“MASSIVE Issue” | JK Rowling Slams Labour’s Anneliese Dodds For ‘Woman’ Definition In Past
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 07. 2024
- JK Rowling has described as “nonsensical” past comments made by Anneliese Dodds on gender as the Labour MP was announced as women and equalities minister.
The Harry Potter author has previously accused Labour of having “abandoned” her and others campaigning for women’s rights.
Ms Rowling has become known as a fierce advocate for the rights of biological women after criticising Scottish Government proposals to introduce self-identification for transgender people.
Assistant editor at The Critic Jo Bartosch joins Talk’s Julia Hartley-Brewer to discuss this further.
Click here for more from Talk talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
#talk #jkrowling
Love JKR keep up the good work in protecting Women
She works with nazis in what world is she helping women
How is this protecting women. It just contributes to a pointless divisiveness. People with gender dysphoria should be treated with respect others who want to dress up in women's clothes should just shut up and let the rest of society get on with their own lives AND keep out of women's safe places.
She keeps tweeting about it though, needs to come on mainstream television and bring this out in the open.
JKR speaks the truth full stop
Maybe if your a fan of mein kampf
@@barl6412 calm down
@@karynirwin2477maybe don’t listen to people who hang out with Nazis
@@karynirwin2477counterpoint, you’re a brainlet.
@@barl6412why what were hitlers views on sex and gender? 😂
JK Rowling talks more sense than most politicians.
Sometimes that is not difficult.
@@tomgreene1843 Just what I was going to say!
That's a low bar.
Absolutely 💯
Unlike them she knows her fiction is fantasy & not policy.
We really have gone to hell in a handcart. I fear for the grandkids who are born into this madness.
Well @ least we know no trans woman will be popping them out, though India Willoughby is a father.
Labour is a lost cause when it comes to political correctness and wokery. This latest pathetic statement by Dodds about how she defines a woman is frankly ludicrous.
Its not going to get better
They should have their own space and let them get on with it. WOMEN’s space is our own.
They don't want that.They want validation that they are women
You're dead right Julia and Jo 💯
What on earth do you expect from Labour??? Actual Truth and reality? Nah.
It appears they have dropped their pledge to control IMMIGRATION already. Liebour at its finest.
The translation is being a woman doesn't mean a thing anymore.
People like honesty, until we start being honest with them, then we're labelled racist/biggot / fascist etc😂
Dysphoria delusion.
I identify as a horse and i demand the government to put stables in all hotels and restaurants as i am offended that they dont know what a horse is.i am a specil horse that can walk on two legs. And type. Unicorn.
Anneliese Dodds received a private education. I should have thought this would disqualify her from being considered for a place in a Labour cabinet, given their prejudice against fee-paying schools.
You'd think. But the indoctrination begins in these institutions. The poshies like to dip their toes in the murky waters and I'm sure they see us as the guinea pigs in their sick experiments. Truly vile.
You would have thought so..but no cos they are adamant they are the party of the working people
Jk hen your spot on , women dont put up with this ! Biology is truth , science dont lie !
This appointment is very worrying. If this nonsense continues we can kiss goodbye to women and girls’ safety, rights and aspirations! Context doesn’t define a woman, biology does. It really isn’t that difficult.
Yep...100% agree
Stand your ground JHB. I’m with you and JK all the way. This madness has to stop.
i still don't get why any women voted for Labour - turkeys voting for Christmas (before you scream - yes why men voted for them is beyond me)
Exactly….why did anyone ?
Because their husband took all 6 votes from his wives and voted for Labour!
I think the issue is that, for too long, many people have been (conveniently) convinced that voting makes no difference. That may well be true when we look at the main two parties.
Labour only won because many people did not bother to vote, particularly from the rightwing.
Next time, we need to promote the idea that voting should be done regardless. It only takes a few minutes and we will never know if it is truly a waste of our time unless as many of us get out there to try as possible.
Disenfranchisement has allowed Labour power for the next five years. We cannot afford for them to have five more after that.
@mariabenetti8902 after the way the government and politicians tried every trick in the book to overturn the referendum results, it's no wonder people believe that voting is pointless. I never bothered voting again after they essentially went against the will of the people. That, along with the unelected HOL deciding what's good for us serfs, proves that voting is pointless. Politicians are NEVER held accountable.
