I think them being honest and frank with each other is one of the reasons why they've stayed together for so long and are close. There is no faking in the group. They have a real relationship based on honesty and trust.
that moment when all you can do it is just listen to it but do nothing to help him.. seems like he already knew about it... but still he could have asked the members for help... can't help it but my eyes don't obey and tears keep running out... Miss him a lot... Miss you Jong Hyun aa 😪😢😢😢😢
Notice when he said he won't do it without the members It meant the members by his side is the one who kept him going for 9 years achieving his passions and exploring his creativity
His friend received his letter 2 weeks before but didn't tell no one and released it after his family's approval like why didn't he inform his mom or sister when he received a letter from Bling Bling
in an ice cream interview didn't jonghyun said that he doesn't want to be an idol in his next life but if its gonna be with the other members then he'd gladly be an idol again. Only if its Shinee. jjongD is making me cry
He has been suffering for so long. 😭 he has been talking like this for so long. ...the members were his strength. But the moment he felt alone he just disappeared 😭.. May his soul rest in peace.
I'm crying too...I can't believe he's not here anymore. He was always so kind. His supportive and warm personality is why he was my bias ever since the first video I saw of shinee. In his last letter, he said that the celebrity life wasn't for him. I wish we saw how much pain he was in. I wish we could've helped him. He deserved the world. We love you Jonghyun. We always did, we do and we always will.
Jonghyun is so compassionate and filled with love. The fact that he would not be SHINee again if it wasn’t the same members shows how close they are. And he is right, SHINee would not be SHINee without the 5 of them only. And the fact that he never thought about breaking up also warms my heart. Although he physically left us, he will forever be in your hearts and SHINee will also be 5. I’ve been there with them since day one of debut till today and forever. My life during my HS years was heavily shaped and inspired by SHINee.
I love how SHINee are very frank with each other and don't try to sugarcoat things. The disbanding questioning from the radio dj was kinda weird though... like even if theoretically things weren't going well (which fortunately they are) of course they're not going to say that they have plans on disbanding especially when they're in the middle of promotions as 5???
I agree he Seokjin was a little weird, bu he is weird xD hahaha no, but SHINee is known to have been going the same since debut, never lost a member, not really any scandals and always been popular from debut.... So I guess Seokjin was curious about if things will keep goin on this bright path??
It's honestly not that weird seeing as most kpop groups disband around year 5. They (and other groups past this mark) haven't gotten this question a lot.
i think it makes sense actually because quite a few groups from around the time they debuted have been disbanding. i do think it's a pointless question though because it's clear how much they communicate with each other and how much like a family they are.
이 미 나 Not exactly. He just said that shinee will be together until a member's health is not good. Sadly, due to the amount of awful people and terrible professional he found... he felt like he could not heal himself.... We don't deserve someone so pure and wise like Jonghyun. All he did in his life was to give light and love with his art and talent.
@@aayushisingh9666 no, not really. He was battling depression for many years. However unfortunately mental health problems aren't really treated well if at all in most East Asian countries, south Korea included, people don't really know how to support someone through that and he did get the help he needed.
What makes them a great group is that they know that they are in a business and that they must put their business first before themselves. This system works well for them that you can never see them slack off in whatever it is they do even when they get the short end of the stick.They kept on improving and improving all through these years. The fact that there are also just five of them in the group makes it easier for their handlers and Onew to manage them so they shine individually without sacrificing the image harmony of the group. They are also very honest but are discreet with their actions being very careful not to cause scandals. They may nt be SM's best selling artists but as a group they are the best in many aspects such as their overall artistry and CD perfection live singing while doing difficult choreographies. I have nothing but admiration for the group.
Yes you are right they actually were able to adjust them selves and not to cross each other boundaries and not to revealing each other secrets to the media like what super junior members used to do and they have a very good team work every one would cover for the other that is why they lasted for such a long time
@@aa-cx8wb What I have learned to admire about them is that their artistry and being honest to that and their development has allowed them to excel in more ways than one. I see how they have trully become multi-talents and owning their spaces 100% while being a Shinee family. Their longevity will be that...not that selling at #1 isnt important, but think being seen as experimental has given them more freedom than most Kpop groups as they try new things and learn new things all the time. Their growth is nice to see. (November 2022)
Jonghyun stayed true to what e said that shinee will stay together until they physically fall apart . Now he is physically gone from this world.... I cant even say anything . 😭 May his soul rest in peace. 😭
Their relationship are really gold. Especially where jjong said he will be in SHINee again if the members are still the same. I like them very much. SHINee fighting.
