Is BTS the greatest K-Pop group ever?! Professional Singer Reaction & Vocal ANALYSIS | "Fake Love"
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 06. 2024
- 💿 Pre-save my new album for free! distrokid.com/hyperfollow/pet...
💰 If you'd like to support me, please consider joining my Patreon family for as little as $1/month. Higher tiers come with access to my private Discord server, Patreon-Exclusive Reaction & Analysis videos, Patreon-Selected Reaction & Analysis videos, merch, behind-the-scenes footage, and more! Join here: / petermbarber
🎽 Get your custom jersey here! www.diyoj.com and use code "Peter" at checkout 🎽
⭐ Check out Tunelark for 50% OFF your trial lesson! www.tunelark.com/promo/peter-... ⭐
⭐ Link to Original Video: • BTS (방탄소년단) 'FAKE LOVE... ⭐
=======================================
📱 Follow me on social media:
Linktree: linktr.ee/petermbarber
Instagram: @petermbarber
OnlyFans (Fitness Content): petermbarber
TikTok: @petermbarber
Facebook: Peter Barber, bass
CZcams: Peter Barber
Patreon: / petermbarber
Website: www.petermbarber.com/
🎤 Join the Bass Singing Nation on Discord! / discord
=======================================
🛍️ Get your merch:
Etsy: www.etsy.com/shop/PeterBarber...
TeeSpring: www.peterbarbermerch.com/
=======================================
#bts #btsfakelove #btsreaction
⏰ Timestamps:
0:00 - Intro
1:15 - Reaction & Analysis
22:30 - Final Thoughts - Hudba
BTS is absolutely WORLD-CLASS! What else do I need to watch and analyze from this amazing group?
Please do BTS Room Live - czcams.com/video/RRhjdYsNwAk/video.htmlsi=4m7ieAvDhCn8y1vy ! It’s a live medley performance of parts of their songs throughout their albums and it really introduces their music perfectly! Also, I would love to see you react to this czcams.com/video/szcdEG5ccxU/video.htmlsi=5XebB4U30_lIN25e - it’s Jimin’s solo song arranged in a jazz manner, completely stripped down and intimate. I think it’s kind of a performance you’d enjoy! Thank you for your videos, I’m always looking forward to your reactions and hoping for more of BTS💜
Com certeza você deve olhar "Black Swan" e "ON" eu particularmente amo "Blood Sweet and Tears" ☺️💜
@@Ella-qk1rt yesss it is must, also all of their live performances.
FLY TO MY ROOM PLEASEEE
@@Ella-qk1rt One of my alltime favourites "Pied Piper"💜
Thanks for the reaction. There are 3 rappers and 4 vocalists in BTS. Kpop isn't really a genre, it's more of an industry in South Korea. This is how Suga from BTS defined kpop when asked in an interview if he considered kpop a genre "K-pop includes not just the music, but the clothes, the makeup, the choreography…all these elements I think sort of amalgamate together in a visual and auditory content package, that I think sets it apart from other music or maybe other genres so again, as I said, rather than approach K-pop as it’s own genre I think approaching it as this integration of different content would be better.” In my opinion BTS isn't just the best kpop group but they are one of the best of groups/artists of all time. They are global superstars competing with the biggest artists of all time and in some instances beating them or surpassing their records. People are so quick to box BTS into the kpop or boy band bubble, I don't see this happen often with western artists. BTS has also said they don't want to limit their hearts and their music to the term kpop. And I kind of wish you would've put BTS' name in the title of the video, but I'm sure you didn't mean any harm in not putting their name in the title. I hope you understand where I'm coming from and I would love to see more reactions to BTS or even the members' solo songs/albums.
Thanks for this info! I just added "BTS" to the title :]
@@PeterBarber Thank you.
I agree with everything you said
BTS has 6 videos with over 1 B view count with 2 other videos close to the Billion mark. The most is Dynamite with 1.8 B views. And yes, in my opinion, they are the best.
We will be there for any BTS reactions but live performances are always amazing!
70 yrs old, BTS is the best I've witnessed by FAR!