I think they only got 37% of the vote
The sooner the new Labour ministers realise that objective reality does not make compromises, the safer it’ll be for women and children in the UK.
Dodds is mad or dishonest, most likely both, silly childish woman
I identify as a pensioner, but I still have to wait 30 years to get my state pension!
I'm a pensioner, but identify as a 20 year old
@@Raspberryruffles-ul7hui was born in july 1953 and i am 39 this year my cake my candles😁😁
I identity as 🍆, but nature doesn't support me. Neither does JKR, should I call the police or secret cervyx?
Labour have lost the plot, big time
Reform will sort them out!
So have all the people that voted for them.
They have only been in power 5 minutes and they are already in the bin.
Why do we need a Women and equalities minister in the first place ?
Cos women's rights are being removed and this minister will continue to do it at a faster pace
The system was.. good men stay out so that bad men stand out
We Need JK Rowling to Join REFORM UK. 🙏
I can only hope that Labour's perverse attitude to real women and female impersonators will create a huge backlash and lose this government much support in the country.
...In 4 years!
According to the results of the election they don't have much support right now
vote in clowns and you get a circus that doesn't function properly
Or you still have clowns who continue to think votes are real.
@@halloweenville1 true, what other choice is there though ? the electorate has to take some blame also when only 50% voted
@@simonclare-fu7sx Wow, my comment literally went right over your head, please wake up.
@@halloweenville1 you'll have to explain that if you can 😂
@@simonclare-fu7sx Well what do we have here, a smart-ass, who isn't remotely smart. Get back out into the field to graze with the other sheep. Continue being dumb.
If you paint a gold necklace with a silver colour, it may look like a silver necklace but beneath there is still a golden necklace.
But when you scrape away the silver paint and glitter in this example, what you find is a cheap plastic counterfeit copy, harming the environment.
I`m so upset today .... I woke up this morning and identified as the PM of the UK and they wont accept it ... This government picks and chooses what they want to believe in .....
Where have all the transvestites gone in all this?
Not in gynecologist's stirrups. Salon?
Maybe they've all gone back into the closet 🤭
Wives of various politicians…?
@@unowen-nh9ov
@@realstevieb7201
If you buy a blue car but decide to spray it green the car is still blue underneath.
The wokery will be on steroids now…..
Give your GUEST A CHANCE TO TALK, you gave YOUR side. She wasn’t allowed to speak!
Fed up with politics. Leave the planet
SUPPORT REFORM UK !!!!! 🙏
Does Dodds know whether she is a woman or not
What do we do about men who think they are women?... Tell them otherwise and then ignore them.
Does Starmer know whether his wife is a woman or not
If you have to declare you transitioning into something you are not, it’s clear you are not what you now pretend to be.
You’ve admitted yourself you are not what you now claim to be!
I’m a Volkswagen with a Lamborghini badge, therefore you’re admitting you’re a dressed up Volkswagen.
Is there a law called “indecent exposure?”.
Not in the Ladies' & if they complain they get banned, ask a nurse or female Planet Fitness member.
Does a real woman have to shave every morning NO does a real woman have the ability to have children YES so whars the the problem anyone who thinks differant needs their heads looked at.
@@saltylips9965 I know you can't be one if you don't know what a woman is.
@@saltylips9965 yes all women can have babies. The ones who are irreparably infertile are such a minority that is trascurabile. Its dishonest to even mention it and it just proves how low is the level of your arguments
Some do..if they have poly cystic ovaries
@@madmelwood3778 why don't you wake up men can't have babies
1 question why does the number of men transitioning far out way the number of women transitioning Surely it should be roughly equal .
There are different reasons for transitioning. The two largest demographics are middle aged men for whom it's a sexual fetish, and young, confused girls trying to escape the discomfort of their growing female bodies. Utterly different reasons. In little children, nine times out of ten its the parent or a caregiver who has some weird, rigid idea of gender, so a little boy who wants to play with Barbie dolls must be a girl, not a little boy who likes Barbie. It isn't a sexual thing at such a young age so there's absolutely nothing a 5 year old girl can do or wear that a 5 year old boy can't.