I love SHINee relationship and how they managed to stay together for so long...I hope new groups that I stan can look up to them and last that long as well too...and yes I know it's groups that older than them but some of their members have decided to leave their group...SHINee Together FOREVER!!!!
"We are not going to be like that unless we physically fall apart" -Jjong puppy. I'm not crying you are😭😭the most beautiful and real brotherhood relationship❤️
Jonghyun is so kind and considerate - he tried not to embarrass and tried to protect their manager when taemin said that he is single since birth. I miss him..
i never knew tht whn jonhyun said tht they wont be leaving shinee unlessl they r physically apart he genuinely meant tht. i wish all this was jst a dream
Aw my baby Jjong defending manager hyung!! This man.. Oh lord this man is the death of me!! How kind can he be.. Oh my God neomu saranghamnida Jonghyun oppa!!!
I'm so mad, and sad, and frustrated, I wish you'd come back. I'm sorry and I miss you and love you so much. Everyone is in pain and I hate it. I wish I talked to you, we both had the same thing. The only difference is I battled for 4 years and finally got the right meds. I wish you did too. I'm on this roller coaster of emotions, I'm sad for a while then happy watching memories of you then devastated again. You were so beautiful and kind and just such a lovely human being. I wish you found a solution.
Shinee has always stood out to me as having a unique dynamic. At first I thought it was a little strange but I've grown to truly appreciate it. They seem to have a genuine and mature respect for one another. And really see each other as equals. It's admirable.
With his innate and immense talent, we know Jonghyun can go solo from the time of their debut and be successful, so him saying with conviction that he'd never thought about disbanding is impressive. He had a taste of success with his solo album and he was not blinded with the temptation that he can be on his own now, he's rooted to Shinee, apparently.
Am I the only one who got teary eyes when they started talking about disbanding and stuff? Like as a Shawol for 3yrs-ish, ofc Ik that they're not that "kind" of group but still, in this kind of industry, u just never know. I like how the members answer the question about it, they're not sugarcoating their answer, i.e. saying cliché stuff, but proving how strong their relationship is and doing the most important thing, communication.
maria kamille esplana I would've preferred a million times for Jonghyun to leave the group to get some proper treatment in the U.S or anywhere where he wouldn't have a quack psychiatrist provide him no support towards a path of recovery. Poor baby, he suffered so much. I hope with death he finally got the peace he wanted even though millions of hearts were shattered. #YouDidWellJonghyun
Mc: Are the member tired of it (Shinee) Kim Jonghyun: *Actually we aren’t going to be like that unless we physically fall apart* 18/12/17~ Why did you fall apart...?
Gosh I'm used to Shinee 😐 and not as a fangirl Its like I have massive respect for them And their music stirs my soul,their bond makes me feel warm,gosh they keep me sane and the same time they make me so emotional 😢 Gosh I never knew that this could happen to me
I have checked lots of SHINee clips and I really think that the depression got to him the last two three years. In earlier shows you could see he enjoyed doing them and he looked like he enjoyed himself but the more recent ones he looks so hollow and serious in them. Sad that no one noticed this chance. Sad that he had to go the way he did, if only he'd known that there was a way to conquer depression and that wasn't in depending on others but understanding that it's you who has to do it on your own. I'm speaking from experience. I've also always depended on others to help me through my depression but Ive learned that the only way to conquer it is by doing it yourself and knowing that relying on others will only make u dissapointed even more. It's really sad, I can't imagine how the members are feeling now. I can't imagine a smile upon their faces anymore.
