Should reservation be determined by caste or religion?
Vložit
- čas přidán 4. 09. 2015
- Just as we saw the demand for publication of caste-based data subside, a 22-year-old youth belonging to the Patel community in Gujarat burst into the scene demanding that Patels be included in the OBC (Other Backward Classes) list. Hardik Patel created a stir by gathering lakhs of Patels for the cause and by issuing a firm warning to the government of a continuous agitation if demands were not met. Vice President Hamid Ansari, highlighting the plight of Muslims also demanded affirmative action for the community but stopped short of demanding any reservation. Is reservation the only tool for the marginalised, backward communities for empowerment? Is it more of a political path of expressing the plight and might of your community to be recognised as a homogenous votebank? What about doing away with reservations at the IITs and IIMs? Finally, should reservation be determined by caste or religion? Should social and economic empowerment be the only criteria?
Watch full video: www.ndtv.com/video/player/the-...
Reservation system should definitely be removed!!people should be given jobs based on their talent and credibility,not on caste,religion or whatsoever!!
Intergenerational land and wealth and connections and favouring of some caste caste because of God what should we do about that
Merit only merit only merit only no other base
India can keep the reserved.
We import the deserved
nice.hope i can come to europe!
What is the relation of reservation and low cut off ?
People says that people scoring 90% are jobless and people scoring 40% are getting job.Remove this low cut off ,increase this cut off so that all have to score high.
Why both the supporters of reservation, mr. Udit raj and dr. Prasad have to defend themselves so forcefully.
It speaks everything.
instablaster
R.i.p indian development 😂😂
40% scorer - make in India
90% scorer- go make in USA, China,Japan
Bhai Kaha pakad loge inko😂😂
Vote banks vote banks vote banks
Kisiko ghanta farak Nahi padta ki India Kaha ja rha h
Is bjp wale ko bta to dete ki English me ho rha h garib admi fsa dia😅😅😅
the way he insults professor chopra,show his intellect🤏
Caste and reservations are not divine. These are against the law of nature. Being blessed divine creation we should render justice to all and divinity both.
Height of secularism
Mr Chopra your real nature of casteism is apparently visible
Thanks Prasad sir
reservation should b throw away
if a person is stoned because he is dalit then he shoud be given Law support..
IIT me reservation dene se kya hoga???? IIT me jake chup jayega???
its like Mujhe pyas laga hai but govt mujhe pani ke wajay Biriyani de raha hai..
What a Logic.... Kill all the tigers to save Goats... That is Social justice...
bijoy I am reserved category and I oppose those who oppose reservations but this point of yours has lots of logic which I support.but do u support social equality . do u oppose atrocities against dalits
or u support discrimination against dalits like raping their women burning their houses not allowing them education or not allowing them to enter temples .please give honest and unbiased answer .
andy murray
I support social equality and reservation in no way support it..
Do you know what equality menas?? If reservation was a good plan then why so much criticize about it?? why after 70+ years of reservation more and more caste are becoming backwards ???
andy murray
During arguments dalit say that "We are majority and we have power to topple govt"
Then why are you so much concerned about the So called "Discrimination" by monority upper caste...
You support Reservation which discriminate every Upper caste person.. makes him a victim and you are talking about equality...
Ridiculous...
+Bijoy Chakraborty i support reservation out of compulsion as upper castes support casteism and practise it wherever possible. i know reservations compromise merit but merit has been compromised for past 5000 years and special reservations were enjoyed by upoer castes for 5000 years. they fail to realise this and want to continue with this ancestral legacy. mindset of upper castes must change which will help in actually bringing social equality than reservations. if upper castes give up on casteism we giveup on reservations.
Nothing would be worse than having reservations on basis of caste.
Reservation May determined by necessity of work field for man civilization i. E cleaning, medical services,.. Etc
Dr. Prasad when you speak to someone who is probably more educated than you like Professor Chopra that "he is from a different planet", shows that even 100 years of quota education can not redress the issue. Name calling is an act of an uneducated, illiterate man.
Remove reaservation
shd there be it on basis of religion caste creed etc?
Anti reservation squad is not actually worried about merit and country's development. There main objective is to maintain upper castism and there privilege status in society that's why they have been trying to oppose reservation since 1932.
Nonsense keep lying to yourself
When an individual fears his candy to be snatched away then individuals like you come up with foolish arguments
Mr Chopra is great casteist
are yar why you got this politician in such high ground debate , it should be with high intellectuals & bureaucrats .
its time to change Barker of reservation to not to cast as based on income only
Well done NDTV for a well balanced discussion
the part where Udit Raj goes berserk is so funny @15:05, he says he is second to none....lol
this is a must watch @ 17:40
Remove reservation at temple .
