The Dominican Republic and Haiti Compared

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 27. 04. 2023
  • Buy a DNA kit here: bit.ly/MrBeat_mh. Use coupon code MrBeat for free shipping. As an added bonus, you can start a 30-day free trial of MyHeritage's best subscription for family history research - and enjoy a 50% discount if you decide to continue it.
    Mr. Beat compares and contrasts Haiti and the Dominican Republic, the two countries that share the island of Hispaniola.
    Check out @h0ser's video: • A Tale of Two Islands
    Produced by Matt Beat. All images and video by Matt Beat, used under fair use guidelines, or found in the public domain. Music by The Honey Trap at creatormix.com/.
    Correction:
    5:02 I accidentally swapped the life expectancies
    @ReligionForBreakfast 's video about Haitian Vodou: • Vodou: Haiti's African...
    @williamcfox 's video about the Haitian Revolution: • Haiti's Revolution is ...
    Here's an annotated script with footnotes:
    docs.google.com/document/d/1k...
    Sources/further reading:
    versus.com/en/dominican-repub...
    www.worlddata.info/country-co...
    Join this channel to get access to perks:
    / @iammrbeat
    For business inquiries or to send snail mail to Mr. Beat:
    www.iammrbeat.com/contact.html
    / iammrbeat
    How to support and donate to my channel:
    Subscribe to @iammrbeat & hit the notification bell 🔔
    Join for great perks on Patreon: / iammrbeat
    Donate to Mr. Beat on Paypal: www.paypal.me/mrbeat
    Buy Mr. Beat a coffee: ko-fi.com/iammrbeat
    Cameo: www.cameo.com/iammrbeat
    Subscribe to my second channel: @mattbeatgoeson
    Patreon for The Beat Goes On: / thebeatgoeson
    Connect with me:
    Links: linktr.ee/iammrbeat
    Website: www.iammrbeat.com/
    Podcast: anchor.fm/thebeatpod
    Reddit: / mrbeat
    @beatmastermatt on Twitter: / beatmastermatt
    Facebook: / iammrbeat
    Instagram: / iammrbeat
    Beatcord: / discord
    TikTok: / iammrbeat
    Merch:
    matt-beat-shop.fourthwall.com/
    www.bonfire.com/store/mr-beat/
    sfsf.shop/support-mrbeat/
    amzn.to/3fdakiZ
    Affiliate Links:
    Useful Charts: usefulcharts.com/?aff=12
    #geography #haiti #dominicana
    Haiti and The Dominican Republic
    The two countries that share the island of Hispaniola, the most populous island and second-largest island in the West Indies. What are the West Indies? Well, all these islands in or near the Caribbean Sea, for real. Because that Christopher Columbus dude, who was the first European to lead a voyage to the islands, thought he was near India when he first explored them, other Europeans began to call them the “West Indies” to distinguish the islands from India.
    Anyway, Haiti is located on the western part of Hispaniola and The Dominican Republic is located on the eastern part of it. This 242-mile (391 km) border separates the two countries. Seen from space, this border is quite dramatic. On the Haitian side, you can see massive deforestation. On the Dominican side, forests remain.
    While both countries have a lot in common, today a lot of people tend to focus on their many differences.

Komentáře • 2K

  • @iammrbeat
    @iammrbeat  Před rokem +321

    Sponsorship information:
    Buy a DNA kit here: bit.ly/MrBeat_mh. Use coupon code MrBeat for free shipping. As an added bonus, you can start a 30-day free trial of MyHeritage's best subscription for family history research - and enjoy a 50% discount if you decide to continue it.
    Which two countries should I compare for this series next?
    Correction:
    5:02 I accidentally swapped the life expectancies

  • @h0ser
    @h0ser Před rokem +1518

    That hoser fellow deserves an Oscar for that performance

    • @wednesdayatwork
      @wednesdayatwork Před rokem +44

      hoser in da mr beat comments
      edit: and video 😎

    • @helenwyant3449
      @helenwyant3449 Před rokem +4

      noice

    • @frogglen6350
      @frogglen6350 Před rokem +4

      You should really delete that far right Italy video. it just comes off as disingenuous and makes you seem like an unreliable source of educational content. Sometimes when I watch your videos, you come off as someone who thinks they know about another country, without experiencing said country

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +165

      We laughed, we cried, we held by your every word.

    • @wednesdayatwork
      @wednesdayatwork Před rokem

      @@frogglen6350 Wrong comment section, cornball

  • @josecarvajal6654
    @josecarvajal6654 Před rokem +774

    As a Dominican, I'm glad to see a well informed, unbiased video about the situation in the island.
    Wish to see our Haitian brothers finally get their country back and be able to work together to improve our nations

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +67

      Great comment, Jose. You live in a beautiful place.

    • @josecarvajal6654
      @josecarvajal6654 Před rokem +36

      @@iammrbeat It really is beutiful here, we just have some issues to resolve to make it even better

    • @IvanPlayStation4LiFe
      @IvanPlayStation4LiFe Před rokem

      Haiti has no industry they have no cell towers basically no food no vehicles

    • @mariagloriadelcarmen
      @mariagloriadelcarmen Před rokem +9

      When are gonna do Baltimore and Washington compared?

    • @mariagloriadelcarmen
      @mariagloriadelcarmen Před rokem +5

      @@iammrbeat When are gonna do Baltimore and Washington compared?

  • @FrancescaEtheart
    @FrancescaEtheart Před 10 měsíci +258

    As a Haitian, I respect how professionally and accurately you discuss the two countries. It is very sad the state Haiti is in. We have had nothing but bad luck for a long time. While Dominique Republique was able to overcome their difficulties. I pray to God our situation changes every day. May Haiti rise and prove everyone wrong.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před 10 měsíci +31

      Much respect to Haitians. Thank you for the kind comment.

    • @FrancescaEtheart
      @FrancescaEtheart Před 10 měsíci +6

      @@iammrbeat Thank you, you're most welcome ya.

    • @CBatista1234
      @CBatista1234 Před 8 měsíci +22

      Haiti has had bad luck? Really? How about taking responsibility for your actions?

    • @MarieJoseph-ll7kg
      @MarieJoseph-ll7kg Před 8 měsíci +10

      I think the report is good but the picture comparison is unfair. Haiti got also nice near the water beaches like the port or Cap Haitians city. He only show rich part of Republicans not one slum part. While he doesn't show any rich part of Haiti or not even a place near water like Haiti doesn't have any beautiful beaches

    • @DiamondX_zl7668
      @DiamondX_zl7668 Před 8 měsíci +22

      @@CBatista1234 bros talking about a whole country as if it’s a person. WHO ARE YOU?

  • @Reina007clavel
    @Reina007clavel Před rokem +252

    I can speak for all Dominicans, who want Haiti to come out of the crisis and begin to grow as a country.

    • @creditrepairwizards
      @creditrepairwizards Před 11 měsíci +14

      This is why: Dominicans are God fearing Christians and God prospers them. Hattians practice VOODOO" and this is what God says about that. "You shall not bow down to them or serve them, for I the LORD your God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children to the third and the fourth generation of those who hate me, 6 but showing steadfast love to thousands2 of those who love me and keep my commandments." Could this be any more clear?

    • @sereidamartines1608
      @sereidamartines1608 Před 11 měsíci +16

      Y que salgan de nuestrA RD

    • @Jean-vp1yr
      @Jean-vp1yr Před 11 měsíci

      @@sereidamartines1608 Then how come agnostic countries like Sweden, Denmark and Norway where almost the entire population does not believe in any form of god are prosperous? It has NOTHING to do with religion, stop spreading lies, that’s ignorant as fck!

    • @lisev415
      @lisev415 Před 11 měsíci +15

      @@sereidamartines1608 siempre hay un payaso

    • @maxkrystal7403
      @maxkrystal7403 Před 11 měsíci

      @@creditrepairwizardsyour god sounds like a cunt

  • @tregua24
    @tregua24 Před rokem +38

    When the French arrived on the island of Santo Domingo in 1697, there was already a people (Dominicans), with language, religion, gastronomy, culture, towns, churches, roads, schools, monastery, and even a university. The University of Santo Domingo founded in 1538. The French came 200 years later, which turned out to be a historical mistake, for the simple reason that you can not have a country inside another country.

    • @bastianx8772
      @bastianx8772 Před rokem +2

      What's the point

    • @tregua24
      @tregua24 Před rokem +14

      @@bastianx8772 That Haiti was a French historical mistake.

    • @charlottecamila2859
      @charlottecamila2859 Před 9 měsíci +16

      ​@@tregua24 I'm so glad some people are standing up for Dominicans finally after all the defamation Haitians, the French powers, and Black Americans have tried to push us like the bad guys. Going around saying that the Island is theirs and how we don't belong there. Like it is OUR land. We have Taino DNA we existed first. LA ESPAÑOLA.

