Pocket Power: Springfield Armory XDS .45 Vs Smith and Wesson Shield .357 sig

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 20. 10. 2023

Komentáře • 70

  • @user-dq9pq8uv4e
    @user-dq9pq8uv4e Před 8 měsíci +2

    Folks... subscribers, members, casual watchers... we have a challenge!
    We have to help SPN come up with new terms to replace "Ergonomics".
    My contribution is "hand meld"
    Let's hear what you have! Help SPN out! 😄

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci +1

      Haha love this! Drop it in the comments!

    • @Sceptis
      @Sceptis Před 8 měsíci +1

      "Finger-feels."

    • @roadwarriormp88
      @roadwarriormp88 Před 8 měsíci +2

      Gripability

    • @user-dq9pq8uv4e
      @user-dq9pq8uv4e Před 8 měsíci

      😅 hand happy rating

    • @steven3379
      @steven3379 Před 8 měsíci

      I think a "Flintstones" rating would be great.. You know a square wheel vs a round wheel! For example a "1 Flintstone" would be not so good and "5 Flintstones" would be great!

  • @user-dq9pq8uv4e
    @user-dq9pq8uv4e Před 8 měsíci +4

    Ahhhhh, I remember the .357 conversion. That was my first video from you! And I remember commenting to watch the frame for cracking.
    I am really, really glad to see that she's holding up, she's being reliable, and that you're enjoying her!

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci +1

      Yes she runs great, handles great and no cracking! I actually took that and while shooting always checked so I appreciate it. I’ve had a frame crack before on a different firearm and I knew immediately from the way the firearm felt on my hand

    • @user-dq9pq8uv4e
      @user-dq9pq8uv4e Před 8 měsíci

      @@spnfirearms HAHA I _still_ wanna do that conversion too. Think about it every time you showcase her. That's awesome, definitely appreciate hearing that it's part of your routine for the conversion 👍😊
      Agreed, quite a few of them, you can just tell right away that something went wrong. Some of them can be sneaky, so as they say, we must always be vigilant, LOL.
      Awesome brother, I love that conversion, and I love hearing that she's still doing so well!

  • @Dressed2KillTaye
    @Dressed2KillTaye Před 8 měsíci +6

    Once you Go 357 Sig it's hard to go back. I need the G32 &;33 😂😂😂😂❤

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci +1

      Yessir, that’s a fact. Real power!

  • @charlesj.6563
    @charlesj.6563 Před 8 měsíci +3

    Over the years, I have owned an XDs 45 pistol and a 2.0 S&W Shield 45 pistol with 4” barrel. Having put quite a few rounds through each, for me the 4” Shield 45 shoots more accurately and with much less felt recoil compared to the XDs 45. I still own the Shield 45 and the XDs 45 went to a new home. Both are well made and reliable but we each have our preferences and for me it is the Shield 45. I carry a 9mm such as a G26 or Shield Plus 4” quite a bit but I still believe that a larger caliber is preferable. Currently I am carrying an optic ready 2.0 Shield in 40 S&W with a factory ported 4” barrel.

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci +1

      Great choices! Respect!

    • @charlesj.6563
      @charlesj.6563 Před 5 měsíci

      @@ColonelCarnage Over the years I have tried the XDs 45 in both barrel lengths. For me, the Shield 45 with 4” barrel recoils softer and I shoot it much more accurately. For someone else, the opposite may be true.

  • @popinfresh3088
    @popinfresh3088 Před 8 měsíci +3

    Thanks for the review! Hey, don't worry about pinning the grip safety. It's a feature not a bug. I've had to pull my XD 45acp a couple of times for stray dogs. The grip safety wasn't even a thought. I think all striker fired guns should have a grip safety, like a 1911.

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci +1

      agreed. It has never affected me on any of my springfields. The xds, the xd subcompact and my xdm elite! Respect

  • @robknapp6856
    @robknapp6856 Před 8 měsíci +3

    Love the xds. My favorite 45 to carry. Smith and Wesson have great firearms, but, customer service is so ridiculously poor it cancels my wanting to ever purchase another smith and Wesson firearm! EXS, CARRY ON!

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci +1

      Fair enough! The xds is just so smooth and accurate. I shoot my xds .45 better than a lot of my 9mm’s! It has pin point accuracy!

  • @robknapp6856
    @robknapp6856 Před 8 měsíci +2

    Ok, XDS, CARRY ON!

  • @user-dq9pq8uv4e
    @user-dq9pq8uv4e Před 8 měsíci +4

    What's wrong with "ergonomics"? Was the complaint that you were overusing it? Or.. do we have "gun correctness" issues?
    "Ergos" is commonly in practice. 😁

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci +1

      That I over use it haha. But it’s a great word to describe a firearm and how it feels in my hand so it is what it is!

