Salafi Discusses Is Imam Nawawi Kafir?
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 09. 2024
- Copyright disclaimer:
In no way or form does AL-ISLAM PRODUCTIONS intend to infringe any rights of the copyright holder. Content here is used strictly for teaching and scholarship under the fair use law.
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research.
Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
Br Muhammad Hijab's Arabic video:
czcams.com/video/UXRf-FBW7v8/video.html
Don't you see the lion is silent and yet feared while the dog barks constantly and is despised ?
Imam Shaafì ì ( رحمه الله )
That guy made a series disrespecting Imams Suyuti, Baqilliani, Izz ibn Abdelsalam etc.
Yehh he made a bunch of videos disrespecting Imam Abu Hanifa who is from the salaf 80 -150 Hijri. That guy is part of a salafi group known as the haddadis who are similar a bit to madkhalis.
@@TheDarpaChief I watched some of his recent videos against Salim Tawil. He was defending Zakir Naik. I had no idea he was haddadi, what's the difference between them and madakhila?
I also noticed that some of the salafis can sometimes try to disguise their dislike of the hanafi madhab. Some others are just open about it. It makes me really uncomfortable when they try to be sly about defaming Abu Hanifa.
Does anyone know what they have against him and his madhab?
@Comparative Islam Apprentice Haddaddis originate from some Egyptian student called Haddad who had some bad manners and insulted/bordeline takfeer on all the scholars of the khalaf.
With regards to the madkhalis they are many groups now but originally attributed to Rabi’ Al Madkhali and Mohammad Aman al Jaami (hence why they are also called jamiya in Arabia) they pledge 100% allegiance to the ruler even it they are non muslim and usually work for the authorities. The guy in the video is against madkhalis. In fact there are about 7 different strands of salafism.
The reason why Salafis (not all) dislike Imam Abu Hanifa, is because they have a very surface understanding of the deen. Furthermore, in the 20th century an influential yemeni sheikh named Muqbil compiled a book or ‘hit piece’ with all the worst opinions of some of the salaf about the Imam. He didn’t include any of the vast praiseworthy opinions of the salaf. In the end they could slander all they want about Imam Abu Hanifa but the opinions of Imam Alshafi’ii, Abdullah Ibn AlMubarak, Aldhahabi and the majority of the ummah says otherwise.
Astagfirullah, he dared slander Imam hafid Jalaluddin Al Suyuti (RA) the polymath genius who had an ocean of knowlegde in all sciences and considered mujahid in each one and unanimously agreed upon that he was the 10th century mujaddid?
He dare insult Imam Al Baqillani (RA) the mujaddid of the 4th century and Imam Ibn Abdal Salam (RA) the mujahid and leading scholar of his era?
Even Salafis respect these great Imams of Ahlu Sunnah but it seems their extremists have loss the plot.
@@lumiam6982 the guy who wrote a book of Kamasutra haha
أَسْتَغْفِرُ اللَّهَ الْعَظِيمَ الَّذِي لاَ إِلَهَ إِلاَّ هُوَ الْحَيُّ الْْقَيُّومُ وَ أَتُوبُ إِلَيْهِ
Our deobandi ullama have contributed to the spread of salafism, due to their brushing under the carpet stance. Most of these salafis are 4 month tabligh brothers or studied in a deobandi maktab or darul uloom. When these brothers had legitimate questions they would approach their local teacher or imam who would most often tell them 'is baat ko chor do' as a result these brothers would fo their own research and conclude with salafism being the correct path. Its such a problem that out madaaris are producing salafi molvis. Its time to wake up and smell the coffee.
what are you talking brother salafis are produced in Saudi Arabia, you are just making an thought up in your head with no proof and accusing great ulama of hanafi school being the problem
@@mkdon101 Astaghfirullah, how is this possible? But some of Taliban went also to darul uloom in Pakistan what I can also not understand... im afghan and I can tell supporting Taliban is supporting terrorists and criminals. May you forgive me for my lack of knowledge though, I had so far only very good experiences with darul uloom people. InshaAllah it won't change.
@@Azimi001 my 30 year observation..i have children who studiea in deobandi madaaris im not against anyone, im pponting our weakness.
@@Azimi001 these refutations should of been done 30 years ago. Our ullama are great people however in the field of refuting baatil we have been lacking.