    • @Xenlacasa45
      @Xenlacasa45 Před 8 měsíci +2

      @@charlottecamila2859it’s a whole movement of us I’m one of the first ones I remember when I was the only one defending our people from defamation

    • @karenpena3315
      @karenpena3315 Před 8 měsíci +7

      ⁠@@Xenlacasa45Haitians hate us because they themselves don't know the history of their own country😂

  • @sirnetflix7162
    @sirnetflix7162 Před rokem +219

    To anyone who is worried about the Dominican Republic and crime, tourist locations are completely safe (Punta Cana/Puerto Plata) but obviously don’t have 100k laying around in your open hands in the middle of the night (but that’s anywhere). Crime in general is only really seen in the big cities like the capital, but smaller pueblos/villages generally have low violent crime and at worst you’ll get some petty theft or something. It’s more so focused in certain places than spread equally throughout the country. Just use your head and you shouldn’t have any issues.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +64

      The tourist spots in the Dominican Republic are just as safe, if not more safer than tourist spots throughout the rest of the Americas.

    • @sirnetflix7162
      @sirnetflix7162 Před rokem +8

      @@iammrbeat Exactly. Thank you for highlighting these two countries that definitely don’t get the respect they deserve in terms of historical recognition.

    • @axelpepen2642
      @axelpepen2642 Před rokem

      Yeah, most of the crimes are concentrated in SD

    • @the-scribbler352
      @the-scribbler352 Před rokem +4

      I think this can be said about any Caribbean country that has major tourist areas. They're almost always safe and secure.

    • @IvanPlayStation4LiFe
      @IvanPlayStation4LiFe Před rokem +2

      ​@@axelpepen2642 because of blacks the best part is cibao white areas aka 30% of the country mi gente

  • @theconqueringram5295
    @theconqueringram5295 Před rokem +148

    Recently I've become obsessed with the Dominican Republic and this comparison is very interesting! While these countries may share the same island, they couldn't be anymore different. Right now, the Dominican Republic is ahead of Haiti in practically everything. However, the Dominican Republic is still a developing economy and they still have a long way to go, but they are headed there. I'd like to see Haiti catch up to the Dominican Republic one day, it'll be a rough road but hopefully one day Haiti can achieve stability.

    • @rdoscar
      @rdoscar Před rokem +4

      Nice! Im dominciano if you need anything let me know

    • @coderdecoder5947
      @coderdecoder5947 Před rokem

      Doubt it. Haiti is occupied by low iq subhumans.

    • @nancia24
      @nancia24 Před rokem +7

      ​@@rdoscar hi I'm Haitian American and I'm happy to see that the Dominican is finally growing smoothly and slowly I'm really happy for you guys I just hope one day Haiti can do the same but right now I don't think so ❤

    • @creditrepairwizards
      @creditrepairwizards Před 11 měsíci +5

      This is why: Dominicans are God fearing Christians and God prospers them. Hattians practice VOODOO" and this is what God says about that. "You shall not bow down to them or serve them, for I the LORD your God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children to the third and the fourth generation of those who hate me, 6 but showing steadfast love to thousands2 of those who love me and keep my commandments." Could this be any more clear?

    • @DCampusano1
      @DCampusano1 Před 11 měsíci +3

      Haitians need to get their political system in order first before they can even begin to take off economically.

  • @jvmade84
    @jvmade84 Před rokem +132

    Great work. One thing I’d like to add…most videos comparing both countries always mention the massacre of the 30s from the DR to Haitians. This is sad and accurate. However, it should also be mentioned that Haiti invaded the DR 6 times while the DR never invaded Haiti. Not only did they do this, but they did it in a very gruesome way. One of the worst atrocities is called “degüello de moca”…degüello means beheading and Moca is a town in the north of DR. There are great videos on it but not sure if any are in English. Basically Haitians beheaded everyone in that town especially the white people…including women and children. This is something the DR govt purposely leaves out of elementary thru HS leaving it only to scholars and college level in order to avoid hate. I don’t justify xenophobia or mistreatment of Haitians but the tension between both countries lies especially in the history and it bothers me when people just chalk it up to pure “racism.” You did not do this and I thank you for that. You kept it objective…just wanted to give you that little piece of little known history even amongst Dominicans.

    • @PLATANITO829
      @PLATANITO829 Před rokem +28

      They don't dare mention these facts because it will hurt their reputation to speak the truth.

    • @Jimmy_none
      @Jimmy_none Před rokem +20

      They would never mention that. Not one of these bozos that do these pieces for some reason, forget that part.

    • @DynamicUnreal
      @DynamicUnreal Před rokem +27

      I’m from Moca and most people here know that history even if it’s not spoken much.

    • @coldleo4950
      @coldleo4950 Před rokem

      of course they wont you know the light skins are always the villans and the darker side are always gonna be the victim even though they killed and ran light skinned Dominicans out of the island when they invaded and ran the Dominican side for over 22 years but they never bring that up either they erase all that history its insane

    • @queenrudshel9802
      @queenrudshel9802 Před rokem +4

      Yes this may be very true. it’s important to learn history. There is still constant miss treatment that Haitians have to go through in DR and on the boarder In the present. Even if you travel legally the police still will hit you they will touch you inappropriately, swear at you etc. While Dominicans freely cross the border to go to Haiti an whenever they want. The many times I’ve cross the border I’ve seen this, and I’m not a hard-core victim of this because they considered me as American. When you speak English to them, they act differently.

  • @NeoCoreSaturn
    @NeoCoreSaturn Před rokem +367

    Honestly, as someone from the neighbouring Jamaica I'm worried about the current state Haiti is going through. I really hope it doesn't become a failed state and hopefully pulls through

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +63

      I hope not. I've been to Jamaica. It's a magical place.

    • @c.michellesparks2925
      @c.michellesparks2925 Před rokem +17

      @@iammrbeat It truly is. I live in Florida and am seriously looking at whether or not I could live comfortably in Jamaica.

    • @ryankline1164
      @ryankline1164 Před rokem +23

      Seeing how the Fragile State Index has Haiti at 99.7 in 2022 and the 11th most fragile in the world just barely above Myanmar (at 100 and currently in a civil war), I'm not sure it's not already there.

    • @edcasado6651
      @edcasado6651 Před rokem +52

      What world do you live in? Haiti has been a failed state for a long time. By any measure IT IS a failed state. Sad but true

    • @radidov5333
      @radidov5333 Před rokem +33

      wait..isn't Haiti already a failed state ? xD lol since the 1700's

  • @jayjasperjp
    @jayjasperjp Před rokem +84

    In 1950, Haiti and the Dominican Republic had nearly identical rates of poverty and GDP per capita. But since then, the DR’s economy has grown tremendously while Haiti remains poor and underdeveloped. The gap between the two countries is now wider than ever

    • @blad89s65
      @blad89s65 Před rokem

      The people from this country were picked up from Senegal threw out Congo check out the poverty level of these countries it’s bad the reason they choose to stay and continue to occupy a territory that should be a Dominican territory. Haitians not wanting to go to their true countries is because they prefer to leach off neighboring countries truly shameless.

    • @TheGeorgelobo
      @TheGeorgelobo Před rokem

      ​@@blad89s65 the French people bought slaves from rivals tribe and brought them to that side of the island together they been battling each since that's why Haiti never will be unified as country, one family control one side the other family controls the other side, killing their presidents now a gang controls the government basically that's a no one land right now

    • @OpinionesDeJACCsOpinions
      @OpinionesDeJACCsOpinions Před rokem

      ​@@blad89s65
      What?

    • @blad89s65
      @blad89s65 Před rokem

      @@OpinionesDeJACCsOpinions ?

    • @OpinionesDeJACCsOpinions
      @OpinionesDeJACCsOpinions Před rokem

      @@blad89s65
      Well you've since deleted your comment and I can't remember what it was, so I don't know.

  • @aneru9396
    @aneru9396 Před rokem +79

    The DOminican Republic is also Host to la Universidad Autonoma De Santo Domingo, which started as a Sunday School around the time of the First Colony in the 1500s, evolving to become the Oldest Educational Institution in the Western Hemesphere.
    Although that series of Occupations by the Haiti pretty much shut the school down, but it was able to be revived after the War of Independence, and continues to run today.

    • @bastianx8772
      @bastianx8772 Před rokem +2

      Who cares??

    • @jodh-cx1zd
      @jodh-cx1zd Před rokem +14

      @@bastianx8772 why are you mad

    • @nancia24
      @nancia24 Před rokem +7

      ​@@bastianx8772 why you mad

    • @familyandfriends3519
      @familyandfriends3519 Před 9 měsíci

      Dominican republic got independence from Spain in 1821 your people should be celebrating that day

    • @amhumanperson3592
      @amhumanperson3592 Před 8 měsíci

      We celebrate the independence form haiti cuz the first one was short lived and did nothing as we went back to being a colony of another nation@@familyandfriends3519

  • @jpe1
    @jpe1 Před rokem +106

    5:01 “Haiti has a much lower life expectancy.” (Shows 72.9 for Haiti and 64 for The Dominican Republic) 🤔
    Perhaps the numbers got swapped?

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +94

      Yep, the numbers got swapped. This was the first mistake I've ever made.

