I think the light thing is genius. Typically when there are monsters around, our instinct is to turn on all the lights so we can't die, but here we're actually forced to keep ourselves in the dark.
Think about it, When the lights are on, shadows are stronger. They have edges. When the lights are off, it’s blurry and indistinct.
Horror movie characters: We have to keep the lights on th keep the monsters out.
Flumpty, Blam, Eyesaur and Grunkfuss: Allow us to introduce ourselves.
Thats the difference between a monster (who has a physical defined form) and a shadow (who is not completely formed, so its much better at the shadows since it can hide in there, but gets limited when there is light since it damages it)
There are two relevant phrases:
"Stay in the light to avoid being caught by the shadows and monsters in the dark."
"Stay in the dark to not being seen by whatever is also looking for you in the darkness."
Jonochrome: How should I make the office?
Dreams: Let us help you
If i was him in the "garage turn off light" thing i would probably not sleep for days..
One night at a relative's house
+Comic sans This is the one comment I remember from the original upload and it's kinda great to see it back
+Jonochrome u should make one night at a relatives house a fnaf fan game lel
"But yeah, I drew the room, and it is very similar to how it looked in my dream."
So there was a Beer Gut Piglet stuck to the wall in your nightmare?
EDIT: Could you guys shut up? It's a joke, I'm not stupid.
AromaGamma well no not really it was really a giant room filled with giant spiders and tiny spider crawling all over me pulling out hair bye hair slowly
Did I make you cringe because every time I dream I cringe >:3
So I added a peek-a-boo animation
*Flumpty comes in WITH THE PEEK-A-BOO ANIMATION*
How convenient!
AJ Roo It’s A Really Good Animation Plus You Dont Get Exposure until he opens his eyes
Flumpty was listening and decided to help Jonochrome out with the commentary
"Yesterday, Flumpty killed approximately 100 billion birds with one stone. That stone was a meteorite, and yesterday was the apocalypse."
Flumpty once broke into a man's house because he was cooking an egg. Flumpty was voluntarily arrested for breaking and entering just so he could escape prison.
faCTs i didn't know befor
Have you ever wondered what it would be like to swallow a human baby? I mean, an entire baby, all at once. It’s totally doable if you have a big enough mouth. Would the baby die from suffocation or stomach acid first? A live baby would probably be brutal to the intestines.
@@Subscriberswithnovideos-en3lw There are alot of words in the English alphabet to mix into sentences. And you chose those words....
"I won't make a hard boiled mode for ONaF 1" "I probably won't make a ONaF 3"
Scott: are you sure?
@MageBurger I don't think so. From what I can tell, Scott is simply funding the creators of making the games, and isn't asking for any money back. Could be wrong though...
I must admit, that laptop has some pretty crappy batteries
After using rechargeable batteries for a long time, they burn out and don't last as long, so the laptop battery is just a decade or two old.
18:50
INHUMAN REACTIONS
The One Jack that’s a jack shit answer i once programmed a small horror game it was like mr.hopp but with creepy sounds and giggles and a much scarier monster, I played it at 4am since I’m a night owl and i tell ya i was fucking terrified of the little jumpscares and shit
PlasmaOJ15 _ i was going to launch it but I lost my computer and I didn’t make a copy so it’s lost for ever
I literally just noticed that 'Eyesaur' is a play-on-words of 'Eyesore'
It’s for Eye and Dinosaur.
If you can catch him in Camera 6, he’s some lizard looking thing.
2:07 Just look how happy Piglet looks while his stomach is open.
I was going to say am I the only one that noticed that but thank God I'm not crazy
OH NO. I AM NOT DOING THAT AGAIN. PIGLET SCARED THE FRICK OUT OF ME WHEN IT DID THAT. Also, thanks for warning me for when it happens.
Life lesson: always make games from your dreams
so if i dream about porn(no racist just a joke) i would make a porn(same on that one ok) game?
Gibs nah that a joke i was dreaming about a epic face guy with a top hat and he has a suit with tie all black then i on a fnac office .
We need to applaud this man for remembering dreams.