Caste base reservation must be removed from everywhere. You can see progress in positive way that many temples have Non-bramhin pujari. 👍
@@yashesh8229 : In similar way there are many government area where there is no reservation. First remove caste. Caste is a brutal, inhuman system should be rooted out from society.
@@manasranjan2305 I completely agree with you brother . . . Caste has to be removed from our society . . . Inter caste marriage is one of the best way to eliminate casteism . . .
Reservation should not be determined by caste or religion but only economic base.
1% marks zero marks m addmission milta h
Dr. Prasad, every word u spoke proved that u have survived only on quota.
GAURAV VASHISHT just like u survived on temple quota..
Abbe cgutiye..tujhe temple main jana chaiye iya fir job chaiye..konsa???
@@nickukumarsingh7983 nonsense. temple is not the question. Jobs and education far more desired by most people
what Prof. Chopra spoke is a reality. I have seen some of my friends hating education even if they manage to pass out from IIT. They feel ashamed of many things and lacks the confidence of not able to compete. There are also some of my friends who grasp how to compete and study for the exams and make a good career but still, the majority of students lack.
its true. in fact IITs run bridge courses. If students of reserved category fail to show even the minimum competence but have to be admitted because seats are to be filled. Then these students are given special preference and taught at the govt's cost, mind you not their cost but with public money and then admitted for the degree course. And these students usually are from good economic and social backgrounds. Their parents have decent jobs, education and social status. How can any system justify such preference where quality educational institutes are so limited for a very large population.
A general category student is not given education even when he is meritorious and a reserved category student gets education even when he lacks merit and given subsidized education when he can afford it. Then there is nothing wrong in general caste students asking for reservation. Because there is no other way they can compete in this system.
neither cast based nor religion based.
I love udit raj points, completely baseless
Do away with reservations totally
Caste based reservation is a problem for nation. Because the person who has taken benifit of it, their relatives, and his generation is taking benifit. Other poor fellow of his Cast still waiting for it
Like this India will never be a developed country everyone fighting for reservations there should ban this one's and for all cant even believe in 21st century we still have this debate.
eligibility should be qualification ...give them chance to study where they can improve and process not blindly making them sit on top of qualified people....don't give them fish teach them to fish......
Bastard JNU.. tera awaz dekha... sounds like a begger
USA had more reservation than India
The one and only Chandra Bhan prasad...
So funny..
And they think that they are nationalist....
vikram chandra stop doing these kindof shows man, seriously religion or cast? who wants to uplift a religion or cast ? we want to uplift people? so we need to target people not religion or cast.....and first of all debate on reservation was not the innermost motive of this show....distracting people from the actual path was the hidden agenda of this show....that is what i feel
मेरे पास एक सबसे बढ़िया उपाय है रिजर्वेशन ख़तम करने का . ब्राहमणों ने हजारो साल तक sc/st/obc (बहुजनो) को शिक्षा, बेसिक सुविधा, संपत्ति रखनेका के अधिकारों से वंचित रखा. अब ब्राह्मण, और अप्पर कास्ट वालो को अगले २० साल तक सिर्फ शिक्षा से वंचित रखा जाए. 20 साल 3000 सालो के मुकाबले ज्यादा नहीं है. और अगले 20 साल तक कोई इस नियम का उल्लंघन करे तो उसे 100 कोड़े मारने की शिक्षा का अमल किया जाना चाहिए. और 20 साल बाद किसी भी रिजर्वेशन के मांग को जायज ना ठहराया जाए. सहमत है तो शेयर करे.
bilkul bada achcha hai, fuck nation lick dalit's ass.
agreed rangari bhau j'ai bhim
aise hi logo se neeyat samajh me aati hai dalito ki. Imaandari ke liye shukriya.
+champak chaudry tumhari banayi hui kadvi dava jab tumehi pini pad rahi hain toh kitni takleef ho rahi hain na champak babu isse samajh mein aati hain kamzori so called uppercaste waloki. humne toh Yeh dava 5000 saal pi aura tumhari 60 saal mein hi pungi Baj gayi.
jab logo ne jaat paat k hathiyar se shoshan kiya hai tab uska ant v to usi k nam par hona chahiye
First time agree with pathan
जाटव विदेशी अफ्रीकन है।इसे इसके देश भेजना होगा।
Chandala according to Manu smriti.... Brahmin women and shudra man 😂😂😂
Simple solution... no reservation for all
Reservation is Shame to India--The greedy Politicians really brought a terrible system for the Votebank.
I mean its a shame just because you belong from certain caste you get admission on 0% and 1% ...common what are we doing and we are supporting Reservation why?
Whenever they are stuck they will talk about History and past common if something has happened on the past that should be corrected but going back to history will not help ..
Is reservation right or Wrong??
Well everyone including the so called son and daughter of govt the SC/ST(OBC are financial based reservation) know that..