    • @ricardocontreras94
      @ricardocontreras94 Před rokem +52

      72.9 is smaller than 64 if you dont think about it

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +31

      @@ricardocontreras94 Exactly

    • @creemyice
      @creemyice Před rokem +4

      @@ricardocontreras94 how so?

    • @enmanuel961
      @enmanuel961 Před rokem +14

      @@creemyice With the magic of "Sarcasm"

  • @mr.normalguy69
    @mr.normalguy69 Před rokem +326

    Dominican Republic all day 🇩🇴, great people, great food, great environment, relatively affordable goods and services. One of the most underrated countries to visit outside the US.

  • @velileon101
    @velileon101 Před rokem +245

    I remember as a kid in Dominican Republic I saw a Haitian hiding in a mattress in the back of a truck trying to get by a checkpoint, forgot if it was in the eastern part of DR or what not, but my entire childhood I was friends with older haitian men that worked for my Dad's construction company. Very hardworking and humble country, that Haiti is.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +36

      Thanks for sharing that. I wish I had a chance to talk to more folks like you before I made this video.

    • @mrcocoloco7200
      @mrcocoloco7200 Před rokem +6

      Same story here too but my Uncle pay them.

    • @johnnymonestime3742
      @johnnymonestime3742 Před rokem +15

      Puerto Ricans have Similar stories about Dominicans.

    • @whatdadogdoin9818
      @whatdadogdoin9818 Před rokem +2

      Lots of crime

    • @manfredthen
      @manfredthen Před rokem +7

      @@johnnymonestime3742 I doubt it

  • @nicolasrouzier1657
    @nicolasrouzier1657 Před rokem +99

    I’ve lived in haiit for most of my life, and am now studying in the Dominican Republic, living in both countries isn’t really different in terms of living expenses, however u seem to spend more money in Haiti, due to the lack of infrastructure (water, electricity, etc) u spend 5 times more everywhere just because the country doesn’t provide and everything is imported. The electricity is almost non existent in Haiti people run their properties on generators almost 24/7, water isn’t fed through pipes it’s brought to your house in a truck and put in a reservoir on property and all this really ramps up your spending. It’s not cheap either to pay these “basic” services.

    • @nicolasrouzier1657
      @nicolasrouzier1657 Před rokem +16

      But at the surface electricity bills on both sides of the island are similar except that one actually provides and the other just makes you pay a non existent service and you have to go out and buy gasoline for your generator instead

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +44

      So THAT explains the confusion online about cost of living differences. This is fascinating stuff. Thanks for sharing.

    • @joelmonsion1639
      @joelmonsion1639 Před rokem +3

      I went down to the comments specifically to find this one, thanks!

    • @israelescalante7971
      @israelescalante7971 Před rokem

      Hoy comparación en ningún aspecto sin tener que poner los sentimientos partió de cualquier país entre República Dominicana y Haití hay una diferencia del cielo a la tierra en todos los sentidos. Y si hay alguna duda hay más vídeos en CZcams que hablan de la diferencia entre los dos países e incluso muestran más Tomás.

    • @cristiandiaz6333
      @cristiandiaz6333 Před rokem +3

      As a dominican, I admire Haitians' work habits. However, I always encouraged them to invest in DR and start business like other immigrants in DR do. If more Haitians become dominicans and act and think like dominicans, the Island could slowly become one nation. But, I also understand that Haitians might not want to succumb to the Dominican way of life and even less feel like they are under them (us).

  • @WaluigiisthekingASmith
    @WaluigiisthekingASmith Před rokem +11

    I saw you and hoser upload within 4 minutes of each other and I said "that cant be a coincidence"

  • @perceivedvelocity9914
    @perceivedvelocity9914 Před rokem +49

    Baseball is a huge economic driver for the Dominican Republic. Kid's are trained from a very early age to play the game. The player's that make it to the MLB send home a lot of money. The game has done a lot of good for the community. On the negative side.... A lot of kids never make it to the MLB. Those kids do not get a lot of education in anything else. All that they know how to do is play baseball.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +16

      Well put. It's comparable to inner city kids trying to make it as professional basketball players or rappers.

    • @juddstjohn1487
      @juddstjohn1487 Před rokem +6

      You can see the reason Dominicans are so good at baseball if you drive around the countryside. You will see very poor boys playing baseball without real equipment. The fielders have no gloves, so they learn to field the "ball" flawlessly. Often the ball itself is just tape rolled into a lumpy sphere, so it curves like crazy when pitched. Often the bat is just a broomstick, so you can imagine how they learn to bat so well hitting a drastically curving tape ball with a thin stick. When they are given proper equipment, they are awesome.

    • @DCampusano1
      @DCampusano1 Před 11 měsíci +1

      @@iammrbeat good comparison.

    • @IvanDiazpalbatey
      @IvanDiazpalbatey Před 8 měsíci

      @@juddstjohn1487 there's a game here called "Vitilla" which is like stick-ball but instead of a ball we use a bottle cap (pitched like a flying saucer) and broom stick. Great practice for eye-hand coordination.

  • @Illuso07
    @Illuso07 Před rokem +142

    I’m Haitian, thanks for the educational content mr beat

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +23

      Represent! Thanks for watching. Hopefully I didn't get much wrong.

    • @clean280
      @clean280 Před rokem +10

      I am sorry for the place you were born in.

    • @JCPplays
      @JCPplays Před rokem +20

      ​@@clean280 Just because things aren't looking so hot in Haiti doesn't mean you should regret being born there.

    • @kenos911
      @kenos911 Před rokem +4

      @@clean280 woah there lol

    • @josephjojo698
      @josephjojo698 Před rokem +19

      @@clean280 As Haitians, we’re extremely proud of being born in Haiti, we’re just not proud of the many issues, mismanagement, political instability , insecurity etc going on in our beloved motherland

  • @petermorla8309
    @petermorla8309 Před rokem +15

    Dominicans and Haitians have entirely different demographic origins that set us apart we are not the same.
    Dominicans are an admixed ethic group the result of Arawaks , Spanish and Africans they brought mixing.
    The Haitian people are an Afro Franco ethnic group who were brought into the island by the French.
    In 1625 the islands history splits into two:
    Spanish side evolved into cattle ranching, meat and contraband. Major factor was Spain abandoning the Spanish side for three centuries. Slavery due to this was practically non existent. Spanish side as a result never had black codes or Jim crow laws. And had relax views towards mixing (taino and African maternal heritage in the Greater Antilles 2017).
    The French side had an export economy based on slave labor. The Spanish stop importing enslaved people of African descent by the end of the 16th century. Whereas the French began importing towards the middle of the 17th century and continued this practice throughout the 18th century until 1791 when the revolution of the Haitian people began.
    Dominicans have three independence:
    Brief independence in 1821.
    Independence from Haiti in 1844 (we have two historical manifestos explaining our separation which is rooted in social and economic reasons).
    Haiti problems is multi factor with both internal and external factors.
    Haiti and the Dominican Republic constitution is similar to Japan, rooted in ethic origins.
    Both sides have complex histories.
    Dominicans also have the right to protect and secure it's boarders.
    My two cents.

  • @cosmegonzalez
    @cosmegonzalez Před rokem +39

    This is going to be one of those long comments...
    Dominican here. These countries are vastly different, in spite of their similarities.
    The grudge between the two countries is still alive. Many Dominicans loathe and fear haitians for the 1821 invasion. Many Haitians still believe the island should be one.
    Many Dominicans still have a strong sense of patriotism. Our national anthem sings about the independence from Haiti and about the death of our Founding Fathers in those battles.
    Haiti's main religion is voodoo, not catholicism.
    Creole and french in Haiti. Spanish in the Dominican Republic.
    Haiti has A LOT OF ECONOMICAL PROBLEMS AND DEBT, A LOT. The Dominican Republic has plenty too. However both countries are mired in corruption. The Dominican Republic cannot unite with Haiti.
    We cannot assimilate their poverty or their corrupt money thirsty leaders. We barely have enough to feed our own leeches. WE ARE A THIRD WORLD COUNTRY TOO. I don't know what indexes they use to point to a " growing economy", our gas prices are the highest in the region, food is expensive, the minimum wage is usd1.25 an hour. Cost of living is $650 without rent. We do not have the resources.
    Violence and social instability is far worse in Haiti. Another reason Dominicans fear Haitians.
    What if Russia bordered with the US? Would Americans fear them? That is called Xenophobia. I have heard some ignorants quote racism when they actually mean xenophobia. Xenophobia can also be between blacks and whites and vice versa.
    I do not go around telling americans or the french what to do with their illegal immigrants. I respect those country's sovereignty, I expect fhe same.
    Haitians are welcome here, if they come through the proper channels. Is the immigration system corrupt? Yes, like everything else here. Welcome to the DR. You come here, become a Dominican, pay your 28% tax like everyone else, abide by our laws, sing our national anthem (dunno how you're going to go about that), don't give us trouble, and all is good.
    This idea of uniting with other countries and open border policies is childish. It's irrational foolish crap.