Very few middle aged women suddenly decide to become men, and a huge proportion of trans identified men are from this category. For them it is almost entirely sexual.
Actually the statistics now show that the majority of people identifying as "trans" are female, girls and young women, followed closely by middle aged men. The reason for the perception that it is mostly men transitioning is because they are the only ones demanding access to spaces where they don't belong, and uniquely able to benefit from male physiology in sports etc. Ask yourself why you hear of no cases of women demanding and receiving access to men's prisons, etc? The entire thing is misogynistic and inherently homophobic and incredibly regressive. It's driven by the p0rn1fied culture we find ourselves in, represented perfectly by the aforementioned statistics, the two groups wishing to opt out of objectification(young women/girls) and the males who wish to opt in to it.
@@hmsealey3243 saw your comment after posting mine, great minds think alike (and have done the research) UPDATE CZcams censored my comment so you'll have no idea what I'm referring to, too much truth for the tech overloads.
There is basically no advantage in transitioning into a man. Many who try it turn out to regret the decision and detransition, or like many men........ self implode.
Where is Starmers minister for men in his new "inclusive", less "other" more "equal" cabinet?
Outweighs*
one flew over the cuckoo's nest with labour its a flock flew over the cuckoo's nest.
Julia you just talked right over your guest. That was so rude.
Coincidentally, I took six kittens to be vaccinated recently.
I asked the vet how many were females? and she said, "Well... It depends on the context really!"
They are putting women back years get a grip Britain
I wonder if the Transport Minister can define what a car is.
Let the guest speak
Go JK Rowling. She's a legend. ❤❤❤
God help this daft world
I’m behind JK.
What about minister for men!!!
I wonder when Labour voters will realise what they have done . . .
I’m from Inverness City, I love JKR.
Our Minister for women should be working in partnership with JKR to protect women
instead of asking 'what is a woman' ask: what are the consequences of changing the definition of woman from 'adult human female' to 'anyone who says they are'? And who benefits from those consequences vs. who loses? The answer is very clear: the consequences are dire, and only women suffer - while transidentifying males and predatory men benefit. So: the question is not whether transwomen are women, the question is: should we change the definition of woman - and the answer is NO. Transpeople can have protections without a semantic trick that harms women and girls across all areas of their lives.
Make JK the Minister for Women and Equalities, she would do a better job and consider trans at the same time. Delia Morris
So tired of this BS
I Love to hear common sense.
Many women voted Labour. I guess they’ll have to deal with whatever happens next.
I'm really not surprised Dodds doesn't know what a woman is 😊
Dodds should not be in that position. However, this is not a surprise when even Starmer does not know what a woman is. This is part of the reason that Labour’s front bench has a collective IQ in low double digits. Love the way JKR keeps up the pressure.
She (Dodds) is really Mrs Doyle from Father Ted “Oh go on, go on, go on”
Dodds is coming around. Stop whipping up rear-guard resentment. Helen Joyce has a very good, clear take on Dodds, Starmer and the current situation.
You are erasing the existence of that which they want to be because for the illusion to work everyone must buy in to it.
In Starmers new, inclusive, diverse cabinet ......... who was named minister for men and boys....... the "Other" 48% of the population.
Those LEAST represented in many socio economic areas where focus is on negative outcome.
Starmer is a suspicious character…….
51 percent and the male children.
Mind you, I would have difficulties calling Hippoabbopotumus a woman
Labour party won't last long am afraid give it six months they will be toast 😮
Tell the to stop being delusional. Tell them what they are.
Dandelion Seeds.
Even if they have surgery they are not woman
Woman XX Chromosome, man XY Chromosome, anything else is a personal choice.
I have no problem with those who are attracted to their own sex or wish to live as a member of the opposite sex. This is their choice and they should accept the restrictions, particularly on safe spaces for women!
One of the nicest and most helpful guys I ever worked with married his partner, a male doctor. Definitely not a problem for me. Each to his/or her own.