STRAY KIDS IS THE KING OF KPOP FOREVER THE BESTS ARTISTS LEGENDARY STRAY KIDS TRUE KINGS OF KPOP
@@himaririku9254sk is pure noice music 💀
@@himaririku9254 🤖🤖🤖
@@himaririku9254 LMAOROFL.....You need to check into mental hospital.....
Are you lie to yourself 😂😂😂??i am a stay but the truth is bts is the best @@himaririku9254
BTS…
Is way more than k-pop. They’ve really done a great job infiltrating most genres
Has 3 rappers and 4 singers
Lived together for years and have an unbeatable bond
were looked down upon when they first started. Eric Nam stated it best when he said that BTS are underdogs. When they went global, Korea then started to give them their flowers.
There’s a running tidbit that BTS are actually full time comedians than idols 😂 you’ll see in their Run BTS shows, in the soop, and bon voyage
Army will give you a wonderful list of recommendations to listen to
71 year old BTS Army here. Other groups have singers that rap. BTS has rappers that rap. Suga and RM come from underground rap and J-hope was a street dancer at a young age that basically learned from them. The BTS rappers are the most prolific songwriters of the 7. Most of BTS stats such as awards are usually at least 2 or 3 times the number of the other groups. They have led the way for other groups, and there will never be another BTS!
Thanks for your great reaction as always! 💜
There are a few other rappers that are aknowledged rappers in Idol music: Zico, Jessi, Jay Park, G-Dragon, Stray Kids rapline...
But you are right: the majority in Idol groups do have vocalists who (occassional) rap or even people that rap because they can't sing.
💜
@@ruthfischer7615Only kpoppies think that Jay Park, G Dragon or the stray kids rapline are real rappers let alone good ones. They only are rap pretenders who use hip hop as an aesthetic and think that rap and hip hop is about being cool and having swag. LoL they are completely clueless about hip hop culture.
@@ruthfischer7615 pls look up to what "underground rappers " Mean rm and suga were exactly that raw hiphop lovers rapping for their life in underground scene under different names not getting trained in a company on how to rhyme or flow
@@pennybleta2300
That's cute.
I don't listen to any of them.
Stray Kids rapline not only became full members of the KOMCA last year for their song writing - you should really look up the list of their songs:
About every third song has no one but members on song credits and they are also in the other songs.
They also have a song with a K-Hiphop rapper.
Jay Park has done a lot for K-Hiphop actually - you and i don't have to like him for that - but he has clout in the scene.
Why do you think Hobi was on a show with him at "the seasons"(sp?)?
G-Dragon I have less knowledge of but he has written a lot, too and began rap early.
I think he may have been 9.
With him admittedly I have no idea how much he is aknowledged.
You should try the K-Hiphop scene because they are different from what you think.
Even if - admittedly - most of them didn't study US-Hiphop I guess by now they don't have to.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
It would help you if you look into the K-Hiphop scene.
BTW: the only rappers I'm interested in are Yoongi, Hobi and Namjoon.
@@jayashree-el3sz
Yes, and?
I know that about Namjoon aka. Runch Randa and Yoongi aka. Gloss.
There are people in the Idol scene that are aknowledged in the K-Hiphop scene.
You don't have to like it.
I'm certainly not listening to them.
But it does not make it untrue.
The auto tune section feeds into the lyrical theme of falsifying the perfect person for their love
The images combined with the lyrics paints, to me, the kind of "pressure to be perfect" that can happen for famous people.
Like, the vitriol from fan bases if you don't stay in the same box of genere/apperwnce
You should react to the live version of The Truth Untold it's hauntingly beautiful, I recommend the stage mix which is a compilation of multiple performances but 1 live performance overlaid on the video
Thanks for reacting to BTS again, I missed your reactions to them 😊 I recommend live performances next! Maybe "your eyes tell", "the truth untold" (only vocal line) or "for youth" from the proof live performance. Thank you 💜
68 year old BTS army I suggest you have a look at all the members' recent solo endeavours before thay all commenced their military duties. Which thay are all now serving.💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
BTS as a group have 6 MVs with over a billion views (Dynamite, Boy With Love( feat. Halsey), DNA, Mic Drop, IDOL & Fake Love, in that order), plus two that are over 900M (Blood, Sweat & Tears and Butter) that are very close to 1B views. 💜
Thanks for the interesting analysis of the vocal techniques. If you ever want to listen to a very unique (to BTS) song that is a hidden gem mostly only known to ARMY as it's a b-side that's never been performed live because according to BTS themselves it'd be very difficult to perform, definitely consider checking out "Louder Than Bombs"
Born singer- BTS live stage mix. This performance is so emotional you could just feel it
For checking their vocals I suggest you to react Film out and Fix you.thank you.