    • @chriswhite3692
      @chriswhite3692 Před 11 měsíci +15

      Exactly. I don't blame you. Haiti didn't turn out like Haiti for no reason. That was the most successful planter colony in the Western hemisphere; the Pearl of the Antilles. And they turned into a virtually barren hellscape, stripped the surrounding waters of fish...it's insane.

    • @cosmegonzalez
      @cosmegonzalez Před 11 měsíci

      @@chriswhite3692 History is complicated. People always think poor means oppressed. They fought for their freedom. They won. They beat most of us here in the Americas. But once free, they failed to organize, plan, build a structure. Tribalism and slavery (because african tribes enslaved other tribes) were no longer a thing. So they would have to evolve into a political system they did not fully understand. Corruption followed. Violence too. Fast forward to 2023 and they are still struggling to break this cycle.
      We had the same beginnings in the Dominican Republic. Except we had an averagely better education because there wasn't segregation. Our founding Fathers, mainly Juan Pablo Duarte, studied in Europe and longed for his country to be like European countries.
      Yet we still struggle.

    • @prezzlola
      @prezzlola Před 8 měsíci +13

      The thought of reuniting the DR with the country they literally became independent from makes my skin crawl. So our founder fathers fought for nothing? This is the most idiotic thing ever. Haiti and the DR don't even share a language ffs, how can you unite 2 vastly different cultures? The fact that people expect the DR to just "assume" Haití and all their issues is unfair and just ridiculously absurd

    • @karenpena3315
      @karenpena3315 Před 8 měsíci

      @@prezzlola Because Haitians have impregnated in their brain that their country's curse is our fault because we shared the same land, got colonized by 2 powerful countries yet only DR turned out to be prosperous and overcame poverty.
      They lack so much knowledge from the history of their country, that they abstain themselves from hating the ones who took from them the most, France mostly, England, and the US.
      Haitians could be white and blond haired, but if the circumstances were still the same (extreme poverty, violence, totally different cultures) we wouldn't open the border and unify the island. Dominicans can't take care of 10M people who've lived in extreme poverty their entire life and bring them into their 2/3 quarter of an island when we're not even a world power.
      It would destroy our economy. Those are facts. But people are more kin on being morally superior, than reasonable.

    • @orchidart
      @orchidart Před 7 měsíci +3

      Also, the chaos generated by uniting such culturally, religiously, socially and everything else different countries, is something which those pro-annexation people haven't deemed! We have to use common sense and not only utopian ideals to project an image of "diplomatic peace" among two nations that the only similar thing they possess is precisely the portion of land they share. We must remember the disputes that turning us into one single state may provoke, in both sides: Haitians won't like to be ruled by Dominicans and vice versa. Not everyone is willing to accept an agreement of that magnitude to happen, not without fighting fiercely first. In my opinion, whoever who proposes it as the most "viable" solution for the island, doesn't have a clue about how both work.
      The Dominican Republic and Haiti would make a shared government, with two presidents? No, and I can't just imagine the riots and protests because of being governed by, for example, a Haitian president, Dominicans would get angry, and the same in the parallel case. In order to provide a possible alternative to the border crisis, we ought not to think in the problematic as we do related to other countries, this needs a lot of historical and geographic study beforehand.

  • @pavelnunezbrito.8134
    @pavelnunezbrito.8134 Před rokem +17

    Great video. Greetings from Dominican Republic 🇩🇴

  • @Sami-pq8lm
    @Sami-pq8lm Před rokem +21

    As someone who has been to both, it is insane these are both on the same island. Great Video!

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +1

      It really is. Thanks for watching!

    • @marvinbrando722
      @marvinbrando722 Před 11 měsíci +1

      Me too. No, you are right, the difference is abysmal.
      In DR, basically you have everything of the current World. Still it is in develop, but it goes. Haiti, omg, omg. Haiti is reqlly really sad

  • @dpl280
    @dpl280 Před rokem +37

    Theres something really important that you left out in this video, this is not about Dominicans kicking out “black Dominicans”
    If any foreigner (lets say a tourist or an illegal haitian) have a kid in DR, the Government will supply a “birth certificate for foreigners” this birth certificate is only valid to claim their parents citizenship at their embassy, therefore the constitucion explicits says if somebody is descendants of at least one Dominican parent they can claim DR citizenship, if not, is just another foreigner.
    These “black dominicans” are haitians denying their origin and reality, theres an ongoing propaganda anti DR cause we just don’t hand out our nationality.
    Good video tho i love it!

    • @Jimmy_none
      @Jimmy_none Před rokem

      Exactly. I don’t see them having pieces on Israel which makes you take a blood test to see if you have blood ties to the land. In order to get citizenship.

    • @DynamicUnreal
      @DynamicUnreal Před rokem +5

      I still don’t understand how there are Haitians (born in the Dominican Republic to Haitian parents) that have a cédula (I.D.)?

    • @dpl280
      @dpl280 Před rokem

      @@DynamicUnreal very simple, their parents committed fraud or they themselves haitian born in haiti and DR they pay JCE institution corrupt agents so they could steal somebody’s identity, either they steal it from a dead person or somebody living overseas, theres many many cases already of haitians stealing identities, somebody is legaly Dominican only if one of their parents is a Dominican national.

    • @Leissamzil
      @Leissamzil Před rokem +12

      @@DynamicUnrealthe majority of Haitians are not documented… for generations. Unfortunately is like the comment above but many of them still claim DR citizenship & demand the government to give it to them ooor they will claim that they are Dominicans and just because we are “racists” its not given to them when clearly its the law & constitution of our country.

    • @irresponsibleparent3
      @irresponsibleparent3 Před měsícem

      There are black dominicans, some of you act like dominicans are only white when that's not the case.

  • @pedromanuelpujolstejedal5766

    The video I was waiting for years. As a big fan of your contents and citizen of the DR I’m very glad you talked about my country.

  • @LW-qb2bx
    @LW-qb2bx Před rokem +64

    I live in Dominican Republic! Great video. You mention both countries as being high crime, and while that's true, the power of gangs and the level of violence and gang warfare is Haiti is off the charts compared with here.

    • @creditrepairwizards
      @creditrepairwizards Před 11 měsíci +3

      This is why: Dominicans are God fearing Christians and God prospers them. Hattians practice VOODOO" and this is what God says about that. "You shall not bow down to them or serve them, for I the LORD your God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children to the third and the fourth generation of those who hate me, 6 but showing steadfast love to thousands2 of those who love me and keep my commandments." Could this be any more clear?

    • @waltuh2412
      @waltuh2412 Před 11 měsíci

      @@creditrepairwizards stop spreading your ignorant rhetoric, Haitians aren’t some evil witch people nor is voodoo a common practice. And from history has shown Christians have spread a lot of violence and ignorance. No ones perfect let’s not pretend one belief is the one true one, only leads to more problems and further ignorance

    • @peguerordchannel3234
      @peguerordchannel3234 Před 8 měsíci +5

      Hello, I'm Dominican, the crime situation in Haiti compares with the crime rate of any country on the American continent, years ago the most violent country was El Salvador because of the gangs but now bukele filed the crime and put a strong hand, in DR there are more robberies and assaults and one or another homicide as in any other Latin country.

    • @CarlosCastro_
      @CarlosCastro_ Před 7 měsíci +2

      High crime in DR?...Please look up the stats. Yes, DR has crime like all countries around this world. But high crime, what do you consider high crime as?..And please show documented facts. Not just "oh there is".. I will wait.

    • @msvesta3931
      @msvesta3931 Před 6 měsíci

      ​@@creditrepairwizardswell if you worship Mary that's idolatry. Trust me everywhere people doing voodoo,hoodoo, black magic, Hindu, budist,new age cabalist freemasonry that's all magics.stop the hate Haiti has many churches for protestant.

  • @MrInternationalSound
    @MrInternationalSound Před 11 měsíci +55

    As an 🇺🇸 of 🇭🇹 descent . .. it’s sad to see everything that’s going on in Haiti. Kudos to what DR has done on there side..Haiti needs a long look in the mirror. Self accountability and a heavy handed leader to get that side in order. There’s no other way at this point. Unfortunately

    • @beankobe8205
      @beankobe8205 Před 11 měsíci

      He tried to downplay haiti to highlight dr smh both countries are poor. They know how to make y’all look bad . Both countries are 90 percent black

    • @davidsantana9138
      @davidsantana9138 Před 10 měsíci +13

      Folks that say shit like Haiti needs to be "accountable" sound ignorant, esp. assuming you watched the video you still said that, on top of being Haitian yourself lmao, accountable for what? Developing a strong leader is not easy without them being bloodthirsty or selfish also

    • @sheedhasilv235
      @sheedhasilv235 Před 8 měsíci

      @@davidsantana9138 Haiti needs to take accountability for the self-inflicted harm that keeps being blamed on DR. Internationally, we are seen as a bunch racists that REFUSE to help Haiti solve its MANY issues. Sadly, some Haitians contribute to this discourse by continuously boicot DR for the simple reason that our country is doing better than theirs.
      Now, tho DR is wealthier than Haiti, it is by no means a rich enough country to take in all of Haiti and continuously aid them in every single one of its problems BECAUSE WE HAVE MANY OF OUR OWN. We also have corruption eating away our country to the roots, it may be better than the other side but it is still bad over here. We need to deal with our issues first because Dominicans come first in DR.
      Lastly, if the UN, US, Canada and all those other orgs and powerful countries (that are pressuring DR tho NOT inflict its immigration policies) actually cared about Haiti they would intervene themselves and not expect another poor country to come in and get everything fixed.
      Sorry if it is too long, but i feel like it needs to be said because i see a very strong bias that usually portrays Haiti as this poor victim that can do no wrong and the evil DR, which is indeed a very ignorant way of seeing things given the severity of what’s going on. My family from both sides comes from villages near the border area, therefore i grew up surrounded by the Haitian reality because i observed it closely. It is very sad, but the facts need to be said because pity won’t help Haiti stabilize itself and prosper.