I can go back to the 50s living in a rural area when a local couple of females lived as man and wife. Local people just accepted them and walking by we often stopped to pass the time of day with them. One dressed very much as a man while the other was very feminine. I'm sure there was a little banter in the pub but in reality they were accepted and had the support of the community.
Many years later they were mentioned in a book by the retired local GP.
cutest female voice ever tells us what woman are love it
Can you imagine the uproar and the video tik tok if JK actually ran into one of these in a public toilet? She does go shopping some times doesn't she.
Oh I'd love to see that. There would be some hate speech in that moment.
There are loads of women labour mp,s. What to they think?
Not a lot apparently.
What the manifest demand they think.
They are not allowed to think.
👍
I have always viewed Anneliese Dodds as a strange one! I am sure she is a well-meaning, nice lady, but to me, she is a bit weird. (She could also do something about her hair - jeez!)
Her appointment is akin to appointing Dr. Josef Mengele as Minister for Health & Social Care!
This is the lunacy which pervades our political class, who should really be the "sensible ones"!
Ken Dodds love child.
JKR may have common sense but she's a rubbish writer . Absolute drivel
Her track record on book sales is appalling, n’est pas?🤣
that's some of the best drivel I have ever read
She crazy. You know someone has lost it when Elon Musk tells them to change the record😂.
that rowling walk past me when i was a tramp never gave me apenny very mean three young arab girls gave me thee 50 pound notes im on my feet now no thanks to rowling thanks for noing
is JKR to give to everyone who asks for money then. now you are on your feet do you do that? everyone, mind
Dodds should be minister of agriculture - a scarecrow in field - she would be brilliant
X team good, Y team bad? So, 1) There is likely nothing that will improve peoples lives in the next five years and new additive taxes will be collected, Joy! 2) We know the last government also did not improve peoples lives and was horrible, Joy! Knowing 1) & 2) you not only would not consider a new approach you are also so certain of this that you rally against a new approach. It would be refreshing to actually hear your thoughts on what you think is wrong with this new approach and why you think the current government approach is right? (i.e. Mass immigration is good because it generates £xM is revenue -please cite-, reduces crime -please cite-, eases the burden on housing, heath and welfare -please cite-, unifies the country as a whole whilst enriching local communities - please cite- and helps reduce carbon emissions -please cite. Otherwise all I understood from your post was X team good, Y team bad.
Jk Rowling representative of the left
yaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaawn so boring
oh dear Julia. This is such a non issue, why do you keep banging on about it? No one's interested. In a recent poll, only 2% of people thought this was an important subject. Do some proper journalism, for once
Women's rights are a non issue? WOW
@@lourdeszurita9244 who said that? i said the definition is a non issue. Apart from 2% of people, mostly TALKTV viewers i assume, no one else deems it an issue. Everyone else just gets on with it. Culture wars are over. Deal with it
@@robnewell2303 The definition is the most importan issue because if politicians can include males to define women, our rights are gone. Also, I wouldn't base my opinion on "a poll" Do you have women in your life? Because they will be affected negatively by this, no matter what the poll says
@@lourdeszurita9244 the poll just backs up my own experience. No one, and i mean no one around me even mentions this in any conversations. It just never comes up, and most of those around me are women. The only place i hear it mentioned is places like TalkTv or GBeebies news
@@robnewell2303 It doesn't come up to me personally either, but do you agree that it shouldn't be considered a non issue because women and girls are important? I mean, imagine your rights being erased. I don't mean to be antagonistic. It's just frustrating to me that people can dismiss a huge issue so easily
Who cares what JK Rowling thinks she just a annoying Karen
I do
I care what JKR says Nobody cares who or what you say !
and you are an anti white POS.
What makes you think that you are not annoying to many of us?
Obviously very very many people 👍
Labour 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡😡un real.
Welcome to 5 years hard labour.........hope you liebour voters are happy🤡🌎
I am 66 but i identify as a 21 year old billionair who is an absolute fanny magnet so where is my money and all the chicks?
Mad world
Always has been
I have a moped licence but i can barely ride it!, i identify as an airline pilot, so hands up on who wants taking on holiday?.....steady on peeps there's to many to count ....
Did Starmer marry a woman , ask him .
Julia you just talked right over your guest. That was so rude.