Me clicking this video: "ooh maybe I'll get a deep insight into their opinions on their songs, this will be interesting" 5SOS: "Voodoo Doll is a morning song, it has no vibes"
Ash’s assessment of Catch Fire was SO accurate for me “In my heart of hearts I feel like it’s D, I don’t love it, but for some reason I’ve always been very gentle with it” same. Y tho
Honestly same and idk I think it's bc like, the song is harmlessly mid in every way. The chorus isn't bad at all, but it doesn't stand out either, the song itself isn't that soft but it's also not heavy, the whole thing sounds really pleasant and is rly easy to listen to but It's also catchy and memorable without being invasive In a way, It's almost the perfect song in general
So what I get from this is that Michael has the closest to my opinions, and I like that he sticks up for a lot of their older songs, Ashton is way too harsh on their old songs, Luke doesn't care about doing this, and Calum hates his own band 😂 I do appreciate that they didn't just stick all of the old stuff on the bottom and the new stuff on top, but I STILL think a lot of their old stuff got put way too low.
timestamps for myself lmao 13:26 - dont stop tier 14:15 - voodoo doll no vibes 20:22 - this trio gives me chills 22:48 - valentine (JUSTICE FOR VALENTINE) 26:36 - WAMMANAMOW 26:48 - i know its A tier 27:10 - pizza either S or everybody makes mistakes 30:13 - co-writers 32:09 - did that happen in an alternate dimension 34:07 - just reckless 36:04 - absoluelty reckless 39:12 - thats reckless / just feel 40:07 - unfortualy its B 41:00 - now that ive zoomed out 43:21 - i agree with its ok 45:50 - i love this dont stop catergory/ i feel weird here 46:36 - unlocking the code lmao 48:41 - old me is shitty 53:16 - dont stop is like pergatory 55:10 - gotta respect the forefathers 56:11 - its a stinka 1:00:31 - bongos 1:03:13 - this moment lmao 1:04:11 - the gates of hell 1:06:18 - valentine again (JUSTICE FOR VALENTINE) this took forever...
Same! I stopped following them as closely a few months after the release of the Youngblood album and I've been falling back into them lately and watching this just felt so...comforting.
me watching this in 2022 when they're on their take my hand tour and realizing all the throwback songs in their setlist are from the S and A tier they put together ;_; I wonder if they looked back at this list to decide what songs to throw in for the tour lolll
And looking at this in Fall 2023 near the end of their The 5Sos5 Show tour, I think we can see again the influence of this brainstorming and the fan feedback. The old songs they kept in the set list were some of the higher ranked ones. And I think we can see where the “Dice Songs” came from: mostly the Don’t Stop tier. And I think just doing this ranking reminded them of old songs they liked or the fans liked but had not played in a long time.
them creating a new label titled "we made a mistake" for heartbreak girl is an INSULT to me bc that song was my saving grace lmfao it's what made me stan them PLS
I love that you watched this even though you were not a fan 😂 they are hilarious aren’t they? I hope you have listened to their music and checked out more of their hilarious interviews and livestreams. Their friendship and silliness is definitely a huge appeal to me and many other people. That was one of the things that I first liked about them 😅
I love that they had the nerve to do this and I just love learning about them. The songs they do and don't like really says something about them. Me here a bit heart broken but lmao! I need more artists to do this! I can't blame them for some D tears.