I'd add that if he listens to Film Out it should be one of the live versions from Japanese TV (Music Blood or CDTV); they were more focused on the vocals, IMO superior to the MV.
And "Your eyes tell", "Magic shop" with "Truth Untold"
BTS is the best group in the world from my point of view of all time and there are many reasons why I say this 1: the Deep message in their songs 2: choreography and live music are on another level 3: most of the songs have a theme that continues in the other songs 4: their songs are related in literature, psychology, (Carl Jung), psychotherapy.. 5: there is a story line that crosses separately through the songs that a puzzle and you have to figure it out .. 5: their songs save lives ..all regardless if he sings about depression ...anxiety ..sadness ...he tells you to get up and think positive ...There would be a lot to say but us army and even kpopul don't consider Bts as part of this industry. ..they are above K-pop ...
BTS is in a whole other league. They really can't be compared to other KPop. Their level of talent, artistry, originality, diversity and passion is second to none. Their dance line is world class. Their vocal line is top notch and unique. Their songwriting is being studied in colleges around the world and lyrics of theirs were put in the S Korean National Hangeul Museum as a beautiful example of Korean poetry. Their rappers are among the best in the world, period. Suga, the only member to tour solo thus far, as his alter ego Agust D, completed a world tour last year that was the biggest and most lucrative tour for a rapper in global history.
They have close to 1000 awards now. They crank out work as some of the hardest workers in the music indusrty. They are like the Stephen King of music, just prolific, with 20 albums as a group, 12 albums among members as soloists, plus many other collabs, OSTs, singles and covers for a discography many hundreds of songs deep (over 600 with remixes and collabs.) They are currently number 7 in the top 10 best selling artists on earth in the last 30+ years (since 1990) right between Garth Brooks and Rihanna. But I have no doubt they will continue to climb that list and end up in the top 3-5 best sellers of All Time with the likes of the Beatles and MJ, some of whose records they have already broken.
Well said! Agreed with everything
Awesome examples and yes, everything you said is true 💜
@Jazmin22271 yes, our boys are amazing, and I feel so lucky to be a part of them 💜
Facts!!!!!!!💜💜💜💜
Now it's straykids
Finally another BTS reaction! I’ve been waiting for so long💜
What’s REALLY impressive is that they can still sound amazing while dancing this hard live. They are superstars.
YES PETER!!!!!! YAY for BTS and YAY for K pop!!!! Loved your analysis!!!
To answer your question… YES.. they ARE! 65 years old and love them!💜💜💜
BTS's fandom is 60-90 million. They must be doing something right.
Watch any live performance. Japan 4th muster Jin hits a triple high note. Also the vocal line singing zero O'clock, check out rap line Ddaeng and watch the Ddaeng explanation, j Hope's Arson, RM's Joke and Suga aka Agust D his triple performance consisting of Daechwita, Haegum and Amygdala. Welcome to BTS rabbit hole.Thwie discography covers many genres. 💜🇺🇸🔥🫰
Wonderful R&A. Always educational, and always fun to get the "behind the scenes" dirt on how these videos are made.
our jin "fake love" is soooo epic and keep reasoning in my ears
Still and always BTS is a legend and the best boyband of today, no one can replace them. Thier songs and Thier talent each one of them is extremely good and most of all they have a very nice and humble beginning as an artist.
My favorite BTS song!
Singing mixed with rapping is something BTS do, and because many other Kpop groups study BTS now many of them sing and rap together.
To be precise Kpop is not a genre, it just means popular music of Korea.
BTS is heavy with rsp because they started as a hip hop group and then changed to be an Idol group. The first members of the group were underground rappers.
I doubt autotune was used in this track.
"Autotune" is used for texture not to correct "bad" singing.