@@mohdiqbal8972 MashaAllah, yes they should change that, the Fitnah is at this point way too big, these wahhabis are confusing all new Muslims. May Allah Ta’Ala forgive us and make this big fitna disappear soon Amin.
Plz don’t call him brother he doesn’t deserve it
why are you mad that Salafis criticize Nawawi? He was Ashari after all. I don’t get surprised when Asharis criticize Ibn Taymyiah because of credal differences.
You are mad about a Salafi criticizing an Ashari. Yet you glorify Kawthari who spoke ill of more than 90 imam and hafid like Shafāi, Ahmad and Althawri in order to defend Abu Hanifa.
Double standards
wahhabis smoothbrain can't criticize sh it. 🤣
ibn taymiyyah was an anthropomorphist who got refuted by scholars of the 4 madhhabs.
@@Ryan-lf6ds ok nothing worshiper. The Ashari Shaykh Bouti has a different opinion about Ibn Taymyiah falling into anthropomorphism
czcams.com/video/FSlbzX6EVdw/video.html
@@traveler9212 aight, ahl saud dk worshipper. 🤣
finally one ashari who spared pagan taymiyyah.
@@Ryan-lf6ds I only worship Allah who is above the seven sky on his Throne ya zindiq. As for the Bouti, he was no minor Ashari. He was one of the major Ashari scholars of modern time revered i. Arab world by Asharis. So go figure
@@traveler9212 sit down, kid.
yea, i'm a zindeeq of wahhabi pagans. 🤣
it's aight yo smoothbrain can worship mbs dk, atleast that'll make wahhabis look smart.
bouti was the father of wahhabis like all asharis, that's all. lmao
He is a staunch Salafi who cannot handle criticism and report the videos that are made against him
Don't waste your time with him
He often changes the voices of the Sufies and Ashaaris he responds to in his videos because they report every single video he makes, what an irony....
What exactly are you complaining about here?
Astaghfirullah...
Slandering Al Imam An-Nawawi Rahimahullahu and As-Ariyah in general as Kuffar was a very serious accusation.
Naudzubillah tsuma naudzubillah....
May that man samsudin do a taubah before his ajal...
Jzkl ustad..keep exposing them.
Salāms Team
Keep going Bros, better to refute late than never. This 'salafi' movement was ignored and left unchallenged for the most part in the 90's and 2000, certainly in Leicester. Alhamdulillāh for such channels. Leicester 'Ulama lacks debating skills or just lacks the confidence to hit back hard! Come on Shuyuks...
How can you disrespect Imam Nawawi?! You learn his books before becoming an Imam.. he was a giant and accepted within Sunni Islam and by Allah! There is no "Salafi" Scholar on the same level as him! Shocking to see this!
The Reality of an-Nawawiyy
Aḏ-Ḏahabiyy said, “An-Nawawiyy was a brilliant imām with intense piety and asceticism, and left clothes to wear ripped and patched garments, and he did not go to the shower. Šayḵ Abū al-Ḥasan ibn al-Atār narrated to us that an-Nawawiyy took off his garment, and one of his students began to dust off the lice, but he prevented him from removing the lice, and said, ‘Let it be.’” (Tarīḵ al-Islām)
Why do you call them brothers? Please stop it
There is no scholar within Salafiyya that can come close to Imam Al Nawawi (RA), not even their master Ibn Taymiyyah (RA).
Imam Al Nawawi (RA) was one of the greatest hadith experts and fuqaha of the khalaf. His creed was sound and upon the creed of the Salaf Al-Saliheen. He was a wali extremely loved by Allah more than Wahhabis put together.
Let me mention some of his contribution just to showcase how great this scholar was, subhanullah.
He authored Al-Minhaj Sharh Sahih.
It is considered to be the greatest commentary of Sahih Muslim.
He authored Rawdatu Talibin (Shafi'i Fiqh 8 volumes)
A great reference and authority of the Shafi'i madhab. Rawdatu Talibin is a summary of Al Aziz (Sharh al-kabir) of Al-Kabir, it is a complete and comprehensive book on the Shafii Madhhab that develops opinions within the school and gives the predominant opinion.