I keep thinking about the other members too ....i feel like minho and taemin will be especially hollow for a long time....i feel like the spark in their eyes will disappear...its not like jonghyun died naturally too...he committed suicide took his own life in sadness...there is no way the members will be normal from now on its so sad :(
Jiggly Rose Same just the thought of them not being the same anymore and at such a young age kills me. I'm so sad for them. It's so sad they were such a perfect group. I wish Jonghyun would have realised what kind of impact his existence had for the others. I guess he depended too much on others to bring him out of his depression and I guess that was his downfall :(
i think the reason i keep thinking about minho/taemin more is because key/onew already expressed themselves online in a way it was comforting? but taemin seemed soo angry at the funeral and minho is terrible at expressing his emotions + type to blame himself so i worry about him a lot...i heard he went to filming the rest of his movie but im not ready to see pictures of him tbh
Jiggly Rose I get what you mean but even if the others havent expressed themselves yet, I think they all are suffering equally. Idk I'm worried about Key even cause they were extremely close but yeah Idk they all were really close I hope they can close this chapter peacefully in due time
But that's the problem with people who have depression. They feel they need to handle everything on their own so they don't become a burden to those they love. It does help if someone is there to listen to them or just there so they know they are not alone. If you have been a long time fan of SHINee you would know Jonghyun never hid his depression from the fans and the general public. In fact, it's also known that Onew has depression too. If anyone understood Jonghyun the most, it's his leader. Because he knew what Jonghyun was going through, he took the news of his passing the hardest out of the whole group. The other 4 are noticeably affected too. How could they not be? That's their brother and band mate. Depression is not the same for everyone. Some can fight and help themselves out of their mental stress but some can't do it any longer. They just want the pain and emptiness to end. This was the case with Jonghyun. What you said about trying to help themselves out of it can only do so much. If there is no therapy or understanding from others, how can they have the will to live on? What you said is not that simple for everyone to grasp. You need to learn that yourself.
*Rewatching this on 12/20/17 is so painful so so painful i can't stop crying it feels so unreal that he's gone. Jonghyun rest in peace angel god..this hurts.*
I'm back here because of Jonghyun (Dec 18, 2017) how much he loves shinee, his dorkyness. SHINee is the first group that makes me love Kpop 😭😭😭 still don't want to believe that Jjong had left us, shinee will always be 5 😭😭😭
I believe in his words here where he would still be in SHINee with the same members.. He really loves Onew Key Minho Taemin and SHINee World... I miss you Jjong so much..
Physically fall apart but never the heart of them. 5 hearts are always staying together. 5HINee is truly a family that will never fall apart, all 5 of them.
Whenever I want to lift my spirits up,I turn to shinee Whenever I want to feel happy, sad,joyful, any other emotions,I turn to shinee Whenever I want to calm myself ,I turn to shinee Whenever I want to control my madness,intensity, stress,I turn to shinee Whenever I want to be strong, I turn to shinee Whenever I want to feel hopeful, loved I I to shinee I know how it sounds But can't help it And not saying it as some fangirl Welcome back shinee 💖
No matter what Shinee will forever be shinee. Even though we lost our sweet Jjong ❤️, they’re still is 5 members. 4memebers 1 angel ! 5hinee forever and always 💕🔐
Jonghyun keep his promise.. He still with Shinee until he fall apart.. I hope the rest member can stay together too until they fall apart and God will meet them again in heaven.. RIP angel. You did the best. Thanks for everything. We always here for you and your best brothers.
"Which member would you like to introduce with your sister??" Jong🦕:members except Minho🔥 and Key🗝️.....(both are energetic) Me:wth??! Okay!;;(Reason seems correct) Minho🔥:Onew hyung🐇(he understands everyone) Me:okay good!!! (I too agree with the reason) Taemin🧀:Manager Me: can't stop laughing 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Taemin and Manager's story is a never ending saga.......
NEVER DISBAND!! NEVER EVER!! I will legit cry. I have gone through enough heartbreaks from my favorite group disbanding. SHINee needs to stay together till they are old!
![[Eng] SHINee Roleplay: calling their "girlfriends"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QugW-UjgVjg/mqdefault.jpg)
![[샤.계.한] EP.1-3 우리는 왜 서로의 말을 안 들을까 | Spoiler](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JVJk4mttK74/mqdefault.jpg)
Taemin is always promoting the manager 😂😂😂
Sakshi Karande hahaha ikr😂
"PROMOTING" HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!
ikrrrr😂😂
I shipp taenager
...To this days 😂😂
I think them being honest and frank with each other is one of the reasons why they've stayed together for so long and are close. There is no faking in the group. They have a real relationship based on honesty and trust.