There are 1000000000000 of ways to end reservation but only think we lack is willpower ....
If you can't end reservation... Legalize caste change as you have legalized religion change...
Why most of the corrupted and scammers are from upper caste. For example Ajay Mehta nirav Modi Vijay malya. And these people tell about country's development.
50.5 % reservation is for general i.e (Without OBC's ,SCs, and STs). IN spite of having more than 50% population of OBCs, its presence in Govt is very dismal. Come on OBC's candidates, pz catch up.
Aaa..idiot...that 50% is for ipen category ..everyone can apply in that space...
@@debarjundutta8912 s u r absolutely right.every one can apply in that open category
Reservations should be reviewed and should be the basis of reservation economic.
Agreed. Reservation should based on economic level to every indian citizen irrespective of the religion they follow. Muslims condition is worse than even SC/ST/OBC people.
Nazira there are 75percent dalits in Indian Muslims.Upper caste Indian Muslims are generally rich
Asharfi Lal Mishra, Educationist. Caste inequality is extremely higher than economic inequality.
Lets take this example.
SBI PO exam result declared on 12/7/2015.
Lets see cut offs:-
1.General category-47.25
2.OBC-42
3.SC-35
4.ST- 19
Now somebody tell me how a candidate with 20 marks entering in sbi can contribute to strengthening of SBI better than a General category thrown out at 46 marks.
Is SBI an educational institute?
Didn't u provide the same candidate reservation at educational institute?
India can never progress if we ll continue reservations even in jobs.
Get a life.
GAURAV VASHISHT there is no empirical evidence which shows reservation deprives advancements
GAURAV VASHISHT that u have to ask ur uper caste brahman why did they made cast system due to reservation has been applied in india..i think they will give u better answer..
Khudi dekh lo.. yaha pe jo dalit khde h unki haalt.. ? Wo khud hi yaha khda hona deserve nahi krte.. baat krna tk nahi aata... aisa hi hr jgh h jaha b quota h... quota mtlb quality compromised
More anti-reservation arguments by propenents of barbaric Manusmriti..Fundamental basis for reservations are.
1. Take the poverty among castes..its highest in SC/ST and BC.. Forward castes own more than disproportionate wealth. Brahmin enjoyed free housing in Temple properties in agraharam and possess most temple kattalai lands. Varnasharam system only educate brahmins. So is there a level playing field? NEVER!
2. Learning environment is not available to underprivileged SC/ST and BC compared to privileged castes. Also most of the SC/ST and BC live in Rural India and severly handicapped in terms of quality education and exposure to developments and advancements. UNEVEN SOTUATION.
3. In a uneven playing field reservation is a must. More than 90% of jobs were taken by 10% of the privileged population. Then how to ensure equality and social justice...
4. I am surprised how selfish we as a society and we lost social perception. We are not bothered to grow together as a nation.
5. Let us touch our conciousness and ask the almighty to guide us to treat all Indians equally and share and uplift all together.
6. EVR PERIYAR fought for Antidiscrimation, and social justice and fought for reservations..in Tamil Nadu which is successful. Now we can see Tamil SC/BC ARE EMPLOYED in the USA and everywhere . There is no reservation in the USA for SC/BC.
7. The top schools and colleges are managed by Christian missionaries. Most of these educational institutions are managed by the the SC/ST and BC and most of the so called elites were taught by these underprivileged people. Those teachers were treated hither to either as untouchabkes are sudras but they could teach all of us and make us good educated citizens.
8. Merit is conveniently abused. If opportunity is given to all of them, everyone has the inherent merit that needs exposure to an enabling environment and thats what reservations are all about. Let us stop all these selfish cry against reservations. Let us help to enable all of us to grow together to make India the Great!!!
India the country that 40% passed got the job but 80%can't got the job. so think what will be India future
Could you say caste system and Varna system destroyed india
The Indian voter needs to mature. Right now, the mindset is too short sighted
The solution for this is seperate technical , professional colleges for Dalits. No dalit should go to upper caste college. Dalit should be provided seperate college.
i support prof. k.l chopra ye quota wale IIT ka nam kharab kar rahen hai
Modi talks about Youth..... but he forgot that teh same youth he talks, who he thinks has the capability of change workd, has Iphones in their hard.. use to tweet or post on facebook how backward are them...
Do the IIT education has changed them even after IAS job... they still think they are backwards...
Bhai India bheekh manga ka desh hai... Kisiko free me doge to wo zindagi me kaam nai karega...
Chopra sir is blatantly lying
The Dalits sound like bullies
It is very shameful that a foreign journalist is discussing our local issue. Our local issues should discussed among Indians only.
Local issue only Indian.
he teaches in JNU and Delhi University, and is teaching for the past 30 yrs
He’s an Indian now
national lebal. international lebal. hahaha