The other day I was watching some CZcams video and I forget what it was, but it gave me perfect memory of a dream I had like 7 years ago. And I had this moment of like “omg I remember that!” And then it was gone instantly. Very strange
Jonochrome: Maybe there’s a fourth FNaF game
Me: *laughs in 6 new FNaF games, books, and a movie teased*
Man, I can't wait for Flumpty Birthday Simulator and Ultimate Hard-boiled Night
13:44 damn my man got every single character back to b a c k
@@schuymac2639 red man appears shortly after so the only one missing is golden flumpty
I watched both commentary videos, and I have to say, I really enjoy your thoughts behind the gameplay, story and humor. The games themselves are also quite remarkable, and everything about One Night at Flumpty's interests me, so thanks for posting these. :)
(Angry Baldi) HEY YOU. NO MORE GAMEPLAY OF ONE NIGHT AT FLUMPTY'S 1, 2, AND 3. ALRIGHT?!!! >:(
So what you're telling me is...
Your dreams were LITERALLY telling yourself to make this game?
No, that’s not what he said at all, and even if it was, that’s really not that surprising.
@@crypt5129 its usually said to people when a joke goes over their/ don't understand it. Im was too lazy to add 4 "o" so I did 1.
The fact that you can remember your dreams more than 10 seconds let alone hours is impressive
When I have a dream there is like a 75% chance that I will remember it for more than a minute and if that happens I can remember it for years.
@@st4ndg4mes87 i remember my dreams more than 10 seconds... SO I AM AN ALIEN?!😲
This is nostagic
i though the developer commentary was deleted and there was no traces of it
Good thing to note: That clown is entering through the Declaration of Independence.
It's actually the US Constitution. The Declaration of Independence does not start with We The People
13:24 "like if I made a hard boiled mode if the first one night at flumpty's which I won't-"
I like how john likes to retcon himself from time to time.
"I don't think I'll be making One Night at Flumpty's 3"
Ah yes, this statement aged real well, didn't it lmao
and hard boiled mode for one night at flumpty's 1 WHICH HE SAID HE WILL NOT NOT THINK NOT
Honestly, what this game really reminds me of is Gamer from Game & Wario, as you're basically trying to hide from something that keeps appearing and disappearing from your view, while also focusing on many tasks at hand. That being said, this also added some nice twists to its concept, like the exposure meter so the game wasn't completely reaction time-based and broken.
This is definitely one of the most well-made of all the FNAF spin-offs, and is worthy of all the praise it deserves. Well done, Jon.
"Blam goes in a complete circle around the map"
Has a rectangle for a head
jonochrome: says he wont add a hard boiled mode on onaf1,
also jonochrome: there's a hard boiled mode on onaf1.
He truly is the master of saying he will never do something then randomly doing it like three years later
“If I ever added a hard boiled mode to the first One Nights at Flumpty’s, which I won’t...”Well well well how the turn tables.
"If I had a Hard Boiled Mode in One Night at Flumpty's, which I won't-"
*LAUGHS IN RETROSPECT*
"Bang bang, yall" the three words I now live by.
Jonochrome:I don’t think I’ll make one night at flumptys 3.
Me: are you shure about that?
And JonoChrome, I you see this, could you say some stuff on how the merchandise and ports of ONaF’s gonna be like.
11:00 Wait, so every time someone lost Flumpty’s “game” it just made it easier for the next person to “play”??? That’s kinda creepy
I don't know how you reached that conclusion from what he said because he never implied that at all.
@@0mathgaming ok, so basically my idea here was that:
In ONAF1, there’s a pit of eyes in one of the rooms. Now assuming those eyes are Eyesaur , every time a person dies their eyes are merged into the pit.
In ONAF1, are 50 eyes in the pit. When Grunkfus is active, one of them disappears every time you flip up the camera. When all the eyes are gone, Grunkfus attacks and kills the player.
Based off that, every death adds 2 eyes to the pile, which then means 2 additional camera flips are needed for Grunkfus to kill you. _(That also means atleast 25 people have died before you.)_
Make sense? Maybe...