    • @luisacleaves9592
      @luisacleaves9592 Před 8 měsíci

      Correct

    • @JoseRodriguez-fe4dw
      @JoseRodriguez-fe4dw Před 8 měsíci +8

      @@DeeztNutztkk537 Haitian always playing the victims will never develop.
      Haitian has stop talking about the past history and move forward to the present and future.

  • @juliamichelle6212
    @juliamichelle6212 Před 11 měsíci +1

    I love the speed of your speech. It is perfect. CZcamsrs are really amped up these days and it makes it hard to absorb information. Thank you.

  • @nikolairau9841
    @nikolairau9841 Před rokem +1

    Again..your ideas and compassions in comparisons become better and better and better. Well done. Thank-you so much. 🤗

  • @Tonyfernandez45
    @Tonyfernandez45 Před rokem +3

    Great great video my friend,I’m a Dominican and this type of video help me a lot to understand the history of both countries.
    Thank you for all your information. Looking forward to seeing more videos soon.

  • @sethaniel1
    @sethaniel1 Před rokem +1

    So many huge colabs in this one! MyHeritage as the sponsor, Hoser's colab, and a suggested Religion for Breakfast video! I really friggin hope this does well in the algorithm because this video is PERFECT!

  • @rosswebster7877
    @rosswebster7877 Před rokem

    Thanks Mr. Beat! I’ve been waiting for this vid for a long time!

  • @j.mieses8139
    @j.mieses8139 Před rokem +24

    I follow and and enjoy your content. I was wondering when you were going to eventually do a comparison between these two countries. I was Born in the Dominican Republic and moved to the states as a teen so I appreciate what you have done. The history of what has happened in that island for centuries is facinating!

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +3

      Awesome. Thanks for sharing. I hopefully did your home country justice!

    • @jorgeacosta3993
      @jorgeacosta3993 Před rokem

      Fascinating? or CATASTROPHIC?

    • @Sagiriteloresume
      @Sagiriteloresume Před 7 měsíci

      a los espectadores de catastrofes les parece entretenido todo como a la ridicula de Lizzy George Griffin@@jorgeacosta3993

  • @kevindurant2070
    @kevindurant2070 Před rokem +7

    So happy to see this collaboration between 2 of my favorite CZcamsrs

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +3

      Aww, thanks for the nice words!

    • @kevindurant2070
      @kevindurant2070 Před rokem

      @@iammrbeat thanks for the awesome content Mr. Beat 🔥

  • @Tubeyou72
    @Tubeyou72 Před 11 měsíci +1

    Thank you for sharing this informative video!🙌🏻🙌🏻

  • @Clueback
    @Clueback Před rokem +142

    Please do Yemen and Oman compared! That would be interesting

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +47

      This idea has been on my list for awhile. Thanks for suggesting it.

    • @corneliaaurelli1603
      @corneliaaurelli1603 Před rokem +2

      ​@@iammrbeatYeah man

    • @therealevilmudbug
      @therealevilmudbug Před rokem +1

      O, man...

    • @The_whales
      @The_whales Před rokem +2

      What about democrat republic of Congo with republic of Congo?

    • @lucinae8510
      @lucinae8510 Před rokem +2

      They are pretty similar to Haiti and the Dominican Republic, and sadly not in a good way.

  • @sketchyskies8531
    @sketchyskies8531 Před rokem +3

    Congratulations you actually made the sponsorship interesting enough that I watched it all the way through

  • @solar3013
    @solar3013 Před rokem +137

    The Dominican Republic isn’t among the poorest countries in the Western Hemisphere. It’s actually one of the wealthier countries in Latin America and the Western Hemisphere

    • @lilzim9559
      @lilzim9559 Před rokem +23

      Yup most people don’t know this nor they care to educate themselves

    • @PLATANITO829
      @PLATANITO829 Před rokem +14

      Judging by the clip he keeps posting that don't show el mirador sur nor downtown DR one will actually believe him 😂. Santo Domingo will soon be neck in neck with Miami by the way it's going if not better.

    • @icecreambeats101
      @icecreambeats101 Před rokem +13

      I don’t think so. I’m tired of my relatives in Dominican Republic asking me for money. And my american friends say Dominicans on Facebook as for money too. None of my Haitian relatives ask me for money.

    • @onasismatadelrosariogmailcom
      @onasismatadelrosariogmailcom Před rokem +9

      @@icecreambeats101 there's many lazy peopple also, and most of the dominicans are very good at administrating the money.

    • @icecreambeats101
      @icecreambeats101 Před rokem +6

      @@onasismatadelrosariogmailcom I’d say my mom and grandparents and few friends can manage their money well but many others, oh no. As if they think i am an atm machine lol

  • @nikolairau9841
    @nikolairau9841 Před rokem

    And also thanks for doing your MyHeritage. 😊

  • @JULIUSCOOLX
    @JULIUSCOOLX Před rokem +24

    Oh cool! I’m from the dominican republic, pretty cool that you’re talking about it

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +3

      That's awesome.

    • @familyandfriends3519
      @familyandfriends3519 Před 9 měsíci

      Your independence day is from Spain in 1821 your should be celebrating that day

  • @chrissurena1540
    @chrissurena1540 Před rokem +22

    Mi quisqueya 🇩🇴❤️ Dios, patria y libertad ,. For ever dominicana

  • @Noobprokermit
    @Noobprokermit Před rokem +7

    This is what we’ve been waiting for 🗣️

  • @Sonaholic
    @Sonaholic Před rokem

    Yooooo one of my favorite youtubers making a cameo in one of my other favorites love to see it

  • @Being_John
    @Being_John Před rokem +2

    Great video! Don’t think I’ve ever seen a video so early after upload. Great timing!

  • @JM290900
    @JM290900 Před rokem +68

    The DR is by no means a rich country, but I think calling it "one of the poorest countries in the Western hemisphere" seems a little too much, specially considering that below it you have countries like Nicaragua, Venezuela, Guatemala, Bolivia, El Salvador, Ecuador, etc in terms of gdp per capita. Of course when compared to countries like the US, Canada, and the Southern Cone, it's quite poor by comparison; but is it really appropiate to say "one of the poorest", specially considering it outperfoms a significant portion of the LAC region?

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +5

      I think you're being nitpicky

    • @jay1jayf
      @jay1jayf Před rokem +50

      @@iammrbeat Nah, he's right.

    • @agwa7832
      @agwa7832 Před rokem +15

      USA is very rich, however I have seen very poor areas in the states and homeless allover in the States that in the DR you dont see. Some areas in Brooklyn and some area in California look really poor. European Countries look richer than USA and cleaner.

    • @MikelOvalle
      @MikelOvalle Před rokem +26

      The DR actually is one of the richest countries in latin america.

    • @emanueldelacruz1101
      @emanueldelacruz1101 Před rokem +25

      @@iammrbeat
      The DR is one of the richest countries in the hemisphere with a GDP PPP Per Capita of 24,000 according to the IMF. It is slightly richer than Mexico

  • @karlpark8575
    @karlpark8575 Před rokem +30

    Used to travel DR to escape Canadian winter in the 90s. Very friendly people and loved their beaches. Surprisingly you can buy good cigars in DR. Hope they are doing well. Haiti is a basket case right now, wish them well.

    • @prohibitedname
      @prohibitedname Před rokem +4

      Why You havent returned? Definately is very different from the 90s DR.

    • @sgjoyder2890
      @sgjoyder2890 Před rokem +3

      @@prohibitedname And way better now!

    • @DynamicUnreal
      @DynamicUnreal Před rokem +5

      Dominican Republic is now known to have the best cigars in the world.

    • @karlpark8575
      @karlpark8575 Před rokem +5

      @@prohibitedname I don't know. Just got used to going down to Florida. I should restart my trip to DR.

    • @karlpark8575
      @karlpark8575 Před rokem +2

      @@DynamicUnreal I agree with that.

  • @2008Sanai
    @2008Sanai Před 7 měsíci

    Just found your channel and I love it! Thanks for the great accurate info!!