everyone is talking about the disrespect towards ‘heartbreak girl’. i mean- their biggest bop ‘i can’t remember’ didn’t even make it to the list. talk about disrespect smh
5sos’s favorite pass time is dissing every single song that made my teenage years
Yes... It hurts... 😂
The fact that almost all of Youngblood is in C tier is a CRIME
Agreed 😅
exactly
literally when they started on talk fast/moving along i gasped
ur a poser😂
exactly omg
How can they make such a bops but be so tasteless 😭💀
Yessss read them to filth they deserve it after the crime they just committed
FRRRRR
tbh some of them they didn't write tho LMAO
but their best songs they have written, don't get me wrong
@@niallsirishflag983 love your user name
Michael's "wow" when all of them said Valentine is a B tier song lmao felt that
Valentine is the absolute S TIER gosh i dont care its their song it made me so mad lol
i feel him, how can they be so tasteless? lol
I actually loveeeeddddd Valentine. It’s def a different sound for them but i love the beat
Honestly I don’t like valentine 😢
Calum saying that lie to me is b and ashton responding with "mate have you ever listened to lie to me" soothes my heart
“Don’t compare, just feel” what a quote
“I feeeeel”
The anger that simmered in me when they moved Heartbreak Girl down to "everybody makes mistakes" but left 18 in D 😭😭😭
HEARTBREAK GIRL IS MY FAVOURITE SONG BY THEM IDK WHY THEY DONT LIKE IT
ik heartbreak girl is so much better than 18 and neither deserved what it got😭
hearing troye sivan cover a snippet of heartbreak girl when it first came out was what made me discover 5sos so this kinda hurts ngl🥲
18 is soooo good tho
That song has so much “pick me” energy
not them putting my favorite songs in everybody makes mistakes
Just saying is one of my favorites and they put it there 😭
heartbreak girl deserves better
@@taniyajaffar3113 ugh for real
Lmao ikr
ikr!! daylight didn’t deserve everybody makes mistakes 😔💔
this whole tier list is OUTRAGEOUS
This comment is a wholearse mood
Me clicking this video: "ooh maybe I'll get a deep insight into their opinions on their songs, this will be interesting"
5SOS: "Voodoo Doll is a morning song, it has no vibes"
Voodoo Doll is so vibey! Idk what they're talking abt
They are so wrong.
the way that ashton just makes drum noises to prove all of his points in the ranks
Luke: what are we ranking it by?
Everyone else: BY THE VIBES LUKE GOD 😫
Ash saying “ you're being reckless” is big brother energy
He IS the big brother
the way they're sleeping on their own songs pls this tier makes my blood boil 💀💀💀
Not them saying that voodoo doll has no vibes - excuse me 911 I would like to report a crime….
SAMMMMEEE I WAS LIKE WTF ;-;
After Michael literally called it one of his favorite songs off the first album during the quarantine stream 💀💀
I've never wanted to fight a band about the ranking of their own songs.
this is all I've ever wanted them to do! better than any interview just them being themselves
they do that a lot
@@user-it5ro5pw6c almost all the time lol
The fact that most of my favorite songs they’ve ever recorded are in don’t stop speaks to me as a person I think
no cause same
😂😂😂me tooo
But they're playing a lot of Dont Stop songs during the 2023 tour so I don't know what to think lol
Ash’s assessment of Catch Fire was SO accurate for me “In my heart of hearts I feel like it’s D, I don’t love it, but for some reason I’ve always been very gentle with it” same. Y tho
Honestly same and idk I think it's bc like, the song is harmlessly mid in every way. The chorus isn't bad at all, but it doesn't stand out either, the song itself isn't that soft but it's also not heavy, the whole thing sounds really pleasant and is rly easy to listen to but It's also catchy and memorable without being invasive
In a way, It's almost the perfect song in general
BABYLON NOT BEING IN S TIER HAS ME LIKE
Yes BABYLON YES
:( IKR
WTF?! I WILL GO ON A CRUSADE.
@@kingkinee8373hi🥁☺️
So what I get from this is that Michael has the closest to my opinions, and I like that he sticks up for a lot of their older songs, Ashton is way too harsh on their old songs, Luke doesn't care about doing this, and Calum hates his own band 😂
I do appreciate that they didn't just stick all of the old stuff on the bottom and the new stuff on top, but I STILL think a lot of their old stuff got put way too low.
the disrespect towards heartbreak girl 😭✋🏼
43:39 when ashton said “now that im looking at lost boy, who let him in here 🤨” i am dying😭
timestamps for myself lmao
13:26 - dont stop tier
14:15 - voodoo doll no vibes
20:22 - this trio gives me chills
22:48 - valentine (JUSTICE FOR VALENTINE)
26:36 - WAMMANAMOW
26:48 - i know its A tier
27:10 - pizza either S or everybody makes mistakes
30:13 - co-writers
32:09 - did that happen in an alternate dimension
34:07 - just reckless
36:04 - absoluelty reckless
39:12 - thats reckless / just feel
40:07 - unfortualy its B
41:00 - now that ive zoomed out
43:21 - i agree with its ok
45:50 - i love this dont stop catergory/ i feel weird here
46:36 - unlocking the code lmao
48:41 - old me is shitty
53:16 - dont stop is like pergatory
55:10 - gotta respect the forefathers
56:11 - its a stinka
1:00:31 - bongos
1:03:13 - this moment lmao
1:04:11 - the gates of hell
1:06:18 - valentine again (JUSTICE FOR VALENTINE)
this took forever...
you are my favorite person ever
You absolute life saver thank you!!!