Lets cherish these things. I miss you, Jonghyun.
“ we’ve been together for a long time. we aren’t gonna get tired of it unless we physically fall apart.”
기누 that moment you realize it
I can't help but miss him 😢
that moment when all you can do it is just listen to it but do nothing to help him.. seems like he already knew about it... but still he could have asked the members for help... can't help it but my eyes don't obey and tears keep running out... Miss him a lot... Miss you Jong Hyun aa 😪😢😢😢😢
Notice when he said he won't do it without the members
It meant the members by his side is the one who kept him going for 9 years achieving his passions and exploring his creativity
His friend received his letter 2 weeks before but didn't tell no one and released it after his family's approval like why didn't he inform his mom or sister when he received a letter from Bling Bling
in an ice cream interview didn't jonghyun said that he doesn't want to be an idol in his next life but if its gonna be with the other members then he'd gladly be an idol again. Only if its Shinee. jjongD is making me cry
Awww Jonghyun :')
I'm crying even more with what happened last night... jonghyun.. you'll be missed...
He has been suffering for so long. 😭 he has been talking like this for so long. ...the members were his strength. But the moment he felt alone he just disappeared 😭.. May his soul rest in peace.
I'm crying too...I can't believe he's not here anymore. He was always so kind. His supportive and warm personality is why he was my bias ever since the first video I saw of shinee. In his last letter, he said that the celebrity life wasn't for him. I wish we saw how much pain he was in. I wish we could've helped him. He deserved the world. We love you Jonghyun. We always did, we do and we always will.
"...unless we physically fall apart" jonghyun...RIP
HappyTofu I guess he was right about that - wasn't he?
SHINee hwaiting! You did very well Jonghyun...
Feeling very sad...miss you jonghyun .stay strong shinee........
SHINEE is five forever...
RIP jonghyun
Jonghyung😭😪
@@sofiher37 um that’s not his name
Jonghyun is so compassionate and filled with love. The fact that he would not be SHINee again if it wasn’t the same members shows how close they are. And he is right, SHINee would not be SHINee without the 5 of them only. And the fact that he never thought about breaking up also warms my heart. Although he physically left us, he will forever be in your hearts and SHINee will also be 5.
I’ve been there with them since day one of debut till today and forever.
My life during my HS years was heavily shaped and inspired by SHINee.
Gozuag Xiong I miss him so much
Sujuelf Emy yes, we shall continue to live in his loving memories.
Gotta love the mutual agreement that they wouldn't do all that shit with anyone else.
I love how SHINee are very frank with each other and don't try to sugarcoat things. The disbanding questioning from the radio dj was kinda weird though... like even if theoretically things weren't going well (which fortunately they are) of course they're not going to say that they have plans on disbanding especially when they're in the middle of promotions as 5???
I agree he Seokjin was a little weird, bu he is weird xD hahaha
no, but SHINee is known to have been going the same since debut, never lost a member, not really any scandals and always been popular from debut.... So I guess Seokjin was curious about if things will keep goin on this bright path??
It's honestly not that weird seeing as most kpop groups disband around year 5. They (and other groups past this mark) haven't gotten this question a lot.
SHINee35 I actually like that question... their replies made e pretty touched. :)
i think it makes sense actually because quite a few groups from around the time they debuted have been disbanding. i do think it's a pointless question though because it's clear how much they communicate with each other and how much like a family they are.
jonghyun leave us already 😢
" we aren't going to be like that unless the members physically fall apart, " - jonghyun... he decided it for a long time.
이 미 나 Not exactly. He just said that shinee will be together until a member's health is not good. Sadly, due to the amount of awful people and terrible professional he found... he felt like he could not heal himself.... We don't deserve someone so pure and wise like Jonghyun. All he did in his life was to give light and love with his art and talent.
@@auraacqua9434 was any incident specifically hurting him
@@aayushisingh9666 no, not really. He was battling depression for many years. However unfortunately mental health problems aren't really treated well if at all in most East Asian countries, south Korea included, people don't really know how to support someone through that and he did get the help he needed.