  • @chocolateavian
    @chocolateavian Před rokem

    Seeing this back to back with the hoser video is a great experience.

  • @ekmalsukarno2302
    @ekmalsukarno2302 Před rokem +103

    Mr. Beat, can you please make these following videos:
    - Malaysia and Indonesia Compared
    - Kenya and Tanzania Compared
    - Madrid and Barcelona Compared
    - Rome and Milan Compared
    - Chile and Argentina Compared
    - Cape Town and Johannesburg Compared

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +44

      An epic suggestion list. Thank you for that.

    • @axelpepen2642
      @axelpepen2642 Před rokem +2

      Why Madrid and Barcelona xD
      They're both cities of the same country i don't understand

    • @skyeshwin
      @skyeshwin Před rokem +4

      Also, can u do india vs Pakistan or Bangladesh vs Pakistan.. cheers 👍

    • @SabeethThePilot
      @SabeethThePilot Před rokem +4

      Yes FC Barcelona and real Madrid compared

    • @matrixfull
      @matrixfull Před rokem

      Compare Samara and Chelyabinsk. It would be interesting to see video about fun differences that are harder to find for normal viewer ( aka take more effort )

  • @subparnaturedocumentary
    @subparnaturedocumentary Před rokem +50

    this was interesting because honestly as an american we arent taught much about these countries in school at most we're shown one is poor and unstable and one is great for vacationing and finding good baseball players.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +5

      Well hopefully you learned a lot from watching this video. 🙂

    • @subparnaturedocumentary
      @subparnaturedocumentary Před rokem +2

      @Mr. Beat yes thank you and thanks for the links to other creators to watch more on the topic. my wife's friends husband is actually Haitian but moved here (southern New jersey) as a child, never talk much about history since every time I see him we spend the entire time talking about the goings on in the world of soccer.

    • @paul9299
      @paul9299 Před rokem +1

      Why would you be taught much about some of the most economically and strategically unimportant counties in global affairs in the American education system? I hate to break it to you but even in European schools very little is taught about these two countries as well

    • @fsexplorer9727
      @fsexplorer9727 Před rokem +2

      @@paul9299 Probably because of the human rights abuses and the illegal occupation of those countries? Luxembourg isn't very important for the global economy but you sure as hell will learn about it in German History during WWII because they illegally invaded it. That in it of itself is justification enough, and this whataboutism doesn't change the fact that the American Education system is incredibly americocentric.

    • @subparnaturedocumentary
      @subparnaturedocumentary Před rokem

      @Paul not saying it's right or wrong just saying for a place so close to the country we don't learn much about their history

  • @MrGrogan02
    @MrGrogan02 Před rokem +17

    Excellent video choice. I got entirely consumed by the duality of these two countries at some point during COVID.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +6

      It has always fascinated me.

  • @shawn.champagne
    @shawn.champagne Před rokem +3

    Both videos popped up in my recommended and I was like "Whoa, this has to be a collab. Let's goooo!" 😄

  • @yvesco5096
    @yvesco5096 Před rokem +19

    respect to the people 🇭🇹
    thank you for the video you should make a comparison between Morocco and Algeria

  • @quisqueyanguy120
    @quisqueyanguy120 Před rokem +38

    This is a great video, I know that there's a lot of bad blood between our people's but I hope that one day Haiti will be a more stable and peaceful country, so that we could see each other more like equals and live in peace and harmony in our common island. Greetings from the DR.

  • @danieltucker8382
    @danieltucker8382 Před rokem

    This Dan was listening!!! Thanks for spooking me!

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +1

      Haha I'm sorry but I love pulling that 😏

    • @danieltucker8382
      @danieltucker8382 Před rokem

      Just makes me love your videos even more! Thanks!

  • @BasicallyADiety
    @BasicallyADiety Před rokem

    I love this channel so much. Thank you for sharing education :)

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem

      I truly appreciate the kind words!

  • @ludel3539
    @ludel3539 Před rokem +3

    Hi Mr. Beat! I'm a fan from the Dominican Republic. Thank you for making this video. As always greast stuff. You should come visit our country someday.

  • @hennybautista3520
    @hennybautista3520 Před 7 měsíci +3

    Dominican republic has only one thing in common with Haiti, And it's that they share the same Island. Dominicans and Haitians are totally opposite of each other it's like oil and water they don't mix.

  • @adriandejesus2945
    @adriandejesus2945 Před 7 měsíci

    Very well explained about the two countries!

  • @mistermakeralquds
    @mistermakeralquds Před rokem +1

    Thanks for the great video!
    Just one detail: Christopher Columbus was looking for The Indies (not India), which is a much more generic concept. In particular was looking for the Islands of the Species, which is the Moluccas, in Indonesia

  • @edcasado6651
    @edcasado6651 Před rokem +22

    Video is GOOD/OK. But I don't really understand why every video about Haiti and DR finishes with this idea that both countries somehow should eventually be connected. Or that they have more in common than differences. That can literally apply to the entire world. We are all humans. We all have more in common than differences
    I mean, there is far more in common between the United States and Canada and no one ever arrives at that conclusion when doing a fair comparison assessment between those countries.
    Its hard to understand the low key obsession that the world has with a united D.R- Haiti when it has never been so. It makes no sense. Will Mexico and the USA ever be united? No

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +5

      You are ignoring the overwhelming evidence that backs up the fact that open borders lead to more prosperity. Will Mexico and the USA ever be united? Yeah, I can see that happening. The border wall that currently exists between the two countries is only a few decades old. Their cultures are way more similar than you'd probably realize.

    • @evillink1
      @evillink1 Před rokem +7

      Having grown up in Dominican Republic, I can say you're 100% correct. Culturally we're very different, and every child gets taught in school about our war of independence against the Hatians. It's a matter of national pride. Plus, there's a bit of racism in there unfortunately, we will never see the island united.

    • @jay1jayf
      @jay1jayf Před rokem +7

      @@iammrbeat LMAO, hold up. What evidence?

    • @quisqueyanguy120
      @quisqueyanguy120 Před rokem +13

      @@iammrbeat We Dominicans are open to more economic cooperation with Haiti and all nations but the idea of political unification as in giving up Dominican sovereignty and independence is unthinkable.

    • @edcasado6651
      @edcasado6651 Před rokem +3

      @@iammrbeat Open borders only exist in your head and is impossible as long as we live under a capitalist market economy. The capitalist market economy literally collapses if you have open borders. Modern nation-state exist in the modern world to separate markets and everything that it entails (labor laws, wages, standards, production, flow of capital, financing). Open border is a pipe-dream. Even countries of similar development do not have open borders among each other (See USA vs Canada which both protect their internal market).
      Why would you suggest that such economically and socially divergent countries such as the Dominican Republic and Haiti should implement open borders? That would be crazy and suggest you have very little knowledge of how the modern economy works. No Dominican in their right mind would accept such punishment. The moment you open the border the working class dominican population will have to compete with poorer Haitians willing to do the same work for less.

  • @rasmoise568
    @rasmoise568 Před rokem +80

    as a Haitian who trace his lineage to two African tribes Hausa & Tikar. Haitians in general we have absolutely nothing in common with Dominicans but more in common with Africa, hence why we wanted to join the African Union

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +10

      I had no idea about that!

    • @rasmoise568
      @rasmoise568 Před rokem +22

      @@iammrbeat yeah, phenotypically, genetically, linguistically & culturally we are different we only go to D.R. for work & that's that but other than that great videos

    • @danielgermain5572
      @danielgermain5572 Před rokem +27

      Culturally we Haitians are very similar to Africans especially Nigerians but to say that we don't have culture in common with DR is a lie because so much of Dominican culture comes from Africa as well. Do you think Dominican dances came from Spain or their slaves?

    • @jay1jayf
      @jay1jayf Před rokem +28

      @@danielgermain5572 Merengue is based on european ballroom dance. What makes you think is african?

    • @danielgermain5572
      @danielgermain5572 Před rokem +9

      @@jay1jayf From what i read on the origins of the dance is that is was created when the Africans mimicked the French minuet. But they considered the dance boring so they added elements to make it more exciting. Just look up the origins of the dance it should not be hard to find

  • @btrntsqsh
    @btrntsqsh Před rokem +1

    I knew there was a reason hoser and mr beat uploaded similar videos in the same week

  • @elmascavidal1797
    @elmascavidal1797 Před rokem

    I asked for this video… Months ago… good looking Mr Beat

  • @GiveMeYourFACE9089
    @GiveMeYourFACE9089 Před rokem +18

    If it's not too repetitive, a Dominica vs. Dominican Republic video would be cool!

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +10

      I actually considered this

    • @prod.jimmyhd
      @prod.jimmyhd Před rokem +9

      People from Dominica are culturally closer to us haitians then they are to dominicans, they speak a french based creole just like us. But theirs seems to be mixed with english.

    • @GiveMeYourFACE9089
      @GiveMeYourFACE9089 Před rokem +1

      @@prod.jimmyhd Interesting! Thanks for letting me know!