    • @user-dq9pq8uv4e
      @user-dq9pq8uv4e Před 8 měsíci

      @@spnfirearms HAHAHA, uh oh. Ugh, that's a rough one. It's such a one size fits all, so often used term.
      I posted a new comment. I asked the community to help out, and pitch in new terms to use! 👍
      Let's see what we can come up with 😁

  • @michaelsweaney3890
    @michaelsweaney3890 Před 8 měsíci +7

    If a 9MM Can blow the lungs out of your chest, what can a 357 or 45 do? 🤡

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci +1

      Haha true, respect

    • @tombazemore1098
      @tombazemore1098 Před 8 měsíci +2

      Why, they could take down a 747!

    • @Usaamah_Haarithi
      @Usaamah_Haarithi Před 6 měsíci +1

      I think people with no real life experience in having to hurt people forget that 9….45…357 they are just tools and they all work just fine… however I have seen a guy get shot in the head fall down passed out… then get up and start shooting…. He was trying to defend his brother… he died after but tactically a man down getting back up is a dangerous scenario after you moved on to other threats… it was a 9mm btw… so just saying.

  • @marvinmartinez2637
    @marvinmartinez2637 Před 8 měsíci +3

    I like both two

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci +3

      Thanks man I appreciate it. They truly are great, reliable, powerful and so easy to carry.

    • @user-dq9pq8uv4e
      @user-dq9pq8uv4e Před 8 měsíci +2

      @@spnfirearms Oh, and let's not forget... so ergonomic! 😁
      Ok, I'm not making fun of the subscriber. I just know you wanted to so bad to say it, so it needed to be said
      😉

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci +1

      @@user-dq9pq8uv4e haha fair enough. Respect!

  • @youngsquidling2545
    @youngsquidling2545 Před 8 měsíci +1

    Hey I just found a pocket holster for the DB9 gen 4 from Alabama holsters. Hickock 45 uses the company.

    • @steven3379
      @steven3379 Před 8 měsíci

      I just got one for my P938! Love it.

  • @MDR-hn2yz
    @MDR-hn2yz Před 3 měsíci

    XDS-45 is a great carry gun. And if need more ammo, the XDS magazine are thin enough to stick one in my pocket. Need more ammo? I have a nice leather double mag carrier for it. 6+1 of .45 ACP is legit, just ask the 1911 fanboys.

  • @socity13
    @socity13 Před 8 měsíci +1

    I wish they made a shield plus in 40s&w…. My only complaint with my shield is the capacity. I still edc it though.

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci +1

      Yes agreed. That would be unreal having 9-10 rounds in a shield plus size firearm

  • @jdinn32
    @jdinn32 Před 8 měsíci +1

    Bro dont let people tell you what words you can and cannot use. Wtf is that? That is a perfect word to use to describe a weapon and how it handles.

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci +1

      Haha I’m aware. It was more of a joke but it’s true! It just is the perfect word to describe firearms and how they fit your hand!

    • @jdinn32
      @jdinn32 Před 8 měsíci

      @@spnfirearms Literally, was just wanting to voice that bc the Internet is so toxic and people always police others lmao

  • @reviewthebest
    @reviewthebest Před 8 měsíci

    Quick question I’m thinking of starting a guntuber channel however my question is can you monetize a guntuber channel?

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci +2

      Yes of course. Just follow guidelines and you are good!

    • @user-dq9pq8uv4e
      @user-dq9pq8uv4e Před 8 měsíci +1

      If that's the name that you're gonna be using for the channel, it's a great choice! I like it!
      In regards to monetization. Granted, YT is *constantly* changing the rules, and the way that they do things. At least when I checked into it which has been a while... 🙄 We didn't start off qualifying for monetization right away. It was a level that had to be built up to. Again, it's been a while since I checked into it. So like with *everything* concerning guns, check the local rules, hahaha.
      But yeah... if you go with a channel, great luck to you, and hope that things work out really well!