(10:20)
Jonochrome: It's not a character
Players: It's a character
Jonochrome: It's a character
Probably late but when he was on about the blind character, I thought of him being able to see through cameras, so your exposure meter goes up if you see him looking at a camera but very slowly
I’d say that’d be too rng dependant, if you had a one second grace I think that’d be better but he game is good already
Now I imagine it’s some fleshy bloody blob of skin and it has multiple cameras on it and they are poorly sewn on. And all of the cameras face your camera and it can’t move on it’s own so it needs something to push it around, and if you look back at the camera it was on there will be a blood trail that leads to whatever camera he is now visible on
Flumpty is so powerful he made the creator have a dream to make the second game.
"if i ever made a hard boiled mode in onaf 1, which i wont." me looks back at the Fazbear Fanverse initiative and now onaf 1 has a hard boiled mode.
1:10 "One night (not at Flumpty's)"
I think it would have been funny if BBB started walking, and you turn the light back on because he's not looking directly at you. But when you turn it back on, he turns his head toward you again. Imagine the reactions.
@@CelestinaakaClonaClox9999 me too. Not only is it funny, it could also be an interesting game mechanic.
@@peetah_gryffyn kinda like eyesaur in onaf3 where you have to flash him multiple times to make him go away, but here, you have to turn the light off multiple times/keep it off
I just realized that Grunkfuss is kind of like ucn Funtime Foxy.
Oh boy. Imagine if he continued. I wonder what five nights at flumpty's vr would look like
"If I added a hard mode to the original, which I won't." Okay, so this was from before the Fazbear Fanverse initiative.
The animation in this game is so awesome, and just seeing them pop out of nowhere looking into the room is terrifying.
2:08 SMILING PIGLEET
I like how one of the most unsettling, hardest, polished, and one of the first fnaf fangames which has one of the best game mechanics has the funnist story.
So yeah one night I got a dream about being in a world made out of cubes where I had to collect wood to make a crafting table and then I made a pickaxe and collected stone to make stone tools and then I collected iron with which I could collect diamonds and then I went through a portal into a hell like world and killed yellow creatures so I could go into another world and then I had to beat a dragon and I thought yeah that was a pretty normal dream maybe that would make for a good game
Dude I had the same one but also had one where a blue hedgehog ran and saved animals from a mad scientist
You guys ever have a dream about some guy in red, stomping on mushrooms and eating them to grow bigger.
I once dreamt that there was a pink ball that eats alot and fights a penguin cus he stole food
Weird. I remember this strange dream about a zombie knight trying to light himself on fire to save the world.
that development process is basically proving ONAF was a fever dream
7:13 Perfect timing.
I like developer commentaries! Also thanks for inspiring me.
"If i made a hard boiled mode of the first one night at flumptys, which i wont" apparently you eventually had different plans
I'm really happy you've gone and reuploaded these. One of the most interesting things about this series to me was honestly hearing your process behind making them.
Jono: It feels weird to have 2 nights if it’s called ONE Night at Flumpty’s
FNAF: *has a 6th Night*
Hey Jonochrome! This is a really old video you've made, however, I love coming back to your commentary videos about One Night at Flumpty's (1 - 3) as they always bring some sort of motivation to me. Listening to how you've started from inside jokes to wanting to create an amazing game for a supportive community brings a rather inspirational, motivating feeling that imagination can become a project, then turned into something even greater. Your progress in making these games while I draw helps me stay focused as I always feel that someday, what I create will become something big. Thank you for not only making such a lovable game that I always return to but also being an inspiration to many other artists/game developers. :) 💚
"Im not adding hard boiled mode into onaf 1" .but he did it anyway.
Jonochrome thank you for being such an inspiration to me. You introduced me to game dev entirely and I look up to you a lot. I admire your games and your work and you got me out of a tough time in life and now I'm making games with a small fanbase so thank you :')
I really think its amazing how he uses his dreams/nightmares to not only mold the aesthetic of the game, but some of the mechanical features too.
Thank you for making these commentary videos, I want to try and start game developing sometime in my life (since I wasted enough time in college to do so) but listening to your thoughts and how things came to be gives me confidence since I have similar ways of getting gameplay ideas.
Good luck with any other projects and games you work on in the future
You are the best game creators ever
Thank you SO much for reuploading this! These videos inspired me to try and make my own FNaF game! Thank you!