  • @johnchessant3012
    @johnchessant3012 Před rokem +13

    Great video! I think the history of US interventions in Latin America would make for a really interesting video topic.

  • @adrianogutierrezhernandez8137

    Great video! My greetings from Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic.🇩🇴🇩🇴🇩🇴

  • @Owlowlowl11
    @Owlowlowl11 Před rokem +15

    Please do Edmonton and Calgary next. As an American, I often get these two major cities mixed up.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +6

      I literally am doing that comparison next. :)

  • @zachheilman784
    @zachheilman784 Před rokem +3

    Mike Duncan's podcast Revolutions covered the Haitian Revolution, it's an excellent deep dive into a part of history too few people know about.

  • @despinal3830
    @despinal3830 Před rokem +18

    Thank you so much for this video, it shows you made your research. We are a multicolor nation not just a Black Nation as many Anti-Dominicans want to show. Haiti came 200 years later after we, dominicanos were already colonized and spoke Spanish.

    • @alexanderdelacruz3162
      @alexanderdelacruz3162 Před rokem +4

      Error, los dominicanos no fueron colonizados, de las tres raíces que conforman al pueblo dominicano la fundamental es la Española, nosotros los dominicanos somos los conquistadores de esta tierra y nadie nos colonizó.

    • @josecarvajal6654
      @josecarvajal6654 Před rokem +16

      @@alexanderdelacruz3162 somos las tres cosas: el conquistador, el conquistado y el esclavizado. Decir que solo somos descendientes de los conquistadores es un error muy grande, especialmente cuando el dominicano promedio tiene más ADN africano que español

    • @DynamicUnreal
      @DynamicUnreal Před rokem +3

      @@josecarvajal6654 No es cierto, es más o menos 50% Español, 35% Africano, y 5-15% indígena. Es más Africano si solo tomas en cuenta la ciudad de Santo Domingo. Los Cibaeños tienen mucho mas descendencia Española.

    • @josecarvajal6654
      @josecarvajal6654 Před rokem +4

      @@DynamicUnreal Es el promedio, obviamente algunos dominicanos tienen mas de Europeo, otros tienen mas de Africano, depende mucho de la persona y de la región, y no, no solo en la capital tenemos mas ADN africano, aplica a toda la región Este, Samaná y buena parte del Sur también.

    • @igpxmaster
      @igpxmaster Před rokem

      @@josecarvajal6654 Trujillo mindset is still rampant

  • @KristianWontroba
    @KristianWontroba Před rokem

    Great shirt Mr. Beat!

  • @neonzombi9928
    @neonzombi9928 Před rokem

    Great video Mr Beat

  • @prod.jimmyhd
    @prod.jimmyhd Před rokem +13

    22:28 not really. Nothing needs to be "connected" between the two nations anymore than it already is. Haitians we have our own culture, history, music, even language. Dominicans have all that too, minus the language. The only thing that needs to happen is for haitians to continue focusing on developing our own country and keep out foreign intervention. We have too many problems as a country right now to worry about lunch table drama with the DR.

    • @maximoarias-dn8kw
      @maximoarias-dn8kw Před rokem +2

      In name of all Dominicans we agreed with fix ya problems we dont have too we cant anymore. Too manny years carryin ya. God bless you quisqueya.

    • @MannyMonchy
      @MannyMonchy Před rokem +2

      This is accurate 💯

    • @maximoarias-dn8kw
      @maximoarias-dn8kw Před rokem +2

      Do it we aré cansado

    • @maximoarias-dn8kw
      @maximoarias-dn8kw Před rokem +1

      Ya need to move on n stop comin here take care of ta country.

    • @toshiIlI
      @toshiIlI Před rokem

      @@maximoarias-dn8kw you too

  • @BBoyy15
    @BBoyy15 Před rokem +6

    As a Dominican I can say that this is a very well made video, very aligned with the History we have always been taught. In terms of the cost of living question I would say the DR is definitely higher. Due to the points you made about the economies, but also from experience I know the haitian migrants get paid a miniscule amount in Dominican standards but would happily(relatively) do the job becuase its high compared to what they could get and need to survive in Haiti. As to the "closeness" and similarities they are mostly geographical since every major category that would separate any two societies exists (culture, religion, language, etc) so we can definitely work on joining forces to make each individual society better and stronger, but I dont think there will ever be more "closeness" than that. I always pray to see Haiti as a prosperous country which will benefit everyone. Peace and love to all our hatian neighbors.

    • @pedrovc6605
      @pedrovc6605 Před 8 měsíci

      Usted no es dominicano!

    • @BBoyy15
      @BBoyy15 Před 8 měsíci

      @@pedrovc6605 usted claramente no leyo( o entendio) lo que escribi. Vaya en paz! 😃

  • @self_improvement_d
    @self_improvement_d Před rokem

    Came here after watching Hoser's video, nice video!

  • @mingfanzhang8927
    @mingfanzhang8927 Před rokem

    I really enjoy the video,keep up the good work 🤗🤗🤗🤗❤️❤️❤️❤️💗💗💗❣️❣️❣️

  • @thephiladelphiantoddler2855

    I loves these videos! Could you do Botswana vs Zimbabwe?

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem

      Great suggestion and thank you!

  • @mapk1516
    @mapk1516 Před rokem +15

    Ahhh the compared series has returned!
    I would like to suggest Egypt and Sudan compared, East Timor and West Timor compared, and Portland Oregon and Portland Maine compared

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +4

      I like the suggestions, but I doubt the East Timor and West Timor video would get that many views. What country should I compare Indonesia to?

    • @soifon7000
      @soifon7000 Před rokem +2

      @@iammrbeat How about Malaysia?

    • @SabeethThePilot
      @SabeethThePilot Před rokem +2

      ​@@iammrbeatI think Philippines?

    • @RK-cj4oc
      @RK-cj4oc Před rokem

      ​@@iammrbeatMay i suggest something different?
      Indonesia is huge. Especially in population. 4th largest in the world. Maybe " compare" its huge size to different countries. For example if put over the US Indonesia stretches from beyond coast to coast. The island of Java has more people than ALL of russia. And Jakarta their capital has more people than their former colonial overlord has total population.

    • @mapk1516
      @mapk1516 Před rokem +1

      @@iammrbeat Hmm maybe comparing Philippines to Indonesia would be better. Malaysia should be compared to Thailand because they're both monarchies with substantial populations of each other's main religions (Thailand Buddhist majority with sizeable Muslim minority whole Malaysia is Muslim majority with sizeable Buddhist minority)

  • @jankusthegreat9233
    @jankusthegreat9233 Před rokem

    U are the best along side vlogging through history

  • @millenniumvintage9726
    @millenniumvintage9726 Před rokem +1

    Was not expecting to see the Mr. Beat/hoser crossover episode in my lifetime

  • @PersioAcevedo
    @PersioAcevedo Před 7 měsíci +10

    As a Dominican, I hope that Haiti and its people can unite and take the necessary steps to restore the country to its former glory. I would also love to see Haiti and its people prosper. I sincerely hope that both nations can find productive and positive methods to work together.

  • @curtisthomas2670
    @curtisthomas2670 Před rokem +8

    Fun fact: Toussaint L'Ouverture served as a General in the French Republican Army in Haiti after France abolished slavery there fighting against the Spanish and British, for more than a year he served as a General in the Spanish Army in Santo Domingo fighting against the French and British for Spain, then served as a General in the Armee Indiginee - the rebel army of former slaves and indigenous peoples fighting against the French, British and Spanish.

  • @meepmeep8035
    @meepmeep8035 Před rokem

    That's awesome that you went on Hoser lol!

  • @eddyg.1366
    @eddyg.1366 Před 8 měsíci

    Thank you Hoser.

  • @jumagomos
    @jumagomos Před rokem +10

    Soy Dominicano y te voy a poner claro, al final del video dices que tenemos demasiado en común y que estamos divididos por que Haití es mas pobre, pero nada que ver con tu comentario, somos muy diferentes culturalmente, no es un problema de racismo ni de clasismo, ademas los enfrentamientos históricos que nos preceden hace que tengamos cierta desconfianza en ambos países, sin embargo los Haitianos no corren ningún peligro en Republica Dominicana, mientras que los Dominicanos que visitan Haití están constantemente en peligro, incluso han sido secuestrados muchos en varias ocasiones, también los haitianos han cometido muchos crímenes atroces en nuestro pais, a pesar de que hay muy pocos Dominicanos que están de acuerdo con fusionar la isla, esto traerá muchos conflictos sociales y muchos enfrentamientos y consecuencias nefastas. Espero que puedas entender lo que he escrito, ya que es la realidad que vivimos los Dominicanos y lo que la mayoria piensa y quiere, no fusion de la isla, somos independientes cada pais.

    • @raymondcerv1370
      @raymondcerv1370 Před rokem

      La mayoría de los crimenes en RD lo hacen los mismos Dominicanos

  • @av.6809
    @av.6809 Před rokem +22

    Phenotypically, genetically, linguistically and culturally we are different. We practically have nothing in common. We Dominicans don't like to be compared to Haitians and they don't like to be compared to us either. I wish the best for our neighbors. that is what we are neighbors, we cannot be brothers because we do not share the same roots, but it is the same to your lifelong neighbor you appreciate, you help him in what you can and you wish him the best.