    • @reviewthebest
      @reviewthebest Před 8 měsíci

      @@spnfirearmsThank you 👍

    • @reviewthebest
      @reviewthebest Před 8 měsíci

      @@user-dq9pq8uv4e👍

  • @Crossdariver504
    @Crossdariver504 Před 8 měsíci +2

    Where don you stand in the 9mm Vs 40cal Vs 45acp Vs .357sig debate

    • @michaelgandy4684
      @michaelgandy4684 Před 8 měsíci +2

      45 has a little more power than 9 but the least capacity and penetration.. 9 gets the most capacity and is the cheapest ammo but is the weakest. 40 has power and penetration with good capacity as well as 357 sig.. 40 is cheaper and more available than 357 but not as powerful. My order would be 40,9,357 sig and 45

    • @Hebrews10_26
      @Hebrews10_26 Před 8 měsíci +1

      10mm

    • @user-dq9pq8uv4e
      @user-dq9pq8uv4e Před 8 měsíci

      There's also muzzle blast. If that's a concern, which... it is for some. Ranking those, I'd say 9mm 357, 40, 45. 45s I can actually feel the blast, standing in the next aisle, from somebody shooting one. (Now also keep in mind that when _I_ say 357, I'm talking 357 magnum. Just cuz I haven't had a chance to shoot 357 sig yet. (But not for lack of wanting to!)

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci +2

      I carry 9mm about 40% of the time and the remainder I carry .40, .357 Sig and .45acp I think .40 overall is the best round and most versatile. I don’t carry 10mm because of known over penetration issues

    • @user-dq9pq8uv4e
      @user-dq9pq8uv4e Před 8 měsíci +1

      @@michaelgandy4684 45 carries quite a bit of "smack" when it hits tho too. I mean, it's not like the movies where it sends people flying off the screen, but it hits pretty hard when it connects to something solid.
      Where 9mm likes to try to zip through what it hits, 45 just hammers it. As for punch, I'd rate 9mm as a beginner boxer. 357 and sig are middle weights. (Edit, I meant to say 357 and 40. 40 hits harder, but not quite like 45) 45 tho, that's getting up there with Tyson. (Sans the ear biting).

  • @3689enlighten.RC.
    @3689enlighten.RC. Před 8 měsíci

    You used " Egernomic" In the correct application...Firearms are tools....keep making good content 👌.. Take the. Letter (S) off the word, it has a different meaning

  • @mikelasa5173
    @mikelasa5173 Před 8 měsíci

    I happen to love the ergonomics of both! 😆 😂 JK it didn’t bother me cause I’m huge on ergonomics!

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci +1

      Haha agreed! And it’s just the best way to describe a firearm that fits your hand like a glove! Respect

    • @mikelasa5173
      @mikelasa5173 Před 8 měsíci

      @@spnfirearms exactly!

  • @gloriamaletta8667
    @gloriamaletta8667 Před 8 měsíci +1

    While the 45acp will be effective to me its not a 357 SIG the 357 SIG is a superior round not a doubt in my mind l love 357 SIG and 10mm if you need more power than 9mm these two would be my choices 10mm is also is more powerful than 45acp as is 357 SIG both by a decent amount 10mm is the most powerful of the 3 Underwood 150 grain JHP 10mm 1500fps Underwood 115 grain JHP 357 SIG 1550fps means very effective stopping power that shoots extremely flat at 100+ yards while still being very effective at stopping any human threat at that distance

  • @551chinnoo
    @551chinnoo Před 8 měsíci

    dont hear much on 357 sig i need to do more research on the round sounds interesting

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci +1

      It’s a bottle neck cartridge! It’s a 9mm size projectile with a .40 casing. Tons of power!

    • @551chinnoo
      @551chinnoo Před 8 měsíci

      @@spnfirearms I have that same gun too lol the smith .40

    • @551chinnoo
      @551chinnoo Před 8 měsíci

      @@spnfirearms what do u think about 380 !? U should do a video on that round

  • @kevindelee5473
    @kevindelee5473 Před 8 měsíci +1

    I nerve can get with Springfield

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci +1

      My springfields have been as reliable if not more reliable than my Glocks

  • @Caniksigboy78
    @Caniksigboy78 Před 8 měsíci

    How do you know how gangsters are going to run up on you based on were you go. They can show up any were you're at. I understand the mailbox or work. When I'm out period. I carry two firearms canik mete sf and my shield plus

    • @spnfirearms
      @spnfirearms  Před 8 měsíci

      They can, but I live in a very nice area. And I stay aware. Situation awareness is key. And I’ll be fine even with 7 rounds. I train so much and I’m not missing 7 rounds

    • @Caniksigboy78
      @Caniksigboy78 Před 8 měsíci

      @@spnfirearms I hear you nice area don't mean anything, I feel you on the training part.

  • @jasonaffeldt7838
    @jasonaffeldt7838 Před 8 měsíci

    Nice videi👍👍👍.🇺🇲🔪🌲🔥

  • @Usaamah_Haarithi
    @Usaamah_Haarithi Před 6 měsíci

    Wait…. Why not say ergonomics…… that’s a real question community.

  • @dhardy6654
    @dhardy6654 Před 4 měsíci

    How big are your pockets?