And what K-pop is is complex
"bby gang mag" may help understand that with his video essays:
- BTS vs K-pop (has a section about what K-pop is)
- you are wrong about K-pop (because people in North American and European countries missrepresent it)
(and as a bonus: "BTS: More Than K-pop")
💜
Thank you so much for the great reaction! Of course Black Swan or ON is amazing to see and hear. But I would really like you to check out The Truth Untold as well vocally it's so beautiful and phenomenal.
Great reaction! Great editing! Great band! ❤
Thank you! 😊
Congrats on 151k ➕️ to the 🌟🌟🌟
I would absolutely love to see your reaction to "The Truth Untold", which is a vocal line B-side (there are lots of live versions floating around on CZcams that are thoroughly worthwhile in addition to the studio version with color coded lyrics) that really shows off what all four of them are best at. It's also a beautiful, miserable ballad that I think you'd appreciate thematically as well.
Agreed completely! People have used the lives to teach vocal technique, they're well worth digging into as a singer 😁
I discovered the rock version of this song, really loved it. Thanks for your review
To get to know BTS's vocal line better, you need to listen to their solo songs 💜 because each of them is unique and better reveals their talent individually. but there are also great collaboration songs, for example The Truth Untold💜
If you want to really talk about their vocals perhaps a live performance is better to react to? But i really appreciate your reaction to this one too!
💜💯💜👏💜
Bts always be 🔛🔝
One of the most beautiful voices in Korea is IU. She recently put a song out titled "Love Wins All" and the MV stars herself and V, from BTS. (he doesn't contribute vocals, just acts". It is an incredibly beautiful song and 100% worth checking out.
Fr I loved her verses so much 😭 IU x BTS are always great when they’re collaborating, eg Ppl pt 2, Love wins all….etc
IU is seriously one of Korea's national treasures - she's got such a lovely voice, but then she's also a delightful, sincere person.
you gotta see magic shop the live performance its so beautiful.
you might like v's Tiny Desk performance, or his BTS song Stigma (theres a great live performance), he has the most baritone voice of the group and a really unique tone I think. the other end of the spectrum is Jimin with a unique high voice. My fave from him is Serendipity or Letter (both have live performances). for the group as a whole, maybe something like ON Kinetic Manifesto Film or Festa Room Live
I actually already have videos for their Tiny Desk Concert on my channel! As well as at least one video for Jimin :]
7 incredibly talented humans. BTS really is their own genre... They can't be defined by nor confined to K-pop. 💜
Love the Zelda reference. Was feeling the same vibes. 😂❤
Every time I here someone say 'wala,waka,waka'. makes me think of Fozzy Bear from The Muppets 😊
Please react to film out , the truth untold and Crystal snow
I just want to suggest you to watch the BTS "film out" live performance in music blood & I hope you will like it also😊💜
Felicitări BTS cei mai talentați frumoși perfecți tare dor de ei ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
If they are not, they have been the most entertaining with all their shows and so charismic.
Truth Untold live, Zero O'clock live ad Dimple and Pied Piper live.
When reactions on live performance?😁
You must reaction to A guide to bts members the bangtang if you want to get to know them better, however, if you want to react to their voices, I suggest you react to Park Jimin real live vocals ( hight notes, growls, vocal effects, background vocals) ❤
You need to watch one of their live performances. Here’s a good medley to start with - shows their energy and interplay with each other and the audience while on stage. Enjoy! 💜
czcams.com/video/illd6N3socs/video.htmlsi=FYotwj2eRteXvIZf
Hi! Great reaction! This is one of my favorite songs from them.
If you're doing more BTS I would be curious what you think about the song "Louder than bombs" both vocally and production wise(there's no MV)
at 5:00, you talk about Tenor high C.
That's Jin, who started singing (and dancing) around age 20 ! Specialists call him 'Silver voice ' and 'belting king! 🤗
No doubt in my mind they are the best. They have so many hits, even B-sides, their albums I can put on auto shuffle play and let it run.
Some other groups are awkward sounding where it's like listening just for the chorus and filler in between. The other groups are more like one hit wonders where they may have a few songs but many more misses.
BTS songs LYRICS, MELODY, CHORUS, CHOREOGRAPHY, RAPPING, OUTFITS, are second to none. Their songs are well structured, and because they need to give 7 members a part, my only criticism is that their songs are too short!