I love SHINee relationship.
Bless Minho, he did that thing again where he just repeats what the members say, just in a different way towards the end ahaha
Ever since weekly idol I notice it in all their interviews lol
he loves doing that and the members just let him. the reason when in interviews where they need to say last words, his part always cut,.sigh our ming
Jiminie Kimchi He does do that!😂😂😂
Jiminie Kimchi and i started to recognize JH's accent "Guyo", the thing Taemin imitated in Yang and Nam show lol
flameonyou ints same lmaooo
What makes them a great group is that they know that they are in a business and that they must put their business first before themselves. This system works well for them that you can never see them slack off in whatever it is they do even when they get the short end of the stick.They kept on improving and improving all through these years. The fact that there are also just five of them in the group makes it easier for their handlers and Onew to manage them so they shine individually without sacrificing the image harmony of the group. They are also very honest but are discreet with their actions being very careful not to cause scandals. They may nt be SM's best selling artists but as a group they are the best in many aspects such as their overall artistry and CD perfection live singing while doing difficult choreographies. I have nothing but admiration for the group.
i agree with you
Zee Taylor Agree👍🏽
Yes you are right they actually were able to adjust them selves and not to cross each other boundaries and not to revealing each other secrets to the media like what super junior members used to do and they have a very good team work every one would cover for the other that is why they lasted for such a long time
Actually they were best selling SM artist for some time and they earned most for the company during it
@@aa-cx8wb What I have learned to admire about them is that their artistry and being honest to that and their development has allowed them to excel in more ways than one. I see how they have trully become multi-talents and owning their spaces 100% while being a Shinee family. Their longevity will be that...not that selling at #1 isnt important, but think being seen as experimental has given them more freedom than most Kpop groups as they try new things and learn new things all the time. Their growth is nice to see. (November 2022)
"Unless we physically fall apart"
He keep the promise until the end of his life.
😇💙
i like how jonghyun was sticking up for the manager. he’s so sweet.
not going to lie, I love when shinee "fight" with each other -- particularly those epic key/minho fights
“We are not going to be like that unless we physically fall apart”-Jonghyun
Sadly one of them has left us to go to a better place...😭
R.I.P JongHyun❤️
shinee is seriously the closest group ever though. I can't imagine shinee any differently
this is so sad :( rip jonghyun we love u
taemin always mention his manager XD
Softhearted Jonghyun took pity on Taemin describing the maknae manager as single since birth (i.e. never had a girlfriend) in interviews. :)
😂😂
and minho always mention onew
SHINee are living legends.
ANINDITA shawol < absolutely
Jonghyun stayed true to what e said that shinee will stay together until they physically fall apart . Now he is physically gone from this world.... I cant even say anything . 😭 May his soul rest in peace. 😭
shafaq kamran he keep his promise..
At this point there might as well be a TaeminXmaknaemanager ship going on
DJ: So, SHINee definitely won’t break up?
J: I actually have never thought of that before.
Me: 😭💔😭💔😭💔😭💔😭💔
Their relationship are really gold. Especially where jjong said he will be in SHINee again if the members are still the same. I like them very much. SHINee fighting.
I love SHINee relationship and how they managed to stay together for so long...I hope new groups that I stan can look up to them and last that long as well too...and yes I know it's groups that older than them but some of their members have decided to leave their group...SHINee Together FOREVER!!!!
J-Hope Is Bae ikr
But now jonghyun left to never come back. 😭😭 it hurts so much.
shafaq kamran stfu shinee is five period
:'(
5HINee forever! 💕
Only last year bling bling said this.. miss him
Jin's Bae 사랑해
"We are not going to be like that unless we physically fall apart" -Jjong puppy. I'm not crying you are😭😭the most beautiful and real brotherhood relationship❤️
and he did physically fall apart.. rip jonghyun 💕
rest in peace 🙏😢 miss him so much
and at the end he really meant it :'(
Cant imagine its the truth...
Wow how many countries did i save in my past life to have SHINee in my life.... Living legends.