Tasteless or not, I’m just grateful Ghost of You was put in S because I will forever love and defend that masterpiece :’)
I love how michael is the only one who cares about the nostalgia of it all
They did not just put English love affair in c that song Is literally too good for s tier !!
LITERALLY WHAT I WAS THINKING
i wouldn’t say s tier but it is a good don’t stop
Michael: somebody google the lyrics to Greenlight
Luke: please don’t ruin my day
me: still waiting for the rating of the 5sos hairstyles...
the stream of michael ranking his hairstyles was a disrespect, imagine with the 4 of them ranking all your hair lol
the fact that i’ve seen this a million times and still get mad every time is ASTONISHING
*Ashtonishing
watching this makes me realize how much i miss them
Same! I stopped following them as closely a few months after the release of the Youngblood album and I've been falling back into them lately and watching this just felt so...comforting.
@@Rachel-pj5pw me too :(( calm wasn’t my fav so I fell off but I really miss them and this vid is just so calming
@@lexieezhi 🥁😊
Empty wallets almost being in everybody makes mistakes is so absurd like wtf????? Thats a fucking BOP
I felt so offended bc of that, it's so unfair
It’s literally my favourite 5sos song😭
For real tho😂
the bass in the song is PURE GOLD
Ik I'm late but fr! That song is fire....pure fuego
When they moved disconnected down my heart broke
Seriously like how dare they 😭😭 that’s a classic
Outer Space is definitely S tier 😭😭 the vocals, the instruments it literally sounds dreamy and the lyricssss???? Wooooow
i cannot believe i sat and watched them diss the soundtrack of my preteen years for an hour and a half...
Putting Red Dessert in B tier is really a crime you guys. It's not even a S tier, it's higher oh my god I'm shook
_Don‘t compare, just feel._ - Ashton Shakespeare
A wordsmith of sorts
Michael having a mental breakdown over the other members wanting to put Valentine in B tier is me LOL
putting heartbreak girl in to D tier is a crime
Controversial opinion: English love affair is top 3 best 5sos songs of all time
YESSSSS!! It’s S tier for sure
yes,stop simping slow songs like disconnected lol
me watching this in 2022 when they're on their take my hand tour and realizing all the throwback songs in their setlist are from the S and A tier they put together ;_; I wonder if they looked back at this list to decide what songs to throw in for the tour lolll
I was thinking that too lol
And looking at this in Fall 2023 near the end of their The 5Sos5 Show tour, I think we can see again the influence of this brainstorming and the fan feedback. The old songs they kept in the set list were some of the higher ranked ones. And I think we can see where the “Dice Songs” came from: mostly the Don’t Stop tier. And I think just doing this ranking reminded them of old songs they liked or the fans liked but had not played in a long time.
The happiness achieved when disconnected immediately goes to S tier. Best 5sos bop no one can change my mind
I agree with Michael.. Valentine is such an A or S tier song
I'm with Michael on most of these... If You Don't Know is definitely S tier
teeth is def S tier. id argue its one of their best songs ever, if not the best
they were so hard on themselves like damn
no one hates 5sos as much as 5sos....
The fact that my favorite song is S tier makes me feel like my only accomplishment in life. Also never getting over that Calum hates heartbreak girl.
the disrespect to their earlier songs, i haven't been this outraged in a long time
them creating a new label titled "we made a mistake" for heartbreak girl is an INSULT to me bc that song was my saving grace lmfao it's what made me stan them PLS
This entire tier list is CRIMINAL
Monster Among Men is one of my top favorites and they put it in the d category 😭
Sameee😭😭
It’s not one of their best, IMO
Same with Better Man and Woke Up In Japan, they’re kinda slow for me and don’t have that 5sos banging / badass feel to it.
IMO the 5 best songs on Youngblood are (YB) / Talk Fast, Babylon, More and If Walls Could Talk
I need one direction to do this
Harry would FIGHT for What Makes You Beautiful to be S tier I know
where's the petition for this
Well bestie I'm sorry to tell you this....
If story of my life wouldn't be S tier, I'll sue.
