeah true when I was in kindergarten I could speak it fluently XD

    • @favourabraham5444
      @favourabraham5444 Před 2 lety +7

      @@mkieran2619 exactly. What nas actually said (to me) isn't the right pidgin. But it might be another language, but I for sure know that there is no other pidgin language
      FYI eat is chop not what he said in the video.

  • @Legendaryassasin
    @Legendaryassasin Před 7 měsíci

    am from ctoatian and i learnd english myself and am 9 years

  • @ArthurTaylor
    @ArthurTaylor Před rokem +1

    Um guys, as a Belizean, this sound like creole lol. Because is like a broken English. For example, regular English would say Where is my cup, Creole would say that sentence like Weh mi cup de or like Which pat mi cup de. Another example would like I will go to the shop, creole version of that sentence will be I qwen da de shop. So yea, this reminds me of creole

  • @nugget2366
    @nugget2366 Před 2 lety +633

    imagine a person that lives in a jungle telling an english person were they live
    "I live in a big bush"

  • @whatislife3967
    @whatislife3967 Před 3 lety +655

    Pigeon:*exists*
    Pidgin: I'm about to ruin this man's whole career

  • @Fizzy_Lars
    @Fizzy_Lars Před 3 dny

    I know about Majjin Buu's Language ages ago.

  • @avrinrose5457
    @avrinrose5457 Před 3 měsíci +1

    In my fictional world, most people worldwide can speak English

  • @hl-fl7sy
    @hl-fl7sy Před 4 lety +1448

    Friend: Me come inside?
    Me: You no come inside, me eat night food

  • @roroscript8264
    @roroscript8264 Před 3 lety +578

    If I just spoke this at my English teacher 😂😂😂

  • @Jager71604
    @Jager71604 Před 7 měsíci

    English: Actualy easy
    Pidgin: English but having a stroke

  • @VArsovski10
    @VArsovski10 Před rokem

    Honestly, no
    Learninga new languagecan be a challenge butalsoa humblingexperience
    800+ languages is not a problem, its a blessing on its own

  • @alexadk5438
    @alexadk5438 Před 4 lety +345

    English: I'm tall
    Pidgin: Me me big boy

  • @crappysauce9776
    @crappysauce9776 Před 4 lety +538

    My teacher:who broke the glass of water
    Me: *mi,yu,ol*

  • @sams4948
    @sams4948 Před měsícem

    its like creating a new distro.
    coz there a two many.

  • @liam.h7472
    @liam.h7472 Před rokem +1

    All his videos compared to one video would be insane

  • @spencer5508
    @spencer5508 Před 3 lety +170

    Duolingo bird : chuckles, I'm in danger.

    • @bido64
      @bido64 Před 2 lety +3

      Duolingo bird vs the Pidgin Pigeon

  • @roastingpotatoes6022
    @roastingpotatoes6022 Před 4 lety +671

    Well this sucks, my name starts with one of the only letters that have been removed