Monika Dr not only you. its more like what did humanity do to deserve them
Apparently humanity didn't do enough as we couldn't keep them whole... 😭
:’(
im here watching old videos trying to smile but it's so hard.
same instead of feeling better i'm breaking down more
You just need to find the right videos.. because this one is so heartbreaking..
Same, i thought i would be able to smile because i thought i'm fine, but when i started crying when i got this Video i knew i was not fine😢😭😭😭😭
Same as me I can't smile every time I watch them together
i feel you- ik this is 2 years old but stay strong
Jonghyun is so kind and considerate - he tried not to embarrass and tried to protect their manager when taemin said that he is single since birth. I miss him..
Coming here and I didn't expect that this video will be so sad with Jonghyun's answer 'except we physically fall apart'
i never knew tht whn jonhyun said tht they wont be leaving shinee unlessl they r physically apart he genuinely meant tht. i wish all this was jst a dream
Aw my baby Jjong defending manager hyung!! This man.. Oh lord this man is the death of me!! How kind can he be.. Oh my God neomu saranghamnida Jonghyun oppa!!!
he was so sweet. Jonghyun seemed like the type of person that loved helping other people. I'm going to miss him so much
He seemed so kind and didn't like seeing other people hurt...
Truly an angel 💙
I just noticed that it was Ji Suk Jin talking 😂😂😂
Diana Gonzalez omygosh I didn't notice until I saw this comment and looked at the end scene 😂😂
Minho's voice is so soft...it makes me calm every time i hear it ^^
ikr like chocolate
Minho asmr
I loled so hard when Taemin chose manager-ssi to introduce to her "younger sister" 😂
Shinee will never change even in the absence of Jonghyun. I know they can do this. LOVE YOU ALL
5HINee definitely won't break up! You did well, you've worked hard. Be happy! Thank you. ✨
I'm so mad, and sad, and frustrated, I wish you'd come back. I'm sorry and I miss you and love you so much. Everyone is in pain and I hate it. I wish I talked to you, we both had the same thing. The only difference is I battled for 4 years and finally got the right meds. I wish you did too. I'm on this roller coaster of emotions, I'm sad for a while then happy watching memories of you then devastated again. You were so beautiful and kind and just such a lovely human being. I wish you found a solution.
Shinee has always stood out to me as having a unique dynamic. At first I thought it was a little strange but I've grown to truly appreciate it. They seem to have a genuine and mature respect for one another. And really see each other as equals. It's admirable.
SHINee was the first kpop group I got into and I'm so glad I discovered them.
You were wrong jonghyun!!! Minho was the one who was comforting Sodam.😢😢he grew up so well and also matured!!!
With his innate and immense talent, we know Jonghyun can go solo from the time of their debut and be successful, so him saying with conviction that he'd never thought about disbanding is impressive. He had a taste of success with his solo album and he was not blinded with the temptation that he can be on his own now, he's rooted to Shinee, apparently.
he did physically fall apart.. rip jonghyun
"We are not going to break up, Only if we are phisiclly apart" Jjong 😭😢
Am I the only one who got teary eyes when they started talking about disbanding and stuff? Like as a Shawol for 3yrs-ish, ofc Ik that they're not that "kind" of group but still, in this kind of industry, u just never know. I like how the members answer the question about it, they're not sugarcoating their answer, i.e. saying cliché stuff, but proving how strong their relationship is and doing the most important thing, communication.
maria kamille esplana i hope you are okay
please stay strong
#jonghyun
#shawolsstaystrong
#shinee
maria kamille esplana I would've preferred a million times for Jonghyun to leave the group to get some proper treatment in the U.S or anywhere where he wouldn't have a quack psychiatrist provide him no support towards a path of recovery. Poor baby, he suffered so much. I hope with death he finally got the peace he wanted even though millions of hearts were shattered.
#YouDidWellJonghyun
Minho really has a habbit of repeat what members already said😂😂😂
" Until we physically fall apart " 😢😢 ... im sorry u fell apart mentally alone 😢😢😢 RIP jonghyun baby
Mc: Are the member tired of it (Shinee)
Kim Jonghyun: *Actually we aren’t going to be like that unless we physically fall apart*
18/12/17~ Why did you fall apart...?