Jonochrome 6 years ago:I won't make a hard mode at onaf
Jonochrome a year ago: So I lied
Don’t judge me but
I love the eyesore, as in the idea
“I might not make onaf3”
5 years later: k time to release onaf3
Don’t sell yourself short. One night at flumpty’s both 1 and 2 are the most creative fnaf spin-offs I’ve ever seen even if it could be called a fnaf spin-off
This was the first commentary I watch, I loved it so much that I started watching movie commentary's, every time I watch one, I think of this!
I couldn't find this and the other developer's commentary video for a while. I really liked the insight that went into these games, I'm glad I'm able to listen to them again.
Thanks so much for making this game. It's a timeless gem.
Hey Jonochrome, just to say that as a fan of What you do, i would be sooo pleased to see a brand new thing with flumpty ! I Know you wanted to throw It, but i'm not asking you to do One week or a 3rd installment, I'm just asking for something with Flumpty ! It may be an animation, a comic or a brand new game ! It's just that this set of characters are so neat they deserve more than a fan game ! I don't Know, maybe a little game that Could be out on Steam ! Platformer or RPG, I don't care ! But the characters are so great and so dear to my game story that I want more !
Well, good lucky with the actual game you're working on :)
YOU ARE So CREATIVE! Also,it's so fun to see a developer playing his own Game!
13:29
Things that Aged Poorly
Of all the ONaF characters, which one would you say is your favorite?
I like Birthday Boy Blam, he just has that feeling of cool and kinda cute at the same time
Exposure bar, more like EGGsposure! Hahaha, I'll show myself out.
You talk about the game not being unique enough of an idea yet the turnout is amazing, I never could have thought of something like this. Good job man.
This game introduced me to FNAF Fan Games. I loved the dark humor that's just riddled throughout your two ONAF's. I thought it was AMAZING that you decided to actually animate your characters because that really wasn't in any other FNAF game at the time. It was really inspiring to me. My favorite character of these two games has to be BBB. He's just super random and because you went through the effort of making each of your characters so unique, his wackiness stands out a lot more.
4 years later, and a few things from here didn't age well.
Still awesome.
'That stone was a meteorite, and yesterday was the apocalypse' And now Phil, with the weather.
just wanna thank you for making this game, sure 4 years too late, but thank you still, it's nice to see you still work on other projects!
"Like if i made a hard boiled mode for the first one night at flumpty's, which i won't"
2020: hard boiled is in one night at flumpty's
Through watching the video and getting to the blind character, I thought of an idea for that character. it could be a character that will make your awareness meter go up when the lights are off, giving a spin in the works and really makes you step on your feet and it could get rid of the "keep the lights off most of the time" Strategy
The ONAF CHARACTERS CANNOT DEFEAT THE CREATOR JONOCHROME
Dude, I've had those weird dreams, and I still do, and much like you and One Night at Flumpty's 2, they kinda help me finish my vision.
Dude, you're good at what you do! I hope you make whatever you're happy with!
“I might recycle the idea of a blind monster In another game”
Oh no
Should've just said the beaver went out to buy more toilet paper.
Ahhh! How lucky am I to ask if you have this and have it uploaded a few hours later??
Thank you Jonochrome! You are like, an idol to me :33
Again, thank you!! x3
Wow you have come far since riddle school I love you so much man you made my childhood basically
I find the map being based on the urinary system funny as hell
13:27 well here we are
it exists
I really enjoy this commentary, makes the game feel more personal.
Hi jonochrome I just wanna say that I am a huge fan, and you've made me inspired to create a comic world called Chester and friends. Thank you for making an amazing franchise, and I hope you get better.
"Bang Bang, y'all". Oh, that got me good.
12:50 now i know why the clown works that way in onaf3 :)
Man 2 times in a row that a dream has given you ideas
I think flumpty is trying to communicate with you
It's cool looking back at these commentary videos after 3 is released seeing everything scrapped in the first 2 made it into the 3rd
“Yesterday, Flumpty killed approximately 100 billion birds with one stone. That stone was a meteorite. Yesterday was the apocalypse.”
That’s a little more than 2 birds, good job Flumpty
@Maker Man X owl and flumpty frends, she help him in hide and seek
kolakyr They’re All Males
Good job flumpty you did it
@@leafyjr-amp5063 they don't have genders
They do. The creator approved it