He authored Al-Majmu' Sharh Al-Mubaddhab (22 volumes)
One of the most important encyclopedia of Fiqh that was written, under the pen of the great Shafii Imam, an-Nawawi. This work is comparable to the Mughni of Ibn Qudama al-Maqdissi, because it exposes the differences in the 4 schools
He authored Riyad As-Salihin.
The famous collection of hadeeth "Riyaad as-Saaliheen" by imam an-Nawawi. A must have, recommended by many Ulema to its content rich and important.
He authored the 40 hadith.
Imam Nawawi's 40 Hadith have come to be known as the most comprehensive and holistic collection of hadiths of the Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him). They convey the essence of Islam as each hadith is based on a foundational principle of our religion.
There are so many beneficial books he authored that benefited the ummah and you have a tiny deviant sect discussing whether he was a kaffir or not? Astagfirullah, how far will they go to ruin their journey to the next world?
Their real master is Muhammad Ibn Wahhab, not Ibn Taymiyah.
Shaykh Ibn Taymiyah wasnt a Salafi
@@hamzaa9396 he was a salafi, those neo salafis aren't
He still has heretical beliefs, it doesn't matter if he wrote a billion book.
The average person with the right aqeeda is better than any Ashaari no matter what his status is.
@@abhmd4481 Sheikh al-Islam Al-Nawawi (RA) had the aqeeda of the Salaf and based on that stupid comment you made. You will have to answer it on the day of judgement because you disrespected and slandered a wali. The only people with the heretical beliefs are pseudo-Salafis who came 300 years ago and don't have isnad to prove their baatil creed. Imam Ash'ari (RA) was from the Salaf and simply compiled the creed of the earliest Muslims. His contemporaries accepted him and he is backed up in Hadith. Those who are against him in creed have strayed from the Sunnah.
The man should have brought the reasons why An Nawawi was.consider a kafir by the man and refute those. As for saying he did that and that those are not daleel for one being kafir or Muslim. Every let's read the books of our salaf and let's ask Allah to forgive us if we did shirk knowingly or unknowingly in our every salah.
MaahaAllah
He is rejected by the salafis... He is very dangerous. Sheikh Al-fawzan's advice is to never take knowledge from people like him. He is no degree of salafiyah baarkAllah feekum.
My advice to all is to not take islam on youtube and tiktok. As good and trustworthy a source may be, too much information and views can corrupt you very quickly.
When is 100 mistakes compilation coming out?
Some brothers requested not to compile it and upon giving certain agreement
MashaAllah
brother i stand with u when it comes to this man called mohammad shams al deen ...... iam following him n wanted someone who answers him
Okay so where did he say that al-Nawawi is a Kaffir?!
He discussed the possibility.
سبحان الله. هذا رجل ضال مضل. امام النووي امام امة رحمة الله عليه. هذا ضال يجترء کفر امام النووي
Asharis consider Salafis Mujaseemah. Tajseem is kufr in Ashari and Maturidi creed. And many of Ashari scholars made takfeer on Salafis. So why are you mad? Many of your scholars made takfeer on Ibn Taymyiah like Al Kawthari.
I have yet to see an Ashari refuting another Ashari for making takfeer on Ibn Taymyiah. You Asharis actually consider it a difference of opinions.
Just man up and don’t resort to crocodile tears. Go read the book of aqeedah before Ashari was born and you will see how they nullify your false deviant creed.
Because ibn taymiyyah was a mujassim. He was not upon the creed of the salaf. He was rejected by scholars of his own age and those alter for his kufr. Essentially you’re comparing apples and oranges
Estughfir Allah
Imam Nawawi and Hafiz ibn Hajar
His friend khulaifi does takfir of Ashairah and Imam Abu Hanifah
@@AzadAli-re2fz Sh. Kulaify makes takfeer of Asharis, yes. That’s true. But not Abu Hanifa. He considers Abu Hanifa innovator like all early scholars of Hadith like Al Thawri, Bukhari, Malik, Ahmad, Shafāi and many many more.
Well, Abu Yusuf said that Abu Haneefah died as a Jahmi in Kitab As-Sunnah by Abdullah ibn Ahmad and even also mentions the narration that Abu Haneefah made taqiyyah of being asked to repent twice. Which I hold those positions which are authenticated.@@traveler9212