He mentally fell apart... not physically.
he never left shinee ...
"Actually we aren't going to be like that unless we physically fall apart" Ok, I've truly understand your point now :(((((
Gosh I'm used to Shinee
😐 and not as a fangirl
Its like I have massive respect for them
And their music stirs my soul,their bond makes me feel warm,gosh they keep me sane and the same time they make me so emotional 😢
Gosh I never knew that this could happen to me
I have checked lots of SHINee clips and I really think that the depression got to him the last two three years. In earlier shows you could see he enjoyed doing them and he looked like he enjoyed himself but the more recent ones he looks so hollow and serious in them. Sad that no one noticed this chance. Sad that he had to go the way he did, if only he'd known that there was a way to conquer depression and that wasn't in depending on others but understanding that it's you who has to do it on your own. I'm speaking from experience. I've also always depended on others to help me through my depression but Ive learned that the only way to conquer it is by doing it yourself and knowing that relying on others will only make u dissapointed even more. It's really sad, I can't imagine how the members are feeling now. I can't imagine a smile upon their faces anymore.
I keep thinking about the other members too ....i feel like minho and taemin will be especially hollow for a long time....i feel like the spark in their eyes will disappear...its not like jonghyun died naturally too...he committed suicide took his own life in sadness...there is no way the members will be normal from now on its so sad :(
Jiggly Rose Same just the thought of them not being the same anymore and at such a young age kills me. I'm so sad for them. It's so sad they were such a perfect group. I wish Jonghyun would have realised what kind of impact his existence had for the others. I guess he depended too much on others to bring him out of his depression and I guess that was his downfall :(
i think the reason i keep thinking about minho/taemin more is because key/onew already expressed themselves online in a way it was comforting? but taemin seemed soo angry at the funeral and minho is terrible at expressing his emotions + type to blame himself so i worry about him a lot...i heard he went to filming the rest of his movie but im not ready to see pictures of him tbh
Jiggly Rose I get what you mean but even if the others havent expressed themselves yet, I think they all are suffering equally. Idk I'm worried about Key even cause they were extremely close but yeah Idk they all were really close I hope they can close this chapter peacefully in due time
But that's the problem with people who have depression. They feel they need to handle everything on their own so they don't become a burden to those they love. It does help if someone is there to listen to them or just there so they know they are not alone. If you have been a long time fan of SHINee you would know Jonghyun never hid his depression from the fans and the general public. In fact, it's also known that Onew has depression too. If anyone understood Jonghyun the most, it's his leader. Because he knew what Jonghyun was going through, he took the news of his passing the hardest out of the whole group. The other 4 are noticeably affected too. How could they not be? That's their brother and band mate. Depression is not the same for everyone. Some can fight and help themselves out of their mental stress but some can't do it any longer. They just want the pain and emptiness to end. This was the case with Jonghyun. What you said about trying to help themselves out of it can only do so much. If there is no therapy or understanding from others, how can they have the will to live on? What you said is not that simple for everyone to grasp. You need to learn that yourself.
너희만큼 예쁘고 착하고 잘맞는 그룹이 어디있겠어
I already miss hearing Jonghyun's voice😭😭
I still broken.. Watching this after jonghyun gone.. I miss u jonghyun-ah
*Rewatching this on 12/20/17 is so painful so so painful i can't stop crying it feels so unreal that he's gone. Jonghyun rest in peace angel god..this hurts.*
i miss jonghyun already TT WHYYYYY JONGHYUN WHY??????????????????
They are and will always together. Only the body separated them ㅠㅠ Miss u already jonghyun.. We love you~
These men are legends i love em 💚
R.I.P JongHyun❤️
Watching this now, I go back in time. It was only a little more than a year ago...
5:27 “I actually have never thought of that before (disbanding)”
*me: but why did you leave us… ㅠㅠ*
AM I THE ONLY ONE WHO CRIED WHILE WATCHING THIS? T^T
Majae Esteban nope, but for different reasons im pretty sure
I'm back here because of Jonghyun (Dec 18, 2017) how much he loves shinee, his dorkyness. SHINee is the first group that makes me love Kpop 😭😭😭 still don't want to believe that Jjong had left us, shinee will always be 5 😭😭😭
I really hate how people still are talking about jonghyuns death as if thats what hes only known for, hes a great and kind person.