Thanks for opening my eyes and ears to a genre all of its own! 😊
BTS are the pioneers of Kpop many of their techniques have been adopted by most of Kpop
Please watch live concerts and dance practices as these are second to none. Love to ARMY xxx
Thank you for your good reaction... you have a long journey for this boy (Please react the guide of Bangtan 7 and many songs that legendary!!)
they're produced their songs (almost) and talented
Borahae💜💜💜
HANDS DOWN!!!
J-hope of bts, one of the rappers, just released an album called 'Hope On The Street' with the song Neuron, maybe you can check it out💜
I am not sure if you have heard these BTS songs before or not but might I suggest Let Me Know, House Of Cards, and Truth Untold (live versions of each-they don't have mvs. Individual members--RM--Wildflowers, feature on Don't Ever Say Love Me by Colde, feature on Smoke Sprite by SO!yoOn, Jin--Abyss, Yours, Astronaut. Tonight, Awake. and Epiphany. AgustD--Amygdala, The Last, Dear My Friend. Jhope--Piece of Peace, =(Equal Sign), Arson, and More. Jimin--Serendipity, Closer Than This, Face-Off, and Alone. V--Fri(end)s, the LayoVer album, wherever u r, Singularity, and Stigma. JungKook--I am not sure if you have checked out his entire Golden album or not but it is great, Stay Alive, My You, Still With You, and so many of his covers--Fallin orig by Harry Styles, 10,000 hours orig Dan and Shay and JB, Let There Be Love orig by Oasis, and any and all on this SoundCloud playlist soundcloud.com/prestigebird/sets/jungkooks-cover-songs-only?si=f9a1e4f5a5c143d7b7f42285700be84f& Thanks so much!
there's an extended version of the video with a different musical version of the song. and there's a metal cover, which is very good too: czcams.com/video/kdjhmGNlKWs/video.html
There's another metal cover too... czcams.com/video/jp53Q7xomRo/video.html, which is very good as well, especially in therms of vocals!
Oh my God: how professional your reaction is! It’s really a pleasure to hear and watch… Thank you!💜
OMG!I’ve been waiting for this, since a long time you reacted to their tiny desk and MTV unplugged cover of Fix You…. Thank you sooo much ❤🎉💞. Will watch now 🥰😉💜
Any of their live performances are a great choice. You should comment on the meaning of the song and/or lyrics too. The deeper meanings in their songs are what makes BTS so famous.
❤
Learning smch thank you! I appreciate the art more! 🙏💜
"You can have singers that are super versatile and they can sing any genre...", yeah, nice nod to all your Dears followers :) He published new music video couple of weeks ago, When I've got you ! Check it out if you dare, Mr.D as Dracula !
💜 Thank you!!
"Fake love" -This music video was filmed using actual stage equipment without computer graphics. Especially the scene where Jungkook runs down a collapsing hallway.
Yes. Just little effects with fire in Yoongi's scene and Jimin scene
Jin is a king of belting. So strong, controlled.
No hay ninguna duda. El mejor grupo de los últimos tiempos es BTS. Están en otro nivel y lo demuestran en cada directo. Siempre con Bangtan.
Please react to my current obsession "lock / unlock" from j-hope 🥰 would be fun to hear your thoughts
Loved your knowledge, React more to BTS
I like this reaction, besides the explanation, singing and added beatboxing - Not gonna lie: Watching a talented, pretty guy reacting to the 7 talented, pretty guys in BTS was all I needed to wake up rn. 😇 (Respectfully ofc.)
I love the way our 🌟 B T S 💜 sing this *Love Song* - not whined
Love your intelligent breakdowns. I second the live vocal line songs reco’d by others.
They have multiple songs that have already reached more than 1B not just FAKE LOVE. You can check out BOY WITH LUV, DNA, IDOL, MIC DROP, and DYNAMITE. BLOOD SWEAT & TEARS ARE ALMOST 1B as well.
Thank you so much for this! I really wish you would react to more of their live performances though… They are amazing live!💜
The Truth Untold is fantastic… make sure you pick the live stage mix so you don’t get blocked!