    • @bastianx8772
      @bastianx8772 Před rokem

      Where are your roots?? I mean where are you from?? Spain

    • @av.6809
      @av.6809 Před rokem +10

      @@bastianx8772 Actually, I am half Spanish and half Dominican (you would be surprised at the number of Dominicans like me, children of a foreign father/mother) but it is more than clear that Haitians have preserved more of their African roots; They have been cared for and passed down from generation to generation and also retain most of their physical features. and we Dominicans have segregated ourselves, that's why there are many mestizos here LIKE ME. and there is nothing wrong with that. what I said was not with bad intentions, it is simply the truth.

    • @jgerman5093
      @jgerman5093 Před 11 měsíci +4

      @bastian X we Dominicans are indeed a Hispanic people. To say or insinuate otherwise is to be disingenuous.

    • @MikelOvalle
      @MikelOvalle Před 7 měsíci +1

      @@bastianx8772 We have roots in Africa, Spain and Tainos. Haitans are mostly 100% african.

    • @MoneyMindset-ho1ch
      @MoneyMindset-ho1ch Před 7 měsíci

      My friend haitians come from west africa and we are mixed race thats true but our black side is also from west africa basicly we are from diferent father but the same mother

  • @fosahistorica2537
    @fosahistorica2537 Před rokem +1

    I was waiting this video for years now

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +1

      Well thanks for your patience. :)

    • @maximoarias-dn8kw
      @maximoarias-dn8kw Před rokem

      U waited for nothin he dindt reseach rite. Maybe 60 percent of it its accurate. We dont get along with haitians point. We are not the same culture. Its like tellin irish his culture its mexican or a white vice n versa

    • @fosahistorica2537
      @fosahistorica2537 Před rokem

      @@maximoarias-dn8kw yeah its a little biased , but please, check your orthography in English

    • @maximoarias-dn8kw
      @maximoarias-dn8kw Před rokem

      @@fosahistorica2537 my phone its not on point.i type too fast thank you

  • @therealevilmudbug
    @therealevilmudbug Před rokem

    Cool video, Mr. Beat

  • @lilzim9559
    @lilzim9559 Před rokem +25

    Correction the Dominican Republic is actually one of the iciest countries in Latin America and the Western Hemisphere it’s city Santo Domingo is one of the richest most developed cities in Latin America, the dr is the most visited country in the Caribbean and it’s growth is quite impressive

    • @familyandfriends3519
      @familyandfriends3519 Před 9 měsíci

      Dominican republic got independence from Spain in 1821 you should be celebrating that independence day

    • @mickeyjimenez
      @mickeyjimenez Před 8 měsíci +1

      @@familyandfriends3519 we do...restoration day august 16th

    • @familyandfriends3519
      @familyandfriends3519 Před 8 měsíci

      @@mickeyjimenez Dominican republic got independence from Spain in 1821

    • @mickeyjimenez
      @mickeyjimenez Před 8 měsíci +2

      @@familyandfriends3519 exactly we call it the restoration of our independence....that's why i told you the first independence day is celebrating every february 27th and the restoration of our independence, from spain, is celebrating every august 16th

    • @familyandfriends3519
      @familyandfriends3519 Před 8 měsíci

      @@mickeyjimenez no Dominican republic first got independence from Spain in 1821 then independence restored from Haiti then again from Spain in 1865

  • @queenrudshel9802
    @queenrudshel9802 Před rokem +7

    You couldn’t find better pictures of Haiti? 😂 There are wayyyy more “civils” places in Haiti than is shown.

    • @MVictorious11
      @MVictorious11 Před rokem +4

      I said the same thing! There’s definitely WAaaayyyy better pictures of Haiti that could have been posted… Coming from a Haitian person 😒

    • @phsza5607
      @phsza5607 Před 11 měsíci

      The yt man hates Haiti lol despite Haiti current state 1804 was a major L for them . If you look at early films from the 20’s and 30’s they even created the narrative associating “zombies” with Haitians. Their propaganda train is crazy

  • @shoelady6457
    @shoelady6457 Před rokem

    Informative 😊

  • @spinyslasher6586
    @spinyslasher6586 Před rokem +5

    Thanks to hoser for bringing me here 😁

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +3

      He has more viewers than I do.

    • @spinyslasher6586
      @spinyslasher6586 Před rokem +2

      @@iammrbeat Well I'll now contribute to both since both of you are incredible channels 😊

  • @ashliesatwick5977
    @ashliesatwick5977 Před rokem +16

    Hi there, I’m commenting from Luxembourg . Interesting to know she connects with people from different parts of the world. Such an ambitious woman. I got in touch with Ms. Davis early this year. As a newbie in the market, I had little knowledge on predicting the stock market, but with Ms. Norman weekly analysis and advise profits are guaranteed! I received three times my initial deposit in a week!!

    • @eleanorchelsie6094
      @eleanorchelsie6094 Před rokem +1

      You put out some valuable content. A little off topic maybe, but there’s this woman I got in touch with during the market downsizing which cost me my job. Ms. Norman Davis helped me manage my assets by introducing my to the best trading platform and strategies, I earned a lot of $$$ working with Norman at the comfort of my home. I still keep in touch with the amazing lady

    • @eleanoryvaine4846
      @eleanoryvaine4846 Před rokem +4

      Love and light from Florida, I’m trying to create long term wealth to set towards property one day . How can i reach out to her? she could be of great help

    • @ashliesatwick5977
      @ashliesatwick5977 Před rokem +4

      < normandavis

    • @despachellesD
      @despachellesD Před rokem +1

      I run a mini food business in Paris which have been affected by food inflation and I needed a side hustle that could help me boost my small business, so I could give my employees better wages , I got in contact with Ms. Norman a month ago and my stories became testimonies… I wasn’t charged on my first investment with her. Yes, I received my first returns last week… I’m considering reinvesting

  • @Trethan3266
    @Trethan3266 Před rokem

    Hey from hoser’s channel! Nice vid

  • @paulosoria1279
    @paulosoria1279 Před rokem

    Very well done comparison,
    Please do Lima and Bogotá next.

  • @Iamme516
    @Iamme516 Před rokem +6

    DR is not one of the poorest countries of the region.
    Guatemala, Bolivia, El Salvador, Nicaragua, Venezuela etc are poorer than DR.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +1

      Of the Americas

    • @o.ramirez
      @o.ramirez Před rokem +2

      @@iammrbeat Not even in The Américas, find out before “inform”.

    • @Jimmy_none
      @Jimmy_none Před rokem +1

      @@iammrbeat why you ain’t mention the “beheadings of moca” you had chance to make a factual video but decide to do what hundreds of other CZcamsrs did. Smh

    • @thebembucaro4566
      @thebembucaro4566 Před rokem +1

      @@iammrbeat Not even, guatemala, el salvador, colombia, mexico, Ecuador, brasil, peru, bolivia, paraguay, Nicaragua, honduras, are the poorest

  • @abrahamlincoln937
    @abrahamlincoln937 Před rokem +3

    Mr. Beat, you should do a video comparing Liberia and Libya.

  • @CarlosCastro_
    @CarlosCastro_ Před 7 měsíci +2

    Can you talk about the Degüello de Moca, amongst other violent events that took place in DR when Haiti invaded the DR for 22 years.

  • @Theover4000
    @Theover4000 Před rokem

    I'm here from Hoser, I'm surprised I found him before I found you, good stuff in your backlog, guess I have something to do tonight!

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +1

      Awesome. I appreciate you giving my channel a chance!

    • @Theover4000
      @Theover4000 Před rokem

      @@iammrbeat it’s good content, of course I’ll give it a chance!

  • @orboakin8074
    @orboakin8074 Před rokem +6

    As a Nigerian, this video and history of Haiti makes me appreciate the fact that the British were the ones who colonized/created my country and not the French. Most former British colonies tend to do better socioeconomically and politically compared to French ones. The British had a habit of importing and imposing their political and economic and social ideals on their colonies which tended to help them after colonialism. Yes, my country still has issues aplenty but compared to many other countries here in Africa and like Haiti, we are so much better economically and socially and politically and getting better still.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  Před rokem +4

      I've noticed this as well.

    • @orboakin8074
      @orboakin8074 Před rokem +1

      @@iammrbeat it is a very common trend in much of world history. I'd love to see you and others, like h0ser, talk about it. For all the negatives the British had, their colonial history had more net positives than most. On major example being that they were among the first in most nations and empires to abolish slavery, especially where it existed before they came like in Africa. That's one of the reasons why even in my country, despite our issues, most of us have a very positive view of the British.

    • @MoneyMindset-ho1ch
      @MoneyMindset-ho1ch Před 7 měsíci

      The same thing happen in the DR my country with spanish it seems like french were more cruel, by the way i have a Nigerian friend, good food that you have