5sos: write the songs
us: we’ll take it from here
I died at moving along being in C, it's a freaking S+++
I was definitely not expecting that 😭 i love that song
Yea, some songs are slow and boring and yet overrated💀
Them placing no shame in the S tier then moving it to A made me die inside a little
“just because taka’s involved S TIER” agree 100% i literally ascend into a different plane of existence during the bridge in twyw
I feel fulfilled watching Michael defend Greenlight 🤧💪
the fact they put when you walk away so low is a CRIME
watching this after their concert and i think this is how they determined their set list😂
I’m late to this but I have to say, Ghost of You is the best 5sos song and I’m glad they ranked it in S
that tier list is DESPICABLE.
“Should we make a block for 5SOS5 and put it in s tier?” - Luke Hemmings spoiling the new album on August 19th, 2021
i feel like a lot of this could have been solved if they just did a b+ row and b- row
michael interrupting luke for 1,5 hours straight
ashton is so real for saying “if luke combs did close as strangers it’d be massive” LIKE WHERES THE LIE THAT WOULD BE SUCH A FUCKING COUNTRY BANGER
i clicked to the end to see the full chart but i had to figure out why there was a dont stop tier so i ended up watching the whole thing 💀💀💀
Ashton's smile makes my heart melt.
“don’t act like you have friends calum”
FHDIHEBSKDHSKDB THIS KILLED ME
Luke: "I'd go A or S"
Michael: "IRS?"
Luke: "I have to call the IRS"
Idk why that part kills me every time I watch this video 😭😭😭
With Not in the Same Way being my favorite song of all time, I’m very upset w it being C. Of 5sos’ songs it would sit perfectly in B🥲
this randomly popped up on my youtube recommended and ive literally not stopped laughing! for sure will have to check their music out now!
I love that you watched this even though you were not a fan 😂 they are hilarious aren’t they? I hope you have listened to their music and checked out more of their hilarious interviews and livestreams. Their friendship and silliness is definitely a huge appeal to me and many other people. That was one of the things that I first liked about them 😅
justice for literally every song in this list 😭😭😭
the way they make all this masterpiece but are completely TASTELESS
The breath of relief I let out when they put She’s So Perfect and Ghost Of You in S. Personally Old Me got put too low, I honestly love it.
“Someone said ‘Old Me is sHITTY’.”
Whoever that was had me crying laughing 🤣🤣
GOOD GIRLS AND STORY OF ANOTHER US DESERVE MORE IMO 😭😭😭😭
I love that they had the nerve to do this and I just love learning about them. The songs they do and don't like really says something about them. Me here a bit heart broken but lmao! I need more artists to do this!
I can't blame them for some D tears.
it’s nice to see that they’re still friends after being so successful and stuff together
my heart hurt when they lowered wherever you are, heartbreak girl, san Fransisco, and fly away😭😹
especially fly away for me
no matter how many times i watch this, it manages to disappoint mE MORE-
This reminds me of when they use to do twitcams, good times lol
It's amazing how when they're looking at the chat Ash and Cal see all the negative comments and Mikey sees the positive comments.
heartache on the big screen deserves better putting it in C is a crime
FACTS
everyone is talking about the disrespect towards ‘heartbreak girl’. i mean- their biggest bop ‘i can’t remember’ didn’t even make it to the list. talk about disrespect smh
That’s what I was thinking!!
red desert in B causes me physical pain. That's an S tier song.
Amnesia, Jet Black Heart, Not In The Same Way, She Looks So Perfect, Youngblood and Voodoo Doll are my top/most listened to songs
This just makes me realize how much I love their music 🔥 How dare they?...
I can't stop wheezing when ash started sassy to mike 💀💀 at 9:15
I cannot thank you enough for this. This is amazing. I just love watching them discussing. I come and rewatch this so often.
meet you there and more in C???? its S++++ tier... how can they be so tasteless when they make such good music 😭
me watching them move outer space and leaving pizza in s tier and pretending it never happened is crazy
i will literally fight for lover of mine lmao idec it's one of their best songs ever
not in the same way is the most criminally underrated and underappreciated song ever. top 3 5sos songs of all time for me!
AHHHHHHH they sang "Close as Strangers" i think i could die in peace right now... my life goal has been successfully fulfilled 😭💖💖
Disconnected and Wildflower were literally perfectly fine in S tier whyd they do that!!!
Slow and boring songs.
My one question is why is everyone hating on “Heartbreak Girl?” I love that song
It’s so fun to see how they feel about these songs years later cuz nostalgia is a thing
Thank you for uploading!
Sorry I didn't reply I had no idea my youtube notifications were off😫😫😫
Permanent vacation being C tier is my villain origin story