I think you dipped into kpop a few times and if you want to there is so much amazing diverse vocal work to dissect and discover (I could name a few like SHINee especially Onew who has one of the most interesting kpop voices I ever heard, but honestly most groups have their own interesting vocals). Hope you have a lot of fun with that in the future ☺️
BTS is the best, though, although they are beyond k-pop.
@@1badlibrarian I don't think it's necessary to put other groups down or BTS above them to appreciate what they do and from all I've seen from BTS they don't think so either. Music is wonderful and doesn't require someone to look down on and neither does BTS. Be proud of your group (and yourself for that matter) cause of what they do not how they compare 😊
BTS are considered just a K pop boy band bcz they come from Korea and dance instead of playing instruments. If we take that as given then BTS are the best boy band in the history of boy bands, not only K Pop. Why ? Because they all wright and compose beautifull and meaningful music (of many different genres) , they are exceptional singers and rapers ,they dance as no other boy band ever danced before ( they are better as dancers than most pop soloist of our times), most of them are playing at least one instrument and last but not least their production of their music and mv are out of this world! As a 54 yrs old ARMY I can say that labeling BTS as a K pop boy band we do not do justice to them and to their work! For exactly the same reasons I mentioned before BTS are the best Pop-not only K pop- Band in the history of pop music! Of course this is just my humble opinion but I believe time will prove me right!
For us ARMY their songs are about the music, the lyrics, what it's about, who they are and what they mean to us. That's different for anyone of course, but most of us are 'saved' by them.... We love them unconditionally and eternally . So their songs mean a lot to us. Live they sing, dance and perform really awesome!! And I am immensely proud of them.
I came here after the mention in your Lorna Shore video. I'm really looking forward to more metal reactions, but I really like this too.
Suga’s concert will be in theaters on Wednesday and Saturday this week
It was great
Thank you very much for justifying and Analysis as saying from you.... Words for think about my sang revival version new & generation aswell like .
ok hopefully i`ll see you react to stray kids also someday
Very interesting!
I would love the same analysis on one of the members tiny desk concert : V…
Some live of the guys deep voice vocalist 👌
K-pop no es un genero, es una industria, la produccion y direccion de MV, conciertos, espectaculos, premiaciones y shows no tienen competencia a nivel mundial.
Sus artistas son cantantes, bailarines, raperos, modelos, hacen programas de entretenimiento, son presentadores, actores, Productores y compositores de sus propias canciones....
Cada uno de los chicos englobados en lo que llamamos K-pop ha pasado por una criba muy exigente para llegar a donde estan, años de entrenamiento antes de poder debutar si es que llegan a hacerlo superando a miles de aspirantes con el mismo talento que ellos en todas las facetas que antes dije.
Por eso el K-pop tiene todo mi respeto y admiracion desde el ultimo Rooky hasta el mas alto directivo de las agencias.
In this mv Jimin and Jin are on another level, they sing and dance amazing.
jimin always exceeds my expectations
Louder than bambs please 🥺 there areally perfect high note and voice💗💗🤏🤏🤍🤍
Please react to more BTS songs. I am enjoying your reactions to their music so much. Please react to Film Out live performance by BTS.
Congratulations on reaching 150K subs
Would love to hear your reaction to their live performances. Several good ones have been mentioned in the comments already. I would add their MAMA award performances 2016 thru 2019 are all fabulous.
Thank you for reacting to BTS. They have a huge discography that dips into many genres. Definitely check out more.
I loved your reaction to this video. You provided a lot of interesting insights to the music which I had not known. For certain, versatility and talent are evident in each member of BTS. That high G4 is their baritone singer V, who has the widest vocal range in the band. Thank you, a new subscriber
💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Hey you are an amazing bass, I’m 13 and can hit a c2 do you have any advice on singing lower or just over all expanding my range?
TY
Great reaction!
One thing is that what BTS does is very unique to themselves! Their style, concept, themes, and arrangement in songs are very them. Basically, K-pop is not a genre but more of an industry just like Hollywood. But BTS has definitely transcended this and can do any genre! Even you can checkout their solo stuff cause the range is amazing as they all are so versatile. I would say there's no comparison between them and other K-pop artists no offense to them but BTS are miles ahead