LMAOO MINHO JUST REPEATED EXACTLY WHAT JONGHYUN SAID IM LAUGHING
I believe in his words here where he would still be in SHINee with the same members.. He really loves Onew Key Minho Taemin and SHINee World... I miss you Jjong so much..
MY HEART, Jonghyun saying that the members must always be the same!
And finally one member has parted. RIP Jonghyun oppa
Rest in peace jonghyun, we shall take care of your sister
Minho's face when Jonghyun excluding him out XD
He looked fine. 😭😭 he didn't look the part of a depressed soul at all. Why jonghyun baby. 😭😭😭 miss you.
„until we physically fall apart“
i‘m crying
RIP JONGHYUN OPPA 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Physically fall apart but never the heart of them. 5 hearts are always staying together. 5HINee is truly a family that will never fall apart, all 5 of them.
SHINee members are real and sincere that's why i stan them, and of course their talent too
Ugh this is so sad to watch... SHINee was the first kpop group that I loved. 😢 I miss you Jonghyun... We miss you. Hope you are happier where you are.
So much love for these boys. Goodbye Jonghyun you will be missed Xx
ӴÅᴬÅᴬÅᴬÅᴬÅᴬꙄ❣❣ Minho oppa💖💖
Onew oppa iꙅ juꙅt Å PEЯFËCT Boӵfrieиd//Huꙅbaиd Matєяial💚💚
Thx sööö ოuch foя shariиg ωith Eng sub ღღ
Lmao even then Taemin was joking on Nam Euisoo
If someone asks taemin who would he date if he was a girl that baby is definitely going with the manager 😌 😂😂😂
Whenever I want to lift my spirits up,I turn to shinee
Whenever I want to feel happy, sad,joyful, any other emotions,I turn to shinee
Whenever I want to calm myself ,I turn to shinee
Whenever I want to control my madness,intensity, stress,I turn to shinee
Whenever I want to be strong, I turn to shinee
Whenever I want to feel hopeful, loved I I to shinee
I know how it sounds
But can't help it
And not saying it as some fangirl
Welcome back shinee 💖
No matter what Shinee will forever be shinee. Even though we lost our sweet Jjong ❤️, they’re still is 5 members. 4memebers 1 angel ! 5hinee forever and always 💕🔐
- "So SHINee won't definitely break up?"
JH: "I never actually thought if that before."
I guess they went through a lot as a group.
T_T
yeah they actually did but its amazing how they stick together for nearly 10 years
Jonghyun keep his promise.. He still with Shinee until he fall apart.. I hope the rest member can stay together too until they fall apart and God will meet them again in heaven..
RIP angel. You did the best. Thanks for everything. We always here for you and your best brothers.
"Which member would you like to introduce with your sister??"
Jong🦕:members except Minho🔥 and Key🗝️.....(both are energetic)
Me:wth??! Okay!;;(Reason seems correct)
Minho🔥:Onew hyung🐇(he understands everyone)
Me:okay good!!! (I too agree with the reason)
Taemin🧀:Manager
Me: can't stop laughing
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Taemin and Manager's story is a never ending saga.......
Thank you for this sub,
please keep doing it =*
Jonghyun you are truly missed by us all.
"we are going to be Shinee until we physically fall apart" - jonghyun
I love you, Jonghyun ❤️
NEVER DISBAND!! NEVER EVER!! I will legit cry. I have gone through enough heartbreaks from my favorite group disbanding. SHINee needs to stay together till they are old!
It's 2021 and Taemin is still promoting his manager. lol.
watching these happier moments are comforting...
I miss jonghyun so much ❤ thank you for everything rest in peace 🙏💕 18/12/2017 the angel now go back to his place,Kim Jonghyun
I don't know but this suddenly appear in my recommended . RIP Jonghyun T^T
Rest in peace Jonghyun xx
Unless we physically apart😢😔💔
2021 : I miss you Jonghyun😭
But Jonghyun emotionally fell apart. This hurts more than seeing them physicaly fell apart. I still miss you, Jjong.